![]() |
||
Links: Home | swarblaw - law discussions |
swarb.co.uk - law indexThese cases are from the lawindexpro database. They are now being transferred to the swarb.co.uk website in a better form. As a case is published there, an entry here will link to it. The swarb.co.uk site includes many later cases. Â |
|
![]() ![]() |
![]() |
Commonwealth - From: 1900 To: 1929This page lists 2831 cases, and was prepared on 20 May 2019. ÂCoates (The Receiver for Debenture Holders of The New Zealand Railway Company Limited) v The Queen (New Zealand) [1900] UKPC 2 17 Feb 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Edward Taylor and John Roy Trustees of Bertha Sturrock v Bertha Sturrock and Annie Cuthbert As Excutrixes of John Thompson Sturrock (Deceased) and Others (Natal) [1900] UKPC 3 17 Feb 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Forman and Company Propriety Limited v The Ship Liddesdale (Victoria) [1900] UKPC 1 17 Feb 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Municipal Council of Shanghai v McMurray; PC 17-Feb-1900 - [1900] UKPC 6  Wentworth v Mathieu [1900] UKPC 5 17 Feb 1900 PC Commonwealth Quebec [ Bailii ]  The Bank of New Zealand v Simpson (New South Wales) [1900] UKPC 4 17 Feb 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Palmer (Official Assignee of The Estate of M. Lamrock) v Moore (New South Wales) [1900] UKPC 7 2 Mar 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sardar Jagjot Singh v Rani Brij Nath Kunwar (Oudh) [1900] UKPC 8 2 Mar 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Eddy v Eddy Et Vir (Quebec) [1900] UKPC 16 24 Mar 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Fatimatulnissa Begum and Others v Soonder Das and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1900] UKPC 12 24 Mar 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Girish Chunder Lahiri v Shoshi Shikhareswar Roy (Fort William (Bengal)) [1900] UKPC 9 24 Mar 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Padapa Bin Bhujangapa v Swamirao Shriniwas and Another (Bombay) [1900] UKPC 13 24 Mar 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Radhamoni Debi v The Collector of Khulna On Behalf of The Syedpore Trust Estate and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1900] UKPC 14 24 Mar 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Reverend William Aron Woods (Petition for Special Leave To Appeal) v Evans (The Consistory Court of The Diocese of Worcester) [1900] UKPC 17 24 Mar 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sah Lal Chand v Indarjit (Allahabad) [1900] UKPC 10 24 Mar 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Yeo Htean Sew v Abu Zaffer Koreeshee (Rangoon) [1900] UKPC 11 24 Mar 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  National Telephone Company Limited v The Constables of St. Peter Port (Guernsey) [1900] UKPC 15 24 Mar 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Falkingham and Others v The Victorian Railways Commissioner (Victoria) [1900] UKPC 18 6 Apr 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Simms and Others v The Registrar of Probates (South Australia) [1900] UKPC 19 6 Apr 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Forget and Another v Baxter (Quebec) [1900] UKPC 20 2 May 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Amrito Lall Dutt v Surnomoye Dasi and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1900] UKPC 21 2 May 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Royal Mail Steampacket Company v George and Branday [1900] UKPC 22 2 May 1900 PC Commonwealth (Jamaica) [ Bailii ]  Wasteneys v Wasteneys (New Zealand) [1900] UKPC 24 15 May 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Edgar v Plomley and Another (New South Wales) [1900] UKPC 23 15 May 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Quinlan (Petition for Special Leave To Appeal) v Child (St. Lucia) [1900] UKPC 25 22 May 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Williams v Scott (New South Wales) [1900] UKPC 27; [1900] AC 499 19 Jun 1900 PC Davey, Robertson, Lindley LL, Sir Henry de Villiers, Sir Ford North Commonwealth, Land New South Wales - title to land - whether purchase from self in a different capacity (as co-trustee) was invalid. [ Bailii ]  Luchmi Koer v Chowdhry Mount Roghu Nath Das (Fort William (Bengal)) [1900] UKPC 26 19 Jun 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Fleming v The Bank of New Zealand (New Zealand) [1900] UKPC 29 27 Jun 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Garurudhwaja Parshad v Saparandhwaja Parshad Singh (Allahabad) [1900] UKPC 28 27 Jun 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commissioners of Taxation v Kirk (Public Officer Broken Hill Proprietary Block 10 Company) (New South Wales) [1900] UKPC 31 27 Jun 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commissioners of Taxation v Kirk (Public Officer Broken Hill Proprietary Block 10 Company) (New South Wales) [1900] UKPC 30 27 Jun 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kotagiri Venkata Subbamma Rao v Vellanki Ventarama Rao (Madras) [1900] UKPC 32 28 Jun 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Galliers and Others v Rycroft and Another (Natal) [1900] UKPC 33 3 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Moung Tha Hnyeen v Moung Pan Nyo (Lower Burma) [1900] UKPC 34 6 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thiruthipalli Roman Menon v Variangattil Palisseri Roman Menon (Madras) [1900] UKPC 36 7 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Torva Exploring Syndicate Limited v Kelly (Cape of Good Hope) [1900] UKPC 35 7 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Yarlagadda Mallikarjuna Prasada Nayudu v Raja Yarlagadda Durga Prasada Nayudu and Raja Yarlagadda Mallikarjuna Prasada Nayudu and Another (Madras) [1900] UKPC 38 11 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Yarlagadda Mallikarjuna Prasada Nayudu v Raja Yarlagadda Durga Prasada Nayudu and Raja Yarlagadda Mallikarjuna Prasada Nayudu and Another (Madras) [1900] UKPC 39 11 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Allan v Morrison and Others (New Zealand) [1900] UKPC 37 11 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Khushi Ram v The Deputy Commissioner of Kheri (As Manager of The Mallanpur Estate) and Another (Oudh) [1900] UKPC 48 21 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dwin George Jellicoe v The Wellington Law District Law Society (New Zealand) [1900] UKPC 50 21 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  James Penny (Informa Pauperis) v The Commissioner of Railways and Others (New South Wales) [1900] UKPC 46 21 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Malkarjun Bin Shidramappa Pasare v Narhari Bin Shivappa and Another (Bombay) [1900] UKPC 40 21 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mody v The Queen (Bombay) [1900] UKPC 41 21 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Moung Tha Hnyin v Mah Thein Myah and Another (Rangoon) [1900] UKPC 43 21 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Bhup Indar Bahadur Singh v Bijai Bahadur Singh (Allahabad) [1900] UKPC 49 21 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Subbarayer and Others v Subbammal and Others (Madras) [1900] UKPC 44 21 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Surjan Singh and Others v Sardar Singh and Others (Oudh) [1900] UKPC 42 21 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Williams v Papworth and Others [1900] UKPC 47 21 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth New South Wales [ Bailii ]  Hodges and Another v The Delhi and London Bank Limited (Oudh) [1900] UKPC 45 21 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   La Banque D' Hochelga v Archibald W. Stevenson; PC 28-Jul-1900 - [1900] UKPC 54  J. B. Gregory (Petition for Special Leave To Appeal) v &Nbsp; (Victoria) [1900] UKPC 55 28 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  King and Another v Cheyne (Victoria) [1900] UKPC 53 28 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Montreal Gas Company v Vasey (Quebec) [1900] UKPC 52 28 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Beaudry v Barbean (Quebec) [1900] UKPC 51 28 Jul 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Melbourne Tramway and Omnibus Company Limited v The Mayor of The City of Fitzroy (Victoria) [1900] UKPC 57 10 Nov 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaja of The State of Bharatpur v Rani Kanno Dei (Allahabad) [1900] UKPC 56 10 Nov 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Healey (Appealing In Forma Pauperise) v The Bank of New South Wales (Victoria) [1900] UKPC 58 28 Nov 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Australian Gold Recovery Company Limited v The Lake View Consols Limited (Western Australia) [1900] UKPC 60 8 Dec 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rajah Rameshar Bakhsh Singh and Another v Arjun Singh (Oudh) [1900] UKPC 62 8 Dec 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rai Radha Kishen v The Collector Jaunpore (Allahabad) [1900] UKPC 61 8 Dec 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hardoon v Belilios (Hong Kong) [1900] UKPC 66 8 Dec 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kondama Naik and Another v Periya Dorasami and Another (Madras) [1900] UKPC 63 8 Dec 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Mujib-Un-Nisa and Others v Abdul Rahim and Abdul Aziz (Representatives of Ulfat-Un-Nisa Dececeased) (Allahabad) [1900] UKPC 65 8 Dec 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Owners of The S.S. Montauk v The Owners of The S.S. Luigia Premuda (Constantinople) [1900] UKPC 59 8 Dec 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Banarsi Parshad v Kashi Krishin Narain and Another (Allahabad) [1900] UKPC 64 8 Dec 1900 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Livingstone v Ross (Quebec) [1901] UKPC 2 16 Feb 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Secretary for State for Foreign Affairs v Charlesworth Pilling and Co. and Another (Zanzibar) [1901] UKPC 1 16 Feb 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The East Indian Railway Company v Kalidas Mukerjee (Fort William (Bengal)) [1901] UKPC 3 21 Feb 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Harendra Lal Roy Chowdhury v Maharani Dasi and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1901] UKPC 4 22 Feb 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Udwant Singh and Others v Tokhan Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1901] UKPC 5 26 Feb 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Scottish Provident Institution v The Commissioner of Taxes [1901] UKPC 8 2 Mar 1901 PC Commonwealth (Victoria) [ Bailii ]  The Minister for Lands v Wilson (New South Wales) [1901] UKPC 6 2 Mar 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ajum Goolam Hossen and Co. and Hajee Cassim Joosub and And Another v The Union Marine Insurance Company Limited (Mauritius) [1901] UKPC 7 2 Mar 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Aziz-Un-Nisa v Tasadduq Husain Khan (Oudh) [1901] UKPC 10 9 Mar 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jafri Begam and Another v Syed Ali Raza (A Minor By His Friend and Guardian Syed Mahomed Raza) (Oudh) [1901] UKPC 9 9 Mar 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Turret Steamship Company Limited v William G. Jenks and Others (Oudh) [1901] UKPC 11 20 Mar 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pereira v Pereira; Perera v Perera [1901] UKPC 16; [1901] AC 354; [1901] 70 LJPC 46; [1901] 84 LT 371 23 Mar 1901 PC Lord MacNaghten, Lord Uthwatt Wills and Probate, Commonwealth The court considered the effect of a testator having lost capacity at the time he executed his will, saying that, the principal inquiry as to testamentary capacity will be directed to the time when the instructions were given. Held: It is sufficient if the testator, at the moment of execution, believes the Will to be and if the Will is in accordance with the instructions previously given. The Board saw no reason in this case to question evidence that the testator was of sound mind when he executed the will, but cited Parker to say that the will might have remained effective if executed in accordance with the conditions in Parker -v- Felgate. As to the evidence of the attesting witnesses: "The question, therefore, comes to this: Having regard to all the circumstances of the case, ought the diagnosis of Dr. Fonseka and Dr. Rockwood, who were not present when the will was executed, to outweigh and prevail over the testimony of eye-witnesses based upon the evidence of their own senses?" Lord Uthwatt said: "Reports of judicial and parliamentary proceedings and, maybe, of some bodies which are neither judicial nor parliamentary in character, stand in a class apart by reason that the nature of their activities is treated as conclusively establishing that the public interest is forwarded by publication of reports of their proceedings. As regards reports of proceedings of other bodies, the status of those bodies taken alone is not conclusive and it is necessary to consider the subject-matter dealt with in the particular report with which the court is concerned. If it appears that it is to the public interest that a particular report should be published, privilege will attach." 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ]  Jagdish Bahadur v Sheo Partab Singh (Oudh) [1901] UKPC 13 23 Mar 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Minister of Mines v Harvey and Others (Western Australia) [1901] UKPC 15 23 Mar 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Vasudeva Padhi Khadanga Garu v Maguni (Magata) Devan Bakshi (Madras) [1901] UKPC 12 23 Mar 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Annoda Mohini Roy Chowdhry v Bhuban Mohini Debi and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1901] UKPC 14 23 Mar 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Radha Raman Shaha and Others v Pran Nath Roy and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1901] UKPC 17 2 May 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nireha Tamaki v Baker [1901] UKPC 18 11 May 1901 PC Commonwealth New Zealand [ Bailii ]  Ahmad Yar Khan and Others v The Secretary for State for India In Council (Punjab) [1901] UKPC 19 11 May 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Choudhri Makbul Husain and Another v Lalta Pershad (Ex Parte) (Oudh) [1901] UKPC 20 11 May 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shankar Sarup and Others v Lala Phul Chand Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Mejo Mal and Others) (Allahabad) [1901] UKPC 21 16 May 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Louise Lesage (Legal Representative of Octave Ribault Deceased) v Scicluna (Malta) [1901] UKPC 22 16 May 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Mohammad Mumtaz Ali Khan v Sakhawat Ali Khan and Another (Oudh) [1901] UKPC 25 13 Jun 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Harvey v The King (Ceylon) [1901] UKPC 28 13 Jun 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Cook v Ricketson and Others (New South Wales) [1901] UKPC 31 13 Jun 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Master and Owners of The S.S. Baku Standard v The Master and Owners of The S.S. Angþle (Constantinople) [1901] UKPC 27 13 Jun 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Caledonian Coal Company Limited v The Seaham Colliery Company Limited [1901] UKPC 30 13 Jun 1901 PC Commonwealth New South Wales [ Bailii ]  Karim Nensey v Heinichs and Another (Bombay) [1901] UKPC 24 13 Jun 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Colonial Sugar Refining Company Limited v The Attorney General of Victoria [1901] UKPC 29 13 Jun 1901 PC Commonwealth (Victoria) [ Bailii ]  Karim Nensey v Heinichs and Another (Bombay) [1901] UKPC 23 13 Jun 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kong Lee Lone and Company v Lowjee Nanjee (Rangoon) [1901] UKPC 26 13 Jun 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Radha Krishn Das v Rai Krishn Chand (A Minor Through His Guardian Rani Mathi Kuar) (Allahabad) [1901] UKPC 32 18 Jun 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ganga Bakhsh Singh v Babu Dalip Singh and Others (Oudh) [1901] UKPC 33 20 Jun 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Harriss and Another v Brown and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1901] UKPC 34 22 Jun 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sukh Dei v Kedar Nath Ram Charan and Bisheshar Parshad (Oudh) [1901] UKPC 35 22 Jun 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Pudmanund Singh and Others v Hayes and Others Executors of Dharam Chand Lal (Deceased) (Fort William (Bengal)) [1901] UKPC 38 13 Jul 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rangayya Goudan and Another v Nanjappa Rao and Others (Madras) [1901] UKPC 36 13 Jul 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  British Aluminium Company Limited (For The Extension of Henderson'S Patient No. 7,426 of 1887) (Reasons) v Whitehall Court Chamber [13 July 1901] (Whitehall Court Chamber) [1901] UKPC 40 13 Jul 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Batul Begam v Mansur Ali Khan Umrai Bibi and Bhagwati Parshad (Allahabad) [1901] UKPC 37 13 Jul 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Quinlan (Reasons) v Quinlan (St. Lucia) [1901] UKPC 39 13 Jul 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Murli Dhar v Raghuraj Singh (Oudh) [1901] UKPC 41 19 Jul 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Queen v Harold Vincent Aldred (Isle of Man) [1901] UKPC 43 24 Jul 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Queen v J. L. Marais (Madras) [1901] UKPC 42 24 Jul 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Falkners Goldmining Company Limited v Mckinnery [1901] UKPC 46; [1901] AC 581 27 Jul 1901 PC Commonwealth (New South Wales) Mining dispute [ Bailii ]  Asghar Ali Khan v Kurshed Ali Khan and Another (Allahabad) [1901] UKPC 45 27 Jul 1901 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Owners of The Steamship Chittagong v The Owners of The Steamship Kostroma [1901] UKPC 44; [1901] AC 597 27 Jul 1901 PC Commonwealth, Transport (Constantinople) Liability after collision between two ships. [ Bailii ]  The Toronto Railway Company v The Corporation of The City of Toronto [1901] UKPC 48 2 Aug 1901 PC Commonwealth, Landlord and Tenant (Ontario) [ Bailii ]  NA Subramania Iyer v The King [1901] UKPC 47 2 Aug 1901 PC Commonwealth, Criminal Practice (Madras) The defendant said that he had been charged with a multiplicity of charges in breach of a local provision limiting the numbers of charges to be dealt with together. [ Bailii ]  Te Teira Te Paea and Others v The Roera Tareha and Another [1901] UKPC 50; [1902] AC 56 9 Nov 1901 PC Commonwealth, Land, Trusts (New Zealand) The Board was asked whether certain lands allotted to the Maori chief were held for himself or as trustee for other natives. [ Bailii ]  Burland and Others v Earle and Others [1901] UKPC 49; [1902] AC 83 9 Nov 1901 PC Commonwealth, Company (Ontario) [ Bailii ]  Sir Malcolm Donald McEacharn v The Honourable Sir John Colton KCMG and Others [1901] UKPC 51; [1902] AC 104 19 Nov 1901 PC Commonwealth, Landlord and Tenant (South Australia) [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Province of Manitoba v The Manitoba Licence Holders Association [1901] UKPC 52 22 Nov 1901 PC Commonwealth (Canada) [ Bailii ]  Ho Tung v The Man On Insurance Company Limited [1901] UKPC 54 30 Nov 1901 PC Commonwealth (Hong Kong) [ Bailii ]  Ho Tung v The Man On Insurance Company Limited [1901] UKPC 53 30 Nov 1901 PC Commonwealth (Hong Kong) [ Bailii ]  Dinobundhu Shaw Chowdhry v Jogmaya Dasi and Others [1901] UKPC 57 30 Nov 1901 PC Commonwealth (Fort William (Bengal)) [ Bailii ]  William Humble v Hugh Humphreys [1901] UKPC 55 30 Nov 1901 PC Commonwealth (New South Wales) [ Bailii ]  Bahadur Singh and Others v Mohar Singh and Others [1901] UKPC 58 30 Nov 1901 PC Commonwealth (Allahabad) [ Bailii ]  Moti Cahand and Others v Ganga Parshad Singh [1901] UKPC 59 30 Nov 1901 PC Commonwealth (Allahabad) [ Bailii ]  Narendra Nath Pahari v Ram Gobind Pahari and Others [1901] UKPC 56 30 Nov 1901 PC Commonwealth (Fort William (Bengal)) [ Bailii ]  Karuppanan Servai and Others v Srinvasan Chetti and Others [1901] UKPC 61 3 Dec 1901 PC Commonwealth (Madras) [ Bailii ]  Ghulam Jilani and Others v Muhammad Hassan [1901] UKPC 60 3 Dec 1901 PC Commonwealth (Punjab) [ Bailii ]  Dinomoni Chrowdhuri (Representative of Janhavi Chrowdhuri Deceased) v Brojo Mohini Chrowdhuri [1901] UKPC 66 18 Dec 1901 PC Commonwealth (Fort William (Bengal)) [ Bailii ]  Nye Rai Administrator of Prah Primoon Sombat Puket (Deceased) v Lim Loh [1901] UKPC 65 18 Dec 1901 PC Commonwealth (Singapore) [ Bailii ]  The Canadian Pacific Railway Company v Roy [1901] UKPC 63 18 Dec 1901 PC Commonwealth (Quebec) [ Bailii ]  David Francois Marais (Reasons) v The General Officer Commanding The Lines of Communication and The Attorney General of The Colony [1901] UKPC 62 18 Dec 1901 PC Commonwealth (Cape of Good Hope) [ Bailii ]  The Mayor and Councillors of East Freemantle v Annois [1901] UKPC 64 18 Dec 1901 PC Commonwealth (Western Australia) [ Bailii ]  Charles Banks Nelson v The King [1902] UKPC 1 12 Feb 1902 PC Commonwealth Isle of Man [ Bailii ]  Bhoy Hong Kong and Another v R.M.M.S.P. Ramanathan Chetty and Others (Rangoon) [1902] UKPC 2 13 Feb 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Srimati Rani Parbati Kumari Debi v Jagadis Chunder Dhabal and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1902] UKPC 6 22 Feb 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mohesh Chunder Dhal v Satrugham Dhal and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1902] UKPC 5 22 Feb 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Hull Electric Company v The Ottawa Electric Company and The Corporation of The City of Hull (Quebec) [1902] UKPC 7 22 Feb 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chandika Bakhsh and Drigbijai Singh v Mana Kuar (Representative of Ratan Singh Deceased) (Oudh) [1902] UKPC 4 22 Feb 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chandika Bakhsh and Drigbijai Singh v Mana Kuar (Representative of Ratan Singh Deceased) (Oudh) [1902] UKPC 3 22 Feb 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kalagurla Suryanarayana v Yarlagadda Naidoo (Fort William (Bengal)) [1902] UKPC 8 1 Mar 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Khagendra Nath Mahata and Others v Pran Nath Roy (Fort William (Bengal)) [1902] UKPC 9 1 Mar 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chan Kit San and Another v Ho Fung Hang (Hong Kong) [1902] UKPC 10 12 Mar 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Louisa Maria Botegoe Jayatilleke Karunaratne v Elizabeth Ferdinandus and Others (Ceylon) [1902] UKPC 11 19 Mar 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Mayor Councillors and Citizens of The City of Wellington v Johnston and Another (New Zealand) [1902] UKPC 15 18 Apr 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Mayor Councillors and Citizens of The City of Wellington v Lloyd and Another (New Zealand) [1902] UKPC 16 18 Apr 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Bommadevara Venkata Narasimha Naidu and Another v Raja Bommadevara Bhashyakarlu Naidu and Others (Madras) [1902] UKPC 13 18 Apr 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council v Krishnamoni Gupta and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1902] UKPC 18 18 Apr 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thanmull and Another v Sirdar Ali Khan [1902] UKPC 12 18 Apr 1902 PC Commonwealth Hyderabad [ Bailii ]  Turnbull and Company v Duval (Jamaica) [1902] UKPC 17 18 Apr 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Eastern and South African Telegraph Company Limited v The Cape Town Tramway Companies Limited (The Cape of Good Hope) [1902] UKPC 14 18 Apr 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Gupal Chunder Bose v Kartrick Chunder Dey and Others; PC 2-May-1902 - [1902] UKPC 19  Gangaram (Since Deceased) and Others v Sitaram and Others (Hyderabad) [1902] UKPC 20 6 May 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commissioners of Taxation v The Trustees of St. Marks Glebe (New South Wales) [1902] UKPC 21 14 May 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Douglas v Franz Sander and Company (Natal) [1902] UKPC 23 14 May 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Richard Spurrier and John Le Cronier (Agents In Jersey of The Sun Fire Office) v George Francis La Cloche [1902] UKPC 22 14 May 1902 PC Commonwealth (Jersey) [ Bailii ]  Sham Koer and Rupan Singh v Dah Koer and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1902] UKPC 25 5 Jun 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commissioners of Taxation v Antill (New South Wales) [1902] UKPC 24 5 Jun 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mussummat Shambati Koeri and Others v Mussummat Jago Bibi (Fort William (Bengal)) [1902] UKPC 27 6 Jun 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Gopal v Pirthi Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1902] UKPC 26 6 Jun 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Tassaduq Rasul Khan and Another v Manik Chand (Since Deceased) [1902] UKPC 28 11 Jun 1902 PC Commonwealth (Oudh) [ Bailii ]  Godfray v The Constables of The Island of Sark (Guernsey) [1902] UKPC 29 18 Jun 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Horne and Another v Struben and Another (Cape of Good Hope) [1902] UKPC 31 18 Jun 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Chelikani Venkayyamma Garu Widow and Legal Representative of Raja Chelikani Appa Rao Bahadur Garu Deceased v Raja Chelikani Venkataramanayyamma Bahadur Garu (Madras) [1902] UKPC 30 18 Jun 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gokul Mandar and Others v Pudmanund Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1902] UKPC 35 9 Jul 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Subramanian Chettiar v Arunachalam Chettiar and Others [1902] UKPC 36 9 Jul 1902 PC Commonwealth Madras [ Bailii ]  Raja Rampal Singh v Balbhaddar Singh (Oudh) [1902] UKPC 37 9 Jul 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Payne and Others v The King (Victoria) [1902] UKPC 32 9 Jul 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The National Bank of Australasia Limited v J. Falkingham and Sons (Victoria) [1902] UKPC 34 9 Jul 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Bank of New South Wales v The Goulburn Valley Butter Factory and Company Proprietary Limited (Victoria) [1902] UKPC 33 9 Jul 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Neo Ong Hee v Neo Ong Tew (Singapore) [1902] UKPC 38 9 Jul 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Archambault Et Vir v Archambault Et Al (Quebec) [1902] UKPC 39 16 Jul 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Pertap Bahadur Singh v Gajadher Bakhsh Singh (Oudh) [1902] UKPC 40 22 Jul 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Dominion Cotton Mills Company Limited and Others v The General Engineering Company of Ontario Limited [1902] UKPC 42 23 Jul 1902 PC Commonwealth (Canada) [ Bailii ]  The Commissioners of Trade and Customs v R. Bell and Company Limited (New Zealand) [1902] UKPC 41 23 Jul 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Buta v The Municipal Committee of Lahore (Punjab) [1902] UKPC 43 2 Aug 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ram Nundun Singh v Maharani Janki Koer (Fort William (Bengal)) [1902] UKPC 44 2 Aug 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Province of Ontario v The Attorney General for The Province of Quebec (Canada) [1902] UKPC 45 12 Nov 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Joseph Kieffer v Les Ecclisiastiques Du Seminaire Des Missions Etrangeres a Quebec [1902] UKPC 47 12 Nov 1902 PC Commonwealth (Quebec) [ Bailii ]  The Ontario Mining Company Limited and The Attorney General for The Dominion of Canada v The Attorney General for The Province of Ontario (Canada) [1902] UKPC 46 12 Nov 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Imperial Bank of Canada v The Bank of Hamilton (Canada) [1902] UKPC 48 13 Nov 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ram Pershad Singh and Others v Lakhpati Koer and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1902] UKPC 49 14 Nov 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lambe and Another v Manuel and Others [1902] UKPC 50 19 Nov 1902 PC Commonwealth (Canada) [ Bailii ]  Ram Satrupa Koer v Rani Hulas Koer (Oudh) [1902] UKPC 52 19 Nov 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nidha Sah (Since Deceased) and Sant Din v Murli Dhar and Others (Oudh) [1902] UKPC 54 3 Dec 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jagatpal Singh v Raja Jageshar Bakhsh Singh and Another (Oudh) [1902] UKPC 53 3 Dec 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Raja Jee Bahadur Garu v Raja Parthasaradhi Apppa Row and Others (Representatives of Raja Papamma Row Bahadur (Deceased) (Madras) [1902] UKPC 57 13 Dec 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Wise v The Perpetual Trustee Company Limited (Executors of WH Paling (Deceased); PC 13-Dec-1902 - [1902] UKPC 59; [1903] AC 139  Ram Anugra Narain Singh v Chowdhry Hanuman Sahai (Fort William (Bengal)) [1902] UKPC 55 13 Dec 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaja Jagadindra Nath Roy Bahadoor v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Fort William (Bengal)) [1902] UKPC 56 13 Dec 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ram Narain Joshi v Parmeswar Narain Mahta and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1902] UKPC 58 13 Dec 1902 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Collector of Voter for The Electoral District of Vancouver City and The Attorney General for The Province of British Columbia v Tomey Homma and The Attorney General for The Dominions of Canada [1902] UKPC 60 17 Dec 1902 PC Commonwealth (British Columbia) [ Bailii ]  Attorney-General for Ontario v Hamilton Street Ry Co [1903] AC 524 1903 PC Crime, Commonwealth The phrase 'Criminal law' means 'the criminal law in its widest sense'. The Judicial Committee refused to give its opinion on a number of questions relating to the operation of certain Canadian legislation which purported to prevent "the Profanation of the Lord's Day" by proscribing the doing of work on that day. The Lord Chancellor said of a court being requested to answer an hypotheticala question: With regard to the remaining questions, which it has been suggested should be reserved for further argument, their Lordships are of opinion that it would be inexpedient and contrary to the established practice of this Board to attempt to give any judicial opinion upon those questions. They are questions proper to be considered in concrete cases only; and opinions expressed upon the operation of the sections referred to, and the extent to which they are applicable, would be worthless for many reasons. They would be worthless as being speculative opinions on hypothetical questions. It would be contrary to principle, inconvenient, and inexpedient that opinions should be given upon such questions at all. When they arise, they must arise in concrete cases, involving private rights; and it would be extremely unwise for any judicial tribunal to attempt beforehand to exhaust all possible cases and facts which might occur to qualify, cut down, and override the operation of particular words when the concrete case is not before it. 1 Citers  Regina v Blight (1903) 22 NZLR 837 1903 Williams J Commonwealth, Crime (New Zealand) The Criminal Code in force at the time, reflecting the English, included an offence of sexual intercourse with a girl under 16, to which a one month time limit applied, and also an offence of indecent assault to which no time limit applied but to which, in the case of a young victim, consent was not a defence. After the time limit expired, the defendant was prosecuted for indecent assault, he having had sexual intercourse with a girl under 16. Held: (Majority) This was impermissible: "In the present case it is clear that everything done by the accused was an offence under section 196 [unlawful sexual intercourse] and nothing more. I think, therefore, the prosecution was instituted out of time. If the above construction be not adopted the result is that no effect could be given to section 196, and that section would be practically expunged from the Act, and the protection given by the time limit would be quite illusory." 1 Cites 1 Citers  His Highness The Gaekwar Sarkar of Baroda and Bombay and Central India Railway Company v Gandhi Kachrabhai Kasturchand [1903] UKPC 3 10 Feb 1903 PC Commonwealth Bombay [ Bailii ]  Frederick Wallis and Others v His Majesty's Solicitor General [1903] UKPC 1 10 Feb 1903 PC Commonwealth New Zealand [ Bailii ]  Chiam Josef and Others v Maria Susanna Mulder (Cape of Good Hope) [1903] UKPC 2 10 Feb 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Banka Behari Das v Raj Kumar Das (Fort William (Bengal)) [1903] UKPC 5 11 Feb 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lala Chatrilal v Musammat Nandon Kunwar (Since Deceased) and Others (Allahabad) [1903] UKPC 4 11 Feb 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Vinayak Waman Joshi Rayarikar v Gopal Hari Joshi Rayarikar and Others (Bombay) [1903] UKPC 6 12 Feb 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Robert Milroy Walker v Critchett Walker (New South Wales) [1903] UKPC 10 13 Feb 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The King v James Fisher (Victoria) [1903] UKPC 8 13 Feb 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The King v Frederick William Bull (Victoria) [1903] UKPC 9 13 Feb 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dwarkanath Sadanand Kale v Munchershaw Bomonji Cholic (Bombay) [1903] UKPC 7 13 Feb 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Emil Alexander Wuterich for An Extension of Letters Patent Granted 22 February 1889 No. 3199 v Whitehall Court Chamber [18 February 1903] (Whitehall Court Chamber) [1903] UKPC 11 18 Feb 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Aitken Spence and Company v Fernando (Ceylon) [1903] UKPC 14 4 Mar 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Baker Ali Khan and Another v Anjuman Ara Begam and Wasi Ali Khan (Oudh) [1903] UKPC 13 4 Mar 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mohori Bibee and Another v Dharmodas Ghose (Fort William (Bengal)) [1903] UKPC 12 4 Mar 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jiban Krishna Roy v Brojo Lal Sen (Fort William (Bengal)) [1903] UKPC 16 4 Mar 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Syed Asghar Reza Khan v Syed Mahomed Mehdi Hossein Khan and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1903] UKPC 15 4 Mar 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kent and Others (Liquidators of La Banque Ville-Marie) v La Communautu Des Soeurs De Charitu De La Providence and Others [1903] UKPC 17; [1903] AC 220 20 Mar 1903 PC Commonwealth, Insolvency, Litigation Practice (Quebec) The liquidators of a bank had sued on a cause of action vested in the bank. The Canadian courts had refused leave to amend to add the bank as a plaintiff on appeal. Held: The liquidators' appeal succeeded. There was power to amend to allow an amendment to add the bank as a party and that it should have been exercised. 1 Citers [ Bailii ]  Walker v Simpson (New South Wales) [1903] UKPC 18 25 Mar 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Banarsi Parshad v Ram Narain and Others (Allahabad) [1903] UKPC 19 25 Mar 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rahim-Ud-Din and Others v Rewal (Since Deceased) and Others (Punjab) [1903] UKPC 20 25 Mar 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Kensington Land Company and Others v The Canadian Industrial Company (Quebec) [1903] UKPC 21 28 Mar 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Balkishen Das (Since Deceased) and Others v Ram Narain Sahu and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1903] UKPC 23 29 Apr 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Balabux Ladhuram v Rukhmabai and Another (Hyderabad) [1903] UKPC 22 29 Apr 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Tirlok Nath Shukul and Others v Musammat Lachhmin Kunwari and Another (Allahabad) [1903] UKPC 25 30 Apr 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Haji Saboo Sidick and Others v Ayeshabai and Another (Bombay) [1903] UKPC 24 30 Apr 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pria Nath Das v Ram Taran Chatterji and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1903] UKPC 27 6 May 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gharib-Ul-Lah v Khalak Singh and Others (Oudh) [1903] UKPC 28 7 May 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Verabhai and Others v Bai Hiraba and Others (Bombay) [1903] UKPC 29 12 May 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  O'Keefe v Malone (New South Wales) [1903] UKPC 30 13 May 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Firm of Shriram Rupram (Owner: Rupram) v The Firm of Madangopalm Gowardhan (Owners: Rampratap and Others) (Hyderabad) [1903] UKPC 33 15 May 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Syed Mahamad Yusuf-Ud-Din v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Hyderabad) [1903] UKPC 32 15 May 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sardar Muhammad Afzal Khan v Nawab Ghulam Kasim Khan (Punjab) [1903] UKPC 31 15 May 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Annamalai Chetty v Murgasa Chetty and Another (Madras) [1903] UKPC 34 25 May 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Owners of The Steamship Amboina v Maung Shwe I (Lower Burma) [1903] UKPC 35 11 Jun 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commissioner of Public Works Representing The Colonial Government of The Colony of The Cape of Good Hope v Logan (Cape of Good Hope) [1903] UKPC 36 12 Jun 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shaik Mahomed Meracoir v Donner and Others (Madras) [1903] UKPC 37 12 Jun 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Wappu Marikar Naguda Marikar v Wappu Marikar Mohamado As Administrator of The Estate of Cader Mohideen Saibu Wappu Marikar Deceased (Ceylon) [1903] UKPC 39 18 Jun 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Edyvean and Others v Archer and Others (In Re Harriet Brooke Deceased) [1903] UKPC 38 18 Jun 1903 PC Commonwealth Tasmania [ Bailii ]  Mussammat Bibi Walian and Others v Bankse Behari Pershad Singh and Others [1903] UKPC 40 19 Jun 1903 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Sheo Pertab Bahadur Singh v The Allahabad Bank Limited and Another (Oudh Lucknow) [1903] UKPC 43 24 Jun 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sheo Shankar Lal and Another v Debi Sahai (Allahabad) [1903] UKPC 42 24 Jun 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The City of Montreal v The Montreal Street Railway Company (Quebec) [1903] UKPC 44 24 Jun 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hem Chunder Chowdhry v Kali Prosunno Bhaduri and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1903] UKPC 41 24 Jun 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maung Po Hti v Mahomed Cassim and Another (Lower Burma) [1903] UKPC 45 24 Jun 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Webb and Another Executors of The Will of William Lloyd) Deceased v Macpherson (Fort William (Bengal)) [1903] UKPC 46 1 Jul 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Balwant Singh v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Allahabad) [1903] UKPC 48 7 Jul 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Duffill and Another v Duffill (Natal) [1903] UKPC 47 7 Jul 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pestonji Jehangirji and Others v The Firm of Jaisingdas Hansraj (Hyderabad) [1903] UKPC 50 8 Jul 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thomas Mitchell (Special Leave To Appeal) v The New Zealand Loan and Mercantile Agency Company Limited and Others [1903] UKPC 49 8 Jul 1903 PC Commonwealth (New Zealand) [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Province of Ontario v Hamilton Street Railway Company and Others (Ontario) [1903] UKPC 51 14 Jul 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Peninsular and Oriental Steam Navigation Company (Substituted for Charles Gadd Deceased) v Charles Cameron Kingston Minister of State for Trade Customs of The Commonwealth of Australia (Victoria) [1903] UKPC 52 15 Jul 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Algoma Central Railway Company v The King (Canada) [1903] UKPC 54 16 Jul 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hugo Young Master of The Steamship Furnesia v The Steamship Scotia (Newfoundland) [1903] UKPC 53 16 Jul 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bertrand J. Clerque and Another (Special Leave To Appeal) v Elizabeth and Another (Canada) [1903] UKPC 55 21 Jul 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Harry Graves and Company Limited v Gorrie [1903] UKPC 56 28 Jul 1903 PC Commonwealth (Ontario) [ Bailii ]  Connolly and Another v The Consumers Cordage Company (Canada) [1903] UKPC 57 4 Aug 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kaur v Bose and Others [1903] UKPC 58 5 Aug 1903 PC Commonwealth (Punjab) [ Bailii ]  The Consolidated Car Heating Company v Came (Quebec) [1903] UKPC 59 5 Aug 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Trust Loan Company of Canada v Gauthier and Others (Quebec) [1903] UKPC 60 3 Nov 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Grand Hotel Company of Caledonia Springs Limited v Wilson and Others (Ontario) [1903] UKPC 61 4 Nov 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sahebzadah Mahomed Zahur-Ud-Din v Sahebzadah Nur-Ud-Din and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1903] UKPC 62 5 Nov 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hadji Mahomed Hady v The Collector of Rangoon Town Lands (Lower Burma) [1903] UKPC 64 6 Nov 1903 PC Commonwealth Lower Burma [ Bailii ]  Musammat Maqboolas v Ahmad Husain and Others (Oudh) [1903] UKPC 65 10 Nov 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  La Compagnie De La Guinue Portugaise v J. Stadelmann and Company (Sierra Leone) [1903] UKPC 66 10 Nov 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaj Kumar Bagheswari Pershad Singh and Others v Khaja Mahomed Gowhar Ali Khan and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1903] UKPC 69 12 Nov 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chowdhry Ganesh Dutt Thakoor and Others v Mussummat Jewach Thakoorain (Fort William (Bengal)) [1903] UKPC 68 12 Nov 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Abdul Aziz Khan v Appayasami Naicker (Since Deceased) and Others and of Munhar Das and Others (Madras) [1903] UKPC 67 13 Nov 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Province v Ostrum (British Columbia) [1903] UKPC 71 25 Nov 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commissioner of Stamp Duties v Stephen (New South Wales) [1903] UKPC 70 25 Nov 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mohammad Abdussamad and Others v Kurban Husain and Others (Oudh) [1903] UKPC 72 25 Nov 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Yarlagadda Durga Prasada and Others v Raja Yarlagadda Mallikarjuna Prasada Nayadu Bahadur Garu and Others (Madras) [1903] UKPC 78 2 Dec 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kedar Mal Marwari and Another Representative of Bisewar Lal Marwari (Deceased) v Dewan Bishen Pershad (Deceased) and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1903] UKPC 76 2 Dec 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chappele and Others v The King (Canada) [1903] UKPC 73 2 Dec 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chaudhri Thakur Das and Others v Chaudhri Jairaj Singh (Allahabad) [1903] UKPC 77 2 Dec 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Natal Land and Colonization Company Limited v The Pauline Colliery and Development Syndicate Limited (Natal) [1903] UKPC 74 2 Dec 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Bangayya Appa Rao Bahadur Zemindar of Nazvid v Bobba Sriramulu and Others (Madras) [1903] UKPC 75 2 Dec 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Colony of Cape of Good Hope v Van Reesen Smit (Cape of Good Hope) [1903] UKPC 79 9 Dec 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Colony of Cape of Good Hope v Van Reesen Smit (Cape of Good Hope) [1903] UKPC 80 9 Dec 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Amar Chunder Kundu v Soshi Bhusan Roy and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1903] UKPC 81 10 Dec 1903 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bree v Scott (1904) 29 VLR 692 1904 Beckett J, Madden C.J Commonwealth, Landlord and Tenant, Limitation (Supreme Court of Victoria) The defendant squatted from 1878 upon land allotted to her mother as Crown licensee. A Crown licensee was entitled to acquire the fee upon performance of obligations in the licence. In 1885 a Crown grant was duly issued to the mother in consideration of a payment then made. A mortgagee sought to eject the defendant. The question which arose was whether the 15-year limitation period had run its course by 1899. If the period ran from 1878 the claim was barred. If the period ran only from 1885, being the date of the grant of the legal estate through which the mortgagee claimed title, the claim was not barred. Held: Time ran from the earlier date. The licence under the Land Act 1869 was the seed of which the subsequent grant was the fruition of title. "Stated generally, the policy of the [limitation legislation] was to require a person having a right to land to exercise it as against a person illegally occupying at the peril of losing the land if the illegal occupation continued undisturbed for fifteen years. Here we have an occupation such as the Statute contemplated continuing undisturbed, and when it commenced, and up to the time of the issue of the grant, a person having legal title from the Crown who could have recovered the land against the occupant ... This inactive licensee and lessee afterwards acquired a legal estate in the fee, not by virtue of any new right unconnected with her prior interest, but by the maturing of a right which had its inception in the licence. No doubt, up to the issue of the grant, there was no certainty that the fee would be acquired: the right to the land was inchoate, and might have been lost, but it was in fact perfected, and we have to say whether the nature of this new title is such as to wipe out all the consequences of past inaction, and to give a new term of fifteen years within which inaction must continue before the illegal occupant could acquire title ... I should say that since the Judicature Act, if not before, the mere difference between legal and equitable estates would be insufficient. Take the case of omission to proceed against an illegal occupant by a purchaser under a contract of sale ... there is no reason for saying that a conveyance by the vendor ... would give this new start in the owner's favour ... The changes in the legal interest of the person who might have brought the action against the defendant in the present case made no changes in her rights as against the defendant; the right to turn her out was as good in the licensee as in the grantee." 1 Citers  The Master and Owners of The Steamship City of Lincoln v Smith [1904] UKPC 1 3 Feb 1904 PC Commonwealth Natal [ Bailii ]  Amyot v Dwarris and Others (Jamaica) [1904] UKPC 2 4 Feb 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Minister of Public Works v Hart and Another (New South Wales) [1904] UKPC 3 5 Feb 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Seth Narsinghdass v Seth Ramlal and Others (Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces India) [1904] UKPC 4 25 Feb 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakurain Jaipal Kunwar and Another v Bhaiya Indar Bahadur Singh (Oudh) [1904] UKPC 5 25 Feb 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Seena Pena Reena Seena Mayandi Chettiyar v Chokkalingam Pillay and Others [1904] UKPC 6 26 Feb 1904 PC Commonwealth (Madras) [ Bailii ]  Bola Nath Nundi and 6 Others and Others v The Midnapore Zemindary Company Limited (Fort William (Bengal)) [1904] UKPC 7 26 Feb 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raj Chunder Sen and Another v Gangadas Seal and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1904] UKPC 8 2 Mar 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Fitzmaurice v Hesketh (The Consistory Court of The Diocese of Manchester) [1904] UKPC 10 2 Mar 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for New South Wales v Dickson and Others [1904] UKPC 9 2 Mar 1904 PC Commonwealth (New South Wales) [ Bailii ]  Moore v The Bishop of Oxford (The Consistory Court of The Diocese of Oxford) [1904] UKPC 11 17 Mar 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jotindra Mohun Lahiri v Guru Prosunno Lahiri and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1904] UKPC 14 23 Mar 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Ganesh Bakhsh v Thakur Harihar Bakhsh (Oudh) [1904] UKPC 13 23 Mar 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Durga Prosad Sureka and Others v Bhujan Lall Lohea and Others; PC 23-Mar-1904 - [1904] UKPC 16  D. Henderson and Company Limited and Others v Daniell and Others (New Zealand) [1904] UKPC 12 23 Mar 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Srish Chandra Roy and Others v Roy Banomali Rai Bahadur (Fort William (Bengal)) [1904] UKPC 15 23 Mar 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Kingston Light Heat and Power Company v The Corporation of The City of Kingston (Ontario) [1904] UKPC 17 20 Apr 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Alexander Mcdonald v Frank J Belcher and Others [1904] UKPC 18 28 Apr 1904 PC Commonwealth (Canada) [ Bailii ]  Bernard Duff v James Duff (Western Australia) [1904] UKPC 19 5 May 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Citizens Life Assurance Company Limited v Brown [1904] UKPC 20; [1904] AC 423 6 May 1904 PC Lord Lindley Commonwealth, Company, Vicarious Liability (New South Wales) A malicious libel was alleged. The life assurance company was vicariously liable in respect of a libel contained in a circular sent out by a person who was employed by the company under a written agreement as its "superintendent of agencies". By the terms of the agreement that person was to devote his whole time to furthering the company's business and was to be paid a salary weekly as well as a commission on policies procured by him. Held: He was a servant of the company for whose actions the company was liable. Once companies are recognised by the law as legal persons, they are liable to have the mental states of agents and employees such as dishonesty or malice attributed to them for the purpose of establishing civil liability. Lord Lindley said: "If it is once granted that corporations are for civil purposes to be regarded as persons, ie as principals acting by agents and servants, it is difficult to see why the ordinary doctrines of agency and of master and servant are not to be applied to corporations as well as to ordinary individuals." 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ]  W.H. Martin Executor of The Will of R. Hunt Deceased, v G. J. Adams (Newfoundland) [1904] UKPC 21 11 May 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Smith v Mcarthur and Others (New Zealand) [1904] UKPC 27 14 May 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Glenwood Lumber Company Limited v George L. Phillips (Since Deceased and Now Represented By Robert K. Bishop [1904] UKPC 23 14 May 1904 PC Commonwealth Newfoundland [ Bailii ]  John Mcneil (Now Deceased) and Others v Monroe (Newfoundland) [1904] UKPC 22 14 May 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rami Srimati (Deceased) and Others v Khajendra Narayan Singh and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1904] UKPC 25 14 May 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lukey and Another v The Sydney Harbour Trust Commissioners (New South Wales) [1904] UKPC 24 14 May 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakurain Balraj Kunwar and Another v Rae Jagatpal Singh [1904] UKPC 26 14 May 1904 PC Commonwealth (Oudh) [ Bailii ]  The South African Breweries Limited v Hodgson (Cape of Good Hope) [1904] UKPC 28 18 May 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Fakir Chunder Dutt and Others v Ram Kumar Chatterji and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1904] UKPC 30 3 Jun 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Bombay Tramway Company Limited v The Municipal Corporation of The City of Bombay and Others (Bombay) [1904] UKPC 29 3 Jun 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Blain v The Canadian Pacific Railway Company [1904] UKPC 33 7 Jun 1904 PC Commonwealth (Canada) [ Bailii ]  The Newfoundland Steam Whaling Company Limited v The Government of Newfoundland [1904] UKPC 31 7 Jun 1904 PC Commonwealth Newfoundland [ Bailii ]  Kali Das Chuckerbutty and Another v Ishan Chunder Chuckerbutty and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1904] UKPC 32 7 Jun 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Puliyampatti Narainer v Kuppier and Another (Madras) [1904] UKPC 35 8 Jun 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The King v Louw (Cape of Good Hope) [1904] UKPC 36 8 Jun 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The New Trinidad Lake Asphalt Company Limited v The Attorney General for Trinidad and Tobacco (Trinidad and Tobacco) [1904] UKPC 34 8 Jun 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The African Gold Recovery Company Limited v Hay (Transvaal) [1904] UKPC 40 22 Jun 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lodder and Another v Solwey (New Zealand) [1904] UKPC 39 22 Jun 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Turner and Another v Haji Goolam Mohomed Azam [1904] UKPC 37 22 Jun 1904 PC Commonwealth (Bombay) [ Bailii ]  Johnson v The King (Sierra Leone) [1904] UKPC 38 22 Jun 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Aghore Nath Chatterji v Damodar Das Barman and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1904] UKPC 41 6 Jul 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Sahfiq-Un-Nisa v Khan Bahadur Raja Shaban Ali Khan (Oudh) [1904] UKPC 42 8 Jul 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Munnu Lal and Another v Maulvi Saiyid Muhammad Ismail and Others (Oudh) [1904] UKPC 45 12 Jul 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Sham Kumari v Raja Rameswar Singh Bahadoor and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1904] UKPC 43 12 Jul 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Official Assignee In Bankruptcy v Tan Cheng Guan (Singapore) [1904] UKPC 44 12 Jul 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  McLaughlin v Daily Telegraph Newspaper Co. Ltd [1904] 1 CLR 243; [1904] UKPC 46 15 Jul 1904 Griffith CJ Commonwealth, Contract, Commonwealth (High Court of Australia) The court considered the law on the effect of mental incapacity on a contract in the two cases Imperial Loan, and Molton v Camroux: "The principle of the decision seems, however, to be the same in both cases, which, in our judgment, establish that a contract made by a person actually of unsound, but apparently of sound mind with another who deals with him directly, and who has no knowledge of the unsoundness of mind, is as valid as if the unsoundness of mind had not existed. If the man dealing with the person of unsound mind is aware of his insanity, the contract is voidable at the option of the latter, but the party who takes advantage of the other cannot himself set up the incapacity. In this respect the matter is treated on the same footing as cases of fraud inducing a contract. There is, indeed, authority for saying that the equitable doctrines governing the validity or invalidity of a contract made with an insane person are only a particular instance of the general doctrines relating to fraudulent contracts. In the cases last mentioned no unfairness of dealing could be imputed to the persons who sought to take advantage of the contract, which was, in fact, made, In each case, with an apparently sane person. The principle appears to be that the validity of a contract made with an apparently sane person is to be determined - by the application of the same rules as are applied in ordinary cases." 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ]  McLaughlin v Daily Telegraph Newspaper Co. Ltd [1904] 1 CLR 243; [1904] UKPC 46 15 Jul 1904 Griffith CJ Commonwealth, Contract, Commonwealth (High Court of Australia) The court considered the law on the effect of mental incapacity on a contract in the two cases Imperial Loan, and Molton v Camroux: "The principle of the decision seems, however, to be the same in both cases, which, in our judgment, establish that a contract made by a person actually of unsound, but apparently of sound mind with another who deals with him directly, and who has no knowledge of the unsoundness of mind, is as valid as if the unsoundness of mind had not existed. If the man dealing with the person of unsound mind is aware of his insanity, the contract is voidable at the option of the latter, but the party who takes advantage of the other cannot himself set up the incapacity. In this respect the matter is treated on the same footing as cases of fraud inducing a contract. There is, indeed, authority for saying that the equitable doctrines governing the validity or invalidity of a contract made with an insane person are only a particular instance of the general doctrines relating to fraudulent contracts. In the cases last mentioned no unfairness of dealing could be imputed to the persons who sought to take advantage of the contract, which was, in fact, made, In each case, with an apparently sane person. The principle appears to be that the validity of a contract made with an apparently sane person is to be determined - by the application of the same rules as are applied in ordinary cases." 