

Links: Home \| swarblaw - law discussions		swarb.co.uk - law index These cases are from the lawindexpro database. They are now being transferred to the swarb.co.uk website in a better form. As a case is published there, an entry here will link to it. The swarb.co.uk site includes many later cases. Â
		Intellectual Property - From: 2002 To: 2002 This page lists 1589 cases, and was prepared on 08 August 2015. Â Ghazilian's Trade Mark Application [2002] RPC 628 2002 Intellectual Property The court considered the basis of the conduct of an appeal from a trade mark registry decision. Held: The correct approach is for the appeal to proceed by way of re-hearing, but with due weight being given to the decision of the Registrar, whose hearing officers have extensive experience in dealing with trade mark matters Â Â Sutherland -v- V2 Music Ltd; 2002 - [2002] EMLR 28 Â WB -v- H Bauer Publishing Ltd [2002] EMLR 145 2002 Eady J Intellectual Property, Media 1 Citers Â Â Regina -v- Comptroller-General of Patents Designs and Trademarks ex parte Ash & Lacey Building Products Ltd; 2002 - [2002] RPC 46 Â Regina -v- Johnstone [2002] EWCA Crim 194 2002 CACD Intellectual Property, Crime 1 Cites 1 Citers Â Regina -v- Rhodes [2003] FSR 147; [2002] EWCA 1390 2002 CACD Kay LJ and Andrew Smith J Intellectual Property, Crime Andrew Smith J: "No doubt in many cases the fact that a trader could ascertain whether a trade mark was registered by searching the register will make it extremely difficult to establish a belief involving ignorance of a registered mark is held on 'on reasonable grounds'." Trade Marks Act 1994 1 Cites 1 Citers Â Beckingham -v- Hodgens [2002] EWHC 2143 (Ch); [2002] EMLR 45 2002 ChD Intellectual Property Copyright in music - custom amd practice within the industry. 1 Citers Â CIL International Ltd -v- Vitrashop Ltd [2002] FSR 67 2002 ChD Pumfrey J Intellectual Property Pumfrey J held that an Earth Closet order was not incompatible with the CPR. His reason was that such an order was not incompatible with the overriding objective: "That being the existing state of the law prior to the Civil Procedure Rules it may be seen immediately that it is consistent with the overriding objective of the Civil Procedure Rules, particularly since it can be properly viewed as a means of imposing a sanction in relation to waste caused by lack of diligence by the defendant." 1 Cites 1 Citers Â Sonopress Produktionsgesellschaft Fur Ton- Und Informationstrager Mbh (Unopposed) - O/004/02 7 Jan 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Nokia Corporation -v- Just Phones Ltd [2002] DRS 58 7 Jan 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Sonopress Produktionsgesellschaft Fur Ton-Und Informationstrager Mbh and Artur Redder-Pohlmann (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o00402; GB 0011553.5 7 Jan 2002 IPO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property IPO As a result of an uncontested application filed under section 13(1) by Sonopress Produktionsgesellschaft fur Ton-und Informationstrager mbH, it was found that Artur Redder-Pohlmann should be mentioned as a joint inventor in any patent granted for the invention and directed that an addendum slip mentioning him as a joint inventor be prepared for the published application of the patent. [ Bailii ] Â Sonopress Produktionsgesellschaft Fur Ton- Und Informationstrager Mbh (Unopposed) - Gb001155305 O/004/02; O/004/02 7 Jan 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Barclays Bank Plc -v- Game [2002] DRS 115 7 Jan 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Takeda Chemical Industries Limited (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o00502 8 Jan 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â China White (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o05402 8 Jan 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: PERSONAL M 724668 8 Jan 2002 TMR Mr J Hamilton-Jones Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â 'Personal': Application No M 724668 8 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Hamilton-Jones Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Trade Marks [ PO ] Â Takeda Chemicals Limited - O/005/02 8 Jan 2002 PO Mr R Walker Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Mark: CHINA WHITE 2192332 8 Jan 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'China White': Application No 2192332 OPP 50250; OPP 50250 8 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Takeda Chemicals Limited - Spc/Gb/96/030-035 O/005/02; O/005/02 8 Jan 2002 PO Mr R Walker Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Peoplesoft UK Ltd -v- Kane [2002] DRS 120 9 Jan 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: IDEAL HOME EXHIBITION 2027013A 10 Jan 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Televes UK Ltd -v- Barrington [2002] DRS 74 10 Jan 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Ge Fanuc -v- Pennine Automation Ltd [2002] DRS 77 10 Jan 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Ideal Home Exhibition': Application No 2027013A OPP 50260; OPP 50260 10 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'American Golf Discount': Application No 2045327 OPP 45319; OPP 45319 10 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Kitchin QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Dr Wilhelm Hoermann - O/007/02 10 Jan 2002 PO Mr M Wright Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 2045330 10 Jan 2002 TMR Mr David Kitchin QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: AMERICAN GOLF DISCOUNT 2045327 10 Jan 2002 TMR Mr David Kitchin QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Wilhelm Hoerrmann (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o00702 10 Jan 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Dr Wilhelm Hoermann - Ep0223850 O/007/02; O/007/02 10 Jan 2002 PO Mr M Wright Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â 'Device Only Mark': Application No 2045330 OPP 45530; OPP 45530 10 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Kitchin QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: LENSBURY FIELD SPORTS 2207576 11 Jan 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 1558253 11 Jan 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: FORM ONLY MARK 2185286 F 11 Jan 2002 TMR Mr C Redmore Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â 'Form Only Mark': Application No 2185286 I 11 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Redmore Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Trade Marks [ PO ] Â Mark: RATE WATCH % 2139348B 11 Jan 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: STONEHEAD 2192118 11 Jan 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: RATE WATCH % 2139348A 11 Jan 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Device Only Mark': Application No 1558253 OPP 42081; OPP 42081 11 Jan 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Form Only Mark': Application No 2185286 F 11 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Redmore Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Trade Marks [ PO ] Â 'Stonehead': Application No 2192118 OPP 50343; OPP 50343 11 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Lensbury Field Sports': Application No 2207576 OPP 50723 11 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Rate Watch %': Application No 2139348A OPP 48122; OPP 48122 11 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Rate Watch %': Application No 2139348B OPP 48123; OPP 48123 11 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: FORM ONLY MARK 2185286 I 11 Jan 2002 TMR Mr C Redmore Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â 'Browns': Application No 2105268 OPP 47029; OPP 47029 14 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Torrelongares (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o04502 14 Jan 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Mezzanne': Application No 2204534 OPP 51067; OPP 51067 14 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Lazapell': Application No 2191661 INV 11553; INV 11553 14 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â 'Adrenalin': Application No 2061071 INV 12522; INV 12522 14 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Thorley QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Mark: TORRELONGARES M 667877 14 Jan 2002 TMR Professor Ruth Annand Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: LAZAPELL 2191661 14 Jan 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Mark: ADRENALIN 2061071 14 Jan 2002 TMR Mr S Thorley QC Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Mark: BROWNS 2105268 14 Jan 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: OMEGA METER OPP 50827; 2179158 14 Jan 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition Trade Marks Act 1994 [ PO ] - [ IPO ] Â Mark: MEZZANINE 2204534 14 Jan 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: ULTRAFINE 2182084 14 Jan 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Ultrafine': Application No 2182084 OPP 49780; OPP 49780 14 Jan 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Telstra Corporation Ltd -v- Flipjack [2002] DRS 78 14 Jan 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Torrelongares': Application No M 667877 M OPP 70049; M OPP 70049 14 Jan 2002 TMR Prof Annand Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - [ PO ] Â Newsquest London Ltd -v- Raymond [2002] DRS 00159 15 Jan 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Stage 1&Nbsp;': Application No 2135312 INV 11765; INV 11765 15 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Rose'Meyer Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Mark: ACLAV M 714120 15 Jan 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Aker Oil & Gas Technology UK Plc -v- Sovereign Corporate Ltd [2002] EWHC 104 (TCC) 15 Jan 2002 PatC Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Aclav': Application No M 714120 OPP 70345; OPP 70345 15 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: RAW DESIGN 2164280 15 Jan 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Raw Design': Application No 2164280 OPP 50068; OPP 50068 15 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Foley Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: STAGE 1 2135312 15 Jan 2002 TMR Mr G Rose'Meyer Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Mark: GIANT'S 2123735 17 Jan 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Cb Cheque Bleau': Application No 1281471, 1521713, 1521717 REV 12212; REV 12281; REV 12282 17 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â 'Giant'S': Application No 2123735 OPP 49313; OPP 49313 17 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: CB CHEQUE BLEAU 1281471, 1521713, 1521717 17 Jan 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Pharmacia Ab -v- Wagstaff [2002] DRS 48 18 Jan 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: HYPER BLASTER 2109192 18 Jan 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Â Interroof Products Limited (Patent); IPO 18-Jan-2002 - [2002] UKIntelP o02302; GB 2251575 Â 'Sundip': Application No 2209524 OPP 50875; OPP 50875 18 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Interroof Products Ltd - O/023/02 18 Jan 2002 PO Mr M Wright Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â 'Hyper Blaster': Application No 2109192 OPP 46448 18 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Interroof Products Ltd - Gb2251575 O/023/02; O/023/02 18 Jan 2002 PO Mr M Wright Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Mark: SUNDIP 2209524 18 Jan 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: SMART LIFT M 722469 19 Jan 2002 TMR Miss J Folwell Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â 'Smart Lift': Application No M 722469 19 Jan 2002 TMR Miss Folwell Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Trade Marks [ PO ] Â Mark: IRIS 1564851 22 Jan 2002 TMR Mrs A Cheeseman Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â 'Iris': Application No 1564851 22 Jan 2002 TMR Ms Cheeseman Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Trade Marks [ PO ] Â Lilly Icos Ltd -v- Pfizer Ltd (No 2) Times, 28 January 2002; Gazette, 06 March 2002; [2002] EWCA Civ 2; [2002] 1 WLR 2253 23 Jan 2002 CA Lord Justice Aldous, Lord Justice Buxton and Lord Justice Longmore Intellectual Property, Litigation Practice, Civil Procedure Rules, Information The respondent sought an order to maintain the confidentiality of documents disclosed during patent revocation proceedings. It now appealed an order refusing confidentiality. Held: Under normal circumstances, a party requesting such an order must provide clear reasons for it to be granted. The court should recognise the lack of protection which would attach to a document disclosed during proceedings but then, however it arose, coming into third party hands. In this case, the figures sought to be protected were figures for marketing costs. Patent cases were subject to the same general rules as any other cases, but did present some particular problems, and were subject to some particular considerations. The sensitivity of such figures was recognised, and the court should have granted protection, allowing for the limited part it played in the trial. Civil Procedure Rules 31.22 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ Bailii ] Â Commerzbank Ag -v- Castellomedia Ltd [2002] DRS 106 23 Jan 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Lilly Icos Llc -v- Pfizer Ltd (1) [2002] EWCA Civ 1 23 Jan 2002 CA Lord Justice Aldous Lord Justice Buxton And Lord Justice Longmore Intellectual Property The claimant had begun proceedings to apply for the revocation of the defendant's patent for Viagra, on the grounds of obviousness. The defendant appealed the revocation. Held: The prior literature was clear. It would have been obvious to have tried such a new medication in animal based experiments, and the need for those could not be used to support a claim for lack of obviousness. Any such testing would have taken a comparatively short time. That is what the skilled man in the art would have done. The patent was obvious, and the appeal against revocation failed. 1 Cites [ Bailii ] Â Sony Computer Entertainment -v- Paul Owen [2002] EMLR 34; [2002] EWHC 45 (Ch) 23 Jan 2002 ChD Jacob J Media, Intellectual Property, Damages Claim for infringement - sale of chip designed to bypass country code control on the claimant's gaming machines. Held: An infringement of copyright committed in breach of an injunction restraining such infringement can found an award of additional damages. In distinguishing WB, Jacob J said: "That seems to me to be a very different case because there is no provision authorising damages for contempt itself and no provision in the general law for additional damages for the wrongs alleged [Bauer's case was a case of breach of confidence]. Here there is. Section 97 requires the Court to have regard to all the circumstances. Those circumstances, to my mind, plainly can include the circumstance that the sales were done in breach of a Court Order. They make the act flagrant. They make the act fairly describable as "scandalous". In this regard, copyright is different from many other rights precisely because there is the statutory right to additional damages if the Court, in all the circumstances, thinks it right to grant them. I do, in this case, in principle, although I am told that the evidence will establish mitigating circumstances. " 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Â Tickner, Woodhouse -v- Honda Motor Company Limited (a Company Incorporated Under the Laws of Japan), Honda Europe Nv (a Company Incorporated Under the Laws of Belgium), Honda Motor Europe Limited; PatC 24-Jan-2002 - [2002] EWHC 8 (Patents) Â 'Bendy': Application No 2157304 OPP 48744; OPP 48744 24 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Rose'Meyer Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 2134604 24 Jan 2002 TMR Mr A Pike Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Mark: ULKER 2113583 24 Jan 2002 TMR Mr E S Smith Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Mark: BENDY 2157304 24 Jan 2002 TMR Mr G Rose'Meyer Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Ulker': Application No 2113583 INV 12501; INV 12501 24 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Smith Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â 'Device Only Mark': Application No 2134604 24 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Pike Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Trade Marks [ PO ] Â 'Diana Princess of Wales Memorial Fund': Application No 2161386, 2143993B, 2161371 OPP 49431; OPP 49400 25 Jan 2002 TMR Mr James Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: DIANA PRINCESS OF WALES MEMORIAL FUND 2143993B, 2161371, 2161386 25 Jan 2002 TMR Mr A James Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â British Board of Film Classification -v- Bulletin Board for Film Censorship [2002] DRS 104 28 Jan 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: GOLF COURTS 2140143A, 2140143B 28 Jan 2002 TMR Mr David Kitchin QC Intellectual Property IPO Rectification. [ IPO ] Â 'Guildford of Maine': Application No 1536580 OPP 41991; OPP 41991 28 Jan 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Golf Courts (Trade Mark: Rectification) [2002] UKIntelP o05602 28 Jan 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Golf Courts': Application No 2140143A 2140143B REC 11445 REC 11446; REC 11445, REC 11446 28 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Kitchin QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Rectification [ PO ] Â Mark: GUILDFORD OF MAINE 1536580 28 Jan 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â London Metal Exchange -v- CPIC Net [2002] DRS 133 29 Jan 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Form Only Mark (Trade Mark: Appointed Person) [2002] UKIntelP o05502 29 Jan 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: FORM ONLY MARK 2148672 29 Jan 2002 TMR Mr David Kitchin QC Intellectual Property IPO Appointed Person. [ IPO ] Â 'Form Only Mark': Application No 2148672 29 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Kitchin QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - [ PO ] Â 'Tesco People Make the Difference': Application No 2203648 OPP 50578 30 Jan 2002 TMR Dr Trott Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Donuts & Company': Application No 2146004A 2146004B OPP 48878 OPP 48883; OPP 48878, OPP 48883 30 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Kitchin QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Luxor': Application No 2203017 OPP 50538; OPP 50538 30 Jan 2002 TMR Dr Trott Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: TESCO PEOPLE MAKE THE DIFFERENCE 2203648 30 Jan 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: 3 DIMENSIONAL 2209937 30 Jan 2002 TMR Mr I Peggie Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Mark: 3 DIMENSIONAL 2209936 30 Jan 2002 TMR Mr I Peggie Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Mark: LUXOR 2203017 30 Jan 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Donuts Company (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o06902 30 Jan 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â '3 Dimensional': Application No 2209936 30 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Peggie Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Trade Marks [ PO ] Â '3 Dimensional': Application No 2209937 30 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Peggie Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Trade Marks [ PO ] Â Mark: DONUTS & COMPANY 2146004A, 2146004B 30 Jan 2002 TMR Mr David Kitchin QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Device Only': Application No 2191419 31 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Rees Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Trade Marks [ PO ] Â Mark: ROYAL COUNTY OF BERKSHIRE POLO CLUB 2132617 31 Jan 2002 TMR Mr David Kitchin QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Nexavar': Application No 2234375 INV 12067; INV 12067 31 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â China National Petroleum Corporation and others -v- Fenwick Elliott, Techint International Construction Company [2002] EWHC 60 (Ch) 31 Jan 2002 ChD The Vice-Chancellor Construction, Intellectual Property, Information, Legal Professions In the course of a dispute, the claimants concluded that the respondents had acquired documents of a confidential nature, and sought restoration and disclosure of the source. The solicitors for the respondents suggested that the claimants were in breach of disclosure orders, and that the materials were not privileged, and would be subject to disclosure in any event. It was then alleged that the respondent firm had acted improperly in seeking privileged information from employees of the claimants. It was argued that the sources of the information should be disclosed, but the respondents argued that this might put them at personal risk. In this case there was no evidence of privilege inhering, and no specific allegations, and the respondents claim of privilege attaching to his interviews of witnesses succeeded. The claim had no prospect of success and was struck out. 1 Cites [ Bailii ] Â Â Intel Corporation -v- Via Technologies (Patent); IPO 31-Jan-2002 - [2002] UKIntelP o07102 Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY 2191419 31 Jan 2002 TMR Mr M Rees Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Mark: NEXAVAR 2234375 31 Jan 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Royal County of Berkshire Polo Club (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o06802 31 Jan 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Royal County of Berkshire Polo Club': Application No 2132617 OPP 47418; OPP 47418 31 Jan 2002 TMR Mr Kitchin QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Device Only (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o04602 31 Jan 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Intel Corporation -v- Via Technologies - O/071/02 31 Jan 2002 PO Mr P Hayward Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Intel Corporation -v- Via Technologies - Ep0804763 O/071/02; O/071/02 31 Jan 2002 PO Mr P Hayward Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â 'Darigard': Application No 1481338 INV 11005; INV 11005 1 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Foley Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Darigard (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o04702 1 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DARIGARD 1481338 1 Feb 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Regina -v- Johnstone, etc Times, 12 March 2002; Gazette, 28 March 2002; [2002] EWCA Crim 194 1 Feb 2002 CACD Lord Justice Tuckey, Mr Justice Pumfrey and Mr Justice Burton Crime, Intellectual Property The several defendants appealed convictions for breaches of section 92 of the Act. Held: The section presumed that a civil infringement of the Trade Mark had taken place. Accordingly any of the defences available to a civil action must be available also against a criminal action. Furthermore there was no conflict between the Act and the Directive. Council Directive 89/104/EEC (OJ 1989 L40/5) the Trade Marks Directive - Trade Marks Act 1994 1 Cites [ Bailii ] Â Â Regina (Ash and Lacy Building Products Ltd) -v- Comptroller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks; ChD 1-Feb-2002 - Times, 12 March 2002; Gazette, 15 March 2002 Â Foot Anstey Sargent -v- Cameron [2002] DRS 160 3 Feb 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Gandhi Restaurant -v- Mahmmued [2002] DRS 1413 4 Feb 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Team': Application No 1572646 REV 10563; REV 10563 4 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Hobbs QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â 'Spambuster': Application No 2152840 INV 12433; INV 12433 4 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Mark: SPAMBUSTER 2152840 4 Feb 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Mark: MEZZACORONA 2029556 4 Feb 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mezzacorona (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o04902 4 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Team (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o05202 4 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: TEAM 1572646 4 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Geoffrey Hobbs QC Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â 'Mezzacorona': Application No 2029556 OPP 46049; OPP 46049 4 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Spambuster (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o04802 4 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Otto Santi': Application No 2129800 OPP 50698; OPP 50698 5 Feb 2002 TMR Dr Trott Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Churchwards Lightning Jack': Application No 2225149 OPP 51239 5 Feb 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Vintage Reds (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o05302 5 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Vintage Reds': Application No 2242346 OPP 52297; OPP 52297 5 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: OTTO SANTI 2129800 5 Feb 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: CHURCHWARDS LIGHTNING JACK 2225149 5 Feb 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: VINTAGE REDS 2242346 5 Feb 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Churchwards Lightning Jack (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o05002 5 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Otto Santi (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o05102 5 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Â Ancare New Zealand Limited -v- Fort Dodge New Zealand and Nufarm Limited; PC 6-Feb-2002 - Appeal No 32 of 2001; [2002] UKPC 8 Â The Thrombosis Research Institute And Trigen Limited -v- West Pharmaceutical Services Drug Delivery And Clinical Research Centre Limited - O/058/02 6 Feb 2002 PO Mr D Barford Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Â The Thrombosis Research Institute and Trigen Limited -v- West Pharmaceutical Services Drug Delivery and Clinical Research Centre Limited (Formerly Danbiosyst) Or, In The Case of The Usa, Peter Watts (Patent); IPO 6-Feb-2002 - [2002] UKIntelP o05802; PCT/GB98/03511 Â The Thrombosis Research Institute and Trigen Limited -v- West Pharmaceutical Services Drug Delivery and Clinical Research Centre Limited - Pct/Gb98/03511 O/058/02; O/058/02 6 Feb 2002 PO Mr D Barford Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Mark: e ORACLE BUSINESS EUROPE 2249175 7 Feb 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Â E Oracle Business Europe (Trade Mark: Invalidity); IPO 7-Feb-2002 - [2002] UKIntelP o05702 Â Vista Computer Services Ltd -v- Ankostuff Ltd [2002] DRS 145 7 Feb 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'E Oracle Business Europe': Application No 2249175 INV 12541 7 Feb 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Â Radiuscrown Limited -v- Ash & Lacey Building Products Limited; PO 7-Feb-2002 - O/060/02; GB2240559 Â Â Radiuscrown Limited -v- Ash & Lacey Building Products Limited; PO 7-Feb-2002 - O/060/02 Â Â Radiuscrown Limited -v- Ash Lacey Building Products Limited (Patent); IPO 7-Feb-2002 - [2002] UKIntelP o06002 Â Mark: DATACOLOUR IMAGING 2164931 8 Feb 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Datacolour Imaging (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o06302 8 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Â Lisa Mori (Trade Mark: Opposition); IPO 8-Feb-2002 - [2002] UKIntelP o05902 Â 'Lisa Mori': Application No 717233 OPP 70262; OPP 70262 8 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 2188098 8 Feb 2002 TMR Mr C Hamilton Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â 'Datacolour Imaging': Application No 2164931 OPP 50554; OPP 50554 8 Feb 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: LISA MORI 717233 8 Feb 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Device Only Mark': Application No 2188098 8 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Hamilton Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Trade Marks [ PO ] Â Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Ex Parte); IPO 8-Feb-2002 - [2002] UKIntelP o06402 Â James Sandiford (Motorcycles) Ltd -v- KJM Ltd [2002] DRS 141 9 Feb 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â David Broughton -v- Baylis Generators Limited (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o06102 11 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Dandy (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o06502 11 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DANDY 2045573A 11 Feb 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â David Broughton -v- Baylis Generators Limited - O/061/02 11 Feb 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â David Broughton -v- Baylis Generators Limited - Gb2304208 O/061/02 11 Feb 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â 'Dandy': Application No 2045573A OPP 49362; OPP 49362 11 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â IDA Limited and Others -v- University of Southampton (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o06702 12 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â I D A Limited, Colin Thomas Metcalfe, David Julian Lax and Polymer Powder Technology (Licensing) Limited -v- The University of Southampton O/067/02; O/067/02 12 Feb 2002 PO Mr R Kennell Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â I D A Limited, Colin Thomas Metcalfe, David Julian Lax And Polymer Powder Technology (Licensing) Limited -v- The