

Links: Home \| swarblaw - law discussions		swarb.co.uk - law index These cases are from the lawindexpro database. They are now being transferred to the swarb.co.uk website in a better form. As a case is published there, an entry here will link to it. The swarb.co.uk site includes many later cases.
		Scotland - From: 2004 To: 2004 This page lists 735 cases, and was prepared on 20 May 2019. Her Majestys Advocate v Gilmour [2004] ScotHC 1 6 Jan 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Her Majestys Advocate v John Gilmour 6 Jan 2004 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Osborne And Lord Cameron Of Lochbroom Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Mckerrow v Crawford [2004] ScotSC 1 6 Jan 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Brian Mckerrow v Susan Crawford 6 Jan 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal E.F. Bowen Scotland [ ScotC ] Bryceland v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 2 6 Jan 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] George Mackie Thompson Bryceland (Aka George Nelson) v Her Majesty's Advocate 6 Jan 2004 HCJ Lady Cosgrove And Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Wheatley Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Howgate Shopping Centre and others v Catercraft Services Ltd [2004] ScotCS 2 7 Jan 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Canmore Housing Association Ltd v Bairnsfather (T/A Br Autos) [2004] ScotCS 1 7 Jan 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] the Howgate Shopping Centre and others v Catercraft Services Limited 7 Jan 2004 OHCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland, Commercial [ ScotC ] Tudhope v Park Trading As Park Hutchison, Solicitors [2004] ScotCS 3 7 Jan 2004 OHCS Lord Cameron of Lochbroom Scotland 1 Cites [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Thomas Clifton v Hays Plc Scottish and Newcastle 7 Jan 2004 OHCS Lady Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] Allison v Orr [2004] ScotCS 5 8 Jan 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Russell Patterson (Ap) v Lanarkshire Acute Hospitals NHS Trust [2004] ScotCS 4 8 Jan 2004 OHCS Lord Mccluskey Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Lisa Margaret Allison v Sir John Orr 8 Jan 2004 OHCS Lady Paton And Lord Johnston And Lord President Scotland [ ScotC ] Pacitti v Nicol [2004] ScotSC 2 9 Jan 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Dawn Evelyn Pacitti Or Nicol v Robert Clark Nicol 9 Jan 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Dawn Evelyn Pacitti Or Nicol v Robert Clark Nicol 9 Jan 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Lafarge Aggregates Ltd and others v Scottish Ministers and others [2004] ScotCS 6; 2004 SC 524 9 Jan 2004 SCS Lord Marnoch And Lord President And Lord Weir Scotland, Planning The court set out the evolution of planning law on the control of long standing permissions for mineral extraction. 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Wishaw and District Housing Association Limited v Michael Neary (Ap) 13 Jan 2004 OHCS Lord Hamilton And Lord Kingarth And Lord Mccluskey Scotland [ ScotC ] Wishaw District Housing Association v Neary [2004] ScotCS 10 13 Jan 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] William Livingstone v Fife Council [2004] ScotCS 9 13 Jan 2004 OHCS Lord Philip Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Justin Alexander Watts v Bell and Scott W S 14 Jan 2004 OHCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Glasgow City Council, Re Petition for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 12 15 Jan 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Boehringer Ingelheim Pharma Gmbh and Co, Kg v Munro Wholesale Medical Supplies Limited [2004] ScotCS 13 15 Jan 2004 OHCS Lord Bonomy And Lord Hamilton And Lord Marnoch Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Glasgow City Council for Judicial Review of an Interlocutor Dated 4Th July 2003 of A Sheriff of the Sheriffdom of Glasgow and Strathkelvin at Glasgow 15 Jan 2004 OHCS Lord Menzies Scotland [ ScotC ] Bayram Cinci v Her Majesty's Advocate 16 Jan 2004 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Kirkwood And Lord Mccluskey Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] McKearney v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC HCJAC - 69; 2004 SCCR 251; 2004 JC 87; 2004 GWD 15-332; 2004 SLT 739 16 Jan 2004 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Kirkwood And Lord Mccluskey Scotland, Crime The appellant had been convicted of rape. The court was now asked: "(1) whether the trial judge failed properly to direct the jury on the question of mens rea; (2) whether he erred in directing them to disregard the question of honest belief; (3) whether distress de recenti on the part of the complainer was evidence of mens rea on the part of the appellant, and (4) whether the jury were entitled to hold that the complainer remained frightened of the appellant when he had intercourse with her." [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Her Majesty's Advocate v Craig Fleming 16 Jan 2004 HCJ Lord Johnston And Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Wheatley Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Her Majesty's Advocate v Fleming [2004] ScotHC 3 16 Jan 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Ewen v Annand [2004] ScotSC 5 19 Jan 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Grampianhousing Association Limited v Carol Pyper 19 Jan 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Diane Mary Ewen Or Annand v Richard Annand 19 Jan 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Grampian Housing Association v Pyper [2004] ScotSC 4 19 Jan 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Aberdeen City Council v Robb [2004] ScotSC 6 20 Jan 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Macgregor and Another v City of Edinburgh Council [2004] ScotCS 18 20 Jan 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Helen Macgregor and Another v the City of Edinburgh Council 20 Jan 2004 OHCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] A O v R E O 20 Jan 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Jab v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 4 21 Jan 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] J A B v Her Majesty's Advocate 21 Jan 2004 HCJ Lord Caplan And Lady Cosgrove And Lord Justice Clerk Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] James Edward Martin v Had-Fab Limited 21 Jan 2004 OHCS Lord Clarke Scotland [ ScotC ] Determination By Sheriff Kenneth A Ross Into the Circumstances of the Deaths of Willian Sneddon, Lemond Milroy, David Brodie Mcfarlane, Agnes Mccoull, 21 Jan 2004 ScSf Sheriff K.A. Ross Scotland, Coroners [ ScotC ] Her Majesty's Secretary of State for Trade and Industry v Raymond Brown for A Disqualification Order 21 Jan 2004 OHCS Lord Mackay Of Drumadoon Scotland [ ScotC ] Martin v Had-Fab Ltd [2004] ScotCS 36 21 Jan 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Robert Smith (Ap) v Messrs D L Mcguinness 21 Jan 2004 OHCS Lord Clarke Scotland [ ScotC ] Clydebank Housing Association Ltd v Mcemerson [2004] ScotSC 8 22 Jan 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Clydebank Housing Association Lilmited v Mrs Kathleen Mcemerson 22 Jan 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal B A Kerr Scotland [ ScotC ] Bryan A Jackson Philip J Long (Managers Ad Interim of the Motherwell Football and Athletic Club) [2004] ScotCS 15 23 Jan 2004 OHCS Lord Carloway Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Angus Bell and Another v Flora Brown Campbell Or Fiddes 23 Jan 2004 OHCS Lord Mcewan Scotland [ ScotC ] Scottish Property Investment Limited v Scottish Provident Limited 23 Jan 2004 OHCS Lord Mackay Of Drumadoon Scotland [ ScotC ] the Highland Council for Suspension of A Charge for Payment of Money and Suspension Ad Interim 23 Jan 2004 OHCS Lord Johnston And Lord Maclean And Lord Osborne Scotland [ ScotC ] Highland Council, Re Petition for Suspension of A Charge [2004] ScotCS 16 23 Jan 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Bell and Another v Campbell [2004] ScotCS 14 23 Jan 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Scottish Property Investment Ltd v Scottish Provident Ltd [2004] ScotCS 17 23 Jan 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] John Sexton Maureen Allan v Marco Coia Carmela Rosina Coia 27 Jan 2004 OHCS Lord Emslie Scotland [ ScotC ] Sexton and Another v Coia and Another [2004] ScotCS 19 27 Jan 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Citex Professional Services v Kenmore Developments Limited 28 Jan 2004 OHCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Citex Professional Services v Kenmore Developments [2004] ScotCS 20 28 Jan 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Procurator Fiscal, Hamilton v Andrew Richard Sneddon 29 Jan 2004 HCJ Lord Macfadyen And Lord Marnoch And Sheriff Principal C.G.B. Nicholson Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Robert John Clark v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow 29 Jan 2004 HCJ Lord Abernethy And Lord Marnoch And Lord Weir Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Ranald Alasdair Macdonald of Keppoch v the Lord Advocate for Confirmation of Arms [2003] ScotCS 23 30 Jan 2004 OHCS Lord Macfadyen And Lord Nimmo Smith And Lord President Scotland [ Bailii ] MC, Re Application for Judicial Review [2003] ScotCS 22 30 Jan 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Liddell v Law Holdings and others [2003] ScotCS 21 30 Jan 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Calderwood v Renfrewshire Council [2003] ScotCS 24 3 Feb 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Carol Calderwood v Renfrewshire Council 3 Feb 2004 OHCS Lord Osborne And Lady Cosgrove And Lord Maclean Scotland [ ScotC ] HM Secretary State Trade Industry v Walker [2003] ScotCS 25 3 Feb 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Hm Secretary of State for Trade and Industry v Alexander Macbean Walker 3 Feb 2004 OHCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Standard Life Trustee Co Limited and others v Crimins Trustee 5 Feb 2004 ScSf Sheriff C A L Scott Scotland [ ScotC ] Standard Life Trustee Co and others v Crimins Trustee [2004] ScotSC 9 5 Feb 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Procurator Fiscal Aberdeen v Andrew Summers Stuart 5 Feb 2004 HCJ Lord Marnoch And Lord Macfadyen And Sir G.H. Gordon, Q.C. Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Procurator Fiscal v Stuart [2004] ScotHC 7 5 Feb 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Thomas William Latta and Another v Brian Edward Buns 6 Feb 2004 OHCS Lord Carloway Scotland [ ScotC ] Shields v Jarvis Hotels Plc and Another [2003] ScotCS 26 6 Feb 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Linda Shields v Jarvis Hotels Plc Edinburgh Leisure 6 Feb 2004 OHCS Lord Wheatley Scotland [ ScotC ] Mckellar v Mackinnon [2003] ScotCS 28 6 Feb 2004 OHCS Lord Abernethy And Lord Kirkwood And Lord Osborne Scotland [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Lorna Ann Mckelvie Houston Or Fraser v Alexander Fernie Fraser [2004] ScotSC 10 6 Feb 2004 ScSf Sheriff G.J. Evans Scotland [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Latta and Another v Buns [2003] ScotCS 27 6 Feb 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Capurro v Burrows and others [2004] ScotSC 12 9 Feb 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal I.D. Macphail, Q.C. Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Harrison v Chief Constable Grampian Police [2004] ScotSC 11 9 Feb 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Harrison v Chief Constable, Grampian Police 9 Feb 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Lothian Borders Police Board, Re Petition for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 29 10 Feb 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Stephen v Peters and Another [2004] ScotCS 31 10 Feb 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Procurator Fiscal, Hamilton v Michael Joseph Kelly Graeme Stewart Steven John Shaw 10 Feb 2004 HCJ Lord Macfadyen And Lord Marnoch And Sheriff Principal C.G.B. Nicholson Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Leith Stephen (Ap) v Robert Peters and Another 10 Feb 2004 OHCS Lord Carloway Scotland [ ScotC ] In Petition of Carlton Clubs Plc Foir Judicial Review of A Resolution By the Highland Council 10 Feb 2004 OHCS Lord Wheatley Scotland [ ScotC ] In the Petition of Lothian and Borders Police Board for Judicial Review of A Medical Certificate 10 Feb 2004 OHCS Lady Cosgrove And Lord Kingarth And Lord Osborne Scotland [ ScotC ] Procurator Fiscal v Kelly and others [2004] ScotHC 8 10 Feb 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Carlton Clubs Plc Foir Petition for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 30 10 Feb 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Mcdonald v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 9 11 Feb 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Sim v Independent Insurance Co Ltd [2004] ScotCS 34; [2003] ScotCS 58; [2004] ScotCS 57 13 Feb 2004 SCS Sheriff RG Craig QC Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ Bailii ] - [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Wolanski and Co Trustees Limited v First Quench Retailing Limited [2004] ScotSC 13 13 Feb 2004 ScSf Sheriff C.A.L. Scott Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Grampian University Hospitals NHS Trust v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 10 13 Feb 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Ii, Re Petition for an Order [2004] ScotCS 33 13 Feb 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Duffield Morgan Ltd v Historic Scotland [2004] ScotCS 32 13 Feb 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Grampian University Hospitals NHS Trust v Her Majesty's Advocate 13 Feb 2004 HCJ Lord Marnoch And Lord Macfadyen And Sir G.H. Gordon, Q.C. Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Duffield Morgan Limited v the Right Honourable Colin Boyd, Qc, Lord Advocate As Representing Historic Scotland 13 Feb 2004 OHCS Lady Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] I I for an Order Under the Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985 13 Feb 2004 OHCS Lord Menzies Scotland, Children Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985 [ ScotC ] Frame v Grampian University Hospitals NHS Trust Times, 02 March 2004 14 Feb 2004 HCJ Marnoch, Macfadyen LL, Sir Gerald Gordon QC Scotland, Human Rights The defendant NHS trust objected as to the leading of certain evidence by the prosecutor, saying it infringed the right to a fair trial. Held: As a governmental body rather the Trust could not have human rights capable of being infringed, it did not qualify as a victim under the Act. The French version of the Convention clearly referred to physical individuals, and the alternative claimants under article 34 were mutually exclusive.There were three tests as to whether an organisation was a state one: Was it a decentralised authority exercising public functions; would its acts engage the state's responsibility under the Convention; and was it sufficiently independent of the State. In this case the establishment of the Trust was a decentralisation of the state's administration. Scotland Act 1998 100(1)(b) - European Convention on Human Rights 834 1 Cites O'Donnell v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 12 18 Feb 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Francis Martin Thomas O'Donnell v Her Majesty's Advocate 18 Feb 2004 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Kirkwood And Lady Cosgrove Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Alan Pearson v J Ray Mcdermott Diving International Inc 18 Feb 2004 OHCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Pearson v J Ray Mcdermott Diving International Inc [2004] ScotCS 35 18 Feb 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Maxwell Farms Ltd v John Rennie and Son [2004] ScotSC 14 19 Feb 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Maxwell Far Limited v John Rennie and Son 19 Feb 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Macdonald-Haig v Macneill and Critchley (A Firm) and others [2004] ScotSC 15 20 Feb 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Crampshee v North Lanarkshire Council [2004] ScotCS CSOH - 37 20 Feb 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Petition of Spring Salmon and Seafood Limited for Judicial Review [2004] ScotScotCS 39; Times, 22 March 2004 20 Feb 2004 OHCS Lady Smith Scotland, Taxes Management The Inland Revenue began an investigation of the applicant's tax affairs. They objected that written notice had not been given, and that it had not been given at the company's registered office. Held: The Act contained sections requiring written notice to be given. This section required notification, which implied only communication of the intention, though noi doubt written notification would be usual. The Interpretation Act could not be used to require service at the registered office. Interpretation Act 1978 115(2) - Finance Act 1998 Sch 18 p 24 [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Delaney v Beechwood Nurseries [2004] ScotCS CSOH - 38 20 Feb 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Norma Mahon Crampshee v North Lanarkshire Council 20 Feb 2004 OHCS Lord Carloway Scotland [ ScotC ] Fiona Delaney v Beechwood Nurseries Limited [2004] ScotScotCS 38 20 Feb 2004 OHCS Lord Kingarth Scotland [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Crampshee v North Lanarkshire Council [2004] ScotScotCS 37 20 Feb 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Jrd v Wh [2004] ScotSC 16 23 Feb 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] J R D v and W H 23 Feb 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal E.F. Bowen Scotland [ ScotC ] Mccue v Procurator Fiscal [2004] ScotHC 14 24 Feb 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] McCue v Procurator Fiscal, Kilmarnock 24 Feb 2004 HCJ Lord Macfadyen And Lord Marnoch And Sheriff Principal C.G.B. Nicholson Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Verona Burnett (Ap) v Menzies Dougal, A Firm Peter D Aitken Gordon S Lockerbie Alexander D Burnett Three of the Partners Thereof, As Such Partners and As Indivuals [2004] ScotCS 40 24 Feb 2004 OHCS R.F.Macdonald, Q.C. Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Am v Jw [2004] ScotCS 43 24 Feb 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] O'Connor and Another v Bullimore Underwriting Agency (T/As Leisure Consortium at Lloyds) [2004] ScotCS 42 24 Feb 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] A M Or W v J W 24 Feb 2004 OHCS Lord Clarke Scotland [ ScotC ] Frank O'Connor and Another v Bullimore Underwriting Agency Limited Trading As the Leisure Consortium at Lloyds 24 Feb 2004 OHCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ ScotC ] Scottish Water for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 41 24 Feb 2004 OHCS Lord Cameron Of Lochbroom Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Platt v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 15 25 Feb 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Mclean v University St Andrews [2004] ScotCS 45 25 Feb 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Erin Leigh Mclean (Ap) v the University of St Andrews 25 Feb 2004 OHCS Sheriff R.G. Craig, QC Scotland [ ScotC ] Candace Donaldson (Ap) v Hays Distribution Services Limited Cb Hillier Parker Management Services Limited Cb Hillier Parker Limited National Britannia Health and Safety Limited [2004] ScotCS 44 25 Feb 2004 OHCS Lord Menzies Scotland 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Gordon Platt v Her Majesty's Advocate 25 Feb 2004 HCJ Lord Caplan And Lord Justice General And Lord Hamilton Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Taylor v Dumfries and Galloway Citizens Advice Services [2004] ScotCS 88 26 Feb 2004 OHCS Lady Cosgrove And Lord Hamilton And Lord Bonomy Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Millar v Watt and others [2004] ScotCS 47 26 Feb 2004 OHCS Lady Smith Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Hamilton v Seamark Systems Limited [2004] ScotCS 48 26 Feb 2004 OHCS Lady Paton Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Sayers v Loganair Limited [2004] ScotCS 46 26 Feb 2004 OHCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Smillie v Olympic House Limited Cameron K Russell [2004] ScotCS 50 27 Feb 2004 OHCS Lord Drummond Young Litigation Practice, Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Farrans Construction Limited v RMC Ready Mixed Concrete (Scotland) Limited [2004] ScotCS 51 27 Feb 2004 OHCS Lord Drummond Young Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Yuille Irvine for Judicial Review of A Decision of the Royal Burgess Golfing Society of Edinburgh; OHCS 27-Feb-2004 - Irvine, Re Petition for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 49 27 Feb 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Ballantyne and Another v Procurator Fiscal [2004] ScotHC 18 2 Mar 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Andrew Ballantyne Norman Mcdermott Hunter v Procurator Fiscal, Aberdeen 2 Mar 2004 HCJ Lord Marnoch And Lord Macfadyen And Sheriff Principal C.G.B. Nicholson Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] John Deans v Thus Plc 3 Mar 2004 OHCS Lord Clarke Scotland, Commercial [ ScotC ] Deans v Thus Plc [2004] ScotCS 53 3 Mar 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Musselburgh and Fisherrow Co-Operative Society Limited v Mowlem Scotland Limited [2004] ScotCS 52 3 Mar 2004 OHCS Lord Eassie Scotland, Commercial [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Alexander Noble v Cornelius De Boer [2003] ScotCS 54 4 Mar 2004 OHCS Lord Hamilton And Lord Marnoch And Lord Osborne Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Determination Into the Death of Donald Mcandrew Under the Fatal Accidents and Sudden Deaths Inquiry (Scotland) Act 1976 S 6 4 Mar 2004 ScSf Sheriff D.J. Cusine Scotland, Coroners Fatal Accidents and Sudden Deaths Inquiry (Scotland) Act 1976 6 [ ScotC ] Ceiling Decor Limited v Carol Ann Parratt [2004] ScotCS 56 5 Mar 2004 OHCS Lord Mackay Of Drumadoon Scotland [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Charles Kilna v De La Salle 5 Mar 2004 OHCS Lord Mcewan Scotland [ ScotC ] Kilna v De La Salle [2004] ScotCS 55 5 Mar 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Kennedy v Kennedy [2004] ScotSC 17 8 Mar 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Kennedy v Kennedy 8 Mar 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal B A Kerr Scotland [ ScotC ] Cochrane v Gaughan [2003] ScotCS 62 9 Mar 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Mohammed Aslam for Judicial Review 9 Mar 2004 OHCS Lord Mcewan Scotland [ ScotC ] John Walker Forey v Rhi Refractories (Uk) Limited 9 Mar 2004 OHCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Mrs Carol Dall Or Cochrane v John Gaughan 9 Mar 2004 OHCS Lord Brodie Scotland [ ScotC ] John Strain v Ian Byers and Another 9 Mar 2004 OHCS Lord Mccluskey Scotland [ ScotC ] In the petition of Duncan Watson [2004] ScotSC 18 9 Mar 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Forey v RHI Refractories (Uk) [2003] ScotCS 59 9 Mar 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Aslam, Re Judicial Review [2003] ScotCS 61 9 Mar 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Strain v Byers and Another [2003] ScotCS 60 9 Mar 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Duncan Watson 9 Mar 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal I.D. Macphail, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Capurro, Re Application of [2004] ScotSC 19 10 Mar 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Joseph Anthony Gerard Capurro 10 Mar 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal I.D. Macphail, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Hazel Wilson Elizabeth Gould v Glasgow City Council 11 Mar 2004 OHCS Lady Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] Wilson and Another v Glasgow City Council [2004] ScotCS 75 11 Mar 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Anderson v Cluny Investment Services [2004] ScotSC 20 11 Mar 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Mohamed Moneim Al-Fayed for Judicial Review of A Decision of the Lord Advocate To Refuse To Instruct A Public Inquiry Into the Death of Emad Al-Fayed [2003] ScotCS 66 12 Mar 2004 OHCS Lord Drummond Young Scotland, Human Rights, Jurisdiction The claimant sought judicial review of the minister's decision not to order a judicial public investigation of the death of his son in a car crash in Paris. Held: The primary obligation to undertake an enquiry fell upon France. The obligation of the respondent to instigate an inquiry applied only where the death occurred within the jurisdiction and where there was proper evidence that the death was violent: '"jurisdiction" in article 1 of the Convention is to be understood in a territorial sense. Thus the responsibility of a High Contracting Party under the Convention is confined, generally speaking, to events that take place within its own territory.' European Convention on Human Rights 1 1 Cites [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Christie v Christie 12 Mar 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal B A Kerr Scotland [ ScotC ] Elizabeth Macdonald Or Dalton v Turcan Connell (Trustees) Limited 12 Mar 2004 OHCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Ian Skinner v Scottish Ambulance Service 12 Mar 2004 OHCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Christie v Christie [2004] ScotSC 21 12 Mar 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Colin Fraser, A.P. v The Professinal Golders Association Limited 12 Mar 2004 OHCS Lord Philip Scotland [ ScotC ] Skinner v Scottish Ambulance Service [2003] ScotCS 65 12 Mar 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Macdonald v Turcan Connell (Trustees) [2003] ScotCS 64 12 Mar 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Fraser v Professional Golfers Association [2003] ScotCS 63 12 Mar 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Qamar, Re Appeal Against A Determination [2004] ScotCS 76 16 Mar 2004 SCS Lord Mackay Of Drumadoon And Lord Macfadyen And Lord Marnoch Scotland, Immigration [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Mcfarlane v Ferguson Shipbuilders Limited [2004] ScotCS 68 16 Mar 2004 OHCS Lady Smith Scotland, Health and Safety 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Innes, Re an Order Wind Up Scotpigs Ltd [2004] ScotCS 67 16 Mar 2004 OHCS Lady Paton Insolvency, Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] David Edward Brown v Procurator Fiscal, Inverness 17 Mar 2004 HCJ Lord Macfadyen And Sheriff Principal E.F. Bowen Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Messrs. Drever and Heddle v Mrs. Joan Pentland-Clark 17 Mar 2004 OHCS Lord Clarke And Lord Weir And Lord Osborne Scotland [ ScotC ] Thomas Campbell Joseph Steele Thomas Gray v Her Majesty's Advocate 17 Mar 2004 OHCS Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Maclean And Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ ScotC ] Flynn, Meek, Nicol and McMurray v Her Majesty's Advocate Times, 18 March 2004; [2004] UKPC D1 18 Mar 2004 PC Lord Bingham of Cornhill, Lord Hope of Craighead, Lord Rodger of Earlsferry, Baroness Hale of Richmond, Lord Carswell Scotland, Criminal Sentencing, Human Rights, Constitutional PC (High Court of Justiciary) The applicants had each been convicted of murder, and complained that the transitional provisions for determining how long should be served under the life sentences infringed their Human Rights, the Act being made outside the competence of the Scottish Parliament. Held: The 2001 Act incorporated the Human Rights Convention into Scottish law. It should not be taken to take away any existing right. Accordingly when deciding the punitive part of a punishment so as to prevent reference of his case to the Parole Board, the court must take account any date already set for such a