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Bailii ]  The Mayor, Councillors and Citzens of The City of Wellington v The Mayor, Councillors and Burgesses of The Borough of Lower Hutt (New Zealand) [1904] UKPC 51 26 Jul 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Dominion Bank (Petition for Special Leave To Appeal) v William Ewing and Another (Canada) [1904] UKPC 53 26 Jul 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Debi Pershad Chowdhry and Others v Rani Radha Chowdhrain (Since Deceased) and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1904] UKPC 50 26 Jul 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Upendra Krishna Mandal Executors of The Will of Kali Krishna Mandal (Deceased) v Ismail Khan Mahomed (Fort William (Bengal)) [1904] UKPC 47 26 Jul 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nilratan Mandal and Others v Ismail Khan Mahomed (Fort William (Bengal)) [1904] UKPC 48 26 Jul 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maung Shwe Oh and Another v Maung Tun Gyaw and Another (Lower Burma) [1904] UKPC 49 26 Jul 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharajah Madhava Singh (Petition for Special Leave To Appeal) v The Governor-General of India (India) [1904] UKPC 52 26 Jul 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Midland Navigation Company Limited (Petition for Special Leave To Appeal) v The Dominion Elevator Company Limited (Canada) [1904] UKPC 54 26 Jul 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mussummatt Kishmish Koer v Phil Chand Lal and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1904] UKPC 55 28 Jul 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Durga Bakhsh Singh v Mirza Muhammad Ali Beg (Oudh) [1904] UKPC 58 29 Jul 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shivabasava Kom Amingavda v Sangappa Bin Amingavda (Bombay) [1904] UKPC 57 29 Jul 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Pacific Co-Operative Steam Coal Company Limited v The Railway Commissioners of New South Wales (New South Wales) [1904] UKPC 59 29 Jul 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaja Jagadindra Nath Roy Bahadur v Rani Hemanta Kumari Debi and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1904] UKPC 56 29 Jul 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lee (Petition for Special Leave To Appeal v Reverend Robert Atherton (Diocese of Ely) [1904] UKPC 60 4 Aug 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Province of Manitoba v The Attorney General for The Dominion of Canada (Canada) [1904] UKPC 63 5 Aug 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Calgary and Edmonton Railway Company and Another v The King (Canada) [1904] UKPC 64 5 Aug 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hanson and Another v The Corporation of The Village of Grand Mþre (Canada) [1904] UKPC 62 5 Aug 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Toronto Railway Company v The Corporation of The City of Toronto (Ontario) [1904] UKPC 61 5 Aug 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Heslop v The Minister of Mines for New Zealand (New Zealand) [1904] UKPC 65 5 Aug 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Province of Prince Edward Island v The Attorney General for The Dominion of Canada (Canada) [1904] UKPC 66 4 Nov 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Province of New Brunswick v The Attorney General for The Dominion of Canada (Canada) [1904] UKPC 67 4 Nov 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Rampal Singh v Ram Ghulam Singh and Others Representatives of Ram Parshad Singh (Deceased) (Oudh) [1904] UKPC 70 11 Nov 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mcarthur v The Dominion Cartridge Company Limited (Canada) [1904] UKPC 69 11 Nov 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Khiarajmal and Others v Daim and Others (Sindh) [1904] UKPC 72 11 Nov 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Corporation of The City of Toronto v The Bell Telephone Company of Canada (Canada) [1904] UKPC 71 11 Nov 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chutterput Singh and Others v Maharaj Bahadoor and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1904] UKPC 68 11 Nov 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Canadian Pacific Railway Company v The Corporation of The City of Toronto [1904] UKPC 73 11 Nov 1904 PC Commonwealth Ontario [ Bailii ]  Chaudhri Latafat Husain v Badshah Husain Khan (Oudh) [1904] UKPC 74 15 Nov 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Akbar Khan (Since Deceased) and Others v Ramzan Khan and Others (Oudh) [1904] UKPC 76 8 Dec 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Me Gale v Ma Sa Yi (Lower Burma) [1904] UKPC 75 8 Dec 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Roberts v Ereaut (Connutable of The Parish of St. Saviour'S) (Jersey) [1904] UKPC 78 19 Dec 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commonwealth Portland Cement Company Limited v Weber Lohmann and Co. Limited [1904] UKPC 80 19 Dec 1904 PC Commonwealth New South Wales [ Bailii ]  The Bombay Uburmah Trading Corporation Limited v Dorabji Cursetji Shroff [1904] UKPC 79 19 Dec 1904 PC Commonwealth Bombay [ Bailii ]  Sri Vikrama Deo Maharajulugaru Maharaja of Jeypore v Gunapuram Deenabandu Patnaick and Others (Fort St. George Madras) [1904] UKPC 77 19 Dec 1904 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Donnelly v Adams [1905] 1 Irish Reports 154 1905 Commonwealth, Land (Ireland) 1 Citers  The United States of America v Gaynor [1905] AC 128 1905 PC Lord Halsbury L.C Commonwealth, Constitutional, Extradition The Privy Council allowed an appeal from an order of a Judge, itself having given special leave to appeal. Lord Halsbury LC said: "Their Lordships do not mean to suggest that the writ of habeas corpus is not applicable when there is a preliminary proceeding. Each case must depend upon its own merits. But where a prisoner is brought before a competent tribunal, and is charged with an extradition offence and remanded for the express purpose of affording the prosecution the opportunity of bringing forward the evidence by which that accusation is to be supported; if, in such a case, upon a writ of habeas corpus, a learned Judge treats the remand warrant as a nullity, and proceeds to adjudicate upon the case as though the whole evidence were before him, it would paralyze the administration of justice and render it impossible for the proceedings in extradition to be effective." 1 Citers   Re Collins (No 3); 1905 - (1905) 10 CCC 80  Riddiford v The King [1905] UKPC 3 8 Feb 1905 PC Commonwealth (New Zealand) [ Bailii ]  The United States of America v Gaynor and Another (Canada) [1905] UKPC 4 8 Feb 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Tali Concessions Limited v Hepple (Bechuanaland) [1905] UKPC 1 8 Feb 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Sri Sri Goura Chandra Gajapati Narayana Deo Maharajulun Garu v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Madras) [1905] UKPC 2 8 Feb 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lal Achal Ram v Raja Kazim Husain Khan (Oudh) [1905] UKPC 5 9 Feb 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Syed Asgar Reza v Hayes and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1905] UKPC 6 16 Feb 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Jawahir Singh v Lachhman Das (Oudh) [1905] UKPC 7 17 Feb 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Municipal Council of Sydney v The Austral Freezing Works Limited (New South Wales) [1905] UKPC 8 22 Feb 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Cox v The English Scottish and Australian Bank Limited (Queensland) [1905] UKPC 9 23 Feb 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Assets Company Limited v Pananapa Waihopi and Others (New Zealand) [1905] UKPC 11 1 Mar 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Assets Company Limited v Mere Roihi and Others (New Zealand) [1905] UKPC 10 1 Mar 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Assets Company Limited v Teira Ranginui and Others (New Zealand) [1905] UKPC 12 1 Mar 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Neame v The Ashanti Gold Coast Acquisitions Company Limited (Gold Coast Colony) [1905] UKPC 13 2 Mar 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ezra v The Secretary of State for India In Council and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1905] UKPC 14 3 Mar 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rai Banomali Roy Bahadur v Jagat Chandra Bhowmick and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1905] UKPC 15 15 Mar 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gopi Narain Khanna and Others v Babu Bansidhar [1905] UKPC 17 16 Mar 1905 PC Commonwealth Allahabad [ Bailii ]  Maulvi Saiyid Muhammad Munawwar Ali v Razia Bibi and Others (Allahabad) [1905] UKPC 16 16 Mar 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Veerabhadra Raju Bahadur Garu v Chrianjivi Ragu Garu (Madras) [1905] UKPC 18 16 Mar 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Bulli Kunwar v Musammat Bhagirathi (Allahabad) [1905] UKPC 20 24 Mar 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shaikh Kumar-Ud-Din Ahmad v Jawahir Lal and Another (Allahabad) [1905] UKPC 19 24 Mar 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  John Mclaughlin v Henry Francis Barton [1905] UKPC 21 6 Apr 1905 PC Commonwealth (New South Wales) [ Bailii ]  The Melbourne Tramway and Omnibus Company Limited v The Corporation of The City of Melbourne (Victoria) [1905] UKPC 22 12 Apr 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bastings and Others v Callaghan (New Zealand) [1905] UKPC 24 12 May 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nurjahan Begam Deceased By Her Heirs and Legal Representatives Haidar Husain Khan and Others v Faghfur Mirza and Others (Oudh) [1905] UKPC 23 12 May 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The National Trustees Executors and Agency Company of Australasia Limited v The General Finance Company of Australasia Limited (Victoria) [1905] UKPC 25 16 May 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Colonial Sugar Refining Company Limited v Irving The Collector of Customs for Queensland [1905] UKPC 27; [1905] AC 369 17 May 1905 PC Commonwealth (Queensland) A later Order cannot retroactively place restrictions upon a right of appeal that currently exists. 1 Citers [ Bailii ]  Ponnamma v Arumogam and Others (Ceylon) [1905] UKPC 26 17 May 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Sheo Singh Deceased and Raj Indra Bahadur Singh v Rani Raghubans Kunwar Andnrendra Bahadur Singh (Oudh) [1905] UKPC 28 18 May 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bai Gunabai and Others v Bhugwandas Valji and Others (Bombay) [1905] UKPC 29 24 May 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lichauco v Riley Hargreaves and Company Limited (Singapore) [1905] UKPC 31 25 May 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The New Zealand and Mercantile Agency Company Limited v Reid (New Zealand) [1905] UKPC 30 25 May 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mahant Bishambhar Das v Thakur Drigbijai Singh and Others and Others (Oudh) [1905] UKPC 32 29 Jun 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakurain Ritraj Koer v Thakurain Sarfaraz Koer (Oudh) [1905] UKPC 33 29 Jun 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Louis William Short, Frans Johannes Wepener and The Turffontein Propriety Estates Limited v The Turffontein Estate Limited (Transvaal) [1905] UKPC 35 3 Jul 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mirza Kurratulain Bahadur (Since Deceased and Represented By Nawab Akbari Begum and Others) and Others v Nawab Nuzhat-Ud-Dowla Abbas Hossein Khan Alias Peara Saheb (Fort William (Bengal)) [1905] UKPC 36 5 Jul 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Melbourne and Metropolitan Board of Works v Metropolitan Gas Company (Victoria) [1905] UKPC 37 5 Jul 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Benode Behari Bose and Others v Srimati Nistarini Dassi and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1905] UKPC 38 7 Jul 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  James Leslie Williams (Substituted for Critchett Walker Deceased) v John Howarth (New South Wales) [1905] UKPC 39 14 Jul 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Basanta Kumari Debi v Kamikshya Kumari Debi and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1905] UKPC 42 26 Jul 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Moola Cassim Bin Moola Ahmed v Moola Abdul Rahim and Others (Lower Burma) [1905] UKPC 41 26 Jul 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Burland v Earle and Others (Ontario) [1905] UKPC 43 26 Jul 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mcmaster v Mcphillamy (New South Wales) [1905] UKPC 44 26 Jul 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Henry Lewis Lubeck v Court of The Resident In Mysore (Mysore) [1905] UKPC 40 26 Jul 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  E W Gillett Company Limited v Lumsden [1905] UKPC 45 28 Jul 1905 PC Commonwealth Ontario [ Bailii ]  Kachi Yuva Rengappa Kalakka Thola Udayar and Others and Others v Kachi Yuva Rengappa Kalakka Thola Udayar and Others and Others (Madras) [1905] UKPC 46 31 Jul 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Alexander F. C. Ross v Beaudry and Others (Quebec) [1905] UKPC 47 2 Aug 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chaudhri Ahmad Bakhsh v Seth Raghubar Dayal and Another (Oudh) [1905] UKPC 48 2 Aug 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Central Ontario Railway v The Trusts and Guarantee Company Limited (Ontario) [1905] UKPC 50 4 Aug 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Tituram Mukerji and Others v Cohen and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1905] UKPC 49 4 Aug 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Owners of The British Steamship Empress of India v The Imperial Chinese Government Owners of The Cruiser Quangtai (China and Corea) [1905] UKPC 51 4 Aug 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Potter v Broken Hill Pty Co Ltd [1905] VLR 612; [1905] VicLawRp 93; [1905] 11 ALR 357; [1905] 27 Alt 74 21 Aug 1905 Hodges, Hood JJ Jurisdiction, Commonwealth VLR (Supreme Court - Victoria) International law - Conflict of laws - Tort committed abroad - Jurisdiction - Patent in New South Wales - Infringement by Victorian company in New South Wales of New South Wales patent - Action not justiciable in Victoria - "Local action" - "Transitory action" - Practice - Demurrer - Right of reply. Patents could be granted by the several States in Australia. Potter obtained a patent in Victoria for the separation of metals from sulphide ores and a patent for the same process in New South Wales. He claimed that (as well as a threatened infringement of the Victorian patent in Victoria) the defendant had infringed the New South Wales patent at its mine in New South Wales. Broken Hill denied novelty and utility, but also said that an action for the infringement in New South Wales of a New South Wales patent was not justiciable in the Victorian courts. Held: The Full Court of the Supreme Court of Victoria, decided by a majority that the claim was not justiciable. 1 Citers [ Austlii ]  The Mayor Councillors and Citizens of The City of Hawthorn v Kannuluik [1905] UKPC 52 7 Nov 1905 PC Commonwealth (Victoria) [ Bailii ]  The Toronto Railway Company v The Corporation of The City of Toronto [1905] UKPC 53 8 Nov 1905 PC Commonwealth (Ontario) [ Bailii ]  Saunby v The Water Commissioners of The City of London and The Corporation of The City of London (Canada) [1905] UKPC 54 9 Nov 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Montreal Street Railway Company v The City of Montreal (Canada) [1905] UKPC 55 14 Nov 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Mort'S Dock Engineering Company Limited v Wadley and (New South Wales) [1905] UKPC 57 15 Nov 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Raja Venkata Narasimha Appa Rao Bahadur Zemindar Garu v Sri Raja Sobhanadri Appa Rao Bahadur Zemindar and 16 Others [1905] UKPC 59 15 Nov 1905 PC Commonwealth (Madras) [ Bailii ]  Wadley v The Mort'S Dock Engineering Company Limited (New South Wales) [1905] UKPC 58 15 Nov 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Mort'S Dock Engineering Company Limited v Wadley and (New South Wales) [1905] UKPC 56 15 Nov 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Sahoda and Others v Ganesh Parshad (Oudh) [1905] UKPC 60 17 Nov 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bibi Jarao Kumari Debi v Gopi Chand Bothra and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1905] UKPC 61 17 Nov 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kunwar Sanwal Singh v Rani Satrupa Kunwar (Oudh) [1905] UKPC 62 22 Nov 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Chitpal Singh v Bhairon Bakhsh Singh (Oudh) [1905] UKPC 63 23 Nov 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Balwant Singh v Amolak Ram and Others (Allahabad) [1905] UKPC 64 24 Nov 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Walter Baine Grieve v Marion Jack Tasker (Newfoundland) [1905] UKPC 68 28 Nov 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jawahir Singh v Someshar Dat and Others (Oudh) [1905] UKPC 69 28 Nov 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaja Bahadur Sir Jotindra Mohun Tagore v Bibi Jarao Kumari (Fort William (Bengal)) [1905] UKPC 65 28 Nov 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Municipal Officer Aden v Hajee Ismail Allana and Others (Bombay) [1905] UKPC 67 28 Nov 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chapman and Another v The Great Central Freehold Mines Limited (Victoria) [1905] UKPC 66 28 Nov 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Clouston and Company Limited v Corry [1905] UKPC 70; [1906] AC 122 1 Dec 1905 PC Commonwealth, Employment (New Zealand) 1 Citers [ Bailii ]  The Van Diemen's Land Company v The Marine Board of Table Cape [1905] UKPC 71 4 Dec 1905 PC Commonwealth (Tasmania) [ Bailii ]  Raja Udai Partab Adiya Dat Singh v Musammat Muna and Others (Oudh) [1905] UKPC 72 7 Dec 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Deoki Singh and Others v Musammat Anupa and Madho Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1905] UKPC 73 8 Dec 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Reid v Smith [1905] 3 CLR 656 8 Dec 1905 Griffiths CJ, O'Connor J Commonwealth (High Court of Australia) The Supreme Court of Queensland had held that the house remained a chattel. "The short point raised in this case is whether an ordinary dwelling-house, erected upon an ordinary town allotment in a large town, but not fastened to the soil, remains a chattel or becomes part of the freehold." Held: The High Court reversed the decision, treating the answer as being almost a matter of common sense. The house was made of wood, and rested by its own weight on brick piers. The house was not attached to the brick piers in any way. It was separated by iron plates placed on top of the piers, in order to prevent an invasion of white ants. O'Connor J: "It would I think be stretching the rules of the common law to a point at which they cease to be rules of common sense, if it were to be laid down as a general rule that, except in very exceptional cases, wooden houses, resting by their own weight on land, could ever be regarded as mere chattels, removable at the will of the owner of the timber of which they are built." Griffith CJ: "I differ from the learned judge in thinking that it is not sufficient to show that the thing in question is a dwelling-house -- an ordinary dwelling-house, on a town allotment, in an inhabited town. In the case of a similar building in another part of the country, erected under entirely different circumstances, a different conclusion might be drawn." 1 Citers [ Austlii ]  The Taluka of Kotda-Sangani v The State of Gondal [1905] UKPC 75 18 Dec 1905 PC Commonwealth (Bombay) [ Bailii ]  Hemchand Devchand v Azam Sakarlal Chhotamlal (Bombay) [1905] UKPC 74 18 Dec 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Ship Kitty D v The King (Canada) [1905] UKPC 76 21 Dec 1905 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Regina v Andrew Brown (1907) 7 NSWSR 290 1906 Darley CJ Commonwealth, Criminal Practice (New South Wales - Australia) Darley CJ said: "I have come to the conclusion that the authorities are all one way, and that the Court cannot look at the affidavits of jurymen for any purpose, whether it be for the purpose of granting a new trial, or for the purpose of establishing the misconduct of a juryman". 1 Citers  Sardar Karam Singh v Thakurain Bhagwant Kunwar and Another [1906] UKPC 1 7 Feb 1906 PC Commonwealth Oudh Lucknow [ Bailii ]  The Montreal and St. Lawrence Light and Power Company v Robert [1906] UKPC 2 7 Feb 1906 PC Commonwealth Quebec [ Bailii ]  Max Herman Wehner v The King [1906] UKPC 3 8 Feb 1906 PC Commonwealth Eastern Africa [ Bailii ]  Robertson v Fairweather [1906] UKPC 6 14 Feb 1906 PC Commonwealth New Brunswick [ Bailii ]  Mutsaddi Lal (Since Deceased and Now Represented By Jet Mal and Another) and Umrao Singh v Kundan Lal Alias Kanhaiya Lal [1906] UKPC 4 14 Feb 1906 PC Commonwealth Allahabad [ Bailii ]  Dame Mary Miller sub-Nom Et sub-Qualite v The Grand Trunk Railway Company of Canada [1906] UKPC 5 14 Feb 1906 PC Commonwealth (Canada) [ Bailii ]  Venganat Swaroopathil Valia Nambidi Avergal v Cherakunnath Nambiyathan Manbudris Son Khrishnan Nambudripad and Another [1906] UKPC 7 15 Feb 1906 PC Commonwealth Madras [ Bailii ]  Gangamoyi Debi v Troiluckhya Nath Chowdhry and Another [1906] UKPC 8 16 Feb 1906 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Thakur Durga Singh v Thakur Sheopal Singh [1906] UKPC 9 21 Feb 1906 PC Commonwealth (Oudh) [ Bailii ]  Baudains and Others v Richardson and Another [1906] UKPC 10 27 Feb 1906 PC Commonwealth (Jersey) [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Province of British Columbia v The Canadian Pacific Railway Company [1906] UKPC 11 27 Feb 1906 PC Commonwealth British Columbia [ Bailii ]  Ismail Mussajee Mookerdum v Hafiz Boo [1906] UKPC 14 14 Mar 1906 PC Commonwealth (Lower Burma) [ Bailii ]  Williams and Another v The Permanent Trustee Company of New South Wales Limited [1906] UKPC 12 14 Mar 1906 PC Commonwealth (New South Wales) [ Bailii ]  The City of Montreal v Cantin and Others [1906] UKPC 13 14 Mar 1906 PC Commonwealth (Canada) [ Bailii ]  Potter v Broken Hill Pty Co Ltd (1906) 3 CLR 479; [1906] HCA 88 20 Mar 1906 Griffith C.J., Barton and O'Connor JJ Jurisdiction, Commonwealth, Intellectual Property (High Court of Australia) (affirmed) 1 Cites 1 Citers [ Austlii ]  Malik Ahmad Wali Khan v Musammat Shamsi Jahan Begam and Another (Allahabad) [1906] UKPC 16 21 Mar 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rani Hemanta Kumari Debi and Another v The Secretary of State for India In Council and Another [1906] UKPC 17 21 Mar 1906 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Rani Hemanta Kumari Debi v Maharaja Jagadindra Nath Roy Bahadur and The Secretary of State for India In Council (Fort William (Bengal)) [1906] UKPC 19 21 Mar 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chaudhri Mehdi Hasan v Muhammad Hasan (Oudh) [1906] UKPC 15 21 Mar 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Colonial Sugar Refining Company Limited v Irving [1906] UKPC 20 28 Mar 1906 PC Commonwealth (Queensland) [ Bailii ]  Rani Itraq Kunwar v Musammat Bachcha Mahadeo Kunwar (Oudh) [1906] UKPC 21 28 Mar 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mgomini and Others v The Governor of Natal (Natal) [1906] UKPC 22 2 Apr 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Lali v Murli Dhar (Allahabad) [1906] UKPC 23 9 Apr 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  John Norton v Allan Arthur Taylor (New South Wales) [1906] UKPC 25 10 Apr 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sheikh Hub Ali v Wazir-Un-Nissa and Another (Oudh) [1906] UKPC 24 10 Apr 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chasrles Frederick Cross and Others Patent v Patent No. 8700 of 1892 (Whitehall Court Chamber) [1906] UKPC 26 2 May 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Manohar Lal v Jadunath Singh and Others (Oudh) [1906] UKPC 27 3 May 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gangaram Biharilal v The Firm of Shriram Shaligram (Hyderabad) [1906] UKPC 28 8 May 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bai Kesserbai v Hunsraj Morarji and Another (Bombay) [1906] UKPC 29 9 May 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Auseri Lal (Since Deceased and Now Represented By Dhanipal Das) and Another v Raja Maneshar Bakhsh Singh (Oudh) [1906] UKPC 30 10 May 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chu Ping v Chan Ut Chin and Another (Hong Kong) [1906] UKPC 31 10 May 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mclaughlin v Westgarth and Another [1906] UKPC 33 17 May 1906 PC Commonwealth (New South Wales) [ Bailii ]  Evans v Thomas (His Britannic Majesty'S Supreme Court for China) [1906] UKPC 34 17 May 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Vasudeva Modeliar and Others v Shadagopa Modeliar (Madras) [1906] UKPC 32 17 May 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ramanathan Chetti v Murugappa Chetti (Madras) [1906] UKPC 36 24 May 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maniram v Seth Rupchand (India) [1906] UKPC 37 25 May 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaja Kumar Babu Ganeswar Singh(Since Deceased and Now Represented By Babu Laliteswar Singh) v Mohunt Ganesh Das (Since Deceased and Now Represented By Mahant Ram Kishen Das) (Fort William (Bengal)) [1906] UKPC 38 19 Jun 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Spencer and Others v Langdon [1906] UKPC 39 19 Jun 1906 PC Commonwealth (Western Australia) [ Bailii ]  The Victorian Railway Commissioners v Brown [1906] UKPC 40 20 Jun 1906 PC Commonwealth (Australia) [ Bailii ]  Kannepalli Suryanarayana and Others v Pucha Venkataramana (Madras) [1906] UKPC 41 21 Jun 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chandrasang Himatsang v Mohansang Hamirsang (Bombay) [1906] UKPC 42 22 Jun 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Wifrey Ore Concentrator Syndicate Limited v N. Guthridge Limited (Australia) [1906] UKPC 43 27 Jun 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  E R Whitney (Deceased and Now Represented By Neuberger and Another) The Executors of His Will v Joyce and Another [1906] UKPC 44 4 Jul 1906 PC Commonwealth (Quebec) [ Bailii ]  The Michigan Central Railroad Company and Another v The Lake Erie and Detroit River Company Railway Company (Ontario) [1906] UKPC 45 11 Jul 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Trimble and Another v Goldberg (Transvaal) [1906] UKPC 46 16 Jul 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hamburg v Pickard (Transvaal) [1906] UKPC 47 16 Jul 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Harsha v United States of America (Ontario) [1906] UKPC 48 18 Jul 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  George D. Emery Company v Wells (British Honduras) [1906] UKPC 50 24 Jul 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Dundee Coal Company Limited v The Minister of Agriculture of The Colony Natal [1906] UKPC 49 24 Jul 1906 PC Commonwealth Natal [ Bailii ]  Spencer v The Registrar of Titles [1906] UKPC 51 25 Jul 1906 PC Commonwealth Western Australia [ Bailii ]  The Commissioner of Taxes v The Eastern Extension Australasia and China Telegraph Company Limited (New Zealand) [1906] UKPC 52 25 Jul 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Colonial Bank of Australasia Limited v Marshall and Another [1906] UKPC 54 27 Jul 1906 PC Commonwealth (Australia) [ Bailii ]  Thakur Tirbhuwan Bahadur Singh (Minor Son and Legal Representative of Thakur Sher Bahadur Singh Deceased) v Raja Rameshar Bakhsh Singh (Oudh) [1906] UKPC 53 27 Jul 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Dominion of Canada v Everett E. Cain and James Raymond Gilhula (Ontario) [1906] UKPC 55 27 Jul 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lapointe v L' Association De Bienfaisance Et Retraite De La Police De Montreal (Quebec) [1906] UKPC 56 27 Jul 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Emmerson v Maddison (Canada) [1906] UKPC 57 27 Jul 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nawab Shah Alam Mirza v The Deputy Commissioner of Sitapur [1906] UKPC 58 27 Jul 1906 PC Commonwealth (Oudh) [ Bailii ]  Mussammat Parbati Koer and Others v Ram Kishan Singh Deceased (Now Represented By Joy Kishan Singh and Others) and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1906] UKPC 60 27 Jul 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lekha Singh and Others v Champat Singh (Oudh) [1906] UKPC 59 27 Jul 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Joan Olive Dunsmuir v James Dunsmuir and Edna Wallace Hopper (British Columbia) [1906] UKPC 62 2 Aug 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Province of British Columbia v The Attorney General for The Dominion of Canada (British Columbia) [1906] UKPC 61 2 Aug 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nawab Shah Ara Begam and Others v Nanhi Begam and Another (Oudh) [1906] UKPC 64 1 Nov 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ganesh Pershad v Syed Mahomed Khaliluddin [1906] UKPC 63 1 Nov 1906 PC Commonwealth (Fort William (Bengal)) [ Bailii ]  Goswami Sri Ghanshiam Lalji v Ram Narain (Allahabad) [1906] UKPC 65 1 Nov 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Tilonko v The King (Natal) [1906] UKPC 71 2 Nov 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Anijad Ali Khan v Nawab Ali Khan and Others (Oudh) [1906] UKPC 69 2 Nov 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Prufontaine v Grenier (Quebec) [1906] UKPC 66 2 Nov 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Home Insurance of New York v Victoria-Montreal Fire Insurance Company (Canada) [1906] UKPC 67 2 Nov 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Brothers of The Christian Schools and Others v The Minister of Education for The Province of Ontario and Another (Ontario) [1906] UKPC 68 2 Nov 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Khan Bahadur Haji Sajan Lalji v The Hyderabad (Deccan) Company Limited (Hyderabad) [1906] UKPC 70 2 Nov 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Grand Trunk Railway Company of Canada v The Attorney General for The Dominion of Canada (Canada) [1906] UKPC 72 5 Nov 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ward v The Bishop of Mauritius (Seychelles) [1906] UKPC 73 8 Nov 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rameswar Pershad Singh v Ram Bahadur Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1906] UKPC 74 15 Nov 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Webb v Outrim (Victoria) [1906] UKPC 75 6 Dec 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rani Chandra Kunwar v Chaudhri Narpat Singh and Others Raja Makund Singh (Allahabad) [1906] UKPC 82 14 Dec 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shahar Banooa v Aga Mahomed Jaffer Bindaneem and Others [1906] UKPC 79 14 Dec 1906 PC Commonwealth Lower Burma [ Bailii ]  S. B. Sarbadhicary v In The Matter Of [1906] UKPC 78 14 Dec 1906 PC Commonwealth Allahabad [ Bailii ]  Rani Sundar Koer v Rai Sham Krishen and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1906] UKPC 84 14 Dec 1906 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Perry v Cissold and Others [1906] UKPC 81 14 Dec 1906 PC Commonwealth Australia [ Bailii ]  The Owners of The Steamship Stephanos v The Owners of The Steamship Craiglee [1906] UKPC 77 14 Dec 1906 PC Commonwealth Constantinople [ Bailii ]  Gajrajmatii Teorain and Others v Saiyid Akbar Husain and Others [1906] UKPC 80 14 Dec 1906 PC Commonwealth Allahabad [ Bailii ]  Bomanjee Cowasjee v The Chief Judge and Judges of The Court of Lower Burma [1906] UKPC 83 14 Dec 1906 PC Commonwealth Lower Burma [ Bailii ]  The Richelieu and Ontario Navigation Company Owners of The Steamship Canada v The Owners of The Steamship Cape Breton [1906] UKPC 76 14 Dec 1906 PC Commonwealth Canada [ Bailii ]  Jonnalagadda Venkamma and Jonnalagadda Lakshminarayana v Jonnalagadda Subrahmaniam and Jonnalagadda Narasimham [1906] UKPC 85 18 Dec 1906 PC Commonwealth Madras [ Bailii ]  The Equitable Fire and Accident Office Limited v The Ching Wo Hong [1906] UKPC 86 19 Dec 1906 PC Commonwealth His Britannic Majesty's Supreme Court for China and Corea [ Bailii ]   Regina v Andrew Brown; 1907 - (1907) 7 NSW State Reports 290  The Attorney General v Ward Brothers (New Zealand) [1907] UKPC 1 5 Feb 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Abdul Ghani Khan and Another v The Deputy Commissioner of Kheri (Oudh) [1907] UKPC 2 6 Feb 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Vilander Concessions Syndicate v The Government of The Colony of The Cape of Good Hope (Cape of Good Hope) [1907] UKPC 6 7 Feb 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lal Bahadur and Others v Kanhaia Lal (Allahabad) [1907] UKPC 7 7 Feb 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Deputy Commissioner of Kheri v Khanjan Singh and Others (Oudh) [1907] UKPC 4 7 Feb 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Anandrao Ganpatrao and Others v Vasantrao Madhavrao and Others (Bombay) [1907] UKPC 3 7 Feb 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bijoy Gopal Mukerji and Others v Srimati Kristna Mahishi Debi (Legal Representative of Nil Ratan Kristna Deceased) (Fort William (Bengal)) [1907] UKPC 5 7 Feb 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Prayaga Doss Jee Varu v Tirumala Anandam Pillai Purisa Sriranga Charylu Varu and Another (Madras) [1907] UKPC 8 8 Feb 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commissioners of Taxation v Palmer and Others (New South Wales) [1907] UKPC 9 8 Feb 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  William Philips Thompson v Pieter Van Gelder (Patents) (The Whitehall Court Chamber) [1907] UKPC 10 14 Feb 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Ship Albano and Her Freight v The Allan Line Steamship Company Limited (Canada) [1907] UKPC 11 27 Feb 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sadagopa Chariar and Others v A. Rama (Since Deceased Now Represented By Krishnamoorthy Rao) and Others (Madras) [1907] UKPC 13 21 Mar 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Faiyaz Husain Khan v Munshi Prag Narain and Others (Oudh) [1907] UKPC 12 21 Mar 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Actieselskad Langfond (Owners of The Steamship Langfond) v The Canadian Forwarding and Export Company Limited (Quebec) [1907] UKPC 14 22 Mar 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dhanukdhari Singh and Another v Mahabir Pershad Singh and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1907] UKPC 15 23 Apr 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Corporation of The City of Toronto v The Toronto Railway Company (Ontario) [1907] UKPC 17 26 Apr 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Corporation of The City of Toronto v The Toronto Railway Company (Ontario) [1907] UKPC 17 26 Apr 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Delmege Forsyth and Company v Wairamuttu Candyah (Ceylon) [1907] UKPC 20 26 Apr 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Demerara Electric Company Limited v White and Others (British Guiana) [1907] UKPC 16 26 Apr 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Tung Ta Bank and Others v The Chartered Bank of India, Australia and China (China and Corea) [1907] UKPC 19 26 Apr 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Russo-Chinese Bank v The Yangtsze Insurance Association Limited (China and Corea) [1907] UKPC 18 26 Apr 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bachoo Hurkisondas v Mankorebai and Others (Bombay) [1907] UKPC 21 9 May 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Barrette v Le Syndicat Lyonnais Du Klondyke (Canada) [1907] UKPC 22 9 May 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kessowji Issur v The Great Indian Peninsula Railway Company (Bombay) [1907] UKPC 23 9 May 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The King v Lodewyk Johannes Dr Jager (Natal) [1907] UKPC 24 9 May 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Annada Pershad Panja and Others v Prasannamoyi Dasi (Fort William (Bengal)) [1907] UKPC 25 15 May 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Har Shankar Partab Singh and Another v Lal Raghuraj Singh [1907] UKPC 26 15 May 1907 PC Commonwealth Oudh [ Bailii ]  Hari Mohun Misser and Others v Surendra Narayan Singh (Fort William (Bengal)) [1907] UKPC 27 15 May 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nabakumari Debi v Behari Lal Sen and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1907] UKPC 28 5 Jun 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Chanda Dei and Another v Madho Saran (Allahabad) [1907] UKPC 29 6 Jun 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jawahir Singh v Baldeo Bakhsh Singh and Others (Oudh) [1907] UKPC 30 11 Jun 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Municipal Council of Sydney v Terry (New South Wales) [1907] UKPC 31 19 Jun 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Omanhene F.W.Q. Akuffo and Others v Kwabina Yarenchi (Gold Coast Colony) [1907] UKPC 35 20 Jun 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Muhammad Mumtaz Ali Khan v Murad Bakhsh and 5 Others (Oudh) [1907] UKPC 32 20 Jun 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Muhammad Mumtaz Ali Khan v Saiyid Muhammad Mohsin and Another and Others (Oudh) [1907] UKPC 33 20 Jun 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Standard Bank of South Africa Limited v Heydenrych (Cape of Good Hope) [1907] UKPC 34 20 Jun 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ibrahim Goolam Ariff v Saiboo and Others (Lower Burma) [1907] UKPC 36 3 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shahzadi Begam (Since Deceased) and Others v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Fort William (Bengal)) [1907] UKPC 38 3 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shahzadi Begam (Since Deceased) and Others v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Fort William (Bengal)) [1907] UKPC 38 3 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Moulvie Mahomed Ikramull Huq v Wilkie and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1907] UKPC 37 3 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commissioners of Taxation v Mooney (Australia) [1907] UKPC 39 4 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The King v Tilonko (Natal) [1907] UKPC 41 5 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chop Ek Chiang and Another v The Official Assignee (Straits Settlements) [1907] UKPC 40 5 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mcnaghten v Patterson (Australia) [1907] UKPC 46 22 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mcgregor v The Esquimalt and Nanaimo Railway Company (British Columbia) [1907] UKPC 44 22 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Vasudeva Mudaliar and Others v K. S. Srinivasa Pillai and Another (Madras) [1907] UKPC 43 22 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chabildas Lalloobhai v Dayal Mowji and Others (Bombay) [1907] UKPC 42 22 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commissioners of Stamp Duties v Salting and Another (New South Wales) [1907] UKPC 45 22 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mccormick v Simpson and Others (Quebec) [1907] UKPC 50 31 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for New South Wales v The Curator of Intestate Estates (New South Wales) [1907] UKPC 48 31 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The State of Victoria v The Mayor Aldermen Councillors and Citizens of The City of Melbourne [1907] UKPC 55 31 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth (Australia) [ Bailii ]  Cabot v The Attorney General of The Province of Quebec (Quebec) [1907] UKPC 53 31 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dumphy v The Montreal Light Heat and Power Company (Quebec) [1907] UKPC 49 31 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Esquimalt Waterworks Company v The Corporation of The City of Victoria (British Columbia) [1907] UKPC 52 31 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The King v Badger (New Zealand) [1907] UKPC 51 31 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   The Lyttelton Times Company Limited v Warners Limited; PC 31-Jul-1907 - [1907] UKPC 47; [1907] AC 476; [1904-07] All ER 200  Townsend v Cox (Nova Scotia) [1907] UKPC 54 31 Jul 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bajrangi Singh (Since Deceased and Now Represented By Drighpal Singh and Gulab Singh) and Another v Manokarnika Bakhsh Singh (Oudh Lucknow) [1907] UKPC 56 31 Oct 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lovell and Christmas Limited v The Commissioner of Taxes [1907] UKPC 57 31 Oct 1907 PC Commonwealth (New Zealand) [ Bailii ]  The Corporation of The City of Toronto v The Canadian Pacific Railway Company [1907] UKPC 58 18 Nov 1907 PC Commonwealth Ontario [ Bailii ]  Raja Gokuldas and Others v Seth Ghasiram (India) [1907] UKPC 60 19 Nov 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bibi Phul Kumari v Ghanshyam Misra and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1907] UKPC 59 19 Nov 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mussammat Walihan and Others v Jogeshwar Narayan and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1907] UKPC 61 20 Nov 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Fatima Bibi and Others v Sheikh Ahmed Buksh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1907] UKPC 64 2 Dec 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Garu Prasanna Lahiri and Others v Jotindra Mohun Lahiri (Fort William (Bengal)) [1907] UKPC 62 2 Dec 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Wun Di and Another v Ma Kin and Others (Lower Burma) [1907] UKPC 63 2 Dec 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mcvity and Another v Tranouth and Another (Canada) [1907] UKPC 65 3 Dec 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Zacklynski and Others v Polushie and Others (Canada) [1907] UKPC 66 3 Dec 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Surajmani and Others v Rabi Nath Ojha and Another (Allahabad) [1907] UKPC 67 5 Dec 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mcconnell v Beatty and Another (Ontario) [1907] UKPC 68 10 Dec 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Pramada Nath Roy v Raja Ramani Kanta Roy and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1907] UKPC 69 11 Dec 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Muhammad Naseem v Mirza Muhammad Abbas Ali Khan (Oudh) [1907] UKPC 70 11 Dec 1907 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Leeder v The Mayor, etc, of the Town of Ballarat East 1908 VLR 214 1908 Cussen J Commonwealth (Supreme Court of Victoria in Australia) The court considered the requirement of giving notice within a certain period of time to the municipality as a precondition of a person recovering damages from the municipality as a result of the state of the highway. Notice had to be given within 21 days unless the plaintiff could "show some sufficient reason why the person injured or the owner of such property was unable to give such notice". Held: The court discussed what shade of meaning should be attached to the word "unable". Cussen J focused more on the words "sufficient reason" within the statutory provision, and said: "I think, for myself, that the emphatic words in the section are the words 'show sufficient reason'." 1 Citers   Doodeward v Spence; 1908 - [1908] 6 CLR 40  The Commissioners of Taxation (Reasons) v John Baxter and Others [1908] UKPC 1 14 Jan 1908 PC Commonwealth Australia [ Bailii ]  The Owners of The British Steamship Midlothian v The Owners of The Spanish Brig Dolores Vilaseca (Admiralty Jurisdiction) [1908] UKPC 6 24 Jan 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Quebec Improvement Company v The Quebec Bridge and Railway Company (Quebec) [1908] UKPC 4 24 Jan 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Baijnath Gaenka Legal Representative of Mangani Ram Marwari Deceased and Another v Ramhari Chowdhry and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1908] UKPC 3 24 Jan 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Rai Bhagwat Dayal Singh and Others v Debi Dayal Sahu and Others [1908] UKPC 2 24 Jan 1908 PC Commonwealth (Fort William (Bengal)) [ Bailii ]  Spencer v The Registrar of Titles [1908] UKPC 5 24 Jan 1908 PC Commonwealth Western Australia [ Bailii ]  The Mcarthur Export Company v J. B. Klock (Quebec) [1908] UKPC 7 24 Jan 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chhattrapat Singh Dugar v Maharaj Bahadur Singh and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1908] UKPC 8 4 Feb 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Douglas Menzies v Umphelby and Others (New South Wales) [1908] UKPC 10 12 Feb 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pestonji Jivanji and Others v Shapurji Edulji Chinroy and Others (Hyderabad) [1908] UKPC 9 12 Feb 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Toronto Railway Company v King and Another (Ontario) [1908] UKPC 11 13 Mar 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The China Navigation Company Limited Owners of The SS Chinkiang v The Commissioners for Executing The Office of The Lord High Admiral of The United Kingdom and Another [1908] UKPC 12 18 Mar 1908 PC Commonwealth, Transport China and Corea [ Bailii ]  Hansraj and Others v Dwarka Das and Another and Another (Central India) [1908] UKPC 14 18 Mar 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hansraj and Others v Sundar Lal and Another (Central India) [1908] UKPC 13 18 Mar 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The King v Mbombo and Others (Natal) [1908] UKPC 17 18 Mar 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Municipality of Bulawayo v The Bulawayo Waterworks Company Limited (Cape of Good Hope) [1908] UKPC 16 18 Mar 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  T. P. Petherpermal Chetty v R. Muniandy Servai and Others (Lower Burma) [1908] UKPC 15 18 Mar 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The East London Harbour Board v The Caledonia Landing Shipping and Salvage Company Limited (Cape of Good Hope) [1908] UKPC 19 2 Apr 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Houlder Brothers and Company Limited v The Commissioner of Public Works [1908] UKPC 20 2 Apr 1908 PC Commonwealth Cape of Good Hope [ Bailii ]  Dalip Singh and Others v Chaudhrain Nawal Kunwar and Another (Allahabad) [1908] UKPC 18 2 Apr 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Campbell v The Australia Mutual Provident Society and Others (New South Wales) [1908] UKPC 21 12 May 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Radha Prosad Mullick and Another v Ranimoni Dassi and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1908] UKPC 22 14 May 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shrager and Another v March (Singapore) [1908] UKPC 23 21 May 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Henry Charles [Patent ] v No. 10,274 of 1894 (Whitehall Court Chamber) [1908] UKPC 24 22 May 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Blake and Another v Bayne and Another (Australia) [1908] UKPC 25 26 May 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Bank of Bombay v Suleman Somji (Bombay) [1908] UKPC 26 2 Jun 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Macintosh and Another v Dun and Others (Australia) [1908] UKPC 27 3 Jun 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Debendra Nath Dutt v The Administrator General of Bengal and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1908] UKPC 28 3 Jun 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The International Harvester Company of America v Walter Chamberlain Peacock (Australia) [1908] UKPC 29 25 Jun 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sarkaralinga Nadan and Others v Raja Rajeswara Dorai Alias Mutturamalinga Dorai and Others [1908] UKPC 30 1 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth Madras [ Bailii ]  Ibrahim Esmael and Others v Abdool Carrim Peermamode and Others [1908] UKPC 31 3 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth Mauritius [ Bailii ]  Strickland and Others v Strickland [1908] UKPC 32; [1908] AC 551 8 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth, Wills and Probate Malta [ Bailii ]  Fulton v Norton (Canada) [1908] UKPC 33 9 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The King v Mclean (Canada) [1908] UKPC 34 10 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  C. W. Reardon and Te Pamoa v The King (New Zealand) [1908] UKPC 37 16 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Atar Singh and Others v Thakar Singh (Punjab) [1908] UKPC 36 16 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commercial Rubber Company Limited v The Corporation of The Town of St. Jerome (Quebec) [1908] UKPC 35 16 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  John Mcgrath v The Bench of Justices for The Adelaide Licensing District (South Australia) [1908] UKPC 38 17 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Reid-Newfoundland Company v The King (Newfoundland) [1908] UKPC 39 17 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rieken v The Bench of Justices for The Yorke Peninsula Licensing District (South Australia) [1908] UKPC 41 20 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Keam and Others v The Bench of Justices for The Adelaide Licensing District (South Australia) [1908] UKPC 42 20 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  J. Ullman and Company v Cesar Leuba and Another (Hong Kong) [1908] UKPC 43 20 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Foong Tai and Company v Buchhiester and Company (China and Corea) [1908] UKPC 40 20 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Bank of Bombay and Another v Suleman Somji and Others (Bombay) [1908] UKPC 44 21 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  James Douglas v Joseph Baynes (Transvaal) [1908] UKPC 46 27 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kalka Parshad and Others v Mathura Parshad and Others (Oudh) [1908] UKPC 45 27 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The King v Walkem (British Columbia) [1908] UKPC 47 27 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Laurence Joseph Harnett v William Patrick Crick (New South Wales) [1908] UKPC 48 28 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  William Jose and Others v The Metallic Roofing Company of Canada Limited (Ontario) [1908] UKPC 50 30 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Reid-Newfoundland Company v The Anglo-American Telegraph Company Limited (Newfoundland) [1908] UKPC 52 30 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mary Watts v Rubin Watts (British Columbia) [1908] UKPC 53 30 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Corporation of The City of Toronto v John Russell (Ontario) [1908] UKPC 49 30 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  George Shea Mayor of St. Johns Municipal Council v The Reid-Newfoundland Company (Newfoundland) [1908] UKPC 51 30 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pandit Gayna Parshad Tewari v Sardar Bhagat Singh and Another (Oudh) [1908] UKPC 54 31 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pruvost and Others v Pruvost and Others (Canada) [1908] UKPC 56 31 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Alfred S. Woodruff and Others v The Attorney General for The Province of Ontario (Ontario) [1908] UKPC 57 31 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Crown Grain Company Limited The Attorney General for The Province of Manitoba (Intervenient) v H. L. Day (Canada) [1908] UKPC 58 31 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mahomed Ali Haidar Khan and Another Heirs and Legal Representatives of Mahomed Ali Amjad Khan Deceased v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Fort William (Bengal)) [1908] UKPC 55 31 Jul 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Scottish Union and National Insurance Company v Alfred Pawsey and Company [1908] UKPC 60 16 Oct 1908 PC Commonwealth (Jamaica) [ Bailii ]  La Compagnie Hydraulique De St. Franþois v The Continental Heat and Light Company and Another (Quebec) [1908] UKPC 59 16 Oct 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Henry Howard Chippendall v William Laidley and Company Limited (New South Wales) [1908] UKPC 61 29 Oct 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Amna Bibi and Others v Udit Narain Misra and Others (Allahabad) [1908] UKPC 63 10 Nov 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Natal Land and Colonization Company Limited v John William Rycroft (Natal) [1908] UKPC 62 10 Nov 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Udugama Koralalage Dona Eugena Hamine Otherwise Loku Nona and Others v The King (Ceylon) [1908] UKPC 64 18 Nov 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chokhey Singh and Another v Jote Singh (Oudh) [1908] UKPC 65 7 Dec 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sham Shivendar Sahi Alias Lal Saheb v Maharani Janki Koer [1908] UKPC 66 15 Dec 1908 PC Commonwealth (Fort William (Bengal)) [ Bailii ]  Arthur Gilbert Hordern and Another v Samuel Horden [1908] UKPC 67 15 Dec 1908 PC Commonwealth (New South Wales) [ Bailii ]  John Brown v William Brown and Stephen Brown (New South Wales) [1908] UKPC 68 15 Dec 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kishori Lal v Chunni Lal (Allahabad) [1908] UKPC 71 15 Dec 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mahomed Kala Mea v A. V. Harperink and Others (Lower Burma) [1908] UKPC 70 15 Dec 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ram Golam Sahu and Another v Barsati Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1908] UKPC 69 15 Dec 1908 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rabot and Another v De Silva and Others (Ceylon) [1909] UKPC 2 10 Feb 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  La Rose Mining Company Limited v The Temiskaming and Northern Ontario Railway Commission and Others (Ontario) [1909] UKPC 1 - 1 10 Feb 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Dominion Coal Company Limited v The Dominion Iron and Steel Company Limited and Another (Nova Scotia) [1909] UKPC 3 11 Feb 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Grand Trunk Railway Company of Canada v W. N. Robertson (Canada) [1909] UKPC 4 17 Feb 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jacob Bruhn v The King (Singapore) [1909] UKPC 5 26 Feb 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chang Hang Kiu and Others v Lai Hing Firm (Bankrupts) (Hong Kong) [1909] UKPC 6 2 Mar 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rama Kanta Das Mahapatra and Others v Chowdhuri Shamanand Das Paharaj Bidyadhar Bhuiyan Mahapatra (Fort William (Bengal)) [1909] UKPC 7 11 Mar 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Attorney General for New South Wales v The Collector of Customs (Australia) [1909] UKPC 9 18 Mar 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nogendra Nath Mitter v Kumudini Dasi and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1909] UKPC 8 18 Mar 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  United Shoe Machinery Company of Canada v Brunet [1909] AC 330; [1909] UKPC 10 23 Mar 1909 PC Contract, Commonwealth (Quebec) The defendant Company leased machinery under a condition that it should not be used in conjunction with machinery made by any other manufacturer. Held: The condition was not in restraint of trade. 