University Of Southampton - O/067/02 12 Feb 2002 PO Mr R Kennell Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Hug (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o07002 13 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: HUG 2247696 13 Feb 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Red-X (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o08102 13 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: RED-X 2238189 13 Feb 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Hug': Application No 2247696 OPP 52185; OPP 52185 13 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Red-X': Application No 2238189 OPP 51777; OPP 51777 13 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Tarmac Ltd -v- Etches [2002] DRS 177 14 Feb 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â John Quentin Phillips - Gb9913529 5 O/072/02 14 Feb 2002 PO Mr B Westerman Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â John Quentin Phillips - O/072/02 14 Feb 2002 PO Mr B Westerman Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â John Quentin Phillips (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o07202 14 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Ludlow Music Inc -v- Williams and others (No.2) [2002] EWHC 638 (Ch); [2002] ECDR CN 6; [2002] EMLR 29; [2002] FSR 57 14 Feb 2002 ChD Intellectual Property 1 Cites [ Bailii ] Â Arthur Stephen Boardman O/080/02 15 Feb 2002 PO Mr D Jerreat Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Damien Davies -v- Loughborough University Innovations Ltd - O/079/02 15 Feb 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â 'Client Service Frame Work': Application No 2186298 15 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Hamilton Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Trade Marks [ PO ] Â Health Matters (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o07602 15 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Camoris (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o06602 15 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Damien Davies -v- Loughborough University Innovations Limited (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o07902 15 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Dialogue (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o08402 15 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o07302 15 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DIALOGUE 1429292 15 Feb 2002 TMR Mr David Kitchin QC Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Mark: CAMORIS 2111766 15 Feb 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 2017806 15 Feb 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: SKY DIGIBOX 2152881 15 Feb 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: PUPSTER 2181668B 15 Feb 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: HEALTH MATTERS 2248161 15 Feb 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Tel-Box -v- Saltire Investments Ltd [2002] DRS 69 15 Feb 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: CLIENT SERVICE FRAME WORK 2186298 15 Feb 2002 TMR Mr C Hamilton Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Client Service Frame Work (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o08202 15 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Bat Out of Hell': Application No 2024326 15 Feb 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Health Matters': Application No 2248161 OPP 52183; OPP 52183; Annex OPP 52183 15 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] - [ PO ] Â 'Sky Digibox': Application No 2152881 OPP 50034; OPP 50034 15 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Device Only Mark': Application No 2017806 OPP 45214; OPP 45214 15 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Camoris': Application No 2111766 OPP 50570; OPP 50570 15 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Dialogue': Application No 1429292 REV 10491; REV 10491 15 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Kitchin QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â Mark: BAT OUT OF HELL 2024326 15 Feb 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Inter Partes. [ IPO ] Â Arthur Stephen Boardman (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o08002 15 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Arthur Stephen Boardman - Gb0008475 6 O/080/02 15 Feb 2002 PO Mr D Jerreat Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Sky Digibox (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o07402 15 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Damien Davies -v- Loughborough University Innovations Ltd - Gb2359924 O/079/02; O/079/02 15 Feb 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Pupster (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o07502 15 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Bat Out of Hell (Trade Mark: Inter Partes) [2002] UKIntelP o07702 15 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Ufi Ltd -v- Inet Learning Ltd [2002] DRS 161 17 Feb 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â John Gunton Pty Ltd -v- Ilight Ltd [2002] DRS 95 18 Feb 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Ferrucci (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o07802 18 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: FERRUCCI 2205983 18 Feb 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Ferrucci': Application No 2205983 OPP 50642; OPP 50642 18 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Andrew Tobias Ward (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o14302 19 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Lambrini': Application No 2201916 OPP 50435 20 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: LAMBRINI 2201916 20 Feb 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Lambrini (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o08302 20 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property (Trade Mark: Opposition) [ Bailii ] Â 'Animal': Application No 2054886 REV 11640; INV 11643 21 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Ghi Ltd (T/A Aviance Uk) -v- Draper [2002] DRS 147 21 Feb 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Animal (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o08502 21 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: ANIMAL 2054886 21 Feb 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Mark: DAN DAIRIES 2187124 22 Feb 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Cofton Country Holidays -v- Jeffery [2002] DRS 153 22 Feb 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Ge Capital Corporation (Holdings) -v- Perry [2002] DRS 186 22 Feb 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Dan Dairies': Application No 2187124 INV 12398; INV 12398 22 Feb 2002 TMR Dr Trott Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Dan Dairies (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o08602 22 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Swiss Watch Company': Application No 740106 M OPP 70536; M OPP 70536 25 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Foley Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 2231098A 25 Feb 2002 TMR Miss J Folwell Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â 'Device Only Mark': Application No 2231098A 25 Feb 2002 TMR Miss Folwell Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Trade Marks [ PO ] Â Rexham Plastics Inc (Unopposed) - Gb2330256 O/095/02; O/095/02 25 Feb 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â 'After Sex Mints': Application No 2208294 OPP 50696; OPP 50696 25 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Foley Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o08802 25 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Swiss Watch Company (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o08902 25 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Rexam Plastics, Inc -v- Jeffrey C Minnette (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o09502 25 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 2231098B 25 Feb 2002 TMR Miss J Folwell Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o08702 25 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Rexham Plastics Inc (Unopposed) - O/095/02 25 Feb 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â APC Overnight Ltd -v- M J Couriers [2002] DRS 192 25 Feb 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: AFTER SEX MINTS 2208294 25 Feb 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â After Sex Mints (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o09002 25 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: SWISS WATCH COMPANY 740106 25 Feb 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: VERSALUX 2168334 27 Feb 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: QUESTOR 2190881 27 Feb 2002 TMR Mr C Redmore Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Versalux (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o09602 27 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: ALCHEMY 2168582 27 Feb 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Questor (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o09102 27 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â WWF - World Wide Fund for Nature (Formerly World Wildlife Fund); World Wildlife Fund Inc -v- World Wrestling Federation Entertainment Inc Times, 12 March 2002; Gazette, 11 April 2002; [2002] EWCA Civ 196 27 Feb 2002 CA Lord Phillips M.R., Lord Justice Judge, Lord Justice Carnwath Intellectual Property, Contract, Commercial The claimant sought enforcement of a contract restricting the use by the appellant defendant of the initials 'WWF' in their trading. The agreement had been reached in settlement of an action for breach of the claimant's trade mark rights. The claimant was particularly concerned as to the injurious association with the respondent, and its use of the mark on the Internet. Held: The scratch logo used by the federation was a clear breach. They had not seriously sought to argue that they were not in breach of the agreement. The protection of the intellectual property rights of one business inevitably implies some restriction on the rights of others with potentially conflicting interests. There was no undue interference in the freedom of the defendant to trade. The breaches were clear, and the agreement was to be upheld. Appeal against summary judgement dismissed. 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â 'Versalux': Application No 2168334 OPP 49107; OPP 49107 27 Feb 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Alchemy': Application No 2168582 OPP 49398; OPP 49398 27 Feb 2002 TMR Dr Trott Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Alchemy (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o09702 27 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â LogicaComMx (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o09202 28 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Say It With A Chocolate (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o09302 28 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Fibreguide Limited -v- Deutsche Institute Fur Textil-Und Faserforschung Stuttgart O/094/02; [2002] UKIntelP o09402 28 Feb 2002 IPO Intellectual Property Patent - The application under section 71(1) had been stayed to await the outcome of court proceedings on validity and infringement. Following a finding that the patent was invalid and not infringed and dismissal of an appeal by consent, the patent fell to be revoked. Only the issue of costs then remained outstanding in the section 71(1) proceedings, and the parties were directed to bear their own cost [ Bailii ] Â Mark: SAY IT WITH A CHOCOLATE 734783 28 Feb 2002 TMR Mr A Pike Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Mark: LOGICA.COM.MX 2214271 28 Feb 2002 TMR Mr A Pike Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Fibreguide Limited -v- Deutsche Institute Fur Textil-Und Faserforschung Stuttgart - O/094/02 28 Feb 2002 PO Mr R Kennell Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Fibreguide Limited -v- Deutsche Institute Fur Textil-Und Faserforschung Stuttgart - Ep0326552 O/094/02; O/094/02 28 Feb 2002 PO Mr R Kennell Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o10002 1 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 2215669 1 Mar 2002 TMR Mr C Hamilton Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Cheltenham & Gloucester -v- Ryder [2002] DRS 203 1 Mar 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Merlinroute Ltd -v- Oliver [2002] DRS 172 3 Mar 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Admiral Management Services Ltd -v- Para-Protect Europe Ltd and Others Times, 26 March 2002; Gazette, 18 April 2002; [2002] 1 WLR 2722; [2002] EWHC 233 (Ch); [2002] FSR 59; [2002] CP Rep 37; [2003] 2 All ER 1017; [2003] 1 Costs LR 1 4 Mar 2002 ChD Mr Justice Stanley Burnton Intellectual Property, Damages The claimants suspected the defendants of wrongfully using their confidential information. Their staff made an initial investigation. They obtained a search and seizure order; and the material seized was examined by the staff. A Tomlin Order was made, under which an issue between the parties as to the defendants' liability to the claimants for their staff costs referable to the investigation and examination was referred to a judge. Held: In general a party's own employees' expenses incurred in investigating a claim were not recoverable, but the exception in Nossen was not limited to patents challenges, and could include other intellectual property tort claims. The test was whether if the company had employed an external expert, that expert's expenses would also have been recoverable, and or where revenue has been lost as a result of the employee being unavailable to carry out revenue producing work. Stanley Burnton J: "Of course, it may be difficult to quantify any loss of revenue or business consequential on the diversion of employee time to dealing with the tort or breach of contract suffered by an employer. It may be that the cost of employee time may be taken as an approximation for the loss of revenue involved; but, if so, the claim remains a claim for loss of revenue rather than a claim for expenditure occasioned by the tort or breach of contract." 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Penguin Books Ltd -v- Cieplak [2002] DRS 114 4 Mar 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Club Nation': Application No 2149426 OPP 48408; OPP 48408 5 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: CLUB NATION 2149426 5 Mar 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Club Nation (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o09902 5 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Pavneet S Mumick -v- Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc - O/102/02 5 Mar 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Pavneet S Mumick -v- Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o10202; GB 0117044.8 5 Mar 2002 IPO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property IPO As a result of an uncontested application filed under section 13(1) by Pavneet S Mumick, it was found that Pavneet S Mumick should be mentioned as a joint inventor in any patent granted for the invention and directed that an addendum slip mentioning him as a joint inventor be prepared for the published application of the patent. [ Bailii ] Â Pavneet S Mumick -v- Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc - Gb0117044 8 O/102/02 5 Mar 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Mark: CELEXA 2172950 6 Mar 2002 TMR Mr R A Jones Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 2208648 6 Mar 2002 TMR Mr A Pike Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Celexa (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o09802 6 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o10102 6 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Cairnstores Limited Generics (UK) Limited -v- Aktiebolaget Hassle [2002] EWHC 309 (Ch) 6 Mar 2002 ChD The Honourable Mr Justice Laddie Intellectual Property Patents were challenged which were for mechanisms for protecting from the effects of acid in the stomach of drugs which required to be delivered to the intestine, but delivered orally The challengers claimed that the claims were obvious. The layers of chemicals used to coat the drugs would have been known. Held: The claims were indeed obvious on the facts. The different layers would have been expected to produce an unwelcome interaction, and therefore required an intermediate barrier layer. The challenge succeeded. 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â 'Celexa': Application No 2172950 OPP 49345; OPP 49345 6 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Jones Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Brama Brown & Root (A Firm) -v- Marshall Aerospace Ltd [2002] EWHC 1569 (TCC) 6 Mar 2002 PatC Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Technic': Application No 2161257 868593 1181046 1187039 REV 11473; OPP 49498 7 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Hobbs QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Technic (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o20202 7 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: TECHNIC 1181046, 1187039, 2161257, 868 7 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Geoffrey Hobbs QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Harman International Industries Inc -v- Joleys [2002] DRS 193 8 Mar 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Harrodian (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o10402 11 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Holder & Holder -v- Countrywide Surveyors Ltd [2002] EWHC 856 (TCC) 11 Mar 2002 PatC Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Drillvac (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o10502 11 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Parcel Point (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o10602 11 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Ready Steady Go! (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o10302 11 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Saab (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o10802 11 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Harrodian': Application No 2041293 OPP 46377; OPP 46377 11 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â L E Jones (Insurance Brokers) Ltd -v- Portsmouth City Council [2002] EWHC 1568 (TCC) 11 Mar 2002 PatC Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Drillvac': Application No 2200317 OPP 50419; OPP 50419 11 Mar 2002 TMR Mr James Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Parcel Point': Application No 2239970 OPP 51955; OPP 51955 11 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: READY STEADY GO! 2149184A, 2149484B 11 Mar 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â 'Saab': Application No 1128486 REV 11423; REV 11423 11 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â Mark: SAAB 1128486 11 Mar 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Mark: PARCEL POINT 2239970 11 Mar 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: DRILLVAC 2200317 11 Mar 2002 TMR Mr A James Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: HARRODIAN 2041293 11 Mar 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Ready Steady Go!': Application No 2149184A 2149484B INV 12418; INV 12417 11 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â 'Discovery Pc': Application No 2150205 OPP 50246; OPP 50246 12 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Foley Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Pipeline (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o11002 12 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Pc Clear (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o11102 12 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Trustedmime (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o10902 12 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Pc Clear': Application No 2126739 OPP 48501; OPP 48501 12 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: DISCOVERY PC 2150205 12 Mar 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: TrustedMIME M.713149 12 Mar 2002 TMR Mr J Hamilton-Jones Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Mark: PIPELINE 2173875 12 Mar 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: PC CLEAR 2126739 12 Mar 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 1369454 12 Mar 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Mark: ISP 2162786 12 Mar 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Isp': Application No 2162786 OPP 50023; OPP 50023 12 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Foley Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Device Only Mark': Application No 1369454 INV 9914; INV 9914 12 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o11202 12 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Discovery Pc (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o10702 12 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Isp (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o11302 12 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Pipeline': Application No 2173875 OPP 50294; OPP 50294 12 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Â Irvine, Tidswell Ltd -v- Talksport Ltd; ChD 13-Mar-2002 - Gazette, 23 May 2002; [2002] EWHC 367 (Ch); [2002] EMLR 32; [2002] 2 All ER 414; (2002) 25(6) IPD 25039; [2002] 1 WLR 2355; [2002] FSR 60 Â Mark: SURF UNLIMITED 2216981 13 Mar 2002 TMR Mr R A Jones Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Me Mail Order -v- Starlight [2002] DRS 205 13 Mar 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Surf Unlimited (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o11802 13 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Aeronet (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o11502 14 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Giorgio Venturi': Application No 2132590 OPP 50509 14 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Thai Ceramics (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o11702 14 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Oded Sturman -v- Sturman Industries Inc GB 2323411; O/120/02 14 Mar 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents Patents Act 1977 13(1) [ PO ] Â Oded E Sturman -v- Sturman Industries Inc (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o12002 14 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Giorgio Venturi (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o11402 14 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â George (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o11602 14 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'the Original Est 1954 El Torito Restaurant': Application No 1312756 REV 10170 14 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â 'Thai Ceramics': Application No 2225337 INV 12467 14 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â 'George': Application No 2160590A OPP 49549 14 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Aeronet': Application No 2026845B 2026845A OPP 49245 14 Mar 2002 TMR Mr James Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â The Original Est 1954 El Torito Restaurant (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o11902 14 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: GEORGE 2160590A 14 Mar 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Â Nottinghamshire Healthcare National Health Service Trust -v- News Group Newspapers Ltd; ChD 14-Mar-2002 - Times, 01 April 2002; Gazette, 23 May 2002; [2002] EWHC 409 (Ch); [2002] EMLR 33 Â Mark: THE ORIGINAL EST 1954 EL TORITO RESTAURANT 1312756 14 Mar 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Mark: THAI CERAMICS 2225337 14 Mar 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Mark: GIORGIO VENTURI 2132590 14 Mar 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Oded Sturman -v- Sturman Industries Inc - O/120/02 14 Mar 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Mark: AERONET 2026845A, 2026845B 14 Mar 2002 TMR Mr A James Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Captain K': Application No 21592404 OPP 51405; OPP 51405 15 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Armando Pollini (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o14602 15 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: NETHEALTH 2209842 15 Mar 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Pickfords Ltd -v- Anglo Continental Ltd [2002] DRS 187 15 Mar 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Nethealth': Application No 2209842 OPP 51405; OPP 51405 15 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Nethealth (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o12102 15 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Armando Pollini': Application No 2011477 INV 9349 15 Mar 2002 TMR Professor Annand Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Mark: ARMANDO POLLINI 2011477 15 Mar 2002 TMR Professor Ruth Annand Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Captain K (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o12202 15 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Menashe Business Mercantile Ltd and Another -v- William Hill Organization Ltd [2002] EWHC 397 (Patents) 15 Mar 2002 PatC Mr Justice Jacob Intellectual Property The claimants had a patent specifying a means of gambling over computers connected at a distance. They brought infringement proceedings against the respondent, who defended by asserting that since the host computer was located abroad it did not infringe, claiming in aid the provisions which referred to the making of a supply within the UK. Held: The requirement under the Act and the convention was that there needed to be shown only the production of an effect within a convention state. That part of the process took place outside could not protect it. European Patent Convention - Patents Act 1977 60(2) 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Mark: CAPTAIN K 21592404 15 Mar 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Vetrepharm Limited & Alpharma -v- Vericore Limited - Gb2270261 O/125/02; O/125/02 18 Mar 2002 PO Mr S Dennehey Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Vetrepharm Limited & Alpharma -v- Vericore Limited - O/125/02 18 Mar 2002 PO Mr S Dennehey Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Vetrapharm Limited and Alpharma; Vericore (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o12502 18 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Gerber Products Company -v- Gerber Foods International Ltd Gazette, 25 April 2002; [2002] EWHC 428 (Ch) 18 Mar 2002 ChD The Vice-Chancellor Intellectual Property The opponent marketed baby food using the trade mark. The applicant sough revocation of the trade mark on the grounds of it not having been bona-fide used. Held: The Electrolux case did not establish that the mark owner had to establish commercial use on a substantial scale in addition to bona fide use. Section 26(1) of the 1938 Act continued to apply to this matter. A test marketing of 1200 jars of baby food was a bona fide use, and was sufficient to defend the mark. Trade Marks Act 1938 26(1) - Trade Marks Act 1994 Sch 3 para 17(1) 1 Cites [ Bailii ] Â Mark: FORMULA ONE 1479350, 1479665 19 Mar 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â 'Formula One': Application No 1479665 1479350 REV 11420 REV 11421; REV 11420 REV 11421 19 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â 'Dinos': Application No 2169931 OPP 50500; OPP 50500 19 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: AMERICAN COLLEGE IN LONDON 2171459 19 Mar 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Formula One (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o12402 19 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â American College In London (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o12902 19 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'American Collegein London': Application No 2171459 OPP 50517; OPP 50517 19 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Acroprint (Trade Mark: Invalidity) INV 11410; 1371224; [2002] UKIntelP o12702 19 Mar 2002 IPO Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] - [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DINOS 2169931 19 Mar 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Dinos (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o12602 19 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Dynamark': Application No 1109421 REV 11244; REV 11244 20 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â Dynamark (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o12802 20 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DYNAMARK 1109421 20 Mar 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Mark: THE ORIGINAL EL TORITO RESTAURANT EST 1954 2129516 21 Mar 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Police (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o13102 21 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: POLICE 2008994 21 Mar 2002 TMR Mr G Rose'Meyer Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â The Original El Torito Restaurant Est 1954 (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o13002 21 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Roy of The Rovers (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o13202 21 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: ROY OF THE ROVERS 2170497 21 Mar 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Govia Ltd -v- Painter [2002] DRS 238 21 Mar 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Police': Application No 2008994 REV 12215; REV 12215 21 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Rose'Meyer Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â 'Roy of the Rovers': Application No 2170497 OPP 50425; OPP 50425 21 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Hoechst Marion Roussel Ltd and others -v- Kirin-Amgen Inc and others [2002] EWHC 471 (Patents) 21 Mar 2002 PatC The Hon Mr Justice Neuberger Intellectual Property A claim was made on the one hand for a patent infringement, and on the other it was challenged. The patent related to recombinant erythropoietin. Held: The claim 19 was invalid (for insufficiency) but that claim 26 was valid and infringed. 