By an application notice the First Defendant, Syleta Monica Susan Samuel, applies for an order that a probate claim brought by her sister, Merlina Jacqueline Samuel, be struck out as an abuse of process pursuant to CPR r 3.4(2)(b). Shortly stated, the basis for the application is that Merlina was a party to a probate … Continue reading Samuel v Samuel and Others: ChD 17 Dec 2018
Appeal against dismissal of claim for damages on basis that it was an abuse being a second attempt to litigate a matter already decided. Judges: Judge, Jonathan Parker LJJ, Bodey J Citations: [2002] CP Rep 6, [2001] EWCA Civ 1597 Links: Bailii Statutes: Civil Procedure Rules 3.4(2)(b) Jurisdiction: England and Wales Litigation Practice, Civil Procedure … Continue reading Collins v CPS Fuels Ltd: CA 9 Oct 2001
In the course of unfair dismissal proceedings, the defendant had disclosed possession of confidential materials of his former employer. The employer began these proceedings based on the materials. Only at a later point when he appointed solicitors was a challenge to made to that use as contempt. The company now appealed against the strike out … Continue reading IG Index Ltd v Cloete: CA 31 Jul 2014
The defendant applied to have struck out the claim, saying that it was based upon a misuse of documents disclosed during an employment tribunal case, and was an abuse since the claimants had not sought the permission of the Tribunal for a second use of disclosed information. The defendant said that the information had been … Continue reading IG Index Plc v Cloete: QBD 11 Dec 2013
Application to strike out claim as an abuse of process. The claim was for asbestos related condition leading to the death of the claimant’s husband. The defendants denied liability and causation, saying that he had been a confirmed smoker. The post mortem had found asbestos fibres. The defendants complained that the actions of the claimants … Continue reading Matthews v Collins (T/A Herbert Collins and Sons) and Others: QBD 4 Oct 2013