1 Citers [ Bailii ]  Stephan and Another v The Board of Executors Cape Town and Others (Cape of Good Hope) [1909] UKPC 11 31 Mar 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Chartered Bank of India Australia and China v The British India Steam Navigation Company Limited (Penang) [1909] UKPC 12 31 Mar 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  James Leslie Williams v The Curator of Intestate Estates (Substituted for Henry James Greville Deceased) (Australia) [1909] UKPC 14 31 Mar 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Louis Blue and Joseph Stephen Deschamps Trading Together Under The Name of Blue and Deschamps v The Red Mountain Railway Company (Canada) [1909] UKPC 13 31 Mar 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Herbert Wakeman (Official Receiver and Trustee In The Bankruptcy of Lai Hing Firm) v Wong Li Shi (Administatrix of The Estate and Effects of Wong Ka Chuen Deceased) (Hong Kong) [1909] UKPC 15 7 May 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Muneshar Bakhsh Singh v Shadi Lal and Others (Oudh) [1909] UKPC 21 11 May 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ram Chandra Marwari and Others v Rani Keshobati Kumari and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1909] UKPC 20 11 May 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Parshad and Others v Muhammad Ewaz Ali Khan (Oudh) [1909] UKPC 22 11 May 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Owners and Parties Interested In The Steamship Maori King v His Britannic Majesty'S Consul U General At Shanghai Sir Pelham L. Warren K.C.M.G. (China and Corea) [1909] UKPC 17 11 May 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  C. E. Victor S. Corea v Henry Joseph Peiris (Ceylon) [1909] UKPC 18 11 May 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jaganath Pershad v Hanuman Pershad Deceased (Now Represented By Sukhdei Koer) and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1909] UKPC 19 11 May 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lala Rup Narain and Another v Mussammat Gopal Devi and Others (Punjab) [1909] UKPC 16 11 May 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Parbati Kunwar v Rani Chandarpal Kunwar and Others (Oudh) [1909] UKPC 24 13 May 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Parbati Deceased (Now Represented By Musammat Bhu Devi and Another) v Chaudhri Naunihal Singh (Allahabad) [1909] UKPC 23 13 May 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  William Price v The Chicoutimi Pulp Company and The Attorney General of The Province of Quebec (Quebec) [1909] UKPC 25 29 Jun 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Durgadut Singh (Since Deceased) and Others v Maharaja Sir Rameshwar Singh Bahadur (Fort William (Bengal)) [1909] UKPC 26 29 Jun 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Munshi Karim-Ud-Din Deceased (Now Represented By Musammat Mumtaz Begam and Others) v Kunwar Gobind Krishna Narain and Another (Allahabad) [1909] UKPC 27 1 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sham Sunder Lal v Musammat Kaisar Zamani Begam (Allahabad) [1909] UKPC 28 2 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Ywet v Ma Me and Another (Lower Burma) [1909] UKPC 29 9 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shunmugaroya Mudaliar v Manikka Mudaliar (Madras) [1909] UKPC 31 20 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council v The India General Steam Navigation and Railway Company Limited (Fort William (Bengal)) [1909] UKPC 33 20 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Munshi Prag Narain v Thakur Kamakhia Singh and Others (Oudh) [1909] UKPC 32 20 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Tengachee Nachair Deceased (Now Represented By Badar Bee) v Habib Merican Noordin and Others (Penang) [1909] UKPC 30 20 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  James Thomas Isles v The Council of The City of Brisbane (Australia) [1909] UKPC 34 22 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Minister of Stamp Duties v Anne Quale Townsend (New Zealand) [1909] UKPC 36 23 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bow Mclachlin and Company Limited v The Ship Camosun and The Union Steamship Company of British Columbia Limited (Canada) [1909] UKPC 35 23 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Henry Jones and Others v James Holmes and Others (New South Wales) [1909] UKPC 37 29 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Abhiram Goswami Mahant Deceased (Now Represented By Nrittomoyi Debi) and Another v Shyama Charan Nandi and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1909] UKPC 41 30 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The James Bay Railway Company v Samuel W. Armstrong (Canada) [1909] UKPC 45 30 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Muhammad Kamil and Others v Musammat Imtiaz Fatima (Oudh) [1909] UKPC 39 30 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  George Taylor Fulford v Dorothy Fulford Hardy and Others (Ontario) [1909] UKPC 44 30 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Dominion Natural Gas Company Limited v James H. Collins and Florence Mary Perkins and Others (Ontario) [1909] UKPC 46 30 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Izzat-Un-Nisa Begam and Another v Kunwar Pertab Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1909] UKPC 42 30 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Rashid-Un-Nisa v Muhammad Ismail Khan and Others (Allahabad) [1909] UKPC 40 30 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Canadian Pacific Railway Company v Robert Henderson Bryce Deceased (Now Represented By His Executor William Henry Johnson) [1909] UKPC 38 30 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth British Columbia [ Bailii ]  Henry L. Sprague v John R. Booth (Ontario) [1909] UKPC 43 30 Jul 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Ss. Senlac Company Limited and Others v The Ss. Rosalind and Her Freight (Canada) [1909] UKPC 47 26 Oct 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Owners of The Ss Ta Ning and Her Cargo and Freight v The Owners of The Ss Da Sing and Her Cargo and Freight (China and Corea) [1909] UKPC 49 27 Oct 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The China Navigation Company Limited v The Asiatic Petroleum Company Limited [1909] UKPC 48 27 Oct 1909 PC Commonwealth (China and Corea) [ Bailii ]  The St. John Pilot Commissioners and The Attorney General for The Dominion of Canada v The Cumberland Railway and Coal Company [1909] UKPC 50 28 Oct 1909 PC Commonwealth Canada [ Bailii ]  The Richelieu and Ontario Navigation Company Owners of The Steamer Prescott v G. B. Taylor Owner of The Steamer Havana (Canada) [1909] UKPC 51 29 Oct 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maulvi Abdul Kaiyum v Kuer Partab Singh and Another (Allahabad) [1909] UKPC 52 9 Nov 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Russo-Chinese Bank v Li Yau Sam (Hong Kong) [1909] UKPC 53 2 Dec 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Nawab Ali Khan v Wahid Ali (Oudh) [1909] UKPC 55 2 Dec 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kelly v Hart (New South Wales) [1909] UKPC 54 2 Dec 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maung Tha Hnyin v Maung Mya Su and Others (Lower Burma) [1909] UKPC 56 2 Dec 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Archibald Nugent Robertson v The Balmain New Ferry Company Limited; PC 10-Dec-1909 - [1909] UKPC 58  Robertson v The Balmain New Ferry Company Ltd [1909] UKPC 1; [1910] AC 295 10 Dec 1909 PC Commonwealth, Transport, Contract, Torts - Other High Court of Australia - The Plaintiff paid a penny on entering the wharf to stay there till the boat should start and then be taken by the boat to the other side. The Defendants were admittedly always ready and willing to carry out their part of this contract. Then the Plaintiff changed his mind, and wished to go back. The rules as to the exit from the wharf by the turnstile required a penny for any person who went though. This the Plaintiff refused to pay, and he was by force prevented from going through the turnstile. He then claimed damages for assault and false imprisonment, [ Bailii ]  James Leslie Williams v Edward O'Keefe and Others (Australia) [1909] UKPC 57 10 Dec 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Lal Kunwar v Chiranji Lal (Allahabad) [1909] UKPC 60 16 Dec 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sardar Ganpat Rao Moharkar v Sardar Anand Rao Baji Sahib Moharkar (Allahabad) [1909] UKPC 62 16 Dec 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Peary Mohan Mukerji v Narendra Nath Mukerji and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1909] UKPC 61 16 Dec 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Alexander Gill v T T B Westlake (Isle of Man) [1909] UKPC 59 16 Dec 1909 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Rex v Earl of Crewe, Ex parte Sekgome; CA 1910 - [1910] 2 KB 576   Clark v Norton; 1910 - [1910] VLR 494   Clarke v Norton; 1910 - [1910] VLR 494  Udai Raj Singh and Others v Raja Bhagwan Bakhsh Singh and Others [1910] UKPC 1 15 Feb 1910 PC Commonwealth Oudh [ Bailii ]  Imdad Ahmad and Others v Raja Pateshri Pratrap Narain Singh and Another (Allahabad) [1910] UKPC 2 15 Feb 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chandra Singh (Reasons) v Chief Court of Punjab (Chief Court of Punjab) [1910] UKPC 3 22 Feb 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Munshi Munnu Lal and Another v Glum Abbas and Others (Oudh) [1910] UKPC 4 8 Mar 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kasim Ahmed Jewa v Narainan Chetty and Others (Burma) [1910] UKPC 8 9 Mar 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lala Rup Chand (Since Deceased, Now Represented By Hulas Rai and Another) v Jambu Parshad (Allahabad) [1910] UKPC 7 9 Mar 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Official Assignee Bombay v The Registrar Small Cause Court Amritsar and Another (Chief Court of Punjab) [1910] UKPC 5 9 Mar 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kanhaya Lal v The National Bank of India Limited Delhi (Chief Court of Punjab) [1910] UKPC 6 9 Mar 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Alfred Ernest Barton v John Thompson Lempriere and Another (New South Wales) [1910] UKPC 15 18 Mar 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Corporation of The City of Toronto v The Toronto Railway Company (Ontario) [1910] UKPC 12 18 Mar 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Florence Mining Company Limited v The Cobalt Lake Mining Company Limited (Ontario) [1910] UKPC 11 18 Mar 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Hamilton Gas Company v The Mayor Councillors and Burgesses of The Borough of Hamilton (New Zealand) [1910] UKPC 10 18 Mar 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Reginald Palmer Greville and Another v Crespin Parker (New Zealand) [1910] UKPC 14 18 Mar 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sally Wertheim v The Chicoutimi Pulp Company (Quebec) [1910] UKPC 9 18 Mar 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sally Wertheim v The Chicoutimi Pulp Company [1911] AC 301; [1910] UKPC 1 18 Mar 1910 PC Lord Macnaghten, Lord Atkinson, Lord Collins, Lord Shaw Damages, Commonwealth The buyer sought damages for late delivery of goods calculated on the difference between the market price at the place of delivery when the goods should have been delivered and the market price there when the goods were in fact delivered. If successful, he would have recovered rather more than if the contract had not been broken. Held: The governing purpose of damages is to put the party whose rights have been violated in the same position, so far as money can do so, as if his rights had been observed. An award of damages for breach of contract should not put the claimant in a better position than he would have been in had the contract been performed. 1 Citers [ Bailii ]  Clara B Jones and Another v The North Vancouver Land and Improvement Company Limited Liability (British Columbia) [1910] UKPC 13 18 Mar 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lala Brij Narain v Kunwar Tejbal Bikram Bahadur (Allahabad) [1910] UKPC 16 19 Apr 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Raja Partasarathi Appa Row Savai Aswa Row Bahadur Zemindar Garu v Chevendra Venkata Narasayya and Others (Madras) [1910] UKPC 17 27 Apr 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ghazanfar Ali Khan v Musammat Kaniz Fatima and Another (Oudh) [1910] UKPC 18 29 Apr 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thomas George Molloy v Frederic Wilhelm Gustav Liebe (Western Australia) [1910] UKPC 22 7 May 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kumar Hari Narayan Singh Deo Bahadur v Sriram Chakravarti and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1910] UKPC 20 7 May 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Anant Singh v Thakur Durga Singh (Oudh) [1910] UKPC 21 7 May 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakurain Sheora Kunwar v Thakur Harrihar Bakhsh Singh and Another (Oudh) [1910] UKPC 19 7 May 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The English and American Shipping Company Limited Owners of The Ship Mystic and Her Master and Crew v The Ship Nanna Her Cargo and Freight (Canada) [1910] UKPC 23 7 Jun 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jame Leslie Williams v John Macharg (Australia) [1910] UKPC 29 7 Jun 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mahant Damodar Das v Adhikari Lakhan Das (Fort William (Bengal)) [1910] UKPC 24 7 Jun 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaj Kedar Nath and Others v Thakur Ratan Singh (Oudh) [1910] UKPC 27 7 Jun 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nawab Khwaja Muhammad Khan v Nawab Husaini Begam Alais Dilbari Begam (Allahabad) [1910] UKPC 25 7 Jun 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Arthur Gilbert Hordern and Another v Samuel Hordern and Another (New South Wales) [1910] UKPC 28 7 Jun 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Federal Supply and Cold Storage Company of South Africa Limited v Adolf Angehrn, Albert Piel (Transvaal) [1910] UKPC 32 15 Jul 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Alfred Nelson Laughton v The Commissioners of Port Erin (Isle of Man) [1910] UKPC 34 15 Jul 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Debi Bakhsh Singh v Chandrabhan Singh (Oudh) [1910] UKPC 33 15 Jul 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  J C Thompson v The Equity Fire Insurance Company and The Union Bank of Canada (Canada) [1910] UKPC 36 15 Jul 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lala Bhagwat Sahai Since Deceased, and Others v Bepin Behari Mitter Since Deceased, and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1910] UKPC 30 15 Jul 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Natal Bank Limited v Hendrick Theodore Rood and Others (Transvaal) [1910] UKPC 35 15 Jul 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Reid Newfoundland Company v The Anglo American Telegraph Company (Newfoundland) [1910] UKPC 31 15 Jul 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bohra Thakur Das and Others Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Musammat Jarao Kunwar and Another v The Collector of Aligarh and Others (Allahabad) [1910] UKPC 37 22 Jul 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Montreal Light Heat and Power Compa v H B> Sedgwick and Others (Canada) [1910] UKPC 38 25 Jul 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Judicial Committee of The Privy Council v Report On Oaths Following The Kings Death (Jcpc) [1910] UKPC 39 25 Jul 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   James Francis White and Another v The Victoria Lumber and Manufacturing Company Limited; PC 29-Jul-1910 - [1910] UKPC 42   William J and Helen White v Samuel Simpson Sharpe; PC 29-Jul-1910 - [1910] UKPC 46  The Western Electric Company v Francis Xavier Plaunt [1910] UKPC 45 29 Jul 1910 PC Commonwealth (Ontario) [ Bailii ]   Burchell v The Gowrie and Blockhouse Collieries Limited; PC 29-Jul-1910 - [1910] UKPC 43  The Dominion of Canada v The Province of Ontario (Canada) [1910] UKPC 40 29 Jul 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Charles R Gordon v Thomas Horne and Others (Canada) [1910] UKPC 41 29 Jul 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Province of Quebec v The Attorney General for The Province of Ontario (Canada) [1910] UKPC 44 29 Jul 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Standard Ideal Company v The Standard Sanitary Manufacturing Company (Quebec) [1910] UKPC 47 1 Nov 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  W J Mcfarland v The Bank of Montreal and The Royal Trust Company (Ontario) [1910] UKPC 49 1 Nov 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Burrard Power Company Limited and Another v The King (Canada) [1910] UKPC 48 1 Nov 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Roy Jatindra Nath Chowdhri and Another v Prasanna Kumar Banerji and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1910] UKPC 50 15 Nov 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Bachi and Others v Birkchand Jiomal and Another (Sind) [1910] UKPC 51 17 Nov 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kumar Chandra Kishore Roy v 1, Prasanna Kumari Dasi 2, Sarat Kumari Dasi (Fort William (Bengal)) [1910] UKPC 54 2 Dec 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Muhammad Bakar and Another v Nawab Mirza Muhammad Bakar Ali Khan and Another (Oudh) [1910] UKPC 52 2 Dec 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Bank of Montreal v Jane Jacques Stuart and Another (Canada) [1910] UKPC 53 2 Dec 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Charles Spencer v The Registrar of Titles [1910] UKPC 56 2 Dec 1910 PC Commonwealth Western Australia [ Bailii ]  Bur Singh and Others v Uttam Singh and Others (Chief Court of Punjab) [1910] UKPC 55 2 Dec 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  John Munro and Others v Charles Didcot and Another (Natal) [1910] UKPC 59 14 Dec 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Erie County Natural Gas and Fuel Company Limited and Others v Samuel S Carroll and Another (Ontario) [1910] UKPC 57 14 Dec 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaj Manindra Chandra Nandi v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Fort William (Bengal)) [1910] UKPC 58 14 Dec 1910 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Grand Trunk Railway Co of Canada v Barnett; PC 1911 - [1911] AC 361 PC  Attorney General for Canada v Fedorenko [1911] AC 735 1911 PC Commonwealth 1 Citers  Kishen Parshad and Others v Har Narain Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1911] UKPC 3 1 Feb 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Damodar Narayan Chowdhri v Dalgliesh and Others; PC 1-Feb-1911 - [1911] UKPC 1  Harji Ashfaq Husain and Others v Lala Gauri Sahai (Allahabad) [1911] UKPC 2 1 Feb 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  John Matthew Vincent Smith and Others v Charles Matthew Germain Cock and Others (Australia) [1911] UKPC 4 2 Feb 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  John Brown v William Brown and Another (New South Wales) [1911] UKPC 8 3 Feb 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The King v The Canadian Pacific Railway Company [1911] UKPC 6 3 Feb 1911 PC Commonwealth Alberta [ Bailii ]  The Minister of Public Works of The Province of Alberta v The Canadian Pacific Railway Company [1911] UKPC 5 3 Feb 1911 PC Commonwealth Alberta [ Bailii ]  The National Phonograph Company of Australia v Walter T. Menck (Australia) [1911] UKPC 7 3 Feb 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bhagabati Barmanya (Since Deceased) and Another v Kali Charan Singh and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1911] UKPC 9 14 Feb 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Hanif-Un-Nisa and Another v Chaudhrain Musammat Faiz-Un-Nisa (Since Deceased Now Represented By Abdul Shakur Khan and Another) and Another (Allahabad) [1911] UKPC 10 14 Feb 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Bhawani Kunwar v Kunwar Himmat Bahadur and Another (Allahabad) [1911] UKPC 12 15 Feb 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lingham Kristna Bhupati Devu Garu v Sri Miza Sri Pusapati Vijayarama Gajapatiraj Maharaja Manya Sultan Bahadur of Vizianagaram (Madras) [1911] UKPC 11 15 Feb 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Sri Ishwar Shyam Chand Jiu and Another v Ram Kani Ghose and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1911] UKPC 13 28 Feb 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Umrao Singh and Another v Thakur Lachman Singh and Another (Oudh) [1911] UKPC 15 28 Feb 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sheikh Mahomed Jan v Munshi Ganga Bishun Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1911] UKPC 14 28 Feb 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Srimati Nityamoni Dasi and Others v Madhu Sudan Sen and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1911] UKPC 17 10 Mar 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bishun Chand Bachhaot v Bijoy Singh Dudhuria (Fort William (Bengal)) [1911] UKPC 16 10 Mar 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Samuel Jacobus Greyvensteyn v Daniel Wilhelmus Hattingh and Others (Cape of Good Hope) [1911] UKPC 19 28 Mar 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Khunni Lal and Others v Kunwar Gobind Krishna Narain and Another (Allahabad) [1911] UKPC 21 28 Mar 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Grand Trunk Railway Company of Canada v Walter C. Barnett (Ontario) [1911] UKPC 20 28 Mar 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The American Asbestos Company v The Johnsons Company (Quebec) [1911] UKPC 18 28 Mar 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   The Municipal Council of Sydney v Frederica Sarah Fleay and Others; PC 4-Apr-1911 - [1911] UKPC 22  James Leslie Williams v Haines Thomas Giddy (New South Wales) [1911] UKPC 23 4 Apr 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commissioner of Stamp Duties v Charles Julian Byrnes and Others (New South Wales) [1911] UKPC 24 4 Apr 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Durga Kunwar v Musammat Mathura Kunwar and Others (Allahabad) [1911] UKPC 25 4 May 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Cornelis Gideon De Jager and Others v James Alexander Foster and Others [1911] UKPC 27 4 May 1911 PC Commonwealth Cape of Good Hope [ Bailii ]  Purna Sashi Bhattacharji and Others v Kalidhan Rai Chowdhuri and Others [1911] UKPC 26 4 May 1911 PC Commonwealth (Fort William (Bengal)) [ Bailii ]  Srinivasa Moorthy v Venkatavarada Iyengar and Others (Madras) [1911] UKPC 28 9 May 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maung Pe v Ma Lon Ma Gale (Lower Burma) [1911] UKPC 29 9 May 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Canadian Pacific Railway Company v The Corporation of The City of Toronto and The Grand Trunk Railway Company of Canada [1911] UKPC 30 10 May 1911 PC Commonwealth Ontario [ Bailii ]  The British Guiana Bank v The Official Receiver (As Liquidator of The The British Guiana Ice Company Limited) (British Guiana) [1911] UKPC 31 12 May 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commissioner for Stamp Duties v The Broken Hill South Extended Limited (New South Wales) [1911] UKPC 32 15 May 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raman Chetty v Steel Brothers and Co, Limited (Lower Burma) [1911] UKPC 34 18 May 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Robert Gilmour Leckie and Others v William Marshall and Others [1911] UKPC 33 18 May 1911 PC Commonwealth (Ontario) [ Bailii ]  Mouji Lal Since Deceased (Now Represented By Tarini Prasad) and Others v Musammat Chandrabati Kumari and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1911] UKPC 35 18 May 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Golden Horseshoe Estates Company Limited v The Crown (Western Australia) [1911] UKPC 36 19 May 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Dominion of Canada v The Standard Trust Company of New York (Canada) [1911] UKPC 37 23 May 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Madappa Hegde Bin Ganap Hegde and Others v Ramkrishna Narayan Bhat and Others (Bombay) [1911] UKPC 40 13 Jun 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ko Tha Hnyin v Ma Hnin I. (Lower Burma) [1911] UKPC 41 13 Jun 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Martha Suzanna Wyatt and Others v The Attorney General of The Province of Quebec (Canada) [1911] UKPC 39 13 Jun 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  G. W. Davis v Maung Shwe Go (Lower Burma) [1911] UKPC 43 14 Jun 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Li Yue Bank v The China Import and Export Lumber Company Limited (Shanghai) [1911] UKPC 42 14 Jun 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Madho Prasad v Mahant Ramrattan Gir and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1911] UKPC 44 16 Jun 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kaikhursu Aderji Ghaswala and Others v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Bombay) [1911] UKPC 45 27 Jun 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Louise A. Lapointe and Others v Henri Lairn (Canada) [1911] UKPC 46 28 Jun 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaja Jagadindra Nath Roy Bahadur v Rani Hemanta Kumari Debi and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1911] UKPC 47 28 Jun 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Perth Gas Company Limited v The Mayor and Councillors of The City of Perth (Western Australia) [1911] UKPC 48 30 Jun 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maung Kyin and Another v Ma Shwe La and Others (Lower Burma) [1911] UKPC 49 11 Jul 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Bombay Uburmah Trading Corporation Limited v Aga Mahomed Khaleel Shirazee (Madras) [1911] UKPC 51 11 Jul 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sukhraj Roy v Morrison and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1911] UKPC 50 11 Jul 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaja Rameshwar Singh Bahadur v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Fort William (Bengal)) [1911] UKPC 52 12 Jul 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Dominion of Canada v Fedorenko (Manitoba) [1911] UKPC 54 13 Jul 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Dominion of Canada v Fedorenko (Manitoba) [1911] UKPC 53 13 Jul 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mirza Sadik Husain v Musammat Kaniz Zohra Begam (Oudh) [1911] UKPC 55 21 Jul 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Samaradiwakara and Another v De Saram and Others (Ceylon) [1911] UKPC 56 21 Jul 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The City of Vancouver v The Vancouver Lumber Company and Another (British Columbia) [1911] UKPC 57 25 Jul 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Haddington Island Quarry Company Limited v Alden Wesley Huson and Others (British Columbia) [1911] UKPC 60 27 Jul 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Idroos Lebbe Maricar Abdul Azeez v Mohamed Ismail Abdul Rahiman Mudliyar (Ceylon) [1911] UKPC 59 27 Jul 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Agnes Allardice and Another v Elizabeth Allardice and Others (New Zealand) [1911] UKPC 61 27 Jul 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Rang Lal Singh and Another v Maharaja Sir Ravaneshwar Pershad Singh Bahadur and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1911] UKPC 58 27 Jul 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Miza Mohamet Tackey v R. S. F. Mcbain [1911] UKPC 63 31 Jul 1911 PC Commonwealth (Shanghai) [ Bailii ]  Jit Singh Since Deceased (Now Represented By Raghuraj Singh and Others) and Another v Maharaj Singh (Allahabad) [1911] UKPC 64 1 Nov 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Grand Trunk Railway Company of Canada v The Landowners Fronting On Empire Avenue and Mckellar or Hardisty Street Fort William and Others [1911] UKPC 66 2 Nov 1911 PC Commonwealth (Canada) [ Bailii ]  Jamna Das v Pandit Ram Autar Pande and Others (Allahabad) [1911] UKPC 69 2 Nov 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lady De Soysa and Others v Stanislaus De Pless Pol and Another (Ceylon) [1911] UKPC 68 2 Nov 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Grand Trunk Railway Company of Canada v The King (Canada) [1911] UKPC 65 2 Nov 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The King v Irvine A. Lovitt and Others (Canada) [1911] UKPC 67 2 Nov 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mir Sarwarjan v Fakhruddin Mahomed Chowdhuri and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1911] UKPC 70 9 Nov 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Durga Prasad Lahiri Chowdhuri and Another v Srimati Sashibala Debi and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1911] UKPC 71 21 Nov 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakurain Lekhraj Kunwar v Thakur Harpal Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1911] UKPC 72 22 Nov 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Yap Hon Chin v G. L. Jones (Malay) [1911] UKPC 73 23 Nov 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Muhammad Umar Khan Since Deceased (Now Represented By Muhammad Fakhar Din Khan) and Another v Muhammad Niaz-Ud-Din Khan [1911] UKPC 74 14 Dec 1911 PC Commonwealth (Chief Court of The Punjab) [ Bailii ]  Charles Edward Victor Seneviratne Corea v Mahatantrigey Iseris Appuhamy and Another (Ceylon) [1911] UKPC 75 14 Dec 1911 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Webster v Bosanquet; PC 1912 - [1912] AC 394   E D Sassoon and Co v Western Assurance Co; PC 1912 - [1912] AC 561   Thomas A Edison Ltd v Bock; 1912 - (1912) 15 CLR 679  The City of Montreal v The Montreal Street Railway Company (Canada) [1912] UKPC 5 16 Jan 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Syed Mahomed Ibrahim Hossein Khan and Another v Ambika Pershad Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal) [1912] UKPC 1 16 Jan 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mata Din v Sheikh Ahmad Ali (Oudh) [1912] UKPC 3 16 Jan 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Imperial Bank of China v Leung Shui Kong (Hong Kong) [1912] UKPC 4 16 Jan 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bir Birram Deo v The Secretary of State for India In Council (India) [1912] UKPC 2 16 Jan 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kunwar Ragho Prasad and Others v Lala Mewa Lal and Another (Allahabad) [1912] UKPC 7 23 Jan 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Khoo Sit Hon and Others v Lim Thean Tong (Penang) [1912] UKPC 8 23 Jan 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jeolal Mahton and Another v Loke Narayan Mahton and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1912] UKPC 6 23 Jan 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mi Me and Others v Mi Shwe Ma (Upper Burma) [1912] UKPC 9 25 Jan 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Moses Amado Taylor v &Nbsp; (Sierra Leone) [1912] UKPC 10 26 Jan 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nawab Ibrahim Ali Khan v Nawab Muhammad Ahsan Ullah Khan and Another (Punjab) [1912] UKPC 11 30 Jan 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Debi Mangal Prasad Singh v Mahadeo Prasad Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1912] UKPC 12 2 Feb 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Parbati v Saiyid Muhammad Muzaffar Ali Khan and Others (Allahabad) [1912] UKPC 22 21 Feb 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The South American Breweries Limited v The Mayor and Councillors of The Borough of Durban (Natal) [1912] UKPC 19 21 Feb 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  James Perera Senevirante Gunatilleke v Daniel John Fernando [1912] UKPC 17 21 Feb 1912 PC Commonwealth Ceylon [ Bailii ]  Vasudeva Mudaliar and Others v Sadagopa Mudaliar (Allahabad) [1912] UKPC 21 21 Feb 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rowland Valentine Webster v William David Bosanquet (Ceylon) [1912] UKPC 18 21 Feb 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Sri Sri Durga Prasad Singh v Braja Nath Bose and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1912] UKPC 20 21 Feb 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   The Commissioner of Taxation of New South Wales v Adams; PC 21-Feb-1912 - [1912] UKPC 16  The City of Winnipeg v The Winnipeg Electric Railway Company (Manitoba) [1912] UKPC 15 21 Feb 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The National Trust Company v Louis E Whicher [1912] UKPC 13 21 Feb 1912 PC Commonwealth Ontario [ Bailii ]  The Winnipeg Electric Railway Company v The City of Winnipeg (Manitoba) [1912] UKPC 14 21 Feb 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Most Reverend Robert Dunne and Another v James Byrne (Australia) [1912] UKPC 23 22 Feb 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Frederick August Neubauer and Another v Gordon Grant and Co (Trinidad and Tobago) [1912] UKPC 24 28 Feb 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Balwant Singh Since Deceased (Now Represented By The Collector of Etah) v 1 The Reverend Rockwell Clancy 2 Rao Maharaj Singh (Allahabad) [1912] UKPC 26 28 Feb 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Lemm v Mitchell; PC 28-Feb-1912 - [1912] UKPC 25  Jadu Lal Sahu and Others v Maharani Janki Koer and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1912] UKPC 27 20 Mar 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Moreton Frewen v Charles M Hays and Others (British Columbia) [1912] UKPC 28 20 Mar 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rani Dharam Kunwar v Balwant Singh [1912] UKPC 30 23 Apr 1912 PC Commonwealth Allahabad [ Bailii ]  The Reid-Newfoundland Company v The Anglo-American Telegraph Company Limited [1912] UKPC 29 23 Apr 1912 PC Commonwealth Newfoundland [ Bailii ]  Sevak Kirpashankar Daji and Others v Gopal Rao Manohar Tambekar and Others (Bombay) [1912] UKPC 31 2 May 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Brij Lal Since Deceased (Now Represented By Ram Bharose) and Others v Suraj Bikram Singh [1912] UKPC 32 2 May 1912 PC Commonwealth Oudh [ Bailii ]  Champat Singh and Others v Jangu Singh Since Deceased (Now Represented By Hanwant Singh) and Another (Oudh) [1912] UKPC 33 3 May 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Vissanji Sons and Company v Sharpurji Burjorji Bharoocha (Bombay) [1912] UKPC 34 3 May 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Province of Ontario and Others v The Attorney General for The Dominion of Canada and Another [1912] UKPC 35 16 May 1912 PC Commonwealth Canada [ Bailii ]  Fairclough v The Swan Brewery Company Limited [1912] UKPC 37 17 May 1912 PC Commonwealth Western Australia [ Bailii ]  E D Sassoon and Company v The Western Assurance Company [1912] UKPC 36 17 May 1912 PC Commonwealth China [ Bailii ]  The Dominion Cotton Mills Company Limited and Others v George E Amyot and Others (Respondents) and Alfred Brunet (Intervenant) [1912] UKPC 39 17 May 1912 PC Commonwealth Quebec [ Bailii ]  Fairclough v The Swan Brewery Company Ltd [1912] UKPC 1; [1912] AC 565 17 May 1912 PC Commonwealth, Equity 1 Cites [ Bailii ]  Massey v The New Zealand Times Company Limited [1912] UKPC 38 17 May 1912 PC Commonwealth New Zealand [ Bailii ]  Haji Buksh Elahi v Durlav Chandra Kar (Fort William (Bengal)) [1912] UKPC 42 13 Jun 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ganga Bahu Debi Since Deceased (Now Represented By Shama Bibi and Another) v Apurba Krishna Roy and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1912] UKPC 40 13 Jun 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mizra Sajjad Husain and Another v Nawab Wazir Ali Khan and Others (Oudh) [1912] UKPC 41 13 Jun 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Richard J Kirby v John J Cowderoy [1912] UKPC 46 18 Jun 1912 PC Commonwealth British Columbia [ Bailii ]  Kruz v The Crow's Nest Pass Coal Company Limited [1912] UKPC 45 18 Jun 1912 PC Commonwealth British Columbia [ Bailii ]  Loftus Otway Clarke v Brojendra Kishore Roy Chowdhury And, Srimati Bisweswari Debi Chowdhurani (Fort William (Bengal)) [1912] UKPC 44 18 Jun 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Edward F Swift and Others v Lester W David (British Columbia) [1912] UKPC 47 18 Jun 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chaudhri Mohammad Mehdi Hasan Khan v Sri Mandir Das (Fort William (Bengal)) [1912] UKPC 43 18 Jun 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of G Krishnasami Aiyar v &Nbsp; (Madras) [1912] UKPC 48 20 Jun 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ferrier v Stewart [1912] 15 CLR 32; [1912] HCA 47 24 Jun 1912 Isaacs J Commonwealth, Estoppel, Contract High Court of Australia - The plaintiffs were the surviving members of a firm, owed money by the defendant's husband confirmed promissory notes. The firm extend his credit against new promissory notes, provided that they were indorsed by the defendant also so as to make her liable on the notes. This she agreed to do. In order to effect a contract between herself and the firm, the notes had formally to be indorsed by the firm to her before she put her indorsement on them. In fact, the notes were given to her, for her indorsement, before the firm's indorsement appeared on them and she placed her indorsement on them as if they had already been indorsed to her. The notes were thereafter indorsed by the firm, so that on their face they appeared to have been indorsed in the correct chronological sequence, contrary to the facts as both parties knew them to be. The defendant subsequently refused to pay the bills on the ground that they had not been indorsed to her at the time of her signature. Held: This defence failed. The parties had adopted a conventional basis for the transaction. They impliedly agreed that, when the promissory note should be completed by other indorsements, it should be assumed to have been issued and indorsed by the parties in due order. From this assumption the indorsee was not permitted to depart, although all parties had been aware of the actual state of affairs. 1 Citers [ Austlii ]  Moosa Goolam Ariff and Others v Ebrahim Goolam Ariff and Another (Lower Burma) [1912] UKPC 49 26 Jun 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  White v Williams [1912] UKPC 50 3 Jul 1912 PC Commonwealth New South Wales [ Bailii ]  The Commercial Cable Company v The Attorney General of Newfoundland [1912] UKPC 51 10 Jul 1912 PC Commonwealth Newfoundland [ Bailii ]  Lala Faeh Chand Since Deceased (Now Represented By Lala Jugal Kishore and Another) and Others v Rani Kishen Kunwar (Allahabad) [1912] UKPC 52 12 Jul 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Rangoon Botatoung Company Limited v The Collector Rangoon [1912] UKPC 54 16 Jul 1912 PC Commonwealth Lower Burma [ Bailii ]  Banarsi Das v Bansi Lal [1912] UKPC 53 16 Jul 1912 PC Commonwealth Punjab [ Bailii ]  Shrimant Raje Bahadur Raghojirao Saheb v Shrimant Raje Lakshmanrao Saheb [1912] UKPC 55 18 Jul 1912 PC Commonwealth Bombay [ Bailii ]  Shankar Din and Others v Munshi Gokul Prasad and Others [1912] UKPC 56 18 Jul 1912 PC Commonwealth Oudh [ Bailii ]  Angus Corinthe and Others v The Ecclesiastics of The Seminary of St Sulpice of Montreal [1912] UKPC 57 19 Jul 1912 PC Commonwealth Quebec [ Bailii ]  Musammat Bhawani Kumar v Mathura Prasad Singh (Fort William (Bengal)) [1912] UKPC 58 22 Jul 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Samson v Aitchison [1912] UKPC 59 22 Jul 1912 PC Commonwealth New Zealand [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Province of Ontario and Others v The Canadian Nigara Power Company [1912] UKPC 60 22 Jul 1912 PC Commonwealth Ontario [ Bailii ]  The Toronto and Niagara Power Company v The Corporation of The Town of North Toronto (Ontario) [1912] UKPC 61 24 Jul 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The King v The Alberta Railway and Irrigation Company (Canada) [1912] UKPC 62 25 Jul 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of A Reference To The Supreme Court of Canada Pursuant To Section 60 of The Supreme Court Act of Certain Questions Concerning Marriage for Hearing and Consideration v Canada [1912] UKPC 63 29 Jul 1912 PC Commonwealth Canada [ Bailii ]  Charles W Stapleton v The American Asbestos Company Limited (Quebec) [1912] UKPC 64 30 Jul 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shamu Patter v 1 Abdul Kadir Ravuthan and Others 2 Abdul Rajak Sahib and Others [1912] UKPC 66 30 Jul 1912 PC Commonwealth Madras [ Bailii ]  Charles Langelier v Philippe Angers [1912] UKPC 68 31 Jul 1912 PC Commonwealth Quebec [ Bailii ]  The Barnard-Ague-Roth-Stearns Oil and Gas Company Limited and Others v Alexander Farquharson [1912] UKPC 67 31 Jul 1912 PC Commonwealth Ontario [ Bailii ]  Scahindra Nath Roy and Others v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Fort William (Bengal)) [1912] UKPC 69 29 Oct 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  William H Parsons and Others v The Sovereign Bank of China (Ontario) [1912] UKPC 70 30 Oct 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Town of Outrement v Alfred Joyce (Quebec) [1912] UKPC 72 30 Oct 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Minnie Ann Mckenzie and Others v The Corporation of The Township or District of Challiwack (British Columbia) [1912] UKPC 71 30 Oct 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mahant Kristna Dayal Gir v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Oudh) [1912] UKPC 74 31 Oct 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sayedani Mahmuda Khataun Chowdhurrani v Mahomed Elahadad Khanpani Since Deceased (Fort William (Bengal)) [1912] UKPC 75 31 Oct 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   The Bank of Bombay v Nandlal Thackerseydas; PC 31-Oct-1912 - [1912] UKPC 73  Tripurari Pal and Another v Jagat Tarinin Dasi and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1912] UKPC 76 31 Oct 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  P v Subramania Pillai v P v Murugesa Pillai and Others (Madras) [1912] UKPC 77 7 Nov 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Narain and Another v Lala Raghubans Rai Since Deceased (Allahabad) [1912] UKPC 79 8 Nov 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Muhammad Ismail Khan and Others v 1 Lala Sheomukh Rai Since Deceased 2 Musammat Imtiaz-Un-Nisa (Allahabad) [1912] UKPC 78 8 Nov 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   George A Pearson v Thomas R O'Brien and Another; PC 12-Nov-1912 - [1912] UKPC 81  Babui Bacha Kumar v Babui Surajkala Kumar [1912] UKPC 80 12 Nov 1912 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Sardar Kirpal Singh v Sadar Balwant Singh and Another (Punjab) [1912] UKPC 82 13 Nov 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Noel Charles Minchin Home v John Charles Edward Douglas (China) [1912] UKPC 83 14 Nov 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Akwesi Dobbin and Others v Bibiani Limited (Substituted for The Bibianigoldfields Limited) (Gold Coast Colony) [1912] UKPC 84 14 Nov 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Allan Mcpherson and Another v The Temiskaming Lumber Company Limited [1912] UKPC 86 19 Nov 1912 PC Commonwealth Ontario [ Bailii ]  Charles Munasinha v The Assistant Government Agent of Puttalam [1912] UKPC 85 19 Nov 1912 PC Commonwealth Ceylon [ Bailii ]  Mulraj Khatau v Vishwanath Prabhuram Vaidya [1912] UKPC 87 21 Nov 1912 PC Commonwealth Bombay [ Bailii ]  Munshi Indra Sahai v Kunwar Shiam Bahadur and Others (Allahabad) [1912] UKPC 91 26 Nov 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kunwar Raghubir Singh and Another v Musammat Moti Kunwar [1912] UKPC 90 26 Nov 1912 PC Commonwealth (Allahabad) [ Bailii ]  The Court of Wards for The Property of Makhdum Hassan Bakhsh v Ilahi Bakhsh and Others (Punjab) [1912] UKPC 88 26 Nov 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Azima Bibi Since Deceased (Now Represented By Dewan Amir Hossein Khan and Another and Others v Munshi Shamalanand; PC 26-Nov-1912 - [1912] UKPC 92  Ahmedbhoy Habibbhoy v The Bombay Fire and Marine Insurance Company Limited (Bombay) [1912] UKPC 89 26 Nov 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Saiyid Abdullah Khan v Saiyid Basharat Husain Since Deceased (Allahabad) [1912] UKPC 95 29 Nov 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Meringhege Arnolis Fernando and Another v Anthony Nicholas De Silva (Penang) [1912] UKPC 93 29 Nov 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  A Strauss and Company and Others v Chin Ho and Sons and Others (Penang) [1912] UKPC 94 29 Nov 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mathura Prasad and Others v Sheikh Muhammad (Allahabad) [1912] UKPC 96 5 Dec 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lallu Sahi v Mahant Rajbans Bharthi and Another (Allahabad) [1912] UKPC 98 5 Dec 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Compagnie De Navigation Mixte (Compagnie Touache) v The Ship Silverton and Freight (Gibraltar) [1912] UKPC 99 5 Dec 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dharani Kanta Lahiri Chowdhuri and Another v Gabar Ali Khan Since Deceased and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1912] UKPC 97 5 Dec 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  James Leslie Williams v Cornelius Delohery (New South Wales) [1912] UKPC 101 10 Dec 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pandit Suraj Narain and Another v Pandit Ikbal Narain and Others (Oudh) [1912] UKPC 102 10 Dec 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council v J Moment [1912] UKPC 100 10 Dec 1912 PC Commonwealth Lower Burma [ Bailii ]  Srimat Prathivadi Bhayankaram Govinda Charyulu and Another v Sri Rajah Rangayya Appa Rao Bahadur Since Deceased and Others (Madras) [1912] UKPC 103 13 Dec 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  J Kerr Wilson v The Corporation of Delta (British Columbia) [1912] UKPC 104 13 Dec 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Michael Kelly and Another v C H Enderton and Others [1912] UKPC 106 16 Dec 1912 PC Commonwealth Manitoba [ Bailii ]  Michael Kelly and Another v Thomas Kelly (Manitoba) [1912] UKPC 105 16 Dec 1912 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Attorney General of the Commonwealth of Australia v Adelaide Steamship Company; PC 1913 - [1913] AC 781   Hedderwick v The Federal Commissioner of Land Tax; 1913 - (1913) 16 CLR 27   The Royal Bank of Canada and Others v The King and Another; PC 31-Jan-1913 - [1913] UKPC 1   Harry Rickards Since Deceased, (Now Represented By John Charles Leete and Others) v John Inglis Lothian; PC 11-Feb-1913 - [1913] UKPC 2   Baijnath Ram Goenka v Nand Kumar Singh and Others; PC 11-Feb-1913 - [1913] UKPC 3   Kidar Nath v Mathu Mal; PC 14-Feb-1913 - [1913] UKPC 4  Ohia and Others v Yao Ntikora [1913] UKPC 6 17 Feb 1913 PC Commonwealth Gold Coast Colony [ Bailii ]  Felix A Mchugh and Thomas P Mchugh Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Felix Alexander Joseph Mchugh and Others) v The Union Bank of Canada (Canada) [1913] UKPC 5 17 Feb 1913 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gordon v Holland [1913] UKPC 7 19 Feb 1913 PC Commonwealth (British Columbia) [ Bailii ]  Kanhaya Lal v The National Bank of India Limited (Punjab) [1913] UKPC 9 25 Feb 1913 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Majmudar Hiralal Ichhalal and Others v Desai Narsilal Chaturhujdas and Others (Bombay) [1913] UKPC 8 25 Feb 1913 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Skinner v Kunwar Naunihal Singh and Another [1913] UKPC 11 4 Mar 1913 PC Commonwealth Allahabad [ Bailii ]  Lala Soni Ram v Kanhaiya Lal and Others [1913] UKPC 12 6 Mar 1913 PC Commonwealth Allahabad [ Bailii ]  Teakait Krishna Prasad Singh v Moti Chand [1913] UKPC 13 6 Mar 1913 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  The National Protector Fire Insurance Company Limited v Charles Nivert [1913] UKPC 15 14 Mar 1913 PC Commonwealth Ottoman Porte [ Bailii ]  Thakur Basant Singh v Mahabir Pershad [1913] UKPC 14 14 Mar 1913 PC Commonwealth Oudh [ Bailii ]  Mohan Lalji and Another v Tikait Sri Gordhan Lalji Maharaj and Others [1913] UKPC 16 17 Mar 1913 PC Commonwealth North-West Frontier Province [ Bailii ]  Joopoody Sarayya and Others v Pulavarti Lakshmanaswamy [1913] UKPC 18 19 Mar 1913 PC Commonwealth Madras [ Bailii ]  Loke Yew v The Port Swettenham Rubber Company Limited [1913] UKPC 17 19 Mar 1913 PC Commonwealth Malay States [ Bailii ]  Gulababsingh and Others v Raja Seth Gokuldas and Others [1913] UKPC 19 8 Apr 1913 PC Commonwealth Central Provinces India [ Bailii ]  Ganesha Row v Tuljaram Row and Another [1913] UKPC 20 8 Apr 1913 PC Commonwealth Madras [ Bailii ]  Raja Debi Bakhsh Singh v Habib Shah [1913] UKPC 22 29 Apr 1913 PC Commonwealth Oudh [ Bailii ]  Chiman Lal v Hari Chand (Punjab) [1913] UKPC 23 2 May 1913 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kunwar Brijraj Singh and Another v Kunwar Sheodan Singh and Others (North-West Frontier Province) [1913] UKPC 24 5 May 1913 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Peters v Sinclair; 6-May-1913 - 1913 CanLII 8 (SCC); 48 SCR 57  James Clough v The West India Electric Company Limited [1913] UKPC 25 2 Jun 1913 PC Commonwealth (Jamaica) [ Bailii ]  Bhaiya Janki Pershad Singh v Bhaiya Dwarka Pershad Singh [1913] UKPC 26 10 Jun 1913 PC Commonwealth (Oudh) [ Bailii ]  Joao Pedro Santos v Manoel Augusto Pereira and Others [1913] UKPC 27 19 Jun 1913 PC Commonwealth (British Guiana) [ Bailii ]  John Spencer Brunton and Others v The Acting Commissioner of Stamp Duties for The State of New South Wales [1913] AC 747; [1913] UKPC 28 20 Jun 1913 PC Commonwealth, Stamp Duty (New South Wales) [ Bailii ]  Manu Kapua and Others v Para Haimona and Another [1913] UKPC 29 1 Jul 1913 PC Commonwealth (New Zealand) [ Bailii ]  E Meyer and Company Limited v The Sze Hai Tong Banking and Insurance Company Limited [1913] UKPC 30 10 Jul 1913 PC Commonwealth (Singapore) [ Bailii ]  The Kauri Timber Company Limited v The Commissioner of Taxes [1913] UKPC 31 10 Jul 1913 PC Commonwealth (New Zealand) [ Bailii ]  Ramishore Kedarnath and Others v Ainarayan Ramrachpal and Others [1913] UKPC 32 11 Jul 1913 PC Commonwealth Central Provinces India [ Bailii ]  The Grand Trunk Company v William H Mcalpine (Quebec) [1913] UKPC 33 15 Jul 1913 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Net Ram Singh and Others v Musammat Tursa Kunwar (Allahabad) [1913] UKPC 34 18 Jul 1913 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Donald Mcmillan and Another v W F Stewart and Others [1913] UKPC 37 23 Jul 1913 PC Commonwealth (Ontario) [ Bailii ]  The British Columbia Electric Railway Company Limited v W F Stewart and Others [1913] UKPC 36 23 Jul 1913 PC Commonwealth (British Columbia) [ Bailii ]  Kunwar Partab Singh v Bhabuti Singh (Oudh) [1913] UKPC 35 23 Jul 1913 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Rajah Venkata Narasimha Appa Row Bahadur Since Deceased v Sri Rajah Parthasarathy Appa Row Savai Aswa Row Bahadur and Connected Appeals [1913] UKPC 38 24 Jul 1913 PC Commonwealth (Madras) [ Bailii ]  Vaithinatha Pillai v The King-Emperor [1913] UKPC 39 24 Jul 1913 PC Commonwealth (Madras) [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of The Commonwealth of Australia v The Adelaide Steamship Company Limited and Others [1913] UKPC 40 25 Jul 1913 PC Commonwealth (Australia) [ Bailii ]  James Playfair v The Meadford Elevator Company Limited [1913] UKPC 41 29 Jul 1913 PC Commonwealth (Ontario) [ Bailii ]  The Anglo-Newfoundland Development Company v The Newfoundland Pine and Pulp Company [1913] UKPC 42 30 Jul 1913 PC Commonwealth (Newfoundland) [ Bailii ]  James H Kennedy v David Kennedy and Others [1913] UKPC 45 1 Aug 1913 PC Commonwealth (Ontario) [ Bailii ]  Jones v The Canadian Pacific Railway Company [1913] UKPC 44 1 Aug 1913 PC Commonwealth Ontario [ Bailii ]  The Canadian Pacific Railway Company v The Steamship Kronprinz Olav [1913] UKPC 43 1 Aug 1913 PC Commonwealth Canada [ Bailii ]  Douglas C Cameron v Thomas Afred Cuddy and Another [1913] UKPC 47 7 Aug 1913 PC Commonwealth (Canada) [ Bailii ]  The Imerial Paper Mills of Canada Limited and Another v The Quebec Bank and Others [1913] UKPC 48 7 Aug 1913 PC Commonwealth (Ontario) [ Bailii ]   The Monarch Life Assurance Company v Mackenzie; PC 17-Oct-1913 - [1913] UKPC 49  The Eastern Construction Company Limited v The National Trust Company Limited and Others, Therese Schmidt and Others [1913] UKPC 50 21 Oct 1913 PC Commonwealth (Canada) [ Bailii ]  Muniandy Chetty Ramasamy Chetty v Muttu Caruppen Chetty Suppramaniam Chetty [1913] UKPC 51 27 Oct 1913 PC Commonwealth (Ceylon) [ Bailii ]  Robert Kleinert v The Abosso Gold Mining Company Limited [1913] UKPC 52 28 Oct 1913 PC Commonwealth Gold Coast Colony [ Bailii ]  Raja Durga Prasad Singh v Rajendra Narayan Bagchi Since Deceased and Others [1913] UKPC 53 3 Nov 1913 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Louis Edouard Lanier v The King [1913] UKPC 54 5 Nov 1913 PC Commonwealth Seychelles [ Bailii ]  Rajkumari Bhubaneshwari Kumar v The Collector of Gaya [1913] UKPC 55 7 Nov 1913 PC Commonwealth (Fort William (Bengal)) [ Bailii ]  Charles S Cotton and Another v The King [1913] UKPC 56 11 Nov 1913 PC Commonwealth Canada [ Bailii ]  The Toronto and York Radial Railway Company v The Corporation of The City of Toronto [1913] UKPC 57 14 Nov 1913 PC Commonwealth (Ontario) [ Bailii ]  Clifford and Others Judgment On A Petition for Special Leave v The King-Emperor [1913] UKPC 58 20 Nov 1913 PC Commonwealth (Lower Burma) [ Bailii ]  Ananda Gopal Gossain Since Deceased, (Now Represented By v Nafar Chandra Pal Chowdhuri and Another [1913] UKPC 59 20 Nov 1913 PC Commonwealth (Fort William (Bengal)) [ Bailii ]  Raja Thakur Barmha Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Jai Barmha and Others) and Others v Jiban Ram Marwari and Others [1913] UKPC 60 25 Nov 1913 PC Commonwealth (Fort William (Bengal)) [ Bailii ]  Kali Bakhsh Singh and Others v Ram Gopal Singh and Others [1913] UKPC 61 27 Nov 1913 PC Commonwealth Oudh [ Bailii ]  Barhamdeo Prasad Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Ram Sumiran Prasad) and Another v Tara Chand and Others [1913] UKPC 62 1 Dec 1913 PC Commonwealth (Fort William (Bengal)) [ Bailii ]  Musammat Jagrani Koer and Others v Kuar Durga Parshad [1913] UKPC 64 3 Dec 1913 PC Commonwealth Oudh [ Bailii ]  Parbati Dasi Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Udoy Nath Kar) v Raja Baikuntha Nath De and Others [1913] UKPC 65 3 Dec 1913 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  T S Natcheappa Chetty and Others v The Irrawaddy Flotilla Company Limited [1913] UKPC 66; [1913] UKPC 67 8 Dec 1913 PC Commonwealth, Transport Lower Burma [ Bailii ] - [ Bailii ]  Thakur Sheo Narain Singh Since Deceased and Others v Thakur Bishunath Singh and Another [1913] UKPC 70 10 Dec 1913 PC Commonwealth (Oudh) [ Bailii ]  Sri Raja Venkata Narasimha Appa Row Bahadur Zemindar Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Meka Venkatataramayya Appa Row Bahadur and Another) v Sri Raja Parthasarathy Appa Row Bahadur Zemindar and Others [1913] UKPC 71 10 Dec 1913 PC Commonwealth Madras [ Bailii ]  Arun Chandra Singh and Another v Kamini Kumar and Others [1913] UKPC 69 10 Dec 1913 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Bhaiya Sher Bahadur v Bhaiya Ganga Bakhsh Singh and Others [1913] UKPC 68 10 Dec 1913 PC Commonwealth (Oudh) [ Bailii ]  The Swan Brewery Company Limited (Reasons) v The King [1913] UKPC 72 16 Dec 1913 PC Commonwealth Western Australia [ Bailii ]  William John Miles v The Sydney Meat Preserving Company Limited and Others [1913] UKPC 74 16 Dec 1913 PC Commonwealth (Australia) [ Bailii ]  Payana Reena Layana Saminathan Chetty and Another v Pana Lana Pana Lana Palaniappa Chetty [1913] UKPC 75 16 Dec 1913 PC Commonwealth Ceylon [ Bailii ]  Gan Ngoh Bee v The Assistant Official Assignee Penang and Others [1913] UKPC 73 16 Dec 1913 PC Commonwealth (Straits Settlements) [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for Commonwealth of Australia and Others v The Colonial Sugar Refining Company Limited and Others [1913] UKPC 76 17 Dec 1913 PC Commonwealth (Australia) [ Bailii ]  The Canada Law Book Company v Butterworth and Company and Others [1914] UKPC 1 27 Jan 1914 PC Commonwealth (Manitoba) [ Bailii ]  David Maclaren and Another v The Attorney General for The Province of Quebec [1914] UKPC 2 28 Jan 1914 PC Commonwealth (Canada) [ Bailii ]  The State of South Australia v The State of Victoria [1914] UKPC 3 28 Jan 1914 PC Commonwealth Australia [ Bailii ]  Bijoy Gopal Mukerji and Others v Girindra Nath Mukerji and Others [1914] UKPC 4 2 Feb 1914 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  The Cedars Rapids Manufacturing and Power Company v Sir Alexandre Lascote and Others [1914] UKPC 5 3 Feb 1914 PC Commonwealth Quebec [ Bailii ]  Musammat Bakhtawar Begam v Musammat Husaini Khanam and Another [1914] UKPC 7 6 Feb 1914 PC Commonwealth Allahabad [ Bailii ]  Lala Birj Lal v (1/2) Musammat Inda Kunwar and Others, (3) Het Ram and Others [1914] UKPC 6 6 Feb 1914 PC Commonwealth North-West Frontier Province [ Bailii ]  Bowring Brothers Limited v Henry Toke Munn [1914] UKPC 8 11 Feb 1914 PC Commonwealth Newfoundland [ Bailii ]  Srimutty Manokarani Debi v Haripada Mitter and Others [1914] UKPC 9 24 Feb 1914 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Ma Nhin Bwin v U Shwe Gone [1914] UKPC 10 25 Feb 1914 PC Commonwealth Lower Burma [ Bailii ]  Chidambaram Chettiar v Srinvassa Sastrial and Others [1914] UKPC 13 4 Mar 1914 PC Commonwealth Madras [ Bailii ]  Arthur Henry Forbes v Maharaj Bahadur Singh and Others [1914] UKPC 13 4 Mar 1914 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  The Ship St Pierre-Miquelon v The Renwick Steamship Company Limited and Others [1914] UKPC 11 4 Mar 1914 PC Commonwealth Canada [ Bailii ]   Ibrahim v The King; PC 6-Mar-1914 - [1914] UKPC 1; [1914] AC 599   The Chief Commissioner for Railways and Tramways v Hutchinson and Another; PC 6-Mar-1914 - [1914] UKPC 15  The Ore Concentration Company (1905) Limited and Others v The Sulphide Corporation Limited [1914] UKPC 14 6 Mar 1914 PC Commonwealth New South Wales [ Bailii ]  Ibrahim v The King [1914] UKPC 16 6 Mar 1914 PC Commonwealth Hong Kong [ Bailii ]  Batuk Nath v Musammat Munni Dei and Others [1914] UKPC 17 11 Mar 1914 PC Commonwealth Allahabad [ Bailii ]  Chunilal Parvatishankar v Bai Samrath [1914] UKPC 18 17 Mar 1914 PC Commonwealth Bombay [ Bailii ]  Lala Mahabir Prasad and Others v Musammat Taj Begam and Others [1914] UKPC 19 18 Mar 1914 PC Commonwealth Allahabad [ Bailii ]  The Equitable Life Assurance Society of The United States v Brenda Beatrice