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Edmund Nuttall Ltd -v- R G Carter Ltd [2002] EWHC 400 (Technology); [2002] EWHC 400 (TCC) 21 Mar 2002 PatC Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] - [ Bailii ] Â 'the Original Eltorito Restaurant Est 1954': Application No 2129516 INV 12445; INV 12445 21 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Leeds Festival (Mela) Ltd -v- Preview Channel [2002] DRS 188 22 Mar 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Ww Westwood': Application No 2191548 OPP 50567 22 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: WW WESTWOOD 2191548 22 Mar 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Ww Westwood (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o13302 22 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Greene King Brewing & Retailing Ltd -v- Breworld Ltd [2002] DRS B1 25 Mar 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Chamberlain Carpentry & Joinery Ltd -v- Alfred Mcalpine Construction Ltd [2002] EWHC 514 (TCC) 25 Mar 2002 PatC Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Fieldturf Holdings, Inc (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o19202 25 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Fieldturf Holdings, Inc - Gb 0028560 1 O/192/02; O/192/02 25 Mar 2002 PO Mrs S E Chalmers Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Fieldturf Holdings, Inc - O/192/02 25 Mar 2002 PO Mrs S E Chalmers Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Banana Beach Sunwipe (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o14102 26 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Banana Beachsunwipe': Application No 2211995 OPP 50791; OPP 50791 26 Mar 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Revlon': Application No 1372540 OPP 30883; OPP 30883 26 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Revlon (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o14002 26 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: BANANA BEACH SUNWIPE 2211995 26 Mar 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Premier Luggage and Bags Ltd -v- The Premier Company (UK) Ltd and Another [2002] EWCA Civ 387; [2003] FSR 5 26 Mar 2002 CA Chadwick LJ Intellectual Property The owner of a registered trade mark "Premier" sued for swing tags which carried the defendant's full name "The Premier Company (UK) Ltd.". Held: A trade mark use can fall within the scope of the Art 6.1 defence. There there was no passing off or Art.5.1(a) infringement in respect of these: "If the use by Premier UK plc of swing tags does not amount to passing off, the claim for infringement of trade mark based on that use must fail also. This is because, as the judge recognised, there was no desire on the part of Premier UK to take unfair advantage of the reputation or goodwill of Premier Luggage. The swing tags were used for a legitimate commercial purpose – to identify the trade origin of Premier UK's product and to take advantage of the existing goodwill and trade connections of Premier Decorations. The use of the name 'The Premier Company (UK) Limited and the address 'Premier House' on the swing tags is within s.11(2)(a) of the 1994 Act." However, The Premier Company (UK) Ltd could not use Premier, Premier Luggage or the Premier Luggage Company with impunity under section 11(1)(a) because these were abbreviations or adaptations of the company's name. There was no indication that it had adopted any of these words or phrases as a trading name Trade Marks Act 1994 11(1)(a) 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Mark: REVLON 1372540 26 Mar 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Freemans Plc -v- Park Street Properties (Lincoln) Ltd and others [2002] EWHC 477 (TCC) 26 Mar 2002 PatC Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â C-Tech (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o14202 27 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'C-Tech': Application No 688545 OPP 70094; OPP 70094 27 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Jones Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: C-TECH 688545 27 Mar 2002 TMR Mr R A Jones Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Reality (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o13402 28 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Barca': Application No 2144430A OPP 48546; OPP 48546 28 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Foley Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: REALITY 109113213, 1414581 28 Mar 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Mark: BARCA 2144430A 28 Mar 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Reality': Application No 1414581 109113213 REV 11227; REV 11226 28 Mar 2002 TMR Mr Foley Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â Barca (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o13702 28 Mar 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Bean'S (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o15102 2 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mr J F Pilat Jr - O/139/02 2 Apr 2002 PO Mr M Wright Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Mark: FLAMINAIRE 2192656 2 Apr 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: MR BEAN'S 2187505 2 Apr 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â James F Pilat Jr (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o13902 2 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Bean's': Application No 2187505 OPP 50740; OPP 50740 2 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Flaminaire (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o13802 2 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â J F Pilat Jr - Wo99/47965 O/139/02; O/139/02 2 Apr 2002 PO Mr M Wright Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â 'Flaminaire': Application No 2192656 OPP 50847 2 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 2070715 3 Apr 2002 TMR Mr A James Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: TITANIC 2017821 3 Apr 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Titanic (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o15702 3 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o15402 3 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Device Only Mark': Application No 2070715 OPP 49694; OPP 49694 3 Apr 2002 TMR Mr James Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Titanic': Application No 2017821 INV 10743; INV 10743 3 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Mark: NOMAD 2187914 4 Apr 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Claxxan': Application No 585021 INV 16021; INV 16021 4 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Smit Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â 'Nomad': Application No 2187914 OPP 50101; OPP 50101 4 Apr 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Hereford Bull': Application No 2198918 OPP 50591 4 Apr 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: CLAXXAN 585021 4 Apr 2002 TMR Mr E S Smith Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Radiuscrown Limited -v- Ash & Lacey Building Products Limited O/144/02 4 Apr 2002 PO Mr P Hayward Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Claxxan (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o15202 4 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: HEREFORD BULL 2198918 4 Apr 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Eastman Kodak Company -v- American Photo Booths, Inc - Gb2314719 O/145/02; O/145/02 4 Apr 2002 PO Mr D Barford Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Â Radiuscrown Limited -v- Ash & Lacey Building Products Limited; PO 4-Apr-2002 - O/144/02; GB2240559 Â Â Radiuscrown Limited -v- Ash Lacey Building Products Limited (Patent); IPO 4-Apr-2002 - [2002] UKIntelP o14402; O/144/02; GB2240559 Â Nomad (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o15302 4 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Hereford Bull (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o15502 4 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Eastman Kodak Company -v- American Photo Booths, Inc (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o14502 4 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Eastman Kodak Company -v- American Photo Booths, Inc - O/145/02 4 Apr 2002 PO Mr D Barford Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Mark: PHARMAGENIX 2173107 5 Apr 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Oceanwave': Application No 2219405 OPP 51099; OPP 51099 5 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Ozark': Application No 2170828A INV 11779; INV 11779 5 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Foley Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â 'Pharmagenix': Application No 2173107 OPP 49884; OPP 49884 5 Apr 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: TOMMY GIRL 2112864 5 Apr 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: OZARK 2170828A 5 Apr 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Mark: OCEANWAVE 2219405 5 Apr 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Tommy Girl': Application No 2112864 OPP 46714; OPP 46714 5 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Pharmagenix (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o16002 5 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Ozark (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o14902 5 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Oceanwave (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o14702 5 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Tommy Girl (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o15802 5 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: E CAR 2209306 8 Apr 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â The Money Shop (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o16402 8 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Tottenham (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o15002 8 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: TOTTENHAM 2130740 8 Apr 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Tottenham': Application No 2130740 OPP 47905; OPP 47905 8 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: FIRST PLACE 1336102 8 Apr 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â First Place (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o16102 8 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'the Money Shop': Application No 2167049 OPP 50790; OPP 50790 8 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'First Place': Application No 1336102 REV 11751; REV 11751 8 Apr 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â 'E Car': Application No 2209306 OPP 50742; OPP 50742 8 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: THE MONEY SHOP 2167049 8 Apr 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â E Car (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o16202 8 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Vintage Hallmark of St Jamess's (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o15602 9 Apr 2002 IPO Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property Section 3(6) - Opposition succeeded Section 5(2)(b) - Opposition succeeded against the applicants Class 33 application. Proprietorship: There must be a proprietor in existence at the date of application. The opponents owned registrations for the marks HALLMARK and ISLAY HALLMARK in Class 33 in respect of the same and similar goods to those included within the applicants Class 33 application. They also claimed that they could find no trace of the applicant company Vintage Hallmark. Thus as the applicants did not appear to have any legal status the opponents claimed that the application had been filed in bad faith (Section 3(6)) of the Act. The applicants responded to the allegation of bad faith by stating that the application had mistakenly been filed in a trading name and that it should have been filed in the name of Vintage Hallmark of St James Plc. They stated that there had been no change of ownership and filed a Form TM 21 requesting the Registrar to alter the application and other appropriate records. The Hearing Officer noted from the copy documentation provided by the opponents that Vintage Hallmark of St James Plc had been incorporated on 1 September 2000 which was well after the application date of 24 February 2000. In relation to the Section 3(6) ground the Hearing Officer concluded that as the PLC company had not been incorporated until 1 September 2000 there could not have been a trading name for a company which did not exist at the time of filing of the application. If there was no applicant then there could be no intention to use at the date of application as required by Section 32(3). The opposition thus succeeded under Section 3(6) in respect of the whole of the application. In relation to the Section 5(2)(b) ground the Hearing Officer noted that identical and similar goods were at issue and went on to compare the respective marks HALLMARK and ISLAY HALLMARK with VINTAGE HALLMARK OF ST JAMES'S. In making the comparison the Hearing Officer accepted that the terms ISLAY and ST JAMES'S were merely geographical indicators and that VINTAGE is a very descriptive and non-distinctive word in relation to whisky products and the like. Thus the distinctive and dominant element in each mark was the word HALLMARK and the Hearing Officer concluded that the respective trade marks were so similar that confusion was likely. Opposition thus succeeded on this ground against the applicants Class 33 application. Trade Marks Act 1994 5(2)(b) 3(6) [ Bailii ] Â 'Device Only Mark': Application No 701260 9 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Thorley QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - [ PO ] Â 'Vintage Hallmark of St James': Application No 2223226 OPP 51497; OPP 51497 9 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Appointed Person) [2002] UKIntelP o16502 9 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 701260 9 Apr 2002 TMR Mr S Thorley QC Intellectual Property IPO Appointed Person. [ IPO ] Â Mark: VINTAGE HALLMARK OF ST. JAMESSâ€™S 2223226 9 Apr 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Meadway Estates -v- Michael Wright & Co [2002] DRS 262 10 Apr 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: PRACTICK 2203013 10 Apr 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Practick (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o15902 10 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Practick': Application No 2203013 OPP 51045; OPP 51045 10 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Prudential Assurance Company Ltd -v- Prudential Insurance Company of America [2002] EWHC 534 (Ch); [2002] IP&T 781 11 Apr 2002 ChD Justice Laddie Intellectual Property The claimant sought to restrain the defendant from use of certain names when trading in the UK. The defendants challenged the jurisdiction of the court. The judge rejected the UK claimant's submission, that by applying to strike out the claims on substantive grounds, Prudential (USA) had submitted to the jurisdiction. The strike out application was on three grounds: (i) that there was no arguable case for any legally binding contract between the parties; (ii) that the English court either had no, or should decline, jurisdiction to judge infringement of the mark 'PRUMERICA', and (iii) that for the mark 'PRUDENTIAL-BACHE', there had been no breach of the contract between the parties. Held: The court although "not without considerable misgivings" - that the claim in contract "was sufficiently arguable to justify service out of the jurisdiction", but would not decide the contract issue summarily. It would be unwise to embark on a "mini-trial". Prudential (USA) accepted that unauthorised use of the mark "PRUDENTIAL-BACHE" might infringe the claimant's rights as registered marks' proprietor, but argued that its use the "PRUDENTIAL-BACHE" mark in investment management services in material on a web site "www.prudential-bache.com" was by the claimant's consent. The court held that the varied nature of the defendant's business was such that separating out activities to which consent was given or not, was imprecise and could not be decided then. "the precise scope of the mutual permissions given by each to the other is difficult to discern as is the question whether the activities advertised in the P-US web site fall within any relevant permission from P-UK". That was not an issue which could be resolved in summary proceedings. 1 Citers Â Mark: ZEE PREMIERE 2198199 12 Apr 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Britannia Zinc Ltd -v- Southern Electric Contracting Ltd and Another [2002] EWHC 606 (TCC) 12 Apr 2002 PatC Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Zee Premiere': Application No 2198199 OPP 50368; OPP 50368 12 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Interflora (FTDAA) British Unit Ltd -v- Softdesign Services Ltd [2002] DRS 239 12 Apr 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Woolard, Re A Patent Application [2002] EWHC 535 (Patents); [2002] RPC 39; GB 9711337.7 12 Apr 2002 PatC Laddie J Intellectual Property The question was what was meant by 'application' in section 2(3): the request, or the document. It was crucial, because if it meant the document it would have counted as prior art, and would have been novelty-destroying; but if it meant the request, it would not have done because the request had been withdrawn and so it no longer existed. The hearing officer (BL O/513/01), following an earlier decision of the Patent Office (Zbinden's Application BL O/260/01), held it meant the document, because of "the presumption that when a term is used in different places in a statute it has the same meaning". Held. The word referred to the request Patents Act 1977 2(3) 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Zee Premiere (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o16302 12 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 2206281 15 Apr 2002 TMR Professor Ruth Annand Intellectual Property IPO Appointed Person. [ IPO ] Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Appointed Person) [2002] UKIntelP o19002 15 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Device Only Mark': Application No 2206281 15 Apr 2002 TMR Professor Annand Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - [ PO ] Â Mark: CO-OPERATIVE 2220640A 16 Apr 2002 TMR Mr C Hamilton Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Co-Operative (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o16802 16 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Fastrak': Application No 2199292 OPP 50931; OPP 50931 16 Apr 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Bubbles (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o19802 16 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Asahi Medical Co Ltd -v- Macopharma (UK) Ltd Macopharma S A [2002] EWCA Civ 466 16 Apr 2002 CA Intellectual Property 1 Cites [ Bailii ] Â Fastrak (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o16602 16 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: FASTRAK 2199292 16 Apr 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: BUBBLES 2198259 16 Apr 2002 TMR Mr S Thorley QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Bubbles': Application No 2198259 OPP 50430/50481 16 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Thorley QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Appointed Person) [2002] UKIntelP o20102 17 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Device Only Mark': Application No 2158336 N/A 17 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Thorley QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - [ PO ] Â Vitalat (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o16702 17 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Vitalat': Application No 684514 M OPP 70267; M OPP 70267 17 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: VITALAT 684514 17 Apr 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 2158336 17 Apr 2002 TMR Mr S Thorley QC Intellectual Property IPO Appointed Person. [ IPO ] Â Mark: LAWGYM 2256868 18 Apr 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Lawgym': Application No 2256868 OPP 52551; OPP 52551 18 Apr 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Lawgym (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o16902 18 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Cd Card': Application No 1521388 INV 10921 19 Apr 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Nugrain (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o17002 19 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Cd Card (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o17302 19 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: CD CARD 1521388 19 Apr 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Mark: NUGRAIN 2183855 19 Apr 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: IMMUNOVEX 2232168 19 Apr 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Cd Card': Application No 1521388 INV 12174 19 Apr 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Mark: CD CARD 1521388 19 Apr 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â 'Nugrain': Application No 2183855 OPP 50409; OPP 50409 19 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Immunovex (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o17102 19 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Cd Card (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o17202 19 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Immunovex': Application No 2232168 OPP 51528; OPP 51528 19 Apr 2002 TMR Dr Trott Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Eskandar': Application No 2209438 50711; 50711 22 Apr 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Eskandar (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o17402 22 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: ESKANDAR 2209438 22 Apr 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: LOADED 2042246A 22 Apr 2002 TMR Professor Ruth Annand Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Loaded': Application No 2042246A OPP 48931; OPP 48931 22 Apr 2002 TMR Professor Annand Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Loaded (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o19102 22 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Blarney (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o17502 23 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Delias': Application No 2144536 2144538 OPP 48567,OPP 48568; OPP 48567, OPP 48568 23 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Thorley QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Boehringer Ingelheim KG and Others -v- Swingward Ltd and Another Times, 23 May 2002; C-143/00; [2002] EUECJ C-143/00; [2002] ECR I-3759 23 Apr 2002 ECJ G. C. Rodríguez Iglesias, President and Judges P. Jann, C. Gulmann, D. A. O. Edward, M. Wathelet, R. Schintgen, V. Skouris, J. N. Cunha Rodrigues and C. W. A. Timmermans Advocate-General F. G. Jacobs European, Intellectual Property The applicant sought to restrict the right of parallel importers of its goods to repackage the goods, and re-supply them in packaging on which their trade mark had been re-applied. Held: The prohibition of quantitative restrictions on imports does not preclude restrictions justified on the grounds of the protection of industrial and commercial property. Such restrictions must not allow arbitrary discrimination or be a disguised restriction on trade between member states. The mark owners were allowed to prevent the repackaging so long as it did not operate to prevent trade. First Council Directive 89/104/EEC of December 21, 1988 to approximate the laws of the member states relating to trade marks (OJ 1989 L40, p1) 7(2) 1 Citers [ Europa ] - [ Bailii ] Â Mark: BLARNEY 2024829 23 Apr 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Mark: DELIAS 2144536, 2144538 23 Apr 2002 TMR Mr S Thorley QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Delias (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o20302 23 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Blarney': Application No 2024829 INV 12152; INV 12152 23 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Dell Usa Lp - O/177/02 24 Apr 2002 PO Mr M Wilson Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Dell USA Lp - Gb 0005904 8 O/177/02; O/177/02 24 Apr 2002 PO Mr M Wilson Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Time Up Magazine (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o17602 24 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: TIME UP MAGAZINE 2230904 24 Apr 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Time Up Magazine': Application No 2230904 51441; 51441 24 Apr 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Dell Usa Lp (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o17702 24 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Panduit Corporation -v- Band-It Company Limited [2002] EWCA Civ 465; [2003] FSR 8 25 Apr 2002 CA Lord Justice Aldous, Mance and Latham LJJ Intellectual Property The second step of Windsurfing requires the judge to adopt the mantle of the skilled person. This is particularly important where, as in this case, the attack upon the patent is based upon what was generally known in the art. 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Â Marine Contractors Limited -v- Barnes; IPO 25-Apr-2002 - O/179/02; Gb 0025707 1; [2002] UKIntelP o17902 Â Aktiebolag and Another -v- Irish Ferries Ltd [2002] EWHC 737 (Ch); [2002] RPC 50 25 Apr 2002 Chd Intellectual Property Patents - territoriality. 