hearing. Prisoners and Criminal Proceedings (Scotland) Act 1993 2 - Convention Rights (Compliance) (Scotland) Act 2001 1 Cites 1 Citers [ PC ] - [ Bailii ] Semih Koesger v Her Majesty's Advocate 18 Mar 2004 HCJ Lord Macfadyen And Sheriff Principal E.F. Bowen Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Urquhart and Another v Sweeney and others [2003] ScotCS 69 18 Mar 2004 SCS Lord Kirkwood And Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Mccluskey Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Koesger v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 20 18 Mar 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Donnelly v Fas Products [2004] ScotCS 73 19 Mar 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Thompson v Jardine [2004] ScotCS 180 19 Mar 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Kerry Donnelly v Fas Products Limited 19 Mar 2004 OHCS Lord Brodie Scotland [ ScotC ] John Edward Thomson v John Jardine 19 Mar 2004 OHCS Lord Osborne And Lord Hamilton And Lord Johnston Scotland [ ScotC ] Andrew Porter v Oakbank School [2004] ScotCS 70 19 Mar 2004 OHCS Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Mccluskey And Lord Kirkwood Scotland 1 Cites [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Thomson v Jardine [2004] ScotCS 71 19 Mar 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Will v Argyll Clyde Acute Hospitals NHS Trust [2004] ScotCS 74 19 Mar 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Susan Will v Argyll and Clyde Acute Hospitals NHS Trust 19 Mar 2004 OHCS Sheriff T.A.K. Drummond, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Angus Housing Association v Fraser [2004] ScotSC 22 22 Mar 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Angus Housing Association Limited v Gillian Fraser 22 Mar 2004 ScSf Sheriff F.R. Crowe Scotland [ ScotC ] Western Heritable Investment Company v Hunter [2004] ScotCS 77 23 Mar 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Kerr v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 21 24 Mar 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] David Moir Nelson Kerr v Her Majesty's Advocate 24 Mar 2004 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Macfadyen And Lord Osborne Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Alexander Nicholson and Another v Gary Nicholson and Another 24 Mar 2004 ScSf Sheriff C A L Scott Scotland [ ScotC ] William George Woodland v the Advocate General for Scotland and others 24 Mar 2004 OHCS J. Gordon Reid, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Brown and Another v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 22 25 Mar 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Plooy v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 23 25 Mar 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] L.A. v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions Etc 25 Mar 2004 OHCS Lord Bonomy And Lord Hamilton And Lady Cosgrove Scotland [ ScotC ] William Grant and Sons Ltd v Devlin [2004] UKEAT 0074 - 03 - 2503; EATS/0074/03 25 Mar 2004 EAT Lord Johnston Employment, Scotland The ET had decided that the employee's dismissal had been unfair on grounds including that the employer had taken account of an expired warning. Held: The decision was upheld. Lord Johnston said: "a final written warning, which is given a time limit, becomes null and void at the expiry of that time limit and should not be used for any purpose. Accordingly, we agree with the Tribunal that the employer should not have taken this into account and undoubtedly did. " 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ EATn ] Devonne Du Plooy v Her Majesty's Advocate 25 Mar 2004 HCJ Lord Justice General And Lord Maclean And Lord Hamilton Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] McDougall and Another v Glasgow City Council; EAT 26-Mar-2004 - [2004] UKEAT 0073 - 03 - 2603 The Scottish Legal Aid Board v Shields; OHCS 26-Mar-2004 - [2004] ScotCS 79 Kenneth Harrison v West of Scotland Kart Club and others Royal Automobile Club Motor Sport Association Limited [2004] ScotCS 80 30 Mar 2004 OHCS Lord President And Lord Marnoch And Lady Cosgrove Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Maley v Scottish Ministers [2004] ScotSC 24 31 Mar 2004 SCSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Aerpac and Another v Noi Scotland [2004] ScotCS 82 31 Mar 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Raymond Campbell v East Renfrewshire Council [2004] ScotCS 81 31 Mar 2004 OHCS R.F.Macdonald, Q.C. Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Alexander Maley v Scottish Ministers 31 Mar 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal E.F. Bowen Scotland [ ScotC ] Masroor Ahmed Syed Otherwise Named As Syed Masroor Ahmed v Samrana Ahmed 31 Mar 2004 OHCS Lord Menzies Scotland [ ScotC ] Aerpac Limited (In Administration) Bryan Alan Jackson, C.A. As Administrator Thereof v Noi Scotland Limited 31 Mar 2004 OHCS Lord Drummond Young Scotland, Commercial [ ScotC ] Syed v Ahmed [2004] ScotCS 83 31 Mar 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Mcnamara v Alexander Stone and Company [2004] ScotCS 84 1 Apr 2004 OHCS Lord Hamilton And Lord President And Lord Weir Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Mcwilliams v Caledonian Wild Foods [2004] ScotCS 85 2 Apr 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Anne Harte v Dalkeith Demolitions Limited 2 Apr 2004 OHCS M.G. Thomson, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] James Mcwilliams v Caledonian Wild Foods Limited 2 Apr 2004 OHCS Lord Johnston Scotland [ ScotC ] Cairns v The Chief Constable, Strathclyde Police [2004] ScotSC 25 2 Apr 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal E.F. Bowen Scotland 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Harte v Dalkeith Demolitions Ltd [2004] ScotCS 87 2 Apr 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] North Lanarkshire Council v Kenmure [2004] ScotSC 26 2 Apr 2004 SCSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Kane v Pearl Assurance Plc [2004] ScotCS 86 2 Apr 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Fire Logistics Limited 5 Apr 2004 ScSf Sheriff C.A.L. Scott Scotland [ ScotC ] Myles Oliver Fitzpatrick v the Advocate General for Scotland on Behalf of the Commissioners of Inland Revenue 5 Apr 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal I.D. Macphail, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Fitzpatrick v Inland Revenue [2004] ScotSC 28 5 Apr 2004 SCSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Fire Logistics Ltd, Re Petition of [2004] ScotSC 27 5 Apr 2004 SCSf Scotland [ Bailii ] PBW v AGL Or WHW for an Order Under the Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985 6 Apr 2004 OHCS Lord Hardie Scotland, Children Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985 [ ScotC ] PBW v AGL [2004] ScotCS 89 6 Apr 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Smith and others v Forth Ports Plc [2004] ScotCS 91 7 Apr 2004 OHCS J Gordon Reid QC Scotland [ Bailii ] Watt v Bridges [2004] ScotCS 90 7 Apr 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] W.M. Fotheringham and Son v the British Limousin Cattle Society Ltd [2004] ScotCS 93 8 Apr 2004 OHCS Lord Eassie And Lord Abernethy And Lord Marnoch Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Robertson v Forth Valley Health Board [2004] ScotCS 95 13 Apr 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Eric Campbell Robertson v Forth Valley Health Board 13 Apr 2004 OHCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Samuel Mcbrearty v Her Majesty's Advocate 13 Apr 2004 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Maclean And Lord Mccluskey Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Mcbrearty v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 24 13 Apr 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Ritchie Brothers (Pwc) Limited v David Philp (Commercials) Limited [2004] ScotCS 94 14 Apr 2004 OHCS Lord Eassie Scotland, Construction, Arbitration An arbitrator's decision was to be delivered within a certain time. That date having passed, he no longer had jurisdiction to arbitrate, and his decision was void, 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Halliday Or Millen v Douglas and Another [2004] ScotCS 96 15 Apr 2004 OHCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Dunedin Independent Plc v Kenneth Anderson Welsh [2004] ScotCS 97 16 Apr 2004 OHCS Lord Menzies Scotland [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Mcgoff v Bonnington Roofing Ltd and others [2004] ScotCS 120 20 Apr 2004 OHCS Lord Drummond Young And Lord Kingarth And Lord Osborne Scotland [ Bailii ] Mathew Purdon Henderson ( Liquidator of Letham Grange Development Co Ltd) v 3052775 Nova Scotia Ltd [2004] ScotCS 98 21 Apr 2004 OHCS Lord Carloway Scotland, Insolvency Insolvency Act 1986 242 1 Cites 1 Citers [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Andrew Young v Christine Elizabeth Logan 21 Apr 2004 ScSf Sheriff G.J. Evans Scotland [ ScotC ] Andrew Young v Christine Elizabeth Logan 21 Apr 2004 ScSf Sheriff G.J. Evans Scotland [ ScotC ] Van Overwaele v Hacking and Paterson C Russell and William Duncan and Company 22 Apr 2004 IHCS Lady Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] Overwaele v Hacking and Paterson and Another [2004] ScotCS 144 22 Apr 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Nigel Lowe Holdings Limited v Intercon Construction (Pty) Limited John Glendinning [2004] ScotSC 29 22 Apr 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal R.A. Dunlop, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] The University Court of The University of Glasgow v Melville Dundas Limited E.M. Mackenzie and Co Limited L.C.H. Generators Limited [2004] ScotCS 99 23 Apr 2004 OHCS R.F.Macdonald QC Scotland 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Michael Patrick Mooney for Judicial Review of A Decision of A Social Security Commissioner 23 Apr 2004 OHCS Lord Brodie Scotland [ ScotC ] Dundee City Council for an Order In Relation To the Child C.M. 23 Apr 2004 OHCS Lady Cosgrove And Lord Hamilton And Lord President Scotland [ ScotC ] Alan Alexander Dickson v Her Majesty's Advocate 23 Apr 2004 HCJ Lord Abernethy And Lord Mccluskey And Lord Macfadyen Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Robert Napier (Ap) v the Scottish Ministers for Judicial Review of A Decision To Continue To Detain the Petitioner In Inhuman and Degrading Prison Conditions 26 Apr 2004 OHCS Lord Bonomy Scotland [ ScotC ] Napier, Re Petition for Judicial Review; Higgs v The Scottish Ministers [2004] ScotCS 100; Times, 13 May 2004 26 Apr 2004 OHCS Bonomy L Scotland, Prisons, Human Rights The petitioner complained of the conditions in the Barlinnie Prison in Glasgow. Held: The conditions in the prison infringed the petitioner's human rights against inhuman or degrading treatment and respect for privacy, and he was entitled to damages. The regime involved severe overcrowding. The cells were designed for single occupants and had no running water or toilet facilities. The prisoners were locked in for lengthy periods requiring them to defecate or urinate in a confined space also used as a dining space and with no privacy. The sluicing system available when slopping out occurred was also inedffective. European Conention on Human Rights 3 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Unity Trust Bank Plc v Martin Frost &C 27 Apr 2004 OHCS Lady Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] Mfumu, Re Petition for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 101 27 Apr 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Struk, Re Petition for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS CSIH - 103 27 Apr 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Struk, Re Petition for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 103 27 Apr 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] London and Edinburgh Inns Ltd, Re Petition for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 109 27 Apr 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Unity Trust Bank Plc v Frost and others [2004] ScotCS 123 27 Apr 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] London and Edinburgh Inns Limited for Judicial Review 27 Apr 2004 OHCS Lord Brodie Scotland [ ScotC ] Petition for Salemah Mfumu for Judicial Review of Determinations of the Immigration Appeal Tribunal Etc and Answers for Secretary of State for Home Dept 27 Apr 2004 OHCS Lord Kirkwood And Lord Hamilton And Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ ScotC ] Petition of Behrouz Tehrani for Judicial Review and Answers [2004] ScotCS 102 27 Apr 2004 OHCS Lord Kirkwood And Lord Hamilton And Lord Macfadyen Scotland 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] William Mclaughlan Mrs. Elizabeth Henderson Mcdonald Or Mclaughlan v Keith Edwards 28 Apr 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] West Castle Properties v Scottish Ministers [2004] ScotCS 104 28 Apr 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Mclaughlan and Another v Edwards [2004] ScotSC 31 28 Apr 2004 SCSf Scotland [ Bailii ] West Castle Properties Limited v the Scottish Ministers 28 Apr 2004 OHCS Lord Mackay Of Drumadoon Scotland, Commercial [ ScotC ] Canmore Housing Association Limited v Bruce Bairnsfather Trading As Br Autos 28 Apr 2004 OHCS Lord Brodie Scotland [ ScotC ] Canmore Housing Association v Bairnsfather (Ta Br Autos) [2004] ScotCS 105 28 Apr 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Anees Mohammed Rafiq Against A Determination of the Immigration Appeal Tribunal [2004] ScotCS 121 30 Apr 2004 OHCS Lord Macfadyen And Lord Osborne And Lord Wheatley Scotland, Immigration [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Harper v Harper 30 Apr 2004 ScSf Sheriff K.A. Mclernan Scotland [ ScotC ] Mohammed Safdar v Mohammed Shahid 30 Apr 2004 OHCS Lord Mackay Of Drumadoon Scotland, Commercial [ ScotC ] Marion Renwick Thorburn Mclean Alison A. Campbell Kenneth Campbell Henry Mclean Charlotte Mclean Andrew T. Mclean v William Denny and Bros Limited Kendrick Computing Plc (In Liq) Richard Yerburgh