Reed [1914] UKPC 20 19 Mar 1914 PC Commonwealth New Zealand [ Bailii ]  Harendra Lal Roy Chowdhuri v Srimati Hari Dasi Debi and Others [1914] UKPC 21 25 Mar 1914 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Musammat Amir Begam v Khawaja Saiyed Badr-Ud-Din Husain and Others [1914] UKPC 22 27 Mar 1914 PC Commonwealth (Oudh) [ Bailii ]  Chief Young Dede and Another v The African Association Limited [1914] UKPC 23 27 Mar 1914 PC Commonwealth Nigeria [ Bailii ]  Srimutty Ranimoni Dasi and Another v Radhaprasad Mullick Since Deceased, and Others [1914] UKPC 24 30 Mar 1914 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Arthur Allen and Others v John C Hyatt and Others [1914] UKPC 25 2 Apr 1914 PC Commonwealth Ontario [ Bailii ]  John King and Company Limited v The Chairman of The Municipal Commissioners of Howrah and Others [1914] UKPC 26 6 Apr 1914 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]   Farrell v The National Trust Company Limited and Others; PC 7-Apr-1914 - [1914] UKPC 27   Chaudhri Abdul Majid v Jawahir Lal and Others; PC 7-Apr-1914 - [1914] UKPC 30  Chaudhri Abdul Majid v Jawahir Lal and Others [1914] UKPC 29 7 Apr 1914 PC Commonwealth Allahabad [ Bailii ]  Channing Arnold v The King-Emperor [1914] UKPC 28 7 Apr 1914 PC Commonwealth Lower Burma [ Bailii ]  Nalini Kanta Lahira Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Sarat Kamini Debi and Another) v Sarnamoyi Debya and Others [1914] UKPC 31 23 Apr 1914 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  The Australian Widow's Fund Life Assurance Society Limited v The National Mutual Life Association of Australasia Limited [1914] UKPC 32 23 Apr 1914 PC Commonwealth Australia [ Bailii ]  The Perfect Pottery Company Limited v Ida L Rose [1914] UKPC 33 24 Apr 1914 PC Commonwealth India [ Bailii ]  Ram Sewak and Others v Jagannath [1914] UKPC 35 24 Apr 1914 PC Commonwealth Allahabad [ Bailii ]  Musammat Hiran Bibi Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Krishn Das) and Others v Musammat Sohan Bibi [1914] UKPC 34 24 Apr 1914 PC Commonwealth Allahabad [ Bailii ]  Nga Lu Gale Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Maung Tin Gyi and Others) v Nga Po Than [1914] UKPC 36 27 Apr 1914 PC Commonwealth Upper Burma [ Bailii ]  The Wassaw Exploring Syndicate Limited v The African Rubber Company Limited (Gold Coast Colony) [1914] UKPC 37 29 Apr 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  John Black and Others v John Carson and Others The Crown Reserve Mining Company (Quebec) [1914] UKPC 38 6 May 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rai Dwarka Nath Sarkar Bahadur and Another v Haji Mahomed Akbar and Others [1914] UKPC 39 7 May 1914 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Peter Charles Ernest Paul and Another v William Robson and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1914] UKPC 40 11 May 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bijraj Nopani Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Maliram Nopani and Another v Sreemutty Pura Sundary Dassess (Fort William (Bengal)) [1914] UKPC 41 11 May 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sheo Shankar Ram and Others v Musammat Jaddo Kunwar and Others (Allahabad) [1914] UKPC 42 12 May 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raghunath Das and Others v Sundar Das Khetri Since Deceased and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1914] UKPC 43 14 May 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shoharat Singh and Others v Musammat Jafri Bibi (Allahabad) [1914] UKPC 44 18 May 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maha Prasad Singh Since Deceased (Now Represented By Sashi Bhusan Singh) and Others v Ramani Mohan Singh Since Deceased and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1914] UKPC 45 19 May 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  William Levine v Harry Serling [1914] UKPC 46 21 May 1914 PC Commonwealth Canada [ Bailii ]  Alberto Dini Since Deceased (Now Represented By Dame Malvina Larose) v Joseph Brunet (Quebec) [1914] UKPC 47 22 May 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Annie Besant v G Narayaniah and J Krishnamurti and J Nityananda Added By Order In Council (Madras) [1914] UKPC 48 25 May 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Cecil M Merritt v Gordon E Corbould and Others (British Columbia) [1914] UKPC 50 25 May 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bhaiaji Thakur Since Deceased (Now Represented By Jalandhar Thakur and Another) v Jharula Das (Fort William (Bengal)) [1914] UKPC 49 26 May 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The United Buildings Corporation Limited v The City of Vancouver [1914] UKPC 51 15 Jun 1914 PC Commonwealth British Columbia [ Bailii ]  The British Columbia Electric Railway Limited v Violet Gentle (British Columbia) [1914] UKPC 52 16 Jun 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sinniah Thanna Letchimey and Others v Sayna Suna Nawanna Ramanathan Chetty (Ceylon) [1914] UKPC 53 17 Jun 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ravi Veeraraghavulu and Others v Sri Raja Bomma Devara Venkata Narasimha Naidu Bahadur Zemindar Garu (Madras) [1914] UKPC 54 18 Jun 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  David Cook v The City of Vancouver [1914] UKPC 55 23 Jun 1914 PC Commonwealth British Columbia [ Bailii ]  The British Columbia Electric Railway Company Limited v The Vancouver Victoria and Eastern Railway and Navigation Company and Others [1914] UKPC 56 26 Jun 1914 PC Commonwealth Canada [ Bailii ]  Ramchandra Martand Waikar and Others v Vinayak Venkatesh Kothekar and Another (India) [1914] UKPC 57 29 Jun 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  John Mclaughlin v The City Bank of Sydney [1914] UKPC 58 1 Jul 1914 PC Commonwealth New South Wales [ Bailii ]  The Canadian Collieries (Dunsmuir) Limited and Another v James Dunsmuir [1914] UKPC 59 3 Jul 1914 PC Commonwealth British Columbia [ Bailii ]  Robert Davies v The James Bay Railway Company [1914] UKPC 60 6 Jul 1914 PC Commonwealth Ontario [ Bailii ]  Leslie Gordon Corrie and Another v P J Macdermott [1914] UKPC 63 14 Jul 1914 PC Commonwealth Australia [ Bailii ]  The Canadian Pacific Railway Company and Others v The Canadian Oil Companies Limited and Another [1914] UKPC 62 14 Jul 1914 PC Commonwealth Canada [ Bailii ]  Douglas Brothers v The Acadia Fire Insurance Company [1914] UKPC 61 14 Jul 1914 PC Commonwealth Nova Scotia [ Bailii ]  The Molsons Bank v J B Klock (Quebec) [1914] UKPC 65 16 Jul 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Srinath Roy and Others v Dinabandu Sen Since Deceased, and Others [1914] UKPC 64 16 Jul 1914 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Maharaja Surja Kanta Acharjya Bahadur Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Maharajkumar Sashi Kanta Acharjya) v Sarat Chandra Roy Chowdhuri (Fort William (Bengal)) [1914] UKPC 66 20 Jul 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The West India Electric Company Limited v The Mayor and Council of Kingston [1914] UKPC 68 21 Jul 1914 PC Commonwealth Jamaica [ Bailii ]  Atta Kwamin v Kobina Kufuor [1914] UKPC 67 21 Jul 1914 PC Commonwealth Gold Coast Colony [ Bailii ]  Elias Smith and Others v Seth S Smith and Dale M King [1914] UKPC 69 21 Jul 1914 PC Commonwealth Ontario [ Bailii ]  Edward Feltham Coates and Others v The Sovereign Bank of Canada (Quebec) [1914] UKPC 80 4 Aug 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  J Henry Peters v Angus Sinclair [1914] UKPC 81 4 Aug 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Pastoral Finance Association Limited v The Minister (New South Wales) [1914] UKPC 77 4 Aug 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Windsor Essex and Lake Shore Rapid Railway Company v A J Nelles and Another (Canada) [1914] UKPC 82 20 Oct 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council v Sri Raja Kirtibas Bhupati Harichandan Mahapatra (Fort William (Bengal)) [1914] UKPC 83 21 Oct 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Province of Alberta v The Attorney General for The Dominion of Canada and Another (Canada) [1914] UKPC 84 22 Oct 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Seth Ramlal Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Seth Sheolal) and Another v Narsingdas Since Deceased and Others (India) [1914] UKPC 85 22 Oct 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jhandu v Tarif Since Deceased and Others [1914] UKPC 86 23 Oct 1914 PC Commonwealth North-West Frontier Province [ Bailii ]  The John Deere Plow Company Limited v Theodore F Wharton and Others (British Columbia) [1914] UKPC 87 2 Nov 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dhiraj Chandra Bose and Another v Srimati Hari Dasi Debi and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1914] UKPC 88 2 Nov 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Munna Lal Parruck and Others v Sarat Chunder Mukerji and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1914] UKPC 89 5 Nov 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mildred Howard v William Miller and Another [1914] UKPC 90 6 Nov 1914 PC Commonwealth (Canada) [ Bailii ]   Ufflemann v The Stecher Lithographic Company and Others; PC 9-Nov-1914 - [1914] UKPC 91  Mamabai Framjee Petit v The Secretary of State for India In Council [1914] UKPC 93 18 Nov 1914 PC Commonwealth (Bombay) [ Bailii ]  Karmali Abdulla Allarakhia v Vora Karimji Jiwaji and Others (Bombay) [1914] UKPC 92 18 Nov 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Moosa Hajee Hassam and Others v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Bombay) [1914] UKPC 94 18 Nov 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mahomed Musa Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Mahomed Abdul Aziz and Others) and Others v Aghore Kumar Ganguli and Others [1914] UKPC 95 25 Nov 1914 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Kunwar Digambar Singh v Kunwar Ahmed Sayeed Khan Singh (Allahabad) [1914] UKPC 96 25 Nov 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jambu Parshad v Muhammad Nawab Aftab Ali Khan and Another (Allahabad) [1914] UKPC 97 25 Nov 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jehangir Dadabhoy and Another v Kaikhushru Kavasha and Others [1914] UKPC 98 26 Nov 1914 PC Commonwealth Bombay [ Bailii ]  Hari Kishen Bhagat and Others v Kashi Pershad Singh (Since Deceased) and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1914] UKPC 99 2 Dec 1914 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ex parte Donelly 1915 WLD 29 1915 Mason J Commonwealth (South Africa) A husband had been convicted of drugs offences in South Africa and after serving a period of imprisonment was deported to the United States of America. The wife then applied in South Africa for leave to sue her husband for restitution of conjugal rights or for divorce. Held: The court had no jurisdiction: "A person, it is true, may select any place he likes as his domicile, provided, says the Digest (50, 1, 31), it has not been prohibited for him . . Now in the present case the husband cannot have a true domicile in fact in South Africa; he is liable to instant punishment and deportation if he returns." 1 Citers  State Savings Bank of Victoria Comissioners v Permewan Wright and Co Ltd (1915) 19 CLR 457 1915 Banking, Commonwealth To be held to be a banker in law, it was not necessary for a company to open current accounts. 1 Cites 1 Citers  Shivalingappa Basappa Shintre v Revappa and Others (Bombay) [1915] UKPC 3 19 Jan 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ahmed Musaji Saleji and Others v Hashim Ebrahim Saleji and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1915] UKPC 2 19 Jan 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharajah Sir Ravaneshwar Prasad Singh Bahadur and Others v Baijnath Ram Goenka and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1915] UKPC 1 19 Jan 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Toronto Surburban Railway Company v The Corporation of The City of Toronto (Ontario) [1915] UKPC 4 20 Jan 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The State of New South Wales v James Leslie Williams (Australia) [1915] UKPC 5 25 Jan 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sheikh Haji Mutasaddi Mian and Another v Mahomed Idris and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1915] UKPC 6 29 Jan 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Ramkanai Singh Deb Darpashaha and Another v Mathewson and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1915] UKPC 8 9 Feb 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Bahadur Motilal Shival v The Bombay Cotton Manufacturing Company Limited (Bombay) [1915] UKPC 11 25 Feb 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Minister for Lands v George Coote [1915] UKPC 9 25 Feb 1915 PC Commonwealth New South Wales [ Bailii ]  The Bombay Cotton Manufacturing Company Limited v Raja Bahadur Motilal Shival (Bombay) [1915] UKPC 10 25 Feb 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Motabhoy Mulla Essabhoy v Mulji Haridas (Bombay) [1915] UKPC 12 25 Feb 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Arthur John Fry Gibbons v Walter Vincent Lenfestey and Another [1915] UKPC 13 3 Mar 1915 PC Commonwealth (Guernsey) [ Bailii ]  Balmukand and Others (Reasons) v The King-Emperor (Punjab) [1915] UKPC 14 3 Mar 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chuah Hooi Gnoh Neoh v Khaw Sim Bee Since Deceased (Penang) [1915] UKPC 16 9 Mar 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Union Steamship Company of New Zealand Limited v The Wellington Harbour Board (New Zealand) [1915] UKPC 15 9 Mar 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mahant Lahar Puri v Mahant Puran Nath (Allahabad) [1915] UKPC 17 15 Mar 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  V. Venkatanarayana Pillay (Since Deceased) v V. Subbammal and Another (Madras) [1915] UKPC 18 15 Mar 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bal Gangadhar Tilak and Others v Shri Shriniwas Pandit and Another (Bombay) [1915] UKPC 19 26 Mar 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Toronto Power Company Limited v Kate Paskwan (Ontario) [1915] UKPC 20 15 Apr 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Grant Trunk Railway Company of Canada v Albert Nelson Robinson (Canada) [1915] UKPC 21 20 Apr 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Eastern Trust Company v Mckenzie Mann and Company Limited [1915] UKPC 22 27 Apr 1915 PC Commonwealth Canada [ Bailii ]  Puttu Lal Since Deceased and Others v Musammat Parbati Kunwar and Another (Allahabad) [1915] UKPC 23 5 May 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Vasonji Morarji Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Mulji) v Musammat Chandra Bibi (Allahabad) [1915] UKPC 24 7 May 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Padman and Others v Hanwanta and Others (Punjab) [1915] UKPC 25 19 May 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Padarath Halwai and Others v Pandit Ram Nain Upadhia and Others (Allahabad) [1915] UKPC 28 3 Jun 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council v Bai Rajbai (Bombay) [1915] UKPC 27 3 Jun 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Edward Odlum and Others v The City of Vancouver and Canadian Northern Pacific Railway Company [1915] UKPC 26 3 Jun 1915 PC Commonwealth (British Columbia) [ Bailii ]  Bhagwati Prasad Singh and Another v Nand Prasad Singh and Another (Allahabad) [1915] UKPC 30 8 Jun 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rajwant Prasad Pande and Others v Mahant Ram Ratan Gir and Others (Allahabad) [1915] UKPC 29 8 Jun 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bagga and Others v Saleh and Others (Punjab) [1915] UKPC 31 24 Jun 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Canadian Pacific Railway Company v Fruchette [1915] UKPC 32 25 Jun 1915 PC Commonwealth Quebec [ Bailii ]  Merwanji Muncherji Cama and Another v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Bombay) [1915] UKPC 33 29 Jun 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Charles Holwell Ward and Others v Henry Isaac Close Brown and Others (Jamaica) [1915] UKPC 35 8 Jul 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Duncan Ratherford v William Acton-Adams (New Zealand) [1915] UKPC 36 8 Jul 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thomas Harrison Odonkor v Konor Emmanuel Mate Kole and Others [1915] UKPC 34 8 Jul 1915 PC Commonwealth (Gold Coast Colony) [ Bailii ]  Ganga Sahai v Kersri and Others (Allahabad) [1915] UKPC 37 13 Jul 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Bilas Kunwar Since Deceased, (Now Represented By The Collector of Jaunpur) v Desraj Ranjit Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1915] UKPC 39 13 Jul 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakurani Tara Kumari and Another v Chaturbhuj Narayan Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1915] UKPC 38 13 Jul 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  W. Gardiner and Company Limited v Peter Henry Dessaix and Others (New South Wales) [1915] UKPC 41 20 Jul 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The British South Africa Company v Lennon Limited (South Africa) [1915] UKPC 40 20 Jul 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Canadian Pacific Railway Company v Frank Mcdonald [1915] UKPC 43 22 Jul 1915 PC Commonwealth (Quebec) [ Bailii ]  Arthur John Pate v Charles Henry Pate Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Walter Charles Pate and Others) (Ceylon) [1915] UKPC 42 22 Jul 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The King v Catherine Lena Broad (New Zealand) [1915] UKPC 45 26 Jul 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Copthall Stores Limited v Willoughby's Consolidated Company Limited [1915] UKPC 44 26 Jul 1915 PC Commonwealth (South Africa) [ Bailii ]  The British Columbia Electric Railway Company Limited v T. K. Loach Administrator of The Estate of Benjamin Sands Deceased (British Columbia) [1915] UKPC 46 26 Jul 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Buddha Singh and Others v Laltu Singh and Another (Allahabad) [1915] UKPC 47 29 Jul 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Holt Timber Company Limited v Albert Mccallum (Ontario) [1915] UKPC 48 20 Oct 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Umed Singh and Another v Rai Bahadur Seth Sobhag Mal Dhadha and Another (Ajmer-Merwara) [1915] UKPC 49 2 Nov 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaja Sir Ravaneshwar Prasad Singh Bahadur v Tekait Chandi Prasad Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1915] UKPC 50 2 Nov 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of The Cargo Ex Steamship Roumanian v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1915] UKPC 52 10 Nov 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of The Cargo Ex Odessa and Steamship Woolston v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1915] UKPC 53 11 Nov 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Bhupenra Krishna Ghose and Another v Amarendra Nath Dey and Another; PC 15-Nov-1915 - [1915] UKPC 54  M. R. M. A. Subramanian Chettiar v Rajah Rajeswara Dorai and Others (Madras) [1915] UKPC 55 16 Nov 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nageshar Prasad Pande v Raja Pateshri Partab Narain Singh and Another (Allahabad) [1915] UKPC 56 16 Nov 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  V. Vencatanarayana Pillay Since Deceased, (Now Represented By V. Kuppusami Pillay) v V. Subbammal and Another (Madras) [1915] UKPC 57 17 Nov 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gibbons v His Majesty's Receiver General and Another [1915] UKPC 58 18 Nov 1915 PC Commonwealth (Guernsey) [ Bailii ]  Musahar Sahu and Another v Lala Hakim Lal and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1915] UKPC 60 22 Nov 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Haji Umar Abdul Rahiman v Gustadji Muncherji Cooper (Bombay) [1915] UKPC 59 22 Nov 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Seth Jaswant Rai v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Allahabad) [1915] UKPC 61 23 Nov 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Amir Chand v Bakshi Harihar Prasad Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1915] UKPC 62 25 Nov 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nagindas Bhugwandas v Bachoo Hurkissondas (Bombay) [1915] UKPC 63 26 Nov 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Corporation of The Bank of Australia and Others v The Municipal Council of Sydney (New South Wales) [1915] UKPC 64 2 Dec 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Abdurahim Haji Ismail Mithu v Halimabai (Eastern Africa) [1915] UKPC 65 3 Dec 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jameshed Khodaram Irani v Burjorji Dhunjibhai Contractor (Bombay) [1915] UKPC 66 6 Dec 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Charles F. Curry and Another v Gordon M. Mcgregor (Ontario) [1915] UKPC 67 14 Dec 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pandit Parbhu Dyal v Kayan Das and Others (Allahabad) [1915] UKPC 68 14 Dec 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Union Insurance Society of Canton Limited v George Wills and Company (Western Australia) [1915] UKPC 69 15 Dec 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Bank of Bengal v Ramanathan Chetty and Others (Lower Burma) [1915] UKPC 70 16 Dec 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Steedman v William R Drinkle and Another [1915] UKPC 71; [1916] AC 275 21 Dec 1915 PC Viscount Haldane Commonwealth, Land, Equity (Saskatchewan) Land in Canada was purchased under an agreement, where the price was to be paid by one initial payment and annual instalments. If the purchaser was to default on any payment, the vendor was free to cancel the agreement and to retain, as liquidated damages, the payments already made. It was also provided that time was to be considered as of the essence of the contract. The first deferred payment was not made on the due date. The vendor gave notice cancelling the agreement. Three weeks after the due date the purchaser tendered the amount due, which was refused. He thereupon brought an action claiming specific performance and relief from forfeiture of the amount already paid. Held: The Board upheld the decision of the Canadian Court, that the stipulation as to the retention of the sums already paid was a penalty. But the Board declined to grant specific performance. Viscount Haldane said: "Courts of Equity, which look at the substance as distinguished from the letter of agreements, no doubt exercise an extensive jurisdiction which enables them to decree specific performance where justice requires it, even though literal terms as to stipulation as to time have not been observed. But they never exercise this jurisdiction where the parties have expressly intimated in their agreement that it is not to apply by providing that time is to be of the essence of the bargain". And "As to the relief from forfeiture, their Lordships think that the Supreme Court was right in holding, for the reasons assigned in the former decision of this Board, that the stipulation in question was one for a penalty, against which relief should be given on proper terms. But as regards specific performance they are of opinion that the Supreme Court was wrong in reversing the judgment of Newlands J. Courts of Equity, which look at the substance as distinguished from the letter of agreements, no doubt exercise an extensive jurisdiction which enables them to decree specific performance in cases where justice requires it, even though literal terms of stipulations as to time have not been observed. But they never exercise this jurisdiction where the parties have expressly intimated in their agreement that it is not to apply by providing that time is to be of the essence of their bargain. If, indeed, the parties, having originally so provided, have expressly or by implication waived the provision made, the jurisdiction will again attach." [ Bailii ]  The Central Trust and Safe Deposit Company and Another v Harvey G. Snider and Others (Ontario) [1915] UKPC 72 21 Dec 1915 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jones v De Marchant (1916) 28 DLR 561 1916 Equity, Commonwealth A husband wrongfully used 18 beaver skins belonging to his wife together with four skins of his own, to have a fur coat made up which he then gave to his mistress. The wife was held entitled to recover the coat. The mistress knew nothing of the true ownership of the skins, but her innocence was held to be immaterial. She was a gratuitous donee and could stand in no better position than the husband. The coat was a new asset manufactured from the skins and not merely the product of intermingling them. The problem could not be solved by a sale of the coat in order to reduce the disputed property to a divisible fund, since (as we shall see) the realisation of an asset does not affect its ownership. It would hardly have been appropriate to require the two ladies to share the coat between them. Accordingly it was an all or nothing case in which the ownership of the coat must be assigned to one or other of the parties. The determinative factor was that the mixing was the act of the wrongdoer through whom the mistress acquired the coat otherwise than for value. 1 Citers  Foley Brothers v Mcilwee and Others [1916] UKPC 1 19 Jan 1916 PC Commonwealth (British Columbia) [ Bailii ]  Hajee Mamode Hossen and Others v Mamode Hadee [1916] UKPC 2 20 Jan 1916 PC Commonwealth Mauritius [ Bailii ]  John Livingston and Others v James Livingston [1916] UKPC 3 27 Jan 1916 PC Commonwealth Ontario [ Bailii ]  Srimati Nrityamoni Dassi and Others v Lakhan Chunder Sen (Since Deceased) and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 4 31 Jan 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Ontario Power Company of Nigeria Falls v The Municipal Corporation of The Township of Stamford (Ontario) [1916] UKPC 5 2 Feb 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ernest Holditch v The Canadian Northern Ontario Railway Company [1916] UKPC 6 7 Feb 1916 PC Commonwealth (Canada) [ Bailii ]  Said and Company Having for Its Manager Hajee Mamode Hossen v Mamode Hadee (Seychelles) [1916] UKPC 7 10 Feb 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Suna Ana Arunachellam Chetty and Others v S. R. M. Ramaswami Chetty (Madras) [1916] UKPC 9 21 Feb 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dulhin Genda Kunwar v Harnandan Prashad Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 8 21 Feb 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Bonanza Creek Gold Mining Company Limited v The King and Another (Canada) [1916] UKPC 11 24 Feb 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Provinces of Ontario, Quebec, Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, Manitoba, Prince Edward Island Alberta and Saskatchewan v The Attorney General for The Dominion of Canada (Canada) [1916] UKPC 13 24 Feb 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Dominion of Canada v The Attorney General for The Provinces of Alberta, Manitoba, New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, Ontario, Quebec and Saskatchewan, The Canadian Insurance Federation and The Manufacturers Association of Canada an [1916] UKPC 12 24 Feb 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Adwaitya Prasad and Others v Baldeo Das and Another (Allahabad) [1916] UKPC 14 28 Feb 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Debi Bakhsh Singh v Shadi Lal and Others (Oudh) [1916] UKPC 16 14 Mar 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mahant Ram Parkash Das v Mahant Anand Das and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 17 16 Mar 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sheoparsan Singh and Others v Ramnandan Prasad Narayan Singh Since Deceased and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 18 16 Mar 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jamna Bai Saheb Mohital Avergal v Vasanta Rao Ananda Rao Dhybar (Madras) [1916] UKPC 19 21 Mar 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pranjivandas Jagjivandas Mehta v Chan Mah Phee (Lower Burma) [1916] UKPC 20 21 Mar 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jatindra Nath Basu and Others v Srimati Peyer Deye Debi and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 21 28 Mar 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Kishan Lal v Musammat Kashmiro and Others (Allahabad) [1916] UKPC 22 28 Mar 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kishore Chand and Others v Ahmad Ali Khan and Others (Punjab) [1916] UKPC 23 7 Apr 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Steamship Gutenfels v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1916] UKPC 26 7 Apr 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Steamship Derfflinger v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1916] UKPC 28 7 Apr 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Steamship Belgia v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1916] UKPC 25 7 Apr 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Steamship Barenfels v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1916] UKPC 27 7 Apr 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Steamship Achaia v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1916] UKPC 29 7 Apr 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Steamship Zamora v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1916] UKPC 24 7 Apr 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Steamship Pindos v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1916] UKPC 30 13 Apr 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Steamship Panariellos v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1916] UKPC 35 13 Apr 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Steamship Marquis Bacquehem v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1916] UKPC 33 13 Apr 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Steamship Helgoland v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1916] UKPC 31 13 Apr 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Steamship Rostock v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1916] UKPC 32 13 Apr 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Steamship Concadoro v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1916] UKPC 34 14 Apr 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Rivers Steam Navigation Company (Limited) v The Hathor Steamship Company (Limited) (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 36 5 May 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Steamship Ophelia v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1916] UKPC 37 8 May 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Mangaone Oilfields (Limited) v The Herman and Weger Manufacturing and Contracting Company (Limited) (New Zealand) [1916] UKPC 38 9 May 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaja Ram Narayan Singh Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Maharaj Kumar Lachmi Narayan Singh) v Adhindra Nath Mukhurji and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 39 12 May 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Raja Malraju Lakshmi Venkayyamma Rao Bahadur v Sri Raja Venkata Narasimha Appa Rao Bahadur Since Deceased and Another (Madras) [1916] UKPC 41 15 May 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mahomed Ismail Ariff and Others v Hajee Ahmed Moolla Dawood and Another (Lower Burma) [1916] UKPC 40 15 May 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Manche Kojo Ababio Iv v Quartey and Another (Gold Coast Colony) [1916] UKPC 42 16 May 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Steamship Bolivar v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1916] UKPC 43 17 May 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Girja Bai v Sadashiv Dhundiraj and Others (India) [1916] UKPC 44 19 May 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sir Rodolphe Forget v The Cement Products Company of Canada and Another (Quebec) [1916] UKPC 45 30 May 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Maqbul Fatima and Others v Amir Hasan Khan and Others (Allahabad) [1916] UKPC 46 2 Jun 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The State of Queensland (At The Relation of Goldsbrough Mort and Co. (Limited) and Others (Reasons) v The Attorney General for The Commonwealth of Australia and Another (Australia) [1916] UKPC 47 2 Jun 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Ridd Milking Machine Company (Limited) v The Simplex Milking Machine Company (Limited) [1916] UKPC 51 22 Jun 1916 PC Commonwealth (New Zealand) [ Bailii ]  Ramdas Vithaldas Durbar v S. Amerchand and Co. (Bombay) [1916] UKPC 49 22 Jun 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chandrika Bakhsh Singh (Reasons) v Raja Indar Bikram Singh (Oudh) [1916] UKPC 50 22 Jun 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaja Sri Ram Chandra Bhani Deo Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Maharaja Purns Chandra Bhanj Deo) v The Secretary of State for India In Council and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 48 22 Jun 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Corporation of The City of Toronto v The Toronto Railway Company (Ontario) [1916] UKPC 52 23 Jun 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Fateh Chand v Pandit Rup Chand (Allahabad) [1916] UKPC 54 23 Jun 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kobina Angu v Cudjoe Attah (Gold Coast Colony) [1916] UKPC 53 23 Jun 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Radha Kunwar v Thakur Reoti Singh (Allahabad) [1916] UKPC 55 26 Jun 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Edwin Charles Bacon v Thomas Purcell (Australia) [1916] UKPC 56 30 Jun 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ho Chiu Lam Alias Ho Yiu Tong v Ho San Lam Alias Ho Ngok Lau (Hong Kong) [1916] UKPC 57 4 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council v Sri Raja Chelikani Rama Rao and Others (Madras) [1916] UKPC 58 7 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Janaki Ammal v Narayanasami Aiyer (Madras) [1916] UKPC 59 10 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mirza Sadik Husain Khan v Nawab Saiyed Hashim Ali Khan and Others (Oudh Lucknow) [1916] UKPC 60 11 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bull and Others v The Attorney General for The State of New South Wales [1916] UKPC 63 14 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth Australia [ Bailii ]  Nobin Chandra Barua and Others v Chandra Madhab Barua (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 61 14 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  William Lambert Fowles v The Eastern and Australian Steamship Company (Limited) (Queensland) [1916] UKPC 64 14 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  William Lambert Fowles v The Eastern and Australian Steamship Company (Limited) (Queensland) [1916] UKPC 65 14 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaja of Bobbili v Sree Rajah Narasaraju Peda Baliara Simhulu Bahadur Garu and Another (Madras) [1916] UKPC 62 14 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Azeeza Joseph Solomon Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Elias Joseph Solomon and Others The Executors Under Her Will) v The Corporation of Calcutta (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 67 17 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nanda Lal Dhur Biswas Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Banga Chandra Dhur Biswas and Another) and Another v Jagat Kishore Acharjya Chowdhuri and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 66 17 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Hamilton Grimsby and Beamsville Railway Company v The Attorney General for The Province of Ontario and Others (Ontario) [1916] UKPC 68 18 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mahomed Syedol Ariffin Bin Mahomed Ariff v Yeoh Ooi Gark (Penang) [1916] UKPC 69 20 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Atika Begum v Muhammad Ibrahim Rashid Nawab (Allahabad) [1916] UKPC 70 20 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ahmad Raza and Others v Saiyid Abid Husain and Others (Allahabad) [1916] UKPC 72 21 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Murtaza Husain Khan v Mohammad Yasin Ali Khan (Oudh) [1916] UKPC 71 21 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Diwakar Minor Through His Friend Rao Bahadur Indraraj Bhau v Chandanlal Minor Under The Guardianship of Musammat Jasoda Bai and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1916] UKPC 74 24 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   La Corporation De La Ville De Thetford Mines v Amalgamated Asbestos Corporation Limited; PC 24-Jul-1916 - [1916] UKPC 73  Charlotte Brickles Executrix of The Estate of Isaac Brickles Deceased v William H. Snell [1916] UKPC 75; [1916] 2 AC 599 25 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth, Land Canada - Appeal against order made on application for specific performance of contract by the deceased for the sale of land. [ Bailii ]  Smith v The Council of The Rural Municipality of Vermillion Hills No. 195 and Another [1916] UKPC 76 25 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth (Canada) [ Bailii ]  James Samuel Walker v Maria Mecada Piedra Albo De Soysa (Ceylon) [1916] UKPC 77 25 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jhanda Singh v Sheikh Wahid-Un-Din and Others (Allahabad) [1916] UKPC 78 27 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commercial Cable Company v The Government of Newfoundland [1916] UKPC 80 31 Jul 1916 PC Commonwealth (Newfoundland) [ Bailii ]   The Yorkshire Insurance Company Limited v Archibald Donaldson Campbell; PC 23-Oct-1916 - [1916] UKPC 87  The Toronto Electric Light Company Limited v The Corporation of The City of Toronto (Ontario) [1916] UKPC 86 23 Oct 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Toronto and York Railway Company v The Corporation of The City of Toronto (Ontario) [1916] UKPC 88 23 Oct 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Municipal Corporation of The City of Bombay and Another v The Great Indian Peninsula Railway Company (Bombay) [1916] UKPC 89 26 Oct 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  R.M.A.R.A.R. Somasunderam Chetty v R.M.A.R.A.R.R.M. Aunasalam Chetty and Another (Ceylon) [1916] UKPC 90 26 Oct 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bhagwan Das v Musammat Bhuri Kunwar and Others (Allahabad) [1916] UKPC 91 27 Oct 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Tilbury Town Gas Company Limited v The Maple City Oil and Gas Company Limited and Others (Ontario) [1916] UKPC 94 2 Nov 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Board of Trustesss of The Roman Catholic Separate Schools of The City of Ottawa and Others v The Corporation of The City of Ottawa and Others (Ontario) [1916] UKPC 93 2 Nov 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Board of Trustesss of The Roman Catholic Separate Schools of The City of Ottawa v R. Mackell and Others (Ontario) [1916] UKPC 92 2 Nov 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sripat Singh Dugar and Another v Maharajah Sir Podyot Kumar Tagore and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 95 10 Nov 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maung Tun Tha v Ma Thit and Others (Lower Burma) [1916] UKPC 96 13 Nov 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Daniel Thomas Keymer v P. Viswanatham Reddi (Madras) [1916] UKPC 97 14 Nov 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Steamship Canton (Reasons) v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1916] UKPC 98 15 Nov 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharajah Ram Narayan Singh Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Maharajkumar Lachmi Narayan Singh) v Adhindra Nath Mukerji and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 100 16 Nov 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Alexander Gillies v The Gane Milking Machine Company Limited [1916] UKPC 99 16 Nov 1916 PC Commonwealth New Zealand [ Bailii ]  The Kochien Transportation and Tow-Boat Company Limited v The Shanghai Dock Engineering Company Limited (Shanghai) [1916] UKPC 101 17 Nov 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chhatrapat Singh Dugar v Kharag Singh Lachmiram and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 102 20 Nov 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maung Shwe Goh v Maung Inn and Others (Lower Burma) [1916] UKPC 103 23 Nov 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Montreal Public Service Corporation v Evariste Champagne (Quebec) [1916] UKPC 104 24 Nov 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sulaiman v Biyaththumma and Others (Madras) [1916] UKPC 105 27 Nov 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Mohammad Abdul Husan Khan v Prag and Others (Oudh) [1916] UKPC 106 30 Nov 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mutu K. A. Ramanndan Chettiar v Vava Levvai Marakayar and Others (Madras) [1916] UKPC 107 1 Dec 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ralph Sadleir Falkiner (Trading As The Falkiner Electric Company) v Percy Whitton [1916] UKPC 108 1 Dec 1916 PC Commonwealth Australia [ Bailii ]  Mackenzie Mann and Co. Limited and Others v The Eastern Trust Company (Nova Scotia) [1916] UKPC 109 5 Dec 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shrinivasdas Bavri v Meherbai and Others (Bombay) [1916] UKPC 111 7 Dec 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Deonandan Prashad v Janki Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 110 7 Dec 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sashi Bhushan Misra and Others v Raja Jyoti Prashad Singh Deo and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 112 8 Dec 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Deonandan Prashad Singh and Others v Ramdhari Chowdhri and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 114 11 Dec 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Moti Chand and Others v Khwaja Ikram Ullah Khan and Others [1916] UKPC 115 11 Dec 1916 PC Commonwealth (Allahabad) [ Bailii ]  Mina Kumar Bibi v Raja Bijoy Singh Dudhuria (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 113 11 Dec 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Narottam Das Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Manu Bibi) v Kedar Nath Samanta and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 116 14 Dec 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Har Chandi Lal and Others v Sheoraj Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1916] UKPC 117 18 Dec 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Beg v Allah Ditta and Others (Punjab) [1916] UKPC 118 18 Dec 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Tricomdas Cooverji Bhoja v Sri Sri Gopinath Jiu Thakur (Fort William (Bengal)) [1916] UKPC 119 20 Dec 1916 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Moti Lal and Others v Kundan Lal and Another (Allahabad) [1917] UKPC 4 23 Jan 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Montreal Street Railway Company and Another v Roch Normandin [1917] UKPC 2 23 Jan 1917 PC Commonwealth, Personal Injury (Quebec) 1 Citers [ Bailii ]  T. S. Murugesam Pillai v Manickavasaka Desika Gnana Sambanda Pandara Sannadhi Since Deceased and Others (Madras) [1917] UKPC 5 23 Jan 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  La Compagnie De Pulpe De Chicoutimi v La Compagnie De Pulpe De Jonquiþre (Quebec) [1917] UKPC 3 23 Jan 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ernest L. Ruddy v The Toronto Eastern Railway Company (Canada) [1917] UKPC 1 23 Jan 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Ranjit Singh Bahadur v Srimati Kali Dasi Debi and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1917] UKPC 6 24 Jan 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Dominion Iron and Steel Company Limited v C. W. Burt, George C. Topshee, Emily Burns, Joseph Jamael And, John Kattar (Nova Scotia) [1917] UKPC 9 25 Jan 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mary Wood and Others v James Ebenezer Haines (Ontario) [1917] UKPC 8 25 Jan 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dame Alice Fraser and Others v The City of Fraserville (Quebec) [1917] UKPC 7 25 Jan 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chaudhi Bharath Singh v Chaudhi Balbhaddar Singh Since Deceased and Others (Oudh) [1917] UKPC 12 26 Jan 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  George William Mccaul v Donald Fraser (New Zealand) [1917] UKPC 11 26 Jan 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Canadian Pacific Railway Company v Dame Leosophie Parent and Another [1917] UKPC 10 26 Jan 1917 PC Commonwealth (Canada) [ Bailii ]  Sri Raja Parthasarathi Appa Rao Savai Aswa Row Bahadur Zemindar Garu v Chevendra China Sunara Ramayya and Others (Madras) [1917] UKPC 13 29 Jan 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pandit Suraj Narain and Another v Pandit Ratan Lal and Another (Oudh) [1917] UKPC 14 30 Jan 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kumar Basanta Kumar Roy and Others v The Secretary of State for India In Council and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1917] UKPC 15 1 Feb 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dixson Trust Limited v Beard Watson Limited (New South Wales) [1917] UKPC 16 13 Feb 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Simon De Costa and Others v M. D. L. De Silva and Others (Ceylon) [1917] UKPC 17 19 Feb 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Haji Mohomed Eusop Bin Aboo Bakr, Singh Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Haji Abdul Rahman and Another) v Mohomed Hassan Bin Abdul Latib (Malay States) [1917] UKPC 18 19 Feb 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Steamship Belgia (Appeals of The American Metal Company and The American Smelting and Refining Company) v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1917] UKPC 19 23 Feb 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Muhammad Abdul Aziz and Another v Mir Tasadduq Husain and Others (Allahabad) [1917] UKPC 20 1 Mar 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaja Manindra Chandra Nandi v Raja Sri Sri Durga Prashad Singh Since Deceased (Fort William (Bengal)) [1917] UKPC 22 8 Mar 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dal Singh v The King Emeror (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner of The Central Provinces India) [1917] UKPC 21 8 Mar 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sabu Ram Chandra and Another v Bhup Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1917] UKPC 23 9 Mar 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Steamship Eleftherios (Appeals of La Societo Anonima Alfro Kun of Genoa) v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1917] UKPC 24 15 Mar 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Madhu Sudan Chowdhri (Since Deceased) and Others v Musammat Chandrabati (Since Deceased) and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1917] UKPC 26 20 Mar 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of The Yacht Germania (Claim of Gustav Krupp Von Bohlen) v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1917] UKPC 25 20 Mar 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Palaniappa Chetty and Another v Sreemath Deivasikamony Pandara Sannadhi Alias Nataraja Desikar [1917] UKPC 29 22 Mar 1917 PC Commonwealth Madras [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Steamship Eleftherios (Appeal of Messrs Lindvall and Hemer) v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1917] UKPC 28 22 Mar 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Steamship Daksa His Majesty'S Attorney General and Proctor of Gibraltar V. Louis Dreyfus and Company v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1917] UKPC 27 22 Mar 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Steamship Kronprinzessin Cecilie (Appeal of The American Smelting and Refining Company) v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1917] UKPC 30 26 Mar 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Warnaculasuria Pelesia Tamel and Others v Halambe Aratchige Anohamy and Others (Ceylon) [1917] UKPC 31 27 Mar 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Dominion of New Zealand v John Vigor Brown and Others (New Zealand) [1917] UKPC 32 27 Mar 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jogi Das Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Ram Sarup) and Another v Ganga Ram and Others (Allahabad) [1917] UKPC 33 17 Apr 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kawal Nain and Others v Budh Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1917] UKPC 34 24 Apr 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jadu Nath Singh and Another v Thakur Sita Ramji and Another (Oudh) [1917] UKPC 35 24 Apr 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Rameshar Bakhsh Singh v Thakurain Raj Kunwar (Oudh) [1917] UKPC 37 26 Apr 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lachhman Prasad Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Narain Prasad) and Others v Sarnam Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1917] UKPC 36 26 Apr 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Municipal Corporation of The Township of Cornwall v The Ottawa and New York Railway Company and Others and The Attorney General for The Province of Ontario (Canada) [1917] UKPC 38 1 May 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kandukuri Balasurya Prasadha Row and Another v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Madras) [1917] UKPC 39 3 May 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jones and Others v The Commonwealth Court of Conciliation and Arbitration and Others and The Attorney General for The Commonwealth of Australia and The Attorney General for The State of New South Wales (Australia) [1917] UKPC 40 8 May 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Peirce Leslie and Company v N. Giriah Chettiar (Madras) [1917] UKPC 41 11 May 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sinnetamby Chetty Kadiravel Chetty v Elsie De Livera and Others (Ceylon) [1917] UKPC 42 15 May 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  T. A. Balakrishna Udayar v Vasudeva Aiyar (Madras) [1917] UKPC 44 21 May 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mary Lillian Hira Devi v Kunwar Digbijai Singh (Allahabad) [1917] UKPC 43 21 May 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Steamship Kim William Torrey Baird V. His Majesty'S Proctor General v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1917] UKPC 45 22 May 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chowhuri Shyamananda Das Paharaj Bidyadhar Bhuiya Mahapatra v Ramakanta Das Mahapatra and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1917] UKPC 47 23 May 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gobind Das v Bishambhar Das (Allahabad) [1917] UKPC 46 23 May 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  David Davidson The Public Officer of The Wallaroo and Moonta Mining and Smelting Company v The Commissioner of Taxes [1917] UKPC 49 18 Jun 1917 PC Commonwealth (South Australia) [ Bailii ]  The Australian Alliance Assurance Company v The Attorney General for Queensland and Another (Queensland) [1917] UKPC 48 18 Jun 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ambalavana Pandara Sannadhi Avergal v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Madras) [1917] UKPC 50 20 Jun 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Steamship Consul Corfitzon Per Palen Trading As Nettraby Laderfabrik V. His Majesty'S Proctor General v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1917] UKPC 51 21 Jun 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Khulna Loan Company Limited v Jnanendra Nath Bose (Since Deceased) and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1917] UKPC 53 21 Jun 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  M.A.R.R.M.R.M. Firm v P.K.P.S. Kadersan Chetty and Another (Lower Burma) [1917] UKPC 52 21 Jun 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Abu Mozaffer Khan v Abu Fazel Khan (Fort William (Bengal)) [1917] UKPC 54 22 Jun 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Reginald Ernest De Soysa v The Attorney General for Ceylon (Ceylon) [1917] UKPC 55 26 Jun 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Haradas Acharjya Chowdhuri Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Saroj Kumar Acharjya Chowdhuri) and Others v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Fort William (Bengal)) [1917] UKPC 56 2 Jul 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Steamship Consul Corfitzon The Crew Levick Company V. His Majesty'S Proctor General v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1917] UKPC 57 3 Jul 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maung Thwe v Maung Tun Pe (Deceased By His Legal Representatives) (Lower Burma) [1917] UKPC 58 5 Jul 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Gunjeshwar Kunwar v Durga Prashad Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1917] UKPC 59 6 Jul 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Green and Others v Dumsday and Another; PC 12-Jul-1917 - [1917] UKPC 61  Mensa Akuamankra Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Ohene Kwasi Boahene) v Paul and Another [1917] UKPC 60 12 Jul 1917 PC Commonwealth (Gold Coast Colony) [ Bailii ]  H. H. Brij Indar Singh v Lala Kanshi Ram and Others (Punjab) [1917] UKPC 62 19 Jul 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rajkumar Thakur Giridhari Singh Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Thakur Ran Bahadur Singh) v Megh Lal Pandey Since Deceased and Others (Fort William (Bengal) [1917] UKPC 63 19 Jul 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Sailing Ship Sorfareren Aktiebolaget Ferrolegeringar V. His Majesty'S Proctor-General v The High Court of Justice (England) Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1917] UKPC 64 20 Jul 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Sailing Ship The Chrome Company Limited V. His Majesty'S Proctor-General v The High Court of Justice (England) Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1917] UKPC 65 20 Jul 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Deputy Commissioner of Kheri for Mahewa Estate v Rani Bijai Raj Koer (Oudh) [1917] UKPC 66 24 Jul 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maung Kyin Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Maung Kyaw) and Another v Ma Shwe La Since Deceased and Others (Lower Burma) [1917] UKPC 67 26 Jul 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Fidelity and Casualty Insurance Company of New York v Frederick W. Mitchell [1917] UKPC 68 27 Jul 1917 PC Commonwealth Ontario [ Bailii ]  Abdullah Ashgar Ali Khan v Ganesh Dass (Baluchistan) [1917] UKPC 70 30 Jul 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Vancouver Power Company Limited v The Corporation of The District of North Vancouver (British Columbia) [1917] UKPC 69 30 Jul 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commissioner of Stamps V. The Australian Stock Breeders Company Limited (Queensland) [1917] UKPC 73 3 Aug 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Canadian Northern Pacific Railway Company v The Corporation of The City of New Westminster [1917] UKPC 75 3 Aug 1917 PC Commonwealth (British Columbia) [ Bailii ]  The Commissioner of Stamps V. The Queensland Meat Export Company Limited (Queensland) [1917] UKPC 72 3 Aug 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pacific Coast Coal Mines Limited and Others v John Arbuthnot and Others (British Columbia) [1917] UKPC 76 3 Aug 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Sri Sri Radha Krishna Chanderji v Ram Bahadur and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1917] UKPC 74 3 Aug 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Toronto Railway Company v The King and Others (Ontario) [1917] UKPC 77 3 Aug 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Ex Steamship Sudmark The Hamburg-Amerika Line V. His Majesty'S Proctor In Egypt v Egypt [1917] UKPC 71 3 Aug 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rai Bhaiya Dirgaj Deo Bahadur Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Bhaiya Raj Kishore Deo) v Beni Mahto and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1917] UKPC 79 16 Oct 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Ex Steamship Hakan Augf Aktiebolaget Kepler V. His Majesty'S Proctor v The High Court of Justice (England) Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1917] UKPC 80 16 Oct 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Birj Kumari Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Pokermull Khijriwalla and Another) v Chiman Bux Bhowsinga (Fort William (Bengal)) [1917] UKPC 78 16 Oct 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Westholme Lumber Company Limited v The Corporation of The City of Victoria and Others (British Columbia) [1917] UKPC 81 16 Oct 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Saudagar Singh v Pardip Narayan Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1917] UKPC 82 19 Oct 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Swami Prasad and Another v Bhagwan Das and Others [1917] UKPC 83 22 Oct 1917 PC Commonwealth (Allahabad) [ Bailii ]  Duport and Jones v Grieve and Company (Egypt) [1917] UKPC 85 23 Oct 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Sethuramaswamiar and Others v Sri Meruswamiar