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Mark: GLUTALYTE 2161785 26 Apr 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Mark: HANCOCK'S PRESIDENT'S RESERVE 2233752 26 Apr 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: EL TORITO 1311813 26 Apr 2002 TMR Mr C Bowen Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Hancock's President's Reserve (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o18002 26 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Glutalyte': Application No 2161785 INV 11593; INV 11593 26 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Active Web Solutions -v- Peter Shaw [2002] DRS 228 26 Apr 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Glutalyte (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o17802 26 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â El Torito (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o18102 26 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Hancock's president's Reserve': Application No 2233752 OPP 51587 26 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'El Torito': Application No 1311813 REV 10171; REV 10171 26 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Bowen Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â Mark: LAZEY BONEZ ZZZZ 2228667 29 Apr 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: MUSIC CLIP 2221625 29 Apr 2002 TMR Mr I Peggie Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Mark: WINFIELD 2190446 29 Apr 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: ALLIMAX 2225044 29 Apr 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Music Clip (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o18602 29 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: CALCIMILK 2167713 29 Apr 2002 TMR Mr David Kitchin QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Winfield': Application No 2190446 OPP 51597 29 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Lazey Bonez Zzzz': Application No 2228667 OPP 51517; OPP 51517 29 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Calcimilk': Application No 2167713 OPP 49112; OPP 49112 29 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Kitchin QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Calcimilk (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o19302 29 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Allimax (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o18202 29 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Lazey Bonez Zzzz (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o18302 29 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Winfield (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o18702 29 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Ebel Sa -v- Sm@Rtnet Ltd [2002] DRS 251 29 Apr 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Allimax': Application No 2225044 OPP 51248; OPP 51248 29 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Rigel (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o18902 30 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Three Six Sixthree': Application No 2209963/2209491 OPP 50783/50784; OPP 50783/50784 30 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Rigel': Application No 2150015 OPP 49657; OPP 49657 30 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Fhs': Application No 1154567 REV 12007; REV 12007 30 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â Mark: JOWATHERM 702821 30 Apr 2002 TMR Mr R A Jones Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Three Six Six Three (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o18502 30 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Jowatherm (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o18402 30 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Jowatherm': Application No 702821 OPP 70144; OPP 70144 30 Apr 2002 TMR Mr Jones Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Fhs (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o18802 30 Apr 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: RIGEL 2150015 30 Apr 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: FHS 1154567 30 Apr 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Mark: THREE SIX SIX THREE 2209491, 2209963 30 Apr 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Tools and Middleware': Application No 2224156 1 May 2002 TMR Mr Hobbs QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - [ PO ] Â Tools and Middleware (Trade Mark: Appointed Person) [2002] UKIntelP o21802 1 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: TOOLS AND MIDDLEWARE 2224156 1 May 2002 TMR Mr Geoffrey Hobbs QC Intellectual Property IPO Appointed Person. [ IPO ] Â Fourneaux De France (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o24002 2 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: FOURNEAUX DE FRANCE 2025255 2 May 2002 TMR Mr Geoffrey Hobbs QC Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â 'Fourneaux De France': Application No 2025255 INV 11542; INV 11542 2 May 2002 TMR Mr Hobbs QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Tenby House Hotel -v- A1 Epos [2002] DRS 298 6 May 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â LE MANS - O/130/04 Opp 90792 6 May 2002 TMR Dr Trott Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Opposition [ PO ] Â A To Zinc (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o24202 7 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'A To Zinc': Application No B1281083 REV 10520; REV 10520 7 May 2002 TMR Mr Thorley QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â Mark: A TO ZINC B1281083 7 May 2002 TMR Mr S Thorley QC Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Wolseley Centers Ltd -v- Chromecoast Ltd [2002] DRS 282 7 May 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Biolime': Application No 2137603 & 2171670 OPP 50018 & 50019; OPP 50018 & 50019 8 May 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Torremar': Application No 2178911 OPP 49512; OPP 49512 8 May 2002 TMR Mr Hobbs QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Seiko UK Ltd -v- Designer Time/Wanderweb [2002] DRS 248 8 May 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Oropram': Application No 719637 OPP 70282; OPP 70282 8 May 2002 TMR Professor Annand Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: OROPRAM 719637 8 May 2002 TMR Professor Ruth Annand Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: TORREMAR 2178911 8 May 2002 TMR Mr Geoffrey Hobbs QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: BIOLIME 2137603, 2171670 8 May 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: BOOKWORLD 2207672 8 May 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Bookworld': Application No 2207672 OPP 50998 8 May 2002 TMR Dr Trott Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Oropram (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o20802 8 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Biolime (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o19502 8 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Bookworld (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o19402 8 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Torremar (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o20702 8 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Benjamin James Godfrey - O/197/02 9 May 2002 PO Mr P E. Redding Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Benjamin James Godfrey (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o19702 9 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Benjamin James Godfrey - Gb 9523766 5 O/197/02 9 May 2002 PO Mr P E. Redding Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Mark: CILENSA 2234379 10 May 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Cilensa (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o19902 10 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: TOP CHOICE 2263691 10 May 2002 TMR Mr I Peggie Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â 'Roll Back': Application No 2189273 OPP 50560; OPP 50560 10 May 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Top Choice (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o20402 10 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Cilensa': Application No 2234379 OPP 51527; OPP 51527 10 May 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: ROLL BACK 2189273 10 May 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Hewlett Packard Gmbh and Another -v- Waters Corporation and Another [2002] EWCA Civ 612 10 May 2002 CA Lord Justice Rix Intellectual Property Patent infringement [ Bailii ] Â Roll Back (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o19602 10 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â LAMBRELLA - O/132/04 Opp 80474 11 May 2002 TMR Mrs Corbett Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Opposition [ PO ] Â LITTLE ME - O/131/04 Rev 81421 Rev 81422 Rev 81423 11 May 2002 TMR Mrs Corbett Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Revocation [ PO ] Â SMELLY UNIVERSE SMELLY WORLD SMELLY PLANETS - O/131/05 Opp 92127 Opp 92251 Opp 9225 11 May 2002 TMR >Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Opposition. [ PO ] Â DOCUCENTRE - O/128/04 Opp 91369 12 May 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Opposition [ PO ] Â POWERFOAM - O/127/04 Inv 16031 12 May 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Roset (Uk) Ltd -v- Roset [2002] DRS 311 13 May 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Choco Circus': Application No 2106150 OPP 48682; OPP 48682 13 May 2002 TMR Mr Bowen Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Choco Circus (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o20002 13 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: CHOCO CIRCUS 2106150 13 May 2002 TMR Mr C Bowen Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â SO?...KISS ME - O/134/04 Opp 90790 13 May 2002 TMR Dr Trott Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Elan': Application No 2215854 OPP 50981; OPP 50981 14 May 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â INGENICO Opp 52664; O/136/04 14 May 2002 TMR Mrs Corbett Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Opposition [ PO ] Â Harry Robinson and Laurence Antony Brooks (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o20602 14 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Elan (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o20502 14 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Climate Master': Application No 2018635 OPP 49931; OPP 49931 14 May 2002 TMR Mr Kitchin QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Harry Robinson and Laurence Antony Brooks - Gb 9820519 8 O/206/02; O/206/02 14 May 2002 PO Mr R C Kennell Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â TOMMY - O/135/04 Opp 91177 14 May 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Opposition [ PO ] Â Michael Holterhoff -v- Ulrich Freiesleben C-2/00; [2002] EUECJ C-2/00; [2002] All ER (EC) 665; [2002] ETMR 79; [2002] FSR 52; [2002] ECR I-4187 14 May 2002 ECJ European, Intellectual Property A trade mark was found to have been used to describe a method of cutting precious stones, rather than to identify their producer. 1 Citers [ Europa ] - [ Europa ] - [ Bailii ] - [ Europa ] Â Climate Master (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o21502 14 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: CLIMATE MASTER 2018635 14 May 2002 TMR Mr David Kitchin QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: ELAN 2215854 14 May 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Harry Robinson And Laurence Antony Brooks - O/206/02 14 May 2002 PO Mr R C Kennell Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Oliver Jevons -v- Minnesota Mining And Manufacturing Company - O/220/02 15 May 2002 PO Mr P Hayward Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â SKAGA - O/134/03 REV 80028 15 May 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Revocation - [ PO ] Â Oliver Jevons -v- Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o22002 15 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Oliver Jevons -v- Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company - Pct/Us99/06438 O/220/02 15 May 2002 PO Mr P Hayward Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Elite Promotions -v- Creative Talent Management [2002] DRS 267 16 May 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Baker Hughes Inc -v- Richard Van Buskirk and Darrin L Willauer (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o20902 17 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Baker Hughes Inc - Gb 0109632 0 O/209/02; O/209/02 17 May 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Red Letter (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o21002 17 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Eastern National (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o21202 17 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Zippo Manufacturing Company -v- Robinson [2002] DRS 341 17 May 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Baker Hughes Inc O/209/02 17 May 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Mark: EASTERN NATIONAL 2056098 17 May 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Mark: RED LETTER 2205212 17 May 2002 TMR Mr O Morris Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Eastern National': Application No 2056098 INV 11363; INV 11363 17 May 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â 'Red Letter': Application No 2205212 OPP 51367 17 May 2002 TMR Mr Morris Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â BRAND STORM - O/138/04 Opp 90323 18 May 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Opposition - [ PO ] Â CLEAN CREAM - O/139/04 Opp 91479 18 May 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Opposition - [ PO ] Â Josef Feliks Dembski, Ian Hubbard And Sandra Diana Dembski O/213/02 20 May 2002 PO Mr B Westerman Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Josef Feliks Dembski, Ian Hubbard And Sandra Diana Dembski (Statement Of Reasons For Decision (O/213/02) - O/224/02 20 May 2002 PO Mr B Westerman Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â 'Presidente': Application No 2170658 OPP 50011; OPP 50011 20 May 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Josef Feliks Dembski, Ian Hubbard Sandra Diana Dembski (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o21302 20 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Josef Feliks Dembski, Ian Hubbard and Sandra Diana Dembski - 9724578 1 O/213/02 20 May 2002 PO Mr B Westerman Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Josef Feliks Dembski, Ian Hubbard and Sandra Diana Dembski (Statement of Reasons For&Nbsp; Decision (O/213/02) - 9724578 1 O/224/02 20 May 2002 PO Mr B Westerman Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â TESTAMENT - O/142/04 Inv 81463 20 May 2002 TMR Mr Attfield Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Invalidity - [ PO ] Â Presidente (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o21102 20 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Reed Executive plc and Reed Solutions plc v- Reed Business Information Ltd, Reed Elsevier (UK) Ltd and totaljobs com Ltd Times, 13 June 2002; Gazette, 18 July 2002; [2003] RPC 12; [2002] EWHC 1015 (Ch) 20 May 2002 ChD Mr Justice Pumfrey Intellectual Property The defendant company used the trade marks of the claimant on their web-site to attract visitors. However the trade marks themselves were not visible when the site was browsed, or when it was listed on the search engine. Held: The use of a trade mark could be an infringement, but the section required the use to be visible to a visitor. There was equally no evidence of loss just because the site was listed on a search engine's results. Since now the trade marks had been removed, any action would be limited now to one of damages, and no injunction was appropriate. Trade Marks Act 1994 10 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Mark: PRESIDENTE 2170658 20 May 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Moog': Application No 2056098 INV 10699; INV 10699 21 May 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Moog (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o21602 21 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â RAVANSA - O/143/04 Opp 16037 21 May 2002 TMR Mr Attfield Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Opposition [ PO ] Â Vedatech Corporation -v- Crystal Decisions (Uk) Limited [2002] EWHC 818 (Ch) 21 May 2002 ChD The Honourable Mr Justice Jacob Intellectual Property, Employment The defendant wanted to amend its software and introduce it to the Japanese market, and worked with the claimants for this purpose. The defendant suggested that a concluded agreement existed, the claimant that only no contract was concluded. There were claims for copyright infringement, for an account of damages, and for enticing employees to breach their contracts. Held: The terms proposed were too vague to constitute a contract. Nevertheless the parties had worked together. Agreements signed on the day that an employee left were not binding because no consideration had been given. The claim for procuring breach of the employees contracts is not made out. The claim for unjust enrichment was based upon profits made but or accounted for. It was intended that the services should be paid for, and they must be. A further assessment will be required to assess how much. 1 Cites [ Bailii ] Â Mark: MOOG 2056098 21 May 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â 'Dyna-Ti': Application No 2179856 OPP 50780; OPP 50780 23 May 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Job World': Application No 2166540 OPP 50713; OPP 50713 23 May 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Job World (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o21702 23 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: JOB WORLD 2166540 23 May 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: DYNA-TI 2179856 23 May 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Dyna-Ti (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o21902 23 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Quinn -v- Decalite Limited & David Pearson O/222/02 24 May 2002 PO Mr P Redding Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Quinn -v- Decalite Limited David Pearson (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o22202 24 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Howard Anthony Quinn -v- Decalite Limited & David Pearson - Gb 9905434 8 and Others O/222/02 24 May 2002 PO Mr P Redding Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â WOODBURY ESTATES - O/148/04 Opp 81517 26 May 2002 TMR Mr Attfield Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Opposition [ PO ] Â NATURAL WHITE - O/149/04 Opp 90855 27 May 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: MISCELLANEOUS ONLY 2209049 27 May 2002 TMR Mr A James Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Mark: POWDERHALE 2226448 27 May 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Powderhale (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o22302 27 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Miscellaneous Only (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o22102 27 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Powderhale': Application No 2226448 OPP 51771; OPP 51771 27 May 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Josef Feliks Dembski, Ian Hubbard and Sandra Diana Dembski (Statement of Reasons for Decision (O/213/02) (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o22402 27 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â DigeoComMx (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o22502 28 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Bessant and others -v- South Cone Incorporated; in re REEF Trade Mark Times, 31 May 2002; [2003] RPC 5; [2002] EWCA Civ 763 28 May 2002 CA Lord Justice Robert Walker, Lord Justice Buxton and Lord Justice Clarke Intellectual Property, Litigation Practice The Reef pop group applied to register "REEF" for Classes 25 and 26 – e.g. T-shirts, badges, etc. South Cone opposed them as registered proprietors of "Reef Brazil" for the footwear which also was included in Class 25. South's reputation was primarily amongst surfers. The Hearing Officer conducted a "multi-factorial" comparison, and rejected the opposition based on the likelihood of confusion. The appellant challenged mixed findings of fact and law. Held: The appeal was allowed. When an appeal court considered setting aside a first instance decision, it must look to the several factors affecting the decision as they appeared in each individual case. The opposition had been rejected by the principal officer, then allowed by the judge. The judge should not have reversed the hearing officer on the section 5(2) issue. The hearing officer had not erred in principle, and nor was he clearly wrong. He had to make a multi-factorial comparison, evaluating similarities to reach conclusions about likelihood of confusion and a notional passing-off. He was experienced, and the Civil Procedure Rules do not diminish the respect shown to a hearing officers. But he did not hear oral evidence, and therefore an appellate court should show a real reluctance, but not the very highest degree to interfere in the absence of a distinct and material error of principle. Trade Marks Act 1994 5(2) 5(4) 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DIGEO.COM.MX 2230395 28 May 2002 TMR Mr A Pike Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Lucent Technologies Inc - O/227/02 29 May 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Lucent Technologies Inc - Gb 0118143 7 O/227/02; O/227/02 29 May 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Lucent Technologies Inc (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o22702 29 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â TEAM LOTUS - O/147/03 REV 80210 REV 80211 29 May 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Revocation - [ PO ] Â MISCELLANEOUS ONLY MARK - O/148/03 OPP 50834 30 May 2002 TMR Mr James Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Opposition - [ PO ] Â Baxi Heating Limited -v- Robinson Willey Limited - GB 2305499 O/228/02; GB 2305499 30 May 2002 PO Mr R Kennell Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Baxi Heating Ltd -v- Robinson Willey Ltd (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o22802 30 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Baxi Heating Limited -v- Robinson Willey Limited - O/228/02 30 May 2002 PO Mr R Kennell Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Takeda Chemical Industries Limited - Spc/Gb/96/030-035 O/229/02; O/229/02 31 May 2002 PO Mr R Walker Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Turkcell Iletisim Hizmetleri As -v- Atas [2002] DRS 286 31 May 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Takeda Chemical Industries Limited (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o22902 31 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: HAVE A BREAK 2015684 31 May 2002 TMR Mr A James Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Have A Break (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o23202 31 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Getmapping Plc -v- Ordnance Survey [2002] EWHC 1089 (Pat) 31 May 2002 PatC Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Have A Break': Application No 2015684 OPP 48341; OPP 48341 31 May 2002 TMR Mr James Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Luk Lamellen and Kupplungsbau Gmbh -v- Automotive Products (Uk) Limited (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o37902 31 May 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Takeda Chemical Industries Limited - O/229/02 31 May 2002 PO Mr R Walker Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Sparco Srl -v- Bennett [2002] DRS 285 2 Jun 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Sunny Cities (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o23002 5 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Sunny Cities': Application No 2257927 INV 80045 5 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Mark: SUNNY CITIES 2257927 5 Jun 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â '2Thbrush': Application No 2259535 OPP 52392; OPP 52392 6 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'K2': Application No 674543 OPP 70156; OPP 70156 6 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Foley Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: K2 674543 6 Jun 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Land Hessen -v- G Ricordi & Co Buhnen- und Musikverlag GmbH C-360/00; [2002] EUECJ C-360/00 6 Jun 2002 ECJ European, Intellectual Property Europa Reference for a preliminary ruling: Bundesgerichtshof - Germany. Term of copyright protection - Principle of non-discrimination on grounds of nationality - Applicability to copyright which arose prior to the entry into force of the EEC Treaty. EEC Treaty [ Europa ] - [ Bailii ] Â Mark: 2thBRUSH 2259535 6 Jun 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 2Thbrush (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o23302 6 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Pims Pumps Ltd -v- Polytek [2002] DRS 928 6 Jun 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Nokia Corporation -v- Mahmood and others [2002] DRS 292 6 Jun 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â K2 (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o23102 6 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Cd Now (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o23402 7 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Adrenaline (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o53302 7 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: CD NOW 2190404 7 Jun 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Adrenaline Rev 12553 Rev 12554 7 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Thorley Qc Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: 1272101 1229890 - Revocation [ PO ] Â Mark: ADRENALINE 1229890, 1272101 7 Jun 2002 TMR Mr S Thorley QC Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â 'Cd Now': Application No 2190404 OPP 50665; OPP 50665 7 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Ebuyer (Uk) Ltd -v- Web Auction Ltd [2002] DRS 347 8 Jun 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Discovery Time': Application No 2211210 OPP 50973; OPP 50973 10 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: LOVELETTERS 804672 10 Jun 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â 'Eiretel': Application No 2236315 OPP 51663; OPP 51663 10 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Daawat': Application No 2032467 INV 9986 10 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Hobbs QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity 1 Cites 1 Citers [ PO ] Â Eiretel (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o23902 10 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DAAWAT 2032467 10 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Geoffrey Hobbs QC Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Loveletters (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o23802 10 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DISCOVERY TIME 2211210 10 Jun 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: EIRETEL 2236315 10 Jun 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Discovery Time (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o23502 10 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Loveletters': Application No 804672 INV 11914; INV 11914 10 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Daawat (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o26502 10 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Roset (Uk) Ltd -v- Worthy Consultants [2002] DRS 310 12 Jun 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Cdcard (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o26902 12 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Cdcard': Application No 1521388 REV/INV 10921; REV/INV 10921 12 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Hobbs QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â Mark: CDCARD 1521388 12 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Geoffrey Hobbs QC Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Mark: ERGONOM 2148455 12 Jun 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Ergonom (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o23602 12 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Uk Living (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o23702 12 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Ergonom': Application No 2148455 OPP 49199; OPP 49199 12 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'UK Living': Application No 2134014 OPP 48658; OPP 48658 12 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: UK LIVING 2134014 12 Jun 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Chef Revival USA Inc -v- Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market T-232/00; [2002] EUECJ T-232/00; T-232/00 13 Jun 2002 ECFI European, Intellectual Property Europa Community trade mark - Opposition proceedings - Failure to produce evidence in the language of the opposition proceedings - Rule 18(2) of Regulation (EC) No 2868/95. Regulation (EC) No 2868/95 18(2) [ Europa ] - [ Bailii ] Â Hbos Plc -v- Hodges [2002] DRS 295 13 Jun 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: GARDENIER 2198058 13 Jun 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Oscar Mario Guagnelli Hidalgo (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o24302 13 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Oscar Mario Guagnelli Hidalgo - Ep0535781 O/243/02; O/243/02 13 Jun 2002 PO Mr M Wright Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Mr Oscar Mario Guagnelli Hidalgo - O/243/02 13 Jun 2002 PO Mr M Wright Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Gardenier (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o24102 13 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Gardenier': Application No 2198058 INV 11860; INV 11860 13 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Intel Corporation -v- Via Technologies Inc and others [2002] EWHC 1159 (Ch) 14 Jun 2002 ChD Mr Justice Lawrence Collins Intellectual Property, Commercial, European The claimant sought damages for patent infringement. The respondent asserted that the refusal to licence the patent amounted to an abuse of its dominant position. Complaint had also been brought in the US. Held: the licence offered by Intel would distort the market. The refusal to licence on other terms prevented other companies even getting a foothold in the market. However the refusal to licence an intellectual property is a right in the owner save when it is an abuse, and even then the defence is only available exceptionally. The defendant had not made out the conditions precedent. Summary judgement for the claimant. EC Treaty 81(1) 82 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â 'Intel-Play': Application No 2028015 OPP 47356; OPP 47356 17 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Foley Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Intel-Play (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o24402 17 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: INTEL-PLAY 2028015 17 Jun 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Allied Carpets Group Plc -v- Whicheloe Macfarlane Partnership [2002] EWHC 1155 (TCC) 17 Jun 2002 PatC Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: COLOURS 2148918 18 Jun 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Europhon': Application No 716225 OPP 70246; OPP 70246 18 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Foley Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Device Only Mark': Application No 2114332 REC/INV 9704; REC/INV 9704 18 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Rectification [ PO ] Â 'Colours': Application No 2148918 OPP 49416; OPP 49416 18 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Foley Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 2114332 18 Jun 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Europhon (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o24502 18 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Colours (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o24702 18 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Koninklijke Philips Electronics NV -v- Remington Consumer Products Ltd Times, 20 June 2002; C-299/99; [2002] ETMR 955; [2002] EUECJ C-299/99; [2003] Ch 159; [2003] RPC 2 18 Jun 2002 ECJ G. C. Rodríguez Iglesias, P. Jann, F. Macken, N. Colneric, S. von Bahr, C. Gulmann, D. A. O. Edward, A. La Pergola, J.