Kostic v Chaplin and others: ChD 15 Oct 2007

The deceased had for several years suffered a delusional disorder. The validity of his last two wills was challenged. In one had had left his entire estate to the Conservative Party.
Held: The wills were invalid. It was clear that when made, the testator’s mind was so poisoned by his delusions as to leave him unable to appreciate his proper duties to his son. Though a genuine supporter of the Conservative Party, his actual support was consistently tinged wih evidence of his delusions.

Judges:

Henderson J

Citations:

[2007] EWHC 2298 (Ch)

Links:

Bailii

Jurisdiction:

England and Wales

Citing:

CitedBanks v Goodfellow QBD 6-Jul-1870
Test for Capacity to Execute Will
The testator suffered from delusions, but not so badly or in such a way as was found to affect his capacity or to influence his testamentary disposition. The judge had given the following direction: ‘The question is whether . . the testator was . .
CitedCharles Harwood v Maria Baker PC 1840
The Board emphasised the importance that the Court of Probate should be satisfied that a testatrix had the necessary capacity when she executed the will if the evidence showed that she had lost capacity shortly afterwards. The infirmity of the . .
CitedRobin Sharp and Malcolm Bryson v Grace Collin Adam and Emma Adam and others CA 28-Apr-2006
The testator suffered secondary progressive multiple sclerosis. It was said that he did not have testamentary capacity. He had lost the power of speech but communicated by a speech board. The solicitor had followed appropriate standards in attesting . .
Lists of cited by and citing cases may be incomplete.

Wills and Probate, Health

Updated: 02 June 2022; Ref: scu.259856