Since Deceased and Others (Madras) [1917] UKPC 84 23 Oct 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maung Po Naing v Ma On Gaing (Upper Burma) [1917] UKPC 86 26 Oct 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Braja Sundar Deb v Srimati Swarna Manjari Dei (Fort William (Bengal)) [1917] UKPC 88 29 Oct 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Anant Ram Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Lachmi Narain and Others) and Others) v The Collector of Etah and Others (Allahabad) [1917] UKPC 87 29 Oct 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  H. H. Mir Abdul Hussein Khan v Musammat Bibi Sona Dero and Another (Sind) [1917] UKPC 89 30 Oct 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Krishnasami Panikondar Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Suppammal) v S. R. M. A. R. Ramasami Chettiar Since Deceased and Others (Madras) [1917] UKPC 91 8 Nov 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Sakinda Bai and Others v Kaniz Fatima Begam (Allahabad) [1917] UKPC 92 12 Nov 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Cargo Ex Ship Remonstrant Justus Scharff Limited and Others V. The Proper Officer of The Crown v The Supreme Court of New South Wales Admiralty Jurisdiction (In Prize) [1917] UKPC 93 20 Nov 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Armrit Narayan Singh v Gaya Singh Since Deceased and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1917] UKPC 95 22 Nov 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Steamship Baron Stjernblad Aktiebolaget Forende Chokladfabrikerne V. His Majesty'S Proctor-General v The High Court of Justice (England) Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1917] UKPC 94 22 Nov 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bhagwandas Parasram (A Firm) v Burjorji Ruttonji Bomanji Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Dulichand Shivlal) [1917] UKPC 97 26 Nov 1917 PC Commonwealth (Bombay) [ Bailii ]  Metharam Ramrakhiomal and Others Appeal No. 120 of 1915) v Rewachand Ramrakhiomal and Others (Sind) [1917] UKPC 96 26 Nov 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Tarini Charan Sarkar and Others v Bishun Chand and Others [1917] UKPC 98 26 Nov 1917 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Imperial Tobacco Company (Newfoundland) Limited v Michael A. Duffy (Newfoundland) [1917] UKPC 99 4 Dec 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Steamship Hillerod Brix-Hansen and Co. and Another V. His Majesty'S Proctor-General v The High Court of Justice (England) Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1917] UKPC 100 11 Dec 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Steamship Anglo Mexican His Majesty'S Proctor-General V. Mayer v The High Court of Justice (England) Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1917] UKPC 101 13 Dec 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rehmat-Un-Nissa Begam and Others v Price Since Deceased and Others (Bombay) [1917] UKPC 103 13 Dec 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Steamship Lutzow The American Trading Company V. His Majesty'S Proctor-General In Egypt v His Britannic Majesty'S Court Egypt Admiralty Jurisdiction (In Prize) [1917] UKPC 102 13 Dec 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Radhakant Lal and Others v Musammat Nazama Begam and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1917] UKPC 104 14 Dec 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  C. Ganapathy Mudaliar v N. Krishnamachariar and Others (Madras) [1917] UKPC 105 14 Dec 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Fung Ping Shan and Another v Tong Shun (Hong Kong) [1917] UKPC 107 17 Dec 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Irshad Ali and Others v Musammat Kariman and Others (Oudh) [1917] UKPC 106 17 Dec 1917 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dwarkanath Raimohan Chaudhuri and Another v The Rivers Steam Navigation Company Limited [1917] UKPC 108 18 Dec 1917 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]   Schetky v Cochrane and the Union Funding Co; 1918 - [1918] 1 WWR 821  In The Matter of Steamship Alwina Her Majesty'S Procurator General V. Holland Gulf Stoomvart Maatschappij v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1918] UKPC 1 22 Jan 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hardit Singh and Others v Gurmukh Singh and Others (Punjab) [1918] UKPC 2 29 Jan 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Canada National Fire Insurance Company v Hutchings and Another (Manitoba) [1918] UKPC 3 31 Jan 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Ship Germania and Others Carl Jepsen (Master) and Jaluit Gesellschaft of Hamburg (Owners) and Others V. Holland Gulf Stoomvart Maatschappij v The Supreme Court of New South Wales Admiralty (In Prize) [1918] UKPC 4 31 Jan 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rai Ganga Pershad Singh Bahadur Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Mahamaha Pershad Singh and Others) v Ishri Pershad Singh Since Deceased, and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1918] UKPC 6 1 Feb 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Steamship Louisiana and Others The Baltimore Pearl Hominy Company and Another Her Majesty'S Procurator General v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1918] UKPC 5 1 Feb 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Charles Conrad Stollmeyer v The Petroleum Development Company Limited (Trinidad and Tobago) [1918] UKPC 7 4 Feb 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Charles Fourier Stollmeyer and Others v The Trinidad Lake Petroleum Company Limited and Others (Trinidad and Tobago) [1918] UKPC 8 4 Feb 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Steamship Prinz Adalber and Another Hamburg-Amerika Line Her Majesty'S Procurator General v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1918] UKPC 9 4 Feb 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Das v Roy (Bengal) [1918] UKPC 11 7 Feb 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dakas Khan and Others v Ghulam Kasim Khan and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner of The North-West Frontier Province India) [1918] UKPC 10 7 Feb 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  John and Others v Dodwell and Co. Limited (Ceylon) [1918] UKPC 12 11 Feb 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Fowler v The English Scottish and Australian Bank Limited [1918] UKPC 13 12 Feb 1918 PC Commonwealth New South Wales [ Bailii ]  Jurawan Lal Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Lachman Lal and Another v Baldeo Singh and Another [1918] UKPC 14 22 Feb 1918 PC Commonwealth (Oudh) [ Bailii ]  Thakur Rajindra Bahadur Singh Since Deceased v Rani Raghubans Kunwar Since Deceased [1918] UKPC 15 25 Feb 1918 PC Commonwealth Oudh [ Bailii ]  Imambandi and Others v Sheikh Haji Mutsaddi and Others [1918] UKPC 16 28 Feb 1918 PC Commonwealth (Fort William (Bengal)) [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Damaged Cargo Ex Steamship Sudmark Captain F. D. Gilpin Brown R.N. and Another The Chartered Bank of India, Australia and China and Others v His Britannic Majesty's Supreme Court for Egypt (In Prize) [1918] UKPC 17 1 Mar 1918 PC Commonwealth, Transport [ Bailii ]  Kundan Lal v Musammat Begam-Un-Nisa and Another [1918] UKPC 18 5 Mar 1918 PC Commonwealth (Allahabad) [ Bailii ]  Arthur John Fry Gibbons v The Guernsey Banking Company Limited [1918] UKPC 20 8 Mar 1918 PC Commonwealth (Guernsey) [ Bailii ]  Arthur John Fry Gibbons v Walter Vincent Lenfestey and Another [1918] UKPC 19 8 Mar 1918 PC Commonwealth (Guernsey) [ Bailii ]  The Karachi Port Trust v J. Mackenzie Davidson and Another [1918] UKPC 21 11 Mar 1918 PC Commonwealth (Sind) [ Bailii ]  Abdul Rahim Mahomed Narma and Others v The Municipal Commissioner for The City of Bombay and Others (Bombay) [1918] UKPC 22 14 Mar 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Societo Anonima Il Truciolo v His Majesty'S Procurator In Egypt (His Britannic Majesty'S Supreme Court for Egypt (In Prize)) [1918] UKPC 23 15 Mar 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Yangtsze Insurance Association Limited v Adamjee Lukmanjee (Ceylon) [1918] UKPC 25 15 Mar 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lala Kanhai Lal v Lala Brij Lal and Another (Allahabad) [1918] UKPC 27 15 Mar 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of The Steamship Proton George Kotsovillis (Master) and Michael Kouremetis V. Her Majesty'S Procurator In Egypt v His Britannic Majesty'S Supreme Court for Egypt (In Prize) [1918] UKPC 24 15 Mar 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Het Ram v Shadi Ram Since Deceased and Others (Allahabad) [1918] UKPC 26 15 Mar 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rajkumar Jagannath Prasad Singh v Syed Abdullah and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1918] UKPC 28 18 Mar 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nederlandshe Handel Maatschappij v Maneckjee Pallonjee (Lower Burma) [1918] UKPC 30 21 Mar 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Joyti Prashad Singh Deo Bahadur v Kumad Nath Chatterji and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1918] UKPC 31 21 Mar 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Basudeo Roy and Others v Mahant Jugalkishwar Das and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1918] UKPC 32 21 Mar 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Joseph De Verteuil v The Hon. Samuel William Knaggs Acting Governor and Another (Trinidad and Tobago) [1918] UKPC 29 21 Mar 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rani Parbati Kunwar v The Deputy Commissioner of Kheri and Another (The Court of The Board of Revenue for Provinces of Agra and Oudh) [1918] UKPC 33 16 Apr 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Aziz Khan v Duni Chand and Others (Punjab) [1918] UKPC 34 16 Apr 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lala Kalyan Das and Others v Sheikh Maqbul Ahmad and Others (Allahabad) [1918] UKPC 35 18 Apr 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mewa Singh and Others v Basant Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1918] UKPC 36 18 Apr 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rani Hermanta Kumari Debi and Others v Maharajah Jagadindra Nath Roy Bahadur (Fort William (Bengal)) [1918] UKPC 37 19 Apr 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Minister of Railways Harbours of The Union of South Africa v The Simmer and Jack Proprietary Mines Limited (South Africa) [1918] UKPC 38 23 Apr 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Demerara Turf Club Limited (In Liquidation) v Percy Claude Wight (British Guiana) [1918] UKPC 39 25 Apr 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Sri Sri Madana Mohana Ananga Bheema Deo Kesari Gajapathi v Sri Sri Sri Purushothama Ananga Bheema Deo Since Deceased (Madras) [1918] UKPC 40 26 Apr 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Rajah Rao Venkata Mahipathi Gangadhara Rama Rao Bahadur v Sri Rajah Rao Venkata Kumara Mahipathi Surya Rao Bahadur Garu Rajah of Pittapur (Madras) [1918] UKPC 41 2 May 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lal Sripat Singh v Lal Basant Singh (Oudh) [1918] UKPC 42 2 May 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Narayan Ganesh Ghatate Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Madhorao) v Baliram and Another (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1918] UKPC 43 9 May 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Percy F. Fradd v Brown and Company Limited (Ceylon) [1918] UKPC 44 14 May 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Meghraj and Others v Musammat Bidyabati Koer and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1918] UKPC 45 14 May 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharajah Ranjit Singh Bahadur v Maharaj Bahadur Singh (Fort William (Bengal)) [1918] UKPC 46 30 May 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ram Tahal Naik and Another v Bhagwati Prasad (Allahabad) [1918] UKPC 47 30 May 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chaudhi Risal Singh and Another v Balwant Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1918] UKPC 49 3 Jun 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rajani Kanta Ghose and Another v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Fort William (Bengal)) [1918] UKPC 48 3 Jun 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nafar Chandra Pal Chowdhury v Shukur Sheikh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1918] UKPC 52 4 Jun 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  William Fairchild Marsh and Another v The Honourable Hugh St. Leger [1918] UKPC 50 4 Jun 1918 PC Commonwealth (New Zealand) [ Bailii ]  Permanand Motoomull and Others v The Colombo Hotels Company Limited (Ceylon) [1918] UKPC 53 10 Jun 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Patrick Edgar Watcham v The Attorney General On Behalf of The Government of East Africa Protectorate (Eastern Africa) [1918] UKPC 54 11 Jun 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gaurishankar Balmukund v Chinnumiya and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1918] UKPC 55 13 Jun 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Wickramasinghe Nawaratne Panditta Wasala Abeykoon Ganwila Herat Mudianselage Tikiri Bandara Ellekewala v The Attorney General for Ceylon [1918] UKPC 63 17 Jun 1918 PC Commonwealth (Ceylon) [ Bailii ]  Sheikh Sharfuddin Hossain Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Shamsuddin Hossain and Others) and Another v Samanta Radha Charan Das Since Deceased, and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1918] UKPC 56 18 Jun 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Srimati Bhabatarini Debi Chowdhurani and Others v Dharani Kanta Lahiri Chowdhury and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1918] UKPC 57 20 Jun 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Adusumilli Suryanarayana Since Deceased and Others v Achuta Pothanna and Others (Madras) [1918] UKPC 58 1 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Jagaveera Rama Venkateswara Ettappa Maharaja Iyen Avergal Since Deceased v Alawarasa Asari and Others (Madras) [1918] UKPC 60 2 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Richard Stuart Prieris and Another v Ernest Mark Shattock and Others (Ceylon) [1918] UKPC 59 2 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  James Gibb and Another v The King (Canada) [1918] UKPC 61 4 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lala Balla Mal and Another v Ahad Shah and Another (Punjab) [1918] UKPC 62 5 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kandukuri Veera Basavaraju Pantulu and Others v Kandukuri Balasurya Prasada Rao Pantulu and Another (Madras) [1918] UKPC 64 11 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hip Foong Hong v H. Neotia and Company (China) [1918] UKPC 65 15 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Permanent Trustee Company of New South Wales and Another v Bailia Minia Iankelevna Fels (New South Wales) [1918] UKPC 66 16 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Goswami Banwari Lal v Mahesh and Others (Oudh) [1918] UKPC 68 16 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Harihar Banerji and Others v Ramsashi Roy and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1918] UKPC 67 16 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Aloysia Margaret Muttamma Muttunayagam and Another v Margaret Elizabeth Brito and Another (Ceylon) [1918] UKPC 69 22 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ratanlal Choonilal Panalal v The Municipal Commissioner for The City of Bombay and Others (Bombay) [1918] UKPC 71 26 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Durga Prashad Singh Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Siva Prashad Singh) v Tribeni Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1918] UKPC 74 26 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Durga Prashad Singh Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Siva Prashad Singh) v The Tata Iron and Steel Company Limited (Fort William (Bengal)) [1918] UKPC 72 26 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mohunt Paramanandra Das Goswani Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Mohunt Balabhadra Das) and Others v Kripasindhu Roy and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1918] UKPC 73 26 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jodha Mahto and Another v Dewan Babu Adya Prshad and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1918] UKPC 77 26 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  William Egbert and Others v The Northern Crown Bank (Alberta) [1918] UKPC 70 26 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hakim Maulvi Muhammad Mahbub Ali Khan v Bharat Indu and Others (Allahabad) [1918] UKPC 75 26 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kaikhushru Bezonji Nanabhoy Capadia v Shirinbai Bezonji Capadia and Others (Bombay) [1918] UKPC 76 26 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Special Reference As To The Ownership of The Unalienated Land In Southern Rhodesia (Reasons) v JCPC; PC 29-Jul-1918 - [1918] UKPC 78  The City of Regina and Others v J. Mccarthy (Saskatchewan) [1918] UKPC 79 31 Jul 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Steamship Antilla and Other Steamships Peder Melin and Co. V. Her Majesty'S Procurator General v The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1918] UKPC 82 15 Oct 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shrimant Sunderabai and Another v The Collector of Belgaum and Others (Bombay) [1918] UKPC 81 15 Oct 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  British Columbia Express Company v Grand Trunk Pacific Railway Company (Canada) [1918] UKPC 80 15 Oct 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Canada Foundry Company Limited v Edmonton Portland Cement Company (Alberta) [1918] UKPC 83 16 Oct 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chowdhri Gur Narayan and Others v Sheo Lal Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1918] UKPC 85 17 Oct 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dominion Trust Company (Executor of The Estate of W. R. Arnold Deceased) v New York Life Insurance Company and Others (British Columbia) [1918] UKPC 84 17 Oct 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Madhab Chandra Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Khetra Mohan Bera and Another) v Srimati Rani Sarat Kumari Debi and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1918] UKPC 86 18 Oct 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hayat Khan and Others v Daulat Khan (Baluchistan) [1918] UKPC 87 22 Oct 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chief Ntiaro and Another v Ibok Etok Akpan and Another (Nigeria) [1918] UKPC 88 24 Oct 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Imtiaz-Un-Nisa v Mumtaz Hussain Since Deceased (Allahabad) [1918] UKPC 89 28 Oct 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Firm of Sadasuk Janki Das v Maharaja Sir Kishan Pershad Bahadur and Another (Hyderabad Deccan) [1918] UKPC 92 1 Nov 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Parthasaradhi Appa Rao Savai Aswa Rao Bahadur Zemindar of Sanivarapupet and Others v Raja Bommadevara Satyanarayana Varaprasada Rao Naidu Bahadur Zemindar of South Vallur Minor Under The Court of Wards (Madras) [1918] UKPC 91 1 Nov 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Idris and Others v Jane Skinner and Others (Punjab) [1918] UKPC 90 1 Nov 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Foley Brothers and Others v James A. Mcilwee and Others (British Columbia) [1918] UKPC 93 5 Nov 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Rajeswara Dorai Rajah of Ramnad v V. Sundara Pandiyasami Tevar (Madras) [1918] UKPC 94 7 Nov 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  A. V. Joseph v R. Shew Bux (Lower Burma) [1918] UKPC 95 8 Nov 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Steamship Kronprinzessin Victoria Dahlen and Wahlstedt. V. Her Majesty'S Procurator General v The High Court of Justice (England) Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize) [1918] UKPC 96 13 Nov 1918 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Minister of Justice for The Dominion of Canada v The City of Levis [1918] UKPC 97 25 Nov 1918 PC Commonwealth Quebec [ Bailii ]  Sreemanthu Raja Yerlagadda Mallikharjuna Prasad Nayudu Bahadur Zaminda Garu v Rajulapti Somaya and Others [1918] UKPC 104 3 Dec 1918 PC Commonwealth Madras [ Bailii ]  Sri Sri Maharajah Ram Narayan Singh Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Maharajkumar Lachmi Narayan Singh) v Ram Saran Lal and Others [1918] UKPC 100 3 Dec 1918 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Srimati Rani Kuar Mani Singh Mandhata v H. H. The Hon Nawab Bahadur of Murshidabad [1918] UKPC 103 3 Dec 1918 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Rachappa Subrao Jadhav Desai v Shidappa Venkatrao Jadhav Desai [1918] UKPC 102 3 Dec 1918 PC Commonwealth Bombay [ Bailii ]  William Alexander and Another v Gocul Dass and Another [1918] UKPC 106 3 Dec 1918 PC Commonwealth Madras [ Bailii ]  Musammat Jeuna Bahu Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Hari Krihan Joshi and Others) and Others v Rai Prameshwar Narayan Mahtha Rai Bahadur Since Deceased, and Others [1918] UKPC 99 3 Dec 1918 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Hukumchand Boid Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Juscurn Boid and Another v Pirthchand Lal Chowdhury [1918] UKPC 101 3 Dec 1918 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  John Usher Jones v Ewart Scott Grogan [1918] UKPC 98 3 Dec 1918 PC Commonwealth Eastern Africa [ Bailii ]  Edward Richard Denham and Another v Clan Line Steamers Limited [1918] UKPC 108 13 Dec 1918 PC Commonwealth New South Wales [ Bailii ]  His Majesty's Procurator In Egypt v Deutsche Kohlen Dep T Gesellschaft (His Britannic Majesty's Supreme Court for Egypt (In Prize)) [1918] UKPC 107 13 Dec 1918 PC Transport, Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kali Charan v Abdul Rahman and Others [1918] UKPC 111 13 Dec 1918 PC Commonwealth Allahabad [ Bailii ]  Pratapsing Shivsing and Another v Thakor Shri Agarsinghji Raisinghji [1918] UKPC 110 13 Dec 1918 PC Commonwealth Bombay [ Bailii ]  Rangasami Gounden v Nachiappa Gounden [1918] UKPC 112 16 Dec 1918 PC Commonwealth Madras [ Bailii ]  Belgian Grain and Produce Co Ltd v Cox and Co (France) Ltd [1919] WN 317 1919 Bankes LJ Commonwealth, Costs 1 Citers  Re the Initiative and Referendum Act [1919] AC 935 1919 PC Viscount Ha;dane Constitutional, Commonwealth The Board heard a referral from the Manitoba government to the Court of King’s Bench for a ruling upon the question of whether the Manitoba Legislative Assembly had jurisdiction to enact a referendum act. Mathers CJ had decided that the legislature had such authority. The Court of Appeal overturned that decision. The parties took the matter directly to the Privy Council without going first to the Supreme Court of Canada. Held. The lieutenant Governor had no such power. Viscount Haldane ruled the legislation unconstitutional. The Act, which would permit an initiative voted upon by voters at large to become law if approved by a majority without passage through the legislature and without royal assent, was unconstitutional. A "legislature may not "create and endow with its own capacity a new legislative power not created by the Act to which it owes its own existence" The scheme of the Constitution Act, 1867 was "not to weld the Provinces into one, nor to subordinate Provincial Governments to a central authority, but to establish a central government in which these Provinces should be represented, entrusted with exclusive authority only in affairs in which they had a common interest. Subject to this each Province was to retain its independence and autonomy and to be directly under the Crown as its head." The Board stated (obiter) that while a legislature could delegate legislation to subordinate agencies: "it does not follow that it can create and endow with its own capacity a new legislative power not created by the British North America Act to which it owes it own existence." Viscount Haldane expressed a reservation that the ability to legislate for the government of a territory does not extend to establishing a legislature for a self-governing territory armed with general legislative authority: "No doubt a body, with a power of legislation on the subjects entrusted to it so ample as that enjoyed by a Provincial Legislature in Canada, could, while preserving its own capacity intact, seek the assistance of subordinate agencies, as had been done when in Hodge v. The Queen, the Legislature of Ontario was held entitled to entrust to a Board of Commissioners authority to enact regulations relating to taverns; but it does not follow that it can create and endow with its own capacity a new legislative power not created by the Act to which it owes its own existence. Their Lordships do no more than draw attention to the gravity of the constitutional questions which thus arise."  In The Matter of Steamship Turul Her Majesty'S Procurator General V. The Master and Owners of The Steamship Turul v The High Court of New South Wales Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Jurisdiction (In Prize) [16 January 1919] (The High Court of New [1919] UKPC 1 16 Jan 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargoes Ex Steamships Barenfels and Gutenfels Schroder Smidt and Company V. Her Majesty'S Procurator In Egypt v His Britannic Majesty'S Supreme Court for Egypt (In Prize) [17 January 1919] (His Britannic Majesty'S Supreme Court for E [1919] UKPC 2 17 Jan 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Sri Sri Vikrama Deo Maharajulum Garu Maharaja of Jeypore v Sri Rukmini Pattamahadevi Garu (Madras) [1919] UKPC 3 20 Jan 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Gold Ore Treatment Company of Western Australia Limited (In Liquidation) and Others v The Golden Horseshoe Estates Company Limited (Western Australia) [1919] UKPC 4 20 Jan 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Baikuntha Nath Bera Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Beni Lal Bera) and Others v Chandra Mohan Bera Since Deceased and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1919] UKPC 6 20 Jan 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Golden Horseshoe Estates Company Limited v The Gold Ore Treatment Company of Western Australia Limited (In Liquidation) and Others (Western Australia) [1919] UKPC 5 20 Jan 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The South Australian Brewing Company Limited v Herbert Hill (South Australia) [1919] UKPC 7 21 Jan 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Seth Ghunsham Das and Others v Umapershad and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces India) [1919] UKPC 8 23 Jan 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raghubar Dayal v The Bank of Upper India Limited Lucknow (In Liquidation) (Oudh) [1919] UKPC 9 31 Jan 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mengeltina Allahakoon and Another v Selina Marguerita Abeyesekera and Another (Ceylon) [1919] UKPC 10 6 Feb 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  O. B. Wijeyesekera v Richard Arthur Grindall Festing Assistant Government Agent Kalutara (Ceylon) [1919] UKPC 11 6 Feb 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gannabhattula Venkamma v Gannabhattula Venkataratnamma and Others [1919] UKPC 12 11 Feb 1919 PC Commonwealth (Madras) [ Bailii ]  Musammat Afzal-Un-Nisa (In Substitution for Haji Allah Bakhsh and Others) v Abdul Karim and Others (Punjab) [1919] UKPC 15 18 Feb 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nawab Nazir Begam v Rao Raghunath Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1919] UKPC 13 18 Feb 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Basar Khan and Others v Moulvi Syed Leakat Hossein Since Deceased and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1919] UKPC 14 18 Feb 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raghunath Roy Marwari and Others v Raja Durga Prasad Singh Since Deceased and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1919] UKPC 16 20 Feb 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Steamship Hilding and Others Stollwerck Brothers Incorporated V. Her Majesty'S Procurator General v The High Court of Justice (England) Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Jurisdiction (In Prize) [25 February 1919] (The High Co [1919] UKPC 17 25 Feb 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Raja Setrucherla Ramabhadraraju Bahadur Garu and Others v Sri Sri Sri Vikrama Deo Maharajulum Garu Maharaja of Jeypore (Madras) [1919] UKPC 19 25 Feb 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nalluri Kristna Mma and Another v Kamepalli Venkatasubbayya and Others (Madras) [1919] UKPC 18 25 Feb 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Surendra Nath Roy and Others v Dwarka Nath Chakravarty and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1919] UKPC 21 27 Feb 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Ship Borghild v James D' Entremont and Others (Canada) [1919] UKPC 20 27 Feb 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Hardei v Bhagwan Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1919] UKPC 22 27 Feb 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Damusa and Another v Abdul Samad and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces India) [1919] UKPC 23 27 Feb 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Steamship Rijn (The High Court of Justice (England) Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Jurisdiction (In Prize)) [1919] UKPC 25 3 Mar 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Steamship Prins Der Nederlanden (The High Court of Justice (England) Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Jurisdiction (In Prize)) [1919] UKPC 24 3 Mar 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Harry Mansfield Shelley and Others v The New South Wales Institution for The Deaf and Dumb and Blind and Others (Australia) [1919] UKPC 26 13 Mar 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Upadrashta Venkata Sastrulu v Divi Seetharamudu and Others (Madras) [1919] UKPC 27 17 Mar 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Melbourne Tramway and Omnibus Company Limited v The Tramway Board (Victoria) [1919] UKPC 28 31 Mar 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Peter Awoonor Renner v The Fanti Consolidated Mines Limited and Others (Gold Coast Colony) [1919] UKPC 30 3 Apr 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The British America Elevator Company Limited v The Bank of British North America (Manitoba) [1919] UKPC 29 3 Apr 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Electrical Development Company of Ontario Limited v The Attorney General of Ontario and Others (Ontario) [1919] UKPC 31 7 Apr 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Toronto General Trusts Corporation v The King (Canada) [1919] UKPC 32 11 Apr 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Honourable William Lennon The Secretary for Agriculture and Stock for The State of Queensland v Gibson and Howes Limited (Australia) [1919] UKPC 33 2 May 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Edward Granville Theodore and Another v Laura Duncan and Another (Australia) [1919] UKPC 34 2 May 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Sri Sri Vikrama Deo Maharajulum Garu Maharaja of Jeyporec v Sri Sri Sri Vikrama Deo Garu (Madras) [1919] UKPC 36 12 May 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maung Ba Dun and Another v The Moola Rice Mill Company Limited (Lower Burma) [1919] UKPC 35 12 May 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dalgety and Company Limited v John Guthrie Gray (Australia) [1919] UKPC 37 13 May 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Annie Besant v The Advocate-General of The Government of Madras and Another (Madras) [1919] UKPC 38 13 May 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  S. Paul De Silva and Another v The Korossa (Ceylon) Rubber Company Limited (Ceylon) [1919] UKPC 39 16 May 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Hnit and Others v Maung Po Pu (Upper Burma) [1919] UKPC 41 22 May 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hewadewage Roseline Fernando and Another v Hewadewage Lilian Pedris and Others (Ceylon) [1919] UKPC 40 22 May 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Braja Sundar Deb v Bhola Nath and Another (Allahabad) [1919] UKPC 42 23 May 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Soolema Bee Bee v S. S. A. O. Chetty Firm (Lower Burma) [1919] UKPC 43 23 May 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Madhorao Narayan Ghatate v Gulam Mohiuddin and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces India) [1919] UKPC 45 26 May 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  William Thomas White v The Licensing Court (Australia) [1919] UKPC 44 26 May 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sunitabala Debi v Dhara Sundari Debi Chowdhurani and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1919] UKPC 46 30 May 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Texas Company v The Bombay Banking Company Limited (In Liquidation) and Another (Bombay) [1919] UKPC 47 30 May 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Midnapur Zemindari Company Limited v Uma Charan Mandal and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1919] UKPC 48 3 Jun 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Port Canning and Land Improvement Company Limited v Srimati Katyani Debi (Fort William (Bengal)) [1919] UKPC 49 19 Jun 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  N. Varada Pillai and Another v Jeevarathnammal (Madras) [1919] UKPC 50 20 Jun 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Muhammad Wali Khan v Muhammad Mohi-Ud-Din Khan and Others (Allahabad) [1919] UKPC 51 23 Jun 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chaudhri Satgur Prasad v Lala Raj Kishore Lal and Others (Allahabad) [1919] UKPC 53 26 Jun 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  A.R.R.M.V. Arunachellam Chetty and Others v Venkatachalapathi Guruswamigal (Madras) [1919] UKPC 52 26 Jun 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Angus G. Creelman and Another v The Hudson Bay Insurance Company (British Columbia) [1919] UKPC 54 27 Jun 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Bhagwat Koer and Another v Dhanukhdhari Prasad Singh (Fort William (Bengal)) [1919] UKPC 55 30 Jun 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Balthazar and Son v E. M. Abowath (A Firm) (Lower Burma) [1919] UKPC 57 1 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rani Hemanta Kumari Debi v The Midnapur Zemindari Company Limited (Fort William (Bengal)) [1919] UKPC 56 1 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Sri Sri Jyoti Prasad Singh v Jadu Nath Singh Since Deceased, and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1919] UKPC 61 4 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lachmandas Khandelwal and Another v Raghumull (Fort William (Bengal)) [1919] UKPC 64 8 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Steel Company of Canada Limited v The Dominion Radiator Company Limited (Ontario) [1919] UKPC 65 8 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Steamship Kronprinzessin Cecillie The Vacuum Oil Company of Rochester U.S.A. V. Her Majesty'S Procurator General v The High Court of Justice (England) Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Jurisdiction (In Prize) [8 July 1919] (T [1919] UKPC 63 8 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Canada Pacific Railway Company v David Herman (Saskatchewan) [1919] UKPC 66 10 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  American Surety Company of New York v Calgary Mining Company Limited (Alberta) [1919] UKPC 68 11 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council v Maharaja Sri Maharajah Saheb Meharban Dostan Maharajah Sri Ravu Sir Venkata Swetachalapati Ranga Row Bahadur Garu Maharaja of Bobbili (Madras) [1919] UKPC 67 11 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargo Ex Steamship Santa Catharina The Standard Oil Company of Brazil V. Her Majesty'S Procurator General v The High Court of Justice (England) Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Jurisdiction (In Prize) [14 July 1919] (The High Court o [1919] UKPC 69 14 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  H. Salti and Fits v Her Majesty'S Procurator General (The High Court of Justice (England) Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Jurisdiction (In Prize)) [1919] UKPC 70 15 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hineiti Rirerire Arani v The Public Trustee of New Zealand and Matilda Lindsay and Another (New Zealand) [1919] UKPC 71 22 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Grant Smith and Company and Mcdonnell Limited v The Seattle Construction and Dry Dock Company (British Columbia) [1919] UKPC 72 24 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Amritrao and Others v Munkundrao and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1919] UKPC 74 28 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rao Kishore Singh v Musammat Gahenabai and Another (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1919] UKPC 76 29 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Manna Lal v Karu Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1919] UKPC 78 29 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raj Raghubar Singh and Another v Thakur Jai Indra Bahadur Singh (Oudh) [1919] UKPC 77 29 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of Part Cargoes Ex Steamship Bravo and Other Vessels Her Majesty'S Procurator General V. Catz Brothers v The High Court of Justice (England) Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Jurisdiction (In Prize) [29 July 1919] (The High Court of Justice ( [1919] UKPC 75 29 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The City of Regina and Others v J. Mccarthy (Saskatchewan) [1919] UKPC 79 31 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General for The Dominion of Canada and Others v The Ritchie Contracting and Supply Company Limited and Others (Canada) [1919] UKPC 82 31 Jul 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Governors and Company of Adventurers of England Trading Into Hudson'S Bay v The Council of The Rural Municipality Oi Bratt'S Lake, No 129, and Others (Saskatchewan) [1919] UKPC 85 1 Aug 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Esquimalt and Nanaimo Railway Company v H. W. Treat (British Columbia) [1919] UKPC 83 1 Aug 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  J E Martin v The Council of The Rural Municipality of Snipe Lake No 259 (Saskatchewan) [1919] UKPC 84 1 Aug 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Workmen'S Compensation Board v Canadian Pacific Railway Company (British Columbia) [1919] UKPC 87 5 Aug 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Joseph Edouard Auger and Others v Dame Corinne H. Beaudry and Others (Quebec) [1919] UKPC 86 5 Aug 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Angus Mackenzie and Others v Bing Kee (British Columbia) [1919] UKPC 88 5 Aug 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Esquimalt and Nanaimo Railway Company v The Granby Consolidated Mining Smelting and Power Company Limited (British Columbia) [1919] UKPC 89 5 Aug 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Canadian Pacific Railway Company v Denton Dale Pyne (Manitoba) [1919] UKPC 93 6 Aug 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Corporation of The City of Armstrong v The Canadian Northern Pacific Railway Company [1919] UKPC 91 6 Aug 1919 PC Commonwealth (British Columbia) [ Bailii ]  John Mackay and Company v The Corporation of The City of Toronto (Ontario) [1919] UKPC 94 6 Aug 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Corporation of The City of Vernon v The Canadian Northern Pacific Railway Company [1919] UKPC 92 6 Aug 1919 PC Commonwealth British Columbia [ Bailii ]  The Corporation of The Township of Richmond v Arthur Wellsley Evans and Others (British Columbia) [1919] UKPC 90 6 Aug 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  British Columbia Express Company v Grand Trunk Pacific Railway Company (Canada) [1919] UKPC 80 15 Oct 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shrimant Sunderabai and Another v The Collector of Belgaum and Others (Bombay) [1919] UKPC 81 15 Oct 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Quesnel Fork Gold Mining Company Limited v Robert T. Ward and Others (British Columbia) [1919] UKPC 97 21 Oct 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hakim Shaim Sundar Lal and Others v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Allahabad) [1919] UKPC 95 21 Oct 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Isaie Craig v Dame Arzulie Lamoureux (Canada) [1919] UKPC 96 21 Oct 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Board of Trustees of The Roman Catholic Separate Schools for The City of Ottawa v The Quebec Bank and Others and The Attorney General for The Province of Ontario (Ontario) [1919] UKPC 98 23 Oct 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Esquimalt and Nanaimo Railway Company v Elizabeth Dunlop (British Columbia) [1919] UKPC 100 23 Oct 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Esquimalt and Nanaimo Railway Company v Charles Wilson and Another (British Columbia) [1919] UKPC 99 23 Oct 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Vancouver Lumber Company v The King (Canada) [1919] UKPC 101 23 Oct 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bankim Bithari Maiti v Scrimati Matangini Dasi (Fort William (Bengal)) [1919] UKPC 102 27 Oct 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mahunt Damodar Ramanuj Das v Chemai Tihari (Fort William (Bengal)) [1919] UKPC 104 28 Oct 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Hnit and Others (Substitute Judgment) v Hashim Ebrahim Meter and Another (Upper Burma) [1919] UKPC 103 28 Oct 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  M. Ahamadu Lebbe v Edward Charles Perera [1919] UKPC 105 28 Oct 1919 PC Commonwealth Ceylon [ Bailii ]  Mohunt Bhagwan Ramanuj Das v Ramkrishna Bose and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1919] UKPC 106 31 Oct 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Granpat and Others v Lalamiya and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces India) [1919] UKPC 107 4 Nov 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bindeshri Prasad and Another v Musammat Baisakha Bibi and Others (Allahabad) [1919] UKPC 108 7 Nov 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Demisetti Ramahendrudu Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Demisetti Sattemma) and Others v Demisetti Janakiramanna Since Deceased and Others (Madras) [1919] UKPC 109 14 Nov 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chinamanibhatla Venkata Reddi Pantuku Garu and Another v Her Highness Sri Maharani Sri Sitaba Garu Rani Saheba of Wadhwan (Madras) [1919] UKPC 112 18 Nov 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Haridas Ranchordas and Another v The Mercantile Bank of India Limited (Bombay) [1919] UKPC 111 18 Nov 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Poosathurai v Kannappa Chettiar and Others [1919] UKPC 110; [1919] LR 47 18 Nov 1919 PC Commonwealth, Undue Influence (Madras) 1 Citers [ Bailii ]  Sakinabai v Shirinibai and Others (Bombay) [1919] UKPC 113 21 Nov 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Cheang Thye Phin and Others v Tan Ah Loy Since Deceased (Penang) [1919] UKPC 114 25 Nov 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Scottish Australian Mining Company Limited v New Redhead Estate and Coal Company Limited (New South Wales) [1919] UKPC 115 27 Nov 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Robert Skinner Alias Sardar Mirza and Others v R. H. Skinner and Others (Allahabad) [1919] UKPC 116 28 Nov 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mick Simmons Limited v Thomas Ernest Rofe (New South Wales) [1919] UKPC 117 1 Dec 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Addar Khan and Others v John Mullins (Queensland) [1919] UKPC 118 2 Dec 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kulsambai and Others v Khensabai and Others (Bombay) [1919] UKPC 121 2 Dec 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Radha Kishun v Khurshed Hossein and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1919] UKPC 119 2 Dec 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lala Matru Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Ghansbiam Das and Another) and Others v Musammat Durga Kunwar Since Deceased (Allahabad) [1919] UKPC 120 2 Dec 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rajammal v Srirangathammal and Others (Madras) [1919] UKPC 123 4 Dec 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nawab Bahadur Muhammad Rustam Ali Khan Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Nawab Muhammad Sajjad Ali Khan and Another) and Others v The Municipal Committee of Karnal City [1919] UKPC 122 4 Dec 1919 PC Commonwealth (Punjab) [ Bailii ]  Donald Campbell and Company v Jeshraj Giridhari Lall (Fort William (Bengal)) [1919] UKPC 125 5 Dec 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Canadian Pacific Railway Company (Substituted) v The Steamship Storstad and Others [1919] UKPC 124 5 Dec 1919 PC Commonwealth (Canada) [ Bailii ]  S. D. Krishna Ayyangar v S. V. Nallaperumal Pillia and Others (Madras) [1919] UKPC 128 8 Dec 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  In The Matter of His Majesty'S Submarine Ship E 14 (Prize Bounty) The Commander Officers and Crew of His Majesty'S Submarine E 14 V. Her Majesty'S Procurator General v The High Court of Justice (England) Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Jurisdiction (In P [1919] UKPC 127 8 Dec 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Montreal Tramways Company v Romuo Savignac; PC 8-Dec-1919 - [1919] UKPC 126  The Emerson-Brantingham Implement Company v Charles J. Schofield (Canada) [1919] UKPC 129 9 Dec 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  M. R. Seturatnam Aiyar and Others v Venkatachala Gounden and Others (Madras) [1919] UKPC 131 15 Dec 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The East Indian Railway Company v Major Andrew Torton Kirkwood (Fort William (Bengal)) [1919] UKPC 130 15 Dec 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Toronto Railway Company v The Corporation of The City of Toronto (Ontario) [1919] UKPC 133 18 Dec 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  S. N. Sen and Another v The Bank of Bengal (Lower Burma) [1919] UKPC 134 18 Dec 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Nageshar Bakhsh Singh Appeal No. 88 of 1918) v Musammat Ganesha (Oudh) [1919] UKPC 137 19 Dec 1919 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Marshall's Township Syndicate Limited v Johannesburg Consolidated Investment Company Limited [1919] UKPC 135 19 Dec 1919 PC Commonwealth South Africa [ Bailii ]  Rex v Trupedo (1920) App Div 58 1920 Innes CJ Commonwealth, Criminal Evidence (South Africa) Evidence concerning the activity of a tracker dog was not admissible. Innes CJ said: "We have no scientific or accurate knowledge as to the faculty by which dogs of certain breeds are said to be able to follow the scent of one human being, rejecting the scent of all others . . there is too much uncertainty as to the constancy of his behaviour and as to the extent of the factor of error involved to justify us in drawing legal inferences therefrom." 1 Citers  Commissioners of State Savings Bank v Permewan, Wright and Co 19 CLR 457 1920 Isaacs J Commonwealth, Banking (Year?) (High Court of Australia) The court considered the nature of negligence in a banker: "the test of negligence is whether the transaction of paying in any given cheque [coupled with the circumstances antecedent and present] was so out of the ordinary course that it ought to have aroused doubts in the bankers' mind, and caused them to make inquiry." 1 Citers  Commissioners of Taxation v English, Scottish and Australian Bank Limited [1920] AC 683 2 Jan 1920 PC Lord Dunedin Commonwealth, Banking, Professional Negligence The Board considered what would amount to negligence in a bank. Held: The test in Permewan was to be applied by "the standard to be derived from the ordinary practice of bankers, not individuals." A customer of the bank is a person who has a more permanent relationship with the bank, for instance, having an existing account with the bank. Habit or continued dealings will not make a party a customer unless there is an account in his name. Thus a person who had opened an account on the day before paying in a cheque was a customer of the bank within the meaning of s 88(1) of the 1909 Act: "The contrast is not between an habitue and a newcomer, but between a person for whom the bank performs a casual service, such as, for instance, cashing a cheque for a person introduced by one of their customers, and a person who has an account of his own at the bank." A negligence in collection is not a question of negligence in opening an account, though the circumstances connected with the opening of an account may shed light on the question whether there was negligence in collecting a cheque. Bills of Exchange Act 1909 88(1) 1 Cites 1 Citers  Toronto Railway Company v The Corporation of The City of Toronto [1920] UKPC 2 20 Jan 1920 PC Commonwealth (Ontario) [ Bailii ]  Toronto Railway Company v The Corporation of The City of Toronto (Ontario) [1920] UKPC 1 20 Jan 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Syed Amatul Fatema Bibi Since Deceased (Now Represented By Syed Abdul Hafiz and Others) v Dewan Abdul Alim Saheb and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1920] UKPC 4 20 Jan 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Girdhas Das Since Deceased (Now Represented By Brij Mohan Das) v Raja Sri Kristna Datt Dube and Others (Allahabad) [1920] UKPC 3 20 Jan 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Eleanor Tarbutt and Others v Alfred Nicholson and Another (New Zealand) [1920] UKPC 5 6 Feb 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Union Steamship Company of New Zealand v Mary Kathleen Brown Robin (New Zealand) [1920] UKPC 6 12 Feb 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rajkumar Babu Bishun Prakash Narayan Singh v Manharani Janki Koer and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1920] UKPC 7 13 Feb 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Li Hong Mi v The Attorney General of Hong Kong and Others (Hong Kong) [1920] UKPC 10 17 Feb 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commissioners of Taxation v The English Scottish and Australian Bank Limited (New South Wales) [1920] UKPC 9 17 Feb 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Quebec Railway Light Heat and Power Company Limited v G. A. Vandry and Others (Canada) [1920] UKPC 8 17 Feb 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Firm of Ramchand Manjimal v Firm of Goverdhandas Vishindas Ratanchand (Sind) [1920] UKPC 13 17 Feb 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lal Jagdish Bahadur Singh v Mahabir Prasad Singh (Oudh) [1920] UKPC 12 17 Feb 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ramathai Vadivelu Mudaliar v Peria Manicka Mudaliar and Others (Madras) [1920] UKPC 15 20 Feb 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bugga and Others v The King-Emperor (Lahore) [1920] UKPC 14 20 Feb 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  George A. Moore and Company (Incorporated) v Henry Marks and Company Limited [1920] UKPC 39 26 Feb 1920 PC Commonwealth (Fiji) [ Bailii ]  The Kin Tye Loong v John Hennessey Seth and Others (Hong Kong) [1920] UKPC 19 3 Mar 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   The Montreal Tramways Company v Peter Mcallister; PC 3-Mar-1920 - [1920] UKPC 16  Michael Tzinki and Others v The Government of Cyprus (Cyprus) [1920] UKPC 17 3 Mar 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  B. L. Rai and Others v Bhaiyalal and Another (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1920] UKPC 20 3 Mar 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  A. R.A R. S. M. Somasunderam Chetty v R. M. A. R. A. R. R. M. Arunasalam Chetty and Another [1920] UKPC 18 3 Mar 1920 PC Commonwealth Ceylon [ Bailii ]  Thomas William Mccawley v The King (Australia) [1920] UKPC 22 8 Mar 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Baldeo v Kanhaiyalal and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1920] UKPC 23 12 Mar 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Adusumilli Kristnayya and Another v Adusumilli Lakshmipathi and Others (Madras) [1920] UKPC 25 18 Mar 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lala Ganpat Lal Since Deceased (Now Represented By Jagarnath Prasad and Another) v Bindbasini Prasad Narayan Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1920] UKPC 24 18 Mar 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rederiakatiebolaget Navigator v Edmund L Newcombe KC CMG The Proper Officer of The Crown (The Exchequer Court of Canada Nova Scotia Admiralty District (In Prize) [1920] UKPC 26 18 Mar 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Ship Imo v La Compagnie Generale Transatlanique (Canada) [1920] UKPC 27 22 Mar 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Berg and Hallgreen and Others v His Majesty's Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1920] UKPC 31 23 Mar 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sunderlal and Others v Ranjilal and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1920] UKPC 28 23 Mar 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hermanos Ramis and Others v His Majesty'S Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1920] UKPC 29 23 Mar 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hermanos Ramis and Others v His Majesty's Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1920] UKPC 30 23 Mar 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  David Augustus Taylor and Another v Kate Straw and Another (Nigeria) [1920] UKPC 32 25 Mar 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Vermet and Fuchs v His Majesty'S Procurator General [1920] UKPC 33 19 Apr 1920 PC Commonwealth (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [ Bailii ]  Raja Sir Mohammad Ali Mohammad Khan Bahadur v Qazi Ramzan Ali and Others [1920] UKPC 34 20 Apr 1920 PC Commonwealth (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Oudh) [ Bailii ]  The Official Trustee of Madras v A. Sundaramurthi Mudaliar and Another (Mysore) [1920] UKPC 35 20 Apr 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  R. M. M. C. T. Vyravan Chetti and Another v V. K. N. S.P. Subramanian Chetti and Another (Madras) [1920] UKPC 38 26 Apr 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Sri Sri Ramachandra Deo Garu Rajah Kallikota and Attagada Estates v Chaitana Sahu Since Deceased and Others (Madras) [1920] UKPC 37 26 Apr 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gnanendra Nath Das and Another v Surendra Nath Das and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1920] UKPC 36 26 Apr 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ambalavana Pandara Sannidhi Avergal v Sri Meenakshi Sundareswaral Devastanam of Madura and Others (Madras) [1920] UKPC 40 27 Apr 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Toolsidas Tejpal v M. P. Venkatachalapathy Aiyar and Another (Madras) [1920] UKPC 43 3 May 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commercial Cable Company v The Attorney General of Newfoundland (Newfoundland) [1920] UKPC 42 4 May 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  His Majesty's Procurator General v Olivarius and Christensen and The Thames and Mersey Marine Insurance Company Limited (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1920] UKPC 44 4 May 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  His Majesty's Procurator General v Wiegman's Bank American Express Company Zimmerman and Forshay Louis Korijn and Company and Kalker and Polack (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1920] UKPC 45 4 May 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sitabai and Another v Bapu Anna Patil and Another (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1920] UKPC 46 7 May 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commonwealth of Australia and Another v Alexander Gabriel Zachariassen and Another (Australia) [1920] UKPC 50 14 May 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commonwealth of Australia and Another v Zachariassen and Another [1920] UKPC 51 14 May 1920 PC Commonwealth (Australia) [ Bailii ]  The J. K. Armsby Company v His Majesty'S Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1920] UKPC 47 14 May 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bharat Indu and Others v Hakim Mohammad Hamid Ali Khan and Others (Allahabad) [1920] UKPC 49 14 May 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Trinidad Shipping and Trading Company Limited v Geo. E. Alston and Company (Trinidad and Tobago) [1920] UKPC 48 14 May 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Walter Benjamin Rajapakse v James Peter Fernando (Ceylon) [1920] UKPC 52 14 May 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nataraja Tambiran v Kailasam Pillia (Madras) [1920] UKPC 53 7 Jun 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Tirugnanapal v Ponnammai Nadathi and Others (Madras) [1920] UKPC 56 8 Jun 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mirza Yadalli Beg v Tukaram and Another (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1920] UKPC 55 8 Jun 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rani Indar Kuar v Thakur Baldeo Bakhsh Singh (Oudh) [1920] UKPC 54 8 Jun 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Kamla Lachhmi v Mahant Basdeo Prasad and Another (Oudh) [1920] UKPC 57 15 Jun 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nawab Bahadur Muhammad Rustam Ali Khan Since Deceased and Another v Nawab Maulvi Mushtag Husain Since Deceased and Others (North-West Frontier Province Allahabad) [1920] UKPC 58 18 Jun 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  A/B Alfred Nilsson v His Majesty'S Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1920] UKPC 59 22 Jun 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chowdhury Sureshwar Misser and Another v Musammat Maheshrani Misrain and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1920] UKPC 61 24 Jun 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Balwant Rao and Others v Baji Rao and Others (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1920] UKPC 60 24 Jun 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The City of Montreal v Elephege Dufresne (Quebec) [1920] UKPC 62 25 Jun 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Tilakdhari Lal and Another v Khedan Lal and Others [1920] UKPC 63 2 Jul 1920 PC Commonwealth (Fort William (Bengal)) [ Bailii ]  The Standard Oil Company of New York v T and M Winter [1920] UKPC 64 2 Jul 1920 PC Commonwealth (Newfoundland) [ Bailii ]  Charan Das and Others v Amir Khan and Others [1920] UKPC 65 6 Jul 1920 PC Commonwealth (North-West Frontier Province (Preshawar)) [ Bailii ]  Srimati Giribala Dasi v Kalidas Bhanja and Others [1920] UKPC 66 8 Jul 1920 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Sheokuarbai v Jeoraj [1920] UKPC 67 9 Jul 1920 PC Commonwealth (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [ Bailii ]  The City of Quebec v Ludger Bastien [1920] UKPC 69 15 Jul 1920 PC Commonwealth (Quebec) [ Bailii ]  The West India Electric Company Limited v Alan D Roberts [1920] UKPC 71 16 Jul 1920 PC Commonwealth (Jamaica) [ Bailii ]  W Krishnamachariar and Another v A Sankara Sah (Madras) [1920] UKPC 72 19 Jul 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mati Lal Das v The Eastern Mortgage and Agency Company Limited and Others [1920] UKPC 73 20 Jul 1920 PC Commonwealth (Fort William (Bengal)) [ Bailii ]  Joseph Paquet and Another v The Corporation of Pilots for and Below The Harbour of Quebec [1920] UKPC 74 22 Jul 1920 PC Commonwealth (Montreal) [ Bailii ]  The American Transatlantic Company v His Majesty'S Procurator General [1920] UKPC 75 23 Jul 1920 PC Commonwealth (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [ Bailii ]  Sture Bojsen v His Majesty's Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1920] UKPC 76 23 Jul 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Waldemar Eckell (on Behalf of The Norwegian Government) v His Majesty'S Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1920] UKPC 77 29 Jul 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The King v Paul A. Paulson and Others (Canada) [1920] UKPC 78 2 Aug 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Frederick James Rupert Kerwick v Kathleen Maud Kerwick (Lower Burma) [1920] UKPC 79 3 Aug 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hussonally Sullemanji v Tribhowandas Mangaldas Nathubhai and Others (Bombay) [1920] UKPC 82 5 Aug 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Frederick Lampson v The City of Quebec (Canada) [1920] UKPC 80 5 Aug 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The City of Montreal v La Corporation Du College Sainte Marie O Montreal [1920] UKPC 81 5 Aug 1920 PC Commonwealth (Quebec) [ Bailii ]  Curtis's and Harvey (Canada), Limited, In Liquidation, and Another v The North British and Mercantile Insurance Company, Limited [1920] UKPC 85 19 Oct 1920 PC Commonwealth (Quebec) [ Bailii ]  Scrutton Sons and Company v The Attorney General for Trinidad (Trinidad and Tobago) [1920] UKPC 86 19 Oct 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Curtis'S and Harvey (Canada) Limited In Liquidation and Another` v The North British and Mercantile Insurance Company Limited and Another (Quebec) [1920] UKPC 84 19 Oct 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Les Prusident Et Syndics De La Commune De Laprairie De La Magdeleine v La Compagnie De Jusus (Quebec) [1920] UKPC 83 19 Oct 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The National Bank of Australasia Limited v Paul Hamilton Morris Joseph Since Deceased and Others (Australia) [1920] UKPC 87 26 Oct 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Charles Edward Arnold Dias v The Attorney General of Ceylon (Ceylon) [1920] UKPC 88 26 Oct 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Casciaro Brothers v The Attorney General for Gibraltar (Gibraltar) [1920] UKPC 89 28 Oct 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Dwijendra Narayan Roy v Jogesh Chandra Dey and Another; PC 10-Nov-1920 - [1920] UKPC 90  Raja Anand Rao v Ramdas Dadurum and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1920] UKPC 91 12 Nov 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaj Bahadur Singh v A. H. Forbes (Patna) [1920] UKPC 92 15 Nov 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaja Sir Rameshavar Singh Bahadur v Homeshvar Singh (Patna) [1920] UKPC 93 16 Nov 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Alexander Gerrard v Martin L. Crowe and Another (New Zealand) [1920] UKPC 94 16 Nov 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Daw Bwa and Others v U. Ba Thaw and Others (Lower Burma) [1920] UKPC 95 18 Nov 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney U General for The Province of Quebec and Others v The Attorney U General for The Dominion of Canada and Another (Quebec) [1920] UKPC 96 23 Nov 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Indian Immigration Trust Board of Natal v Vencategin Govindasamy Trading As The Stamford Hill Laundry (South Africa) [1920] UKPC 97 25 Nov 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Waldemar Eckell (on Behalf of The Norwegian Government and Redereaktiebolget) v His Majesty's Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1920] UKPC 99 30 Nov 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney U General for The Dominion of Canada v The Attorney U General for The Province of Quebec and Others (Quebec) [1920] UKPC 98 30 Nov 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Radhakrishna Ayyar and Another v Swaminatha Ayyar (Madras) [1920] UKPC 100 3 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  His Majesty's Procurator General v Ballins Sonner and Company (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1920] UKPC 105 7 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Midnapur Zamindari Company Limited v Kumar Naresh Narayan Roy (Fort William (Bengal)) [1920] UKPC 102 7 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Polak Van Steenwijks Handels Maatschappij v His Majesty's Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1920] UKPC 104 7 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Seth Manikal Mansukhbai v Raja Bijoy Singh Dudhoria and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1920] UKPC 101 7 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Rajah Malraju Lakshmi Venkayyamma Row Bahadur Zamindarini Garu v Sri Rajah Venkatadri Appa Row Bahadur Zamindarini Garu and Others (Madras) [1920] UKPC 103 7 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kali Nath Roy v The King-Emperor (Lahore) [1920] UKPC 107 9 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sayyapureddi Chinnayya Dhora and Others v The King-Emperor (Madras) [1920] UKPC 106 9 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pokhar Singh Since Deceased (Now Represented By Musammat Premdai Koer and Another) and Others v Jagu Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1920] UKPC 108 9 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaj Bahadur Singh v Balchand Chowdury (Substituted for Puran Chand) and Others (Patna) [1920] UKPC 110 10 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaj Bahadur Singh v Balchand Chowdury (Substituted for Puran Chand) and Others (Patna) [1920] UKPC 111 10 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Pacific Coast Coal Mines Limited and Others v John Arbuthot and Others (British Columbia) [1920] UKPC 109 10 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Rajeswara Sethupati Avergal Raja of Ramnad v Velusami Tevar and Others (Madras) [1920] UKPC 113 13 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nakimo Dewani and Others v Musammat Pemba Dichen and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1920] UKPC 114 13 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Khetramoni Dasi Since Deceased (Now Represented By Dunia Chand Baral and Another) v Jiban Krishna Kundu and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1920] UKPC 112 13 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  His Majesty's Procurator General and Others v P. A. Van Es and Company and Others (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1920] UKPC 115 13 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Ship Marlborough Hill v Alex Cowan and Sons Limited and Others (New South Wales) [1920] UKPC 116 16 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Meredith Rowntree v J. and L. M. Ward (Ontario) [1920] UKPC 117 16 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Wazir Sundra Singh v Musammat Farida Khanam and Others (Punjab) [1920] UKPC 118 16 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council v Srinivasa Chariar and Others (Madras) [1920] UKPC 119 16 Dec 1920 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Albert v Hoffnung and Co Ltd (1921) 22 SR (NSW) 75 1921 Harvey J Intellectual Property, Commonwealth (Court of Appeal of New South Wales) 'Knowledge' means . . notice of facts such as would suggest to a reasonable man that a breach of copyright law was being committed." 1 Citers  Gokal Chand v Hukam Chand-Nath Mal (1921) LR 48 IA 162 1921 PC Commonwealth While training for the ICS, the family member had been supported out of joint family resources it was held that the income earned by him from an appointment in the ICS was property of the joint family. This was a strict interpretation of the Hindu Fruits of learning doctrine. 1 Citers  Bai Shirinbai v Ratanbai and Others (Bombay) [1921] UKPC 1 18 Jan 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Adit Narayan Singh v Mahabir Prasad Tiwari (Patna) [1921] UKPC 2 18 Jan 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Scott Moncrieff Jacobsen v The Jamaica Times Limited (Jamaica) [1921] UKPC 3 18 Jan 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Eric Valeur Pay and Company Brodrene Levy and Korsor Margarine Fabrik v H. M. Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 4 20 Jan 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sabitiri Thakurain v Savi and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1921] UKPC 5 20 Jan 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Rosehaugh Tea and Rubber Company Limited v Abekoon Walauwe Abeyrature Banda Substituted for Hendenia Walauwe Muthu Banda (Ceylon) [1921] UKPC 6 20 Jan 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  AE Hickman Company Limited v G. Jarvis Company [1921] UKPC 7 20 Jan 1921 PC Commonwealth (Newfoundland) [ Bailii ]  Raymond Van Hemelryck v The William Lyall Shipbuilding Company Limited (British Columbia) [1921] UKPC 8 21 Jan 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Sitla Bakhsh Singh v Thakur Sital Singh and Others (Oudh) [1921] UKPC 11 24 Jan 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Amar Nath and Another v The Firm of Hukam Chand-Nathu Mal and Others (Punjab) [1921] UKPC 10 24 Jan 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Fakrunissa Since Deceased (Now Represented By Zahirul Said and Others v Moulvi-Izarus Sadik and Others (Judicial Commissioner for Central Provinces) [1921] UKPC 9 24 Jan 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  H. M. Procurator General v Peter M. Kaae (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 13 25 Jan 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Aktiebolaget Shanska Yllefabriken v H. M. Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 14 25 Jan 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Waldemar Eckell (on Behalf of The Norwegian Government) v HM Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 12 25 Jan 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Shwe Mya v Maung Mo Hnaung (Judicial Commissioner Upper Burma) [1921] UKPC 15 28 Jan 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gulabsingh and Others v Diwan Bahadur Ballabhdas (Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1921] UKPC 16 31 Jan 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Baijnath Prasad Singh and Others v Tej Bali Singh Since Deceased (Allahabad) [1921] UKPC 17 7 Feb 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  George Henry Hook v The Administrator-General of Bengal and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1921] UKPC 18 10 Feb 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  La Socyutu Maritime Francaise v The Shanghai Dock and Engineering Company Limited (Shanghai) [1921] UKPC 19 11 Feb 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Malvina Despatie v Napoluon Tremblay (Quebec) [1921] UKPC 20 11 Feb 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bhaidas Shivdas v Bai Gulab and Another (Bombay) [1921] UKPC 21 11 Feb 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sheik Muhammad Habid Ullah v The Firm of Bird and Company (Allahabad) [1921] UKPC 22 14 Feb 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nickels and Todsen v H. M. Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 23 18 Feb 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  H. M. Procurator General v The New York and West Indies Trading Corporation (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 24 22 Feb 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jens Toft v H. M. Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 25 24 Feb 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Great West Saddlery Company Limited and Others v The King (Canada) [1921] UKPC 27 25 Feb 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dewan Bahadur v Ramabhadra Naidu v Kadiriyasami Naicker (Madras) [1921] UKPC 26 25 Feb 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mathura Prasad Since Deceased (Now Represented By Biswanath Prashad and Others) v Chandra Narayan Chowdhury and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1921] UKPC 28 1 Mar 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  William Eden Thompson v The Honourable Francois Stephanus Malan, Minister of Mines and Industries, and As Such Representing The Government of South Africa (South Africa) [1921] UKPC 29 1 Mar 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pande Har Narain Ram and Another v Musammat Surja Kunwari Since Deceased, and Another (Allahabad) [1921] UKPC 30 1 Mar 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Meka Venkatadri Appa Row Bahadur Zemindar Garu and Others v Raja Parthasarathy Appa Row Bahadur Zemindar Garu (Madras) [1921] UKPC 32 1 Mar 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ghulam Abbas Khan and Another v Musammat Amatul Fatima and Others (Oudh) [1921] UKPC 31 1 Mar 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lakshmidar Mahanti Since Deceased (Now Represented By Kshetrabashi Mahanti) v Ratnakar Mahapatra and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1921] UKPC 33 3 Mar 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Muruga Goundan v The King-Emperor (Madras) [1921] UKPC 36 9 Mar 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rai Bahadur Seth Nemichand Since Deceased (Now Represented By Seth Teekam Chand) v Seth Radha Kishen Since Deceased and Others (Ajmer-Merwara) [1921] UKPC 34 9 Mar 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Syed Habibur Rahman Chowdhury and Another v Syed Altaf Ali Chowdhury and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1921] UKPC 35 9 Mar 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  H. M. Procurator General v Koninklijke West Indische Maildienst (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 38 10 Mar 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  H. M. Procurator General v Sudden and Christenson (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 37 10 Mar 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Mohammad Abul Hasan Khan, Since Deceased (Now Represented By The Deputy- Commissioner of Gonda) v Lachmi Narain and Others (Oudh) [1921] UKPC 44 16 Mar 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rederiaktiebolaget Banco v H. M. Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 42 16 Mar 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Aktiebolaget Frosts Hudaffar v H. M. Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 39 16 Mar 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  H. K. Schrevel's Import and Export Company (on Behalf of Enrique Rubio) v H. M. Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 40 16 Mar 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Malayandi Appayasami Naiker v The Midnapore Zamindari Company Limited [1921] UKPC 43 16 Mar 1921 PC Commonwealth Madras [ Bailii ]  N. V. Chemische Fabriek Kampen v H. M. Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 41 16 Mar 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Peary Mohan Mukerji v Monohar Mukerji and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1921] UKPC 46 19 Apr 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Suki v Munshi Ghulam Safdar Khan and Others (Allahabad) [1921] UKPC 47 19 Apr 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gobinda Chandra Pal (A Lunatic) and Others v Kailash Chandra Pal (Deceased) and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1921] UKPC 45 19 Apr 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musti Venkata Jagannadha Sarma v Musti Veerbhadrayya Since Deceased (Madras) [1921] UKPC 48 21 Apr 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rana Mahatab Singh Deceased (Now Represented By Rana Sheonath Singh) v Badan Singh and Others (Judicial Commissioner for Central Provinces) [1921] UKPC 49 21 Apr 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lim Gaik Teen Neoh v Lim Gaik Kee and Others (Penang) [1921] UKPC 53 28 Apr 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Walter Humphrey James v Richard John Barry (South Africa) [1921] UKPC 51 28 Apr 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lascelles De Mercado and Company Limited v James Charley (Jamaica) [1921] UKPC 52 28 Apr 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Condogianis v The Guardian Assurance Company Limited [1921] UKPC 55; [1921] 2 AC 125 2 May 1921 PC Lord Shaw Commonwealth, Insurance Australia - The insured had filled out a proposal form for fire insurance incorrectly having failed to mention in his answer to a question about a second of two fires for which he had previously claimed. The proposal form contained a declaration stating that the proposal was the "basis of the contract [and] is to be taken as part of the policy and . . the particulars to be deemed express and continuing warranties furnished by" the insured; there was also an express clause about material misdescription and misrepresentation. Held: Lord Shaw said: "The case accordingly is one of express warranty. If in point of fact the answer is untrue, the warranty still holds, notwithstanding that the untruths might have arisen inadvertently and without any kind of fraud. Secondly, the materiality of the untruth is not an issue; the parties having settled themselves-by making the fact the basis of the contract, and giving a warranty-that as between them their agreement on that subject precluded all enquiry into the issue of materiality. In the language of Lord Eldon in Newcastle Fire Insurance Co v Macmorran (1815) 3 Dow 255,262: "It is a first principle in the law of insurance, on all occasions, that where a representation is material it must be complied with-if immaterial, that immateriality may be inquired into and shown; but that if there is a warranty it is part of the contract that the matter is such as it is represented to be. Therefore the materiality or immateriality signifies nothing." This rule has been repeated over and over again and is too well-settled to be questioned . . " 1 Citers [ Bailii ]  Mi Asha and Another v Jogendra Lal Chowdhury (Lower Burma) [1921] UKPC 56 3 May 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Arumilli Perrazu and Others v Arumilli Subbarayadu and Other (Madras) [1921] UKPC 57 5 May 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sitaram Bhaurao Deshmukh Since Deceased (Now Represented By Kashinath Sitaram Deshmukh and Others) and Others v Syed Jiaul Hasan Khan Syed Sirajul Hasan Khan [1921] UKPC 59 9 May 1921 PC Commonwealth Bombay [ Bailii ]  Narindra Bahadur Singh v The Oudh Commercial Bank Limited Fyzabad (Oudh) [1921] UKPC 60 9 May 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Abdul Aziz v Niadar Mal and Others (Punjab) [1921] UKPC 61 9 May 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chandra Kanta Das Since Deceased (Now Represented By Manrindra Nath Das and Others) v Parasullah Mullick (Fort William (Bengal)) [1921] UKPC 58 9 May 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Sri Sri Jagannatha Gajapathi Ananga Bheeme Deo Kesari Maharajungaru v Sri Kunja Behari Deo [1921] UKPC 62 10 May 1921 PC Commonwealth Madras [ Bailii ]  Thiruvenkatasami Iyengar and Another v Pavadai Pillay and Others (Madras) [1921] UKPC 63 26 May 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Western Powell Woods Process Limited v The Crown (Australia) [1921] UKPC 64 30 May 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Amba Alias Padmavathi v Shrinivasa Kamathi (Madras) [1921] UKPC 65 2 Jun 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Yadao v Namdeo (Judicial Commissioner for Central Provinces) [1921] UKPC 66 3 Jun 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bandhu Ram and Others v Chintaman Singh and Others (Patna) [1921] UKPC 68 9 Jun 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Palaniappa Chettiar v Alayan Chetti and Others [1921] UKPC 67 9 Jun 1921 PC Commonwealth Madras [ Bailii ]  The Owners of The Italian Ship Cerea and Others v The Owners of The British Ship Solier Prince and Her Freight (Gibraltar) [1921] UKPC 69 10 Jun 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bipradas Pal Chowdhury Since Deceased (Now Represented By Manmatha Pal Chowdhury and Others v Kamini Kumar Lahiri and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1921] UKPC 70 14 Jun 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gordhandas Kessowji v Chamsey Dossa and Others (Bombay) [1921] UKPC 72 17 Jun 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Australasian United Steam Navigation Company Limited v John Linn Hunt (Fiji) [1921] UKPC 71 17 Jun 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Kamawati v Kunwar Digbijai Singh (Allahabad) [1921] UKPC 74 21 Jun 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kadugoda Aratchige Matinus Perera v Adaicappa Chetty and Others [1921] UKPC 73 21 Jun 1921 PC Commonwealth Ceylon [ Bailii ]  Fernando v Menita, Perera Seneviratne Gunatillaka and Another [1921] UKPC 75 28 Jun 1921 PC Commonwealth Ceylon [ Bailii ]  Dulhin Lachhanbati Kumri and Others v Bodhnath Tiwari Since Deceased and Others (Patna) [1921] UKPC 76 1 Jul 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaja Kesho Prasad Singh v Siv Saran Lal (Patna) [1921] UKPC 77 5 Jul 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Vidya Varuthi Thirtha Swamigal v Balusami Ayyar and Others (Madras) [1921] UKPC 78 5 Jul 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  A. S. Vedachela Mudaliar v K. I. Ranganathan Chettiar Since Deceased and Others (Madras) [1921] UKPC 79 7 Jul 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ramkishore and Others v Jainarayan and Others (Judicial Commissioner for Central Provinces) [1921] UKPC 82 11 Jul 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Amodu Tijani v The Secretary Southern Provinces (Nigeria) [1921] UKPC 80 11 Jul 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Surisetti Butchayya and Another v Sri Rajah Parthasarathy Appa Row Bahadur Zaminda Garu and Another (Madras) [1921] UKPC 81 11 Jul 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Corporation of Calcutta v The Chairman of The Cossipore and Chipore Municipality (Fort William (Bengal)) [1921] UKPC 84 12 Jul 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sachindra Nath Roy and Others v Maharaj Bahadur Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1921] UKPC 85 12 Jul 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  M. Ehtisham Ali for Himself and In Place of M. Sakhawat Ali Since Deceased v Jamna Prasad Since Deceased and Others (Oudh) [1921] UKPC 83 12 Jul 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council v Unde Rajahe Raje Sir Velugoti Sri Rajagopala Krishna Yachendra Bahadur Varu Raja of Venkatagiri Since Deceased (Madras) [1921] UKPC 86 15 Jul 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Krishnan Alias Kuthali Moothavar (Styled Vallabhan Chathan) v Peringati Kunharankutty Haji (Madras) [1921] UKPC 87 18 Jul 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council v Maharajadhiraj Sir Bijoy Chand Mahtab Bahadur Maharaja of Burdwan and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1921] UKPC 88 19 Jul 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Canadian Pacific Wine Company Limited v Charles F. Tuley and Others [1921] UKPC 89 21 Jul 1921 PC Commonwealth (British Columbia) [ Bailii ]  Dame Margaret Bain v The Central Vermont Railway Company and Others (Canada) [1921] UKPC 90 21 Jul 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commonwealth of Australia v Hazeldell Limited (Australia) [1921] UKPC 91 25 Jul 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Omfroy De Beaujeu and Others v Casimir Dessaulles and Others (Quebec) [1921] UKPC 92 29 Jul 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Yait v Maung Chit Maung (Lower Burma) [1921] UKPC 95 1 Aug 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Corporation of The City of Victoria v The Bishop of Vancouver (British Columbia) [1921] UKPC 93 1 Aug 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Matamajaw Salmon Club v Thadee Duchaine Since Deceased (Canada) [1921] UKPC 94 1 Aug 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dame Gertrude M. O'Meara and Another v Dame Constance Edith Bennett and Others (Quebec) [1921] UKPC 96 20 Oct 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  F. G. Stephens and Another v Bertram Gray Allen Since Deceased (Eastern Africa) [1921] UKPC 97 20 Oct 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Khaw Sim Tek and Others v Chuah Hooi Gnoh Neoh (The Supreme Court of The Straits Settlements) [1921] UKPC 98 21 Oct 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Noordeen Hadjiar Abdul Hameed and Another v The Special Officer Appointed Under The Waste Lands Ordinances (Ceylon) [1921] UKPC 100 24 Oct 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kaufmann Brothers v H. M. Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 99 24 Oct 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bhaidas Shivdas v Bai Gulab and Another (Bombay) [1921] UKPC 101 25 Oct 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Royal Trust Company v The Minister of Finance of British Columbia (British Columbia) [1921] UKPC 102 25 Oct 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pandurang Krishanaji v Markandeya Tukaram and Others (Judicial Commissioner for Central Provinces) [1921] UKPC 103 28 Oct 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  K. S. Bonnerji Official Receiver v Sitanath Das and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1921] UKPC 104 1 Nov 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Aktieselskabet Osterjolingen and Others v H. M. Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 105 8 Nov 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of Canada v The Attorney General of Alberta and Others (Canada) [1921] UKPC 107 8 Nov 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  T. R. Venkata Row Alias Ganesha Row Since Deceased (Now Represented By T.V. Narayana Row) v T. V. Tuljaram Row and Others (Madras) [1921] UKPC 106 8 Nov 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Rai Bhagwat Dayal Singh Since Deceased (Now Represented By Rajkumar Barhamdeo Narain Singh) v Ram Rattan Sahu and Others (Patna) [1921] UKPC 108 11 Nov 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nalam Pattabhirama Rao and Others v Mandavilli Narayanamoorthy Since Deceased and Others (Madras) [1921] UKPC 109 17 Nov 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Muhammad Hafiz and Another v Mirza Muhammad Zakariya and Others (Allahabad) [1921] UKPC 111 17 Nov 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Edgar Gout and Another v Jivian Cimitian (Cairo) [1921] UKPC 110 17 Nov 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nabakishore Mandal and Others v Upendrakishore Mandal and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1921] UKPC 114 18 Nov 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Charles Wilson and Others v The Esquimalt and Nanaimo Railway Company (British Columbia) [1921] UKPC 113 18 Nov 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Esquimalt and Nanaimo Railway Company v Elizabeth Dunlop and Others (British Columbia) [1921] UKPC 112 18 Nov 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Egyptian Bonded Warehouses Company Limited v Yeyasu Goshi Kaisha and The Marshal of His Britannic Majesty's Prize Court (His Britannic Majesty'S Supreme Court for Egypt Vice Admiralty Jurisdiction (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 115 22 Nov 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  G. H. Burland and Others v The King (Quebec) [1921] UKPC 116 25 Nov 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dame Margaret Alleyn and Others v Ulric Barthe (Canada) [1921] UKPC 117 25 Nov 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nathu Khan Since Deceased (Now Represented By Bibi Mahbubannessa and Others) and Others v Thakur Burtonath Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1921] UKPC 121 2 Dec 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Sasiman Chowdhurain and Others v Shib Narayan Chowdhury and Others (Patna) [1921] UKPC 118 2 Dec 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jens Toft v H. M. Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 120 2 Dec 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jens Toft v H. M. Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 119 2 Dec 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bawa Magniram Sitaram v Sheth Kasturbhai Manibhai and Another (Bombay) [1921] UKPC 122 5 Dec 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Topken Company v H. M. Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 123 6 Dec 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mohammad Sher Khan v Raja Seth Swami Dayal (Oudh) [1921] UKPC 124 9 Dec 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  J. C. De Witt Viser v H. M. Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 126 13 Dec 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  H. M. Procurator General v The Woermann Linie Actien Gesellscaft (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 125 13 Dec 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  G. Larue and Company v H. M. Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1921] UKPC 127 13 Dec 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Hoysted v Federal Commissioner of Taxation; 16-Dec-1921 - (1921) 29 CLR 537; [1921] HCA 56  The Union Bank of Australia Limited v Eva Mcclintock and Others [1921] UKPC 128 19 Dec 1921 PC Commonwealth New South Wales [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council v Sri Sri Sri Meerja Sri Pusapati Viziarama Gajapathiraju Maharajah Manya Sultan Bahadur Raja of Vizianagaram and Another [1921] UKPC 129 19 Dec 1921 PC Commonwealth Madras [ Bailii ]  The Canada Cement Company Limited v La Ville De Montrual Est (Quebec) [1921] UKPC 130 20 Dec 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sydney S. Forbes v Jean K. Git and Others (Canada) [1921] UKPC 131 20 Dec 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gopal Lal Sett, Since Deceased (Now Represented By Sasendra Chandra Sett and Others v Purna Chandra Basak Since Deceased and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1921] UKPC 132 20 Dec 1921 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Macedo v Stroud [1922] 2 AC 330 1922 PC Commonwealth, Land, Equity, Registered Land (Trinidad) The donor purported to give real property (in part) by memorandum which was not registered. Under the law of Trinidad the transfer did not pass any estate or interest in the land. The donor delivered the instrument to his solicitor telling him to keep the document and not to register it. The document accordingly remained in the solicitor’s custody unregistered until the death of the donor, who during his life continued to receive the rents. The judge found that the instrument was intended to operate as an immediate and unconditional gift to the donee. Held: The memorandum not having been registered nor delivered to the donee for that purpose there was an imperfect gift of the properties with which it dealt to which equity could not give effect: "The memorandum of transfer was never made the subject of registration, nor did the donor present it, or hand it to the transferee, for that purpose. It therefore, having regard to the terms of the ordinance, transferred no estate or interest either at law or in equity. At the most it amounted to an incomplete instrument which was not binding for want of consideration. Had it been in terms a declaration of trust, a Court of equity might have compelled the trustee to carry out the trust, which would have been binding on him, even if voluntary. But it does not purport to be a declaration of trust, or anything else than in inchoate transfer. As such, and as it is voluntary, it is no more than an imperfect gift of which a Court of equity will not compel perfection." 1 Cites 1 Citers  Union Bank of Australia Ltd v McClintock [1922] 1 AC 240 1922 PC Commonwealth, Company Where a partner obtains money by drawing on a partnership bank account without authority, he alone and not the partnership obtains legal title to the money so obtained. 1 Citers  Sanyasi Charan Mandal v Krishnadhan Banerji (Fort William (Bengal)) [1922] UKPC 3 17 Jan 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sabz Ali Khan v Khair Muhammad Khan and Others (Punjab) [1922] UKPC 1 17 Jan 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mahomed Ibrahim Rowther v Shaikh Ibrahim Rowther and Others (Madras) [1922] UKPC 2 17 Jan 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nanku Prasad Singh v Kamta Prasad Singh and Others (Patna) [1922] UKPC 4 19 Jan 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mahanath Jagarnath Das v Janki Singh and Others (Patna) [1922] UKPC 5 20 Jan 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Arab Ali Khan Alias Ashan Ali Khan v Mahmud Ali Khan Alias Agha Ali Khan and Another (Allahabad) [1922] UKPC 6 24 Jan 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of Manitoba v Kelly and Others (Manitoba) [1922] UKPC 7 24 Jan 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  T. B. Ramachandra Rao and Another v A. N. S. Ramachandra Rao and Others (Madras) [1922] UKPC 8 31 Jan 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Panna Lal and Another v Nihal Chand Substituted for Marwar Bank (In Liquidation) (Punjab) [1922] UKPC 9 31 Jan 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ram Narain Since Deceased (Now Represented By Khushi Ram and Another) and Others v Harnam Das Alias Har Narayan and Others (Allahabad) [1922] UKPC 10 7 Feb 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rai Baijnath Goenka Since Deceased (Now Represented By Kedarnath Goenka) v Maharaja Sir Ravaneshwar Prasad Singh (Patna) [1922] UKPC 11 9 Feb 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Danziger Rederei Aktien Gesellschaft and Others v His Majesty'S Procurator General (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1922] UKPC 12 10 Feb 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  His Majesty'S Procurator General v The State of Netherlands (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1922] UKPC 13 13 Feb 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Eileen Louise Nicolle v John Winter Nicolle (Jersey) [1922] UKPC 14 14 Feb 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Neil F. Mackay v The Attorney General of British Columbia and Others (British Columbia) [1922] UKPC 17 14 Feb 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sripat Singh Dugar and Another v Rai Hariram Goenka and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1922] UKPC 15 14 Feb 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Joseph Thornes v William Brown and Another (New Zealand) [1922] UKPC 16 14 Feb 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Foley Brothers and Others v James A. Mciiwee (British Columbia) [1922] UKPC 18 20 Feb 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  H.M. Iles (A Solicitor) v Trinidad and Tobago (Trinidad and Tobago) [1922] UKPC 19 20 Feb 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sheo Darshan Singh Since Deceased (Now Represented By Shamsher Bahadur Singh) and Others v The Deputy Commissioner Partabgarth (Oudh) [1922] UKPC 20 20 Feb 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chhajju Ram v Neki and Others [1922] UKPC 21 27 Feb 1922 PC Commonwealth (Punjab) [ Bailii ]  The Madrassa Anjuman Islamia of Kholwad v The Municipal Council of Johannesburg (South Africa) [1922] UKPC 22 2 Mar 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Khajeh Soleman Quadir and Another v Nawab Sir Salimullar Bahadur Since Deceased and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1922] UKPC 23 2 Mar 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Alarie Joseph Seguin v Anna Theresa Boyle (British Columbia) [1922] UKPC 24 3 Mar 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  K. Ramalinga Annavi and Another v Narayana Annavi and Others (Madras) [1922] UKPC 25 7 Mar 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  L Oppenheim and Company v Hajee Mahomed Sahib Since Deceased (Madras) [1922] UKPC 26 7 Mar 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  K. Gopala Chetty Since Deceased v T. G. Vijayaraghavachariar (Madras) [1922] UKPC 27 9 Mar 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Radhakrishna Ayyar and Another v Sundaraswamier Substituted for Swaminatha Ayyar (Madras) [1922] UKPC 28 14 Mar 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raj Kumar Girwar Pershad Singh and Another v Ramesar Lal Bhagat Alias Dukhan Lal Bhagat (Patna) [1922] UKPC 29 14 Mar 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Khan Bahadur Mohammad Abdul Ghani Khan Since Deceased (Now Represented By Mohammad Ibadul Ghani Khan and Another) and Another v Musammat Fakhr Jahan Begam and Others (Oudh) [1922] UKPC 30 21 Mar 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Puttagunta Seshayya and Others v Gullapalli Lakshminarayana and Others (Madras) [1922] UKPC 31 24 Mar 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaja Sir Manindra Chandra Nandi v Ram Kumar Lal Bhagat and Others (Patna) [1922] UKPC 32 3 Apr 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Syed Kasam Since Deceased (Now Represented By Syed Khane Jama and Others) v Jorawar Singh and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1922] UKPC 33 6 Apr 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  T. P. Srinivasa Chariar, Since Deceased (Now Represented By T. P. Rangachariar and Another v C. N. Evalappa Mudaliar (Madras) [1922] UKPC 34 6 Apr 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The King v Nat Bell Liquors Limited (Alberta) [1922] UKPC 35 7 Apr 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chet Ram and Others v Ram Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1922] UKPC 37 10 Apr 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Banku Behari Dhur v J. C. Galstaun and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1922] UKPC 36 10 Apr 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rani Bijai Raj Kunwar v Thakur Jai Indra Bahadur Singh (Agra and Oudh) [1922] UKPC 38 10 Apr 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Amulya Chandra Banerjea and Others v The Corporation of Calcutta (Fort William (Bengal)) [1922] UKPC 39 10 Apr 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lakkimsetti Basavalingam and Others v Lakkimsetti Paridesayya and Another (Madras) [1922] UKPC 41 27 Apr 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sarju Prasad Missir and Others v Maksudan Chowdhury and Others (Patna) [1922] UKPC 40 27 Apr 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hydro-Electric Power Commission (Ontario) v Albright 1922 CanLII 8 (SCC) 2 May 1922 Idington, Duff, Anglin, Brodeur and Mignault JJ Commonwealth Supreme Court of Canada - Contract - Purchase of shares in company - Mortgage on company property - Security for bonds - Covenant to provide sinking fund - Earnings for calendar year-Payments at fixed date - Payments "accrued but not yet due" 1 Cites [ Canlii ]  A. L. Anderson v Sie Everard Duncan Home Fraser and Another (China) [1922] UKPC 42 4 May 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Badri Narain Singh v Thakurain Harnam Kuar and Others (Oudh) [1922] UKPC 43 12 May 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pramatha Nath Roy v The Hon. William Arthur Lee (Fort William (Bengal)) [1922] UKPC 44 12 May 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Chidambara Sivaprakasa Pandara Sannadhigal v Veerama Reddi Alias Mooka Reedi and Others (Madras) [1922] UKPC 45 15 May 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Narain Das v Abinash Chandar and Another (Allahabad) [1922] UKPC 46 23 May 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shankar Ganesh Dabir (Reasons) v The Secretary of State for India In Council (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1922] UKPC 47 23 May 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Fort Press Company Limited v The Municipal Corporation of The City of Bombay and Another (Bombay) [1922] UKPC 51 25 May 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Damodar Narayan Chaudhury and Others v S. A. Miller and Others (Patna) [1922] UKPC 49 25 May 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dinbai v K. B. Nussereanji Rustomji and Others (Sind) [1922] UKPC 48 25 May 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rai Radha Krishna and Others v Bisheshar Sahay and Others (Patna) [1922] UKPC 50 25 May 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Gleaner Company Limited v The Assessment Committee [1922] UKPC 52 31 May 1922 PC Commonwealth (Jamaica) [ Bailii ]  Medai Dalavoi Thirumalaiyappa Mudaliar v Nainar Tevan and Others (Madras) [1922] UKPC 55 31 May 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ramsumran Prasad and Another v Musammat Shyam Kumari and Others (Patna) [1922] UKPC 53 31 May 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Subbaraya Pillai Since Deceased (Now Represented By Subramania Pillai and Others) and Others v Rajah Kumara Venkata Perumal Raju Bahadur Varu and Others (Madras) [1922] UKPC 54 31 May 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Nova Scotia Steel and Coal Company Limited v The Minister of Finance and Customs (Newfoundland) [1922] UKPC 56 15 Jun 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Palchur Sankarareddi and Others v Palchur Mahalaksmama Since Deceased and Others (Madras) [1922] UKPC 57 16 Jun 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jai Berham and Others v Kedar Nath Marwari and Others (Patna) [1922] UKPC 58 19 Jun 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Sisters of Charity of Rockingham v The King (Canada) [1922] UKPC 59 29 Jun 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ram Gopal Lal v Musammat Aipna Kunwar (Allahabad) [1922] UKPC 61 30 Jun 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kunwar Sardar Singh and Others v Kunj Behari Lal and Others (Allahabad) [1922] UKPC 60 30 Jun 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maurice Day Baldwin v Mary A. M. Baldwin (Quebec) [1922] UKPC 62 4 Jul 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Socrates Atychides v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Bombay) [1922] UKPC 63 5 Jul 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jagdeo Narain Singh and Others v Baldeo Singh and Others (Patna) [1922] UKPC 64 7 Jul 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Data Ram Jani and Others v Musammat Basant Kunwar (Allahabad) [1922] UKPC 66 11 Jul 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rai Bahadur Chhotey Lal v The Collector of Moradabad (Allahabad) [1922] UKPC 65 11 Jul 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  J C A Macedo and Others v Beartrice Stroud [1922] UKPC 67 12 Jul 1922 PC Commonwealth Trinidad and Tobago [ Bailii ]  Bholanath Sen v Balaram Das, Since Deceased and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1922] UKPC 68 14 Jul 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ex-Omanhene Ofori Kuma Ii and Others v Acting Omanhene Yao Boaf Iv (Gold Coast Colony) [1922] UKPC 69 18 Jul 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  E D Sassoon and Company v Ramdutt Ramkissen (Fort William (Bengal)) [1922] UKPC 71 20 Jul 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Yorkshire Insurance Company Limited and Another v Thomas Craine (Australia) [1922] UKPC 70 20 Jul 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Behari Lal-Bulaki Ram v Kundan Lal and Another (Punjab) [1922] UKPC 72 28 Jul 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Shwe Mya v Maung Ho Hnaung (Burma) [1922] UKPC 75 31 Jul 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rajangam Ayyar v Rajangam Ayyar (Madras) [1922] UKPC 74 31 Jul 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Royal Trust Company v The Canadian Pacific Railway Company [1922] UKPC 73 31 Jul 1922 PC Commonwealth (Alberta) [ Bailii ]  The City of Montreal v Watt and Scott Limited (Canada) [1922] UKPC 77 3 Aug 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dame Susannah H. Swan Since Deceased and Others v The Eastern Townships Bank (Quebec) [1922] UKPC 76 3 Aug 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Point Anne Quarries Limited v The Ship M. F. Whalen (Canada) [1922] UKPC 78 23 Oct 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shiba Prashad Singh v Rani Prayag Kumari Debi and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1922] UKPC 80 23 Oct 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Harold Eaton McMillan v The Canadian Northern Railway Company [1922] UKPC 82 24 Oct 1922 PC Commonwealth Saskatchewan [ Bailii ]  The City of Montreal v The Attorney General of Canada (Quebec) [1922] UKPC 83 24 Oct 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Edith May Walpole v The Canadian Northern Railway Company [1922] UKPC 81 24 Oct 1922 PC Commonwealth Saskatchewan [ Bailii ]  Amelia Mccoll v The Canadian Northern Railway Company [1922] UKPC 84 26 Oct 1922 PC Commonwealth Manitoba [ Bailii ]  Brito and Another v Muttunayagam and Others (Ceylon) [1922] UKPC 85 30 Oct 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pirthipal Singh v Ganesh Din Singh and Another (Oudh) [1922] UKPC 86 31 Oct 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Khatubai v Mohomed Haji Abu and Others (Bombay) [1922] UKPC 87 9 Nov 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Khawaja Muhammad Hamid v Mian Mahmud and Others [1922] UKPC 88 9 Nov 1922 PC Commonwealth Punjab [ Bailii ]  The Grand Trunk Railway Company of Canada (Reasons) v The King (Canada) [1922] UKPC 89 10 Nov 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ward and Company Limited v The Commissioner of Taxes (New Zealand) [1922] UKPC 90 16 Nov 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rovsing v The Perpetual Trustee Company Limited and Others [1922] UKPC 91 16 Nov 1922 PC Commonwealth (New South Wales) [ Bailii ]  A. E. Salayjee v Fatima Bi Bi (Lower Burma) [1922] UKPC 92 16 Nov 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nur Mahomed Peerbhoy and Another v Dinshaw Hormasji Motiwalla and Another (Bombay) [1922] UKPC 93 21 Nov 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  P. M. Sadasiva Mudaliar and Others v A. R. Hajee Fakeer Mahomed Sait and Sons (Madras) [1922] UKPC 94 24 Nov 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mahomed Saolaiman v Kumar Birendra Chandra Singh Since Deceased and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1922] UKPC 98 28 Nov 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kishan Narain v Pala Mal and Others (Punjab) [1922] UKPC 97 28 Nov 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakurain Harnath Kuar v Thakur Indar Bahadur Singh (Oudh) [1922] UKPC 96 28 Nov 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  A, Hatrick and Company Limited v The King (New Zealand) [1922] UKPC 95 28 Nov 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chalikani Venkatarayanim Garu and Others v Sree Rajah Vatsavaya Venka Subadrayamma Jagapati Bahadur Garu and Others (Madras) [1922] UKPC 99 30 Nov 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Srimati Saratumari Dasi v Amullyadhan Kundu and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1922] UKPC 100 1 Dec 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sahdeo Narain Deo and Others v Kusum Kumari (Patna) [1922] UKPC 101 4 Dec 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Baikuntha Nath Chattoraj v Prasannamoyi Debya and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1922] UKPC 103 8 Dec 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council v Laxmibai and Another (Bombay) [1922] UKPC 102 8 Dec 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ram Bujhawan Prosad Singh and Another v Nathu Ram and Others (Patna) [1922] UKPC 104 11 Dec 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Merla Venkanna and Another v Merla Agasthiah and Others (Madras) [1922] UKPC 105 11 Dec 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chia Khwee Eng v Chia Poh Choon and Others (Straits Settlements) [1922] UKPC 107 12 Dec 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Engineer Mining Company Limited v James Allen Fraser and Others (British Columbia) [1922] UKPC 106 16 Dec 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Hafizan Bibi v Musammat Suba Bibi and Others (Allahabad) [1922] UKPC 116 20 Dec 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  M. Subramonian and Another v M. L. R. M. Lutchman and Others (Burma) [1922] UKPC 109 20 Dec 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rani Jagadamba Kumari v Thakur Wazir Narain Singh (Patna) [1922] UKPC 108 20 Dec 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hurnandrai Fulchand v Pragdas Budhsen (Bombay) [1922] UKPC 110 20 Dec 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kamulammal Since Deceased (Now Represented By Kattari Nagaya Kmarajendra Ramasami Pandiya Naicker) v T. B. K. Visvanathaswami Naicker Since Deceased and Others (Madras) [1922] UKPC 115 20 Dec 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Harichand Mancharam v Govind Luxman Gokhale Since Deceased (Bombay) [1922] UKPC 114 20 Dec 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Haji Abdur Rahim v Narayan Das Aurora Since Deceased and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1922] UKPC 112 20 Dec 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Foolcooverbai v Rai Saheb Keshrisingh Rajmal (Bombay) [1922] UKPC 111 20 Dec 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bibi Akhtari Begam v Diljan Ali (Patna) [1922] UKPC 113 20 Dec 1922 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Myerson v Smith's Weekly (1923) 24 SR (NSW) 20 1923 Ferguson J Commonwealth, Defamation (New South Wales) The court considered the distinction between fact and comment. Ferguson J said: "To say that a man's conduct was dishonourable is not comment, it is a statement of fact. To say that he did certain specific things and that his conduct was dishonourable is a statement of fact coupled with a comment. " 1 Citers  Rajanikanta Pal and Others v Jagamohan (Fort William (Bengal)) [1923] UKPC 2 23 Jan 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Corporation of The Royal Exchange Assurance (Of London) and Another v The Kingsley Navigation Company Limited (British Columbia) [1923] UKPC 1 23 Jan 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kumar Naresh Narayan Roy v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Fort William (Bengal)) [1923] UKPC 3 23 Jan 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Granby Consolidated Mining Smelting and Power Company Limited v The Attorney General of British Columbia (British Columbia) [1923] UKPC 4 26 Jan 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rai Baijnath Goenka Bahadur Since Deceased (Now Represented By Kedar Nath Goenka v Nanda Kumar Singh and Others (Patna) [1923] UKPC 5 12 Feb 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sim E Bak and Another v Ang Yong Huat (Singapore) [1923] UKPC 8 19 Feb 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Seng Djit Hin v Nagurdas Purshotumdas and Company (Singapore) [1923] UKPC 9 20 Feb 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Banubai Framji Commissariat and Another v Manilal Jugaldas (Bombay) [1923] UKPC 10 23 Feb 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Keshaval Brothers and Company v Diwanchand and Company (Bombay) [1923] UKPC 11 27 Feb 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Henry Snushall v The Chairman Councillors and Inhabitants of The County of Kaikoura (New Zealand) [1923] UKPC 13 1 Mar 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gopi Lal v Lakhpat Rai and Others (Allahabad) [1923] UKPC 12 1 Mar 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sourindra Nath Mittra and Others v Heramba Nath Bandopadhaya and Others (Patna) [1923] UKPC 14 5 Mar 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sudhamani Das and Another v Surat Lal Das and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1923] UKPC 17 6 Mar 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Champsey Bhara and Company v The Jivraj Balloo Spinning and Weaving Company [1923] UKPC 15 6 Mar 1923 PC Commonwealth Bombay [ Bailii ]  Mirza Abid Husain Khan (Substituted for Mirza Sadiq Husain) and Another v Ahmad Husain and Others (Oudh) [1923] UKPC 16 6 Mar 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Tata Iron and Steel Company Limited v The Chief Revenue Authority of Bombay (Bombay) [1923] UKPC 18 12 Mar 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Naba Kumar Das and Others v Rudra Narayan Jana and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1923] UKPC 19 13 Apr 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bishwa Nath Singh v Jugal Kishore and Others (Oudh) [1923] UKPC 21 13 Apr 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ernest Kweku Adisi v Frans Thomas Dove (Gold Coast Colony) [1923] UKPC 20 13 Apr 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Tolomeo Gandolfo v The African Plantations Company and Another (Gold Coast Colony) [1923] UKPC 22 17 Apr 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Baliram Sing and Another v Rai Bahadur Seth Narsingdas Prayagdas Mohta and Another (Wardha Central Provinces) [1923] UKPC 23 17 Apr 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Surapati Roy and Others v Ram Narayan Mukerji and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1923] UKPC 24 19 Apr 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Seth Kanhaya Lal Since Deceased (Now Represented By Seth Hanuman Prasad and Another) v The National Bank of India Limited Delhi (Punjab) [1923] UKPC 25 23 Apr 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kumar Prasanna Deb Raikat v Uddhab Chandra Shaha Since Deceased and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1923] UKPC 26 23 Apr 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Heng Moh and Company v Lim Saw Yean and Others (Lower Burma) [1923] UKPC 28 27 Apr 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Satish Chandra Chatterji Since Deceased (Now Represented By Bon Behari Chatterji and Others) v Kumar Satish Kantha Roy and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1923] UKPC 27 27 Apr 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mirza Mohomed and Another v The Official Assignee (Lower Burma) [1923] UKPC 30 30 Apr 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Choa Eng Wan and Others v Choa Giang Tee (Singapore) [1923] UKPC 29 30 Apr 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Michaud v The City of Montreal [1923] UKPC 31 30 Apr 1923 PC Commonwealth (Quebec) [ Bailii ]  Srimati Jinnatannessa Khatun and Another (Substituted for T.C. Tweedie) v Jogesh Chandra Roy Chowdhury and Others [1923] UKPC 32 30 Apr 1923 PC Commonwealth (Fort William (Bengal)) [ Bailii ]  Sir Charles Ross v The Canadian Bank of Commerce and Others (Ontario) [1923] UKPC 33 1 May 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Montreal Tramways Company v The City of Montreal and Another (Quebec) [1923] UKPC 34 3 May 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Manche Agnege Akue v Manche Kojo Ababio Iv (Gold Coast Colony) [1923] UKPC 35 8 May 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Balagobind Since Deceased (Now Represented By Suraj Dat and Another) and Others v Badri Prasad and Another (Oudh) [1923] UKPC 36 10 May 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Robert Sydney Turton v C. Melhado and Sons (British Honduras) [1923] UKPC 39 15 May 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Jatti v Benwari Lal and Others (Punjab) [1923] UKPC 40 15 May 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Putlibai and Others v Sorabji Naoroji Gamadia and Others (Bombay) [1923] UKPC 42 15 May 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Indrajit Pratap Bahadur Sahi v Amar Singh and Others (Patna) [1923] UKPC 37 15 May 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Demerara Bauxite Company Limited v Louisa Malvina Hubbard and Others (British Guiana) [1923] UKPC 38 15 May 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Mohammad Mumtaz Ali Khan v Mohan Singh and Another (Oudh) [1923] UKPC 41 15 May 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Isubu Lebbe Marikar Hadjiar v Idroos Lebbe Marikar Hadjiar Abdul Hamid (Ceylon) [1923] UKPC 43 1 Jun 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Annada Mohan Roy v Gour Mohan Mullick and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1923] UKPC 44 4 Jun 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Alcock Ashdown and Company Limited v The Chief Revenue Authority of Bombay (Bombay) [1923] UKPC 45 7 Jun 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Midnapur Zamindary Company Limited v Uma Charan Mandal and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1923] UKPC 46 8 Jun 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Maharaja of Kolhapur v Shri Bala Maharaj and Others (Bombay) [1923] UKPC 47 12 Jun 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jamnabai v Fazalbhoy Heptoola and Others (Bombay) [1923] UKPC 48 12 Jun 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Seth Kevaldas Tribhovandas v Sakerlal Bulakhidas and Another (Bombay) [1923] UKPC 49 21 Jun 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  A. S. S. Subbaiya Pandaram v Mahamad Mustapha Maracaya (Since Deceased) and Others (Madras) [1923] UKPC 50 26 Jun 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Arthur Herbert Hallen v Frederick Benjamin Spaeth (Fiji) [1923] UKPC 51 26 Jun 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Phirozshaw Bomanjee Petit v Bai Goolbai and Others (Bombay) [1923] UKPC 52 28 Jun 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Raja Bommadevara Naganna Naidu Bahadur Zemindar Garu and Another v Ravi Venkaiappayya and Others (Madras) [1923] UKPC 53 29 Jun 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  David Ross Jamieson v Frederick Joseph Thomas Downie [1923] UKPC 54 29 Jun 1923 PC Commonwealth (New South Wales) [ Bailii ]  Smallfield v The National Mutual Life Association of Australasia Limited [1923] UKPC 55 2 Jul 1923 PC Commonwealth (New Zealand) [ Bailii ]  Lal Ram Singh and Others v The Deputy Commissioner of Partabgarh (Oudh) [1923] UKPC 56 3 Jul 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  George Jaserson v The Dominion Tobacco Company (Ontario) [1923] UKPC 58 6 Jul 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Than Than v Ma Pwa Thit (Lower Burma) [1923] UKPC 57 6 Jul 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Madhavrao Waman Saundalgekar and Others v Raghunath Venkatesh Deshpande and Others [1923] UKPC 60 10 Jul 1923 PC Commonwealth (Bombay) [ Bailii ]  The Oriental Carpet Manufacturers Limited v Dicran Dedeyan [1923] UKPC 61 10 Jul 1923 PC Commonwealth Ottoman Porte [ Bailii ]  The Imperial Bank of India (Substituted for The Bank of Bengal Akyab) v U Rai Gyaw Thu and Company Limited and Others (Lower Burma) [1923] UKPC 59 10 Jul 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commercial Credit Company of Canada Limited v Fullton Brothers (Nova Scotia) [1923] UKPC 62 20 Jul 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The King and Another v The Canadian Northern Railway Company [1923] UKPC 63 20 Jul 1923 PC Commonwealth Canada [ Bailii ]  The Fort Frances Pulp and Paper Company Limited v The Manitoba Free Press Company Limited and Others (Ontario) [1923] UKPC 64 25 Jul 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Srinath Rai and Others v Maharaja Pratap Udai Nath Sahi Deo (Patna) [1923] UKPC 65 25 Jul 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The United States Fidelity and Guaranty Company v The King and Another (Canada) [1923] UKPC 67 27 Jul 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The United States of America and Another v Motor Trucks Limited (Ontario) [1923] UKPC 66 27 Jul 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sir Alexandre Lacoste and Others v Dame Mary M. Duchesnay and Others [1923] UKPC 68 18 Oct 1923 PC Commonwealth (Quebec) [ Bailii ]  The King v The Attorney General of British Columbia (Canada) [1923] UKPC 69 18 Oct 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of British Columbia v The Attorney General of Canada and Another (Canada) [1923] UKPC 70 18 Oct 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of British Columbia v The Attorney General of Canada and Others (Canada) [1923] UKPC 71 18 Oct 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Honourable David Lynch Scott v The Attorney General of Canada and Others (Canada) [1923] UKPC 72 18 Oct 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Julius Carlos Clausen and Others v Canada Timber and Lands Limited (British Columbia) [1923] UKPC 73 18 Oct 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Khanderao Vithoba Kore Since Deceased (Now Represented By Bhimabai) v The Municipal Corporation of Bombay and Another (Bombay) [1923] UKPC 74 19 Oct 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kumar Satya Narain Singh and Others v Raja Satya Niranjan Chakravarti and Others (Patna) [1923] UKPC 75 26 Oct 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ram Singh v Ram Chand (Lahore) [1923] UKPC 76 30 Oct 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Obala Kondama Naicker Ayyan and Another v Kandasamy Goundar (Madras) [1923] UKPC 77 13 Nov 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Bahadur Raja Brij Narain Rai v Mangla Prasad Rai and Others (Allahabad) [1923] UKPC 78 14 Nov 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Eastern Shipping Company Limited v Quah Beng Kee (Penang) [1923] UKPC 79 16 Nov 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kaju Mal and Others Appeal Nos. 93 and 94 of 1922) v Salig Ram (Punjab) [1923] UKPC 80 16 Nov 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shannon Realties Limited v The Town of St. Michel (Canada) [1923] UKPC 81 22 Nov 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Baijnath Singh and Others v Jamal Brothers and Company Limited and Others (Upper Burma) [1923] UKPC 83 22 Nov 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pujari Lakshmana Goundan and Another v Subramania Ayyar and Others (Madras) [1923] UKPC 82 22 Nov 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The India Navigation Railway Company Limited and Others v The Dekhari Tea Company Limited (Fort William (Bengal)) [1923] UKPC 84 23 Nov 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Malireddi Ayyareddi v Adsumilli Gopalakrishnayya and Another (Madras) [1923] UKPC 85 26 Nov 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Srimati Nagendrabala Dasi and Another v Dinanath Mahish and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1923] UKPC 86 29 Nov 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Motibai Hormusjee Kanga v Jamsetjee Hormusjee Kanga (Mysore U Bangalore) [1923] UKPC 87 30 Nov 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Haji Hedayetulla v Mahomed Kamil and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1923] UKPC 88 6 Dec 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ramlal Hargopal v Kisanchandra and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1923] UKPC 89 10 Dec 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  A. S. N. Nainapillai Marakayar Since Deceased (Now Represented By A. S. N. Sheik Muhammad Marakayar and Others) v T. A. R. A. Rm Ramanathan Chettiar and Others (Madras) [1923] UKPC 91 14 Dec 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Thaung and Another v Ma Than and Others (Upper Burma) [1923] UKPC 94 18 Dec 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raghunath Prasad Sahu v Sarju Prasad Sahu and Others (Patna) [1923] UKPC 93 18 Dec 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Auckland Harbour Board v The King (New Zealand) [1923] UKPC 92 18 Dec 1923 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Attorney General for Ontario v Attorney General for Canada; PC 1924 - [1925] AC 750; 94 LJPC 132; (1924) 4 DLR 520   Jaenicke v Schulz; 1924 - [1924] 4 DLR 488   Verge v Somerville; PC 1924 - [1924] AC 496   De Renzy v De Renzy; 1924 - [1924] NZLR 1065  Elijah Welden v George John Smith (Australia) [1924] UKPC 1 22 Jan 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mirza Abid Husain Khan v Musammat Kaniz Fatima and Others (Oudh) [1924] UKPC 3 22 Jan 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hari Bakhsh v Babu Lal and Another (Punjab) [1924] UKPC 4 22 Jan 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Strauss and Company v Angfaktieb Aktiebolag Karin The Owners of The Steamship Lisa (The High Court of Justice Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions (In Prize)) [1924] UKPC 2 22 Jan 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sydney Verge v Arthur Angwin Somerville and Others (New South Wales) [1924] UKPC 6 25 Jan 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of Ontario v The Reciprocal Insurers Having No Licences Under The Dominion Insurance Act and Others (Ontario) [1924] UKPC 5 25 Jan 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Muhammad Raza v Syed Yadgar Hussain and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1924] UKPC 7 28 Jan 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Lajwanti and Others v Safa Chand Since Deceased and Others (Punjab) [1924] UKPC 9 29 Jan 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Waman Ganesh and Another v Sarubai (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1924] UKPC 8 29 Jan 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ramabai v Harnabai and Another (Bombay) [1924] UKPC 11 1 Feb 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Marwadi Ramjivan Nevatia A Firm v H. Bhikaji and Company (Bombay) [1924] UKPC 10 1 Feb 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Judawan Prasad v Shaturan Prasad (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1924] UKPC 12 7 Feb 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chaudhri Nusrat Ali Since Deceased (Now Represented By Chaudhri Fatch Ali and Others) and Others v Ghulam Sarwar Since Deceased and Others (Oudh) [1924] UKPC 14 12 Feb 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sahu Ram Kumar v Muhammad Yaqub and Another (Allahabad) [1924] UKPC 13 12 Feb 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The St. Lucia Usines and Estates Company Limited v The Colonial Treasurer of St. Lucia (St. Lucia) [1924] UKPC 17 14 Feb 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  D. Benaim and Company v Luigi Spiteri Debono (Trading As L. Spiteri Debono and Company) [1924] UKPC 15 14 Feb 1924 PC Commonwealth (Malta) [ Bailii ]  D. Benaim and Company v Luigi Spiteri Debono (Trading As L. Spiteri Debono and Company [1924] UKPC 16 14 Feb 1924 PC Commonwealth (Malta) [ Bailii ]  Malraju Venkata Ramakrishna Rao Garu and Another v Koppuravuri Sriramulu and Others (Madras) [1924] UKPC 18 15 Feb 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Smith Imossi and Company v His Majesty'S Attorney General (Gibraltar) [1924] UKPC 19 19 Feb 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nabi Bakhsh and Others v Ahmad Khan and Others (Lahore) [1924] UKPC 20 21 Feb 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Durga Devi and Another v Shambhu Nath and Others (Punjab) [1924] UKPC 21 26 Feb 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Montreal Light Heat and Power Company v The City of Montreal (Quebec) [1924] UKPC 22 6 Mar 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Frank K. Brown v Phil. M Moore [1924] UKPC 23 10 Mar 1924 PC Commonwealth (Nova Scotia) [ Bailii ]  Kalyandappa Bin Ayappa Desai Since Deceased (Now Represented By Ayappa Bin Kalyandappa Deshmukh and Others) v Chanbasappa Bin Dodappa Desai (Bombay) [1924] UKPC 25 13 Mar 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mahomed Rahimtulla Haji Joosab v Esmail Allarakhia (Bombay) [1924] UKPC 24 13 Mar 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Viswasundara Rao v The Secretary of State for India In Council Represented By The Collector of Godavari (Madras) [1924] UKPC 26 14 Mar 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Seth Hukum Chand and Others v Raja Ran Bahadur Singh and Another (Patna) [1924] UKPC 27 18 Mar 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  John Cooke and Company Proprietary Limited and Others v The Commonwealth of Australia and Others (Australia) [1924] UKPC 28 24 Mar 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  George Stanley Thompson v The New South Wales Branch of The British Medical Association (New South Wales) [1924] UKPC 29 26 Mar 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kodoth Ambu Nair v The Secretary of State for India In Council Represented By The Collector of South Kanara (Madras) [1924] UKPC 30 7 Apr 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Midnapur Zamindary Company Limited v Kumar Naresh Narain Roy and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1924] UKPC 31 7 Apr 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Veerappa Chetty and Another v L. A. R. Arunachellam Chetty (Lower Burma) [1924] UKPC 32 1 May 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council v Roy Jatindra Nath Chowdhury and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1924] UKPC 33 2 May 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Rajah Vatsavaya Venkata Subhadrayyamma Jagapati Bahadur Garu v Sri Poosapati Venkatapati Raju Garu and Others (Madras) [1924] UKPC 34 5 May 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jagatput Singh Alias Kalidas Dugar; (Fort William (Bengal)) [1924] UKPC 37 9 May 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ashrafi Singh v Bidya Prasad Narayan Singh and Others (Patna) [1924] UKPC 36 9 May 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ganga Ram and Others v Natha Singh and Others (Lahore) [1924] UKPC 39 13 May 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Imperial Tobacco Company of India Limited v Albert Bonnan and Bonnan and Company [1924] UKPC 38 13 May 1924 PC Commonwealth (Fort William (Bengal)) [ Bailii ]  Maharu Walad Lotu v Khandu Walad Hari Patil and Another (Bombay) [1924] UKPC 40 13 May 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sant Bakhsh Singh and Others v Mahadeo Bakhsh Singh and Others (Oudh) [1924] UKPC 41 27 May 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sarkar Barnard and Company and Another v Sreematy Bar Kuarain Alak Manjari Kuari and Another [1924] UKPC 42 27 May 1924 PC Commonwealth Patna [ Bailii ]  William Joseph Mayson v A. G. Clouet and Another (Straits Settlements) [1924] UKPC 43 30 May 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rai Radha Kishun and Others v Jag Sahu and Others (Patna) [1924] UKPC 44 30 May 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Janet Livingstone Loch and Another v John Blackwood Limited (Barbados) [1924] UKPC 45 2 Jun 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kenchava Kom Sanyellappa Hosmani and Another v Girimallappa Channappa Somasagar (Bombay) [1924] UKPC 47 19 Jun 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Bahadur Narasingerji Gyanagerji Since Deceased (Now Represented By Raja Dhanarajagirji) v Raja Panuganti Parthasaradhi Rayanim Garu and Others (Madras) [1924] UKPC 46 19 Jun 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Vaidyanatha Ayyar and Another v K Swaminatha Ayyar and Another (Madras) [1924] UKPC 48 19 Jun 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharajadhiraj Sir Rameshwar Singh Bahadur v Hitendra Singh and Others (Patna) [1924] UKPC 49 26 Jun 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharajadhiraj Sir Rameshwar Singh Bahadur v Hitendra Singh and Others (Patna) [1924] UKPC 50 26 Jun 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nayak Vajesingji Joravarsingji and Others v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Bombay) [1924] UKPC 51 26 Jun 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lachhmi Narayan Agarwala and Others v Rameshwar Prasad Singh and Others (Patna) [1924] UKPC 52 26 Jun 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lal Singh and Another v Raghunath Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1924] UKPC 53 26 Jun 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mitra Sen Singh and Others v Musammat Janki Kuar and Others (Oudh) [1924] UKPC 54 1 Jul 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lachmi Narain Marwary and Others v Balmakund Marwary and Another (Patna) [1924] UKPC 55 10 Jul 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Ambalaavana Desika Pandara Sannadhi Avergal of Tiruvaduthurai Mutt Adhinam Since Deceased and Another v Laksh Pillai and Others (Madras) [1924] UKPC 56 11 Jul 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of Ontario v Herbert J. Daly Since Deceased and Others (Ontario) [1924] UKPC 57 14 Jul 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Honourable J. E. Hetherington Provincial Secretary-Treasurer of The Province of New Brunswick v The Security Export Company Limited (Canada) [1924] UKPC 58 23 Jul 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Montreal Tramways Company v La Ville De Montrual Nord (Quebec) [1924] UKPC 59 28 Jul 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaja Kesho Prasad Singh v Sheo Pargash Ojha and Others (Allahabad) [1924] UKPC 60 29 Jul 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Sa Bon and Others v Ma Da Twe and Others (Lower Burma) [1924] UKPC 61 29 Jul 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Chandika Bakhsh Singh and Another v Madho Singh (Oudh) [1924] UKPC 62 29 Jul 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Don Philip Alexander Wijeyewardene v Theodore Godfred Jayawardene (Ceylon) [1924] UKPC 63 30 Jul 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Marie Tiche Sasson v Maurice Sasson (Alexandria) [1924] UKPC 64 30 Jul 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Honourable J. E. Caron v The King (Canada) [1924] UKPC 66 1 Aug 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kathleen Molly Stuart and Another v Kathleen Pittar Kingston and Others (Australia) [1924] UKPC 65 1 Aug 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Tan Soo Hock v Tan Jiak Choo and Others (Straits Settlements) [1924] UKPC 67 4 Aug 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kirkwood (Alias) Ma Thein and Others v Maung Sin and Another (Lower Burma) [1924] UKPC 68 7 Aug 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Northern Pipe Line Company Limited and Others v The Canadian Gas Company Limited (Ontario) [1924] UKPC 70 21 Oct 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maung Dwe and Others v Khoo Haung Shein and Others (Lower Burma) [1924] UKPC 72 21 Oct 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sat Narain v Behari Lal and Others (Lahore) [1924] UKPC 71 21 Oct 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mary Brodie Laing and Another v The Toronto General Trusts Corporation and Others (Ontario) [1924] UKPC 69 21 Oct 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Barendra Kumar Ghosh v The King-Emperor [1924] UKPC 73 23 Oct 1924 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]   Charles W. Gunning and Others v Charles A. Lusby and Others; PC 23-Oct-1924 - [1924] UKPC 74  Dasaraju Jagannadha Rao Pantulu Garu v Sri Vyricherla Suryanarayanaraj Bahadur Garu and Others (Madras) [1924] UKPC 76 23 Oct 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Ontario and Minnesota Power Company Limited v The King (Canada) [1924] UKPC 75 23 Oct 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Corporation of The City of Toronto v The Toronto Railway Company (Ontario) [1924] UKPC 77 24 Oct 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Great Lakes Steamship Company v The Maple Leaf Milling Company Limited (Ontario) [1924] UKPC 78 24 Oct 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Great West Permanent Loan Company and Others v Jacob E. Friesen and Others (Saskatchewan) [1924] UKPC 79 24 Oct 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Cowasji Edalji Dadachanji v Ratanbai and Another (Bombay) [1924] UKPC 80 28 Oct 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lala Jai Narain and Others v Lala Ujagar Lal and Others (Allahabad) [1924] UKPC 81 30 Oct 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Sasi Sekhareswar Roy Bahadur v Lalit Mohan Maitra Since Deceased (Fort William (Bengal)) [1924] UKPC 82 31 Oct 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ramdahin Singh and Others Appeal No. 70 of 1923) v Musammat Chandrama Kuer and Another (Patna) [1924] UKPC 84 13 Nov 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Saiyid Manzur Hasan and Others v Saiyid Muhammad Zaman and Others (Allahabad) [1924] UKPC 83 13 Nov 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Fatch Singh and Others v Jagannath Bakhsh Singh and Another (Oudh) [1924] UKPC 86 17 Nov 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ranodip Singh and Others v Parmeshwar Pershad and Others (Oudh) [1924] UKPC 85 17 Nov 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Umra (Reasons) v The King-Emperor (Lahore) [1924] UKPC 87 17 Nov 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sena Ana Hamido Mohiyadeen and Others v Kuna Mana Nana Muna Kristnappa Chetty and Another (Ceylon) [1924] UKPC 88 17 Nov 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mirza Fida Rasul and Others v Mirza Yakub Beg and Others (Oudh) [1924] UKPC 89 18 Nov 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Palani Ammal v Muthuvenkatachala Moniagar and Others (Madras) [1924] UKPC 90 20 Nov 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ahmed Khan Najoo Khan Since Deceased (Now Represented By Suleman Khan and Others) v Ali Ebrahim Noor and Another (Aden) [1924] UKPC 93 21 Nov 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   William Graham v Kristna Chandra Dey; PC 21-Nov-1924 - [1924] UKPC 91  Gutta Bhadrayya v Kalagara Kanakamma (Madras) [1924] UKPC 92 21 Nov 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Maharaj Kumar Satya Niranjan Chakravarti and Others v Ram Lal Kaviraj and Others (Patna) [1924] UKPC 94 25 Nov 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Debi Rai and Others v Pahlad Das and Others (Allahabad) [1924] UKPC 95 28 Nov 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jag Prasad Rai and Another v Musammat Singari (Allahabad) [1924] UKPC 98 2 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lala Tulsi Ram v Ram Saran Das (Lahore) [1924] UKPC 96 2 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Peter P'Chient v S.R.M.A.L. and Others (Malay States) [1924] UKPC 100 2 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  G. C. Hutchful and Others v The American Colonial Company Limited (Gold Coast Colony) [1924] UKPC 99 2 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Srajmull Nagaremull v The Triton Insurance Company Limited (Fort William (Bengal)) [1924] UKPC 97 2 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Seth Motilal Hirabhai and Others v Bai Mami (Bombay) [1924] UKPC 104 5 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rai Bahadur Lala Narsingh Das v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Lahore) [1924] UKPC 105 5 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Baijnath Singh v Hajee Vally Mahomed Hajee Abba (Lower Burma) [1924] UKPC 102 5 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Municipal Council of Sydney v Laura Augusta Georgiana Campbell and Others (New South Wales) [1924] UKPC 101 5 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Srimati Karimunnessa Khatun Since Deceased (Now Represented By Mahomed Alem and Others) v Mahomed Fazlul Karim and Others [1924] UKPC 103 5 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth (Fort William (Bengal)) [ Bailii ]  Leonard James Martin v Percy Wyfold Stout (Cairo) [1924] UKPC 106 8 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Maina Bibi Since Deceased (Now Represented By Chaudhri Khalilul Rahman and Others) and Others v Chaudhri Vakil Ahmad and Others [1924] UKPC 108 11 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth (Allahabad) [ Bailii ]  Srimati Katyayani Debi v Udoy Kumar Das (Fort William (Bengal)) [1924] UKPC 109 11 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Mutual Life Insurance Company of New York v The Ontario Metal Products Company Limited (Canada) [1924] UKPC 107 11 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ramagirji Neelakantagirji v Annavajjhala Venkatachallam [1924] UKPC 110 12 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth (Madras) [ Bailii ]  The Victoria Insurance Company Limited v The Junction North Broken Hill Mine [1924] UKPC 111 15 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth New South Wales [ Bailii ]  R. J. Ghartley v No. 2 Company of Winnebah Per Kwesi Affaidzi and Another (Gold Coast Colony) [1924] UKPC 115 22 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Osman Effendi Khalil Bartlett and Another v Abdel Hamid Effendi Khehil Bartlett and Others [1924] UKPC 116 22 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth (His Majesty's Supreme Court for Egypt) [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council v The Great Indian Peninsula Railway Company (Bombay) [1924] UKPC 117 22 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Evariste Brassard In Place of J. W. Levesque v Harriett W. Smith and Others (Canada) [1924] UKPC 114 22 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hashmat Ali and Another v Musammat Nasib-Ul-Nisa (Lahore) [1924] UKPC 118 22 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Lord'S Day Alliance of Canada v The Attorney General of Manitoba (Manitoba) [1924] UKPC 112 22 Dec 1924 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Campbell v Municipal Council of Sydney; PC 1925 - [1925] AC 338; [1924] All ER 930   The Toronto Electric Commissioners v Snider and Others; PC 20-Jan-1925 - [1925] UKPC 2  Motilal Ichhalal Gandhi v Haji Moosa Haji Mahomed (Bombay) [1925] UKPC 3 23 Jan 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Rajah Venkatadri Appa Rao Bahadur Zamindar Garu and Others v Mahboob Sirfraz Vanth Sri Rajah Partasarathi Appa Rao Bahadur Varu Zamindar of Bhadrachalam and Palavancha and Others (Madras) [1925] UKPC 4 30 Jan 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Tilakdhari Singh and Others v Maharaja Kesho Prasad Singh (Patna) [1925] UKPC 5 30 Jan 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dhanraj Joharmal v Soni Bai (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1925] UKPC 6 2 Feb 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kedarnath Goenka v Anant Prasad Singh and Others (Patna) [1925] UKPC 7 9 Feb 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Goh Choon Seng v Lee Kim Soo (Singapore) [1925] UKPC 9 17 Feb 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of New South Wales On The Relation of Magrath v The Railway Commissioners for New South Wales (New South Wales) [1925] UKPC 8 17 Feb 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lal Rajindra Narain Singh Alias Lallu Sahib v Musammat Sundar Bibi (Allahabad) [1925] UKPC 11 19 Feb 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sreemanthu Rajah Yarlagadda Mallikarjua Prasada Nayudu Bahadur Zamindar Since Deceased (Now Represented By Sreemanthu Rajah Yarlagadda Ankineedu Prasada Bahadur Zamindar Garu) v Renduchintala Subbayya and Others (Madras) [1925] UKPC 12 20 Feb 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Adappa and Others v Gundappa Bharmagouda Desai Since Deceased and Another (Bombay) [1925] UKPC 13 23 Feb 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Begu and Others v The King-Emperor (Lahore) [1925] UKPC 14 25 Feb 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of Ontario v The Attorney General of Canada (Ontario) [1925] UKPC 15 26 Feb 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Palaniappa Chettiar Since Deceased (Now Represented By N. S. P. K. L. Kolandaivelu Chettiar) v Kathiresan Chettiar and Others [1925] UKPC 16 3 Mar 1925 PC Commonwealth Madras [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General v Pang Ah Yew (Straits Settlements) [1925] UKPC 17 10 Mar 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mian Ghulam Rasul Khan v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Lahore) [1925] UKPC 18 12 Mar 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gajadhar Mahton v Ambika Prasad Tewari and Others (Allahabad) [1925] UKPC 19 13 Mar 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Lajwanti and Others v Safa Chand Since Deceased and Others (Punjab) [1925] UKPC 20 19 Mar 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hope Prudhomme and Company v Hammel and Horley Limited (Madras) [1925] UKPC 23 24 Mar 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of New Brunswick v The Canadian Pacific Railway Company and Another (New Brunswick) [1925] UKPC 22 24 Mar 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of Manitoba v The Attorney General of Canada and Others (Canada) [1925] UKPC 21 24 Mar 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Udoychand Pannalal (Reasons) v P. E, Guzdar and Company (Fort William (Bengal)) [1925] UKPC 24 27 Mar 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Probhadas v Ganidada (Fort William (Bengal)) [1925] UKPC 25 27 Mar 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Charles Edward Wilson v Beatrice Maud Kinnear and Others (Ontario) [1925] UKPC 27 30 Mar 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Aristide Ouellette v The Canadian Pacific Railway Company (Canada) [1925] UKPC 26 30 Mar 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sevak Jeranchod Bhogilal and Others v The Dakore Temple Committee and Others (Bombay) [1925] UKPC 28 30 Mar 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Vaithialinga Mudaliar and Others v Sriangath Anni and Others (Madras) [1925] UKPC 29 2 Apr 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  A. H. Forbes v Sir L. E. Ralli and Others (Patna) [1925] UKPC 31 3 Apr 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Diwan Chand-Kirpa Ram and Company v Weld and Company (Lahore) [1925] UKPC 30 3 Apr 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Harigir Kisangir Gosavi and Another v Ananad Bharthi Vishnu Bharthi Gosavi (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1925] UKPC 32 28 Apr 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pramatha Nath Mullick v Pradyumma Kumar Mullick and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1925] UKPC 33 28 Apr 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kirkwood Alias Ma Thein and Another v Maung Sin and Another (Lower Burma) [1925] UKPC 34 5 May 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Bhagwani Kunwar and Another v Mohan Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1925] UKPC 35 7 May 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Wing Lee v David C. Lew Since Deceased (Now Represented By Yick Pang Lew, The Administrator To The Estate (Canada) [1925] UKPC 36 11 May 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Rajendra Narain Dhanj Deo, Substituted for J. C. Aguilar v Kumar Ganganandra Singh and Others (Patna) [1925] UKPC 37 13 May 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Rajah Venkatadri Appa Rao Bahadur Garu Zamindar v The Revenue Divisional Officer of Guntur (Madras) [1925] UKPC 39 15 May 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  M. S. V. Sri Raja Parthasarathi Appa Rao Savayi Aswarao Bahadur Zamindar Garu and Others v The Secretary of State for India In Council Represented By The Collector of Guntur (Madras) [1925] UKPC 38 15 May 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Doddawa Kom Bennepgowda v Bennepgowda Bin Yenkangowda and Others [1925] UKPC 40 19 May 1925 PC Commonwealth (Bombay) [ Bailii ]  Bai Monghibai and Others v Pragji Dayal Hariani (Bombay) [1925] UKPC 42 22 May 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sura Lakshmiah Chetty and Others v Kothandarama Pillia (Madras) [1925] UKPC 41 22 May 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rajah Ganesh Narayan Sahi Deo v Manik Lal Chandra and Others (Patna) [1925] UKPC 44 25 May 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mir Subhan Ali v Imami Begum and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1925] UKPC 43 25 May 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kondapalli Vijayaratnam and Another v Mandapaka Sundarsana Rao and Others (Madras) [1925] UKPC 45 11 Jun 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Ganesh Narain Sahi and Another v Maharaja Pratap Udai Nath Sahi Deo (Patna) [1925] UKPC 46 11 Jun 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nowroji Rustomji Wadia v The Government of Bombay (Bombay) [1925] UKPC 47 12 Jun 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lucia Jacob v David Alexander Wills (Fort William (Bengal)) [1925] UKPC 48 15 Jun 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Burn and Company Limited v His Highness Thakur Sahib Sree Lukhdirji of Morvi State (Fort William (Bengal)) [1925] UKPC 49 18 Jun 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kumar Pramatha Nath Malia v Burton (Manager, Pandara Encumbered Estate) and Others (Patna) [1925] UKPC 51 19 Jun 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Bhupendra Narayan Singh Bahadur v Madar Buksh Sheikh Since Deceased and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1925] UKPC 50 19 Jun 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Kanchumarthi Venkata Seetharama Chandra Row v Kanchumarthi Raju Alias Venkata Kristna Row and Others (Madras) [1925] UKPC 52 23 Jun 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Hira Bibi and Others v Ram Hari Lal and Others (Patna) [1925] UKPC 53 23 Jun 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Homeshwar Singh and Others v Jugal Kishore Marwari and Another (Patna) [1925] UKPC 54 29 Jun 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Waimiha Sawmilling Company Limited (In Liquidation) v The Waione Timber Company Limited (New Zealand) [1925] UKPC 55 30 Jun 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maung Bya and Another v Maung Kyi Nyo and Others (Lower Burma) [1925] UKPC 56 30 Jun 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Farid-Un-Nisa v Munshi Mukhtar Ahmad and Another (Oudh) [1925] UKPC 60 6 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Edouard Le Cudennec and Another v La Compagnie Sucriere Se Bel Ombre (Mauritius) [1925] UKPC 58 6 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thomas Caven v The Canadian Pacific Railway Company (Alberta) [1925] UKPC 59 6 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  James Townsend Allen v The Royal Bank of Canada (Leeward Islands) [1925] UKPC 57 6 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rajah Bhupendra Narayan Singh v Narapat Singh (Fort William (Bengal)) [1925] UKPC 61 7 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dr. Vrasapillai Gabrriel v A.S. Eliatamby and Another (Ceylon) [1925] UKPC 62 7 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Ticonderoga Pulp and Paper Company v Percy P. Cowans and Others (Quebec) [1925] UKPC 63 9 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mahomed Ali Mamoojee v Howeson Brothers (Fort William (Bengal)) [1925] UKPC 64 10 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Y. A. J. Noorbhai and Another v S. P. L. K. R. Karuppan Chetty (Ceylon) [1925] UKPC 65 13 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  S. Soundara Rajan and Others v C. M. Natarajan and Others (Madras) [1925] UKPC 66 16 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commonwealth Trust Limited v John Akotey (Gold Coast Colony) [1925] UKPC 67 21 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dr. F. V. Nanka-Bruce v The Commonwealth Trust (Gold Coast Colony) [1925] UKPC 68 21 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mahabir Prasad Tewari v Jamuna Singh and Another (Patna) [1925] UKPC 72 21 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Trustee of The Property of Andrew Motherwell of Canada Limited In Bankruptcy v Alexander F. Zimmerman and Another (Ontario) [1925] UKPC 69 21 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sourendra Mohan Sinha and Others v Hari Prasad Sinha and Others (Patna) [1925] UKPC 71 21 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lal Bahadur and Others v Ambika Prasad and Another (Oudh) [1925] UKPC 73 23 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Chit Su v The National Bank of India (Lower Burma) [1925] UKPC 74 23 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rajah Maharaj Kumar Satya Niranjan Chakravarti and Others v Ram Lal Kaviraj and Others (Patna) [1925] UKPC 75 23 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Joseph W. Post v Walter N. Langell (Ontario) [1925] UKPC 76 24 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dadabhoy Framji Cama v Cowasji Dorabji Panday and Others (Bombay) [1925] UKPC 77 24 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Nag Kuer v Sham Lal Sahu and Others (Patna) [1925] UKPC 78 27 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ahmad Khan and Others v Musammat Channi Bibi (Lahore) [1925] UKPC 80 28 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Corporation of The City of Toronto v The Board of Trustees of The Roman Catholic Separate Schools for The City of Toronto (Canada) [1925] UKPC 79 28 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Peddle v Mcdonald [1925] UKPC 81 28 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth (New Zealand) [ Bailii ]  Beni Prasad Since Deceased (Now Represented By Sheoraj Lal) and Others v Lala Darbari Lal (Allahabad) [1925] UKPC 83 30 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kuar Mata Prasad and Another v Kuar Nageshar Sahai and Others (Oudh) [1925] UKPC 82 30 Jul 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Firm of Rai Bahadur Bansilal Abirchand v Ghulam Mahbub Khan and Another (Hyderabad Deccan) [1925] UKPC 85 20 Oct 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ram Protap Chamria v Durga Prosad Chamria and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1925] UKPC 86 20 Oct 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  A. Soosiappa Pillai v H. Bastian Fernando (Ceylon) [1925] UKPC 84 20 Oct 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Palatine Insurance Company Limited v John A. Gregory (New Brunswick) [1925] UKPC 87 22 Oct 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  D. R. K. Saklat and Others v Bella (Lower Burma) [1925] UKPC 88 22 Oct 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Natha Singh v Khan Bahadur Doctor Sayad Amir Shah (Lahore) [1925] UKPC 89 27 Oct 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kumar Kalikanand Singh and Others v Raghunandan Prasad Singh and Others (Patna) [1925] UKPC 91 29 Oct 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Takaur Pyarsingh v Rani Sona Bahuji and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner Central Provinces) [1925] UKPC 90 29 Oct 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Niagara St. Catherine's and Toronto Railway Company v The Lakes and St. Lawrence Transit Company [1925] UKPC 92 2 Nov 1925 PC Commonwealth (Canada) [ Bailii ]  Shafi Ahmed Nabi Ahmed and Others (Reasons) v The King-Emperor (Bombay) [1925] UKPC 93 5 Nov 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Broken Hill Pty Co Ltd v Broken Hill Municipal Council [1926] AC 94; [1925] UKPC 96 10 Nov 1925 PC Taxes Management, Estoppel, Commonwealth A decision of the High Court of Australia on the construction of a section of a statute dealing with rating value did not estop the parties from relitigating the issue on a subsequent year's assessment. 1 Citers [ Bailii ]  The City of Montreal and Others v The Harbour Commissioners of Montreal and Others (Quebec) [1925] UKPC 94 10 Nov 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Tetreault and Others v The Harbour Commissioners of Montreal and Others (Quebec) [1925] UKPC 95 10 Nov 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Lord Strathcona Steamship Company Limited v The Dominion Coal Company Limited (Nova Scotia) [1925] UKPC 97 17 Nov 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Alfred Henry Chesterman and Others v The Federal Commissioner of Taxation (Australia) [1925] UKPC 98 19 Nov 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The King v The Anderson Logging Company Limited (Canada) [1925] UKPC 99 24 Nov 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Pertang Rubber Estates Company Limited v Sociutu Financiere Des Caoutchoucs (Malay States) [1925] UKPC 100 26 Nov 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kunwar Chiranjit Singh v Rai Bahadur Har Swarup Since Deceased (Allahabad) [1925] UKPC 101 1 Dec 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rao Bahadur Man Singh v Maharani Nawlakhbati and Another (Patna) [1925] UKPC 102 2 Dec 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaj Bahadur Singh v Seth Hukum Chand and Others (Patna) [1925] UKPC 104 4 Dec 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jawahir Singh v Udai Parkash and Others (Allahabad) [1925] UKPC 103 4 Dec 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lal Chand Marwari and Others v Mahant Ramrup Gir and Another (Patna) [1925] UKPC 105 5 Dec 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The British Petroleum Company Limited v The Attorney General of Ceylon (Ceylon) [1925] UKPC 106 10 Dec 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lal Rajendar Narain Singh v Musammat Sunder Bibi (Allahabad) [1925] UKPC 109 17 Dec 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Lionel Norton Hoysted and Others v The Commissioner of Taxation; PC 17-Dec-1925 - [1925] UKPC 107  William George Pirrie v Thomas Mcfarlane and Another (Victoria) [1925] UKPC 108 17 Dec 1925 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hoysted v Federal Taxation Commissioner [1926] AC 155 1926 PC Commonwealth, Taxes Management An implied decision of the High Court on the true construction of a will estopped the parties from contending for a different construction relating to a later year's assessment. 1 Citers  Rex v White (1926) 5 DLR 2 1926 Commonwealth, Criminal Evidence (British Colombia) Evidence regarding a tracker dog was held inadmissible. 1 Cites 1 Citers  Sri Mirza Raja Sri Pushavi Alakh Narayan Gajapatiraj Maharaj Manya Sultan Bahadur Garu Substitudes for Rai Saheb V.T. Kristna M Chari- v The Secretary of State for India In Council Represented By The Collector of Godivari (Madras) [1926] UKPC 1 18 Jan 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Rajeswara Setupati Avargal Raja of Ramnad v Kamid Rowthen and Others (Madras) [1926] UKPC 2 21 Jan 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thomas Charles William Skipp v Lilian Mildred Kelly (Mysore) [1926] UKPC 3 26 Jan 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hajee Shakoor Gany Since Deceased (Now Represented By Dawood Hajee Shakoor Minor) v T. S. Sabapathy Pillai (Madras) [1926] UKPC 5 28 Jan 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Maung Kyi Oh and Another v Ma Thet Pon; PC 28-Jan-1926 - [1926] UKPC 4  Mahomed Khaleel Shirazi and Sons v Les Tanneries Lyonnaises and Another (Madras) [1926] UKPC 6 4 Feb 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gajadhar Prashad Sahu v Mahadeo Prashad Sahu (Patna) [1926] UKPC 7 8 Feb 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sourendra Mohan Sinha and Others (Reasons) v Hari Prasad Sinha and Others (Patna) [1926] UKPC 9 16 Feb 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The District Governor Jerusalem Jaffa District and Another v Suleiman Murra and Another (Palestine) [1926] UKPC 8 16 Feb 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of Alberta v Reata E. Cook (Alberta) [1926] UKPC 10 18 Feb 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The British Columbia Electric Railway Company Limited v Kathleen Pribble (British Columbia) [1926] UKPC 11 23 Feb 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hirji Mulji and Others v The Cheong Yue Steamship Company Limited (Hong Kong) [1926] UKPC 12 25 Feb 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Frank Nadan v The King (Alberta) [1926] UKPC 13 25 Feb 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rameswar Bazaz v Rani Shyama Sundari Debi (Fort William (Bengal)) [1926] UKPC 14 26 Feb 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maneckji Pestoni Bharucha Another v Wadilal Sarabhai and Company (Bombay) [1926] UKPC 15 1 Mar 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Montreal Transportation Company Limited v The King (Canada) [1926] UKPC 16 2 Mar 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Eric Grant Peter v The Yorkshire Estate Company (British Columbia) [1926] UKPC 17 5 Mar 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council and Another v Raja Jyoti Prashad Singh Deo Bahadur and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1926] UKPC 18 8 Mar 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pursuttamdas Agarwalla Since Deceased (Now Represented By Agarwalla) v Gobind Prosad Agarwalla and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1926] UKPC 19 12 Mar 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Seth Lakhmi Chand v Musammat Anandi and Others (Allahabad) [1926] UKPC 20 15 Mar 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Balbhaddar Singh and Another v Badri Sah and Another (Oudh) [1926] UKPC 21 16 Mar 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Haveli Shah and Another v Khan Sahib Shaikh Painda Khan (Baluchistan) [1926] UKPC 22 18 Mar 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Owners of The British Steamship Foreric and Her Freight v The Owners of The Inter-Allied Italian Steamship Belvedere (Gibraltar) [1926] UKPC 23 19 Mar 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Koo Hooi Leong v Koo Hean Kwee (Penang) [1926] UKPC 25 23 Mar 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ganesh Lal Pandit and Others v Khetramohan Mahapatra and Others (Patna) [1926] UKPC 26 23 Mar 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Koo Hooi Leong v Koo Hean Kwee (Penang) [1926] UKPC 24 23 Mar 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ram Charan Lonia and Others v Bhagwan Das Maheshri Since Deceased and Others (Allahabad) [1926] UKPC 27 15 Apr 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Sobhuzza Ii v Allister M. Miller and Others; PC 15-Apr-1926 - [1926] UKPC 28  Maung Po Kin and Another v Maung Po Shein (Rangoon) [1926] UKPC 29 16 Apr 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  William Harrington Palmer v Randal Westropp Carey [1926] UKPC 30; [1926] AC 703 19 Apr 1926 PC Commonwealth, Insolvency Australia [ Bailii ]  Mary Scales v David Lindesay Aitken and Another (New South Wales) [1926] UKPC 31 23 Apr 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bai Nagubai Manglorkar v Bai Monghibai Since Deceased and Others (Bombay) [1926] UKPC 34 29 Apr 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bindeshwari Prasad Singh v Maharaja Kesho Prasad Singh Bahadur (Patna) [1926] UKPC 33 29 Apr 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gokul Prasad and Another v Lachhman Prasad and Others (Allahabad) [1926] UKPC 32 29 Apr 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nattu Kesava Mudaliar v V. S. Govindachariar and Others (Madras) [1926] UKPC 35 6 May 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The United Manufacturing Company v The St. Maurice Power Company Limited (Quebec) [1926] UKPC 36 7 May 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Dhakeshwar Prasad Narain Singh Alias Raja Harihar Prasad Narain Singh v Musammat Gulab Kuer and Others (Patna) [1926] UKPC 37 10 May 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kakshman Chandra Mandal v Takim Dhali and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1926] UKPC 38 11 May 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chandar Shekhar Bakhsh Singh and Another v Musammat Raj Kunwar Since Deceased (Allahabad) [1926] UKPC 40 17 May 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of Quebec v The Nipissing Central Railway Company and Another (Canada) [1926] UKPC 39 17 May 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pancham and Others v Ansar Husain and Others (Allahabad) [1926] UKPC 41 17 May 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Noe Letang v The Ottawa Electric Railway Company (Canada) [1926] UKPC 42 20 May 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Bank of N. T. Butterfield and Son Limited v Isaac Golinsky (Bermuda) [1926] UKPC 43 7 Jun 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Australian Bank of Commerce Limited v Irvine Perel and Others (New South Wales) [1926] UKPC 44 8 Jun 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thomas Ernest Rofe v Smith'S Newspapers Limited (New South Wales) [1926] UKPC 45 10 Jun 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Saiyid Jowad Hussain v Gendan Singh Since Deceased and Others (Patna) [1926] UKPC 46 15 Jun 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Price Brothers and Company Limited Appeal No. 103 of 1925) v The King [1926] UKPC 47 17 Jun 1926 PC Commonwealth (Canada) [ Bailii ]  Frederick Germano Martins v Emily Fowler (Nigeria) [1926] UKPC 48 18 Jun 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Annada Prashad Das v Ambica Prashad Das and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1926] UKPC 49 18 Jun 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Charles Adeniran Bucknor and Another v Barclay'S Bank (Dominion and Colonial and Overseas) Formally Called and Sued As Colonial Bank (Nigeria) [1926] UKPC 54 21 Jun 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  William Henry Pope Jarvis v Mary Isabel Jarvis (Ontario) [1926] UKPC 51 21 Jun 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Yamike Kweku v Annor Adjaye (Substituted for Ackah Ayimah) (Gold Coast Colony) [1926] UKPC 53 21 Jun 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Joseph Fournier v The Canadian National Railway Company (Canada) [1926] UKPC 50 21 Jun 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Harry Clifford Bowling v James Cliffton Cox (British Honduras) [1926] UKPC 52 21 Jun 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Andrew Mantoura and Sons v Menachem David (Palestine) [1926] UKPC 56 22 Jun 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Masit-Ullah and Others v Lala Damoda Prasad (Allahabad) [1926] UKPC 55 22 Jun 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Dayal Singh v Indar Singh Since Deceased Now Represented By Kharka Singh Minor Through Musammat Bhagwani; PC 24-Jun-1926 - [1926] UKPC 57   Eugene C Audet and Others v Eugene Trudel and Others; PC 27-Jun-1926 - [1926] UKPC 58   Bhujendra Mohan Sarkar v Sukdeb Rathi Since Deceased and Others; PC 29-Jun-1926 - [1926] UKPC 59  Rawat Sheo Bahadur Singh v Beni Bahadur Singh [1926] UKPC 60 1 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth Oudh [ Bailii ]  Thakur Nirman Singh and Others v Thakur Lal Rudra Partab Narain Singh and Others [1926] UKPC 61 1 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth Oudh [ Bailii ]  The Firm of R. M. K. R. M. v The Firm of M. R. M. V. L. (Straits Settlements) [1926] UKPC 62 5 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Olive Christian and Others v Charles F. Taylor and Another (Newfoundland) [1926] UKPC 63 6 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Niladri Sahu v Mahantan Mahant Chaturbhuj Das and Others (Patna) [1926] UKPC 64 6 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gordon Grant and Company Limited v Fritz Luis Boos (West Indian) [1926] UKPC 65 6 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ram Bujhawan Prasad Singh and Another v Kuldip Sahay and Others (Patna) [1926] UKPC 66 8 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Permutit Company v George Leonard Borrowman (Canada) [1926] UKPC 68 9 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Firm Jhabbu Lal Ranchor Das v Firm Madho Prasad Ganesh Prasad (Allahabad) [1926] UKPC 67 9 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Kofi Numah Substituted for Chief Kweku Mensah v Kojo Pamping; PC 15-Jul-1926 - [1926] UKPC 70  Sheik Nasir-Uddin and Another v Ahmad Husain and Others (Allahabad) [1926] UKPC 71 16 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Ship Steel Scientist v H. M. Wrangell and Company A/S (Canada) [1926] UKPC 72 16 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bisset v Wilkinson and Another [1926] UKPC 1 20 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Robert Hugh Bisset (Appeal No. 42 of 1926) v Thomas Vernon Wilkinson and Another (New Zealand) [1926] UKPC 73 20 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of Ontario and Others v The Mclean Gold Mines Limited (Ontario) [1926] UKPC 74 22 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Bhagwan Singh v The Allahabad Bank Limited (Allahabad) [1926] UKPC 75 23 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Bhagwan Singh v Firm Bhanwani Das Bhagwan Das (Allahabad) [1926] UKPC 76 23 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Narayan Krishna Godbole and Another v Pandu Chandrabhan and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner of The Central Provinces India) [1926] UKPC 77 23 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sobhagmal Gianmal v Mukundchand Balia (Bombay) [1926] UKPC 79 26 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Samuel Crawford Hogarth and Others v Cory Brothers and Company Limited (Fort William (Bengal)) [1926] UKPC 78 26 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Minister of Finance v Cecil R. Smith (Canada) [1926] UKPC 81 27 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Toronto Hockey Club Limited v The Arena Gardens of Toronto Limited (Ontario) [1926] UKPC 80 27 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thomas J. Harrison v Newton Carman Shaver and Others (Ontario) [1926] UKPC 82 27 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  William Arratoon Lucas v The Bank of Bengal and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1926] UKPC 83 27 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mirza Umrao Beg v Musammat Faiyazi Begam and Others (Allahabad) [1926] UKPC 84 29 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ellen Boland v The Canadian National Railway Company (Ontario) [1926] UKPC 85 30 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jagadishwar Narayan v Muhammad Haziq Hussain and Others (Patna) [1926] UKPC 86 30 Jul 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dewan Bahadur Seth Umed Mal Since Deceased (Now Represented By Sobhag Mal) and Others v Chand Mal (Ajema-Merwara) [1926] UKPC 87 19 Oct 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jagannath Prosad Shingh Chowdhury v Surajmul Jalal and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1926] UKPC 88 19 Oct 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Benjamin Stevenson v Dame Flora Florant (Canada) [1926] UKPC 89 21 Oct 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lalit Mohan Pal Roy v Srimati Dayamoyi Roy Chowdhurani (Since Deceased) (Fort William (Bengal)) [1926] UKPC 90 29 Oct 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Nant Rani Kunwar v Musammat Indar Kunwar and Others (Oudh) [1926] UKPC 91 1 Nov 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musamma v Musammat (Patna) [1926] UKPC 92 1 Nov 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Mi and Another v Kallander Ammat (Rangoon) [1926] UKPC 93 1 Nov 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Fitzholmes v The Bank of Upper India Limited In Liquidation (Lahore) [1926] UKPC 94 9 Nov 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pathumsa Ammal v Rajagopala Mudaliyar (Madras) [1926] UKPC 95 9 Nov 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Madat Khan and Another v The King-Emperor (Lahore) [1926] UKPC 96 11 Nov 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Makins Produce Company Incorporated (Reasons) v The Union Steamship Company of New Zealand Limited (British Columbia) [1926] UKPC 97 15 Nov 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Krishnendra Nath Sarkar Since Deceased (Now Represented By Surendra Nath Sarkar and Another) and Others v Rni Kusum Kamini