-P. Puissochet, J. N. Cunha Rodrigues etc European, Intellectual Property The claimant developed a three headed rotary razor for men. They obtained registration of the arrangement as a trade mark. They sued the defendant for infringement, and the defendant countered challenging the validity of the registration, saying the design was functional. Held: A sign consisting exclusively of a product's shape was unregistrable, if it was established that the essential functional features of that shape were attributable only to the technical result. Additional embellishments did not make it registerable, and the existence of alternate ways of achieving the same technical result did not allow registration. The court accepted that art.3(1)(a) imports both limbs of art.2. Distinctiveness is, therefore, an issue under both art.3(1)(a) and art.3(1)(b). Only a single question is posed in relation to distinctiveness of origin, which is whether the sign is capable of distinguishing the goods of one undertaking from those of another in the mind of the consumer, and a positive conclusion (albeit at that level of identification) is required. Council Directive 89/104/EEC of December 21, 1988 to approximate the laws of the member states relating to trade marks 2 3(1)(a) 3(1)(b) 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Europa ] - [ Bailii ] Â Mark: EUROPHON 716225 18 Jun 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Rectification) [2002] UKIntelP o24602 18 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Chf1 Channel F1': Application No 2180339 OPP 50334; OPP 50334 19 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â James Anthony Barry (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o24902 19 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Cardio Theater Holdings Inc -v- Atmospheric Ltd [2002] DRS 376 19 Jun 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: CHF1 CHANNEL F1 2180339 19 Jun 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â James Anthony Barry - Gb 2249125 O/249/02; O/249/02 19 Jun 2002 PO Mr M Wright Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â David John Anderson (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o29702 19 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Met Office -v- Fell of Buydomain.Co.UK [2002] DRS 297 19 Jun 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â David John Anderson - O/297/02 19 Jun 2002 PO Mr D Jerreat Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Mr James Anthony Barry - O/249/02 19 Jun 2002 PO Mr M Wright Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Synthon Bv -v- Smithkline Beecham Plc [2002] EWHC 1172 (Patents) 19 Jun 2002 PatC The Honourable Mr Justice Jacob Intellectual Property 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ Bailii ] Â Chf1 Channel F1 (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o24802 19 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â David John Anderson - Gb 0111205 1 O/297/02; O/297/02 19 Jun 2002 PO Mr D Jerreat Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â 'Unicorn': Application No 2069447 OPP 46750; OPP 46750 20 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Q-Bar (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o25102 20 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: UNICORN 2069447 20 Jun 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: Q-BAR 2201211 20 Jun 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Q-Bar': Application No 2201211 OPP 50888; OPP 50888 20 Jun 2002 TMR Dr Trott Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Unicorn (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o25002 20 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Rug Company -v- Wonderland Rug Company [2002] DRS 370 24 Jun 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Phillip Walter Strong -v- Stafford Rubber Company Limited - O/255/02 25 Jun 2002 PO Mr D Barford Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Phillip Walter Strong -v- Stafford Rubber Company Limited (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o25502 25 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: HAVE A BREAK 2015684 25 Jun 2002 TMR Mr A James Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Have A Break': Application No 2015684 OPP 48305; OPP 48305 25 Jun 2002 TMR Mr James Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Have A Break (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o25402 25 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Phillip Walter Strong -v- Stafford Rubber Company Limited - Gb 9911627 9 O/255/02 25 Jun 2002 PO Mr D Barford Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Animale (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o25602 26 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Aztec (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o25802 26 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Animale': Application No 2200309 OPP 50716; OPP 50716 26 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Foley Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: e-server 2243122 26 Jun 2002 TMR Mr J Hamilton-Jones Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Mark: AZTEC 1546754 26 Jun 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Mark: G2M 2229686 26 Jun 2002 TMR Mr E S Smith Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'G2M': Application No 2229686 OPP 51828; OPP 51828 26 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Smith Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Aztec': Application No 1546754 REV 11772; REV 11772 26 Jun 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â E-Server (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o25902 26 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â G2M (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o25702 26 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Â Mark: ANIMALE; TMR 26-Jun-2002 - 2200309 Â Â Owen Mumford Limited -v- Novo Nordisk A/S (Patent); IPO 27-Jun-2002 - O/261/02; [2002] UKIntelP o26102; EP0549694 Â 2 (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o26002 27 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: 2 2231526A 27 Jun 2002 TMR Miss J Folwell Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Nokia Corporation -v- Liquidsms Ltd [2002] DRS 328 27 Jun 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â K-Tel (Uk) Ltd -v- Sturgeon [2002] DRS 386 27 Jun 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Harry Robinson and Laurence Antony Brooks (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o26202 28 Jun 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Harry Robinson and Laurence Antony Brooks - Gb 9820519 8 O/262/02; O/262/02 28 Jun 2002 PO Mr R Kennell Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Harry Robinson And Laurence Antony Brooks - O/262/02 28 Jun 2002 PO Mr R Kennell Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Regina -v- Zaman Times, 22 July 2002; Gazette, 12 September 2002 1 Jul 2002 CACD Lord Justice Longmore, Mr Justice Wright and Judge Goddard, QC Intellectual Property, Crime The defendant had been convicted of offences under the Act, and challenged a direction form the judge that the phrases 'with a view to' and 'with intent to' meant different things. Held: The judge's direction was correct. 'With a view to' in this context, meant that the offender contemplated some result, without necessarily wanting or intending it, which might realistically occur. Trade Marks Act 1994 92(1) Â Bonnier Media Limited -v- Greg Lloyd Smith and Kestrel Trading Corporation Times, 10 July 2002 1 Jul 2002 SCS Lord Drummond Young Scotland, Media, Intellectual Property, Jurisdiction The defenders registered internet domain names. The claimants alleged an intended infringement of their trade marks, saying the defenders had a history of opening sites intended to deceive. The defenders who were resident in Greece said that the 1982 Act could not be used for a threatened delict, but only for a completed one. Held: The procedure was available for a threatened delict. The difference between one threatened and one complete need not be substantial. Jurisdiction over the defendant was available where it could be seen that the web-site would be directed at the pursuers business. That was the case here. Trade Marks Act 1994 - Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982 Sch 1 1 Cites [ ScotC ] Â Co-Operative Insurance Society Ltd -v- Henry Boot Scotland Ltd and others [2002] EWHC 1270 (TCC) 1 Jul 2002 PatC Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â J T Mackley & Company Ltd -v- Gosport Marina Ltd [2002] EWHC 1315 (TCC) 3 Jul 2002 PatC Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Blooming Tree Productions, Inc -v- Virulent.Net, Dominic Silk Aka Ed Bailey [2002] DRS 387 3 Jul 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Easybed (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o26302 4 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Easybed': Application No 2237781 OPP 52132; OPP 52132 4 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Intel Corporation -v- Via Technologies Inc - Ep0804763 O/268/02; O/268/02 4 Jul 2002 PO Mr P Hayward Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Faeries (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o26402 4 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Faeries': Application No 2224081 OPP 52003 4 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: COMPUTER BOOKSHOPS 2237307B 4 Jul 2002 TMR Mr A James Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Intel Corporation Via Technologies Incorporated (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o26802 4 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: FAERIES 2224081 4 Jul 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: EASYBED 2237781 4 Jul 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Athermal (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o26702 4 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: ATHERMAL 2244225 4 Jul 2002 TMR Mr I Peggie Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Camelot Group Plc -v- Ross [2002] DRS 368 4 Jul 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Computer Bookshops (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o26602 4 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Intel Corporation -v- Via Technologies Inc - O/268/02 4 Jul 2002 PO Mr P Hayward Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Experience Hendrix Llc -v- PPX Enterprises Inc and Chaplin [2002] EWHC 1353 (QB) 5 Jul 2002 QBD The Honourable Mr Justice Buckley Intellectual Property 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â 'Miragan': Application No 2177090 OPP 50441; OPP 50441 5 Jul 2002 TMR Professor Annand Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Miragan (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o29302 5 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: MIRAGAN 2177090 5 Jul 2002 TMR Professor Ruth Annand Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Molewood Garage (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o27002 8 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: MOLEWOOD GARAGE 2213298 8 Jul 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â 'Molewood Garage': Application No 2213298 INV 12408; INV 12408 8 Jul 2002 TMR Dr Trott Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Mark: FLASHPOINT 1158426 9 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Geoffrey Hobbs QC Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Flashpoint (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o53002 9 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Flashpoint Rev 10043 9 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Hobbs Qc Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: 1158426 - Revocation [ PO ] Â Bluparc (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o27102 10 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â H Lundbeck A/S O/275/02 10 Jul 2002 PO Mr R Walker Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Mark: BLUPARC 2261651 10 Jul 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Hanna-Barbera Productions Inc -v- Hay [2002] DRS 389 10 Jul 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Bluparc': Application No 2261651 OPP 52851; OPP 52851 10 Jul 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Halifax Plc and others -v- Halifax Repossessions Ltd and others [2002] EWCA Civ 1060 10 Jul 2002 CA Intellectual Property 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Consorzio Del Prosciutto Di Parma -v- Vital Domains Ltd [2002] DRS 359 10 Jul 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â H Lundbeck A/S (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o27502 10 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â H Lundbeck A/S Spc/Gb/98/010; O/275/02 10 Jul 2002 PO Mr R Walker Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Rowland Brothers -v- Michael Robertson - Gb2335617 O/273/02 11 Jul 2002 PO Mr D Barford Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Mark: COMPASSMARK 2234625 11 Jul 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Rowland Brothers -v- Michael Robertson (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o27302 11 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â SABAF SpA -v- MFI Furniture Centres Ltd and Another Times, 24 July 2002; [2003] RPC 264; [2002] EWCA Civ 976 11 Jul 2002 CA Lord Justice Peter Gibson, Lord Justice Jonathan Parker and Lord Justice Longmore Intellectual Property, Torts - Other The appellant challenged dismissal of its claim for patent infringement. The judge had held that the design was obvious, involving essentially only the collocation of two known features. Held: Collocation was no more than a species of obviousness, and the test remained to be performed as to whether the bringing together of the two ideas, and a case involving collocation should be treated in the same way as the Windsurfing case, the question is whether it will be obvious to the skilled man, using his common general knowledge, to combine those concepts. The test for a joint tortfeasor was that each defendant should commit a tort himself. A mere supplier of goods without input or control as to what was done with them was not liable. It was artificial to regard as an importer of goods one who had no legal or beneficial interest in them. The patent was valid but Meneghetti had not imported the products. Patents Act 1977 3 60 1 Cites 1 Citers Â Wavecrest Communications Plc -v- Wavecrest Computer Solutions Ltd [2002] DRS 333 11 Jul 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Rowland Brothers -v- Michael Robertson - O/273/02 11 Jul 2002 PO Mr D Barford Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Compassmark (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o27202 11 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Compassmark': Application No 2234625 OPP 52113; OPP 52113 11 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: TEMPTATION 1216385 12 Jul 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Temptation (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o27402 12 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Temptation': Application No 1216385 REV 11928; REV 11928 12 Jul 2002 TMR Dr Trott Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â Basf Ag -v- Smithkline Beecham Plc [2002] EWHC 1373 (Patents) 12 Jul 2002 PatC Intellectual property [ Bailii ] Â Bacardi & Company Ltd -v- Strathmade Ltd [2002] DRS 400 12 Jul 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Royal Marines -v- O'Neil [2002] DRS 401 15 Jul 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Premier Finance Services Ltd -v- Premier Exchange Finance Ltd (In Liquidation) [2002] DRS 336 15 Jul 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Blayney (T/A Aardvark Jewelry) -v- Clogau St David's Gold Mines Ltd and others [2002] EWCA Civ 1007; [2003] FSR 19 16 Jul 2002 CA The Vice-Chancellor, Rix LJ, Jonathan Parker LJ Intellectual Property, Damages 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â 'Seahopper': Application No 2209628 OPP 51783; Annex OPP 51783 17 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] - [ PO ] Â British Telecommunications Plc -v- Richard Wyatt, Robert Michael Percival And Raman Kashyap - O/278/02 17 Jul 2002 PO Mr D Barford Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Oliver Jevons -v- Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company - Pct/Us99/06438 O/277/02 17 Jul 2002 PO Mr P Hayward Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â British Telecommunications Plc -v- Richard Wyatt, Robert Michael Percival and Raman Kashyap (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o27802 17 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Huxley Associates Ltd -v- Davies [2002] DRS 407 17 Jul 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: SEAHOPPER 2209628 17 Jul 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: PURELL 749994 17 Jul 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Oliver Jevons -v- Minnesota Mining And Manufacturing Company - O/277/02 17 Jul 2002 PO Mr P Hayward Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Oliver Jevons -v- Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o27702 17 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â British Telecommunications Plc -v- Richard Wyatt, Robert Michael Percival and Raman Kashyap - Us09/805377 Ca2339345 O/278/02 17 Jul 2002 PO Mr D Barford Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â 'Purell': Application No 749994 OPP 70637; OPP 70637 17 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â The Sporting Exchange Ltd - O/280/02 17 Jul 2002 PO Mr P Marchant Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Seahopper (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o27902 17 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Purell (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o27602 17 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â The Sporting Exchange Ltd (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o28002 17 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â the Sporting Exchange Ltd - Gb 0008530 8 O/280/02; O/280/02 17 Jul 2002 PO Mr P Marchant Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Dyson Limited (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o28102 18 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Dyson Limited - Gb2317817 O/281/02; O/281/02 18 Jul 2002 PO Mr R C Kennell Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Dyson Limited - O/281/02 18 Jul 2002 PO Mr R C Kennell Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Mark: KINDER EUKAL 1578831 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: KINDER EUKAL 1578833 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: THE MARK CONSISITS OF A BROWN GREEN COLOUR..... 2121479 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr A Pike Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Seiko UK Ltd -v- Designer Time/Wanderweb [2002] DRS 248_Appeal 19 Jul 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: KINDER DAYLICIOUS 1326031 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Mark: ROCKWALK 2213545 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Rectification. [ IPO ] Â Mark: KINDER MILK SLICE 1357980 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Mark: FORM ONLY MARK 2131647 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: EUKAL FUR KINDER 2137574 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â The Mark Consisits of A Brown Green Colour (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o28202 19 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: KINDER 1440569, 1489981, 1541165, 154 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Kinder Milk Slice (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o28702 19 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: KINDER MILK BREAD 1245781 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â 'Kinder Eukal': Application No 1578831 OPP 47935; OPP 47935 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Walkerland (Trade Mark: Rectification) REC 11925; 2198572; [2002] UKIntelP o28302 19 Jul 2002 IPO Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Rectification 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â 'Kinder Milk Slice': Application No 1357980 REV 9546; REV 9546 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â 'Kinder Milk Bread': Application No 1245781 9548; 9548 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â 'Kinder Daylicious': Application No 1326031 REV 9549; REV 9549 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â KINDER - O/291/02 INV 9547 9550 9551 9552 95 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Invalidity - [ PO ] Â Rockwalk (Trade Mark: Rectification) [2002] UKIntelP o28402 19 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Kinder Eukal': Application No 1578833 OPP 47934; OPP 47934 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Kinder': Application No 1489981 1541166 1569226 1541165 1440569 INV 9547 9550 9551 9552 9553; INV 9547 9550 9551 9552 9553 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â 'Eukal Fur Kinder': Application No 2137574 OPP 48318; OPP 48318 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Eukal Fur Kinder (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o28602 19 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Form Only Mark': Application No 2131647 OPP 51972; OPP 51972 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Rockwalk': Application No 2213545 REC 11925; REC 11925 19 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Rectification [ PO ] Â Form Only Mark (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o28502 19 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Kinder (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o29102 19 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Kinder Daylicious (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o28902 19 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Kinder Eukal (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o29002 19 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Kinder Eukal (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o29202 19 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Kinder Milk Bread (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o28802 19 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Capitol Records Inc -v- Cpic Net [2002] DRS 329 22 Jul 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: ZABTRAM 2238945 23 Jul 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Zabtram (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o29402 23 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 2118079 23 Jul 2002 TMR Mr A James Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o29502 23 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Nichols Plc -v- Trade Mark Application No 2,241,892 [2002] EWHC 1424 (Ch) 23 Jul 2002 ChD The Hon Mr Justice Jacob Intellectual Property 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Harrods Ltd -v- Wilson [2002] DRS 426 23 Jul 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Came Automation Ltd -v- Cameo Electric Gates Ltd [2002] DRS B2 23 Jul 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Zabtram': Application No 2238945 OPP 51787; OPP 51787 23 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â University of Cambridge -v- Qxyz Ltd; (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o31102 23 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â S C Johnson & Son Inc -v- Sara Lee Household & Body Care Uk Ltd O/303/02 24 Jul 2002 PO Mr D Barford Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â S C Johnson & Son Inc -v- Sara Lee Household & Body Care UK Ltd - Gb2338495 O/303/02 24 Jul 2002 PO Mr D Barford Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Sara Lee Household Body Care Uk Ltd -v- Sc Johnson Son Inc (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o30302 24 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â TNT UK Ltd -v- Sibley [2002] DRS 421 24 Jul 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Abbott Laboratories - O/302/02 25 Jul 2002 PO Mr R Walker Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Abbott Laboratories (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o30202 25 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Edward Evans Barker -v- Oystertec Plc (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o29802 25 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 1559532, 1559533 25 Jul 2002 TMR Mr M Layton Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Edward Evans Barker -v- Oystertec Plc O/298/02 25 Jul 2002 PO Mr R Kennell Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Edward Evans Barker -v- Oystertec Plc - Gb2314392 O/298/02 25 Jul 2002 PO Mr R Kennell Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Abbott Laboratories - Spc/Gb/97/080 O/302/02; O/302/02 25 Jul 2002 PO Mr R Walker Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o29602 25 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 722571 26 Jul 2002 TMR Mr R A Jones Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â 'Partybus': Application No 2234201 OPP 51562; OPP 51562 26 Jul 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o30102 26 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o30002 26 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Partybus (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o29902 26 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Seb S A -v- De'longhi Spa, De'longhi Limited [2002] EWHC 1556 (Ch) 26 Jul 2002 ChD The Honourable Mr Justice Pumfrey Intellectual Property The judge dismissed an action for patent infringement on the basis that the patent in suit was invalid for obviousness, though he held that, had the Patent been valid, it would have been infringed by all of the alleged infringements. 