Setchin Scott and Sons (Bowling) Limited [2004] ScotCS 108 30 Apr 2004 OHCS Lord Hamilton And Lord President And Lord Weir Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Josephine Murray As Individual and As Executor Nominate of Joseph Murray Kirsten Allardice Andrew Allardice Josephine Murray As Executor Nominate of the Late Mary Murray v the Greenock Dockyard Company Limited [2004] ScotCS 10; 2004 SLT 1104 30 Apr 2004 OHCS Lord Hamilton And Lord President And Lord Weir Scotland, Wills and Probate 1 Cites [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Safdar v Shahid [2004] ScotCS 106 30 Apr 2004 SCS Scotland The pursuer claimed repayments of loans made for the purchase of company shares. The defender denied any loan had been made, and claimed that any loans would require evidence in writing under the Act. Held: The arguments should be allowed to proceed, allowing a proof before answer, reserving all pleas in law of both parties. Requirements of Writing (Scotland) Act 1995 1 Cites [ Bailii ] Briggs Marine Contractors v Deft Shipping Co (Motor Vessel Toby S) [2004] ScotCS 110 4 May 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Mcgaffney v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 27 6 May 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] James Brannan Mcgaffney v Her Majesty's Advocate 6 May 2004 HCJ Lord Macfadyen And Lord Mcewan Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Richardson and others v Rivers [2004] ScotSC 33 7 May 2004 SCSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Tolley v Abbey Life Assurance Company Ltd and others [2004] ScotCS 111 7 May 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Adrienne Tolley v Abbey Life Assurance Company Limited Abbey Unit Trust Managers Limited Paul Tolley 7 May 2004 OHCS Lord Mackay Of Drumadoon Scotland [ ScotC ] Alastair and Mariane Richardson and others v Lynda Rivers 7 May 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal I.D. Macphail, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Eileen Todd v the Roman Catholic Diocese of Dunkeld Dundee City Council [2004] ScotSC 34 10 May 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal R.A. Dunlop, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Theresa Croly v Her Majesty's Advocate 11 May 2004 HCJ Lord Cameron Of Lochbroom And Lady Cosgrove And Lord Justice General Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] James Maclachlan Orr Walker v Chief Constable Lothian and Borders Police 11 May 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal I.D. Macphail, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Walker v Lothian and Borders Police [2004] ScotSC 35 11 May 2004 SCSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Croly v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 28 11 May 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Leslie Brown for Judicial Review of A Decision of the Scottish Ministers 12 May 2004 OHCS Lord Hardie Scotland [ ScotC ] Julia Hill v Fiona Mcalpine [2004] ScotCS 11 13 May 2004 OHCS Lady Smith Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Neiliann Margaret Scott Or Mcmillan v James Gerard Mcmillan 14 May 2004 IHCS Lord President And Lord Penrose And Lord Mackay Of Drumadoon Scotland [ ScotC ] Stockton v Procurator Fiscal [2004] ScotHC 29 14 May 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Scott v Mcmillan [2004] ScotCS 138 14 May 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Jeremy Patrick Stockton v Procurator Fiscal, Edinburg 14 May 2004 HCJ Lord Maclean And Sheriff Principal C.G.B. Nicholson Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Mick Rennie v Magnus Norquoy 18 May 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Rennie v Norquoy [2004] ScotSC 36 18 May 2004 SCSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Jones v Leslie [2004] ScotCS 115 19 May 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Distribution Limited v Ds Smith (Uk) Limited 19 May 2004 OHCS Lord Drummond Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Distribution Ltd v Ds Smith (UK) Ltd [2004] ScotCS 116 19 May 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Hutcheson v Procurator Fiscal [2004] ScotHC 30 21 May 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Gazi Ahmed Abdallah Against A Determination of the Immigration Appeal Tribunal Dated 3 October 2002 21 May 2004 IHCS Lord President And Lord Mccluskey And Lady Cosgrove Scotland, Immigration [ ScotC ] Abdallah, Re Against A Determination of the Immigration Appeal Tribunal [2004] ScotCS 139 21 May 2004 ScS Scotland, Immigration [ Bailii ] Brian Hutcheson v Procurator Fiscal, Airdrie 21 May 2004 HCJ Lord Macfadyen And Sheriff Principal C.G.B. Nicholson Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Carole Hope for Exoneration and Discharge [2004] ScotCS 118 21 May 2004 OHCS Lord Bracadale Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Malcolm v Aberdeen City Council [2004] ScotSC 37 21 May 2004 SCSf Scotland [ Bailii ] David Prentice T/A Duns Slaters v Portland Manufacturing Limited [2004] ScotCS 117 21 May 2004 OHCS Lord Clarke And Lord Penrose And Lord President Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] George Stephen Malcolm v Aberdeen City Council 21 May 2004 ScSf Sheriff D.J. Cusine Scotland [ ScotC ] James Brouillard v Her Majesty's Advocate 25 May 2004 HCJ Lord Justice General And Lord Hamilton And Lord Maclean Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Dean Warwick v Alan Green [2004] ScotCS 133 25 May 2004 OHCS Lord Kirkwood And Lord Hamilton And Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Brouillard v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 31 25 May 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Petrit Musaj for Judicial Review of A Decision of the Secretary of State for the Home Office 25 May 2004 OHCS Lady Smith Scotland, Immigration [ ScotC ] Musaj, Re Application for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 119 25 May 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Accountant Bankruptcy v Mackay, [2004] ScotCS 122 26 May 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Accountant In Bankruptcy and Another v Jessie Anne Mackay 26 May 2004 OHCS Lord Bracadale Scotland [ ScotC ] Gordon Connolly Mrs. Ann Teresa Connolly v Neville Stuart Brown 27 May 2004 OHCS Lord Johnston Scotland [ ScotC ] Bashir Ahmad Khan for Judicial Review of A Decision of the Immigration Appeal Tribunal 27 May 2004 OHCS Lord Carloway Scotland, Immigration [ ScotC ] Khan, Re Application for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 125 27 May 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Connolly and Another v Brown [2004] ScotCS 126 27 May 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Registrar of Companies v Stonelee Developments Limited 28 May 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal R.A. Dunlop, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Wedderburn v Buchan and others [2004] ScotCS 128 28 May 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Rankin v Procurator Fiscal [2004] ScotHC 32 1 Jun 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Standard Commercial Property Securities Limited Standard Commercial Property Developments Limited v Glasgow City Council Atlas Investments Limited for Judicial Review of Decisions of Glasgow City Counil [2004] ScotCS 129 1 Jun 2004 OHCS Lady Paton Scotland, Planning, Land Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997 191 1 Cites 1 Citers [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] James Rankin v Procurator Fiscal, Ayr 1 Jun 2004 HCJ Lord Abernethy And Lord Hamilton And Lord Philip Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] James Mcwilliams v Caledonian Wild Foods Limited 1 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Mcewan Scotland [ ScotC ] Mcwilliams v Caledonian Wild Foods [2004] ScotCS 171 1 Jun 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Alistair Matthew v Procurator Fiscal Wick 2 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Marnoch And Lord Hamilton And Sir G.H. Gordon, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Matthew v Procurator Fiscal [2004] ScotHC 33 2 Jun 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] City Leisure (Musselburgh) Ltd, Re Petition for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 130 3 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Gary Mitchell v Procurator Fiscal, Haddington 3 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Hamilton And Lord Marnoch And Sir G.H. Gordon, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Mitchell v Procurator Fiscal [2004] ScotHC 34 3 Jun 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Petition of City Leisure (Musselburgh) Limited for Judicial Review of A Decision of East Lothian Licensing Board 3 Jun 2004 OHCS Lord Emslie Scotland [ ScotC ] ITS Drilling Services v Qualitank Services [2004] ScotSC 40 3 Jun 2004 SCSf Scotland [ Bailii ] City Link Development Co Ltd v Lanarkshire Housing Associated Limited 4 Jun 2004 OHCS Lord Mackay Of Drumadoon Scotland [ ScotC ] Philip Anthony Brogan v O'Rourke Limited and others 4 Jun 2004 OHCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Armlea Plc v the Bank of Scotland and Another [2004] ScotCS 132 4 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] City Link Development Co Ltd v Lanarkshire Housing Associated Ltd [2004] ScotCS 131 4 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Clementina Bonita Rodger (Ap) v Robert Paton (Ap) Brian Docherty Edith Docherty 8 Jun 2004 OHCS Lord Hardie Scotland [ ScotC ] Petition of Mecca Bingo Limited for Judicial Review 8 Jun 2004 OHCS Lord Clarke Scotland [ ScotC ] Wilson v Procurator Fiscal [2004] ScotHC 35 8 Jun 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Rodger v Paton and others [2004] ScotCS 135 8 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Napier v Scotsman Publications Limited [2004] ScotCS 134 8 Jun 2004 OHCS Lady Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Mecca Bingo Ltd, Re Petition for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 136 8 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Robert Lyness Wilson v Procurator Fiscal, Livingston 8 Jun 2004 HCJ Lord Kirkwood And Lord Wheatley And Sheriff Principal C.G.B. Nicholson Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Ocra (Isle of Man) Ltd v Business Computer Technology Ltd [2004] ScotCS 137 9 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Ocra (Isle of Man) Limited v Business Computer Technology Limited 9 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Eassie Scotland [ ScotC ] Clark Advertising Limited v Scottish Enterprise Dunbartonshire [2004] ScotSC 41 9 Jun 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal E.F. Bowen Scotland [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] RB v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 37 9 Jun 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] R.B. v Her Majesty's Advocate 9 Jun 2004 HCJ Lord Abernethy And Lord Hamilton And Lord Philip Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Petition of Lothian and Borders Police v Dr Alison West for Judicial Review 10 Jun 2004 IHCS Lady Paton Scotland [ ScotC ] Lloyds Pharmacy Ltd v The National Appeal Panel and Another [2004] ScotCS 140; 2004 SC 703 11 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland, Health Professions The idea of whether the provision of pharnacy services in an area was adequate was an absolute one. National Health Service (Pharmaceutical Services) (Scotland) Regulations 1995 (1995 SI No 414 5(10) 1 Citers [ Bailii ] John Doyle Construction Ltd v Laing Management (Scotland) Ltd [2004] ScotCS 141 11 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Lloyds Pharmacy Limited v The National Appeal Panel E.A. Baird (N'Ards) Limited 11 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Drummond Young And Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ ScotC ] John Doyle Construction Limited v Laing Management (Scotland) Limited 11 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Drummond Young And Lord Johnston And Lord Maclean Scotland [ ScotC ] Riley v James Beaton and Company (Plumbers) Ltd and others [2004] ScotCS 167 14 Jun 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] David Bain v Her Majesty's Advocate 15 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Cameron Of Lochbroom And Lord Justice General And Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Phillips v Strathclyde Joint Police Board for Judicial Review of A Decision of A Medical Referee 15 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Kirkwood And Lord Mcewan Scotland, Police [ ScotC ] Phillips v Strathclyde Joint Police Board [2004] ScotCS 142 15 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland, Police [ Bailii ] Bain v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 38 15 Jun 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Alister Elwis v Consignia (Formerly Parcelforce Worldwide) [2004] ScotCS 160 16 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Reed Scotland [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Holland v Her Majesty's Advocate; IHCS 16-Jun-2004 - [2004] ScotHC 39 Jackson v Mcdougall [2004] ScotCS 143 16 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Simon John Jackson v Alistair Mcdougall 16 Jun 2004 IHCS J. Gordon Reid, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Donald Brown Johnston v Lorraine Pearl Adams Or Johnston 18 Jun 2004 ScSf Sheriff D.J. Cusine Scotland [ ScotC ] Johnston v Adams [2004] ScotSC 42 18 Jun 2004 SCSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Martin Frost v Cintec International and Another 18 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Carloway Scotland [ ScotC ] William Frederick Ian Beggs for Judicial Review of A Decision To Transfer the Petitioner From Hm Prison Edinburgh To Peterhead [2004] ScotCS 145 18 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Drummond Young Scotland, Crime 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Downhole Technology Limited v Sps Afos International (Branch) Limited 22 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Kirkwood And Lord Philip Scotland [ ScotC ] Petition of Aberdeenshire Council for an Order Freeing the Children A, B and C for Adoption 22 Jun 2004 IHCS Lady Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] Richard Zimmerman v Kevin Armstrong 22 Jun 2004 IHCS Lady Paton Scotland [ ScotC ] A B and C (Children), Re Petition for an Order Freeing the Children for Adoption [2004] ScotCS 147 22 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Bernard Kelly v Her Majesty's Advocate 22 Jun 2004 IHCS Lady Cosgrove And Lord Justice General And Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ ScotC ] Downhole Technology Ltd v Sps Afos International (Branch) Ltd [2004] ScotCS 146 22 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Kelly v Her Majesty's Advocate, [2004] ScotHC 43 22 Jun 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Zimmerman v Armstrong [2004] ScotCS 148 22 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Michael Anthony Beaton v Her Majesty's Advocate 23 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Kirkwood And Lord Hamilton And Lord Johnston Scotland [ ScotC ] L E M Or C v P D C 23 Jun 2004 OHCS Lord Mackay Of Drumadoon Scotland [ ScotC ] Waddell v Peebled Hotel (Hydropathic) Limited [2004] ScotCS 149 23 Jun 2004 IHCS T G Coutts, QC Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Beaton v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 40 23 Jun 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Mackay v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 41 23 Jun 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Lc v Pc [2004] ScotCS 199 23 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Its Drilling Services Limited v Qualitank Services Limited 23 Jun 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Alisdair Mackay v Her Majesty's Advocate 23 Jun 2004 HCJ Lord Justice General And Lord Macfadyen And Lady Cosgrove Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Mcmurray v Cloupet [2003] ScotCS 181 23 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Martin Frost and John Parkes v Cintec International Limited 24 Jun 2004 OHCS R.F.Macdonald, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Frost and Another v Cintec International [2004] ScotCS 183 24 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Callison v Scottish Ministers [2004] ScotCS 155 25 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Cronie and others v Messenger and Another [2004] ScotCS 151 25 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Hyndman v Readman [2004] ScotCS 156 25 Jun 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Petition of Charles Welsh v the Committee of the South Western Social and Recreation Club Limited 25 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Carloway Scotland [ ScotC ] Elizabeth Senga Cronie and others v Norman Craig Messenger James Kelly 25 Jun 2004 IHCS C J Macaulay, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Petition of John Callison v Scottish Ministers for Judicial Review 25 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Drummond Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Carole Hyndman v J C Readman, Former Liquidator 25 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord President And Lady Cosgrove And Lord Mccluskey Scotland [ ScotC ] Atlantic Telecom Gmbh In the Petition of Stephen Pearson and Company As Joint Administrators of the Atlantic Telecom Group 25 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Brodie Scotland [ ScotC ] Dolina Macdonald v West Minch Salmon Limited South Uist Estates Limited 25 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Penrose And Lord Abernethy And Lord Mccluskey Scotland [ ScotC ] Macdonald v West Minch Salmon Ltd and Another [2004] ScotCS 150 25 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Welsh v Committee of the South Western Social and Recreation Club Ltd [2004] ScotCS 154 25 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Gonshaw v Procurator Fiscal [2004] ScotHC 42 25 Jun 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Atlantic Telecom Gmbh, Re [2004] ScotCS 152 25 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Matthew Gonshaw v Procurator Fiscal Lochmaddy 25 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Abernethy And Lord Macfadyen And Lord Osborne Scotland [ ScotC ] Elaine Shaw v Andrew Russell and Another 29 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Carloway Scotland [ ScotC ] King v Procurator Fiscal [2004] ScotHC 44 29 Jun 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Hugh Colin Godfrey Stanley King v Procurator Fiscal Paisley 29 Jun 2004 HCJ Lord Hamilton And Lord Maclean And Sheriff Principal C.G.B. Nicholson Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Shaw v Russell and Another [2004] ScotCS 209 29 Jun 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Crimin v Cairnbay Ltd [2004] ScotCS 157 29 Jun 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Charles Crimin v Cairnbay Limited 29 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Carloway Scotland [ ScotC ] Mohamed Abdel Moneim Ali Fayed Ali Ali Fayed Salah Eldin Ali Fayed for Judicial Review of A Decision By the Commissioners of Inland Revenue 29 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord President And Lord Kirkwood And Lord Maclean Scotland [ ScotC ] Montgomerie v Glasgow Prestwick International Airport Ltd and Another [2004] ScotCS 166 29 Jun 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] William Alexander Montgomerie v Glasgow Prestwick International Airport Limited Gill Aviation Limited 29 Jun 2004 IHCS J. Gordon Reid, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Thomas Brown v The Royal Highland and Agricultural Society of Scotland 30 Jun 2004 IHCS Lord Menzies Scotland [ ScotC ] Brown v Royal Highland and Agricultural Society of Scotland [2004] ScotCS 158 30 Jun 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Murray and Another v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 45 30 Jun 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Robert Wilson Murray Paul James Ryan v Her Majesty's Advocate 30 Jun 2004 IHCS Lady Cosgrove And Lord Hamilton And Lord Justice General Scotland [ ScotC ] North British Trust Hotels Ltd and others v Assessor for the Highland and Western Isles Area [2004] ScotCS 222 30 Jun 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Alvin Lee Sinclair v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 46; 2004 SLT 794 1 Jul 2004 IHCS Lord Justice General And Lord Hamilton And Lord Cameron Of Lochbroom Scotland, Scotland, Crime 1 Citers [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Archibald v Fife Council [2004] UKHL 32; Times, 05 July 2004; [2004] ICR 954; 2004 GWD 23-505; [2004] IRLR 651; 2004 SLT 942; [2004] 4 All ER 303 1 Jul 2004 HL Lord Nicholls of Birkenhead, Lord Hope of Craighead, Lord Rodger of Earlsferry, Baroness Hale of Richmond, Lord Brown of Eaton-under-Heywood Discrimination, Scotland The claimant was employed as a street sweeper. She suffered injury to her health making it difficult to do her work. She was dismissed, and claimed that being disabled, the employer had not made reasonable adjustments to find alternative work for her. The Council had considered her for other posts, but had held competitive interviews at which she did not succeed. Held: The Act entails positive discrimination. Employers are required to take steps to help disabled people which they are not required to take for others. The duty is not simply to make adjustments, but rather one to make adjustments for the purpose specified. The tribunal should have asked itself whether it would have been reasonable for the employer to adjust its competitive interview policy to give effect to its duty to the claimant. The matter would have to be remitted for that consideration. Disability Discrimination Act 1995 - Local Government and Housing Act 1989 7 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ House of Lords ] Alam v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2004] ScotCS 162 1 Jul 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Alvin Lee Sinclair v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 46; 2004 SLT 794 1 Jul 2004 IHCS Lord Justice General And Lord Hamilton And Lord Cameron Of Lochbroom Scotland, Scotland, Crime 1 Citers [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Michelle Gail Miller v Lothian Primary Care NHS Trust [2004] ScotCS 159 1 Jul 2004 IHCS Lord Hardie Scotland [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Mrs. Kathleen Doris Moffat O'Callaghan v John Y Simpson 2 Jul 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal I.D. Macphail, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Thomson v Newey and Eyre Limited and Co [2004] ScotCS 163 2 Jul 2004 IHCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ Bailii ] Woodhouse v Johnston and Another [2004] ScotCS 161 2 Jul 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Joan Pentland-Clark v John H Macfie W.S. Gordon Innes 2 Jul 2004 IHCS Lord Hardie Scotland [ ScotC ] Elizabeth Mary Woodhouse v Wright Johnston and Mackenzie 2 Jul 2004 IHCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Pentland-Clark v Macfie [2004] ScotCS 165 2 Jul 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Petition and Answers By Mohammed Khorshejul Alam v the Secretary of State for the Home Department 2 Jul 2004 IHCS Lady Cosgrove And Lord Kirkwood And Lord Eassie Scotland [ ScotC ] Elabas, Re Petition for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 164 2 Jul 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] O'Callaghan v Simpson [2004] ScotSC 43 2 Jul 2004 SCSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Petition of Mutas Elabas for Judicial Review of A Special Adjudicator and Immigration Appeal Tribunal 2 Jul 2004 IHCS Lord Reed Scotland, Immigration [ ScotC ] Ege Endustrive Ticaret v Albion Automotive Limited [2004] ScotCS 168 7 Jul 2004 IHCS Lord Clarke Scotland [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Mcadam v Procurator Fiscal [2004] ScotHC 36 8 Jul 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Skinner v Scottish Ambulance Service [2004] ScotCS 176 8 Jul 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] S v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeal Panel and Another [2004] ScotCS 263 8 Jul 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] S v CICB Etc and Another [2004] ScotCS 172 8 Jul 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Iain Henry Skinner v Scottish Ambulance Service 8 Jul 2004 IHCS Lord Marnoch And Lord Macfadyen And Sir David Edward Scotland [ ScotC ] Kelly v Cox Glasgow City Council 8 Jul 2004 IHCS Lord Hamilton And Lord Menzies And Lord President Scotland [ ScotC ] Gerard Pelosi Ninette Pelosi Adrian Pelosi Anthony Pelosi v Tino Luca Michael Andrew Luca 8 Jul 2004 IHCS Lord Mcewan Scotland [ ScotC ] S. v C.I.C.B. Etc Advocate General 8 Jul 2004 IHCS Lord Mcewan Scotland [ ScotC ] Nancy Mcadam v Procurator Fiscal, Dingwall 8 Jul 2004 IHCS Lord Abernethy And Lord Marnoch And Sheriff Principal C.G.B. Nicholson Scotland [ ScotC ] Kelly v Cox and Another [2004] ScotCS 175 8 Jul 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] James Mcgregor Fairlie v Perth and Kinross Healthcare NHS Trust [2004] ScotCS 174 8 Jul 2004 IHCS Lord Kingarth Scotland, Human Rights A claim for damages might perhaps have been pleaded under article 8 of the European Convention, but since the pursuer's claim was in effect for loss of reputation, the claim in negligence was bound to fail even if the judge had not held, as he did in para 30 of his judgment, that no duty of care was owed to the father. 1 Cites 1 Citers [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Pelosi and others v Luca and Another [2004] ScotCS 173 8 Jul 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Craig Charles Smith v Her Majesty's Advocate 9 Jul 2004 IHCS Lord Mackay Of Drumadoon And Lord Penrose Scotland [ ScotC ] Robert Bruce Wright for Judicial Review of A Decision of the Scottish Ministers 9 Jul 2004 IHCS Lord Hardie Scotland [ ScotC ] Wright, Re Application for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 169 9 Jul 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Gavin Reekie v Eileen Reekie 9 Jul 2004 IHCS R.F.Macdonald, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Connelly v G Group Ltd and Another [2004] ScotSC 44 9 Jul 2004 SCSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Reekie v Reekie [2004] ScotCS 170 9 Jul 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Robert Connelly v G A Group Ltd Stiell Facilities Ltd 9 Jul 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal E.F. Bowen Scotland [ ScotC ] Denise Lamont (Qua Next of Kin of the Late Andrew Lamont) v Christine Ann Fallon (Ap) (Qua Next of Kin of the Late Andrew Lamont) [2004] ScotCS 177 13 Jul 2004 IHCS Lady Smith Scotland, Personal Injury [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Sean Petrie v Dundee City Council 13 Jul 2004 ScSf Sheriff F.R. Crowe Scotland [ ScotC ] Fallon and Another v Lamont and others [2004] ScotCS 184 13 Jul 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Petrie v Dundee City Council [2004] ScotSC 46 13 Jul 2004 SCSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Neil Mckie v Jack Robinson (Trawlers) Limited 13 Jul 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Darren Mair (Ap) v Darron Payne the Motor Insurers' Bureau [2004] ScotCS 178 13 Jul 2004 IHCS Lady Smith Scotland, Personal Injury [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] McKie v Jack Robinson (Trawlers) Ltd [2004] ScotSC 45 13 Jul 2004 SCSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Magell Limited v Dumfries and Galloway Regional Assessor [2004] ScotCS 179 15 Jul 2004 IHCS Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Clarke And Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland, Rating [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] The Royal Bank of Scotland Plc v Kenneth Fraser Lyon Maureen Douglas Lyon 20 Jul 