The legislation encompassed the failure to pay tax as a benefit accrued through criminal activity, and therefore a court could order forfeiture of the proceeds of the crime, even though the wrong-doer might remain liable for the unpaid taxes in civil law. The possibility of such double liability was not relevant to the criminal proceedings. … Continue reading Regina v Allen (Brian Roger): CACD 13 Oct 1999
The defendants appealed against confiscation orders made after a finding that they had been involved (separately) in the smuggling of tobacco, suggesting a conflict between the 1992 Regulations and the Directive. Held: The appeals variously failed and succeeded according to their facts. A person obtains a pecuniary advantage by evading duty or VAT even though … Continue reading White and Others v Regina: CACD 5 May 2010
The defendant appealed against a confiscation order, after conviction for cheating the public revenue. Funds had been diverted from his company to avoid payment of taxes. Held: Tax which was avoided would fall under the section and be a pecuniary advantage ‘obtained by an offender’ within the section only if he benefitted himself. This could … Continue reading Regina v Foggon: CACD 14 Feb 2003
The defendant pleaded guilty to making false statements, and cheating the public revenue by understating his profits as a market trader over a protracted period. The judge made a confiscation order equal to the amount of undeclared profit. On appeal, that element was set aside. The section referred to the pecuniary advantage obtained by the … Continue reading Regina v Frank Adam Moran (Attorney General’s Reference No 25 of 2001): CACD 27 Jul 2001