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 719093 26 Jul 2002 TMR Mr R A Jones Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Mark: PARTYBUS 2234201 26 Jul 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Internet Ltd -v- Ssl [2002] DRS 442 29 Jul 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Club Nation': Application No 2149426 + others OPP 48408 + Others 29 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Bowen Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Club Nation (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o30402 29 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Â Mark: CLUB NATION; TMR 29-Jul-2002 - 2149426 Â 'Benetton Formula 1 Racing Team': Application No 2115577A INV 80033; INV 80033 30 Jul 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Benetton Formula 1 Racing Team (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o30502 30 Jul 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: BENETTON FORMULA 1 RACING TEAM 2115577A 30 Jul 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Â Levi Strauss & Co and Another -v- Tesco Stores Ltd and others; ChD 31-Jul-2002 - [2000] EWHC 1556 (Ch); [2002] ETMR 95 Â Â Levi Strauss & Co and Another -v- Tesco Stores Ltd and Others; ChD 31-Jul-2002 - [2002] 3 CMLR 11; [2002] ETMR 95; [2002] Eu LR 610; [2003] RPC 18; [2002] EWHC 1625 (Ch) Â Pring & St Hill Ltd -v- C J Hafner (T/A Southern Erectors) [2002] EWHC 1775 (TCC) 31 Jul 2002 PatC Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Julious L Willett -v- Biotechnolgy Research & Development Corporation - O/308/02 31 Jul 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Â 'Synergie': Application No 2068227; TMR 31-Jul-2002 - OPP 49371 Â Mark: SYNERGIE 2068227 31 Jul 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Â L Woolley Jewellers Ltd -v- A & A Jewellery Ltd and Another; CA 31-Jul-2002 - Times, 04 October 2002 Â Â Kirin Amgen Inc and others -v- Hoechst Marion Roussel Ltd and others; CA 31-Jul-2002 - [2002] EWCA Civ 1096; [2002] RPC 31 Â Â Synergie (Trade Mark: Opposition); IPO 31-Jul-2002 - [2002] UKIntelP o30602 Â Â Willett -v- Biotechnology Research Development Corporation (Patent); IPO 31-Jul-2002 - [2002] UKIntelP o30802; GB 2356865 Â Â Willett -v- Biotechnolgy Research & Development Corporation; PO 31-Jul-2002 - O/308/02; GB2356865 Â Oliver Bond (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o30702 1 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Oliver Bond': Application No 2199497 INV 12377 1 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Smith Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â 'Aida': Application No 701234 OPP 70268 1 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Epx European Power Exchange': Application No 729381 OPP 70489 1 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: AIDA 701234 1 Aug 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: EPX EUROPEAN POWER EXCHANGE 729381 1 Aug 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: OLIVER BOND 2199497 1 Aug 2002 TMR Mr E S Smith Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Epx European Power Exchange (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o31002 1 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Aida (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o30902 1 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â China White (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o31602 2 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Nalli (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o31402 2 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Flipdisk (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o31302 2 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Walkabout (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o31202 2 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Walkabout': Application No 1450477 REV 11558 2 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â Ty-Bo (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o31502 2 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Flipdisk': Application No 2150671 OPP 49862 2 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Nalli': Application No 1518192 REV 10933 2 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Revocation [ PO ] Â 'Ty-Bo': Application No 2205160 OPP 50542 2 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: CHINA WHITE 2192332 2 Aug 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: TY-BO 2205160 2 Aug 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: WALKABOUT 1450477 2 Aug 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â 'China White': Application No 2192332 OPP 50250 2 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: FLIPDISK 2150671 2 Aug 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: NALLI 1518192 2 Aug 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Edward Evans Barker -v- Oystertec Plc O/317/02 5 Aug 2002 PO Mr R Kennell Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Edward Evans Barker -v- Oystertec Plc (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o31702 5 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Disney Enterprises Inc -v- South (T/A Named By South) [2002] DRS 395 5 Aug 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Edward Evans Barker -v- Oystertec Plc O/317/02; Gb2314392 5 Aug 2002 PO Mr R Kennell Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Vincenzo Branzi -v- Gourmeli International N V;; (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o31902 6 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Deutsche Telekom Ag -v- Ado1 (True Name Darren Turgel) [2002] DRS 456 6 Aug 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Vincenzo Branzi -v- Gourmeli International N -v- - O/319/02 6 Aug 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Vincenzo Branzi -v- Gourmeli International N V&Nbsp;&Nbsp; - Ep(Uk) 1031000 O/319/02 6 Aug 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â 'Ananova': Application No 2218303 OPP 51898 7 Aug 2002 TMR Dr Trott Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Catalis': Application No 2241975 OPP 52021 7 Aug 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Dbt Automation Gmbh and Dr Dirk Abel (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o32702 7 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Light Mask (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o32502 7 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Catalis (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o32102 7 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â DBT Automation Gmbh and Dr Dirk Abel - Gb 0030166 3 O/328/02 7 Aug 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Dbt Automation Gmbh And Dr Dirk Abel - O/327/02 7 Aug 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Dbt Automation Gmbh And Dr Dirk Abel - O/328/02 7 Aug 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Ananova (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o32002 7 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: LIGHT MASK 2266156 7 Aug 2002 TMR Mr C Hamilton Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Mark: CATALIS 2241975 7 Aug 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: ANANOVA 2218303 7 Aug 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â DBT Automation Gmbh and Dr Dirk Abel - Gb 0016654 6 O/327/02 7 Aug 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Dbt Automation Gmbh and Dr Dirk Abel (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o32802 7 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Transframe International': Application No 2232047B OPP 52234 8 Aug 2002 TMR Dr Trott Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Walklander': Application No 2210099 OPP 51019 8 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Omnicell Com - O/329/02 8 Aug 2002 PO Mr M Wright Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â 'Transframe': Application No 2232407A OPP 52233 8 Aug 2002 TMR Dr Trott Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Taxmate (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o32202 8 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: WALKLANDER 2210099 8 Aug 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: TRANSFRAME INTERNATIONAL 2232047B 8 Aug 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: TRANSFRAME 2232407A 8 Aug 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: TAXMATE 2227417 8 Aug 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Â Walklander; IPO 8-Aug-2002 - [2002] UKIntelP o32602 Â Vodafone Group Plc -v- Knights Independent Traders [2002] DRS 445 8 Aug 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Transframe International (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o32402 8 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Pro-Face UK Ltd -v- Price [2002] DRS 399 8 Aug 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Transframe (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o32302 8 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Omnicell Com - Ep0597558, Ep0594268 and Ep0429660 O/329/02 8 Aug 2002 PO Mr M Wright Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Blissworld Ltd & Blissworld Llc -v- Blissworld [2002] DRS 444 8 Aug 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â OmnicellCom (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o32902 8 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Taxmate': Application No 2227417 OPP 51501 8 Aug 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Halliburton Energy Services Inc -v- Baker Hughes Incorporated O/332/02; Gb 2302110 B; Gb 2291909 B 9 Aug 2002 PO Mr S Dennehey Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Halliburton Energy Services Inc -v- Baker Hughes Incorporated O/332/02 9 Aug 2002 PO Mr S Dennehey Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Halliburton Energy Services Inc -v- Baker Hughes Incorporated (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o33202 9 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DIXYLAND CHICKEN & RIBS 2133286 9 Aug 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Dixyland Chicken Ribs (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o33102 9 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Dixyland Chicken& Ribs': Application No 2133286 OPP 51841 9 Aug 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Buko Limited -v- Clares Merchandise Handling Equipment Limited;; (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o33302 12 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Buko Limited -v- Clares Merchandise Handling Equipment Limited - O/333/02 12 Aug 2002 PO Mr S Dennehey Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Buko Limited -v- Clares Merchandise Handling Equipment Limited &Nbsp; - Gb 2293579 B O/333/02 12 Aug 2002 PO Mr S Dennehey Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Allimax (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o37102 13 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: ALLIMAX 2225044 13 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Geoffrey Hobbs QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Allimax': Application No 2225044 OPP 51248 13 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Hobbs QC Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Neptune': Application No 690242 INV 16022 13 Aug 2002 TMR Mrs Long Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Neptune (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o33402 13 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: NEPTUNE 690242 13 Aug 2002 TMR Mrs S Long Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Souledge (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o33702 14 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Police Public Call Box (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o33602 14 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Dakar (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o33902 14 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Orange (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o33502 14 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Dakar': Application No 2027442A OPP 47959 14 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Souledge': Application No 2068253 OPP 45735 14 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Dakar 4X4 (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o33802 14 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DAKAR 2027442A 14 Aug 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: DAKAR 4x4 2121001 14 Aug 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: SOULEDGE 2068253 14 Aug 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: POLICE PUBLIC CALL BOX 2104259 14 Aug 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: ORANGE 2185792 14 Aug 2002 TMR Mr E S Smith Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Police Public Callbox': Application No 2104259 OPP 48452 14 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Orange': Application No 2185792 OPP 80069 14 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Smith Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Dakar 4X4': Application No 2121001 OPP 49860 14 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Adrian Neil Warren (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o34002 15 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Leonardo (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o34602 15 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mr Adrian Neil Warren O/340/02 15 Aug 2002 PO Mr M Wright Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â 'Leonardo': Application No 2210294 OPP 50852 15 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Rowan Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Adrian Neil Warren - Gb0024500 1, Gb0024501 9 and Gb0024503 5 O/340/02 15 Aug 2002 PO Mr M Wright Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Mark: LEONARDO 2210294 15 Aug 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: BLUEBIRD ELECTRIC 2145888 15 Aug 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Bluebird Electric': Application No 2145888 OPP 50452 15 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Bluebird Electric (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o34502 15 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Starbucks Corp -v- Bucknall [2002] DRS 402 16 Aug 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: CALL CENTRE ALLIANCE M.722283 16 Aug 2002 TMR Mrs A Pritchard Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Mark: ORANGE FUTURE TALK 2190538 16 Aug 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Orange Future Talk': Application No 2190538 OPP 51426 16 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Foley Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Lombard Networkservices': Application No 2191353 OPP 50256 16 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Foley Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Lombard Network Services (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o34302 16 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Orange Future Talk (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o34202 16 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Call Centre Alliance (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o34102 16 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: LOMBARD NETWORK SERVICES 2191353 16 Aug 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: MISCELLANEOUS ONLY 2150607 19 Aug 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â 'Miscellaneous Only': Application No 2150607 INV 12442 19 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Miscellaneous Only (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o34402 19 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Dr Helena H Windsor -v- University College London - O/381/02 19 Aug 2002 PO Mr D Barford Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Air China -v- Starlight Vacations [2002] DRS 480 19 Aug 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Dr Helena H Windsor -v- University College London - Gb 0017073 8; Pct/Gb01/03128 O/381/02 19 Aug 2002 PO Mr D Barford Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Dr Helena H Windsor -v- University College London (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o38102 19 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Bo - Bo'S (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o34702 20 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: BO - BO's 2238249 20 Aug 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â 'Bo - Bo'S': Application No 2238249 INV 12468 20 Aug 2002 TMR Dr Trott Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Mark: PEGASUS SECURITY GROUP 2170400 21 Aug 2002 TMR Mr O Morris Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Chae (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o34802 21 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: GLUCOLYTE 2204156 21 Aug 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Hanna-Barbera Productions Inc -v- Hay [2002] DRS 389_Appeal 21 Aug 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Glucolyte (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o35102 21 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Chae': Application No 2192136 OPP 50803 21 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Pegasus Securitygroup': Application No 2170400 OPP 50185 21 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Morris Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Petsure Health Insurance for Dogs and Cats': Application No 2204845 2204846 OPP 51143 OPP 51144 21 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: CHAE 2192136 21 Aug 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Glucolyte': Application No 2204156 OPP 51383 21 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Knight Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Pegasus Security Group (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o34902 21 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Petsure Health Insurance for Dogs and Cats (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o35002 21 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: PETSURE HEALTH INSURANCE FOR DOGS AND CATS 2204845, 2204846 21 Aug 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: SPECIAL EFFECTS 2237923 22 Aug 2002 TMR Mr A James Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Special Effects (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o35202 22 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Special Effects': Application No 2237923 OPP 51774 22 Aug 2002 TMR Mr James Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition 1 Citers [ PO ] Â Golddigga (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o35602 23 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: TC TIMESHARE COUNCIL 2148699 23 Aug 2002 TMR Professor Ruth Annand Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Tc Timeshare Council': Application No 2148699 OPP 49971 23 Aug 2002 TMR Professor Annand Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Tc Timeshare Council (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o37202 23 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Hoyland Fox Ltd -v- Alexander Seven Marketing Company Ltd [2002] DRS 488 23 Aug 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Golddigga': Application No 2150283 INV 10684 23 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Mark: GOLDDIGGA 2150283 23 Aug 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Sun (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o35402 27 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: THE SUN 2203364 27 Aug 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: SUN 2023364A 27 Aug 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â The Sun Football (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o35302 27 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â The Sun (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o35502 27 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Sun': Application No 2023364A OPP 47148 27 Aug 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'the Sun&Nbsp;': Application No 2203364 OPP 47147 27 Aug 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â The Sun Football': Application No 2111872 OPP 46861 27 Aug 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: THE SUN FOOTBALL 2111872 27 Aug 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Taktyle (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o35702 28 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Taktyle': Application No 2242086 INV 80035 28 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Mark: TAKTYLE 2242086 28 Aug 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â 'Reveries': Application No 2237453 OPP 51767 29 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Playjam&Nbsp;': Application No 2225661 OPP 51681 29 Aug 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Golf Courts': Application No 2140143A REC 11445 29 Aug 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Rectification [ PO ] Â 'Oko&Nbsp;': Application No 2204593 OPP 50491 29 Aug 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Reveries (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o36002 29 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Playjam (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o35902 29 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: REVERIES 2237453 29 Aug 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: PLAYJAM 2225661 29 Aug 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Oko (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o36102 29 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Golf Courts (Trade Mark: Rectification) [2002] UKIntelP o35802 29 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â R&G Advertising & Marketing Ltd -v- Ray Gill Advertising [2002] DRS 446 29 Aug 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: GOLF COURTS 2140143A, 2140143B 29 Aug 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Rectification. [ IPO ] Â Mark: OKO 2204593 29 Aug 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: POINT FOUR 2137914 30 Aug 2002 TMR Professor Ruth Annand Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK M.711078 30 Aug 2002 TMR Mr A Pike Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Point Four (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o37302 30 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â British Critical Incident Stress Foundation -v- Durkin [2002] DRS 490 30 Aug 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o36202 30 Aug 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Point Four': Application No 2137914 OPP 48765 30 Aug 2002 TMR Professor Annand Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Daly Systems Ltd -v- Daly Telecommunications Ltd [2002] DRS 422 2 Sep 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Tag Heuer Sa -v- Sm@Rtnet Ltd [2002] DRS 473 2 Sep 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'U F O': Application No 688185 OPP 70324 3 Sep 2002 TMR Mr Rose'Meyer Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â UFO (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o36302 3 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: U.F.O 688185 3 Sep 2002 TMR Mr G Rose'Meyer Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Boss': Application No 2020540 OPP 52025 4 Sep 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Boss (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o36402 4 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: BOSS 2020540 4 Sep 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Poirot': Application No 2188911 OPP 49926 5 Sep 2002 TMR Mr Foley Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Co-Operate Toachieve': Application No 2212804 OPP 50664 5 Sep 2002 TMR Mr James Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â CO-OPERATE TO ACHIEVE - O/365/02 OPP 50664 5 Sep 2002 TMR Mr James Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - Opposition - [ PO ] Â Mark: CO-OPERATE TO ACHIEVE 2212804 5 Sep 2002 TMR Mr A James Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Poirot (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o36802 5 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: POIROT 2188911 5 Sep 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Co-Operate To Achieve (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o36502 5 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Penny Black (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o37802 6 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: PENNY BLACK 2150775B 6 Sep 2002 TMR Professor Ruth Annand Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â 'Penny Black': Application No 2150775B OPP 50039 6 Sep 2002 TMR Professor Annand Intellectual Property cw Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: THE LITTLE BIG FOOD COMPANY 2230948 10 Sep 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: ROLE CALL 2221156 10 Sep 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â The Little Big Food Company (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o36702 10 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: CLIMATE MASTER LTD 2018635 10 Sep 2002 TMR Mr David Kitchin QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Climate Master Ltd (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o37602 10 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Sea World (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o37002 10 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Role Call (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o36902 10 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Climate Master Ltd Opp 49931 10 Sep 2002 TMR Mr Kitchin Qc Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: 2018635 - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Sea World': Application No 2157042 OPP 50869 10 Sep 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'Role Call': Application No 2221156 OPP 51558 10 Sep 2002 TMR Mr Salthouse Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â 'the Little Big Food Company': Application No 2230948 OPP 52315 10 Sep 2002 TMR Mr Landau Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: SEA WORLD 2157042 10 Sep 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: HPMC-OPHTAL (WORD ONLY MARK) M 684466 11 Sep 2002 TMR Mr David Kitchin QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Hpmc-Ophtal (Word Only Mark) M Opp 70073 11 Sep 2002 TMR Mr Kitchin Qc Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: M 684466 [ PO ] Â 'Permajet': Application No 2224590 OPP 51392 11 Sep 2002 TMR Mr Smith Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â HPMC-Ophtal (Word Only Mark) (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o39902 11 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: PERMAJET 2224590 11 Sep 2002 TMR Mr E S Smith Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Permajet (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o36602 11 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Keith Harris -v- Qual-Chem Ltd (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o37402 12 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Consorzio Del Prosciutto Di Parma -v- Vital Domains Ltd [2002] DRS 359_Appeal 12 Sep 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Keith Harris -v- Qual Chem Ltd - O/374/02 12 Sep 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Keith Harris -v- Qual Chem Ltd - Gb 0125007 5 O/374/02 12 Sep 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Jockey Club -v- Buffham [2003] QB 462; Times, 04 October 2002; Gazette, 17 October 2002; [2002] EWHC 1866 (QB) 13 Sep 2002 QBD Gray J Litigation Practice, Contempt of Court, Media, Intellectual Property A court had issued a final order with an injunction against the respondent against revealing matters becoming known to him during his employment by the claimant. The BBC sought a variation to allow it to broadcast material based upon that documents held by the defendant. Held: A final order was not binding against third parties. Once the proceedings had concluded, and a final order made, those proceedings could not be prejudiced, and the law of contempt no longer applied. The BBC was not bound by the injunction. 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Dell USA Lp - Gb0127329 1 O/377/02; O/377/02 16 Sep 2002 PO Mr M Wilson Intellectual Property cw Ex Parte Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Dell Usa Lp (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o37702 16 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Dell Usa Lp - O/377/02 16 Sep 2002 PO Mr M Wilson Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â 'Fishbone': Application No 2233269 OPP 51673; OPP 51673 17 Sep 2002 TMR Mr MacGillivray Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Antonio Munoz Y Cia SA Superior and Fruitcola SA -v- Frumar Limited and Another Times, 20 November 2002; C/253/00; [2003] Ch 328 17 Sep 2002 ECJ Advocate General Geelhoed European, Intellectual Property, Agriculture The claimant grew and sold grapes, and complained that the defendant who also traded in grapes was acting in breach of community legislation in failing to meet quality control standards. The national court had held that the claimant had no right itself directly to enforce the European Regulation. Held: The claimant did have a right itself to enforce the Regulation. As a regulation, it had direct effect, and the national court had a duty to make sure that its effect was ensured, and that in turn implied that it was open to a competitor to request a court to enforce the regulations by civil action. Advocate General Geelhoed said: 'Infringements of Community law are to be penalised under conditions, both procedural and substantive, which are analogous to those applicable to comparable infringements of like seriousness of national law.' Council Regulation (EC) No 2200/96 3(1) - EC Treaty 189 1 Citers Â Camoris (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o40002 17 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: CAMORIS 2111766 17 Sep 2002 TMR Mr David Kitchin QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Future Labs Ltd -v- Towse [2002] DRS 500 17 Sep 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: FISHBONE 2233269 17 Sep 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Fishbone (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o37502 17 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Camoris Opp 50570 17 Sep 2002 TMR Mr Kitchin Qc Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: 2111766 - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: TK PATROL 2167825 19 Sep 2002 TMR Mr David Kitchin QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: BELLINI 2209385 19 Sep 2002 TMR Mr A James Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Bellini (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o38002 19 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Tk Patrol Opp 50544 19 Sep 2002 TMR Mr Kitchin Qc Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: 2167825 - Opposition [ PO ] Â Tk Patrol (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o42602 19 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 'Bellini': Application No 2209385 OPP 50764 19 Sep 2002 TMR Mr James Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Trade Marks - Opposition [ PO ] Â Slack and Slack -v- Haigh O/384/02; Pct/Gb00/02176 20 Sep 2002 PO Mr R Kennell Intellectual Property cw Inter Partes Decisions - Patents [ PO ] Â Philip Trevor Slack and Simon Philip Slack -v- Joshua Charles Michael Haigh (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o38402 20 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Slack and Slack -v- Haigh O/384/02 20 Sep 2002 PO Mr R Kennell Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Cardpoint Plc -v- Riga Industries [2002] DRS 538 20 Sep 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: TCI 2225342 23 Sep 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Mark: THE YELLOW SUBMARINE 2213983 23 Sep 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: ADRENALIN 2061071 23 Sep 2002 TMR Mr Geoffrey Hobbs QC Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Bat Out of Hell (Trade Mark: Appointed Person) [2002] UKIntelP o39802 23 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: BAT OUT OF HELL 2024326 23 Sep 2002 TMR Mr Geoffrey Hobbs QC Intellectual Property IPO Appointed Person. [ IPO ] Â George Opp 46549 23 Sep 2002 TMR Mr Kitchin Qc Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: 2160590A - Opposition [ PO ] Â George (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o53202 23 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: GEORGE 2160590A 23 Sep 2002 TMR Mr David Kitchin QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Adrenalin Inv 80092 23 Sep 2002 TMR Mr Hobbs Qc Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: 2061071 - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Bat Out Of Hell N/A 23 Sep 2002 TMR Mr Hobbs Qc Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: 2024326 [ PO ] Â Tci (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o38302 23 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â The Yellow Submarine (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o38202 23 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Adrenalin (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o39702 23 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Pc Clear Opp 48501 24 Sep 2002 TMR Mr Thorley Qc Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: 2126739 - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: PC CLEAR 2126739 24 Sep 2002 TMR Mr S Thorley QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Pc Clear (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o43302 24 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Viking-Umwelttechnik GmbH -v- Office for Harmonisation of Internal Market (Trade Marks and Designs) Times, 14 October 2002; T-316/00; [2002] EUECJ T-316/00 25 Sep 2002 ECFI European, Intellectual Property The applicant sought a trade mark in the form of two colours in two rectangles, which it claimed supported its reputation in garden equipment. Held: In principle, a juxtaposition of colours could found a trade mark, but that in this case there was insufficient distinctiveness to justify the grant of a mark. [ Europa ] - [ Bailii ] Â Ensure (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o38902 26 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 3D Capsule (Form Only Mark) N/A 26 Sep 2002 TMR Professor Annand Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: 2209936 2209937 [ PO ] Â Mark: ENSURE PLUS 1132516 26 Sep 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Mark: McQUEEN CLOTHING CO 2158217 26 Sep 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: ENSURE 1100805 26 Sep 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Â 3D Capsule (Form Only Mark); IPO 26-Sep-2002 - [2002] UKIntelP o40202 Â Ensure Plus (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o38802 26 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mcqueen Clothing Co (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o38702 26 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: 3D CAPSULE (FORM ONLY MARK) 2209936, 2209937 26 Sep 2002 TMR Professor Ruth Annand Intellectual Property IPO Appointed Person. [ IPO ] Â Eatalia (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o39302 27 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: EATALIA 2227020 27 Sep 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Direct Line Insurance Plc -v- Snoop4.Com Ltd [2002] DRS 550 27 Sep 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Â Mark: ABACUS HIGH QUALITY; TMR 30-Sep-2002 - 2191404 Â Â Abacus High Quality; IPO 30-Sep-2002 - [2002] UKIntelP o39402 Â Mark: SUNWIN 2165852 30 Sep 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Jigsaw (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o39502 30 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: JIGSAW 2220114 30 Sep 2002 TMR Mr A James Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Sunwin (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o39602 30 Sep 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Ultraframe UK Limited -v- Clayton, Fielding and Others [2003] RPC 435 3 Oct 2002 ChD The Honourable Mr Justice Laddie Intellectual Property, Employment The claimants asserted infringement of their registered design rights in parts used in their double glazing and conservatory units. "Therefore it is possible for design right to subsist in the design of the part of the article which is not excluded under the must match provisions." Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 213(6) 215 1 Cites 1 Citers Â Camfil Ab -v- Interfilta (Uk) Ltd - O/390/02 7 Oct 2002 PO Mr P Hayward Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Mark: FORM ONLY MARK 2162087 7 Oct 2002 TMR Mr Geoffrey Hobbs QC Intellectual Property IPO Appointed Person. [ IPO ] Â Form Only Mark N/A 7 Oct 2002 TMR Mr Hobbs Qc Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: 2162087 [ PO ] Â Camfil Ab -v- Interfilta (Uk) Ltd - O/391/02 7 Oct 2002 PO Mr P Hayward Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Interfilta (Uk) Ltd -v- Camfil Ab (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o39102 7 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Marc Nye Solicitor -v- Lock (T/A Legal Publishing Company) [2002] DRS 543 7 Oct 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Form Only Mark (Trade Mark: Appointed Person) [2002] UKIntelP o39202 7 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Interfilta (Uk) -v- Camfil Ab (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o39002 7 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mro Software UK Ltd -v- Commerce Internet Ltd [2002] DRS 475 9 Oct 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mr Kamal Taouabit - O/401/02 10 Oct 2002 PO Mr S Probert Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Kamal Taouabit (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o40102 10 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Jd Edwards & Company -v- Bedar [2002] DRS 495 11 Oct 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Bosendorfer UK Ltd -v- Kensington Computers [2002] DRS 461 11 Oct 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: EBC 2240731 11 Oct 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Royal Brompton Hospital National Health Service Trust -v- Hammond and others [2002] EWHC 2037 (TCC) 11 Oct 2002 PatC Intellectual Property 1 Cites [ Bailii ] Â Ebc (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o40302 11 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: PARTY IN THE PARK 95.8 CAPITAL FM 2202048 14 Oct 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: MANGO 2196430 14 Oct 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: CHF1 CHANNEL F1 2180339 14 Oct 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: CHF1 2180338 14 Oct 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: MIRIVAIR 744742 14 Oct 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: THE CITY, THE REEF, THE ROCK 2230645 14 Oct 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: CHF1 CHANNEL F1 2180339 14 Oct 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: STORM 2229129 14 Oct 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: BERLUCCI 2239210 14 Oct 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: FARMSENSE 2220897 14 Oct 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Frisbee -v- Campbell [2002] EWCA Civ 1374; [2003] ICR 141 14 Oct 2002 CA Lord Justice Keene, Lord Justice Chadwick, Lord Phillips MR Media, Employment, Intellectual Property, Human Rights The claimant sought an account against her former employee for the disclosures made by her of their activities. The respondent had signed a confidentiality agreement. The respondent counterclaimed for assault. She now appealed from dismissal of her appeal against the summary judgment entered against her, arguing that the judge was wrong to dismiss her case as unarguable, since the contract was repudiated by the claimant's own violent and other misconduct. The claimant argued that a confidentiality clause within an employment context survived any repudiation, and no public policy applied to justify the disclosure. Held: Whilst the defendant might not expect to succeed, it could not be said that her case was unarguable and the case was not appropriate for summary judgement. The existence of the Press Code engaged the defendants rights of free expression. Those rights were not absolute, and were to be seen with a balance including also the claimant's privacy rights. Whilst the defendant was not to be encouraged to persist, the case was not so unarguable as to be properly dismissed in a summary procedure: "We consider that it is arguable that a duty of confidentiality that has been expressly assumed under contract carries more weight, when balanced against the right of freedom of expression, that a duty of confidence than is not buttressed by express agreement" 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Mark: LUCENT 2112634 14 Oct 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: LUCENT TECHNOLOGIES 2112625 14 Oct 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY 2112700 14 Oct 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: ROCKFORD 2172923 14 Oct 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Mark: ROCKFORD 2254926 14 Oct 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: ROCKFORD 2204310 14 Oct 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: TRIAGRA 2244557 14 Oct 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: PARTY IN THE PARK 95.8 CAPITAL 2202042 14 Oct 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Berlucci (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o40402 14 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Farmsense (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o41302 14 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Device Only (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o40902 14 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â The City, The Reef, The Rock (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o41702 14 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Chf1 Channel F1 (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o42002 14 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Chf1 Channel F1 (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o41602 14 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Chf1 (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o41902 14 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Party In The Park 958 Capital (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o41402 14 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Party In The Park 958 Capital Fm (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o41202 14 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Lucent (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o41102 14 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Lucent Technologies (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o41002 14 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Rockford (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o40802 14 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Rockford (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o40702 14 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Triagra (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o40502 14 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Storm (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o41502 14 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Rockford (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o40602 14 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mirivair (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o41802 14 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mango (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o42102 14 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Parcel Point (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o45302 15 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: PARCEL POINT 2239970 15 Oct 2002 TMR Mr S Thorley QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Truck 'N Trolley Ltd -v- Eastern Storage Equipment Ltd [2002] DRS 468 15 Oct 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Parcel Point Opp 51955 15 Oct 2002 TMR Mr Thorley Qc Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: 2239970 - Opposition [ PO ] Â James Shanley (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o42202 16 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â James Shanley - O/422/02 16 Oct 2002 PO Mr D Barford Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Â EE Elizabeth Emanuel (Trade Mark: Revocation); IPO 17-Oct-2002 - 2161562B; [2002] UKIntelP o42502; O/425/02 Â Â Elizabeth Emanuel (Trade Mark: Opposition); IPO 17-Oct-2002 - 1586464; [2002] UKIntelP o42402; O/424/02 Â Mr Brian Leo Hardman O/423/02 17 Oct 2002 PO Mr M Wright Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Brian Leo Hardman (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o42302 17 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Our Pet (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o42902 18 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Yorkshire Water Services Ltd -v- Taylor Woodrow Construction Northern Ltd [2002] EWHC 2140 (TCC) 18 Oct 2002 PatC Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: MOBO 2196449 18 Oct 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: MOLEWOOD GARAGE 2213298 18 Oct 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Mark: OUR PET 2199810 18 Oct 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: EASY POWER 2199810 18 Oct 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Molewood Garage (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o43002 18 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mobo (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o43102 18 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Easy Power (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o42802 18 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: LENOPLAST 605138 21 Oct 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Lenoplast (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o42702 21 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Power Magnetics and Electronic Systems Ltd -v- Wood Goldstraw & Yorath and others [2002] EWHC 2912 (TCC) 22 Oct 2002 PatC Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: ZOPAX 2238903 22 Oct 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Zopax (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o43202 22 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Cairnstores Ltd Generics (UK) Ltd and Another -v- Aktiebolaget Hassle [2002] EWCA Civ 1504 22 Oct 2002 CA Lord Justice Longmore, Lord Jusice Aldous, Lord Justice Tuckey Intellectual Property Two patents had been invaildated for obviousness. They related to coatings on medicinal pills. The patent holder said the judge's interruptions indicated bias. Held: The sumissions were unjustified. The interventions were by no means intemporate, and the decision stood. 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Mark: LIFE SAVERS (Device) 2000622, 2000625 23 Oct 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Life Savers (Device) (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o43702 23 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Form Mark Only (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o44002 23 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: NAVY NAVY 2025205 23 Oct 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Form Mark Only (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o44102 23 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: FORM MARK ONLY 2006922 23 Oct 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: FORM MARK ONLY 2006922 23 Oct 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Navy Navy (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o43602 23 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Quest Motors (Maldon) Ltd -v- Internet Assist Ltd [2002] DRS 573 23 Oct 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Pdg Graphics Ltd -v- Pdgraphics Ltd [2002] DRS 526 23 Oct 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Matratzen Concord -v- OHMI T-6/01; [2002] EUECJ T-6/01 23 Oct 2002 ECFI European, Intellectual Property Europa Community trade mark - Opposition - Relative grounds for refusal - Similarity between two trade marks - Likelihood of confusion - Article 8(1)(b) of Regulation (EC) No 40/94 - Application for a figurative Community trade mark containing the word 'Matratzen' - Earlier word trade mark MATRATZEN. Case T-6/01. "In this context, the Court of Justice has held that the assessment of the similarity between the two marks must be based on the overall impression created by them, in light, in particular, of their distinctive and dominant components . . Consequently, it must be held that a complex trade mark cannot be regarded as being similar to another trade mark which is identical or similar to one of the components of the complex mark, unless that component forms the dominant element within the overall impression created by the complex mark. That is the case where that component is likely to dominate, by itself, the image of that mark which the relevant public keeps in mind, with the result that all other components of the mark are negligible with the overall impression created by it . . Wiith regard to the assessment of the dominant character of one or more components of a complex trade mark, account must be taken, in particular, of the intrinsic qualities of each of those components by comparing them with those of the other components. In addition and accessorily, account may be taken of the relative position of the various marks within the arrangement of the complex mark." 1 Citers [ Europa ] - [ Bailii ] - [ Europa ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 2018438 25 Oct 2002 TMR Mr Geoffrey Hobbs QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: T.CO 2210448 25 Oct 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: CD CARD 1521388 25 Oct 2002 TMR Mr S Thorley QC Intellectual Property IPO Appointed Person. [ IPO ] Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o46702 25 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Xtralite Limited Vs Hartington Conway Limited (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o43802 25 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Cd Card (Trade Mark: Appointed Person) [2002] UKIntelP o46902 25 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Cd Card N/A 25 Oct 2002 TMR Mr Thorley Qc Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: 1521388 [ PO ] Â Device Only Mark Opp 44678 25 Oct 2002 TMR Mr Hobbs Qc Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: 2018438 - Opposition [ PO ] Â Xtralite Limited -v- Hartington Conway Limted O/438/02 25 Oct 2002 PO Mr P Hayward Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Leisure Parcs Ltd -v- Www.Your-Name-Here.Co.UK [2002] DRS 570 25 Oct 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â TCo (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o43502 25 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Advanced Hair Studios Pty Ltd -v- Yourwww [2002] DRS 503 27 Oct 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Thomas Cook UK Ltd -v- Whitley Bay Uncovered [2002] DRS B3 27 Oct 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Celltech Chiroscience Ltd -v- Medimmune Inc [2002] EWHC 2167 (Patents) 28 Oct 2002 PatC Jacobs J Intellectual Property 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Podnik -v- Anheuser-Busch Inc [2003] RPC 25; [2002] EWCA Civ 1534 29 Oct 2002 CA Pill LJ, Lord Walker of Guestingthorpe Intellectual Property Trades Mark Act 1994 46 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Acrylios Opp 48477 30 Oct 2002 TMR Professor Annand Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: 2151957 - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mark: ACRYLIOS 2151957 30 Oct 2002 TMR Professor Ruth Annand Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: JAIPUR 228391 30 Oct 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Acrylios (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o46802 30 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â IDA Limited, Metcalfe, D Lax And Polymer Powder Technology (Licensing) Ltd -v- University Of Southampton, Howse And Ashby) O/444/02 30 Oct 2002 PO Mr R Kennell Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â IDA Limited and Others -v- University of Southampton (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o44402 30 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Jaipur (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o43902 30 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: HERITAGE 1364595 31 Oct 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Surf Unlimited N/A 31 Oct 2002 TMR Mr Hobbs Qc Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: 2216981 [ PO ] Â Form Only (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o44602 31 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: Form Only 2243591 31 Oct 2002 TMR Mrs A Pritchard Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Mark: HERITAGE 1524198 31 Oct 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Mark: SURF UNLIMITED 2216981 31 Oct 2002 TMR Mr Geoffrey Hobbs QC Intellectual Property IPO Appointed Person. [ IPO ] Â Surf Unlimited (Trade Mark: Appointed Person) [2002] UKIntelP o48702 31 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â E I Du Pont de Nemours and Co -v- S T Dupont (1) Times, 07 November 2002; Gazette, 09 January 2003; [2003] EWCA 1368 31 Oct 2002 ChD Neuberger J Intellectual Property, Evidence, Civil Procedure Rules Parties appealed from decisions of the Trade Marks Registry, and requested leave to introduce new evidence. Held: It was not agreed what rules applied on appeals under the 1938 Act. The Trade Mark system had public interest effects as well as private law. The rules governing appeals were therefore different from other regimes. The courts should adopt a more relaxed attitude, and treat the appeal as a full re-hearing rather than as a review, and that, accordingly fresh evidence might be admissible. Trade Marks Act 1938 18 - Civil Procedure Rules 52.11(2) 1 Cites 1 Citers Â Heritage (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o44302 31 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Form Only 31 Oct 2002 TMR Mrs A Pritchard Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Heritage (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o44202 31 Oct 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Form Only (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o44502 1 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: FORM ONLY 2273578 1 Nov 2002 TMR Mr A Rees Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Li-Lo (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o44702 5 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: LI-LO 628826 5 Nov 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Mark: LI-LO 654349 5 Nov 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Li-Lo (Trade Mark: Revocation) (1) [2002] UKIntelP o44802 5 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Merck & Co Inc -v- Direct Response Marketing (Jersey) Ltd [2002] DRS 593 6 Nov 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: 2033 2141921 6 Nov 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: 2503 2140535 6 Nov 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: 2003 S 2140532 6 Nov 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: 2004 S 2141316 6 Nov 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: FRUTASTICA 2006922 6 Nov 2002 TMR Mr M Knight Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Frutastica (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o45402 6 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 2503 (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o44902 6 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 2033 (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o45002 6 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 2004 S (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o45202 6 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â 2003 S (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o45102 6 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Ida Limited, Colin Thomas Metcalfe, David J Lax & Polymer Powder Technology (Licensing) Limited -v- University Of Southampton - O/456/02 7 Nov 2002 PO Mr R Kennell Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Saxon (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o45502 7 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â IDA Limited and Others -v- University of Southampton (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o45602 7 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: SAXON 2150052 7 Nov 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Fairview New Homes Ltd -v- Brueton [2002] DRS 522 8 Nov 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Eastman Kodak Company -v- American Photo Booths Inc (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o45702 8 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Eastman Kodak -v- American Photo Booth Inc - O/457/02 8 Nov 2002 PO Mr P Hayward Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Mark: Oncolyse 2247435 11 Nov 2002 TMR Mr A James Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Oncolyse (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o45802 11 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Michael Van Clarke Great Hair Days (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o46002 12 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Arsenal Football Club plc -v- Reed C-206/01; [2003] RPC 144; [2002] EUECJ C-206/01; [2002] ECR I-10273; [2003] ETMR 19 12 Nov 2002 ECJ Iglesias, Puissochet, Wathelet, Timmermans, Gulmann, Edward, Jann, Skouris, Macken, Colneric, von Bahr JJ Intellectual Property, European The trade mark owner sought orders against a street vendor who sold articles using their marks. He asserted that the marks were not attached to show any quality, but were used by the fans as badges of allegiance. Held: The function of a trade mark was to guarantee the identity or origin of the goods, and distinguish them from goods of other origins. The purpose of the Directive was to ensure that the owner was able to protect his specific interests. Whatever the trader did to proclaim that the goods he sold did not originate from the claimants, he could not, for example, prevent confusion on a resale. The purpose of the attachment of the mark was not for purely descriptive purposes. The use of the mark in this way also diluted the guarantee of origin offered by the owner when using it itself. The articles were infringing. First Council Directive 89/104/EEC Dec 21 1988 Art 5(1)(a) 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Europa ] - [ Bailii ] - [ Europa ] Â Mark: Michael Van Clarke Great Hair Days 2214352 12 Nov 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: Red Letter 2205212 12 Nov 2002 TMR Mrs A Corbett Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Red Letter (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o46202 12 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Dot Comment (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o46502 13 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Blackhair (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o46602 13 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: BLACKHAIR 2255961 13 Nov 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: DOT COMMENT 2223452 13 Nov 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Oystertec Plc -v- Edward Evans Barker [2002] EWHC 2324 (Patents) 14 Nov 2002 PatC Jacob J Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Fujitsu Ltd (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o45902 15 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Fujitsu Ltd O/459/02 15 Nov 2002 PO Mr S Probert Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Kent Qualified -v- Hewlett [2002] DRS 599 15 Nov 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Leon Boole -v- Manhar Chauhan (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o46102 18 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Leon J Boole & Manhar Chauhan -v- Leon J Boole - O/461/02 18 Nov 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Thomas Cook UK Ltd -v- Bryant [2002] DRS 655 19 Nov 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Regina -v- S (Trade Mark Defence) (Roger Sliney -v- London Borough of Havering) Times, 02 December 2002; Gazette, 06 February 2003; [2002] EWCA Crim 2558 20 Nov 2002 CACD Rose LJ, Hughes, Davis JJ Intellectual Property, Crime, Human Rights The defendant alleged that the offence of which had been convicted, under the 1994 Act, infringed his rights under article 6.2 in reversing the burden of proof. Held: The principle that the duty of proof lay on the prosecution was subject to statutory exceptions. To place a legal (persuasive) burden of proof on the defendant is possible under statute, but is exceptional, and requires clear words. Here, parliament had used the word 'prove' rather than 'show' in describing the burden on the defendant to establish a defence. The defence did not allege dishonesty. Having regard not only to the interests of the accused and the public, the imposition of legal burden on the accused, in the section is necessary, justified and proportionate. There is a heavy burden on those justifying a reverse legal burden of proof, but that burden was discharged here. Trade Marks Act 1994 92(5) 94 - European Convention on Human Rights 6.2 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â WwwStandupifyouhatemanuCom (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o46402 20 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: THE SUPREMES 2017743 20 Nov 2002 TMR Mr Geoffrey Hobbs QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â A 20 Nov 2002 TMR Mr Fowler Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â The Supremes (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o47802 20 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: SALMAX 2214224 20 Nov 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Salmax (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o46302 20 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: A 2272753A 20 Nov 2002 TMR Mr R Fowler Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â A (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o47002 20 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: www.standupifyouhatemanu.com 2227520 20 Nov 2002 TMR Mr A James Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: Form Only 2226371 20 Nov 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â The Supremes Opp 46997 20 Nov 2002 TMR Mr Hobbs Qc Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: 2017743 - Opposition [ PO ] Â Oliver Bond (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o47102 20 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: OLIVER BOND 2199497 20 Nov 2002 TMR Mr E S Smith Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Form Only (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o47202 20 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Dyson Limited - O/475/02 21 Nov 2002 PO Mr R C Kennell Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Robelco -v- Robeco Groep NV C-23/01; [2002] EUECJ C-23/01; [2002] ECR I-10913 21 Nov 2002 ECJ European, Intellectual Property Europa Directive 89/104/EEC - Article 5(5) - Provisions on protection against use of a sign other than for the purposes of distinguishing goods or services - Extent of such protection - Signs similar to the mark. Directive 89/104/EEC 5(5) 1 Citers [ Europa ] - [ Bailii ] - [ Europa ] Â Dyson Limited (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o47502 21 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â E I Du Pont de Nemours and Co -v- S T Dupont (2) Times, 28 November 2002 22 Nov 2002 ChD Neuberger J Intellectual Property The parties had appeared before a hearing officer at the Trade Marks registry. The opponent of the registration sought leave to argue an additional point which, though unpleaded, could have been argued without any significant adjournment. The Officer declined leave. Held: The appeal succeeded. Justice indicated that in these circumstances, where no significant adjournment was required and no particular prejudice suffered by the other party, and the point might not be difficult, leave should be given. The court had adequate powers in costs and other directions to ensure justice. No general rule could be drawn, and in many cases an adjournment might not be appropriate. 