

Links: Home \| swarblaw - law discussions		swarb.co.uk - law index These cases are from the lawindexpro database. They are now being transferred to the swarb.co.uk website in a better form. As a case is published there, an entry here will link to it. The swarb.co.uk site includes many later cases. Â
		Scotland - From: 1999 To: 1999 This page lists 944 cases, and was prepared on 20 May 2019. Â S v M 1999 SC 388 1999 Scotland, Adoption 1 Citers Â Torbet v H M Advocate 1999 SLT 113 1999 HCJ Rodger LJG Criminal Sentencing, Scotland The appellant had offended while on licence from a life sentence for murder. When sentencing the trial judge took into account the fact that he posed a moderate risk of future violence to women with whom he had had an intimate relationship. The length of the sentence was held to be excessive on appeal by the High Court of Justiciary, but the judge's approach to the matter was approved: "Although a court will be aware that a particular offender has been recalled by the Secretary of State, who will need to bear in mind the safety of the public in considering his future release from custody under the life sentence, the duty of the court in sentencing him for the particular offence of which he has been convicted is to approach the matter in the usual way. The court will therefore chose the sentence which is appropriate, having regard to the nature of the offence, the previous convictions of the offender and all the other factors which a judge normally takes into account. Among those factors may be the need to choose a period which the court considers will give the public appropriate protection from any risk of reoffending." 1 Citers Â Â Duncanson v South Ayrshire Council; 1999 - 1999 SLT 519 Â G and S Properties and Adams and Others v Henderson and Henderson [1999] ScotCS 1 6 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Adams v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 1 6 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General Crime, Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Govell v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 3 7 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord McCluskey Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Emslie v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 2 7 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Compagnie Commercial Andre S A v Artibell Shipping Company Limited and the Governor and Company of the Bank of Scotland [1999] ScotCS 2 7 Jan 1999 SCS Lord MacFadyen Scotland, Transport, Jurisdiction The pursuers employed the defenders to carry sugar across Iraq. The voyage had been abandoned. The defenders challenged the proceedings as to jurisdiction and otherwise. 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â P and O Scottish Ferries Ltd v the Braer Corporation and Assuranceforeningen Skuld 7 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Gill Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Wallace v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 4 7 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â P and O Scottish Ferries Ltd v The Braer Corporation and Assuranceforeningen Skuld [1999] ScotCS 3 7 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â the Governor and Company of the Bank of Scotland v Frank James Junior [1999] ScotCS 9 8 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â James and George Collie v Robert Donald 8 Jan 1999 SCS Lord McCluskey Scotland [ ScotC ] Â John Brady v Messrs Neilsons [1999] ScotCS 5 8 Jan 1999 OHCS Lord Reed Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Mclean v Caledonian Macbrayne Limited 8 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ ScotC ] Â the Governor and Company of the Bank of Scotland v Frank James Junior 8 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Prosser and Lord Penrose and Lord Morison Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Shoprite Group Plc v Kwik Save Stores Ltd [1999] ScotCS 8 8 Jan 1999 OHCS Lord Morison Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Minevco Limited v Barratt Southern Limited [1999] ScotCS 7 8 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â John Mclean v Caledonian Macbrayne Limited [1999] ScotCS 6 8 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Collie v Donald [1999] ScotCS 4 8 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Royal Bank of Scotland Plc v Holmes [1999] ScotCS 10 8 Jan 1999 SCS Lord MacFadyen Scotland The defender, a name at Lloyds, had obtained three guarantees from the pursuers. Initial claims under the gurantees were made and paid, by the bank and defender in turn, but then further claims were made against the guarantees whch were met by the pursuers who now sought payment from the defender. The defender argued that they had acted fraudulently. [ Bailii ] Â Kenneth William Milton v Procurator Fiscal, Perth [1999] ScotHC 6 12 Jan 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Mohammed Asif v Immigration Appeal Tribunal 12 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Penrose Scotland, Immigration [ ScotC ] Â Kenneth William Milton v Procurator Fiscal, Perth 12 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Michelle Doonan v Dhl International (Uk) Ltd 12 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Caplan Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Thomas Steele Bryson and Objections By James Bell v In Petition of Robert Burns Cumming Fulton for Removal of A Trustee 12 Jan 1999 SCS Lord MacLean Scotland [ ScotC ] Â John Logan v Strathclyde Fire Board 12 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Eassie Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Morgan Moore Engineering Limited v Engineering Construction Industry Training Board [1999] ScotCS 14 12 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Penrose Scotland, Employment [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Michelle Doonan v Dhl International (Uk) Ltd [1999] ScotCS 12 12 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Mohammed Asif v Immigration Appeal Tribunal [1999] ScotCS 13 12 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland, Immigration [ Bailii ] Â John Logan v Strathclyde Fire Board [1999] ScotCS 11 12 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Thomas Steele Bryson and Objections By James Bell v In Petition of Robert Burns Cumming Fulton for Removal of a Trustee [1999] ScotCS 15 12 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Ricky Brouwer v Procurator Fiscal, Perth [1999] ScotHC 10 13 Jan 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Cameron Mccartney v Procurator Fiscal, Inverness [1999] ScotHC 7 13 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Ricky Brouwer v Procurator Fiscal, Perth 13 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Michael Edward Taggart v Procurator Fiscal, Paisley [1999] ScotHC 9 13 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Darren O'Brien v Procurator Fiscal, Linlithgow [1999] ScotHC 8 13 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Joseph Watt and Another v the Braer Corporation and others 14 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Gill Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Jamieson, Anderson and Another v The Braer Corporation and others 14 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Gill Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Shetlands Islands Council and Orkney Islands Council v for Judicial Review of Recommendations Made By the Local Government Boundary Commission for Scotland 14 Jan 1999 SCS Lord MacLean Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Robert William Lindsay Gordon v Procurator Fiscal, Cupar [1999] ScotHC 12 14 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord McCluskey Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Robert William Robertson and Another v The Braer Corporation and others 14 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Gill Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Robert William Robertson and Another v the Braer Corporation and others [1999] ScotCS 19 14 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Alfred Stewart Jamieson Alwyn Duncan Anderson and Another v The Braer Corporation and others [1999] ScotCS 16 14 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Hill v General Accident Fire and Life Assurance Corp Plc [1999] ScotCS 17 14 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Andrew John Grant Scott and Derek Alexander Keith v Procurator Fiscal, Perth 14 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord McCluskey Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Shetlands Islands Council and Orkney Islands Council v for Judicial Review of Recommendations Made By the Local Government Boundary Commission for Scotland [1999] ScotCS 20 14 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Andrew John Grant Scott and Derek Alexander Keith v Procurator Fiscal, Perth [1999] ScotHC 11 14 Jan 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Joseph Watt and Another v the Braer Corporation and others [1999] ScotCS 18 14 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Hill v General Accident Fire and Life Assurance Corp Plc 14 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Alastair Morrison v Safeway Stores Plc [1999] ScotCS 21 15 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â David Kean Sodden v the Prudential Assurance Company Limited [1999] ScotCS 22 15 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Mrs Mary Malpas v Fife Council [1999] ScotCS 23 15 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Mary Malpas v Fife Council 15 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Bonomy Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Sodden v The Prudential Assurance Company Limited 15 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Cullen Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Alastair Morrison v Safeway Stores Plc 15 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Abernethy Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Mm v Es [1999] ScotCS 26 19 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Micro Leisure Limited v County Properties and Developments Limited and Keeper of the Registers of Scotland [1999] ScotCS 25 19 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland, Land [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Ahmed v North Lanarkshire Council [1999] ScotCS 24 19 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Prosser Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Mm v Es 19 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Prosser Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Alexander Macdonald v the Lord Advocate [1999] ScotCS 27 20 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â B F S (Dundee) Limited v David Murphie [1999] ScotSC 1 20 Jan 1999 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Iain Douglas Johnston v Robert (K/a Roy) Johnston [1999] ScotCS 28 20 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Iain Douglas Johnston v Robert (K/A Roy) Johnston 20 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Alexander Macdonald v the Lord Advocate 20 Jan 1999 SCS Lord MacLean Scotland [ ScotC ] Â B F S (Dundee) Limited v David Murphie 20 Jan 1999 ScSf Sheriff R.A. Davidson Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Law Hospital NHS Trust v Rush EAT/842/99 21 Jan 1999 EAT The Honourable Lord Johnston Scotland, Discrimination, Employment EAT Disability Discrimination - Disability 1 Citers [ EATn ] Â Silverscreen Print Plc v Ian T Watters and others 22 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Marnoch Scotland [ ScotC ] Â English v North Lanarkshire Council [1999] ScotCS 29; 1999 SCLR 310 22 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Reed Scotland, Health and Safety, European The application of the phrase 'work equipment' is to protect the workman using such equipment. This might embrace routine maintenance or cleaning or even minor repairing while the machine is operating. The 1998 Regulations should not be interpreted narrowly and in a way which would fail to implement the Framework Directive. Work Equipment Directive (Council Directive 89/655/EEC of 30 November 1989 - Provision and Use of Work Equipment Regulations 1998 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Tate Wilson Paterson v Robert Ferguson Lees [1999] ScotHC 14 22 Jan 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Tate Wilson Paterson v Robert Ferguson Lees 22 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Â Taylor v Procurator Fiscal, Edinburgh; HCJ 22-Jan-1999 - [1999] ScotHC 13 Â Silverscreen Print Plc v Ian T Watters and others [1999] ScotCS 30 22 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Andrew Thompson v Frank Crowe, Procurator Fiscal, Hamilton 23 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Andrew Thompson v Frank Crowe, Procurator Fiscal, Hamilton [1999] ScotHC 15 23 Jan 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â William John King v Carron Phoenix Ltd 26 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Kingarth Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Ali v The Secretary of State for the Home Department 26 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Eassie Scotland, Immigration Application for judicial review of decision to refuse bail to asylum applicant. [ ScotC ] Â Sohil Kashmire v Secretary of State for the Home Department 26 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Kingarth Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Don Ian Aaron McNaughton v Procurator Fiscal, Falkirk [1999] ScotHC 17 26 Jan 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â William John King v Carron Phoenix Ltd [1999] ScotCS 34 26 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Sohil Kashmire v Secretary of State for the Home Department [1999] ScotCS 33 26 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Ali v The Secretary of State for the Home Department [1999] ScotCS 32 26 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Steven Dailly v Procurator Fiscal, Paisley 26 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Lawrence Kerrigan v Procurator Fiscal, Kilmarnock [1999] ScotHC 19 26 Jan 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Steven Dailly v Procurator Fiscal, Paisley [1999] ScotHC 20 26 Jan 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Gerald William Ambrose v Procurator Fiscal, Ayr 26 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Lawrence Kerrigan v Procurator Fiscal, Kilmarnock 26 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Gerald William Ambrose v Procurator Fiscal, Ayr [1999] ScotHC 18 26 Jan 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Don Ian Aaron McNaughton v Procurator Fiscal, Falkirk 26 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Angus Hamilton v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow [1999] ScotHC 21 27 Jan 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â David Pole v Procurator Fiscal, Dundee [1999] ScotHC 24 27 Jan 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Charles Walter White v Procurator Fiscal, Perth [1999] ScotHC 22 27 Jan 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Angus Hamilton v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow 27 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â White v Procurator Fiscal, Perth 27 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime The defendant challenged his conviction for supplying false information on applying for a shotgun certificate. He had said that he had no convictions, but failed to disclose an adminishment, refusing to add the case to the application, having explained to the constable that he had not been convicted. Held: "There may have been an error in law in not appreciating that a conviction such as this was a conviction but we are satisfied that this was a false statement made by the appellant and that there was corroboration." Firearms Act 1968 26(5) [ ScotC ] Â David Pole v Procurator Fiscal, Dundee 27 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Morrow v Procurator Fiscal, Lanark [1999] ScotHC 23 27 Jan 1999 HCJ Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â In Petition of Peter Harding and others for Directions and Answers for Joy Manufacturing Holdings 29 Jan 1999 SCS Lord President Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Mcdonald v Salmond and others 29 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Philip Scotland [ ScotC ] Â In Petition of Peter Harding and others for Directions and Answers for Joy Manufacturing Holdings [1999] ScotCS 35 29 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Peter McDonald v Elaine Salmond and others [1999] ScotCS 37 29 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Pet v Recall of Sequestration Against William Allister Mcmillan and Douglas Brown Jackson [1999] ScotCS 36 29 Jan 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Pet v Recall of Sequestration Against William Allister Mcmillan and Douglas Brown Jackson 29 Jan 1999 SCS Lord Osborne Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Peter James Peace v the City of Edinburgh Council Gazette, 02 September 1999; (1999) IRLR 417; [1999] ScotCS 39 2 Feb 1999 OHCS Lord Penrose Employment, Scotland The normal rule is that a tribunal will not compel one party to employ another, but this can be set aside to allow an order restraining an employer from disciplinary proceedings which were in breach of the complex terms negotiated with the employees. This situation had been anticipated by the parties and provided for in the contractual relationship. The employer should not be allowed to breach that duty. [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Martin Frost &C v Unity Trust Bank Plc [1999] ScotCS 38 2 Feb 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Martin Frost &C v Unity Trust Bank Plc 2 Feb 1999 SCS Lord McCluskey Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Thomas Hunter v Her Majesty's Advocate 3 Feb 1999 HCJ Lord Caplan and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Kingarth Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Anthony Duffy (Ap) v the Secretary of State for Scotland [1999] ScotCS 40 3 Feb 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Thomas Hunter v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 26 3 Feb 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Moray Estates Development Company v Anthony Butler and others 3 Feb 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Peter Cockburn Smith v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 25 3 Feb 1999 HCJ Lord Caplan and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Philip Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Anthony Duffy (Ap) v the Secretary of State for Scotland 3 Feb 1999 SCS Lord Bonomy Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Moray Estates Development Company v Anthony Butler and others [1999] ScotCS 41 3 Feb 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Milne and Another v The William Cowie Partnership and Another [1999] ScotCS 42 5 Feb 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Robert Graham Mckernon v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow 9 Feb 1999 HCJ Lord Allanbridge and Lord Caplan and Lord Cowie Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Stephen Peter Moar v Procurator Fiscal, Stornoway 9 Feb 1999 HCJ Lord Allanbridge and Lord Caplan and Lord Cowie Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Dougbar Properties Ltd v Keeper of the Registers of Scotland 1999 SC 513; [1999] ScotCS 43 9 Feb 1999 SCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland, Registered Land Even if there existed an acknowledged error in the Land Registry, rectification was the only available remedy. The existence of an inaccuracy did not alter the legal reality that the registered proprietor had a right created by registration. In certain circumstances a unilateral error by the Keeper could be the subject of rectification. Land Registration (Scotland) Act 1979 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â David John Tulewicz v Procurator Fiscal, Kirkcaldy [1999] ScotHC 27 9 Feb 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Robert Graham Mckernon v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow [1999] ScotHC 28 9 Feb 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Stephen Peter Moar v Procurator Fiscal, Stornoway [1999] ScotHC 29 9 Feb 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â David John Tulewicz v Procurator Fiscal, Kirkcaldy 9 Feb 1999 HCJ Lord Caplan and Lord Allanbridge and Lord Cowie Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Barry Ferguson (Ap) v Irvin Stringfellow [1999] ScotCS 44 10 Feb 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Barry Ferguson (Ap) v Irvin Stringfellow 10 Feb 1999 SCS Lord MacLean Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Appeal for L J v In Petition of Aberdeen City Council for an Order Declaring A Child Free for Adoption [1999] ScotCS 45 11 Feb 1999 SCS Lord Justice Clerk Scotland, Adoption [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Glasgow City Council v T H Or M &C [1999] ScotCS 46 12 Feb 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Michael Keane (Ap) v Walker Contracts Scotland Ltd [1999] ScotCS 48 12 Feb 1999 SCS Lord Osborne Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Glasgow City Council v T H Or M &C 12 Feb 1999 SCS Lord Prosser Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Laurence Grainger and and Adam Armstrong v Pet Hma Against Ian Mclean [1999] ScotCS 47 12 Feb 1999 OHCS Lord Kingarth Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â David Barr v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 30 16 Feb 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â David Barr v Her Majesty's Advocate 16 Feb 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Justice General and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Michael Wilkinson v Secretary of State for Scotland [1999] ScotCS 49 16 Feb 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Michael Wilkinson v Secretary of State for Scotland 16 Feb 1999 SCS Lord McCluskey Scotland [ ScotC ] Â George William Sutherland Presslie and C v Cochrane Mcgregor Group Ltd &C [1999] ScotCS 51 17 Feb 1999 SCS Lord Penrose Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â First National Bank of Southern Africa Ltd &C Executors and Administrators v Lynn De-Courcy Mcstay and John Mcstay [1999] ScotCS 50 17 Feb 1999 SCS Lord Kingarth Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Petition To the Nobile Officium By Potter v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow [1999] ScotHC 31 18 Feb 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Fergus Mccann v Scottish Media Newspapers Ltd [1999] ScotCS 52; 2000 SLT 256 18 Feb 1999 SCS Lord MacFadyen Scotland, Defamation Three articles which appeared in one edition of a newspaper had to be read together and treated as "constituting a whole" for the purposes of determining meaning, where the first ended with a cross-reference to the second, and the second ended with a cross-reference to the third. 