The only way in which a disponee can be sure of preventing a third party, such as an adjudging creditor, from acquiring a real right to the lands which will prevail against his right is by registration. ‘The proper object and effect of every valid seisin is to divest the granter of the heritable right, and to invest the grantee . . It is of the very essence of a real right, not only to found a preference against a less perfect right, but to prevent any third party from acquiring a perfect right to the lands, which most certainly an unregistered seisin does not.’ and ‘In the same way, and on the same principle, the holder of a heritable bond, followed only by unregistered seisin, would fail in claiming a preference over personal creditors, because such creditors have the means of obtaining by adjudication a perfect right to the lands of the debtor.’
References: (1847) 9 D 932
Judges: Lord Fullerton
Jurisdiction: Scotland
This case cites:
- Appeal from – Young v Leith IHCS 1844
Unrecorded instruments of sasine were nullities, but the granter of the sasine was not entitled to plead the nullity: ‘. . I am very glad that the result is such as my noble friend proposes, and that now, on the authority of this House, it will be . .
((1848) 2 Ross’s LC 81, (1844) 6 D 370)
This case is cited by:
- Appealed to – Young v Leith IHCS 1844
Unrecorded instruments of sasine were nullities, but the granter of the sasine was not entitled to plead the nullity: ‘. . I am very glad that the result is such as my noble friend proposes, and that now, on the authority of this House, it will be . .
((1848) 2 Ross’s LC 81, (1844) 6 D 370) - Cited – Burnett’s Trustee v Grainger and Another HL 4-Mar-2004
A flat was sold, but before the purchasers registered the transfer, the seller was sequestrated, and his trustee registered his own interest as trustee. The buyer complained that the trustee was unjustly enriched.
Held: The Act defined the . .
(2004 SCLR 433, 2004 SC (HL) 19, 2004 SLT 513, 2004 GWD 9-211, , [2004] UKHL 8, , Times 08-Mar-04, [2004] 11 EGCS 139)
These lists may be incomplete.
Last Update: 27 November 2020; Ref: scu.194222