1 Cites 1 Citers Â Mark: EASYROOMS THE EASIER WAY TO BOOK A ROOM 2231569 22 Nov 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Easyrooms (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o47302 22 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Easyrooms The Easier Way To Book A Room (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o47402 22 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Models One Ltd -v- Phillips and others [2002] EWCA Civ 1799 22 Nov 2002 CA Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: EASYROOMS 2274082 22 Nov 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: Kala Niketan 1529867 25 Nov 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Kala Niketan (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o47602 25 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: IMAGINARIUM 1567081 25 Nov 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Imaginarium (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o47902 25 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Xarocid (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o47702 25 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Barudan UK Ltd -v- Xceptional [2002] DRS 617 25 Nov 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: XAROCID 254508 25 Nov 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Form Only (Pig Description) (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o48202 26 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: Form Only (Pig Description) 26 Nov 2002 TMR Mr A Pike Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Mark: THINK PINK 2235681C 26 Nov 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Anstalt and others -v- Hayek and others [2002] EWCA Civ 1729 26 Nov 2002 CA Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Form Only (Pig Description) 26 Nov 2002 TMR Mr Pike Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Dranez Anstalt and Others -v- Hayek and Others Times, 03 December 2002 26 Nov 2002 CA Woolf, LCJ, Brooke, Chadwick LJJ Intellectual Property, Commercial A company had bought another and, with it patents assigned to it by the inventor. In addition they obtained an agreement from the inventor not to compete, which agreement they now sought to enforce. Held: The inventor's appeal was upheld. The judge had failed properly to allow for the statutory context. Patents law set a balance of rights, granting a monopoly as a way of encouraging invention. It would be a wholly exceptional case where restraints on a person capable of making a real contribution to the development of science could be justified, and that monopoly right extended. Those restraints here, were unenforceable on the grounds of public policy. Patents Act 1980 60 61 Â Think Pink (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o48402 26 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Unmissable (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o48902 27 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â T for Telecom (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o48302 27 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: T FOR TELECOM 704822 27 Nov 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â XS BAGGAGE - O/486/02 OPP 51907 27 Nov 2002 TMR Mr Reynolds Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Inter Partes Decisions - - [ PO ] Â Mark: PALS4PETS 2237730 27 Nov 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Mark: XS BAGGAGE 2241872 27 Nov 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Xs Baggage (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o48602 27 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: PETPALS 2235947 27 Nov 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Pals4Pets (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o48102 27 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: EON 740205 27 Nov 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: UNMISSABLE 2222412 27 Nov 2002 TMR Mrs A Corbett Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: S.SOYO 1425663 27 Nov 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Eon (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o48502 27 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Petpals (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o48002 27 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â SSoyo (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o49402 27 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Diana (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o49102 28 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Formula One Formula 1 (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o49202 28 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â VIA Technologies -v- Intel Corporation O/488/02 28 Nov 2002 PO Mr P Hayward Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Menashe Business Mercantile Limited, Julian Menashe -v- William Hill Organization Limited [2002] EWCA Civ 1702 28 Nov 2002 CA Lord Justice Dyson, Lord Justice Aldous, Sir Denis Henry Intellectual Property Patent 1 Cites [ Bailii ] Â Â Smithkline Beecham Plc, Glaxosmithkline UK Limited -v- Apotex Europe Limited, Neolab Limited, Waymade Healthcare Plc; PatC 28-Nov-2002 - [2002] EWHC 2324 (Patents) Â Mark: DIANA 1293766 28 Nov 2002 TMR Mr J MacGillivray Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Mark: FORMULA ONE FORMULA 1 1445879 28 Nov 2002 TMR Mr C Bowen Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Via Technologies -v- Intel Corporation (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o48802 28 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: ASTERIX 1209017 29 Nov 2002 TMR Mr O Morris Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Asterix (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o49302 29 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: ENERGAT 727803 29 Nov 2002 TMR Mr R A Jones Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Energat (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o49002 29 Nov 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: NATIONAL 2053772 2 Dec 2002 TMR Mr Geoffrey Hobbs QC Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft Zur Forderung Der Angewandten Forschung Ev, Prem Jindal And Bernard North O/515/02 2 Dec 2002 PO Mrs S Williams Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â National (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o53102 2 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft Zur Forderung Der Angewandten Forschung Ev, Prem Jindal and Bernard North (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o51502 2 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â National Inv 11363 2 Dec 2002 TMR Mr Hobbs Qc Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: 2053772 - Invalidity [ PO ] Â Zara Holdings Ltd -v- Commerce Internet Ltd [2002] DRS 576 3 Dec 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Markem Corporation Inc -v- Zipher Limited (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o49502 4 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Ford Motor Company (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o01003 5 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Ford Motor Company - O/010/03 5 Dec 2002 PO Mrs P Everett Intellectual Property PO Patent Office - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Mark: LE XV DU PRESIDENT 2243686 6 Dec 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Le Xv Du President (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o50702 6 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Fiorelli (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o50902 6 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: FIORELLI 2219833 6 Dec 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: HELLO BAR 2198914 6 Dec 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Hello Bar (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o50602 6 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Cyril Sloggett -v- Hadley Industries Plc - O/533/02 6 Dec 2002 PO Mr J Macgillvray Intellectual Property PO Designs - Designs/Design Right Decisions - [ PO ] Â Big Yellow Group Plc -v- Inca Research Inc [2002] DRS 654 6 Dec 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: FIORELLI 2195383 6 Dec 2002 TMR Mr S P Rowan Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Fiorelli (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o50802 6 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Pharmacia Ab -v- Rashid [2002] DRS 633 8 Dec 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Synthon Bv -v- Smithkline Beecham Plc [2002] EWHC 2324 (Patents) 9 Dec 2002 ChD The Hon Mr Justice Jacob Intellectual Property 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Care (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o50402 10 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: OVICOL 2220302 10 Dec 2002 TMR Mrs A Corbett Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Gold Fischli (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o49902 10 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Goldfischli (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o50002 10 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Camfil Ab -v- Interfilta (Uk) Limited - O/498/02 10 Dec 2002 PO Mr P Hayward Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Mark: COOKIES & CREAM 2162848 10 Dec 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: GOLD FISCHLI 1385089 10 Dec 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: SUSIE TRACK 2242871 10 Dec 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: GOLDFISCHLI 1424644 10 Dec 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Ida Ltd Et Al -v- University of Southampton Et Al (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o51602 10 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Ovicol (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o50502 10 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Ida Ltd Et Al -v- University Of Southampton Et Al - O/516/02 10 Dec 2002 PO Mr R Kennell Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Â Camfil Ab -v- Interfilta (UK) Ltd (Patent); IPO 10-Dec-2002 - O/498/02; [2002] UKIntelP o49802 Â Mark: CARE + 2252623 10 Dec 2002 TMR Mrs A Corbett Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Crease Control 10 Dec 2002 TMR Mr Peggie Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Susie Track (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o50202 10 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Taylor Made (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o50102 10 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: Crease Control 2276373 10 Dec 2002 TMR Mr I Peggie Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Crease Control (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o50302 10 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: TAYLOR MADE 2252623 10 Dec 2002 TMR Mrs A Corbett Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Cookies Cream (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o49702 10 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Arsenal Football Club plc and Others -v- Elte Sports Distribution Ltd Times, 27 December 2002 10 Dec 2002 ChD Vos QC Intellectual Property, Civil Procedure Rules The claimant alleged that the respondent had unlawfully made use of photographs of its footballers in a calendar. The respondent asked the court to strike out the claim as merely speculative, and the claimant sought pre-action disclosure. Held: The intention of Parliament had been to restrict the people who were able to pursue a claim for copyright infringement to the copyright holder. The claimant was not such. The correct route was not to strike the action for abuse of process as merely speculative, but since the claimant was entitled to disclosure as of right, to give the respondent the opportunity to apply again after disclosure. Civil Procedure Rules 31 1 Cites Â Â Peer International Corporation and Others -v- Termidor Music Publishers Ktd and Another; ChD 11-Dec-2002 - Times, 02 January 2003 Â Macross (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o51002 12 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Alligator (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o51102 12 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: MACROSS 2204547 12 Dec 2002 TMR Mr M Foley Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: ALLIGATOR 2238138 12 Dec 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Sativa Sl (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o51402 12 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: PRINTERNET (stylised) 2279676 12 Dec 2002 TMR Mr M Bryant Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Mark: SATIVA SL 2215825 12 Dec 2002 TMR Mr E S Smith Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Printernet (Stylised) (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o51302 12 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Â Aktiebolaget Hassle -v- Alphapharm Pty Ltd; 12-Dec-2002 - [2002] 212 CLR 411; [2002] HCA 59; (2002) 194 ALR 485; (2002) 77 ALJR 398; [2003] AIPC 91-838; (2002) 56 IPR 129 Â Mark: FOIA CENTRE 2276979 12 Dec 2002 TMR Mr A Pike Intellectual Property IPO Ex Parte. [ IPO ] Â Chivas Brothers Ltd -v- Plenderleith [2002] DRS 658 12 Dec 2002 Nom Intellectual Property Where a Respondent registers a Domain Name: 1. which is identical to a name in respect of which the Complainant has rights; and 2. where that name is exclusively referable to the Complainant; and 3. where there is no obvious justification for the Respondent having adopted that name for the Domain Name; and 4. where the Respondent has come forward with no explanation for having selected the Domain Name, it will ordinarily be reasonable for an expert to infer first that the Respondent registered the Domain Name for a purpose and secondly that that purpose was abusive. In this case the Expert draws those inferences. 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Procter and Gamble Company -v- Office for the Harmonisation in the Internal Market (Trade Marks and Designs) Times, 28 December 2002 12 Dec 2002 ECJ Intellectual Property, European, Human Rights A case had been referred back to the Office board by the court of first instance. The applicant complained when the same panel members were listed to hear the case again, Held: The Board of Appeal exercised the same function as the examiner. When it acted, it did so as the administration of the office in exercising those powers, and thus the Board was not properly classified as a tribunal, and therefore no right of fairness to a hearing applied. Â Foia Centre (Trade Mark: Ex Parte) [2002] UKIntelP o51202 12 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Sleckmann -v- Deutsches patent-und Markenamt Times, 27 December 2002; Case C-273/00 12 Dec 2002 ECJ Iglesias, Wathelet, Schintgen, Timmermans, Gulmann, Edward, La Pergola, Skouris, Macken, Colneric, Rodrigues JJ Intellectual Property The applicant sought to register a smell as a trade mark. It filed a chemical formula, a description, and a sealed container holding an example of the smell. Held: A non-visual mark was capable of registration provided it could be represented so as to be precisely defined, so as to allow users of the registry to know what was registered. The formula represented a chemical, not its smell, the description was too uncertain, and the physical sample was neither a graphical representation, nor stable nor durable. First Council Directive 89/104/EEC Â Foia Centre 12 Dec 2002 TMR Mr Pike Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Printernet (Stylised) 12 Dec 2002 TMR Mr Bryant Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Ex Parte Decisions [ PO ] Â Kabushiki Kaisha Fernandes -v- Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market (Trade Marks and Designs) (OHIM) Times, 28 December 2002; Case T-39/01 12 Dec 2002 ECFI Intellectual Property, European The applicant sought to annul the decision of the OHIM to grant a mark, claiming it was similar to its own. Held: Such an applicant bore the burden under the Regulation, if requested, of proving that the earlier trade mark had 'been put to genuine use'. That meant providing evidence of real use in a substantial part of the territory protected, in an effective and consistent way over time, and as a genuine trade mark use, namely to identify the source of the goods. The applicant had failed to establish such use. Council Regulation (EC) No 40/94 of Dec 1993 on the Community Trade Mark Â eCopy -v- OHMI (ECOPY) Times, 31 December 2002; T-247/01; [2002] EUECJ T-247/01; T-247/01 12 Dec 2002 ECFI European, Intellectual Property The applicant sought to register a trade mark, and appealed a refusal of the OHIM on the basis that it had not established at the time the application was made that the mark had 'become distinctive in consequence of the use which had been made of it' Held: The applicant could not rely upon use made after the application had been filed but before a determination had been reached, and the OHIM could not have regard to use after the application was filed. Appeal dismissed. [ Europa ] - [ Bailii ] Â Sieckmann -v- Deutsches Patent- und Markenamt (Judgment) C-273/00; Times, 27 December 2002; [2002] EUECJ C-273/00; [2003] RPC 38 12 Dec 2002 ECJ European, Intellectual Property A graphic representation within article 2 had to enable the sign to be represented visually, and the representation clear and precise, self-contained, easily accessible, intelligible, durable and objective to be registered as a trade mark. "the essential function of a trade mark is to guarantee the identity of the origin of the marked product or service to the consumer or end-user by enabling him, without any possibility of confusion, to distinguish that product or service from others which have another origin and that, for the trade mark to be able to fulfil its essential role in the system of undistorted competition which the EC Treaty seeks to establish, it must offer a guarantee that all the goods or services bearing it have been manufactured or supplied under the control of a single undertaking which is responsible for their quality." 1 Citers [ Europa ] - [ Bailii ] Â Kabushiki Kaisha Fernandes -v- OHMI T-39/01; [2002] EUECJ T-39/01 12 Dec 2002 ECFI European, Intellectual Property [ Europa ] - [ Bailii ] Â Arsenal Football Club plc -v- Reed Times, 17 December 2002; Gazette, 23 January 2003; [2002] EWHC 2695 (Ch) 12 Dec 2002 ChD The Hon Mr Justice Laddie European, Intellectual Property The Club had claimed trade mark infringement against the defendant who sold Arsenal memorabilia, but claimed that the use was not a trade mark use. The case was referred to the European Court of Justice who decided in favour of the club, who then came back to the High Court in the instant case to enforce that decision with an injunction. Held: The European Court appeared to have exceeded its jurisdiction, by finding a fact contrary to that found by the referring court, namely that some consumers would be confused as to the origin of the goods. Accordingly, the claimant was not entitled to its injunction to support that finding. 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Procter & Gamble -v- OHMI T-63/01; [2002] EUECJ T-63/01 12 Dec 2002 ECFI European, Intellectual Property [ Europa ] - [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 2138981 13 Dec 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o51902 13 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Geoffrey Inc -v- Downmark Ltd [2002] DRS 614 13 Dec 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: TIMBERLAKE 2269394 13 Dec 2002 TMR Mr M Reynolds Intellectual Property IPO Invalidity. [ IPO ] Â Timberlake (Trade Mark: Invalidity) [2002] UKIntelP o51802 13 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Smoothie (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o51702 13 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: SMOOTHIE 2206275 13 Dec 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Thomas Cook UK Ltd -v- Whitley Bay Uncovered [2002] DRS 583_Appeal 15 Dec 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Bravissimo -v- Gander [2002] DRS 661 15 Dec 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Device Only Mark (Trade Mark: Appointed Person) [2002] UKIntelP o52002 16 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: DEVICE ONLY MARK 21852861, 2185286F 16 Dec 2002 TMR Mr David Kitchin QC Intellectual Property IPO Appointed Person. [ IPO ] Â Device Only Mark 21852861; 2185286F 16 Dec 2002 TMR Mr Kitchin QC Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the Appointed Person Decisions - Application No: 2185286F 21852861 [ PO ] Â Mark: PERFECT 10 2192687 17 Dec 2002 TMR Mr A James Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Thomson Holidays Limited -v- Norwegian Cruise Line Limited [2002] IP&T 299; [2002] EWCA Civ 1828 17 Dec 2002 CA Mr Justice Scott Baker, Lord Justice Waller, Lord Justice Aldous Intellectual Property Aldous: "Pumfrey J in the Decon case suggested that the court’s task was to arrive at a fair specification of goods having regard to the use made. I agree, but the court still has the difficult task of deciding what is fair. In my view that task should be carried out so as to limit the specification so that it reflects the circumstances of the particular trade and the way that the public would perceive the use. The court, when deciding whether there is confusion under s 10(2), adopts the attitude of the average reasonably informed consumer of the products. If the test of infringement is to be applied by the court having adopted the attitude of such a person, that I believe it appropriate that the court should do the same when deciding what is the fair way to describe the use that a person has made of his mark. Thus the court should inform itself of the nature of trade and then decide how the notional consumer would describe such use." Trade Marks Act 1994 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Perfect 10 (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o52102 17 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mezzacorona Opp 46049 18 Dec 2002 TMR Mr Thorley Qc Intellectual Property PO Trade Marks - Appeals to the appointed person - Application No: 2029556 - Opposition [ PO ] Â Mezzacorona (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o01603 18 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: FUTTI 2275699 18 Dec 2002 TMR Mr A James Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Futti (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o52202 18 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: MEZZACORONA 2029556 18 Dec 2002 TMR Mr S Thorley QC Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Societe De Produits Nestle Sa -v- Unilever Plc [2002] EWHC 2709 (Ch) 18 Dec 2002 ChD The Hon Mr Justice Jacob Intellectual Property The claimant asserted trade mark rights in the shape of its Viennetta ice cream. Held "There is another, quite different, reason why I do not regard the shape alone as having been established as a trade mark. It is not sufficiently distinctive. I revert back to the fact that 15% thought that one or more ice cream products were Viennetta. A trade mark must, in principle, be a unique identifier – denoting one trader and none other. If it is shown that it mainly so acts but also denotes, or may denote, others to a lesser but nonetheless substantial degree, then I think: - It is not capable of distinguishing Art 3(1)(a) - It is "devoid of distinctive character" Art 3(1)(b) - It has "not acquired a distinctive character". 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Edward Evans Barker -v- Oystertec Plc - O/525/02 19 Dec 2002 PO Mr R Kennell Intellectual Property PO Patents - Inter Partes Decisions [ PO ] Â Picardi (T/A Picardi Architects) -v- Cuniberti and Another [2002] EWHC 2923 (TCC) 19 Dec 2002 PatC Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: EMME 2233285 19 Dec 2002 TMR Mr D Landau Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Guinness United Distillers & Vintners Bv -v- Walker [2002] DRS 669 19 Dec 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Emme (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o52302 19 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Edward Evans Barker -v- Oystertec Plc (Patent) [2002] UKIntelP o52502 19 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Reed Executive plc and Reed Solutions plc v- Reed Business Information Ltd, Reed Elsevier (UK) Ltd and totaljobs com Ltd [2002] EWHC 2772 (Ch) 19 Dec 2002 ChD Pumfrey J Intellectual Property Pumfrey J said: "Under Art 5(1) (b) [section 10 (2)] the comparison is not a straightforward mark for sign comparison. On the contrary, it involves a global assessment of the likelihood of confusion as to origin of the goods or services concerned. This involves an assessment of the distinctiveness of the mark, and involves the assessment of many factors familiar in passing-off cases." Trade Marks Act 1994 10 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Max Power (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o52402 20 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: MAX POWER 2232968A, 2260254 20 Dec 2002 TMR Mr A Pike Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Villeroy & Boch Ag -v- Designer Bathrooms Ltd [2002] DRS 663 20 Dec 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Intel Corporation -v- Via Technologies Inc, Elitegroup Computer Systems (UK) Ltd Via Technologies Inc , Via Technologies (Europe) Ltd, Realtime Distribution Ltd [2002] EWCA Civ 1905; [2002] All ER (D) 346; [2003] FSR 33 20 Dec 2002 CA The Vice-Chancellor Lord Justice Mummery Lord Justice Tuckey Intellectual Property, European, Commercial Infringement of patents. Held: With regard in particular to competition law claims (or defences), where the area of law is in the course of development the court should be cautious "to assume that it is beyond argument with real prospect of success that the existing case law will not be extended or modified" so as to encompass the basis of argument advanced. 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â 19 Entertainment Ltd -v- Parker [2002] DRS 631 20 Dec 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Gerber Foods International Limited -v- Gerber Products Company [2002] EWCA Civ 1888 20 Dec 2002 CA Lord Justice Auld Lord Justice Brooke Lord Justice Carnwath Intellectual Property Trade Marks [ Bailii ] Â Watermark Group Plc -v- Watermark Recruitment Bureau [2002] DRS 657 20 Dec 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Mark: SQUIRREL 2232253 23 Dec 2002 TMR Dr W J Trott Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: UPSAFE 2221029 23 Dec 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Mark: VISITOR 2202113 23 Dec 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Revocation. [ IPO ] Â Mark: HUMICADE 2227154 23 Dec 2002 TMR Mr G Salthouse Intellectual Property IPO Opposition. [ IPO ] Â Humicade (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o52602 23 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Squirrel (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o52902 23 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Visitor (Trade Mark: Revocation) [2002] UKIntelP o52702 23 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Upsafe (Trade Mark: Opposition) [2002] UKIntelP o52802 23 Dec 2002 IPO Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â Cabin Crew 89 -v- Bassa [2002] DRS 689 28 Dec 2002 Nom Intellectual Property [ Bailii ] Â
		Copyright 2014 David Swarbrick, 10 Halifax Road, Brighouse, West Yorkshire HD6 2AG.

swarb.co.uk - law index

Intellectual Property - From: 2002 To: 2002