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Lomond Assured Properties Ltd v Mcgrigor Donald [1999] ScotCS 53 18 Feb 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Lomond Assured Properties Ltd v Mcgrigor Donald 18 Feb 1999 SCS Lord Johnston Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Petition To the Nobile Officium by Potter v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow 18 Feb 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Sutherland and Lord Coulsfield Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Living Design (Home Improvements) Ltd for Interim Interdict [1999] ScotCS 56 19 Feb 1999 SCS Lord Cameron of Lochbroom Scotland, Employment The petitioner company sought to enforce a post employment restrictive covenant agreed to by the respondent. He had given notice to leave, and the parties had setteled the departure with an additional restriction. The respondent denied that the defendant company operated significantly within the restricted area and also his formal position in the new company. 1 Cites [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Alexander Finnie v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 32 19 Feb 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Anne Margarget Hunter v David Scott &C (Thomas Moffat's Trustees) and Agnes Moffat 19 Feb 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Anne Margarget Hunter v David Scott &C (Thomas Moffat's Trustees) and Mrs Agnes Moffat [1999] ScotCS 54 19 Feb 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Inverness Taxi Owners and Drivers Association v Highland Council Times, 05 May 1999; [1999] ScotCS 55 19 Feb 1999 OHCS Lord MacLean Licensing, Scotland A statutory right given to individual licensees to object to the grant of licences did not give an association of such licensees standing to challenge a decision to remove a limit on the number of such licences. The application was premature. Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982 [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Baigent and others v The British Broadcasting Corporation and Mcculloch and O'Hare Times, 05 May 1999; [1999] ScotCS 57 19 Feb 1999 SCS TG Coutts QC Defamation, Scotland, Damages Where a defendant in a defamation action caused further distress by persisting through pleadings in attempts to establish the truth of matters alleged, that fact would be reflected properly in an increase in damages. 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Alexandrina Brannigan v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 34 22 Feb 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Alexandrina Brannigan v Her Majesty's Advocate 22 Feb 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Ross Mcintosh v Procurator Fiscal, Dunfermline 23 Feb 1999 HCJ Lord Kirkwood and Lord Prosser and Lord Weir Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Ross Mcintosh v Procurator Fiscal, Dunfermline [1999] ScotHC 40 23 Feb 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Brian Alexander v Procurator Fiscal, Dunferline [1999] ScotHC 35 23 Feb 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Garrow v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 37 23 Feb 1999 ScHC Lord Justice General Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Ian Muir v Procurator Fiscal, Edinburgh [1999] ScotHC 38 23 Feb 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Kenneth Anthony Paton Mills v Her Majesty's Advocate 23 Feb 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Ian Muir v Procurator Fiscal, Edinburgh 23 Feb 1999 HCJ Lord Kirkwood and Lord Prosser and Lord Weir Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Kenneth Anthony Paton Mills v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 39 23 Feb 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â William Boyle v Procurator Fiscal, Stirling [1999] ScotHC 41 23 Feb 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Brian Alexander v Procurator Fiscal, Dunferline 23 Feb 1999 HCJ Lord Kirkwood and Lord Prosser and Lord Weir Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â William Boyle v Procurator Fiscal, Stirling 23 Feb 1999 HCJ Lord Kirkwood and Lord Prosser and Lord Weir Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Graeme William Main v Procurator Fiscal, Cupar [1999] ScotHC 36 23 Feb 1999 HCJ Lord Kirkwood and Lord Prosser and Lord Weir Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Ian Mcnaughton v Procurator Fiscal, Paisley 24 Feb 1999 HCJ Lord Kirkwood and Lord Prosser and Lord Weir Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Patrick Stewart v Procurator Fiscal, Hamilton 24 Feb 1999 HCJ Lord Kirkwood and Lord Prosser and Lord Weir Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Ian Mcnaughton v Procurator Fiscal, Paisley [1999] ScotHC 42 24 Feb 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Stewart v Procurator Fiscal, Hamilton [1999] ScotHC 43 24 Feb 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Douglas Nimmo v The Secretary of State for Scotland [1999] ScotCS 59 24 Feb 1999 SCS Lord Marnoch Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Derek Gavin Hoy v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 44 25 Feb 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Derek Gavin Hoy v Her Majesty's Advocate 25 Feb 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Card Protection Plan Ltd v Commissioners of Customs and Excise Times, 18 March 1999; C-349/96; [1999] STC 270; [1999] 2 AC 601; [1998] EUECJ C-349/96 - O 25 Feb 1999 ECJ European, Scotland, VAT, Insurance A company procuring insurance purchases for credit card protection was as exempt from VAT as was the insurer. A provision which restricted the ability to claim such exemption to those registered as insurers under national was invalid under European Law: "it is for the national court to determine … whether the transactions . . are to be regarded for VAT purposes as comprising two independent supplies . . or whether one of those two supplies is the principal supply to which the other is ancillary, so that it receives the same tax treatment as the principal supply." What matters is "the essential features of the transaction". "There is a single supply in particular in cases where one or more elements are to be regarded as constituting the principal service, whilst one or more elements are to be regarded, by contrast, as ancillary services which share the tax treatment of the principal service. A service must be regarded as ancillary to a principal service if it does not constitute for customers an aim in itself, but a means of better enjoying the principal service supplied . ." As to what amounted to insurance, the court said: "the essentials of an insurance transaction are, as generally understood, that the insurer undertakes, in return for prior payment of a premium, to provide the insured, in the event of materialisation of the risk covered, with the service agreed when the contract was concluded. It is not essential that the service the insurer has undertaken to provide in the event of loss consists in the payment of a sum of money, as that service may also take the form of the provision of assistance in cash or in kind of the type listed in the annex Directive 73/239 as amended by Directive 84/641. There is no reason for the interpretation of the term 'insurance' to differ according to whether it appears in the Directive on insurance or in the Sixth Directive." Directive 73/239 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Rita Henderson Lauder v Ian Briggs and others [1999] ScotCS 63 26 Feb 1999 SCS Lord Penrose Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â R G and R A G v To Adopt W L Son of F M 26 Feb 1999 SCS Lord Coulsfield Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Abacus Trustees (Guersney) Ltd and George Alan More Nisbett v John Cunningham Stewart and Patricia Stewart and the Royal Bank of Scotland Trust Company (Guersney) Ltd [1999] ScotCS 60 26 Feb 1999 SCS Lord Osborne Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â R G and R A G v To Adopt W L Son of F M [1999] ScotCS 62 26 Feb 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Â Gibson v Orr, the Chief Constable, Strathlclyde Police; SCS 26-Feb-1999 - [1999] ScotCS 61; 1999 SCLR 661; 1999 SC 420 Â David Gordon Robb v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 45 2 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â David Gordon Robb v Her Majesty's Advocate 2 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Eassie and Lord Morison Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â James Andrew Greenhorn v Joanne Busby Hamilton and Glasgow City Council and Margaret Busby [1999] ScotSC 2 2 Mar 1999 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Â James Andrew Greenhorn (Ap) v Joanne Busby Hamilton and Glasgow City Council and Margaret Busby (Ap) 2 Mar 1999 ScSf Sheriff Principal B A Kerr Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Jason Dickson Thomson v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 46 3 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â In Petition of M D v A L D Or B Or B for an Order Under the Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985 [1999] ScotCS 64 3 Mar 1999 SCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland, Children Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985 [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â John Penman v Blue Cap Logistics Ltd 3 Mar 1999 SCS Lord Bonomy Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Robbie the Pict v Miller Civil Engineering Limited and others 3 Mar 1999 SCS Lord Eassie Scotland [ ScotC ] Â John Penman v Blue Cap Logistics Ltd [1999] ScotCS 65 3 Mar 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Robbie the Pict v Miller Civil Engineering Limited and others [1999] ScotCS 66 3 Mar 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Jason Dickson Thomson v Her Majesty's Advocate 3 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Eassie and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Morison Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Inquiry Held Under Fatal Accidents and Sudden Deaths Inquiry (Scotland) Act 1976 for Gordon Scott Niven 5 Mar 1999 ScSf Sheriff Principal E.F. Bowen Scotland, Coroners [ ScotC ] Â R J Mackinnon In the Cause Hurst Fuels Limited v Dundonald House Limited [1999] ScotCS 68 5 Mar 1999 SCS Lord McCluskey Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Appeal By the Commissioners of Customs and Excise v A Decision of the Vat and Duties Tribunal Dated 30 November 1998 Communicated To the Appellants 5 Mar 1999 SCS Lord Cameron of Lochbroom Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Irene Agnes Mary Buchanan (Ap) v Drummond Miller, W S and others 5 Mar 1999 SCS Lord MacLean Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Commissioners of Customs and Excise v Decision of the Vat and Duties Tribunal [1999] ScotCS 67 5 Mar 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Derek Alexander Mccreaddie v Her Majesty's Advocate 5 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Philip Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â James Geddes Jack v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 48 5 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Derek Alexander Mccreaddie v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 47 5 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â James Geddes Jack v Her Majesty's Advocate 5 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Philip Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Irene Agnes Mary Buchanan (Ap) v Drummond Miller, W S and others [1999] ScotCS 69 5 Mar 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Agnes Rae v Strathclyde Joint Police Board 9 Mar 1999 SCS Lord Bonomy Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Lewis Morrison Gray v Procurator Fiscal, Kirkcaldy 9 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Kirkwood and Lord Milligan and Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Vicky Roy Thomson Skirving v Procurator Fiscal, Cupar [1999] ScotHC 54 9 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Kirkwood and Lord Milligan and Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Gerald Niven v Procurator Fiscal, Dundee 9 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Kirkwood and Lord Milligan and Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Lewis Morrison Gray v Procurator Fiscal, Kirkcaldy [1999] ScotHC 53 9 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Agnes Rae v Strathclyde Joint Police Board [1999] ScotCS 70 9 Mar 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Gerald Niven v Procurator Fiscal, Dundee [1999] ScotHC 49 9 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Jarvis Orme v Procurator Fiscal, Linlithgow [1999] ScotHC 50 9 Mar 1999 ScHC Lord Kirkwood and Lord Milligan and Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Stewart Roy v M R Pearlman Limited Times, 13 May 1999; 1999 SCLR 803; [1999] ScotCS 71; 1999 SC 459 10 Mar 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton European, Scotland A court investigating legislation, made to implement a European Directive, had still to apply UK principles in that interpretation, and not to disregard entirely common law rules. Commercial Agents (Council Directive) Regulations 1993 No 3053 - Council Directive 86/653/EEC of 18 December 1986 on the coordination of the laws of the Member States relating to self-employed commercial agents 17 1 Cites [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Andrea Mcallan v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 55 10 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Maxwell Neil Mckirdy v Procurator Fiscal, Linlithgow [1999] ScotHC 59 10 Mar 1999 ScHC Lord Kirkwood and Lord Milligan and Lord Prosser Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Terence Jozef Collins v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 62 10 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Terence Jozef Collins v Her Majesty's Advocate 10 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Abernethy and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Philip Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Richard Wilhelm Karling v Her Majesty's Advocate 10 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Kirkwood and Lord Cowie Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â James Anthony Daly v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow [1999] ScotHC 57 10 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Kirkwood and Lord Milligan and Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Andrea McAllan v Her Majesty's Advocate 10 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Caplan and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Kingarth Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Kabasele George Kabalu v Her Majesty's Advocate 10 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Abernethy and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Philip Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Sion Thomas Bailly v Procurator Fiscal, Edinburgh 10 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Kirkwood and Lord Milligan and Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Sion Thomas Bailly v Procurator Fiscal, Edinburgh [1999] ScotHC 61 10 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Kabasele George Kabalu v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 58 10 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Inquiry Held Under the Fatan Accidents and Sudden Deaths (Scotland) Act 1976 for Amanda Duncan 10 Mar 1999 ScSf Sheriff R.A. Davidson Scotland, Coroners [ ScotC ] Â James Andrew Aitchison v Procurator Fiscal, Linlithgow [1999] ScotHC 56 10 Mar 1999 ScHC Lord Kirkwood and Lord Prosser and Lord Milligan Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Richard Wilhelm Karling v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 60 10 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Crown Appeal By the Rt Hon Lord Hardie, Her Majesty's Advocate v Kevin Ian Wallace 11 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Crown Appeal By the Rt Hon Lord Hardie, Her Majesty's Advocate v Kevin Ian Wallace [1999] ScotHC 63 11 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Walker Or Park v Park and Valente [1999] ScotSC 3 11 Mar 1999 ScSf Sheriff Principal B A Kerr Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â David Scott v Procurator Fiscal, Paisley 12 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Kirkwood and Lord Weir and Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Alan Herd v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 64 12 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â David Scott v Procurator Fiscal, Paisley [1999] ScotHC 65 12 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Moira Anne Scott Or Anthony and Michael John Anthony v Michael John Anthony and Moira Anne Scott Or Anthony [1999] ScotCS 79 12 Mar 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Brian John Oliver v Brown and Root Mcdermott Fabricators Limited T/a Barmac [1999] ScotCS 74 12 Mar 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Dorothy Louisa Hillis Or Cunniff v Kevin George Cunniff [1999] ScotCS 75 12 Mar 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â George Douglas Laing v Tai Lee Chung (Ap) [1999] ScotCS 76 12 Mar 1999 SCS Lord Prosser Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Allyson Stewart v Ryden Residential Limited [1999] ScotCS 73 12 Mar 1999 OHCS Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Kulwinder Singh Saini (Ap) v for Judicial Review of a Decision of the Secretary of State for the Home Department [1999] ScotCS 78 12 Mar 1999 SCS Scotland, Judicial Review, Immigration [ Bailii ] Â Brian John Oliver v Brown and Root Mcdermott Fabricators Limited T/A Barmac 12 Mar 1999 SCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Moira Anne Scott Or Anthony and Michael John Anthony v Michael John Anthony and Moira Anne Scott Or Anthony 12 Mar 1999 SCS Lord McCluskey Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Kulwinder Singh Saini (Ap) v for Judicial Review of A Decision of the Secretary of State for the Home Department Dated 6/3/98 12 Mar 1999 SCS Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Alan Herd v Her Majesty's Advocate 12 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Marnoch and Lord Prosser and Lord Weir Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Alasdair Cockburn Kerr Boyle and Angus Lorimer Kerr Boyle v Ronald E Wilson and Ann Kerr Boyle and Neula Kerr Boyle [1999] ScotCS 72 12 Mar 1999 OHCS Lord Eassie Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Dorothy Louisa Hillis Or Cunniff v Kevin George Cunniff 12 Mar 1999 SCS Lord Milligan and Lord McCluskey and Lord Marnoch Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Kevin Keegan and Kevin Mcmullen and Robert Mclean v Procurator Fiscal, Paisley [1999] ScotHC 66 12 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Caplan and Lord Cowie and Lord Allanbridge Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Terry Kennedy v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 69 16 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Philip Paul Lumsden v Her Majesty's Advocate 16 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Coulsfield