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Royal Bank Scotland Plc v Lyon and Another [2004] ScotSC 47 20 Jul 2004 SCSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Douglas Fergusson Stewart Forbes v Brands Development (Worldwide) Limited Euan Coutts Shand 20 Jul 2004 ScSf Sheriff Annella M Cowan Scotland [ ScotC ] Forbes v Brands Development (Worldwide) Ltd and Another [2004] ScotSC 48 20 Jul 2004 SCSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Petition of Norman Robert Duncan v the Scottish Ministers for Judicial Review 20 Jul 2004 OHCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ ScotC ] McRitchie v The Scottish Ministers [2004] ScotSC 49 21 Jul 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal I.D. Macphail, Q.C. Scotland, Personal Injury 1 Cites [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] APC Limited (In Receivership) v Amey Construction Limited Sir Robert Mcalpine Limited Taylor Woodrow Civil Engineering Limited Barr Limited 23 Jul 2004 OHCS Lord Mackay Of Drumadoon Scotland [ ScotC ] Rs v Pq [2004] ScotCS 217 23 Jul 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Diana Fox Flynn v City of Glasgow Council 23 Jul 2004 ScSf Sheriff C A L Scott Scotland [ ScotC ] Andrew Matthews v Glasgow City Council 23 Jul 2004 ScSf Sheriff C A L Scott Scotland 1 Citers [ ScotC ] James Greig v DTZ Management Services Ltd EATS/0033/04; [2004] UKEAT 0033 - 04 - 2707 27 Jul 2004 EAT His Honour Judge Mcmullen QC Discrimination, Employment, Scotland EAT Disability Discrimination - Disability 1 Cites [ Bailii ] - [ EATn ] the Scottish Coal Company Ltd, Re Petition for Suspension and Interdict [2004] ScotCS 186 29 Jul 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Petition of the Scottish Coal Company Limited for Suspension and Interdict 29 Jul 2004 OHCS Lord Bracadale Scotland [ ScotC ] The Standard Life Assurance Company and Another v North Lanarkshire Council 29 Jul 2004 OHCS Lord Carloway Scotland [ ScotC ] The Standard Life Assurance Company and Another v North Lanarkshire Council [2004] ScotCS 187 29 Jul 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Ryan and others v Fairfield Rowan Ltd [2004] ScotCS 185 29 Jul 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Agnes Mcdonald Ryan and others v Fairfield Rowan Limited 29 Jul 2004 OHCS Lord Drummond Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Spence v Murray and others [2004] ScotCS 194 30 Jul 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] W S Karoulias Sa v Drambuie Liqueur Company [2004] ScotCS 189 30 Jul 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Ross and Another v Pryde [2004] ScotCS 195 30 Jul 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Roberts v Chisholm [2004] ScotCS 188 30 Jul 2004 OHCS Lady Paton Scotland [ Bailii ] David Mcmullan v Sister Bernard Mary Murray and others 30 Jul 2004 OHCS Lord Johnston Scotland [ ScotC ] Robert Campbell Ross, Kathleen Ross v Graham Pryde 30 Jul 2004 OHCS R.F.Macdonald, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Clark v Scott Lithgow Limited [2004] ScotCS 191 30 Jul 2004 SCS J Gordon Reid, QC Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Jacqueline Pringle Or Whitton v Sister Bernard Mary Murray and others 30 Jul 2004 OHCS Lord Johnston Scotland [ ScotC ] W S Karoulias Sa v the Drambuie Liqueur Company Limited 30 Jul 2004 OHCS Lord Clarke Scotland [ ScotC ] Nigel Mckenzie (Ap) and others v The Scottish Ministers [2004] ScotCS 196 2 Aug 2004 OHCS Lord Carloway Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Peter Kelly v Smith Anderson and Company Limited [2004] ScotCS 197 3 Aug 2004 OHCS R.F.Macdonald, Q.C. Scotland [ Bailii ] North Lanarkshire Council v Sexton [2004] ScotSC 50 3 Aug 2004 SCSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Scott Robert Morton Miller Agnes Miller v Procurator Fiscal, Falkirk 3 Aug 2004 OHCS Lady Cosgrove And Lord Marnoch And Lord Mcewan Scotland [ ScotC ] Johnston, Re an Order for Rectification of the Register of Members of Wind Save Ltd [2004] ScotCS 228 5 Aug 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] James Brownlee Johnston for an Order for Rectification of the Register of Members of Wind Save Limited 5 Aug 2004 OHCS R.F.Macdonald, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Vaughan v Procurator Fiscal [2004] ScotHC 50 6 Aug 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Barlow v City of Edinburgh Council [2004] ScotSC 51 6 Aug 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Andrew Barlow v City of Edinburgh Council 6 Aug 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal I.D. Macphail, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Stephen Vaughan v Procurator Fiscal, Perth 6 Aug 2004 IHCS Lady Cosgrove And Lord Mcewan And Lord Maclean Scotland [ ScotC ] Secretary State Work Pensions v Cunningham [2004] ScotCS 211 6 Aug 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Mcclelland v Stuart Building Services, A Partnership, Stuart, and Stuart, the Partners Thereof As Such Partners and As Individuals [2004] ScotCS 200 6 Aug 2004 OHCS Lord President Scotland 1 Cites [ Bailii ] Reference By the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission In the Case of Brian Kelly 6 Aug 2004 HCJ Lord Justice General Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Secretary of State for Work and Pensions v A Decision of the Deputy Social Security Commissioner of 19Th February 2003 In Application for A Disability Living Allowance By Helen Cunningham 6 Aug 2004 OHCS Lord Cameron Of Lochbroom And Lord Marnoch And Lord Osborne Scotland [ ScotC ] Kelly, Re Reference By Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission [2004] ScotHC 47 6 Aug 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Irvine v Dundee City Council [2004] ScotSC 52 9 Aug 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Her Majesty's Advocate v Robert Campbell John Wallace Joseph Wright Kevin Michael Connolly Patricia Slaven Kirsty Campbell [2004] ScotHC 48 9 Aug 2004 HCJ Lord Hardie Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Matthew James Moran Irvine v Dundee City Council 9 Aug 2004 ScSf Sheriff F.R. Crowe Scotland [ ScotC ] E v E [2004] ScotSC 53 12 Aug 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] E v E 12 Aug 2004 ScSf Sheriff F.R. Crowe Scotland [ ScotC ] Lannigan v Glasgow City Council [2004] ScotCS 201 12 Aug 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] David Lannigan v Glasgow City Council 12 Aug 2004 OHCS R.F.Macdonald, Q.C. Scotland, Negligence, Education, Limitation The pursuer said the teachers employed by the defendant had failed to identify that was dyslexic, leading him to suffer damage. The defenders said the claim was time barred, which the pursuer admitted, but then said that the claim ought to go ahead under the court's equitable discretion. Held: After reviewing the authorities, the onus was on the pursuer to satisfy the court that it is equitable to allow him to bring the action notwithstanding that it is time-barred. 'This was a case where the responsibility for the action not having been raised in time rests entirely with the pursuer as responsible for the first agents, that he has a remedy against them if he is not allowed to bring this action out of time and that, if he were allowed to bring the action out of time, the defenders would be prejudiced by losing their statutory defence and having to prepare for and contest a lengthy proof, the expenses of which they may not recover even if successful.' The application was denied. Limitation Act 1980 19A 1 Cites [ ScotC ] Iseabal Emslie v Anne Bell [2004] ScotCS 202 12 Aug 2004 OHCS Lord Menzies Scotland, Personal Injury, Damages The defender had driven into the back of the pursuer's car, causing the injuries. She claimed that the accident had aggravated a pre-existing slight injury to her knee. Held: The pursuer's accounts of her injuries had not been entirely consistent. Damages were calculated for solatium at a level between that contended for by either party. 1 Cites [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] AJ for Declarator Under the Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985 [2004] ScotCS 203 13 Aug 2004 OHCS Lady Paton Scotland, Children Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985 [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] X v Y and others [2004] ScotSC 54 16 Aug 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] X v Y and others 16 Aug 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal I.D. Macphail, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Robina Malik v Niamat Ali [2004] ScotCS 205 17 Aug 2004 OHCS Lady Cosgrove And Lord President And Lord Wheatley Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Stephen Davidson and Another v the Kilwinning Homing Society and others [2004] ScotCS 204 17 Aug 2004 OHCS Lord Kirkwood And Lord Hamilton And Lord President Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Alfred Anjalans for Statutory Review of A Decision of the Immigration Appeals Tribunal Dated 22 March 2004 To Refuse Permission To Appeal [2004] ScotCS 206 18 Aug 2004 OHCS Lord Brodie Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Harold Channer Alexander v Metbro Limited Shipbreaking Industries Limited [2004] ScotCS 207 19 Aug 2004 OHCS Lady Paton Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Her Majesty's Advocate v Thomas Macdonald Macpherson 19 Aug 2004 HCJ Lord Justice General And Lord Maclean And Lord Osborne Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Her Majesty's Advocate v Macpherson [2004] ScotHC 51 19 Aug 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] the Lord Advocate v Murray [2004] ScotHC 52 20 Aug 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Allied Dunbar Assurance Plc v Superglass Sections Limited 20 Aug 2004 OHCS Lord Eassie Scotland, Commercial [ ScotC ] Mccollum Or Abernethy v Sister Bernard Mary Murray and others [2004] ScotCS 208 20 Aug 2004 OHCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ Bailii ] The Lord Advocate v Paul Francis Murray 20 Aug 2004 HCJ Lord Justice General And Lord Maclean And Lord Osborne Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Richardson and others v Rivers [2004] ScotSC 55 23 Aug 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Richardson and others v Rivers 23 Aug 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal I.D. Macphail, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Morrison v Key Housing Association EATS/0107/03; [2004] UKEAT 0107 - 03 - 2308 23 Aug 2004 EAT The Honourable Lord Johnston Discrimination, Employment, Scotland EAT Disability Discrimination - Disability 1 Cites [ Bailii ] - [ EATn ] Glasgow Housing Association v O'Donnell [2004] ScotSC 56 24 Aug 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] the Glasgow Housing Association v John O'Donnell 24 Aug 2004 ScSf Sheriff W. Holligan Scotland [ ScotC ] Singh v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 54 25 Aug 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Harpal Singh v Her Majesty's Advocate 25 Aug 2004 HCJ Lord Justice General And Lord Macfadyen And Lord Osborne Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Brash and Another v Boyce [2004] ScotCS 210 26 Aug 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Ian Brash Mrs. Susan Brash v Fiona Boyce 26 Aug 2004 OHCS C J Macaulay, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] the Procurator Fiscal, Dingwall v Robbie the Pict, Old Schoolyard, Dunvegan, Isle of Skye 27 Aug 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Chakal v Procurator Fiscal [2004] ScotHC 55 27 Aug 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Bulent Chakal v Procurator Fiscal Edinburgh 27 Aug 2004 OHCS Lord Maclean And Lord Hamilton And Sheriff Principal C.G.B. Nicholson Scotland [ ScotC ] Procurator Fiscal, Dingwall v Robbie the Pict [2004] ScotSC 57 27 Aug 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Iain Fairley v Robert Thomson 28 Aug 2004 ScSf Sheriff J. Douglas Allan Scotland [ ScotC ] Under the Fatal Accidents and Sudden Deahts Inquiry (Scotland) Act 1975 Determination Into the Circumstances of the Death of Liu Jin Wu 28 Aug 2004 ScSf Sheriff W.J. Totten Scotland, Coroners [ ScotC ] Fairley v Thomson [2004] ScotSC 58 28 Aug 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Iain Fairley v Robert Thomson 2 Sep 2004 ScSf Sheriff J. Douglas Allan Scotland [ ScotC ] Fairley v Thomson [2004] ScotSC 59 2 Sep 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Mackie v Procurator Fiscal [2004] ScotHC 56 2 Sep 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Mackie v Procurator Fiscal, Linlithgow 2 Sep 2004 IHCS Lord Macfadyen And Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] Leslie Brown for Judicial Review of the Decision of the Scottish Ministers [2004] ScotCS 212 3 Sep 2004 OHCS Lord Abernethy Scotland [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Rutco Incorporated v Jamieson and Another [2004] ScotCS 213 7 Sep 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Rutco Incorporated v Peter Lindsay Auld Jo Jamieson and Another 7 Sep 2004 OHCS Lord Kingarth Scotland [ ScotC ] Hallam Land Management Limited v George Nimmo Perratt and Another [2004] ScotCS 214 10 Sep 2004 OHCS Lord Maclean And Lord Hamilton And Lord Brodie Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Maureen Benson v City of Edinburgh District Council [2004] ScotCS 215 14 Sep 2004 OHCS J. Gordon Reid, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Transco Plc v Her Majesty's Advocates; HCJ 16-Sep-2004 - [2004] ScotHC 57; [2004] ScotHC 68 Adams v Thorntons WS and others [2004] ScotCS 216 17 Sep 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Robert Barry and Company v Gallery and Another [2004] ScotSC 60 17 Sep 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Robert Barry and Company v Dunstan Gallery Patricia Gallery 17 Sep 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal B A Kerr Scotland [ ScotC ] John Don Adams v Thorntons, Ws and others 17 Sep 2004 OHCS Lord Marnoch And Lord Penrose And Sir David Edward Scotland [ ScotC ] Robb v Gillan [2004] ScotSC 61 20 Sep 