Claim for infringement – sale of chip designed to bypass country code control on the claimant’s gaming machines.
Held: An infringement of copyright committed in breach of an injunction restraining such infringement can found an award of additional damages.
In distinguishing WB, Jacob J said: ‘That seems to me to be a very different case because there is no provision authorising damages for contempt itself and no provision in the general law for additional damages for the wrongs alleged [Bauer’s case was a case of breach of confidence]. Here there is. Section 97 requires the Court to have regard to all the circumstances. Those circumstances, to my mind, plainly can include the circumstance that the sales were done in breach of a Court Order. They make the act flagrant. They make the act fairly describable as ‘scandalous’. In this regard, copyright is different from many other rights precisely because there is the statutory right to additional damages if the Court, in all the circumstances, thinks it right to grant them. I do, in this case, in principle, although I am told that the evidence will establish mitigating circumstances. ‘
Judges:
Jacob J
Citations:
[2002] EMLR 34, [2002] EWHC 45 (Ch)
Links:
Jurisdiction:
England and Wales
Citing:
Distinguished – WB v H Bauer Publishing Ltd 2002
. .
Cited by:
Cited – Navitaire Inc v Easyjet Airline Co and Another ChD 30-Jul-2004
The claimant alleged infringement of its copyright in a software system which dealt with airline reservations. It was not said that any code had been copied, but merely that an express requirement of the defendant ordering the system was that it . .
Cited – Phonographic Performance Ltd v Reader ChD 22-Mar-2005
The claimant had in the past obtained an injunction to prevent the defendant broadcasting without their licence musical works belonging to their members at his nightclub. The defendant had obtained a licence, but had not renewed it. The claimants in . .
Lists of cited by and citing cases may be incomplete.
Media, Intellectual Property, Damages
Updated: 01 October 2022; Ref: scu.220472
