Professor Annand set out the combined test of bad faith in a trade mark application: ‘Bad faith is to be judged according to the combined test of dishonesty for accessory liability to breach of trust set out by the majority of the House of Lords in Twinsectra Ltd v Yardley, with Gromax Plasticulture Ltd v Don and Low Nonwovens Ltd providing the appropriate standard, namely acceptable commercial behaviour observed by reasonable and experienced persons in the particular commercial area being examined.
the upshot of the Privy Council decision in Barlow Clowes is: (a) to confirm the House of Lords’ test for dishonesty applied in Twinsectra, i.e. the combined test; and (b) to resolve any ambiguity in the majority of their Lordships’ statement of that test by making it clear that an enquiry into a defendant’s views as regards normal standard of honesty is not part of the test. The subjective element of the test means that the tribunal must ascertain what the defendant knew about the transaction or other matters in question. It must then be decided whether in the light of that knowledge, the defendant’s conduct is dishonest judged by ordinary standard of honest people, the defendant’s own standards of honesty being irrelevant to the objective element.’
Judges:
Professor Ruth Annand
Citations:
[2006] RPC 25, 2283796, [2005] UKIntelP o00406
Links:
Jurisdiction:
England and Wales
Citing:
See Also – Ajit Weekly (Trade Mark: Invalidity) IPO 2-Feb-2005
PO Trade Marks – Inter Partes Decisions – Invalidity . .
Cited by:
Cited – Jules Rimet Cup Ltd v The Football Association Ltd. ChD 18-Oct-2007
The parties disputed on preliminary issues the ownership of the rights in the trade mark ‘World Cup Willie’. The claimant had set out to register the mark, and the defendant gave notice of its intention to oppose. The claimant now alleged threat and . .
Lists of cited by and citing cases may be incomplete.
Intellectual Property
Updated: 19 October 2022; Ref: scu.456487