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal R.A. Dunlop, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Shona Scott Barns Or Mccaskill v Douglas Glen Mccaskill 22 Sep 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal I.D. Macphail, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Prudential Assurance v John Gibson Trading As John Gibson Financial Services 22 Sep 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal I.D. Macphail, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Prudential Assurance v Gibson (T/A John Gibson Financial Services) [2004] ScotSC 62 22 Sep 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Barns Or Mccaskill v Mccaskill [2004] ScotSC 63 22 Sep 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] NDT Eye Limited v Servtech Limited [2004] ScotSC 64 23 Sep 2004 ScSf Sheriff D.J. Cusine Scotland [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Her Majesty's Advocate v J.T. 24 Sep 2004 IHCS Lady Cosgrove And Lord Hamilton And Lord Justice General Scotland [ ScotC ] Her Majesty's Advocate v J.T. [2004] ScotHC 58 24 Sep 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Capello v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions [2004] ScotCS 219 28 Sep 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Gordon v Bald [2004] ScotSC 65 28 Sep 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Dominic Capello v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions for Judicial Review of A Decision of A Social Security Commissioner To Refuse Leave To Appeal 28 Sep 2004 OHCS Lady Paton Scotland, Benefits [ ScotC ] David Wood v Lothian and Borders Fire Board 28 Sep 2004 OHCS Lord Hardie Scotland [ ScotC ] Adam Alexander Gordon v Willie Bald, Assistant Chief Constable, Tayside Police 28 Sep 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal R.A. Dunlop, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Wood v Lothian and Borders Fire Board [2004] ScotCS 218 28 Sep 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Spring Salmon and Seafood Limited v Wisco Processing Limited Pieters Visbedrijf Nv Fjord Seafood Chile Sa 29 Sep 2004 OHCS Lord Clarke Scotland [ ScotC ] Graham Gordon v Her Majesty's Advocate 29 Sep 2004 HCJ Lord Justice General And Lord Penrose And Lord Hamilton Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Gordon v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 59 29 Sep 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Spring Salmon and Seafood Ltd v Wisco Processing Ltd and others [2004] ScotCS 220 29 Sep 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Richard Wilhelm Karling (Ap) v Dr Basil Nigel Purdue [2004] ScotCS 221; 2005 SCLR 43 29 Sep 2004 OHCS J. Gordon Reid, Q.C. Scotland 1 Cites [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] UPS Supply Chain Solutions v Glasgow Airport Limited 1 Oct 2004 OHCS Lord Clarke Scotland [ ScotC ] Ups Supply Chain Solutions v Glasgow Airport Ltd [2004] ScotCS 225 1 Oct 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Ups Supply Chain Solutions v Glasgow Airport Ltd [2004] ScotCS 223 1 Oct 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Gillies and others v Lynch and others [2004] ScotCS 224 5 Oct 2004 OHCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ Bailii ] Stronachs Corporate v Mountwest 166 Ltd [2004] ScotSC 101 7 Oct 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Stronachs Corporate v Mountwest 166 Ltd [2005] ScotSC 53 7 Oct 2004 SCSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Pettigrew v Tilbury Douglas Construction Ltd [2004] ScotCS 226 7 Oct 2004 ScS Scotland, Personal Injury [ Bailii ] Stronachs Corporate v Mountwest 166 Ltd [2004] ScotSC 90 7 Oct 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] William Allan Pettigrew v Tilbury Douglas Construction Limited &C 7 Oct 2004 OHCS Lord Mcewan Scotland [ ScotC ] Philip Craig Johnson (Ap) v Amalgamated Construction Company Limited the Scottish Coal Company Limited [2004] ScotCS 227 8 Oct 2004 OHCS Lady Paton Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] M.M. v Her Majesty Advocate [2004] ScotHC 60 11 Oct 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] M.M. v Her Majesty Advocate 11 Oct 2004 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Johnston And Lord Osborne Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Gonshaw v Procurator Fiscal Lochmaddy 12 Oct 2004 HCJ Lord Justice General And Lord Macfadyen And Lord Osborne Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Gonshaw v Procurator Fiscal [2004] ScotHC 61 12 Oct 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Flynn and others v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 62 14 Oct 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Flynn, Mitchell Meek John Gary Nicol Peter Mcmurray v Her Majesty's Advocate 14 Oct 2004 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Maclean And Lord Penrose And Lord Osborne And Lord Macfadyen Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Lothian and Borders Police Board v Robert Macdonald for Judicial Review of A Medical Certificate Under Regulation H2, of the Police Pension Regulations 1987 14 Oct 2004 OHCS Lord Reed Scotland [ ScotC ] Barrie (T/A Barrdrum Tractors) v Alex Butter Landscaping Ltd [2004] ScotSC 66 14 Oct 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Lothian and Borders Police Board v Macdonald [2004] ScotCS 229 14 Oct 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] P C and R C v L K and G K 15 Oct 2004 ScSf Sheriff K.A. Mclernan Scotland [ ScotC ] Pc and Another v Lk and Another [2004] ScotSC 67 15 Oct 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Baker Hughes Limited Baker Hughes Inteq France S.A. for A Winding Up Order In Respect of CCG Contracting International Limited 15 Oct 2004 OHCS Lady Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] Glasgow City Council v C Bvunzai EATS/0004/04; [2004] UKEAT 0004 - 04 - 1810; EATS/0015/04 18 Oct 2004 EAT The Honourable Lord Johnston Discrimination, Employment, Scotland EAT Race Discrimination - Direct 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ EATn ] Hunt v British Bakeries Ltd [2004] ScotCS 231 20 Oct 2004 SCS Lady Smith Scotland Outer House [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Dn v Lj and Another [2004] ScotSC 68 21 Oct 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Allison v Procurator Fiscal [2004] ScotHC 63 21 Oct 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] George Alexander Moggach v Margaret Jane Milne 22 Oct 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Moggach v Milne [2004] ScotSC 69 22 Oct 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Ja v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 64 22 Oct 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Melville Dundas Ltd (In Receivership) Dempster, Merchant v George Wimpey UK Limited, Norwich Union Insurance Ltd 22 Oct 2004 OHCS Lord Clarke Scotland 1 Citers [ ScotC ] James Morris (Ap) v Fife Council 22 Oct 2004 OHCS Lord Maclean And Lord Kingarth And Lord Osborne Scotland [ ScotC ] Commissioners of Inland Revenue v Anchor International Limited 22 Oct 2004 OHCS Lord Kirkwood And Lord Maclean And Lord Osborne Scotland [ ScotC ] J A v Her Majesty's Advocate 22 Oct 2004 HCJ Lord Hamilton And Lord Mackay Of Drumadoon Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Rosalind Watson v Procurator Fiscal, Perth 26 Oct 2004 HCJ Lord Philip And Lord Marnoch And Sheriff Principal C.G.B. Nicholson Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] William Bryson v Procurator Fiscal, Kilmarnock 26 Oct 2004 HCJ Lord Penrose And Lord Mackay Of Drumadoon Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Watson v Procurator Fiscal [2004] ScotHC 65 26 Oct 2004 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Cruickshank Or Zakeri Dehvasati (Ap) v Gholam Hossein Zakeri Dehvasati [2004] ScotCS 233 27 Oct 2004 OHCS Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Kingarth And Lord Osborne Scotland 1 Cites [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Taylor v The Scottish Ministers 27 Oct 2004 OHCS Lord Bracadale Scotland [ ScotC ] S v S for an Order Under the Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985 27 Oct 2004 OHCS Lord Kingarth Scotland, Children Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985 [ ScotC ] Taylor v the Scottish Ministers [2004] ScotCS 232 27 Oct 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Catherine Sharp Or Chisholm &C v Colin Wardrope and others 28 Oct 2004 OHCS Lord Emslie Scotland [ ScotC ] Macisaac v Mills [2004] ScotSC 70 28 Oct 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Sharp v Wardrope and others [2004] ScotCS 234 28 Oct 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] MacIsaac Qua Guardian for Langa v Mills 28 Oct 2004 ScSf Sheriff D.W. Mcintyre Scotland [ ScotC ] Kamall Ahmed v The Highland Council 1 Nov 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Colin Mckay v Lloyds TSB Mortgages Limited [2004] ScotCS 237 2 Nov 2004 OHCS R.F.Macdonald, Q.C. Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] The Governor and Company of the Bank of Scotland v Mrs. Brigitte Kunkel-Griffin [2004] ScotCS 236 2 Nov 2004 OHCS Lord Emslie Scotland 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Her Majesty's Advocate v Raymond Booth 3 Nov 2004 HCJ Lord Justice General And Lord Johnston And Lord Penrose Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Hojgaard v Forth Estuary Transport Authority [2004] ScotCS 239 3 Nov 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Christopher Dudley v Her Majesty's Advocate 3 Nov 2004 HCJ Lord Justice General And Lord Johnston And Lord Penrose Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Mt Hojgaard A/S v Forth Estuary Transport Authority 3 Nov 2004 OHCS Lord Eassie Scotland [ ScotC ] Glasgow Housing Association Limited v David Sharkey 4 Nov 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal E.F. Bowen Scotland [ ScotC ] Jackson v City of Edinburgh Council [2004] ScotCS 240 4 Nov 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] William Gordon Jackson v City of Edinburgh Council 4 Nov 2004 OHCS J. Gordon Reid, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Glasgow Housing Association Ltd v Sharkey [2004] ScotSC 71 4 Nov 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Kelly Banks v Cgu Insurance Plc 5 Nov 2004 OHCS Lady Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] Banks v CGU Insurance Plc [2004] ScotCS 241 5 Nov 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Application for Leave To Appeal Under Section 37 of the Employment Tribunals Act 1996 By Susan Fraser v The Scottish Ambulance Service 5 Nov 2004 OHCS Lord Nimmo Smith And Lord Osborne And Lord Reed Scotland, Employment [ ScotC ] Fraser v Scottish Ambulance Service, Re Application for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 250 5 Nov 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Ralston v Scottish Ministers for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 242 5 Nov 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Samuel Ralston (Ap) v the Scottish Ministers for Judicial Review 5 Nov 2004 OHCS Lady Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] Smith v Scottish Ministers and others [2004] ScotCS 243 8 Nov 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Murdock and Another v Mcqueen [2004] ScotSC 72 8 Nov 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Mr. Brian Murdock Dr. Nicola Kim Murdock v Mrs. Heather Mcqueen 8 Nov 2004 ScSf Sheriff G.J. Evans Scotland [ ScotC ] William Smith v the Scottish Ministers the City of Glasgow Council Scottish Enterprise Peel Holdings Plc Clydeport Operators Limited 8 Nov 2004 OHCS Lord Osborne And Lord Kingarth And Lord Drummond Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Jack Telfer and others v Alan Shields Kellock 10 Nov 2004 OHCS Lady Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] John Sexton Maureen Allan v Marco Coia Carmela Rosina Coia 10 Nov 2004 OHCS Lord Emslie Scotland [ ScotC ] Humphrey v Royal and Sun Alliance Plc [2004] ScotSC 73 10 Nov 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Telfer and others v Kellock [2004] ScotCS 245 10 Nov 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Alan Paul Humphrey v Royal and Sun Alliance Plc 10 Nov 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Moir v Her Majesty's Advocate (Devolution) [2004] UKPC D2 11 Nov 2004 PC Scotland [ Bailii ] M, Re A Petition for an Order [2004] ScotCS 246 11 Nov 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Petition of M for an Order Under the Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985 11 Nov 2004 OHCS Lady Smith Scotland, Children Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985 [ ScotC ] Heyder v Lochridge Ltd [2004] ScotSC 74 12 Nov 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Werner Heyder v Lochridge Limited 12 Nov 2004 ScSf Sheriff N. Mcpartlin Scotland [ ScotC ] Purac Limited v Byzak Limited 12 Nov 2004 OHCS Lord Drummond Young Scotland, Commercial [ ScotC ] Purac Ltd v Byzak Ltd [2004] ScotCS 247 12 Nov 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] John Mayer, Advocate v Her Majesty's Advocate [2004] ScotHC 67 16 Nov 2004 HCJ Lord Abernethy And Lord Hamilton And Lord Penrose Crime, Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] William Hill Organisation Ltd v Glasgow Licensing Board [2004] ScotCS 279 16 Nov 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Caledonia Subsea Limited v Micoperi Srl [2004] ScotCS 274 16 Nov 2004 OHCS Lord Mackay Of Drumadoon Scotland, Commercial 1 Cites [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] William Hill Organisation Ltd v City Of Glasgow Licensing Board &C 16 Nov 2004 OHCS Lord Osborne And Lord Maclean And Lord Kingarth Scotland [ ScotC ] Oliver v John R Weir Ltd [2004] UKEAT 0042 - 05 - 1811 18 Nov 2004 EAT Employment, Scotland EAT The appellant was unsuccessful in his appeal. The respondents lodged an application for an award of expenses under and in terms of Rule 34 and 34A of the Employment Appeal Tribunal Rules 1993. Parties were agreed that the application should be