and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Terry Kennedy v Her Majesty's Advocate 16 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Sutherland and Lord Justice General and Lord Coulsfield Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Rodger Or Houghton v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 67 16 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Coulsfield and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Philip Paul Lumsden v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 68 16 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â James Joseph Hamill and James Burns Gemill v Her Majesty's Advocate 17 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Caplan and Lord Philip Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Kirsty Aird v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow 17 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Kirkwood and Lord Prosser and Lord Weir Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â James Joseph Hamill and James Burns Gemill v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 71 17 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Kirsty Aird v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow [1999] ScotHC 72 17 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â In Petition To the Nobile Officium v By William Moscrop [1999] ScotHC 70 17 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Justice General and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Kevin Keavney v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 73 18 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Vincent Kemp (Ap) v the Secretary of State for Scotland [1999] ScotCS 80 18 Mar 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Vincent Kemp (Ap) v the Secretary of State for Scotland 18 Mar 1999 SCS Lord Osborne Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Kevin Keavney v Her Majesty's Advocate 18 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Sutherland and Lord Coulsfield Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Sylvia Muir Moffat Or Morton v Patricia Knaggs and Strathclyde Regional Council [1999] ScotCS 86 19 Mar 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Petition for Declaring A Child Free for Adoption - the City of Edinburgh Council v N B 19 Mar 1999 SCS Lord Prosser and Lord Osborne and Lady Cosgrove Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Sylvia Muir Moffat Or Morton v Patricia Knaggs and Strathclyde Regional Council 19 Mar 1999 SCS Lord Cameron of Lochbroom Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Petition for Declaring a Child Free for Adoption - the City of Edinburgh Council v N B [1999] ScotCS 85 19 Mar 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â CW v for Judicial Review of Criminal Injuries Compensation Board [1999] ScotCS 82; [1999] ScotCS 82 19 Mar 1999 OHCS Lord Johnston Scotland, Personal Injury [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Belgian International Insurance Group Sa v Euan Mcnicoll 19 Mar 1999 SCS Lord Dawson Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Belgian International Insurance Group Sa v Euan Mcnicoll [1999] ScotCS 81 19 Mar 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â McMahon McFadyen and Co v Buchanan Clothing Co Ltd and Lack Ltd [1999] ScotSC 4 23 Mar 1999 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Â James Anthony Mack v Her Majesty's Advocate 23 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Caplan and Lord Justice Clerk Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â McMahon McFadyen and Co v Buchanan Clothing Co Ltd and Lack Ltd 23 Mar 1999 ScSf Sheriff Principal B A Kerr Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Wanderers World Ltd v Marcos Leisure Ltd [1999] ScotSC 5 24 Mar 1999 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Wanderers World Ltd v Marcos Leisure Ltd 24 Mar 1999 ScSf Sheriff Principal C.G.B. Nicholson Scotland [ ScotC ] Â In Petition of Malkiat Singh v for Judicial Review of A Decision of the Home Secretary 24 Mar 1999 SCS Lord MacLean Scotland [ ScotC ] Â In Petition of Malkiat Singh v for Judicial Review of a Decision of the Home Secretary [1999] ScotCS 87 24 Mar 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Glen Stewart Ogilvie v Her Majesty's Advocate 25 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Caplan and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Morison Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Robert Graham Chalmers v Strathclyde Fire Board 25 Mar 1999 SCS Lord Kingarth Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Robert Graham Chalmers v Strathclyde Fire Board [1999] ScotCS 89 25 Mar 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Glen Stewart Ogilvie v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 77 25 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â James Anthony Mack v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 78 25 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â James Anthony Mack v Her Majesty's Advocate 25 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Caplan and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Morison Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Grant Grassie v Ross Andrew Maclaren [1999] ScotCS 90 26 Mar 1999 SCS Lord Cameron of Lochbroom Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Onifade v The Secretary of State for Social Security [1999] ScotSC 6 29 Mar 1999 ScSf Scotland, Immigration [ Bailii ] Â Daniel Onifade v the Secretary of State for Social Security 29 Mar 1999 ScSf Sheriff I.D. MacPhail Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Crabb v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 79 30 Mar 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Rubislaw Land Company Limited v Aberdeen Construction Group Limited and others [1999] ScotCS 91 30 Mar 1999 SCS Lord Penrose Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Thomas Lamb Crooks (Ap) v Messrs Lawford Kidd and Co and others [1999] ScotCS 92 30 Mar 1999 OHCS Lord Marnoch Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Crabb v Her Majesty's Advocate 30 Mar 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Milligan and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Sandra Farrer (Ap) v Lothian Health Board 31 Mar 1999 SCS Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Sandra Farrer (Ap) v Lothian Health Board [1999] ScotCS 93 31 Mar 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Marie Kelly Kerr Ingram v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 80 31 Mar 1999 ScHC Lord Justice General and Lord Milligan and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Farquhar Forbes v The Duke of Roxburghe and others [1999] ScotCS 94 1 Apr 1999 SCS Lord Eassie Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Mark Robert Birrell and Gordon Williamson and Paul Williamson and Lawrence Milligan v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 83 1 Apr 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Coulsfield and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Paul Cowan and Jennifer Margaret Rennie and Patricia Elaine Blair and Alan Robert Simpson v Her Majesty's Advocate and Procurator Fiscal, Stranraer and Procurator Fiscal, Greenock and Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow [1999] ScotHC 84 1 Apr 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Coulsfield and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Ian Jack Whyte v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 81 1 Apr 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Ian Jack Whyte v Her Majesty's Advocate 1 Apr 1999 HCJ Lord Gill and Lord Justice General and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â James Thomason Diamond v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 82 1 Apr 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â James Thomason Diamond v Her Majesty's Advocate 1 Apr 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Justice General and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Robert Mallinson (Ap) v Ethicon Limited and Arthur Mackay (Electrical Contractors) Ltd [1999] ScotSC 7 6 Apr 1999 ScSf Sheriff Principal C.G.B. Nicholson Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Pet v Charles Dickie 7 Apr 1999 SCS Lord Bonomy Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Pet v Charles Dickie [1999] ScotCS 95 7 Apr 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Prosoft Resources Limited v Mark Griffiths 13 Apr 1999 SCS Lord MacLean Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Prosoft Resources Limited v Mark Griffiths [1999] ScotCS 96 13 Apr 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Graham Munro v Her Majesty's Advocate 15 Apr 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Justice General and Lord Kingarth Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Graham Munro v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 85 15 Apr 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Mrs Margaret Carr Baxter v Central Fife Divisional Licensing Board and the Chief Constable of Fife Constabulary [1999] ScotSC 8 15 Apr 1999 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Assuranceforeningen Skuld v the International Oil Pollution Compensation Funds and others [1999] ScotCS 97 15 Apr 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Mrs Margaret Carr Baxter v Central Fife Divisional Licensing Board and the Chief Constable of Fife Constabulary 15 Apr 1999 ScSf Sheriff F.J. Keane Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Assuranceforeningen Skuld v the International Oil Pollution Compensation Funds and others 15 Apr 1999 SCS Lord Gill Scotland [ ScotC ] Â The Royal Bank of Scotland v Malcolm 1999 SCLR 854; [1999] ScotCS 98 16 Apr 1999 SCS Lord MacLean Scotland 1 Citers [ Bailii ] Â Robert Malcolm Bain v Her Majesty's Advocate 20 Apr 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Malcolm Thomas Cole v Edward Duncan Lonie 20 Apr 1999 ScSf Sheriff Principal C.G.B. Nicholson Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Robert Malcolm Bain v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 87 20 Apr 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Gordon John Reid v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 86 20 Apr 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Gordon John Reid v Her Majesty's Advocate 20 Apr 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Cole v Lonie [1999] ScotSC 9 20 Apr 1999 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Andrea Mcallan v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 88 21 Apr 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â John Harrison v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 90 21 Apr 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â John Harrison v Her Majesty's Advocate 21 Apr 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Allanbridge and Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â James Joseph Hamill v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 89 21 Apr 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â James Joseph Hamill v Her Majesty's Advocate 21 Apr 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Allanbridge and Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Andrea McAllan v Her Majesty's Advocate 21 Apr 1999 HCJ Lord Allanbridge and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v Glen Foley [1999] ScotHC 91 22 Apr 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Richard Swan and others v Secretary of State for Scotland for Judicial Review 23 Apr 1999 SCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ ScotC ] Â In Petition To the Nobile Officium By Alan Scott Mcneilage v Her Majesty's Advocate 23 Apr 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Allanbridge and Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Euan Alexander Mcilvride and Michael Mcgarry Mcletchie v Her Majesty's Advocate 23 Apr 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Eassie and Lord Morison Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Euan Wallace and Partners v Westscot Homes Plc [1999] ScotCS 99 23 Apr 1999 SCS Lord MacFadyen Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â In Petition To the Nobile Officium By Alan Scott Mcneilage v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 92 23 Apr 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Richard Swan and others v Secretary of State for Scotland for Judicial Review [1999] ScotCS 100 23 Apr 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â John Paul Cameron v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotCS 101 26 Apr 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â John Paul Cameron v Her Majesty's Advocate 26 Apr 1999 SCS Lord Justice Clerk and Lord McCluskey and Lord Marnoch Scotland [ ScotC ] Â John Paul Cameron v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 254 26 Apr 1999 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Â Michael Ferguson v the State Hospital Management Committee 26 Apr 1999 ScSf Sheriff J Douglas Allan Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Michael Ferguson v the State Hospital Management Committee [1999] ScotSC 10 26 Apr 1999 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Helen Mcerlean v J and B Scotland Ltd 27 Apr 1999 SCS Lord Prosser Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Helen Mcerlean v J and B Scotland Ltd [1999] ScotCS 102 27 Apr 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â John Cloy and and Janice Cloy v Messrs T M Adams and Thomas Murdoch Adams and Agnes Jane Adams and Colin Adams [1999] ScotSC 12 28 Apr 1999 ScSf Sheriff Principal G Cox Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â James Hamilton and Mrs Anne Hamilton v Mohammed Wahla and Ryeside Construction Ltd 28 Apr 1999 ScSf Sheriff Principal B A Kerr Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Weston John Ross Venters v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 93 28 Apr 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Eassie and Lord Morison Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â James Hamilton and Mrs Anne Hamilton v Mohammed Wahla and Ryeside Construction Ltd [1999] ScotSC 11 28 Apr 1999 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Craig Charles Duff v Procurator Fiscal, Dunfermline 29 Apr 1999 HCJ Lord Hamilton and Lord McCluskey Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â S S v City of Edinburgh Council [1999] ScotSC 13 30 Apr 1999 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Â S S v City of Edinburgh Council 30 Apr 1999 ScSf Sheriff Principal C.G.B. Nicholson Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Mary Lochrie Mcwilliams v Procurator Fiscal, Falkirk [1999] ScotHC 96 30 Apr 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Mary Lochrie Mcwilliams v Procurator Fiscal, Falkirk 30 Apr 1999 HCJ Lord Caplan and Lord Cowie and Lord Kirkwood Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Inquiry Held Under the Fatal Accidents and Sudden Deaths Inquiry (Scotland) Act 1976 for Imran Khan 30 Apr 1999 ScSf Sheriff Principal E.F. Bowen Scotland, Coroners The Fatal Accidents and Sudden Deaths Inquiry (Scotland) Act 1976 [ ScotC ] Â In Petition of Baillie Lite Ltd v for Judicial Review of Purported Notices Raised By Glasgow City Council 4 May 1999 SCS Lord Osborne Scotland [ ScotC ] Â In Petition of Baillie Lite Ltd v for Judicial Review of Purported Notices Raised By Glasgow City Council [1999] ScotCS 103 4 May 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Reclaiming Motion In the Cause David Reitze and Hellen Stephenson Or Macdonald Or Reitze and Kenneth Macdonald v Strathclyde Regional Council [1999] ScotCS 104 4 May 1999 SCS Lord Allanbridge Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Gary John Bullock v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 99 5 May 1999 HCJ Lord Milligan and Lord Sutherland and Lord Justice General Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Philip George Garden v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 101 5 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â David James Reid v Her Majesty's Advocate 5 May 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Coulsfield and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Alexander Bain Donnelly and Alison Donnelly v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 97 5 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Adrian Stewart Mcpherson and William Alexander Mcpherson v Her Majesty's Advocate 5 May 1999 HCJ Lord Allanbridge and Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Alexander Bain Donnelly and Alison Donnelly v Her Majesty's Advocate 5 May 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Joseph Byrne v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 100 5 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Norman Lawson (Ap) v Lothian Health Board [1999] ScotCS 105 5 May 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Homecare Contracts (Scotland) Ltd v Scottish Midland Co-Operative Society Ltd [1999] ScotSC 14 5 May 1999 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Norman Lawson (Ap) v Lothian Health Board 5 May 1999 SCS Lord Eassie Scotland [ ScotC ] Â David James Reid v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 98 5 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Homecare Contracts (Scotland) Ltd v Scottish Midland Co-Operative Society Ltd 5 May 1999 ScSf Sheriff Principal C.G.B. Nicholson Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Joseph Byrne v Her Majesty's Advocate 5 May 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Philip George Garden v Her Majesty's Advocate 5 May 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord McCluskey and Lord Marnoch Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Reclaiming Motion for the Respondent In Petition of Robert Burns Cumming Fulton v for Removal of Trustees and Answers for James Bell [1999] ScotCS 108 6 May 1999 SCS Lord McCluskey Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Â Mathieson v Decision of Edinburgh Vat and Duties Tribunal and the Commissioners of Customs and Excise; SCS 6-May-1999 - [1999] ScotCS 106 Â Reclaiming Motion for the Petition In Petition of James Bell v for Recall of Sequestration and Answers for William Alister Mcmillan and Another [1999] ScotCS 107 6 May 1999 SCS Lord McCluskey Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â In Petition of the Council of the Law Society of Scotland v James Johnston Mcintyre 7 May 1999 SCS Lord McCluskey Scotland [ ScotC ] Â In Petition of the Council of the Law Society of Scotland v Mcintyre [1999] ScotCS 109 7 May 1999 SCS Scotland, Legal Professions [ Bailii ] Â In Note of Appeal By Her Majesty's Advocate v Robert Gilmour Caulfield [1999] ScotHC 102 10 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â In Note of Appeal By Her Majesty's Advocate v Robert Gilmour Caulfield 10 May 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Allanbridge and Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Gary Mcintyre v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow [1999] ScotHC 103 11 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Fraser Trading Co and others v the Governor and Company of the Bank of Scotland 11 May 1999 SCS Lord Eassie Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Kelly and Reid and Stewart and Lamont and Allison v Her Majesty's Advocate 11 May 1999 HCJ Lord Hamilton and Lord McCluskey Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Murdo Ewan Macleod v Procurator Fiscal, Airdrie [1999] ScotHC 108 11 May 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Milligan and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â John Mitchell v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow 11 May 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Milligan and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Gary Mcintyre v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow 11 May 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Milligan and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Ian Taylor Buttercase v Procurator Fiscal, Cupar [1999] ScotHC 105 11 May 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Milligan and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â John Mitchell v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow [1999] ScotHC 106 11 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Kay Louise Kelly and Douglas Reid and David Patterson Stewart and Robert Lamont and Mark Andrew Allison v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 107 11 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Fraser Trading Co and others v the Governor and Company of the Bank of Scotland [1999] ScotCS 110 11 May 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Gordon Ferries v Procurator Fiscal, Aberdeen 12 May 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Milligan and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Rhoda Yule v South Lanarkshire Council [1999] ScotCS 112 12 May 1999 OHCS Lord Philip Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Brian Murray Robertson and Another v Kevin Smith 12 May 1999 SCS Lord Philip Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Derek Johnston