Site icon swarb.co.uk

Kapri v The Lord Advocate for and On Behalf of The Court of First Instance Judicial District of Elbasan, Albania: HCJ 2 Feb 2012

The applicant objected to his proposed extradition to Albania, saying that he would not receive a fair trial. An examination of the reports disclosed that counsel for the Lord Advocate’s analysis of them was correct. None of the examples of the particular deficiencies in the judicial system impacted on circumstances in which the appellant would find himself if returned to face trial in Albania. The material which they contained was of a wholly general nature, and it contained nothing to suggest that any of the concerns identified would apply to his case. Lord Turnbull said: ‘Nothing within either report supports the appellant’s contention that ‘he’ would face an unfair trial on his return to Albania or in any way supports his contention that any retrial would lack the fundamental requirements of article 6. We note also that nothing in either report bears upon the question of whether any such retrial would comply with the particular requirements referred to in section 85(8) of the Act. Accordingly, in our view, the proposed new evidence contained in the reports prepared by Dr Bogdani and Ms Vickers is irrelevant to the ground of appeal in question and ought not to be admitted for this reason.’

Judges:

(Lady Paton, Lord Turnbull and Lord Marnoch

Citations:

[2012] ScotHC HCJAC – 17

Links:

Bailii

Statutes:

Extradition Act 2003

Cited by:

See AlsoKapri v The Lord Advocate Representing The Government of The Republic of Albania HCJ 1-Jun-2012
. .
At HCJKapri v The Lord Advocate (Representing The Government of The Republic of Albania) SC 10-Jul-2013
The Court was asked whether it would be compatible with the appellant’s Convention rights within the meaning of the Human Rights Act 1998 for the appellant, who is an Albanian national, to be extradited to Albania. On 7 April 2001, while he was in . .
See AlsoKapri v Her Majesty’s Advocate (For The Republic of Albania) HCJ 25-Apr-2014
. .
See AlsoKapri v Her Majesty’s Advocate, Re In The Application By (Albania) HCJ 17-Jun-2014
. .
Lists of cited by and citing cases may be incomplete.

Scotland, Extradition

Updated: 04 October 2022; Ref: scu.451013

Exit mobile version