determined on the basis of written submissions. The Employment Appeal Tribunal determined that it should not exercise its discretion to award expenses. It could not be said that the appeal was unnecessary or misconceived. [ Bailii ] Whitbread Group Plc v Goldapple Limited 19 Nov 2004 OHCS Lord Drummond Young Scotland [ ScotC ] ITP Sa v Coflexip Stena Offshore Limited 19 Nov 2004 OHCS Lord President And Lord Macfadyen And Sir David Edward Scotland 1 Citers [ ScotC ] Royal Scottish Assurance Plc v Scottish Equitable Plc 19 Nov 2004 OHCS Lord Bracadale Scotland [ ScotC ] Royal Scottish Assurance Plc v Scottish Equitable Plc [2004] ScotCS 248 19 Nov 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Mario F Lamarra v Capital Bank Plc Shields Automotive Llimited 22 Nov 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal John Mcinnes, Qc Scotland [ ScotC ] Lamarra v Capital Bank Plc and Another [2004] ScotSC 75 22 Nov 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Perth and Kinross Council v Anne Scott [2004] ScotCS 249 22 Nov 2004 OHCS Lady Smith Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Morgan v Dumfries and Galloway Actue Maternity Hospitals NHS Trust [2004] ScotCS 251 23 Nov 2004 OHCS Lord Drummond Young Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Porter v Her Majesty's Advocate 23 Nov 2004 HCJ Lord Kirkwood And Lord Penrose And Lord Wheatley Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Robson v The Council of the Law Society of Scotland and Another [2004] ScotCS 252 24 Nov 2004 ScS Scotland, Legal Professions [ Bailii ] Robson v The Council of the Law Society of Scotland the Scottish Solicitors Discipline Tribunal 24 Nov 2004 OHCS Lord Maclean And Lord Kirkwood And Lord Osborne Scotland, Legal Professions [ ScotC ] John Macinnes v Antonia Lloyd Owen 24 Nov 2004 OHCS C J Macaulay, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Macinnes v Owen [2004] ScotCS 253 24 Nov 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Ailsa Cunningham v M. 25 Nov 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal I.D. Macphail, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Caterleisure Ltd v Glasgow Prestwick International Airport Ltd [2004] ScotCS 255 25 Nov 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Shakespeare Mahechani v Scottish Ambulance Service [2004] ScotCS 254 25 Nov 2004 OHCS Lord Hamilton And Lord Reed And Lord Weir Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Caterleisure Limited v Glasgow Prestwick International Airport Limited 25 Nov 2004 OHCS Lord Mackay Of Drumadoon Scotland [ ScotC ] Cunningham v M [2004] ScotSC 76 25 Nov 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Wallace Bradford Kidd 26 Nov 2004 ScSf Sheriff G C Kavanagh Scotland, Coroners [ ScotC ] Midlothian Council v George Corolla 26 Nov 2004 OHCS Lord Carloway Scotland [ ScotC ] Midlothian Council v Corolla [2004] ScotCS 256 26 Nov 2004 ScS Scotland [ Bailii ] Bennett v Bennett (No 1) [2004] ScotSC 78 29 Nov 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Bennett v Bennett (No 2) [2004] ScotSC 77 29 Nov 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Robert Anderson Bennett v Mrs. Mona Issa Bennett 29 Nov 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Robert Anderson Bennett v Mrs. Mona Issa Bennett 29 Nov 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Claire Macleod Or Chalmers v Procurator Fiscal, Perth 30 Nov 2004 HCJ Lord Hamilton And Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Osborne Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] William Watt v Santa Fe International Services Incorporated 30 Nov 2004 ScSf Sheriff D.J. Cusine Scotland [ ScotC ] Watt v Santa Fe International Services Incorporated [2004] ScotSC 79 30 Nov 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Margaret Arthur John James Arthur v Peter Paul Arthur 1 Dec 2004 ScSf Sheriff J. Baird Scotland [ ScotC ] Arthur and Another v Arthur [2004] ScotSC 80 1 Dec 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Keith Anderson v Procurator Fiscal, Perth 1 Dec 2004 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Hamilton And Lord Osborne Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Assessor for Lanarkshire Valuation Joint Board Assessor for Renfrewshire Valuation Joint Board v Clydesdale Bank Plc Marks and Spencer Plc Marks and Spencer Plc 1 Dec 2004 OHCS Lord Clarke And Lord Kingarth And Lord Justice Clerk Scotland, Rating [ ScotC ] Kelly and others v Stoddart Sekers International Plc [2004] ScotCS 258 2 Dec 2004 SCS R.F.Macdonald, QC Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Clarke v Fennoscandia Limited Freakley, Phillips [2004] ScotCS 257; 2004 SC 197 2 Dec 2004 OHCS Lord Clarke And Lord Menzies And Lord Justice Clerk Scotland, Torts - Other The claimant had said that the defendants conspired to deny him the presidency of a company. He lost his case in the US, and the defendants chased him for costs. He asserted that the US judgment had been obtained by fraud. The defendants undertook not to seek furter enforcement of their costs. 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] GMD v YMSC [2004] ScotSC 100 2 Dec 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Johnson, Re Application for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 280 3 Dec 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Mcleannan (Tay Square Properties Ltd) [2004] ScotCS 262 3 Dec 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Db, Re Petition for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS CSOH - P252 3 Dec 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] DB, Re Petition for Judicial Review [1988] ScotCS CSOH - P252 3 Dec 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Db, Re Petition for Judicial Review [1988] ScotCS SCOH - P252 - 03 3 Dec 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Petition of Dogan Berktas for Judicial Review 3 Dec 2004 OHCS R.F.Macdonald, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Berktas, Re Petition for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 261 3 Dec 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Petition of Helen Johnson (Ap) for Judicial Review 3 Dec 2004 OHCS R.F.Macdonald, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Thomas Campbell Mcleannan Tay Square Properties Limited for an Order Under Section 236 of the Insolvency Act 1986 3 Dec 2004 OHCS Lady Paton Scotland, Insolvency Insolvency Act 1986 236 [ ScotC ] William Mcmillan Bennett v Her Majesty's Advocate 4 Dec 2004 HCJ Lord Kirkwood And Lord Carloway And Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] David Craig v Irina Glaser 7 Dec 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Craig v Glaser [2004] ScotSC 81 7 Dec 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Robbie the Pict v Procurator Fiscal, Dingwall 7 Dec 2004 HCJ Lord Hamilton And Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Osborne Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Robbie the Pict v Procurator Fiscal, Fort William 7 Dec 2004 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Hamilton And Lord Osborne Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Mohammed Mirza Hoseini Against A Decision of the Immigration Appeal Tribunal Intimated on 16 July 2004 8 Dec 2004 OHCS Lady Paton And Lord President And Lord Menzies Scotland [ ScotC ] Philip Anthony Brogan v O'Rourke Limited and others 8 Dec 2004 OHCS Lord Hamilton And Lord Reed And Lord Weir Scotland [ ScotC ] Petition To the Nobile Officium of the High Court of Justiciary of William Frederick Iain Beggs 8 Dec 2004 HCJ Lord Justice General And Lord Marnoch And Lord Macfadyen Scotland, Crime 1 Citers [ ScotC ] Berk, Re an Application for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 264 9 Dec 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Stuart v Telecom Services Centres Ltd [2004] ScotSC 82 9 Dec 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Procurator Fiscal, Jedburgh v Adams [2004] ScotSC 83 10 Dec 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Muslem Berk (Ap) for Judicial Review of A Decision of an Immigration Adjudicator 14 Dec 2004 OHCS Lord Brodie Scotland, Immigration [ ScotC ] James Nolan v Her Majesty's Advocate 14 Dec 2004 HCJ Lord Justice General And Lord Johnston And Lord Penrose Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Her Majesty's Advocate v John Holbein 15 Dec 2004 HCJ Lord Justice General And Lord Hamilton And Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Bruce v Shetland Islands Council [2004] ScotCS 266 16 Dec 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Donald v AMP (UK) Services Ltd EATS/0053/04; [2004] UKEAT 0053 - 04 - 1612 16 Dec 2004 EAT The Honourable Lord Johnston Employment, Scotland EAT Unfair Dismissal - Exclusions including worker 1 Cites [ Bailii ] - [ EATn ] Brydon and Another (T/A Peterson's Crane Hire) v Fe Beaumont Ltd [2004] ScotCS 265 16 Dec 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Ds v Jh [2004] ScotCS 267 16 Dec 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] D.S. v J.H. Or S. 16 Dec 2004 OHCS Lord Penrose And Lady Cosgrove And Lord Maclean Scotland [ ScotC ] N. Brydon, R. Peter T/A Peterson's Crane Hire v F.E. Beaumont Ltd 16 Dec 2004 OHCS Lord Clarke Scotland, Commercial [ ScotC ] David Mccrae v Her Majesty's Advocate 16 Dec 2004 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Maclean And Lord Dawson Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Ian William Bruce v Shetland Islands Council 16 Dec 2004 OHCS Lord Johnston Scotland [ ScotC ] Ronald Evan Wilson (Ap) v Messrs. D.M. Hall and Son [2004] ScotCS 268 17 Dec 2004 OHCS Lady Paton Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Karkhanehche, Re Application for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 269 17 Dec 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Henderson v The Lord Advocate 17 Dec 2004 ScSf Lord Penrose And Lord Weir Scotland [ ScotC ] Kingston Communications (Hull) Plc Ors v Stargas Nominees Ltd and others [2004] ScotCS 270 17 Dec 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Scottish Power Generation Ltd, Re Application for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 271 17 Dec 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Arthur Kearney v Her Majesty's Advocate 17 Dec 2004 HCJ Lord Kirkwood And Lord Hamilton And Lord Macfadyen And Lord Philip And Lady Cosgrove Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Mohammed Reza Karkhanehche for Judicial Review of A Refusal of Leave To Appeal By the Immigration Appeal Tribunal 17 Dec 2004 OHCS Lord Johnston Scotland, Immigration [ ScotC ] Kingston Communications (Hull) Plc Stargas Nominees Limited Stargas Nominees Limited v Stargas Nominees Limited Convergys Emea Limited Kingston Communications (Hull) Limited 17 Dec 2004 OHCS Sir David Edward And Lord President And Lord Marnoch Scotland [ ScotC ] Scottish Power Generation Limited for Judicial Review of A Decision By the Scottish Environment Protection Agency 17 Dec 2004 OHCS Lord Reed Scotland [ ScotC ] Welding v Wilson and others [2004] ScotSC 86 22 Dec 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Tony Beal Ltd v Boyd (T/A R Boyd Roofing) [2004] ScotSC 85 22 Dec 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Tony Beal Limited v Robert Boyd Trading As R Boyd Roofing 22 Dec 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal E.F. Bowen Scotland [ ScotC ] Scottish Power Generation Limited for Judicial Review of A Decision By the Scottish Environment Protection Agency [2004] ScotCS 272 22 Dec 2004 OHCS Lord Reed Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Welding v Wilson, Wilson Julian Humphrey Spencer Cook 22 Dec 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal Sir Stephen S.T. Young Scotland [ ScotC ] Beck (Ap) v Chief Constable Strathclyde Police [2004] ScotCS 273 22 Dec 2004 OHCS Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Penrose And Lord Weir Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Cairns v Andrew Downie, Care of Scottish Enterprise [2004] ScotSC 84 22 Dec 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal E.F. Bowen Scotland [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Jean Waugh v Her Majesty's Advocate 22 Dec 2004 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Marnoch And Lord Penrose Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Andrewina Susan Baird Boyle Or Riddell v Alan Riddell 23 Dec 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal I.D. Macphail, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] City of Edinburgh Council v Z 23 Dec 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal I.D. Macphail, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Boyle Or Riddell v Riddell [2004] ScotSC 88 23 Dec 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] City of Edinburgh Council v Z [2004] ScotSC 87 23 Dec 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Referral By the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission In the Cases of William Gray James Bernard O'Rourke v Her Majesty's Advocate 23 Dec 2004 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk And Lord Osborne And Lord Eassie Scotland, Crime 1 Citers [ ScotC ] University of Edinburgh v Onifade [2004] ScotSC 89 24 Dec 2004 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Sykes v Grant and Another [2004] ScotCS 275 24 Dec 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Middleton (Ap) and others v Brown and others [2004] ScotCS 276 24 Dec 2004 OHCS Lord Mcewan Scotland [ ScotC ] - [ Bailii ] Robert Sykes v Allan Grant Advice Firm Limited 24 Dec 2004 OHCS Lord Bracadale Scotland [ ScotC ] the University of Edinburgh v Daniel Onifade 24 Dec 2004 ScSf Sheriff Principal I.D. Macphail, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Wu, Re Application for Judicial Review [2004] ScotCS 277 30 Dec 2004 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Petition of Wen Jing Wu for Judicial Review 30 Dec 2004 IHCS Lady Smith Scotland [ ScotC ]
		Copyright 2014 David Swarbrick, 10 Halifax Road, Brighouse, West Yorkshire HD6 2AG.

swarb.co.uk - law index

Scotland - From: 2004 To: 2004