v Procurator Fiscal, Paisley [1999] ScotHC 111 12 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Bernard Elliot v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow [1999] ScotHC 110 12 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Alistair James Shepherd v Procurator Fiscal, Dornoch [1999] ScotHC 109 12 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Gordon Ferries v Procurator Fiscal, Aberdeen [1999] ScotHC 112 12 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Yvonne Angela Mitchell Or Harrier v Procurator Fiscal, Perth 12 May 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Milligan and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Shepherd v Procurator Fiscal, Dornoch 12 May 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Milligan and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Derek Johnston v Procurator Fiscal, Paisley 12 May 1999 HCJ Lord Milligan and Lord Sutherland and Lady Cosgrove Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Bernard Elliot v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow 12 May 1999 HCJ Lady Cosgrove and Lord Milligan and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Brian Murray Robertson and Another v Kevin Smith [1999] ScotCS 111 12 May 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Yvonne Angela Mitchell Or Harrier v Procurator Fiscal, Perth [1999] ScotHC 113 12 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Cochrane v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 115 13 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Thomas Ashton and James Carter v Her Majesty's Advocate 13 May 1999 HCJ Lord Allanbridge and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â John Horn v Procurator Fiscal, Kirkcaldy 13 May 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Kirkwood and Lord Milligan Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Horn v Procurator Fiscal, Kirkcaldy [1999] ScotHC 116 13 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Alexander Cochrane v Her Majesty's Advocate 13 May 1999 HCJ Lord Allanbridge and Lord Justice General and Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Lumsden Or Dempsey v Procurator Fiscal, Hamilton 13 May 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Kirkwood and Lord Milligan Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Coll (Ap) v Dr Russell and Victoria Infirmary NHS Trust 13 May 1999 SCS Lord Osborne Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Lumsden Or Dempsey v Procurator Fiscal, Hamilton [1999] ScotHC 114 13 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Moffat v Procurator Fiscal, Edinburgh [1999] ScotHC 117 13 May 1999 ScHC Lord Cowie and Lord Milligan and Lord Kirkwood Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Ashton and Carter v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 118 13 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Frank Coll (Ap) v Dr Derrick Russell and Victoria Infirmary NHS Trust [1999] ScotCS 113 13 May 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Evan Mason v Procurator Fiscal, Dunfermline [1999] ScotHC 120 14 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Evan Mason v Procurator Fiscal, Dunfermline 14 May 1999 HCJ Lord Kirkwood and Lord Milligan and Lord Cowie Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Scott Hendrie v Procurator Fiscal, Linlithgow [1999] ScotHC 121 14 May 1999 HCJ Lord Kirkwood and Lord Milligan and Lord Cowie Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Â L C Application for Judicial Review of Decisions of the Criminal Injuries Compensation Board; OHCS 14-May-1999 - Times, 03 June 1999; 1999 SCLR 992; [1999] ScotCS 114 Â Peter John Cairns v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 122 18 May 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Justice General and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â YUK Wong Chan v Man Fai To [1999] ScotSC 15 18 May 1999 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Â YUK Wong Chan v Man Fai To 18 May 1999 ScSf Sheriff Principal B A Kerr Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Eleanore Campbell Or Loughlin and others v London Midland and Scottish Contractors Limited and others 18 May 1999 SCS Lord Bonomy Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Eleanore Campbell Or Loughlin and others v London Midland and Scottish Contractors Limited and others [1999] ScotCS 115 18 May 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Landcatch Limited v International Oil Pollution Compensation Fund [1999] ScotCS 116 19 May 1999 IHCS Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Cowie and Lord McCluskey Scotland 1 Cites [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Landcatch Limited v The Braer Corporation and Trevor Williams and Anthony Jones and Michael S Hudner and Assurance foreningen Skuld and the International Oil Pollution Compensation Fund Times, 14 June 1999; [1999] ScotCS 117; [1999] 2 Lloyd's LR 316 19 May 1999 IHCS Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Cowie and Lord McCluskey Environment, Scotland, Transport The pursuers raised freshwater salmon (smolt) to the age of two before selling them on. An oil spill prevented them trading. They appealed a refusal of damages on the baiss that this was pure relational economic loss. Held: The appeal failed. Losses which arose following an environmental accident but which were related to particularly advantageous market conditions but for a prospective contract only were properly secondary economic losses and not recoverable under the Act. No distinction was drawn between the smolt that were sold for less than expected and those which were culled. Merchant Shipping (Oil Pollution) Act 1971 5(3) 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Damon Rose v Raymond Bouchet [1999] ScotSC 16; [1999] IRLR 463 19 May 1999 ScSf Sheriff Principal C.G.B. Nicholson Scotland When applying the test within the section, there is a need for the alleged discriminator to show that it was reasonable in all the circumstances of the case for him to hold the opinion in question: 'In my opinion, that part of the test requires an objective assessment of all the relevant circumstances. But that, of course, raises a question as to what circumstances are relevant for this purpose; and in particular it raises the question of whether a person in the defender's position is under some sort of obligation to make inquiries of a disabled person before forming any opinion. In considering this aspect of the case, it may be helpful at the outset to make clear that 'the relevant circumstances' do not extend to include all of the facts which may be established at a much later stage, for example during proof in a litigation. Counsel for the pursuer did not suggest that the reasonableness of an opinion should be tested, ex post facto as it were, by objective reference to all of the facts which might come to light at a later stage, and I am of opinion that counsel was correct to adopt that position. However, as I have noted earlier, he founded strongly on the submission that the defender should have engaged in dialogue with the pursuer so as to obtain more relevant facts than were immediately available to him. The submission bore, of course, to be founded on the Code of Practice, and in particular on the passage which I have already quoted from paragraph 1.7. In my opinion, counsel's submission on this point is crucial if the pursuer is to succeed because, like the sheriff, I consider that the opinion reached by the defender, on the facts as then known to him, was a reasonable one for him to reach. … 37 The question then is whether the defender should have endeavoured to obtain more information before finalising his opinion. The Act itself does not impose any such duty, but I accept that the Code contains a suggestion that some inquiry may be desirable. In my opinion, however, the need for further inquiry will depend very much on the facts and circumstances of a particular case. …' Disability Discrimination Act 1995 24(2) 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Gary John Hunter and Roderick Mclean Snr v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 123 20 May 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Kirkwood and Lord Hamilton Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â In Petition of Alan Taylor for Directions [1999] ScotCS 118 20 May 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â In Petition of Alan Taylor for Directions 20 May 1999 SCS Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] Â D I for an Order Under the Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985 [1999] ScotCS 119 21 May 1999 SCS Scotland, Children Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985 [ Bailii ] Â Martin Frost and Another v Unity Trust Bank Plc [1999] ScotCS 120 21 May 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Pioneer Seafood Limited v The Braer Corporation and Trevor Williams and Anthony Jones and Michael S Hudner and Assuranceforeningen Skuld [1999] ScotCS 121 21 May 1999 SCS Lord Gill Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Rachel Logan v Procurator Fiscal, Kilmarnock [1999] ScotHC 124 21 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Shetland Norse Preserving Co Ltd and Vidlin Lobster Co Ltd and L Williamson (Shetland) Ltd and Framgord Ltd v the Braer Corporation and Another and the International Oil Pollution Compensation Fund [1999] ScotCS 122 21 May 1999 SCS Lord Gill Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â D I for an Order Under the Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985 21 May 1999 SCS Lord Abernethy Scotland Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985 [ ScotC ] Â Rachel Logan v Procurator Fiscal, Kilmarnock 21 May 1999 HCJ Lord Caplan and Lord Cowie and Lord Kirkwood Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Martin Frost and Another v Unity Trust Bank Plc 21 May 1999 SCS Lord Bonomy Scotland [ ScotC ] Â James Mcgregor v Procuator Fiscal, Glasgow, [1999] ScotHC 126 25 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Leslie Lyndon Cartmill v Procurator Fiscal, Dundee [1999] ScotHC 128 25 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v Scott McNally [1999] ScotHC 125 25 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â George Lesley Saunders, for Judicial Review of A Pretended Decision of the Sheriff of Grampian Highlands and Islands at Tain [1999] ScotCS 123 25 May 1999 SCS Lord MacLean Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v Scott Mcnally 25 May 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Justice General and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Kenneth Thomas William Michie v Procurator Fiscal, Perth [1999] ScotHC 127 25 May 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord McCluskey and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Leslie Lyndon Cartmill v Procurator Fiscal, Dundee 25 May 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord McCluskey and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Martin Hardie Lindsay v Procurator Fiscal, Paisley [1999] ScotHC 129 25 May 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord McCluskey and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Ronald Mcintosh Dewar and others v Stewart Andrew Winton [1999] ScotCS 124 25 May 1999 SCS Lord Prosser Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â James Mcgregor v Procuator Fiscal, Glasgow, 25 May 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord McCluskey and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Report By Lord Penrose In Pet of Oliver and Son Ltd for an Order [1999] ScotCS 127 26 May 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Magnus George Smith v The Braer Corporation and Assuranceforeningen Skuld (Gjensidig) and the International Oil Pollution Compensation Fund 26 May 1999 SCS Lord Gill Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Magnus George Smith v The Braer Corporation and Assuranceforeningen Skuld (Gjensidig) and the International Oil Pollution Compensation Fund [1999] ScotCS 126 26 May 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Shaun Van Lierop Aka Batchelor v Procurator Fiscal, Perth [1999] ScotHC 131 26 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â McNicol v Strathclyde Buses Limited and James Sweeney [1999] ScotCS 125 26 May 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Shaun Van Lierop Aka Batchelor v Procurator Fiscal, Perth 26 May 1999 HCJ Lord Caplan and Lord Cowie and Lord Kirkwood Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Report By Lord Penrose In Pet of Oliver and Son Ltd for an Order 26 May 1999 SCS Lord Penrose Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Mcnicol v Strathclyde Buses Limited and James Sweeney 26 May 1999 SCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ ScotC ] Â David Methven Gonsales O'Neill v Procurator Fiscal, Dunfermline 27 May 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord McCluskey and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Michael Kelly v First Engineering Ltd 27 May 1999 SCS Lord Abernethy Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Michael Kelly v First Engineering Ltd [1999] ScotCS 128 27 May 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Kevin Gillespie v Procurator Fiscal, Hamilton 27 May 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord McCluskey and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â David Methven Gonsales O'Neill v Procurator Fiscal, Dunfermline [1999] ScotHC 132 27 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â the Accountant of Court v Halifax Plc 28 May 1999 SCS Lord Penrose Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Rosemary McAuley or McManus and others v Babcock Energy Limited [1999] ScotCS 130 28 May 1999 OHSCS Lord Kingarth Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Christopher Armitt v Procurator Fiscal, Kirkcaldy [1999] ScotHC 134 28 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â James Mcgurk v Procurator Fiscal, Dumbarton [1999] ScotHC 135 28 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Colin Fraser (Ap) v for Judicial Review of A Decision of the Professional Golfers Association 28 May 1999 SCS Lord Eassie Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Paul Patrick Thomas Montague v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow [1999] ScotHC 137 28 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Colin Fraser (Ap) v for Judicial Review of a Decision of the Professional Golfers Association [1999] ScotCS 129 28 May 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â the Accountant of Court v Halifax Plc [1999] ScotCS 131 28 May 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Laura Connelly v Procurator Fiscal, Paisley [1999] ScotHC 136 28 May 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â James Mcgurk v Procurator Fiscal, Dumbarton 28 May 1999 HCJ Lord Caplan and Lord Cowie and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Christopher Armitt v Procurator Fiscal, Kirkcaldy 28 May 1999 HCJ Lord Caplan and Lord Cowie and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Paul Patrick Thomas Montague v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow 28 May 1999 HCJ Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Laura Connelly v Procurator Fiscal, Paisley 28 May 1999 HCJ Lord Caplan and Lord Cowie and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Sibley Robertson v Secretary of State for Scotland 1 Jun 1999 ScSf Sheriff F.L. Reith Scotland [ ScotC ] Â John Malarkey Duff v East Dunbartonshire Council and others 1 Jun 1999 SCS Lady Cosgrove Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Sibley Robertson v Secretary of State for Scotland [1999] ScotSC 17 1 Jun 1999 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Robert Ross Sanderson v Her Majesty's Advocate 1 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Justice General and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Robert Ross Sanderson v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 138 1 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â John Malarkey Duff v East Dunbartonshire Council and others [1999] ScotCS 132 1 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â David Wark Arnott v Her Majesty's Advocate 2 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Justice General and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Mark James Newman v Her Majesty's Advocate 2 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Justice General and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â David Wark Arnott v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 139 2 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Kevin Charles Duggan v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 140 2 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Justice General and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Mark James Newman v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 141 2 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Esmail and Another and Esmail and Karim Or Esmail and Karim Or Esmail and Esmail and Esmail v The Governor and Company of the Bank of Scotland and Another [1999] ScotCS 136 4 Jun 1999 SCS TG Coutts QC Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â David John Milne v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 144 4 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Mark James Armit v Procurator Fiscal, Ayr [1999] ScotHC 146 4 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Gary Keith Henry Morrison v Her Majesty's Advocate 4 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Justice General and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Belgian International Insurance Group Sa v Euan Mcnicoll [1999] ScotCS 133 4 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Brady v National Coal Board [1999] ScotCS 135 4 Jun 1999 SCS Lord Justice Clerk Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Heritage Fisheries Ltd v The Most Noble Sir Guy David Innes Ker, Baronet, Duke of Roxburghe [1999] ScotCS 134 4 Jun 1999 OHCS Lord President Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Belgian International Insurance Group Sa v Euan Mcnicoll 4 Jun 1999 SCS Lord Justice Clerk Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Arron Souter Aka Smart v Procurator Fiscal, Perth 4 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Kirkwood and Lord Milligan Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â David John Milne v Her Majesty's Advocate 4 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Justice General and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Daniel James Biggins v Procurator Fiscal, Dunfermline [1999] ScotHC 143 4 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Kirkwood and Lord Milligan Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Gary Keith Henry Morrison v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 145 4 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Arron Souter Aka Smart v Procurator Fiscal, Perth [1999] ScotHC 142 4 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Scott Alexander Mcgregor v Procurator Fiscal, Paisley [1999] ScotHC 150 8 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â George Connolly Lynn v Procurator Fiscal, Edinburgh 8 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Prosser and Lord Osborne Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Scott Alexander Mcgregor v Procurator Fiscal, Paisley 8 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Prosser and Lord Osborne Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Stewart John Neilson v Procurator Fiscal, Hamilton 8 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Prosser and Lord Osborne Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â George Connolly Lynn v Procurator Fiscal, Edinburgh [1999] ScotHC 148 8 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â the Lord Advocate v Scottish Media Newspapers Etc [1999] ScotHC 152 8 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â John Ryan v Procurator Fiscal, Stirling [1999] ScotHC 149 8 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â John Ryan v Procurator Fiscal, Stirling 8 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Osborne and Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â the Lord Advocate v Scottish Media Newspapers Etc 8 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Sutherland and Lord Justice General Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â David Houston v Procurator Fiscal, Greenock [1999] ScotHC 147 8 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Prosser and Lord Osborne Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Stewart John Neilson v Procurator Fiscal, Hamilton [1999] ScotHC 151 8 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â the Bank of Scotland v Dunedin Property Investment Company Ltd [1999] ScotCS 311 8 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â The Governor and Company of the Bank of Scotland v Dunedin Property Investment Company Ltd [1999] ScotCS 139 8 Jun 1999 OHCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland 1 Cites [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Andrew Wilson and others v Against a Decision of Lands Tribunal for Scotland [1999] ScotCS 137 8 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland, Land [ Bailii ] Â Luigi Macari v Celtic Football and Athletic Co Ltd [1999] ScotCS 138; 1999 SC 628 8 Jun 1999 SCS Lord President Rodger, Lord Marnoch, Lord Caplan Scotland, Contract, Employment One of the issues was whether Mr Macari had been entitled to refuse to carry out the instructions of the managing director because the club were in breach of another obligation to him under the contract between the parties. Held. In the context of the employer/employee contract, the implied obligation of trust and confidence to be found in that relationship fell to be seen as striking at the very root of the contractual relationship between the parties and that all the other obligations in the contract could be seen as the counterpart of that obligation. Lord Caplan said: "The retention of performance must be directed at a failure on the part of the other party to perform a counterpart obligation. Moreover for retention to be available there must be a continuing failure to perform the counterpart obligation. No retention arises in respect of a past breach of contract by the other party." Lord President Rodger said: "This authoritative gloss by Lord Jauncey confirms that the law does not regard each and every obligation by one party as being necessarily and invariably the counterpart of every obligation by others. One has to have regard to the circumstances. Lord Jauncey deduces from this that a material breach by one party of a particular term of a contract does not of itself mean that he cannot require the other to perform any of his obligations under his contract. Rather, the party in breach cannot insist on the other party performing his obligations in relation to the part of the contract of which the first party is in breach." 