The court construed the phrase ‘wilful misconduct’.
Held: The court adopted the definition given in Graham, Lord Alverstone CJ adding: ‘The addition which I would suggest is, ‘or acts with reckless carelessness, not caring what the results of his carelessness may be.’
Judges:
Lord Alverstone CJ
Citations:
[1905] 2 KB 532
Citing:
Adopted – Graham v Belfast and Northern Counties Railway Co 1901
The court had to construe the phrase ‘wilful misconduct’.
Held: ‘Wilful misconduct in such a special condition means misconduct to which the will is party as contradistinguished from accident, and is far beyond any negligence, even gross or . .
Cited by:
Cited – Laceys Footwear (Wholesale) Ltd v Bowler International Freight Ltd and Another CA 18-Apr-1997
The defendant’s driver had taken a consignment of shoes to Spain, where they were stolen. The plaintiff alleged his gross negligence amounted to ‘wilful misconduct’ so as to disapply an exemption clause.
Held: Whether a bailee’s acts . .
Cited – TNT Global Spa and Another v Denfleet International Ltd and Another CA 2-May-2007
The driver of a lorry carrying the claimant’s goods was said to have fallen asleep at the wheel, and the cargo damaged in the accident. The carrier appealed a finding of liability for wilful misconduct.
Held: ‘I am unable to accept that mere . .
Lists of cited by and citing cases may be incomplete.
Contract
Updated: 12 May 2022; Ref: scu.187675