Debi Since Deceased [1926] UKPC 98 19 Nov 1926 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Kachireddi Nagireddi v Sakireddi Chinna Narayanareddi and Others (Madras) [1926] UKPC 99 25 Nov 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Radha Kishu and Others v Hira Lal Sah and Others (Patna) [1926] UKPC 101 29 Nov 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ramsaran Mandar Since Deceased and Others v Mahabir Sahu (Patna) [1926] UKPC 100 29 Nov 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Mi and Another v Kallander Ammat (Rangoon) [1926] UKPC 102 30 Nov 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dewan Bahadur Panganti Ramarayanimgar v Sri Rajah Velugoti Govinda Kristna Vachendra Bahadur Varu Maharaja of Venkatagiri and Others (Madras) [1926] UKPC 103 30 Nov 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Deo Narain Pande v Agyan Ram Pande Since Deceased and Others (Allahabad) [1926] UKPC 104 10 Dec 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Krishn Das and Others v Nathu Ram and Another (Allahabad) [1926] UKPC 105 10 Dec 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  T, V. Kalyanasundaram Pillai v Karuppa Mooppanar and Others (Madras) [1926] UKPC 106 13 Dec 1926 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  V. M. Abdul Rahman v The King-Emperor [1926] UKPC 107 14 Dec 1926 PC Commonwealth Rangoon [ Bailii ]  Price Brothers and Company Limited v La Corporation D'Energie De Montmagny and Another (Quebec) [1927] UKPC 5 18 Jan 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shri Sachidanand Vidya Shankar Bharati Swami Guru Shri Sachidanand Vidya Narsinha Bharati Swami Jagadguru and Another v Shri Vidya Narsinha Bharati Guru Shri Vidya Shankar Bharati Swami Math Karvir and Another (Bombay) [1927] UKPC 1 18 Jan 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Wellesley Tobert Gorges Walsh v The Crown (Western Australia) [1927] UKPC 3 18 Jan 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Crown v Neil Mc Neil and Another (Western Australia) [1927] UKPC 4 18 Jan 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The British America Nickel Corporation Limited Others v M J O'Brien Limited (Ontario) [1927] UKPC 7 18 Jan 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Corporation Agencies Limited v The Home Bank of Canada (Canada) [1927] UKPC 6 18 Jan 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mathu KHMSAR Ramaswamy Chetty v Ramalingam Thaamotharampillai (Ceylon) [1927] UKPC 8 20 Jan 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Frances Clara Gardner v Te Porou Hirawanu and Others (New Zealand) [1927] UKPC 10 21 Jan 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  William Richard Doughty v The Commissioner of Taxes (New Zealand) [1927] UKPC 9 21 Jan 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sonation Pal v J C Galstaun and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1927] UKPC 11 21 Jan 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Crown Milling Company Limited v The King (New Zealand) [1927] UKPC 12 27 Jan 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lingangowda Dod-Basangowda Patil and Others v Basangowda Bistangowda Patil and Others (Bombay) [1927] UKPC 13 3 Feb 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  William Robins v The National Trust Company Limited and Others (Ontario) [1927] UKPC 14 7 Feb 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Saheb Rai Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Jaideo Singh) and Others v Shafiq Ahmad and Others (Allahabad) [1927] UKPC 16 10 Feb 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Barkatunnissa Begam v Debi Bakhsh and Another (Patna) [1927] UKPC 15 10 Feb 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Punjab Cotton Press Company Limited and Others v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Lahore) [1927] UKPC 17 11 Feb 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sathappa Chetti and Others v S N Subramanian Chetty and Others (Madras) [1927] UKPC 18 14 Feb 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Banku Behary Chetterji v Naraindas Dutt and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1927] UKPC 20 22 Feb 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Hnit v Fatima Bibi and Another (Rangoon) [1927] UKPC 21 22 Feb 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Tadi Bulli Gangi Reddi v Tadi Bulli Tammi Reddi and Another (Madras) [1927] UKPC 19 22 Feb 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Keshoram Poddar v Nundo La Mallick (Fort William (Bengal)) [1927] UKPC 22 24 Feb 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaja Bahadur Keshava Prasad Singh v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Patna) [1927] UKPC 23 25 Feb 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma On v Maung Tin (Rangoon) [1927] UKPC 24 28 Feb 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Dominion of Canada of The One Part (Reasons) v The Colony of New Foundland of The Other Part (Canada) [1927] UKPC 25 1 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kala Chand Banerjee v Jagannath Marwari and Another [1927] UKPC 27 3 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council v Tarak Chandra Sadhukhan and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1927] UKPC 28 3 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dhanna Mal and Others v Rai Bahadur Lala Moti Sagar [1927] UKPC 26 3 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth (Lahore) [ Bailii ]  Sheobaran Singh v Musammat Kulsum-Un-Nissa and Others (Allahabad) [1927] UKPC 29 4 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dwarka Nath Singh and Others v Keshri Mall and Others (Patna) [1927] UKPC 30 4 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Basiram Saha Roy and Others v Ram Ratan and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1927] UKPC 31 4 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Srimati Nayan Munjari Dasi v Khagendra Nath Das and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1927] UKPC 32 7 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Krishna Reddi v Gandavaram Raghava Reddi and Another (Madras) [1927] UKPC 33 10 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Niamat Rai and Others v Din Dayal and Others (Lahore) [1927] UKPC 35 11 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mahant Rai and Others v Musammat Lachhmina Kunwar and Another (Allahabad) [1927] UKPC 34 11 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Vibhudapriya Thirtha Swamiar v Lakshmindra Thirtha Swamiar (Madras) [1927] UKPC 36 21 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Narayan Das Khetty Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Musamat Panno Bibi) v Jatindra Nath Roy Chowdhury and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1927] UKPC 37 21 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Radha Binode Mandal v Sri Sri Gopal Jiu Thakur and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1927] UKPC 38 25 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Krishnamurthi Ayyar v Krishnamurthi Ayyar and Another (Madras) [1927] UKPC 39 28 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Soniram Jeetmull (A Firm) v R D Tata and Company Limited (Rangoon) [1927] UKPC 42 29 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Duiru Georges Homsey v Her Majesty'S Procurator for Egypt (Alexandria) [1927] UKPC 40 29 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Daing Soharah Binte Daing Tadaleh and Another v Chabak Binte Lasaliho and Another (Singapore) [1927] UKPC 41 29 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maung Sin v Ma Tok (Rangoon) [1927] UKPC 44 31 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  John Agabog Vertannes and Others v James Golder Robinson and Another (Rangoon) [1927] UKPC 43 31 Mar 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  John Howard Wigg and Another v The Attorney General of The Irish Free State (The Irish Free State) [1927] UKPC 45 3 May 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Protap Chandra Deo Dhabal Deb v Raja Jagadish Chandra Deo Dhabal Deb (Fort William (Bengal)) [1927] UKPC 46 3 May 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kojo Pon v Atta Fan (Gold Coast Colony) [1927] UKPC 49 5 May 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Firm of Saleh Mahomed Umer Dossal v Seth Nathoomal Kessamal (Sind) [1927] UKPC 48 5 May 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sastil Kinkar Banerjee v Hursookdas Chogemull [1927] UKPC 47 5 May 1927 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Lala Indar Prasad and Another v Lala Jagmohan Das and Another (Oudh) [1927] UKPC 50 17 May 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  A H Bull and Company As Agents for The United States Shipping Board Emergency Fleet Corporation v The West African Shipping Agency and Lighterage Company (Nigeria) [1927] UKPC 51 24 May 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bhagchand Daghusa Gujrathi and Others v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Bombay) [1927] UKPC 52 27 May 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  M A Sassoon and Sons Limited v The International Banking Corporation (Fort William (Bengal)) [1927] UKPC 53 27 May 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Andrahennedige Dinohamy and Another v Wijetunge Liyanapatabendige Balahamy and Others [1927] UKPC 56 16 Jun 1927 PC Commonwealth Ceylon [ Bailii ]  Manche Anege Akue v Manche Kojo Ababio Iv (Gold Coast Colony) [1927] UKPC 55 16 Jun 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Steamship Hellen v The Wm Donovan Steamship Company (Incorporated) (Canada) [1927] UKPC 57 16 Jun 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Henry Peter Christopher De Silva v Doroty Margaret Catherine De Silva and Another (Ceylon) [1927] UKPC 58 17 Jun 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Capt J A Cates Tug and Wharfage Company Limited v The Franklin Fire Insurance Company of Philadelphia Pennsylvania [1927] UKPC 59 20 Jun 1927 PC Commonwealth British Columbia [ Bailii ]  The Municipal Council of Sydney v Margaret Alexandra Troy (New South Wales) [1927] UKPC 60 20 Jun 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Balla Mal and Others v Ata Ullah Khan and Others (Lahore) [1927] UKPC 61 23 Jun 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sunmonu v Disu Raphael Since Deceased (Now Represented By Awanotu) (Nigeria) [1927] UKPC 62 27 Jun 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kaikhushroo Rustomji Wallace v The Bombay Company Limited (Bombay) [1927] UKPC 63 28 Jun 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Rajeswara Setupati Alias Muthuramalinga Setupati Avargal Raja of Ramnad v Muthanan Servai Alias Tirunilakantan Servai (Madras) [1927] UKPC 65 28 Jun 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Laxmanrao Madhavrao Jahagirdar v Shriniwas Lingo Nadgir and Others (Bombay) [1927] UKPC 64 28 Jun 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  v E A R M Firm and Another v Maung Ba Kyin and Another (Rangoon) [1927] UKPC 66 1 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Abdul Wahab Khan v Tilakdhari Lal and Others (Patna) [1927] UKPC 68 4 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  George Richards Laffer v Francis Arnold Gillen [1927] UKPC 67 4 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth (Australia) [ Bailii ]  The Canadian American Shipping Company v The Steamship Woron (Canada) [1927] UKPC 69 5 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Snia Viscoha Societa Nazionale Industrai Applicazioni Viscosa and Another v The Ship Yuri Maru and Another (Canada) [1927] UKPC 69 5 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Metropolitan Meat Industry Board v Edward Patrick Michael Sheedy and Others (New South Wales) [1927] UKPC 71 5 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ramgowda Anngowda Patil and Others v Bhausheb and Others (Bombay) [1927] UKPC 72 11 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Suraj Bhan Singh and Others v Sah Chain Sukh and Others (Allahabad) [1927] UKPC 74 12 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lala Jagmohan Saran v Suhu Deoki Nandan Alias Jwala Prasad and Others (Allahabad) [1927] UKPC 75 12 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Bank of British West Africa Limited v Comarex Compagnie Franco Marocaine D'Expotation Sociutu Anonyme Marocaine (Formally Called La Sociutu A L Cane and Co-Operative A T C Ruunis Sociutu Anonyme) (Gibraltar) [1927] UKPC 73 12 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Saiyid Mehdi Ali Khan v Chaudhri Ghanshiam Singh and Another (Allahabad) [1927] UKPC 76 15 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mukund Dharman Bhoir and Others v Balkrishna Padmanji and Others (Bombay) [1927] UKPC 79 18 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of British Columbia v The Canadian Pacific Railway Company (Canada) [1927] UKPC 77 18 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lim Yang Hong Trading As Lee Hong and Company v Lam Choon and Company (Singapore) [1927] UKPC 78 18 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sardar Gurbakhsh Singh v Gurdial Singh and Another [1927] UKPC 80 19 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth Lahore [ Bailii ]  Alwar Naidu and Another v Kothandapani Naidu and Others (Madras) [1927] UKPC 81 19 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Royal Bank of Canada v Joseph Savatori (Trinidad and Tobago) [1927] UKPC 82 21 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   The Ontario Jockey Club v McBride; PC 25-Jul-1927 - [1927] UKPC 83; [1927] AC 916  Tetteh Animle Ii v Theophilus Kwabla Otibo and Another [1927] UKPC 84 25 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth (Gold Coast Colony) [ Bailii ]  The Corporation of The City of Toronto and Another v The Consumers Gas Company Toronto (Ontario) [1927] UKPC 88 26 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maung Po Nyun v Ma Saw Tin (Rangoon) [1927] UKPC 87 26 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council v Girjabai (Bombay) [1927] UKPC 86 26 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Delhi Cloth and General Mills Company Limited (Reasons) v Income Tax Commissioner Delhi and Another (Lahore) [1927] UKPC 85 26 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gauri Shankar and Others v Jiwan Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1927] UKPC 90 28 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Luscar Colliers Limited v N S Mcdondald and Others (Canada) [1927] UKPC 89 28 Jul 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Shaim Sundar Singh v Thakur Jagannath Singh and Another (Oudh) [1927] UKPC 94 18 Oct 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of Nova Scotia v The Legislative Council of Nova Scotia (Nova Scotia) [1927] UKPC 92 18 Oct 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Anna Vassallo and Others v George Debono and Others (Egypt) [1927] UKPC 95 18 Oct 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The City of Halifax v The Estate of James P Fairbanks and Another (Canada) [1927] UKPC 91 18 Oct 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sr Rami Chattra Kumari Devi v W W Broucke (Patna) [1927] UKPC 93 18 Oct 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  v P R v Chockalingham Chetty v Seethai Ache and Others (Rangoon) [1927] UKPC 96 28 Oct 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commissioner of Income Tax v The Western India Turf Club Limited [1927] UKPC 97 4 Nov 1927 PC Commonwealth Bombay [ Bailii ]  Jafferali Bhaloo Lakha and Others v The Standard Bank of South Africa Limited (Eastern Africa) [1927] UKPC 98 7 Nov 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Amuah Gyebu Xii Substituted for Ohene Amuah Gyebu v Ohene Kwesi Abuagyi Iii Substituted for Ohene Kwesi Abuagyi Ii (Gold Coast Colony) [1927] UKPC 99 10 Nov 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Ramanandi Kuer v Musammat Kalawati Kuer (Patna) [1927] UKPC 100 11 Nov 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kumar Baijnath Prasad Singh v Kedar Nath Goenka and Others (Patna) [1927] UKPC 102 15 Nov 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Omanhene Kweku Dua Iii v Omanhene Kwomin Tandoh (Gold Coast Colony) [1927] UKPC 101 15 Nov 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sukdevdoss Ramprasad v Diwan Bahadur Govindoss Chathurbhujadoss and Company (Madras) [1927] UKPC 104 17 Nov 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  John Lachlan Mcgilllivaray Watson v Bertha Elinor Lilian Haggitt and Others (New Zealand) [1927] UKPC 103 17 Nov 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Saw Kin and Others v Maung Tun Aung Gyaw (Rangoon) [1927] UKPC 105 21 Nov 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Martland Rao v Malhar Rao (The Court of Judical Commissioner of The Central Provinces) [1927] UKPC 106 24 Nov 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sir Bissessar Dass Daga and Others v Emmanuel Vas and Others (The Court of Judical Commissioner of The Central Provinces) [1927] UKPC 107 24 Nov 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sime Darby and Company Limited v The Official Assignee of The Estate of Lee Pang Seng (A Bankrupt) [1927] UKPC 108 28 Nov 1927 PC Commonwealth Singapore [ Bailii ]  Khushaldas Gokaldas and Others v Chimanlal Kalidas and Others (Bombay) [1927] UKPC 110 28 Nov 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ardeshir Bhicji Tamboli v The Agent Great Indian Peninsula Railway Company Bombay (Bombay) [1927] UKPC 109 28 Nov 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  P C Mathu Chettiar v K v Meenakshisundaram Ayyar and Others (Madras) [1927] UKPC 112 29 Nov 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Madhavrao Ganpatrao Desai and Others v Balabhai Raghunath Agaskar Since Deceased and Others (Bombay) [1927] UKPC 111 29 Nov 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Abdur Rahim and Others v Syed Abu Mahomed Barkat Ali Shah Since Deceased and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1927] UKPC 113 2 Dec 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bhagwan Singh and Others v Ujagar Singh (Lahore) [1927] UKPC 114 2 Dec 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Puran Chand Nahatta v Monmotho Nath Mukherjee Since Deceased and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1927] UKPC 115 5 Dec 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  John H Arseculeratne v J B M Perera [1927] UKPC 116 6 Dec 1927 PC Commonwealth Ceylon [ Bailii ]  v P R v Chockalingam Chettyar v E N M K Chettyar Firm and Others (Rangoon) [1927] UKPC 118 6 Dec 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sunder Mull and Another v Satya Kinker Sahana and Others (Patna) [1927] UKPC 119 6 Dec 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Seth Maganmal Since Deceased and Others v Darbarilal Chowdhury (The Court of Judical Commissioner of The Central Provinces) [1927] UKPC 117 6 Dec 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  R Arunachala Naydu v S R Balakrishna and Company (Madras) [1927] UKPC 120 8 Dec 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jewan Lal Daga and Another v Nilmani Chaudhuri (Patna) [1927] UKPC 121 12 Dec 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Konammal v Annadana Jaydaya Gounda (Madras) [1927] UKPC 122 15 Dec 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Benoy Kristna Mukherjee and Others v Satish Chandra Giri (Fort William (Bengal)) [1927] UKPC 123 15 Dec 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Robert Hercules Skinner v Rosy Sinner and Others (Lahore) [1927] UKPC 125 16 Dec 1927 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bhogilal Bhikachand and Others (Reasons) v The Royal Insurance Company Limited [1927] UKPC 124 16 Dec 1927 PC Commonwealth (Rangoon) [ Bailii ]  In re Douglas [1928] 29 SR (NSW) 48 1928 Commonwealth, Trusts (New South Wales) The court considered the application of the rule against self dealing as it applied to trustees' wives: "the Court of Equity would presume that the contract was for the benefit of the trustee, and evidence would be required to displace this presumption." 1 Cites 1 Citers  The Hong Kong and Shanghai Banking Corporation v Lo Lee Shi (Hong Kong) [1928] UKPC 5 19 Jan 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sir Alexandre Lacoste and Others v The Cedars Rapids Manufacturing and Power Company (Quebec) [1928] UKPC 2 19 Jan 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of Quebec and The Royal Bank of Canada v Larue and Others (Canada) [1928] UKPC 1 19 Jan 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Balaram and Others v Naktu and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner of The Central Provinces) [1928] UKPC 4 19 Jan 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dame Zoe Turgeon Since Deceased (Now Represented By Raoul Richard and Others) v The City of Quebec (Quebec) [1928] UKPC 3 19 Jan 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Bhagwati Alias Bhagwan Dei and Another v Banarsai Das and Others (Allahabad) [1928] UKPC 6 23 Jan 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Venkat Subba Shrinivas Hegde v Subba Rama Hegde (Bombay) [1928] UKPC 7 24 Jan 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rao Narsingh Rao v Beti Mahalakshmi Bai and Another (Allahabad) [1928] UKPC 8 31 Jan 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Michael Hirsch and Another v The Protestant Board of School Commissioners of The City of Montreal and Others (Canada) [1928] UKPC 10 2 Feb 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Tewari Raghuraj Chandra and Others v Rani Subhadra Kunwar and Others (Oudh) [1928] UKPC 9 2 Feb 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Bhagwan Singh v Darbarsingh [1928] UKPC 11 6 Feb 1928 PC Commonwealth The Court of The Judicial Commissioner of The Central Provinces [ Bailii ]  Baijnath Ram and Another v Gopal Ram Khemka and Others [1928] UKPC 12 9 Feb 1928 PC Commonwealth Patna [ Bailii ]  Firm Chhunna Mal-Ram Nath v Firm Mool Chand-Ram Bhagat [1928] UKPC 13 13 Feb 1928 PC Commonwealth Lahore [ Bailii ]  Jijibhoy N Surty v T S Chettyar (A Firm) [1928] UKPC 14 14 Feb 1928 PC Commonwealth Rangoon [ Bailii ]  The Master of The British Steamship Singleton Abbey v The Master of The Italian Steamship Sara (Malta) [1928] UKPC 15 16 Feb 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musa Miya Walad Mahamad Shaffi and Another v Kadar Bax Walad Khaj Bax Since Deceased and Another (Bombay) [1928] UKPC 16 21 Feb 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Hussain Bibi v Sayad Nur Hussain Shah and Others (Lahore) [1928] UKPC 17 21 Feb 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Universal Negro Improvement Association Inc and Others v Ann Rebecca Morter (British Honduras) [1928] UKPC 18 24 Feb 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jaigobind Pandey v Ramnandan Sahai and Others [1928] UKPC 19 28 Feb 1928 PC Commonwealth Patna [ Bailii ]  Srimati Hemlata Debi v Satya Charan Banerji and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1928] UKPC 20 5 Mar 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hitendra Singh Since Deceased (Now Represented By Jagdish Nandan Singh) and Others v Maharajadhiraj Sir Rameshwar Singh Bahadur and Another (Patna) [1928] UKPC 21 8 Mar 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Muthiah Chetti v Palaniappa Chetti and Others [1928] UKPC 22 12 Mar 1928 PC Commonwealth Madras [ Bailii ]  The Banking Service Corporation Limited Now Called Brooks Securities Limited v The Toronto Finance Corporation Limited and Another [1928] UKPC 23 12 Mar 1928 PC Commonwealth Ontario [ Bailii ]  Motilal and Another v Thakur Ujiar Singh and Another (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner of The Central Provinces) [1928] UKPC 24 15 Mar 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ramkisan Singh and Others v Mohammad Abdul Sattar and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner of The Central Provinces) [1928] UKPC 25 15 Mar 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kumar Kamakhya Narayan Singh v Ram Raksha Singh and Others (Patna) [1928] UKPC 26 22 Mar 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nawab Sadiq Ali Khan and Others v Jai Kishori and Others (Oudh) [1928] UKPC 27 22 Mar 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaja Bahadur Kesho Prashad Singh v Madho Prashad Singh and Others (Patna) [1928] UKPC 28 23 Mar 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kunwar Jang Bahadur v The Bank of Upper India Limited Lucknow In Liquidation (Oudh) [1928] UKPC 29 29 Mar 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Thakur Ashutosh Deo Ghatwai and Another v Bansidhar Shroff (Patna) [1928] UKPC 32 24 Apr 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sakalaguna Nayudu and Another v Chinna Munuswami Nayakar (Madras) [1928] UKPC 31 24 Apr 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Guran Ditta and Another v T Ram Ditta (The Court of The North-West Frontier Province) [1928] UKPC 30 24 Apr 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council v Parbati Charan Shaha Since Deceased, and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1928] UKPC 33 30 Apr 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Rajah Bommadevara Naganna Nayudu Bahadur and Another v Sri Rajah Bommadevara Rajya Lakshmi Devi Amma Garu (Madras) [1928] UKPC 34 4 May 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rikhi Ram and Another v Dhanpat Rai and Others (Lahore) [1928] UKPC 35 8 May 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Parashuram Detaram Shamdasani and Another v The Tata Industrial Bank Limited and Others (Bombay) [1928] UKPC 36 8 May 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  David Moyal and Another v Ahmed Mohamed Halawe (Palestine) [1928] UKPC 37 10 May 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ramgopal and Others v Dhanji Jadhavji Bhatia Trading Under The Name of The Andani Company (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner of The Central Provinces) [1928] UKPC 38 17 May 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jean Horsborough Thompson v Alister Kyle Jefferson [1928] UKPC 40 17 May 1928 PC Commonwealth (Australia) [ Bailii ]  The Dominion Press Limited v The Minister of Customs and Excise (Canada) [1928] UKPC 39 17 May 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  William Edward Akaje Macauley v The Judges of The Supreme Court of Sierra Leone and Another (Sierra Leone) [1928] UKPC 42 18 May 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ruhulla Alias Hakin Hamad and Others v Hassanalli Degumia (Bombay) [1928] UKPC 41 18 May 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maung Shwe Myo v Maung Po Wa (Rangoon) [1928] UKPC 43 18 May 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Tom Boevey Barrett v African Products Limited (Gold Coast Colony) [1928] UKPC 48 21 May 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   The South British Insurance Company Limited v Gauci Brothers and Company; PC 21-May-1928 - [1928] UKPC 47  Firm Tejpal-Jamna Das v Ernest v David Official Receiver and Others (Allahabad) [1928] UKPC 49 21 May 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Deputy Commissioner of Bara Banki Manager of The Estate of Chaudhri Mujtaba Husain v The Receiver In Bankruptcy of The Estate of Chaudhri Shafiq-Uz-Zaman and Others (Oudh) [1928] UKPC 45 21 May 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ardeshir H Mama v Flora Sassoon (Bombay) [1928] UKPC 44 21 May 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chaudhrain Zarif-Un-Nisa Bibi and Others v Chaudhri Shafiq-Uz-Zaman Khan and Others (Oudh) [1928] UKPC 46 21 May 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maung Ba Pe and Another Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Maung Aung Thin) v Maung Shwe Ba (Lower Burma) [1928] UKPC 50 22 May 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  W C Mcdonald Registered v Fred Latimer and Others (Ontario) [1928] UKPC 52 12 Jun 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The King v The Caledonian Collieries Limited (Canada) [1928] UKPC 55 12 Jun 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rajah Bejoy Singh Dudhoria v Surendra Narayan Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1928] UKPC 54 12 Jun 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Munnu Singh and Others v Hira Lal and Others (Oudh) [1928] UKPC 53 12 Jun 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Board of Trustees of The Roman Catholic Separate Schools for Schools Section No 2 In The Township of Tiny and Others v The King (Canada) [1928] UKPC 51 12 Jun 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Karnani Industrial Bank Limited v Satya Niran Shaw and Another [1928] UKPC 58 14 Jun 1928 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  The Karnani Industrial Bank Limited v Satya Niran Shaw and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1928] UKPC 59 14 Jun 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Raja Rao Sri Swetachalapati Ramakrishna Ranga Rao Bahadur Garu Raja of Bobbili v Ayyagari Sodemma (Madras) [1928] UKPC 61 14 Jun 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council v Valarpuram Kandadai Ramanujachiar and Others (Madras) [1928] UKPC 60 14 Jun 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  H Pestonji and Company and Others v Cox and Company (Bombay) [1928] UKPC 57 14 Jun 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Molapo Mojela v Thabo Lerotholi Mojela (Basutoland) [1928] UKPC 62 15 Jun 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Eleko v The Officer Administering The Government of Nigeria and Another [1928] UKPC 63 19 Jun 1928 PC Commonwealth Nigeria [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of Alberta v The Attorney General of Canada (Canada) [1928] UKPC 64 19 Jun 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Narendra Nath Dutta and Another v Sheik Abdul Hakim and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1928] UKPC 65 21 Jun 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Parashuram Detaram Shamdasani and Another (Reasons) v The Tata Industrial Bank Ltd and Others (Bombay) [1928] UKPC 66 21 Jun 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Rector and Churchwardens of The Parish of St Nicholas Acons v The London County Council (The Arches Court of Canterbury) [1928] UKPC 67 25 Jun 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kessarbai v Jethabhai Jivan (Bombay) [1928] UKPC 68 28 Jun 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kishan Singh v The King-Emperor (Allahabad) [1928] UKPC 69 2 Jul 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gauri Nath Kakaji v Musammat Gaya Kuar (Oudh) [1928] UKPC 70 5 Jul 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dame Hermine Belanger v Marie Yvonne Henriette Fraser (Quebec) [1928] UKPC 71 13 Jul 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Inglewood Pulp and Paper Company Limited v The New Brunswick Electric Power Commission (New Brunswick) [1928] UKPC 72 20 Jul 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Vaishno Ditti v Musammat Rameshri and Others (North-West Frontier Province) [1928] UKPC 73 20 Jul 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Bank of Athens v The Firm A G Pilavachi (Cyprus) [1928] UKPC 74 24 Jul 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Secretary of State for India In Council v Volkart Brothers Through Their Authorised Agent H Bachtold (Madras) [1928] UKPC 75 24 Jul 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Adamson and Others v The Melbourne and Metropolitan Board of Works; PC 15-Oct-1928 - [1928] UKPC 77  Inche Noriah Binte Mohamed Tahir v Shaik Allie Bin Omar Bin Abdullah Bahashuan (Singapore) [1928] UKPC 76 15 Oct 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Canadian Spool Cotton Company Limited v The City of Montreal (Quebec) [1928] UKPC 78 16 Oct 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gulam Hussein Ahmed Somaji and Others v The Land Acquisition Officer South Salette Bandra (Bombay) [1928] UKPC 79 16 Oct 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Srimati Tara Kumari and Another v Tribeni Prasad Singh and Another (Patna) [1928] UKPC 80 19 Oct 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bal Kishen Alias Balli Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Bansidhar and Others) v Ram Charan and Another (Allahabad) [1928] UKPC 81 20 Oct 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Messrs Juggi Lal-Kamalapat of Cawnpore and Others v The Swadeshi Mills Company Limited of Bombay (Allahabad) [1928] UKPC 82 2 Nov 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Governor and Company of Adventures of England Trading Into Hudson'S Bay v The Attorney General of Canada and Others (Canada) [1928] UKPC 83 9 Nov 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  K L S v E Annamalai Chetty v K L S v E Subramanian Chetty and Others (Madras) [1928] UKPC 84 9 Nov 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Special Reference In The Matter of Certain Questions Relating To The Payment of Compensation To Civil Servants Under Article X of The Articles of Agreement for A Treaty Between Great Britain and Ireland (Report of The Lords of The Judicial Committee) v [1928] UKPC 85 13 Nov 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kwesi Bediaku v Akosua Mainoo (Gold Coast Colony) [1928] UKPC 87 15 Nov 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Stephen Broomfield v Percival Austin Benjamin (Jamaica) [1928] UKPC 88 15 Nov 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Peddi Reddi Jogi Reddi v Panem Chinnabbi Reddi and Others (Madras) [1928] UKPC 86 15 Nov 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Yellappa Ramappa Nak and Others v Tippanna Bin Laxmanna Naik (Bombay) [1928] UKPC 89 16 Nov 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rajah Shri Prakash Singh v The Allahabad Bank Limited (Lucknow Branch) (Lucknow) [1928] UKPC 93 23 Nov 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Archaryashri Sripati Prasad Bihari Lalji Maharaj v Barot Laxmidas Dungerbai and Others (Bombay) [1928] UKPC 91 23 Nov 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Pope Appliance Corporation v The Spanish River Pulp and Paper Mills Limited (Canada) [1928] UKPC 90 23 Nov 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rajah Keesara Venkatappayya Since Deceased, and Others v Rajah Nayani Venkata Ranga Row (Madras) [1928] UKPC 92 23 Nov 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shrimant Lakhamgowda Basavaprabhu Sar Desai v Appanna Bin Basaprabhu Ili and Others (Bombay) [1928] UKPC 94 27 Nov 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mohendra Nath Biswas and Others v Baikuntha Nath Roy Chowdhury and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1928] UKPC 96 27 Nov 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bomanji Ardeshir Wadia and Others v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Bombay) [1928] UKPC 95 27 Nov 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Manickavachaga Desikar and Others v Paramasivan Alias Ramaswami Desikar and Others (Madras) [1928] UKPC 100 30 Nov 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Ngwe Naing v Maung The Maung (Rangoon) [1928] UKPC 99 30 Nov 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Srimati Sarat Kumari Bibi Appeal No 21 of 1927) v Rai Sakhi Chand Bahadur and Others (Patna) [1928] UKPC 98 30 Nov 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jonathan Collins Zizer v The Judges of The Supreme Court of Nigeria (Nigeria) [1928] UKPC 97 30 Nov 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sreemati Kristna Promada Dasi v Dhirendra Nath Ghosh and Others [1928] UKPC 101 3 Dec 1928 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Mohammad Wajid Ali Khan v Puran Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1928] UKPC 102 6 Dec 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of Manitoba and Another v The Attorney General of Canada and Another (Manitoba) [1928] UKPC 103 10 Dec 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Tan Chew Hoe Neo v Chee Swee Cheng and Others (Singapore) [1928] UKPC 104 10 Dec 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mohomed Ali Mamoojee v William Stansfield Grosvenor Harvey and Others [1928] UKPC 105 13 Dec 1928 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Lewis Pugh Evans Pugh v Ashutosh Sen and Others (Patna) [1928] UKPC 108 14 Dec 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Wearne Brothers Limited v The Russa Engineering Works Limited and Others [1928] UKPC 107 14 Dec 1928 PC Commonwealth (Rangoon) [ Bailii ]  Sennimalai Goundan and Another v Sellappa Goundan and Others (Madras) [1928] UKPC 106 14 Dec 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ram Charan Ramanuj Das Mohant v Gobinda Ramanuj Das Mohant and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1928] UKPC 112 17 Dec 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rajah Udit Narain Singh Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Rajah Harnam Singh v Shaikh Mubarak Ali and Others (Oudh) [1928] UKPC 111 17 Dec 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   Hariram Serowgee v Madan Gopal Bagla and Another; PC 17-Dec-1928 - [1928] UKPC 110  Keshavrao Vasantrao Vijayakar v Nanabhai Sadanand and Others (Bombay) [1928] UKPC 109 17 Dec 1928 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Atmaram Bhagwant Ghadgay v The Collector of Nagpur (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner of The Central Provinces) [1929] UKPC 2 22 Jan 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kumar Gopika Raman Roy v Atal Singh and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1929] UKPC 3 22 Jan 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharajadhiraj Sir Rameshwar Singh and Another v Bajit Lal Pathak and Others (Patna) [1929] UKPC 1 22 Jan 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Olive Finch v The Commissioner of Stamp Duties (New Zealand) [1929] UKPC 4 22 Jan 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ramdutt Ramkissen Dass v E. D. Sassoon and Company (Fort William (Bengal)) [1929] UKPC 5 24 Jan 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commonwealth of Australia v The State of New South Wales and Another (Australia) [1929] UKPC 6 29 Jan 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Haveli Shah and Another v Charan Das Since Deceased and Others (Baluchistan) [1929] UKPC 8 31 Jan 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Percy Arundel Rabett and Others v The Commissioner of Stamp Duties (New South Wales) [1929] UKPC 7 31 Jan 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]   The Canadian Performing Right Society Limited v The Famous Players Canadian Corporation Limited; PC 1-Feb-1929 - [1929] UKPC 9  Bhagat Ram v Khetu Ram and Another (Perak) [1929] UKPC 10 1 Feb 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  U Po Naing v The Burma Oil Company Limited (Rangoon) [1929] UKPC 11 4 Feb 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rakhal Chandra Basak and Others v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Fort William (Bengal)) [1929] UKPC 12 5 Feb 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Vallabhdas Naranji Khot of Kanjur v The Collector Under Act 1 of 1894 (Bombay) [1929] UKPC 14 11 Feb 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Binda Prasad and Another v Lala Kishori Saran and Others (Allahabad) [1929] UKPC 13 11 Feb 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Sin and Others v The Collector of Rangoon (Rangoon) [1929] UKPC 15 12 Feb 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Y. Seethayya and Others v P. Subramanya Somayajulu and Another and 9 Connected Appeals (Madras) [1929] UKPC 16 14 Feb 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gurudas Kundu Chowdhury and Others v Kumar Hemendra Kumar Roy and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1929] UKPC 17 14 Feb 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  K. T. Ganapathy Pillay v Alamaloo and Another (Selangor) [1929] UKPC 18 18 Feb 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  William Herald Thompson and Others v The Commissioner of Stamp Duties (New South Wales) (Australia) [1929] UKPC 19 19 Feb 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rani Srimati Krishna Kumari Devi v Bhaiya Rajendra Bahadur Sinha Deo and Another (Lucknow) [1929] UKPC 20 21 Feb 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Amjad Khan v Ashraf Khan and Others (Oudh) [1929] UKPC 21 26 Feb 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Bhawani Singh v Maulvi Misbah-Ud-Din (Lahore) [1929] UKPC 22 26 Feb 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Jwaladutt R. Pillani v Raja Bahadur Bansilal Motilal (Bombay) [1929] UKPC 24 28 Feb 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Henry Greer Robinson v The State of South Australia (South Australia) [1929] UKPC 23 28 Feb 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Ekradeshwari Bahuasin Saheba v Homeshwar Singh and Others (Patna) [1929] UKPC 25 5 Mar 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Reshee Case Law v Satis Chandra Pal and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1929] UKPC 26 5 Mar 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mohabbat Ali Khan v Muhammad Ibrahim Khan and Others (The Judicial Commissioner of The North-West Frontier Province) [1929] UKPC 27 7 Mar 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Khoo Sain Ban v Tan Guat Tean and Others (Rangoon) [1929] UKPC 28 11 Mar 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ram Sunder Lal and Another v Lachhmi Narain and Another (Allahabad) [1929] UKPC 31 15 Mar 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Faizullah Khan and Another v Mauladad Khan and Others (The Judicial Commissioner of The North-West Frontier Province) [1929] UKPC 29 15 Mar 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Saheb Meharban-I-Dostan Sri Raja Rao Venkata Kumara Mahipati Surya Rao Bahadur Garu Raja of Pittapur v The Secretary of State for India In Council Represented By The Collector of Godaveri (Madras) [1929] UKPC 32 15 Mar 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lal Narsingh Partab Bahadur Singh v Mohammad Yaqub Khan and Others (Lucknow) [1929] UKPC 30 15 Mar 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  James Richard Rennel Skinner v Kunwar Naunihal Singh (Allahabad) [1929] UKPC 34 19 Mar 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Prafulla Nath Tagore v Satya Bhusan Das and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1929] UKPC 33 19 Mar 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Subrahmanya Chettiyar and Others v V. P. Subrahmanya Mudaliyar and Others (Madras) [1929] UKPC 35 19 Mar 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Charles Hubert Kinch v Edward Keith Walcott and Others (Barbados) [1929] UKPC 36 19 Mar 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Satya Niranjan Chakravarty and Others v Srimati Sarajubala Debi and Another (Fort William (Bengal)) [1929] UKPC 37 21 Mar 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Saiyid Qasim Husain and Others v Habibur Rahman and Others (Patna) [1929] UKPC 38 15 Apr 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Vallabhdas Naranji Khot of Kanjur v The Development Officer Bandra (Bombay) [1929] UKPC 39 16 Apr 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bhimnath Missir and Others v Srimati Tara Dai and Others (Patna) [1929] UKPC 40 16 Apr 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Jaggo Bai v Utsava Lal (Allahabad) [1929] UKPC 41 19 Apr 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Mya and Another v Ma Me Kyin and Another (Rangoon) [1929] UKPC 42 23 Apr 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nuh-Ulah Khan and Others v Mohammad Shafiq- Ullah Khan (Allahabad) [1929] UKPC 43 2 May 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bhuban Mohan Basak v The Chairman of Municipal Commissioner of The Dacca Municipality and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1929] UKPC 44 7 May 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ramji Patel v Rao Kishotesingh (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner of The Central Provinces) [1929] UKPC 45 9 May 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Maine and Brunswick Electrical Power Company Limited v Alice M. Hart (New Brunswick) [1929] UKPC 46 13 May 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hira Lal Sahu and Others v Raj Kumar Babu Lachhmi Prasad Narain Singh (Patna) [1929] UKPC 48 14 May 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Fetch Singh Nahar and Another v Nirmal Chandra Banerjee and Another [1929] UKPC 49 14 May 1929 PC Commonwealth Fort William (Bengal) [ Bailii ]  Bhai Panna Singh and Others v Firm Bhai Arjan Singh-Bhajan Singh- Surjan Singh and Another (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner of The North-West Frontier Province) [1929] UKPC 47 14 May 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sheth Mafatlal Gaglbai v Sheth Jivanlal Girdhardas and Another (Bombay) [1929] UKPC 51 4 Jun 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Netherlandsche Handel Maatschappij (Commonly Called Netherlands Trading Society) v R. M. P. Chettiar Firm and Others (Rangoon) [1929] UKPC 50 4 Jun 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gnanendra Kumar Roy Chowhury and Others v Prafulla Nath Thakur (Fort William (Bengal)) [1929] UKPC 52 4 Jun 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kunwar Malayam Singh and Another v Sheoraj Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1929] UKPC 53 6 Jun 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Satish Chandra Joardar and Others v Kumar Birendra Nath Roy Bahadur (Fort William (Bengal)) [1929] UKPC 54 7 Jun 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Benjamin F. Groat v The Hydo-Electric Power Commission of Ontario (Ontario) [1929] UKPC 55 10 Jun 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Maharaj Bahadur Singh and Others v A. H. Forbes (Patna) [1929] UKPC 56 11 Jun 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Joydurga Dasi v Saroj Ranjan Sinha and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1929] UKPC 57 11 Jun 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Albert Bonnan v The Imperial Trading Company of India Limited (Fort William (Bengal)) [1929] UKPC 58 13 Jun 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dorothy Valentine Burnard v William Douglas Lysnar (New Zealand) [1929] UKPC 59 13 Jun 1929 PC Commonwealth (New Zealand) [ Bailii ]  Radhoba Baloba Vagh and Others v Aburao Bhagwantrao Shirole and Others (Bombay) [1929] UKPC 60 14 Jun 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kunwar Muhammad Abdul Jalil Khan and Others v Khan Bahadur Muhammad Obaid Ullah Khan and Others (Allahabad) [1929] UKPC 61 17 Jun 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Shib Chandra and Another v Lachmi Narain and Others (Allahabad) [1929] UKPC 62 21 Jun 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Robert Hall and Another v The Pelmadulla Valley Tea and Rubber Company Limited (Ceylon) [1929] UKPC 63 27 Jun 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Mahant Basdeva Nand Gir v Mahant Shantanand Gir [1929] UKPC 64 28 Jun 1929 PC Commonwealth (Allahabad) [ Bailii ]  Bakare Ajakaiye and Another v The Lieutentant-Governor, Souther Provinces (Nigeria) [1929] UKPC 65 1 Jul 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sri Rajah Bommadevara Naganna Naidu Bahadur (Since Struck Out) and Another v Yelamanchili Pitchayya and Others (Madras) [1929] UKPC 66 1 Jul 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  R. M. A. R. R. M. Arunachalam Chetti v V. E. A. Vayiravan Chetti and Others (Madras) [1929] UKPC 68 4 Jul 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Cheang Thye Phin v Lam Kin Sang and Others (Penang) [1929] UKPC 67 4 Jul 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Pateshwari Partab Narain Singh Since Deceased, (Now Represented By Raja Jwaleshwari Partab Narain Singh) v Sita Ram and Others (Lucknow) [1929] UKPC 70 5 Jul 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Messrs Kamlapat-Moti Lal v The Union Indian Sugar Mills Company Limited (In Liquidation) (Allahabad) [1929] UKPC 69 5 Jul 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Purna Chandra Sett and Others v The Kamarhati Company Limited (Fort William (Bengal)) [1929] UKPC 72 9 Jul 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Honasa Ramasa Lad Dhakad and Others v Kalyanchand Lalchand Patni Gujrathi and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner of The Central Provinces) [1929] UKPC 71 9 Jul 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  James R. R. Skinner v Robert Hercules Skinner and Others (Allahabad) [1929] UKPC 74 16 Jul 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Eugene Berthiaume v Dame Anne-Marie Yvonne Dastous (Quebec) [1929] UKPC 73 16 Jul 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Pwa May and Another v S.R.M.M.A. Chettyar Firm (Rangoon) [1929] UKPC 76 25 Jul 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raghunath Prasad Singh and Another v The Deputy Commissioner Partabgarh and Others (Lucknow) [1929] UKPC 75 25 Jul 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  ES and A Robinson Limited v The Wayagamack Pulp and Paper Company Limited [1929] UKPC 77 26 Jul 1929 PC Commonwealth Quebec [ Bailii ]  The Midnapur Zamindar Y Company Limited v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Fort William (Bengal)) [1929] UKPC 78 29 Jul 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bijai Saran Sahi Alias Bijai Bahadur Sahi and Others v Rudra Bageshwari Prasad Bahadur Sahi and Others (Allahabad) [1929] UKPC 79 29 Jul 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Dominion Building Corporation Limited v The King (Canada) [1929] UKPC 82 15 Oct 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lugi Ambrosini Limited v Bakare Tinko and Another (Nigeria) [1929] UKPC 81 15 Oct 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Attorney General of Canada v The Attorney General of British Columbia and Others (Canada) [1929] UKPC 80 15 Oct 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Canadian General Electric Company Limited v Fada Radio Limited (Canada) [1929] UKPC 83 15 Oct 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Daniel Eugene Lecavalier v The City of Montreal (Quebec) [1929] UKPC 84 15 Oct 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Corporation of The City of St. Catherines v The Hydo-Electric Power Commission of Ontario (Ontario) [1929] UKPC 85 17 Oct 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Edwards and Others v The Attorney General of Canada Appeal No. 121 of 1928; [1930] AC 124; [1929] UKPC 86 18 Oct 1929 PC Lord Sankey LC Commonwealth, Constitutional (Canada) A constitutional Act act should not be interpreted narrowly or technically. Rights in conventions, treaties and like instruments are interpreted like a "living tree capable of growth and expansion within its natural limits." (Lord Sankey LC), and "Customs are apt to develop into traditions which are stronger than law and remain unchallenged long after the reason for them has disappeared." 1 Citers [ Bailii ]  Sri Rajah Nallaparaju Mira Atchutharamaraju Garu and Others v Kruttiventi Perraju Garu and Others (Madras) [1929] UKPC 88 21 Oct 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  John Stirrett and Sons Limited v The Kaministiquia Power Company Limited (Ontario) [1929] UKPC 87 21 Oct 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The National Bank of India Limited (In Liquidation) v Bansidhar and Another (Lucknow) [1929] UKPC 89 24 Oct 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Pir Sidik Mahomed Shah v Musammat Saran Since Deceased and Another (Sind) [1929] UKPC 90 25 Oct 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Yait and Others v The Official Assignee (Rangoon) [1929] UKPC 91 28 Oct 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Ma Safdar Alias Gondumiya and Another v Mirza Maksudali Beg (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner of The Central Provinces) [1929] UKPC 92 29 Oct 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Musammat Fatma Bibi and Others v Saadat Ali and Others (Allahabad) [1929] UKPC 95 31 Oct 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Royal Trust Company v The Attorney General of Alberta (Alberta) [1929] UKPC 93 31 Oct 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Dal Bahadur Singh and Others v Bijai Bahadur Singh and Others (Allahabad) [1929] UKPC 94 31 Oct 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Raja Mohammad Mumtaz Ali Khan v Dhanna Singh Since Deceased, and Others (Oudh) [1929] UKPC 96 1 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Balkisan Devchand and Others v Kunjalal Hiralal Agarwalla Since Deceased, and Others (Bombay) [1929] UKPC 97 1 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Nawab Khajeh Habibullah Saheb and Others v Raja Janaki Nath Roy and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1929] UKPC 98 4 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commissioner of Income Tax v The Ahmedabad New Cotton Mills Company Limited (Bombay) [1929] UKPC 99 4 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Knut Knutson v The Attorney General (Nigeria) [1929] UKPC 101 7 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Eric Beach Company Limited v The Attorney General of Ontario (Ontario) [1929] UKPC 100 7 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hota Virabhadrayya Garu v Sri Raja Manyam Mahalakshmamma Garu and Others (Madras) [1929] UKPC 102 8 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Muddana Virayya v Muddana Adenna Since Deceased, and Others (Madras) [1929] UKPC 103 12 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Tuan Man Bin Tuan Lebeh and Another v Mak Ah Cheang (Malay (Ipoh)) [1929] UKPC 104 12 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Julien Marret v Mahomed Khaleel Shirazi and Sons and Others (Madras) [1929] UKPC 106 15 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Abraham Essell v Rebecca Davis Per John Ekwan Sampson (Gold Coast Colony) [1929] UKPC 105 15 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sheikh Roshan Ali Khan and Another v Chaudhri Asghar Ali and Others and 6 Connected Appeals (Lucknow) [1929] UKPC 108 19 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Kalipada De and Others v Dwijapada Das and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1929] UKPC 107 19 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Bon Kwi and Others v The Firm of S.K.R.S.K.R. By Its Agent Latchmanan Chetty and Others (Rangoon) [1929] UKPC 109 21 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Cheesebrough Manufacturing Company Consolidated v Ibrahim Lebbe Abdul Kudhoos (Ceylon) [1929] UKPC 110 22 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sadasheo v Vithoba and Others (The Court of The Judicial Commissioner of The Central Provinces) [1929] UKPC 112 22 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Vellasawmy Servai and Others v L. Sivaraman Servai (Rangoon) [1929] UKPC 111 22 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Chung Chuck and Others v Rex and Others (British Columbia) [1929] UKPC 113 25 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  The Commissioner of Income Tax Bombay Presidency v The Bombay Trust Corporation Limited As Agent of The Hong Kong Trust Corporation Limited (Bombay) [1929] UKPC 114 26 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Surendra Nath Karan Deo v Kumar Kamakhya Narain Singh (Patna) [1929] UKPC 115 29 Nov 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gangabai Kom Baswantrao Desai and Others v Fakirgowda Somappaagowda Desai and Others (Bombay) [1929] UKPC 117 3 Dec 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Gudivada Mangamma (Reasons) v Maddi Mahalakshamma (Madras) [1929] UKPC 116 3 Dec 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Amiruddi Gazi and Others v Makhan Lal Chatterjee and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1929] UKPC 118 5 Dec 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Rai Pramatha Nath Mullick Bahadur v The Secretary of State for India In Council (Fort William (Bengal)) [1929] UKPC 120 6 Dec 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Harry Kempson Gray and Another v Bhagu Mian and Others (Patna) [1929] UKPC 119 6 Dec 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Atta Mohammad v The King Emperor (Lahore) [1929] UKPC 121 6 Dec 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Hunsraj and Others v Bejoy Lal Seal and Others (Fort William (Bengal)) [1929] UKPC 124 12 Dec 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Lala Ram Narain and Others v Radha Kishen Moti Lal Chamaria (A Firm) (Lucknow) [1929] UKPC 122 12 Dec 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Sir Hukumchand Kasliwal Kt and Another v Radha Kishen Moti Lal Chamaria (A Firm) (Lucknow) [1929] UKPC 123 12 Dec 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Baboo Asharfi (Reasons) v The Judges of The High Court of Judicature At Allahabad (Allahabad) [1929] UKPC 125 13 Dec 1929 PC Commonwealth [ Bailii ]  Wali Mohammad and Others v Mohammad Bakhsh Since Deceased, and Others (Lahore) [1929] UKPC 126 16 Dec 1929 PC Commonwealth, Land [ Bailii ]  |
Copyright 2014 David Swarbrick, 10 Halifax Road, Brighouse, West Yorkshire HD6 2AG. |