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Andrew Wilson and others v Against A Decision of Lands Tribunal for Scotland 8 Jun 1999 SCS Lord McCluskey Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Gaynor Barrett v Procurator Fiscal, Dumbarton [1999] ScotHC 154 10 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Gary John Clark v Procurator Fiscal, Falkirk [1999] ScotHC 153 10 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Johnny Glancy v Procurator Fiscal, Edinburgh [1999] ScotHC 155 10 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Steven Kevin Ward v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 156 10 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Barrett v Procurator Fiscal, Dumbarton 10 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Osborne and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Gary John Clark v Procurator Fiscal, Falkirk 10 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Osborne and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Johnny Glancy v Procurator Fiscal, Edinburgh 10 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Osborne and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Ian Blair Ballantyne and Joseph Docherty v Procurator Fiscal, Paisley 10 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Osborne and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Steven Kevin Ward v Her Majesty's Advocate 10 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Sutherland and Lord Osborne Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Andrew Third and others v North East Ice and Cold Storage Company Limited and Another 11 Jun 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Andrew Third and others v North East Ice and Cold Storage Company Limited and Another [1999] ScotCS 141 11 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Judith Mcleod v Aberdeen City Council [1999] ScotCS 142 11 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Karen Eaton (Ap) v West Lothian NHS Trust [1999] ScotCS 143 11 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Luss Estates Company v G B Garman and Co and Hutchison and Craft Ltd [1999] ScotCS 144 11 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Michael a Johnston v W H Brown Construction (Dundee) Ltd [1999] ScotCS 145 11 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â X v for Judicial Review of A Decision of Criminal Injuries Compensation Board Re Time-Barred Application Times, 05 July 1999; [1999] ScotCS 146 11 Jun 1999 OHCS Lord Penrose Personal Injury, Scotland The CICB exercising its discretion not to extend the time limit for a claim, should normally give reasons, and not limit its decision to a bald assertion that no exceptional circumstances had been shown. The broad circumstances were of the sort where sympathy was normally allowed (a claim by an adult in respect of acts occurring whilst a child). Criminal Injuries Compensation Scheme 1990 para 4 [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Luss Estates Company v G B Garman and Co and Hutchison and Craft Ltd 11 Jun 1999 SCS Lord Dawson Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Michael A Johnston v W H Brown Construction (Dundee) Ltd 11 Jun 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Procurator Fiscal, Hamilton v William Waugh [1999] ScotHC 157 11 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Kirkwood and Lord Milligan and Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Karen Eaton (Ap) v West Lothian NHS Trust 11 Jun 1999 SCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Roger Lindop v Stewart Noble and Sons Ltd and Matthew Purdon Henderson and Cameron King Russell As Receivers of Stewart Noble and Sons Ltd and As Individuals [1999] ScotCS 147 11 Jun 1999 SCS Lord Justice Clerk Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Judith Mcleod v Aberdeen City Council 11 Jun 1999 SCS Lord Dawson Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Eric Nguyen v Searchnet Associates Ltd [1999] ScotSC 18 15 Jun 1999 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Ian Robson v Procurator Fiscal, Airdrie 15 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Kirkwood and Lord Milligan and Lord Cowie Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Eric Nguyen v Searchnet Associates Ltd 15 Jun 1999 ScSf Sheriff Principal C.G.B. Nicholson Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Ian Robson v Procurator Fiscal, Airdrie [1999] ScotHC 158 15 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â John Mcfarlane Carroll and David Samuel Santini v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 162 16 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Justice General and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v Craig Davidson [1999] ScotHC 161 16 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Donald Reid v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 160 16 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v Craig Davidson 16 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Bonomy and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Milligan Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Report To the Inner House By the Lord Ordinary In Petition - Oliver and Son Ltd for an Order Under Section 46 of the Court of Session Act 1998 [1999] ScotCS 148 16 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Donald Reid v Her Majesty's Advocate 16 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Bonomy and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Marnoch Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Report To the Inner House By the Lord Ordinary In Petition - Oliver and Son Ltd for an Order Under Section 46 of the Court of Session Act 1998 16 Jun 1999 SCS Lord President Scotland [ ScotC ] Â David Alexander Wightman v Procurator Fiscal, Edinburgh [1999] ScotHC 159 16 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord McCluskey and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v William Maxwell Little 17 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Kingarth Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Alistair Murray Moffat v News Group Newspapers Ltd [1999] ScotCS 149 17 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v William Maxwell Little [1999] ScotHC 163 17 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Alistair Murray Moffat v News Group Newspapers Ltd 17 Jun 1999 SCS Lord Eassie Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Rhoda Mcdonald v News Group Newspapers Ltd 17 Jun 1999 SCS Lord Eassie Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Rhoda McDonald v News Group Newspapers Ltd [1999] ScotCS 150 17 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Cameron Shead and Mark Cunningham v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 164 18 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Elizabeth Stewart for Judicial Review of A Decision of the Housing and Social Services Department of 18 Jun 1999 SCS Lord Johnston Scotland [ ScotC ] Â James and George Collie v Robert Donald 18 Jun 1999 SCS Lord Dawson Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Elizabeth Stewart for Judicial Review of a Decision of the Housing and Social Services Department of [1999] ScotCS 151 18 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Cameron Shead and Mark Cunningham v Her Majesty's Advocate 18 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Justice General and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â James and George Collie v Robert Donald [1999] ScotCS 153 18 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Hugh Macrae and Company (Builders) Ltd v a Decision of a Reporter Appointed By the Secretary of State for Scotland [1999] ScotCS 152 18 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland, Planning Town and Country Planning Act 1997 [ Bailii ] Â Peter John Geddes v Her Majesty's Advocate 22 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Hamilton and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â the Commissioners of Inland Revenue v Aberdeen Milk Company Limited [1999] ScotCS 154 22 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Peter John Geddes v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 165 22 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â the Commissioners of Inland Revenue v Aberdeen Milk Company Limited 22 Jun 1999 SCS Lord Allanbridge and Lord Kirkwood and Lord Prosser Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Shariff and Kirmani for Exercise of the Nobile Officium Etc [1999] ScotCS 157 23 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Kelvin International Services v Walker [1999] ScotCS 156 23 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Gurdial Singh for Judicial Review of Determination of the Immigration Appeal Tribunal and an Immigra [1999] ScotCS 155 23 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland, Immigration [ Bailii ] Â Maria Ann Kenny v Her Majesty's Advocate 23 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Sutherland and Lord Hamilton Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Kenny v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 166 23 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Kelvin International Services v James Walker 23 Jun 1999 SCS Lord Coulsfield Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Sukhjinder Kaur v Balbir Singh and others [1999] ScotCS 158; 1999 S C 180 23 Jun 1999 OHCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland, Registered Land The case dealt with the nature of the possession referred to in the section. "possession" under the section was a "tie breaker" used to identify who should suffer, or what remedy should be available. The court envisaged that a corporate body, as opposed to a natural person, might be in "possession", in terms of the provision. There were acknowledged to be unresolved issues regarding the degree of "possession" required in terms of the enactment. Land Registration (Scotland) Act 1979 [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Gurdial Singh for Judicial Review of Determination of the Immigration Appeal Tribunal and an Immigra 23 Jun 1999 SCS Lord Abernethy Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Mohammed Shariff and Syed Kirmani for Exercise of the Nobile Officium Etc 23 Jun 1999 SCS Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Kaur v Singh and others [1999] ScotCS 312 23 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Buchanan v Alba Diagnostics Ltd [1999] ScotCS 159; [2000] RPC 367 24 Jun 1999 OHCS Lord Hamilton Scotland, Intellectual Property The pursuer developed and patented a brake fluid safety device. They obtained an interest free loan, and as security assigned the patent and any future developments. After the enforcement of the debt, the lenders sold the assignment to the defenders who made improvements which they patented. The pursuer claimed that those improvements infringed the patent. 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Hector Riley v Her Majesty's Advocate 24 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Justice General and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Sheila Fowlie (Claim No 143) and Assuranceforeningen Skuld v the International Oil Pollution Compensation Fund and others and and Objections By James Robb (Claim No 90) and Huxter Salmon Limited (Claim No 110) [1999] ScotCS 160 24 Jun 1999 SCS Lord Gill Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Hector Riley v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 167 24 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Caterina Ann Ranaldi v the City of Edinburgh Council [1999] ScotCS 161 25 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Paul Cullington v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 172 25 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Bonomy and Lord Marnoch and Lord Justice Clerk Scotland, Crime The defendant appealed his conviction for indecent assault. He challenged the use of evidence of distress as corroboration of an allegation that violence had been threatened or used. Held: The appeal failed. There was no reason to distinguish between acts of rape and of indecent assault on the issue of the weight of such evidence: 'we see no reason whatever why the evidence in question should not corroborate the evidence of the present complainer as to her lack of consent to the appellant's conduct and the use of force by him in exactly the same way as such evidence is used in cases of rape. ' The Sherriff had not been applying the case of Stob which had since been overruled. 1 Cites [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Sutherland and Yair v Procurator Fiscal, Kilmarnock [1999] ScotHC 169 25 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Coulsfield and Lord Hamilton Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Crawford v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 168 25 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Caterina Ann Ranaldi v the City of Edinburgh Council 25 Jun 1999 SCS Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Abernethy and Lord Allanbridge Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Niall Ferguson Thomson v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 170 25 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Paul Antony Mowat and Peter Davidson and Martin Mcglinchey and Shaun Burns and Muir James Reid Mclaughlin and Ryan James Renwicks v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 171 25 Jun 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Niall Ferguson Thomson v Her Majesty's Advocate 25 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Hamilton and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Brian Thompson Moffatt v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 173 26 Jun 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Hamilton and Lord Justice Clerk Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Karen Anne Thomson and Another v Douglas Amateur Football Club Social Club and Leonard Wallace [1999] ScotSC 19 27 Jun 1999 ScSf Sheriff R.A. Davidson Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Campbell v North Lanarkshire Council and Scottish Power Plc [1999] ScotCS 163 30 Jun 1999 SCS Lord Reed Scotland, Personal Injury 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Kinloch Damph Limited v Nordvik Salmon Farms Limited and others [1999] ScotCS 162 30 Jun 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Kinloch Damph Limited v Nordvik Salmon Farms Limited and others 30 Jun 1999 SCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Gunther Robert Macleod v Procurator Fiscal, Dingwall [1999] ScotHC 174 2 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Prosser and Lord Osborne Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Procurator Fiscal, Aberdeen v Aberdeen City Council 2 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Osborne and Lord Prosser Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Procurator Fiscal, Aberdeen v Aberdeen City Council [1999] ScotHC 176 2 Jul 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Gregory Francis Bothwell v British Railways Board [1999] ScotCS 164 2 Jul 1999 SCS Lord Dawson Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Neil Grant Dawson v Procurator Fiscal, Elgin [1999] ScotHC 175 2 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Osborne and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Reclaiming Motion By Respondent In Pet and Ans By M D v A L D Or B Or B for an Order Under the Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985 [1999] ScotCS 165 6 Jul 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Reclaiming Motion By Respondent In Pet and Ans By M D v A L D Or B Or B for an Order Under the Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985 6 Jul 1999 SCS Lord Allanbridge and Lord Kirkwood and Lord Prosser Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Alan James Glancy v Procurator Fiscal, Edinburgh 7 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord McCluskey and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â James Jenkinson Wilson v Procurator Fiscal, Dunoon [1999] ScotHC 180 7 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord McCluskey and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Henry Leo Friel v Procurator Fiscal, Greenock 7 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord McCluskey and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Andrew Walker Penman v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 178 7 Jul 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Henry Leo Friel v Procurator Fiscal, Greenock [1999] ScotHC 179 7 Jul 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Andrew Walker Penman v Her Majesty's Advocate 7 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Marnoch and Lord Bonomy Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Bristol and West Building Society v Messrs Aitken Nairn, W S [1999] ScotCS 166 7 Jul 1999 OHCS Lord Penrose Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Alan James Glancy v Procurator Fiscal, Edinburgh [1999] ScotHC 177 7 Jul 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â John Paterson v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 181 8 Jul 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Livie v Norrie or Livie [1999] ScotSC 20 8 Jul 1999 ScSf Sheriff R.A. Davidson Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Stuart Balfour Bisset and Mrs Kay Bisset v Standard Property Investment Plc 8 Jul 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Stuart Balfour Bisset and Mrs Kay Bisset v Standard Property Investment Plc [1999] ScotCS 167 8 Jul 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â John Paterson v Her Majesty's Advocate 8 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Kirkwood and Lord Justice Clerk Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â John Dundee Kerr and Graeme Bruce Squire v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 184 9 Jul 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Ronald Caskie Mckenzie v The Law Society of Scotland [1999] ScotCS 168 9 Jul 1999 SCS Scotland, Legal Professions [ Bailii ] Â Ronald Caskie Mckenzie v The Law Society of Scotland 9 Jul 1999 SCS Lord Prosser Scotland, Legal Professions [ ScotC ] Â John Dundee Kerr and Graeme Bruce Squire v Her Majesty's Advocate 9 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Bonomy and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Marnoch Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Gordon v British Airways Plc [1999] ScotCS 169 9 Jul 1999 SCS Lord Eassie Scotland, Personal Injury The pursuer sought reparation in respect of injuries said to have been suffered by him in an accident while he was working as a maintenance worker with the defenders at Glasgow Airport. [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v S 9 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Caplan Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Colin Turnbull Reid v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 182 9 Jul 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v S [1999] ScotHC 183 9 Jul 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Colin Turnbull Reid v Her Majesty's Advocate 9 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Bonomy and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Marnoch Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Allied London and Scottish Properties Plc v Riverbrae Construction Limited [1999] ScotCS 170 12 Jul 1999 SCS Lord Kingarth Construction, Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Michelle Suzanna Williamson and Alexander Scott Allan v Procurator Fiscal, Kirkcaldy [1999] ScotHC 186 13 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Cowie and Lord MacLean Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â John Thomson Love v Procurator Fiscal, Hamilton 13 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Coulsfield and Lord MacLean Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â John Thomson Love v Procurator Fiscal, Hamilton [1999] ScotHC 185 13 Jul 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Ruslanus Irzekevikius for Judicial Review of Decisions of the Secretary of State for the Home Department, a Special Adjudicator and the Immigration Ap [1999] ScotCS 172 14 Jul 1999 SCS Scotland, Immigration [ Bailii ] Â Blackfriars (Scotland) Ltd v John Laurie 14 Jul 1999 SCS Lord Penrose Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Ruslanus Irzekevikius for Judicial Review of Decisions of the Secretary of State for the Home Department, A Special Adjudicator and the Immigration Ap 14 Jul 1999 SCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland, Immigration [ ScotC ] Â Victoria Hilary Littlejohn v Procurator Fiscal, Perth 14 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord McCluskey and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Blackfriars (Scotland) Ltd v John Laurie [1999] ScotCS 171 14 Jul 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Victoria Hilary Littlejohn v Procurator Fiscal, Perth [1999] ScotHC 187 14 Jul 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Summit Lease Finance (No 2) Limited v Lithoprint (Scotland) Limited 16 Jul 1999 SCS Lord Penrose Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Summit Lease Finance (No 2) Limited v Lithoprint (Scotland) Limited 16 Jul 1999 SCS Lord Penrose Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Martyn Imrie for Judicial Review of a Decision of Comhairlie Nan Eilean Siar, a Local Authority Constituted In Terms of the Local Government (Scotland [1999] ScotCS 173 16 Jul 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Summit Lease Finance (No 2) Limited v Lithoprint (Scotland) Limited [1999] ScotCS 174 16 Jul 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Summit Lease Finance (No 2) Limited v Lithoprint (Scotland) Limited [1999] ScotCS 175 16 Jul 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Martyn Imrie for Judicial Review of A Decision of Comhairlie Nan Eilean Siar, A Local Authority Constituted In Terms of the Local Government (Scotland 16 Jul 1999 SCS Lord MacLean Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v Lee John Mccann and William Somerville [1999] ScotSC 21 19 Jul 1999 ScSf Sheriff K.A. Ross Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â The City of Aberdeen Council v W A Fairhurst and others [1999] ScotCS 176 20 Jul 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â the City of Aberdeen Council v W A Fairhurst and others 20 Jul 1999 SCS Lord Penrose Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Zahida Naz Jamil for Judicial Review of a Decision Not To Revoke a Deportation Order In Terms of the Immigration Act 1971, Section 5(2) [1999] ScotCS 178 21 Jul 1999 SCS Scotland, Immigration Immigration Act 1971 5(2) [ Bailii ] Â Zahida Naz Jamil for Judicial Review of A Decision Not To Revoke A Deportation Order In Terms of the Immigration Act 1971, Section 5(2) 21 Jul 1999 SCS Lord Eassie Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Rorrison v West Lothian College and Lothian Regional Council [1999] ScotCS 177; 2000 SCLR 245 21 Jul 1999 OHCS Lord Reed Scotland, Personal Injury, Employment The pursuer, a nurse, claimed that she suffered psychological injuries as a result of her treatment at work by two superiors. Held: The court could find nothing in the pleadings: "which, if proved, could establish that Andrews and Henning ought to have foreseen that the pursuer was under a material risk of sustaining a psychiatric disorder in consequence of their behaviour towards her. They might have foreseen that she would at times be unsatisfied, frustrated, embarrassed and upset, but that is a far cry from suffering a psychiatric disorder. Many if not all employees are liable to suffer those emotions, and others mentioned in the present case such as stress, anxiety, loss of confidence and low mood. To suffer such emotions from time to time, not least because of problems at work, is a normal part of human experience. It is only if they are liable to be suffered to such a pathological degree as to constitute a psychiatric disorder that a duty of care to protect against them can arise; and that is not a reasonably foreseeable occurrence (reasonably foreseeable, that is to say by an ordinary bystander rather than by a psychiatrist) unless there is some specific reason to foresee it in a particular case." 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Alexander Love v Her Majesty's Advocate 21 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Hamilton and Lord Justice General and Lord Coulsfield Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v Michael Mcginlay 21 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Coulsfield and Lord Macfadyen Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v McGinlay [1999] ScotHC 189 21 Jul 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Alexander Love v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 188 21 Jul 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Mellors v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 192 22 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Macfadyen and Lord Hamilton Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Harjit Singh for Judicial Review of (1) a Decision of the Secretary of State for the Home Department; (2) a Determination of a Special Adjudicator an [1999] ScotCS 179 22 Jul 1999 SCS Lord Eassie Scotland, Immigration [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â James Callander and Son Limited v Procurator Fiscal, Falkirk [1999] ScotHC 190 22 Jul 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â James Callander and Son Limited v Procurator Fiscal, Falkirk 22 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Cowie and Lord Milligan Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Mary Ryan and Patrick Francis Devine and Francis M T O'Donnell v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 191 22 Jul 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â City of Glasgow District Council v Robert W Peart and Tracey Hood Or Peart [1999] ScotCS 180 23 Jul 1999 SCS Lord Philip Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Steven Steele Urquhart v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 195 23 Jul 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Helen John v Procurator Fiscal, Dumbarton [1999] ScotHC 194 23 Jul 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Andrew William Mccallum v Procurator Fiscal, Hamilton 23 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Cowie and Lord Milligan Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Helen John v Procurator Fiscal, Dumbarton 23 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Cowie and Lord Milligan Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Steven Steele Urquhart v Her Majesty's Advocate 23 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Justice General and Lord Macfadyen Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â John (Helen) v Donnelly [1999] ScotHC HCJ - 257 23 Jul 1999 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Â Andrew William Mccallum v Procurator Fiscal, Hamilton [1999] ScotHC 193 23 Jul 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Watt or Forsyth (Assisted Person) v the Royal Bank of Scotland Plc [1999] ScotCS 181; 2000 SLT 1295 26 Jul 1999 SCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland, Banking It appeared to the creditor that the wife had already had the benefit of professional legal advice, and it did not recommend that she should seek independent legal advice. 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Kenneth John Mackenzie v Her Majesty's Advocate 27 Jul 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Cowie and Lord MacLean Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Kenneth John Mackenzie v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 196 27 Jul 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Beatrice Cummings Mckenzie Bogie Or Nisbet Or Jackson v Peter Jackson [1999] ScotCS 182 28 Jul 1999 OHCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â F A G Or W v J L W and K H W [1999] ScotSC 23 2 Aug 1999 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Colin Mccafferty v William Muir Mccafferty 2 Aug 1999 ScSf Sheriff A.L. Stewart Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Colin Mccafferty v William Muir Mccafferty [1999] ScotSC 22 2 Aug 1999 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Â William Mackenzie for Judicial Review of a Decision of the Employment Appeal Tribunal (Scotland) [1999] ScotCS 183 2 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â William Mackenzie for Judicial Review of A Decision of the Employment Appeal Tribunal (Scotland) 2 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Cameron of Lochbroom Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Noel Ruddle v the Secretary of State for Scotland 2 Aug 1999 ScSf Sheriff J Douglas Allan Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Stewart Dick Nicoll v the Chief Constable Tayside Police 2 Aug 1999 ScSf Sheriff John McInnes, QC Scotland [ ScotC ] Â F A G Or W v J L W and K H W 2 Aug 1999 ScSf Sheriff Principal C.G.B. Nicholson Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Stewart Dick Nicoll v the Chief Constable Tayside Police [1999] ScotSC 25 2 Aug 1999 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Noel Ruddle v the Secretary of State for Scotland [1999] ScotSC 24 2 Aug 1999 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Â David Taylor v City of Glasgow Council 3 Aug 1999 SCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Â David Taylor v City of Glasgow Council [1999] ScotCS 185 3 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Young or Logan v Falkirk and District Royal Infirmary NHS Trust [1999] ScotCS 184 3 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Reed Scotland, Damages 1 Cites [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v Allan Selfridge and Angela Helen Bain [1999] ScotHC 197 4 Aug 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Cowie and Lord MacLean Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Sean Randall Mcaloon v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotCS 186 4 Aug 1999 SCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Thorne v Procurator Fiscal, Dunfermline [1999] ScotHC 198 5 Aug 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Coulsfield and Lord Macfadyen Scotland, Crime 1 Cites [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Bhattacharjee v The Secretary of State for the Home Department for Judicial Review of A Determination of A Special Adjudicator and the Immigration Appeal Tribunal 6 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Bonomy Scotland, Immigration [ ScotC ] Â Belgrade Ltd v Procurator Fiscal, Kilmarnock [1999] ScotHC 199 6 Aug 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Belgrade Ltd v Procurator Fiscal, Kilmarnock 6 Aug 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Cowie and Lord Milligan Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Christopher Paul Douglas and Sean Alexander Mcnulty v Procurator Fiscal, Edinburgh 6 Aug 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Cowie and Lord MacLean Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Christopher Paul Douglas and Sean Alexander McNulty v Procurator Fiscal, Edinburgh [1999] ScotHC 200 6 Aug 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Bessie Bease Ewan Or Sharp (Ap) v Kevin Henderson [1999] ScotCS 187 6 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Bhattacharjee v The Secretary of State for the Home Department for Judicial Review of a Determination of a Special Adjudicator and the Immigration Appeal Tribunal [1999] ScotCS 188 6 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland, Immigration [ Bailii ] Â Bessie Bease Ewan Or Sharp (Ap) v Kevin Henderson 6 Aug 1999 SCS J.M.S. Horsburgh, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Â William Morton Murray v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 203 10 Aug 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Cowie and Lord MacLean Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Pet and Complaint of Abdelbasset Ali Mohamed Al Megrahi and Al Amin Khalifa Fhima v Times Newspapers Ltd and John Witherow and Nicholas Rufford [1999] ScotHC 202 10 Aug 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Coulsfield and Lord Caplan Scotland, Contempt of Court, Media 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â James Anthony Turnock v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 201 10 Aug 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â James Anthony Turnock v Her Majesty's Advocate 10 Aug 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Cowie and Lord MacLean Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Thomas Frederick Mcarthur v Her Majesty's Advocate 11 Aug 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Justice General and Lord MacLean Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Thomas Frederick Mcarthur v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 206 11 Aug 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Gerard John Maher v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 205 11 Aug 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Alan Michael Shields v Procurator Fiscal, Dumbarton [1999] ScotHC 204 11 Aug 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Justice General and Lord Kirkwood Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Gerard John Maher v Her Majesty's Advocate 11 Aug 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Sutherland and Lord Allanbridge Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Stephen Gayne v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow 12 Aug 1999 HCJ Lord Bonomy and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Marnoch Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Stephen Gayne v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow [1999] ScotHC 207 12 Aug 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Reclaiming Motion In Pet of Booker Aquaculture Ltd v The Secretary of State for Scotland for Judicial Review of the Diseases of Fish (Control) Regulations 1994 for Answers for Respondent [1999] ScotCS 189 12 Aug 1999 SCS Lord President and Lord McCluskey and Lord Sutherland Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Nicholas John Paxton v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 208 13 Aug 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â T R (Application By Grampian Regional Council) [1999] ScotCS 192 13 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland, Adoption Adoption (Scotland) Act 1978 8 [ Bailii ] Â T R (Application Under Adoption (Scotland) Act 1978, Section 8 By Grampian Regional Council 13 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Prosser Scotland [ ScotC ] Â North Anderson Cars Ltd Against A Decision of the Edinburgh Vat Tribunal Dated 18 March 1998 13 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Justice Clerk Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Reclaiming Motion In Petition of Dr Avril Osborne for Interdict v British Broadcasting Corporation and Another and the Orcadian Limited [1999] ScotCS 191 13 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Coulsfield Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Nicholas John Paxton v Her Majesty's Advocate 13 Aug 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Sutherland and Lord Coulsfield Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â North Anderson Cars Ltd Against a Decision of the Edinburgh Vat Tribunal Dated 18 March 1998 [1999] ScotCS 190 13 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Robert Andrew v Her Majesty's Advocate 16 Aug 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord McCluskey and Lord Allanbridge Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Robert Andrew v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 209 16 Aug 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Derek Brown v Stanley Prosser and Another [1999] ScotCS 193 17 Aug 1999 OHCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Ian Gaul v Frank Deerey and others 17 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Kingarth Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Ian Gaul v Frank Deerey and others [1999] ScotCS 194 17 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Alba Tools Limited v Nigel Alexander Buchanan and Liquid Levers (1993) Limited [1999] ScotCS 196 19 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Osborne Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Â Her Majesty's Advocate v Carnall and Callaghan and McGing; HCJ 19-Aug-1999 - [1999] ScotHC 210 Â Michael John Mcgarry v Her Majesty's Advocate 19 Aug 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Coulsfield and Lord Reed Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Michael John Mcgarry v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 211 19 Aug 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â In Appeal Under Section 239 of the Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997 By Bass Taverns Limited Against A Decision of the Secretary of State 20 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Kirkwood Scotland, Planning [ ScotC ] Â William Wilson v Pyeroy Limited [1999] ScotCS 199 20 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Reed Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â In Appeal Under the Industrial Tribunals Act 1996 By Colin Heggie v Uniroyal Englebert Tyres Ltd 20 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Milligan Scotland, Employment Industrial Tribunals Act 1996 [ ScotC ] Â In Appeal Under the Industrial Tribunals Act 1996 By Colin Heggie v Uniroyal Englebert Tyres Ltd [1999] ScotCS 198 20 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â In Appeal Under Section 239 of the Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997 By Bass Taverns Limited Against a Decision of the Secretary of State [1999] ScotCS 197 20 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Colin Bryson Campbell v Procurator Fiscal, Stirling [1999] ScotHC 213 26 Aug 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Discovery Communications Inc v Discovery Fm Ltd [1999] ScotCS 200 26 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Discovery Communications Inc v Discovery Fm Ltd 26 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Colin Bryson Campbell v Procurator Fiscal, Stirling 26 Aug 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Coulsfield and Lord Macfadyen Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Procurator Fiscal, Falkirk v William Dick 30 Aug 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Kirkwood and Lord Cowie Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v Andrew Innes [1999] ScotCS 201 31 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v Mrs Shona Anne Scrimgeour Or Roe and Another [1999] ScotCS 212 31 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v Mrs Martha Sarah Murphy Or Young and others [1999] ScotCS 211 31 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v Mrs Dawn Elizabeth Moar Or Robb and Another [1999] ScotCS 210 31 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v Mrs Christine Anne Davies Or Skovronek and Another [1999] ScotCS 209 31 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v Mrs Alice Clark Or Campbell and others [1999] ScotCS 208 31 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v Miss Wendy Parker and Another [1999] ScotCS 207 31 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v John Leonard Barr [1999] ScotCS 206 31 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v Jane Margaret Gaffney Or Ross [1999] ScotCS 205 31 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v George Watson [1999] ScotCS 204 31 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v Gavin Innes [1999] ScotCS 203 31 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v Wendy Torrance Or Fullerton Or Carmichael and others [1999] ScotCS 214 31 Aug 1999 OHCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v Mrs Shona Derrick, Known As Innes, and others [1999] ScotCS 213 31 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v David Gale William Davis [1999] ScotCS 202 31 Aug 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v Gavin Innes 31 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Alexander Love v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 214 31 Aug 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v John Leonard Barr 31 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v Andrew Innes 31 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v Jane Margaret Gaffney Or Ross 31 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v Mrs Martha Sarah Murphy Or Young and others 31 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v David Gale William Davis 31 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v Mrs Dawn Elizabeth Moar Or Robb and Another 31 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v Wendy Parker and Another 31 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Alexander Love v Her Majesty's Advocate 31 Aug 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Hamilton and Lord Justice General Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v George Watson 31 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v Mrs Alice Clark Or Campbell and others 31 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Burnside Kemp Fraser and others v Mrs Shona Derrick, Known As Innes, and others 31 Aug 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â The Newtongrange Branch of the Cottish National Party and others v Judicial Review of a Pretended Decision of the National Executive Committee of the Scottish National Party Dated 10 July 1999 [1999] ScotCS 215 1 Sep 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â the Newtongrange Branch of the Cottish National Party and others v Judicial Review of A Pretended Decision of the National Executive Committee of the Scottish National Party Dated 10 July 1999 1 Sep 1999 SCS Lord Osborne Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Caroline Mcnab v Her Majesty's Advocate 2 Sep 1999 HCJ Lord Allanbridge and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord McCluskey Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Thomas Reid Allan v Her Majesty's Advocate 2 Sep 1999 HCJ Lord Allanbridge and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Thomas Reid Allan v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 216 2 Sep 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Caroline Mcnab v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 215 2 Sep 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Andrew Bryan and Company Ltd v D F Storage and Distribution Ltd [1999] ScotCS 216 3 Sep 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Andrew Bryan and Company Ltd v D F Storage and Distribution Ltd 3 Sep 1999 SCS Lord Osborne Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Procurator Fiscal, Paisley v Scott and Manners and Smith etc [1999] ScotHC 217 7 Sep 1999 IHCS Lord Justice General and Lord Kirkwood and Lord Cowie Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Gibbs-Palmer (Holdings) Ltd v Gibbs-Palmer (Midland) Ltd [1999] ScotCS 217 8 Sep 1999 OHCS Lord Caplan Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Linda Smith and others v Upper Clyde Shipbuilders Ltd (In Liquidation) and Another 8 Sep 1999 SCS Lord Bonomy Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Linda Smith and others v Upper Clyde Shipbuilders Ltd (In Liquidation) and Another [1999] ScotCS 218 8 Sep 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v Annie Mulvey Harkins Gourlay Or Dickson [1999] ScotHC 218 10 Sep 1999 HCJ Lord Osborne and Lord Reed and G.H. Gordon, QC Scotland 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â James M Anderson v Violet Fisher and Another 14 Sep 1999 SCS J.M.S. Horsburgh, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Â James M Anderson v Violet Fisher and Another [1999] ScotCS 219 14 Sep 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â John Alexander Thomson v Procurator Fiscal, Alloa [1999] ScotHC 220 14 Sep 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â John Alexander Thomson v Procurator Fiscal, Alloa 14 Sep 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord McCluskey and Lord Penrose Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Procurator Fiscal, Wick v Kenneth West [1999] ScotHC 222 15 Sep 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Procurator Fiscal, Wick v Kenneth West 15 Sep 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Allanbridge and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Morrison-Low v Paterson and Another [1999] ScotCS 220 16 Sep 1999 IHCS Lord Abernethy and Lord Allanbridge and Lord Kirkwood Scotland, Agriculture 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Societe General S A v Lloyds TSB Bank Plc and Oakstead Garages Limited [1999] ScotCS 221 17 Sep 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Societe General S A v Lloyds TSB Bank Plc and Oakstead Garages Limited 17 Sep 1999 SCS Lord Cullen Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Neil Grant Murray, Mark James Hartley and Steven Simpson v Her Majesty's Advocate 19 Sep 1999 HCJ Lord Bonomy and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Marnoch Scotland, Criminal Sentencing The defendants appealed against sentence. The first and second were youths who had been convicted of a vicious and homophobic murder, and had been sentenced to be detained without limit of time. The third had also been convicted of a savage and brutal murder committed whilst a youth, and had received a sentence under the 1989 Act in the same terms. There was no provision for the possibility of release after a specified time. The Lord Justice General had certified the times to be served. They argued that the sentences included an element of deterrence, which had not been allowed for under the Act. Held: there had been an extension of the system for reviewing the sentences of discretionary life prisoners, whose sentences had already been imposed before the Act and who had been under 18 at the time. Their Lordships set out the procedures under the 1997 Act. The same list of considerations applied as would apply when the court considered the sentence in the first place, including anything which might have been put forward by way of mitigation or aggravation. Discretionary life sentences were imposed just because the court was concerned at the need to protect the public. It includes an element to reflect the crime and a part to protect the public. The Act intended to fix the first part after the event so that the need to protect the public could be tested before the parole board. The O'Neill case was not a good guide for dealing with discretionary sentences. One minimum period was adjusted, the others remained. Crime and Punishment (Scotland) Act 1997 16(2) - Prisons (Scotland) Act 1989 26(1) 1 Cites [ ScotC ] Â Neil Grant Murray, Mark James Hartley and Steven Simpson v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 223 19 Sep 1999 ScHC Scotland, Criminal Sentencing [ Bailii ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v Colin Bryson Campbell [1999] ScotCS 222 21 Sep 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v Colin Bryson Campbell 21 Sep 1999 SCS Lord Cameron of Lochbroom Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Ferguson Shipbuilders Ltd v Voith Hydro Gmbh and Co and others [1999] ScotCS 223 23 Sep 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â John Catleugh (Ap) v Caradon Everest Limited [1999] ScotCS 224 23 Sep 1999 SCS Lord Marnoch Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Pearson v Lynn Mary Margaret Carrick Or Pearson [1999] ScotCS 225 23 Sep 1999 SCS Lord McCluskey Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Ferguson Shipbuilders Ltd v Voith Hydro Gmbh and Co and others 23 Sep 1999 SCS Lord Penrose Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Stuart Douglas Walker v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 224 24 Sep 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Stuart Douglas Walker v Her Majesty's Advocate 24 Sep 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Coulsfield and Lord McCluskey Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v Colin Bryson Campbell 28 Sep 1999 HCJ Lord Cameron of Lochbroom Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v Colin Bryson Campbell [1999] ScotHC 225 28 Sep 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Tom Super Printing Supplies Ltd and Another v South Lanarkshire Council [1999] ScotCS 227 28 Sep 1999 OHCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â John Briggs v South Eastern Recovery Iii Plc [1999] ScotCS 226 28 Sep 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â John Briggs v South Eastern Recovery Iii Plc 28 Sep 1999 SCS Lord Prosser Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Inverness Seafield Development Co Ltd v D C S Mackintosh [1999] ScotCS 229 30 Sep 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Inverness Seafield Development Co Ltd v D C S Mackintosh 30 Sep 1999 SCS Lord Johnston Scotland [ ScotC ] Â George Scott Bennett (Ap) v Messrs J Lamont and Sons and others and Fife Council [1999] ScotCS 228 30 Sep 1999 OHCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â James Gilday v Procurator Fiscal, Stirling [1999] ScotHC 226 1 Oct 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Dramgate Ltd v Tyne Dock Engineering Ltd and others 1 Oct 1999 SCS Lord Cameron of Lochbroom Scotland [ ScotC ] Â James Gilday v Procurator Fiscal, Stirling 1 Oct 1999 HCJ Lord Penrose Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Dramgate Ltd v Tyne Dock Engineering Ltd and others [1999] ScotCS 230 1 Oct 1999 SCS Scotland, Transport 1 Cites [ Bailii ] Â Jean Gisbey Or Marshall v Malcolm Marshall (Otherwise Known As Calum Marshall) [1999] ScotCS 231 5 Oct 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v S [1999] ScotHC 227 5 Oct 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v S 5 Oct 1999 HCJ Lord Caplan Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Jean Gisbey Or Marshall v Malcolm Marshall (Otherwise Known As Calum Marshall) 5 Oct 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â William Wotherspoon v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 228 5 Oct 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Kevin Barry Cannon v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 229 6 Oct 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Michael Patterson v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 230 6 Oct 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Ross Samuel Telfer v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 231 6 Oct 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Michael Patterson v Her Majesty's Advocate 6 Oct 1999 HCJ Lord Allanbridge and Lord Justice General and Lord Marnoch Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Ross Samuel Telfer v Her Majesty's Advocate 6 Oct 1999 HCJ Lord Allanbridge and Lord Justice General and Lord Marnoch Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Kevin Barry Cannon v Her Majesty's Advocate 6 Oct 1999 HCJ Lord Allanbridge and Lord Justice General and Lord Marnoch Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Hma v Mclean [1999] ScotHC HCJ - 258 6 Oct 1999 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Â Petition of Alan Turner (Ap) for Judicial Review of A Decision of A Social Security Commissioner To Refuse Leave To Appeal 7 Oct 1999 SCS Lord Philip Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Petition of Alan Turner (Ap) for Judicial Review of a Decision of a Social Security Commissioner To Refuse Leave To Appeal [1999] ScotCS 232 7 Oct 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â John Mccue v (First) Scottish Daily Record and Sunday Mail Limited and (Second) Norman Silvester [1999] ScotCS 234 8 Oct 1999 SCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Anthony D Green v John Gill and others [1999] ScotCS 233 8 Oct 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Enrico Usai v Procurator Fiscal, Cupar [1999] ScotHC 232 8 Oct 1999 HCJ Lord Cowie and Lord Penrose and Lord McCluskey Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Anthony D Green v John Gill and others 8 Oct 1999 SCS Lord Osborne Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Alistair Moffat v West Highland Publishing Co Ltd [1999] ScotCS 235 11 Oct 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Alistair Moffat v West Highland Publishing Co Ltd 11 Oct 1999 SCS Lord Cameron of Lochbroom Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Carol Wilson v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow [1999] ScotHC 233 13 Oct 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Gala Leisure Ltd v Judicial Review of A Decision of the City of Glasgow Licensing Board To Refuse an Application for A Direction Under Section 32 of the Gaming Act 1968 13 Oct 1999 SCS Lord McCluskey Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Elizabeth Catherine Chisholm Or Gray v James Alexander Gray [1999] ScotCS 236 13 Oct 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Elizabeth Catherine Chisholm or Gray v James Alexander Gray 13 Oct 1999 SCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ ScotC ] Â James Keegan v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow [1999] ScotHC 234 13 Oct 1999 HCJ Lord Allanbridge and Lord Kirkwood and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Carol Wilson v Procurator Fiscal, Glasgow 13 Oct 1999 HCJ Lord Allanbridge and Lord Kirkwood and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Terry Symmers v Procurator Fiscal, Edinburgh [1999] ScotHC 235 13 Oct 1999 HCJ Lord Allanbridge and Lord Kirkwood and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Gala Leisure Ltd v Judicial Review of a Decision of the City of Glasgow Licensing Board To Refuse an Application for a Direction Under Section 32 of the Gaming Act 1968 [1999] ScotCS 237 13 Oct 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â John Montgomery v R G C (Offshore) Limited [1999] ScotCS 238 14 Oct 1999 SCS Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â The Royal Society for the Protection of Birds and the Wildfowl and Wetlands Trust Ltd for Judicial Review of A Decision of the Secretary of State To Grant Licences To Shhot Barnacle Geese Times, 14 December 1999; [1999] ScotCS 239 14 Oct 1999 OHCS Lord Johnston Environment, European, Judicial Review, Scotland When reviewing a decision applying European law, that procedure was the same as for testing a decision made under English law. There is no provision for the examination of factual basis of the decision. When assessing whether a licence was to be granted for the shooting of a protected species, the test for such a licence was the protection of crops. The view of whether the survival of the species was threatened was to be looked at in the light of the entire population,. Not just that at the license site. EC Birds Directive 79/409/EEC [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Joseph Byrne v Her Majesty's Advocate 18 Oct 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Dawson and Lord Justice General and Lord Johnston and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Joseph Byrne v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 236 18 Oct 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â East of Scotland Water Authority v Andrew Logan [1999] ScotCS 242 19 Oct 1999 OHCS Lord Coulsfield Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Ali v Andrew Or Ali [1999] ScotCS 241 19 Oct 1999 SCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â James Hardie (Ap) v Keller Colcrete Limited and Lothian Health Board 20 Oct 1999 SCS Lord Johnston Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Stuart Adamson v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 237 20 Oct 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Pieter Rossmeier v Mounthooly Transport and others 20 Oct 1999 SCS Lord President Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Stuart Adamson v Her Majesty's Advocate 20 Oct 1999 HCJ Lord Sutherland and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Allanbridge Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Pieter Rossmeier v Mounthooly Transport and others [1999] ScotCS 244 20 Oct 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â James Hardie (Ap) v Keller Colcrete Limited and Lothian Health Board [1999] ScotCS 243 20 Oct 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Abbey National Plc v Arthur and Sutherland [1999] ScotCS 245 21 Oct 1999 OHCS Lord Prosser Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â David Thomas Cairns v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 238 21 Oct 1999 HCJ Lord Marnoch and Lord Justice General and Lord Allanbridge Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Montgomery Litho Limited v John Maxwell [1999] ScotCS 246 21 Oct 1999 OHCS Lord Sutherland Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Singh v Secretary of State for the Home Department [1999] ScotCS 310 26 Oct 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Parminder Singh v Secretary of State for the Home Department 26 Oct 1999 SCS Lord Kirkwood Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Hamilton and Hamilton v Rodwell and others [1999] ScotCS 247 27 Oct 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Discovery Communications Inc v Discovery F M Ltd [1999] ScotCS 248 28 Oct 1999 SCS Lord Marnoch Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â J A C (Ap) v R C 28 Oct 1999 SCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland [ ScotC ] Â J A C (Ap) v R C [1999] ScotCS 249 28 Oct 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Maclean v Caledonian Macbrayne Ltd [1999] ScotCS 250 28 Oct 1999 SCS Lord Prosser Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Shetland Sea Farms Ltd (Claim No 71) In the Cause Assuranceforeningen Skuld v the International Oil Pollution Compensation Fund and others and Objections By the Iopfc, James Robb, Brian Robb (Claim No 90) and Alexander Eunson (C [1999] ScotCS 251 28 Oct 1999 SCS Lord Gill Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Pet Mohammed Aslam Farkan for Judicial Review of A Decision of the Immigration and Nationality Department 29 Oct 1999 SCS Lord Penrose Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Pet Mohammed Aslam Farkan for Judicial Review of a Decision of the Immigration and Nationality Department [1999] ScotCS 252 29 Oct 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â William Barclay Grant's Executors v William Grant [1999] ScotCS 253 29 Oct 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â William Barclay Grant's Executors v William Grant 29 Oct 1999 SCS Lord Reed Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Baxter Clark and Paul v Tulloch Construction Group Ltd [1999] ScotCS 254 2 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Penrose Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Gordon Mclean v Her Majesty's Advocate 3 Nov 1999 HCJ Lord Allanbridge and Lord Marnoch and Lord Justice General Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Gordon Mclean v Her Majesty's Advocate 3 Nov 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Allanbridge and Lord Marnoch Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Gordon Mclean v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 239 3 Nov 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Booker Aquaculture Ltd v The Scottish Ministers [1999] ScotCS 257 4 Nov 1999 SCS Lord President Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Mackay v Scottish Hydro Electric Plc [1999] ScotCS 258 4 Nov 1999 SCS Lady Cosgrove Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Alan Keenan v Aberdeen Slating Company Limited [1999] ScotCS 255 4 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Philip Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Arturo Russo v Adrian Russo Otherwise Known As John Hardie [1999] ScotCS 256 4 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Osborne Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Darren Docherty for Judical Review of A Decision of City of Edinburgh Council on 29Th July 1998 5 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Assessor for Tayside Valuation Joint Board v Joseph Johnston and Sons Ltd 5 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Prosser Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Mark David Pringle v Bryan Pringle [1999] ScotCS 262 5 Nov 1999 OHCS Lord Cowie Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Anthony Duffy v Her Majesty's Advocate 5 Nov 1999 HCJ Lord Coulsfield and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Marnoch Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Andrew Thompson v Procurator Fiscal, Hamilton 5 Nov 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Sutherland and Lord Caplan and Lord Hamilton Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Assessor for Tayside Valuation Joint Board v Joseph Johnston and Sons Ltd [1999] ScotCS 259 5 Nov 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Select Service Partner Ltd v the Assessor for Glasgow [1999] ScotCS 263 5 Nov 1999 OHCS Lord Prosser Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Andrew Thompson v Procurator Fiscal, Hamilton [1999] ScotHC 240 5 Nov 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Anthony Duffy v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 241 5 Nov 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Darren Docherty for Judical Review of a Decision of City of Edinburgh Council on 29Th July 1998 [1999] ScotCS 260 5 Nov 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â La Pantofola D'Oro S P A v Blane Leisure Ltd [1999] ScotCS 261 5 Nov 1999 OHCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â John Hardie v the City of Edinburgh Council for Judicial Review of A Decision To Remove the Petitioner From the List of Supply Teachers By the City of Edinburgh Cou [1999] ScotCS 265 10 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Osborne Scotland 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Homer Burgess Limited v Chirex (Annan) Limited 10 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Harinder Singh for Judicial Review of the Refusal of the Secretary of State for the Home Department To Allow the Petitioner To Remain In the U K 11 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Bonomy Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Ian Cumming v Mayen Holdings Limited [1999] ScotSC 26 11 Nov 1999 ScSf Sheriff Fiona Lennox Reith, QC Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Harinder Singh for Judicial Review of the Refusal of the Secretary of State for the Home Department To Allow the Petitioner To Remain In the U K [1999] ScotCS 266 11 Nov 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Procurator Fiscal, Linlithgow v Gary John Johnstone and David Michael Gunn [1999] ScotHC 243 11 Nov 1999 ScHC Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Prosser and Lord Reed Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Starrs and Chalmers and Bill of Advocattion for Procurator Fiscal, Linlithgow v Procurator Fiscal, Linlithgow and Hugh Latta Starrs and James Wilson Chalmers; Starrs v Ruxton, Ruxton v Starrs Times, 17 November 1999; 2000 JC 208; [1999] ScotHC 242; [2000] HRLR 191 11 Nov 1999 ScHC Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Prosser Human Rights, Administrative, Natural Justice, Scotland The system in Scotland whereby lesser judges were appointed by the executive, for a year at a time, and could be discharged without explanation or challenge, meant that they could be seen not to be independent, and the system was a breach of the right to a fair trial by an independent judiciary. There was no open protocol for making such decisions. Unconscious fears of influence in a judge's mind could be enough. Lord Prosser referred to the temporary nature of the appointment of Sherriffs: "But I am inclined to see independence – the need for a judge not to be dependent on others – as an additional substantive requirement, rather than simply a means of achieving impartiality or a perception of impartiality. Independence will guarantee not only that the judge is disinterested in relation to the parties and the cause, but also that in fulfilling his judicial function, generally as well as individual cases, he is and can be seen to be free of links with others (whether in the executive, or indeed the judiciary, or in outside life) which might, or might be thought to, affect his assessment of the matters entrusted to him." European Convention on Human Rights Art 6 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â the Rt Reverend Mark Dilworth Osb v Lovat Highland Estates Limited and the Trustees for St Benedict's Abbey, Fort Augustus and F A Properties Limited and the Trustees for St Benedict's Abbey, Fort Augustus 12 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Philip Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Luss Estates Company v G B Garman and Co and Hutchison and Craft Ltd 12 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Justice Clerk Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Assessor for City of Glasgow v Ron Wood Greeting Cards and others 12 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Coulsfield Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Â Lord Gray's Motion; HL 12-Nov-1999 - Times, 12 November 1999; Times, 12 November 1999; [1999] UKHL 53; 2000 SC (HL) 46; [2000] 2 WLR 664; [2002] 1 AC 124; 2000 SLT 1337 Â Assessor for City of Glasgow v Ron Wood Greeting Cards and others [1999] ScotCS 267 12 Nov 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Luss Estates Company v G B Garman and Co and Hutchison and Craft Ltd [1999] ScotCS 268 12 Nov 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â the Rt Reverend Mark Dilworth Osb v Lovat Highland Estates Limited and the Trustees for St Benedict's Abbey, Fort Augustus and F A Properties Limited and the Trustees for St Benedict's Abbey, Fort Augustus [1999] ScotCS 269 12 Nov 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Allied London and Scottish Properties Plc v Riverbrae Construction Ltd Times, 12 November 1999 12 Nov 1999 OHCS Construction, Scotland An adjudicator who acts under the Scheme upon the written submission of the parties and without any oral hearing was not able to consider making an order for payment of the award by installments where neither party had raised that issue in their written submissions. He was not required by the scheme to consider such a procedure. Housing Grants Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 108 Â Jamieson, A P for Judicial Review of A Decision of the Criminal Injuries Compensation Board [1999] ScotCS 272 16 Nov 1999 OHCS Lord Cameron of Lochbroom Scotland, Personal Injury [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â In the Petition of Neil John Cooper for Judicial Review of a Decision of the Secretary of State Not To Uphold an Appeal By the Petitioner [1999] ScotCS 271 16 Nov 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Robert Jackson Rodger v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 244 16 Nov 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â In the Petition of Neil John Cooper for Judicial Review of A Decision of the Secretary of State Not To Uphold an Appeal By the Petitioner 16 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Eassie Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Robert Jackson Rodger v Her Majesty's Advocate 16 Nov 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Kirkwood and Lord McCluskey Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Elizabeth Murray Laing v Scottish Arts Council [1999] ScotCS 270 16 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Penrose Scotland 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â David Gormley and Elizabeth Cowe Crawford Or Gormley v Her Majesty's Advocate 17 Nov 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord McCluskey and Lord Kirkwood Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â David Gormley and Elizabeth Cowe Crawford Or Gormley v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 245 17 Nov 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Lindsay Plant Limited v Norwest Holst Group Plc [1999] ScotCS 273 17 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland, Personal Injury, Health and Safety [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â John Ian Baird v Drumpelier and Mount Vernon Estates Ltd [1999] ScotCS 274 19 Nov 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Tom Super Printing and Supplies Limited and Another v South Lanarkshire Council [1999] ScotCS 275 19 Nov 1999 OHCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â John Ian Baird v Drumpelier and Mount Vernon Estates Ltd 19 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Hamilton Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Appeal for Third Party - Alexander Goudie v William Mulholland T/A Artlink and Artbank (Scotland) Limited 22 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Kirkwood Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Alexander Goudie v William Mulholland T/a Artlink and Artbank (Scotland) Limited [1999] ScotCS 276 22 Nov 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Robert K Forrest v James M Hendry 23 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Robert K Forrest v James M Hendry [1999] ScotCS 278 23 Nov 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Global Marine Drilling Company v Triton Holdings Limited [1999] ScotCS 277 23 Nov 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Global Marine Drilling Company v Triton Holdings Limited 23 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Marnoch Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Mckenna v Greater Glasgow Health Board [1999] ScotCS 279 24 Nov 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â William Wallace v Dundee City Council [1999] ScotSC 27 24 Nov 1999 ScSf Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Edinburgh Council Against A Decision of the Pensions Ombudsman 25 Nov 1999 SCS Lord McCluskey Scotland [ ScotC ] Â City of Edinburgh Council Against a Decision of the Pensions Ombudsman [1999] ScotCS 280 25 Nov 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â George Leslie Kerr (Aitken's Trustee) v Helen Aitken (Ap) [1999] ScotCS 282 26 Nov 1999 OHCS Lord Eassie Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â David Hannah v Scottish Daily Record and Sunday Mail Limited [1999] ScotCS 281 26 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Marnoch Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Whaley and Trevor Adams and Julia Margaret Furness for Interdict and Interim Interdict 26 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Johnston Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Jeremy Hagan Whaley and Trevor Adams and Julia Margaret Furness for Interdict and Interim Interdict [1999] ScotCS 283 26 Nov 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Linda Jane Hutchison Or Mcadam v Morrison Mcadam 30 Nov 1999 SCS Lord Cameron of Lochbroom Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Linda Jane Hutchison Or Mcadam v Morrison Mcadam [1999] ScotCS 284 30 Nov 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â The Topps Company Incorporated v Tom Hannah (Agencies) Ltd and others 1 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] Â the Topps Company Incorporated v Tom Hannah (Agencies) Ltd and others [1999] ScotCS 285 1 Dec 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â William Stephen v North of Scotland Water Authority [1999] ScotCS 287 2 Dec 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â William Stephen v North of Scotland Water Authority 2 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Marnoch Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Margaret Dunlop Harvey v Mactaggart and Mickel Limited [1999] ScotCS 286 2 Dec 1999 IHCS Lord McCluskey and Lord Caplan and Lord Osborne Scotland, Land [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â In Pet [1999] ScotCS 288 3 Dec 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Nicola Brown v East and Midlothian NHS Trust [1999] ScotCS 290 3 Dec 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Isabella Hay Easson v Dundee Teaching Hospitals National Health Service Trust [1999] ScotCS 289 3 Dec 1999 OHCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Nicola Brown v East and Midlothian NHS Trust 3 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] Â In Pet 3 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Douglas William Gibbs v Procurator Fiscal, Linlithgow [1999] ScotHC 247 4 Dec 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Irma Elina Helkimo Or Kennett Or Robertson v David Callum Robertson [1999] ScotCS 292 7 Dec 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Irma Elina Helkimo Or Kennett Or Robertson v David Callum Robertson 7 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Eassie Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Clydesdale Bank Plc v John Renton Mowbray [1999] ScotCS 291 7 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Kirkwood Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Her Majesty's Advocate v Abdelbaset Ali Mohmed Al Megrahi and Al Amin Khalifa Fhimah [1999] ScotHC 248 8 Dec 1999 HCJ Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime The court considered whether the criminal complaint that the defendants had been part of a conspiracy to set a bomb aboard an airliner which exploded over Scotland, was justiciable in Scotland. Lord Sutherland: "Where however, a crime of the utmost gravity has been in fact committed in a particular country and it can be shown that that crime is the culmination of a long drawn out and complex conspiracy, it appears to me quite illogical to say that that country has no interest in putting the conspirators on trial for their part in what has happened, even though their activities were all carried out abroad. Defence counsel recognise that this is undoubtedly so in relation to the charge of murder in Scotland. I see no logical reason why the same principle should not apply to the charge of conspiring to commit the final criminal act, which is alleged to be the culmination and the whole purpose of the conspiracy." 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Justin Etwala Okello Pyntek v Secretary of State for the Home Department [1999] ScotCS 293 9 Dec 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Justin Etwala Okello Pyntek v Secretary of State for the Home Department 9 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Caplan Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Alan John Howitt and Anthony Duffy v Her Majesty's Advocate 10 Dec 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord McCluskey and Lord Prosser and Lord Penrose and Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Report To the Inner House of the Court of Session By Clancy v Caird [1999] ScotHC 256 10 Dec 1999 HCJ Scotland, Crime [ Bailii ] Â Alan John Howitt and Anthony Duffy v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 249 10 Dec 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Clancy v Caird [1999] ScotCS 294 10 Dec 1999 OHCS T.G. Coutts, Q.C. Scotland 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Neil Johnston (Ap) v J T Inglis and Sons Ltd [1999] ScotCS 295 14 Dec 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Neil Johnston (Ap) v J T Inglis and Sons Ltd 14 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Bonomy Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Robert Carruthers v Her Majesty's Advocate 14 Dec 1999 HCJ Lord Justice General and Lord Prosser and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â Robert Carruthers v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 250 14 Dec 1999 ScHC Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Ian Patrick Souter v Aberdeen City Council [1999] ScotCS 297 15 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Sutherland Scotland [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Waydale Limited v D H L Holdings (Uk) Limited [1999] ScotCS 300 15 Dec 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Lee Sigourney v General Teaching Council for Scotland [1999] ScotCS 298 15 Dec 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Margaret Elizabeth Mccallum v S and D Properties (Commercial) Ltd &C 15 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Mrs Margaret Elizabeth Mccallum v S and D Properties (Commercial) Ltd &C [1999] ScotCS 299 15 Dec 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Alan Douglas Miller v the Council of the Law Society of Sotland [1999] ScotCS 296 15 Dec 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Waydale Limited v D H L Holdings (Uk) Limited 15 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Coulsfield Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Alan Douglas Miller v the Council of the Law Society of Sotland 15 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Lee Sigourney v General Teaching Council for Scotland 15 Dec 1999 SCS Lord President Scotland [ ScotC ] Â James Smith and Patricia Smith v Messrs Lindsay and Kirk and others 16 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Justice General Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Smith and Miller and Mcmorrine and Robbie the Pict v Procurator Fiscal, Dingwall [1999] ScotHC 251 16 Dec 1999 HCJ Lord Sutherland and Lord Marnoch and Lord Cowie Scotland, Constitutional The appellants challenged convictions under regulations imposing toll charges. They challenged the validity of the charges. Held: The first challenge was that the people collecting the charges had not been properly appointed, being private contractors. The regulations had been complied with. Second the orders themselves were said not to have been published as required, having been incorrectly classified as local instruments. They were properly classified as local and did not have to be printed by the Queen's printer and made available for sale. New Roads and Street Works Act 1991 38 - Assignation Statement (Prescribed Information)(Scotland) Regulations 1991 (S.I. 1991/2152) - Assignation Statement (Prescribed Information)(Scotland) Regulations 1991 - Statutory Instruments Act 1946 - Statutory Instruments Regulations 1947 (S.I. 1948/1) [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Andrew Connor v Secretary of State [1999] ScotCS 301 16 Dec 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Andrew Connor v Secretary of State 16 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Philip Scotland [ ScotC ] Â James Smith and Mrs Patricia Smith v Messrs Lindsay and Kirk and others Times, 16 March 2000; [1999] ScotCS 302 16 Dec 1999 SCS Contract, Limitation, Scotland Where a contract specifically provided that it would become unenforceable after two years from the date of the contract, an action for breach of contract, and not just an action for performance of it, was also time barred after the expiry of the agreed time. This applied even if, as in this case, the breach occurred within the two year period. The word 'enforceable' should not be given such a constrained meaning as to limit it to an action for performance. [ Bailii ] Â William Mcdermott v Her Majesty's Advocate 17 Dec 1999 HCJ Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Allanbridge and Lady Cosgrove Scotland, Crime [ ScotC ] Â William McDermott v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 252 17 Dec 1999 HCJ Lady Cosgrove and Lord Allanbridge and Lord Justice Clerk Scotland, Criminal Practice The appellant had been convicted of murder. He had given details of an alibi, but it appeared this might not have been fully investigated, in satisfying the duty imposed on the prosecutor by section 36. The status of the section was questioned. Held: The section imposed no duty on the prosecutor to communicate the results of his investigation, and no sanction for breach of it. The prosecutor should not be required to lead evidence that he had complied with the section. Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 36(10) 205(2) [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Caledonia North Sea Limited v London Bridge Engineering Limited and Pickup No 7 Limited (Formerly Northern Services Co Ltd) and British Telecommunications Plc and Wood Group Engineering Contractors Ltd and Norton (No 2) Limited (In 17 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Caplan and Lord Gill and Lord President and Lord Sutherland and Lord Coulsfield Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Stephen Nigel Millard v Grampian Joint Fire Board [1999] ScotCS 303 21 Dec 1999 OHCS Lord Eassie Scotland 1 Cites [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â Bryan Alan Jackson v Mrs Elizabeth Fleming 22 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Sutherland Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Bryan Alan Jackson v Mrs Elizabeth Fleming [1999] ScotCS 304 22 Dec 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Kathleen Beveridge Milne &C v Messrs Moores [1999] ScotCS 305 23 Dec 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Scottish Nuclear Limited v Assessor for Lanarkshire [1999] ScotCS 306 23 Dec 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Kathleen Beveridge Milne &C v Messrs Moores 23 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Macfadyen Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Scottish Nuclear Limited v Assessor for Lanarkshire 23 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Prosser Scotland [ ScotC ] Â In the Petition of Thomas Porter and John Smith 24 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Abernethy Scotland [ ScotC ] Â In the Petition of Thomas Porter and John Smith [1999] ScotCS 307 24 Dec 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Unity Trust Bank Plc v Martin Frost &C [1999] ScotCS 308 30 Dec 1999 SCS Scotland [ Bailii ] Â Unity Trust Bank Plc v Martin Frost &C 30 Dec 1999 SCS Lord Nimmo Smith Scotland [ ScotC ] Â Michael Mckenna v Her Majesty's Advocate [1999] ScotHC 253 30 Dec 1999 ScHC Lord Justice General and Lord Penrose and Lord Sutherland Scotland, Crime, Human Rights The appellant was charged with murder. A witness had since died, and he objected to the introduction of his written statement, on the basis that this would infringe his right to a fair trial. The evidence was likely to be decisive. Held: The fairness of the trial had to be considered as a whole. There was no basis in authority that admission of the evidence would necessarily prejudice the right to a fair trial. Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 259(5) - European Convention on Human Rights 6.1 6.3 1 Cites [ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ] Â
		Copyright 2014 David Swarbrick, 10 Halifax Road, Brighouse, West Yorkshire HD6 2AG.

swarb.co.uk - law index

Scotland - From: 1999 To: 1999