Links: Home | swarblaw - law discussions

swarb.co.uk - law index


These cases are from the lawindexpro database. They are now being transferred to the swarb.co.uk website in a better form. As a case is published there, an entry here will link to it. The swarb.co.uk site includes many later cases.  














Environment - From: 1999 To: 1999

This page lists 32 cases, and was prepared on 27 May 2018.

 
Mott and Another v Environment Agency Times, 25 January 1999
25 Jan 1999
CA

Environment
A bylaw allowing the placing of fixed engines for the purposes of fishing for eels was not made in excess of the statutory power of the authority, and the Agency was liable in damages for having unlawfully seized the applicants' eel fishing equipment.
Salmon and Freshwater Fisheries Act 1975

 
Regina v Northumbrian Water Limited, Ex Parte Newcastle and North Tyneside Health Authority Gazette, 03 February 1999; [1998] All ER (D) 733
3 Feb 1999
QBD

Environment
A water company's duty as regards fluoridation of water supplies, is to have regard to the interests of its shareholders, not the general public good. Having considered this with the Health authority, it had the choice as a private company to choose.
Water Industry Act 1991 87


 
 Regina v North Yorkshire County Council, ex parte Brown and Another; HL 12-Feb-1999 - Gazette, 03 June 1999; Times, 12 February 1999; [1999] UKHL 7; [1999] 2 WLR 452; [2000] 1 AC 397; [1999] 1 PLR 116; [1999] 1 All ER 969
 
Regina v Durham County Council Sherburn Stone Company Limited Secretary of State for Environment, Transport and Regions ex parte Rodney Huddleston [1999] EWCA Civ 792
15 Feb 1999
CA

Planning, Environment

1 Citers

[ Bailii ]
 
European Parliament v Council of the European Union 162111 C-164/97
25 Feb 1999
ECJ

Agriculture, Environment
ECJ Regulations on the protection of forests against atmospheric pollution and fire - Legal basis - Article 43 of the EC Treaty - Article 130s of the EC Treaty - Parliament's prerogatives.
Europa "It is clear from the provisions of the amended regulations that the aims of the Community schemes for the protection of forests are partly agricultural since they are intended in particular to contribute to safeguarding the productive potential of agriculture, and partly of a specifically environmental nature, since their primary objective is to maintain and monitor forest ecosystems.
In such circumstances it is necessary, in order to determine the appropriate legal basis, to consider whether the measures in question relate principally to a particular field of action, having only incidental effects on other policies, or whether both aspects are equally essential. If the first hypothesis is correct, recourse to a single legal basis is sufficient …; if the second is correct, it is insufficient … and the institution is required to adopt the measure on the basis of both the provisions from which its competence derives … . However, no such dual basis is possible where the procedures laid down for each legal basis are incompatible with each other … .
With more particular reference to the common agricultural policy and the Community environmental policy, there is nothing in the case-law to indicate that, in principle, one should take preference over the other. It makes clear that a Community measure cannot be part of Community action on environmental matters merely because it takes account of requirements of protection referred to in Article 130r(2) of the EC Treaty … . Articles 130r and 130s leave intact the powers held by the Community under other provisions of the Treaty and provide a legal basis only for specific action on environmental matters … . In contrast, Article 130s of the Treaty must be the basis for provisions which fall specifically within the environmental policy …, even if they have an impact on the functioning of the internal market … or if their objective is the improvement of agricultural production …
1 Citers


 
P and O Scottish Ferries Ltd v The Braer Corporation Times, 10 March 1999
10 Mar 1999
OHCS

Environment
The Act excluded wider claims than those prescribed within it. Economic losses arising for a ferry company losing out because of adverse publicity were not to be claimed. The Act is clear and there is no need to refer back to the Convention on which it was based.
Merchant Shipping (Oil Pollution) Act 1971 1 - International Convention on Civil Liability for Oil Pollution Damage

 
Gray and Another v Braer Corporation and Others Times, 10 March 1999
10 Mar 1999
OHCS

Environment
The Act limited claims generally to three years after any damage arose with a back-stop maximum of six years after which no claim at all could be begun. Section is a prescriptive provision not by way of a limitation period as such.
Merchant Shipping (Oil Pollution) Act 1971 9

 
Regina v Milford Haven Port Authority Gazette, 10 March 1999
10 Mar 1999
Crwn

Environment
A four million pound fine for a major pollution event was proper to reflect the genuine and justified public concern which had been caused. If damage flowed directly from the conduct of a business, the business was as liable as those directly responsible.
Water Resources Act 1991 85(1)

 
Commission v France (Judgment) C-166/97; [1999] ECR I-1719
18 Mar 1999
ECJ

European, Environment
ECJ A Member State may not plead provisions, practices or circumstances existing in its internal legal system in order to justify a failure to comply with the obligations and time-limits laid down in a directive. In an action under Article 169 of the Treaty, the question whether a Member State has failed to fulfil its obligations must be determined by reference to the situation prevailing at the end of the period laid down in the reasoned opinion. Article 4(1) and (2) of Directive 79/409 on the conservation of wild birds requires the Member States to provide the special protection areas referred to therein with a legal protection regime that is capable, in particular, of ensuring both the survival and reproduction of the bird species listed in Annex I to the directive and the breeding, moulting and wintering of migratory species which are regular visitors, albeit not listed in that annex. A protection regime under which - for want of any specific substantive measures, except in relation to hunting - the only status enjoyed by a special protection area is that of State-owned land and of a maritime game reserve is incapable of providing adequate protection for the purposes of those provisions. 4 Under Article 4(4) of Directive 79/409 on the conservation of wild birds, Member States are required to take appropriate steps to avoid pollution and deterioration of the habitats of the species concerned, even in relation to an area which has not been classified as a special protection area provided that, under the directive, it should have been so classified. It follows that any infringement of that provision presupposes that the area in question is one of the most suitable territories in number and size for the conservation of protected species, within the meaning of the fourth subparagraph of Article 4(1) of the directive which lays down the criteria for such classification. In this connection, the mere fact that a site has been included by a Member State in an inventory of important areas for bird conservation does not prove that it ought to have been classified as a special protection area.
1 Citers



 
 Regina v St Edmundsbury Borough Council (ex parte Walton); Admn 13-Apr-1999 - Times, 05 May 1999; [1999] JPL 805; [1999] EWHC Admin 298
 
Regina v Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, ex parte Bray Gazette, 21 April 1999; Times, 13 April 1999; [1999] EWHC Admin 252
13 Apr 1999
QBD

Environment, Agriculture
A bylaw, restricting fishing by reference to the size of the ship, was valid. The words must not be construed out of context of the whole Act, and in this case an 'instrument' used for fishing did not include the vessel itself.
Sea Fisheries Regulation Act 1966
[ Bailii ]
 
Falmouth and Truro Health Authority v South West Water Services Times, 06 May 1999; Gazette, 06 May 1999; [1999] EWHC Admin 349
23 Apr 1999
Admn

Environment
A watercourse for the purpose of the Act was only a limited area of water and could not include a river or an estuary. An authority serving an abatement notice in respect of sewerage discharges, was not under a duty to consult first with the water company, but should do so if it had raised an expectation of consultation.
Environmental Protection Act 1990 80 259
1 Cites

1 Citers

[ Bailii ]
 
Regina v Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, ex parte Standley and others C-293/97; [1999] EUECJ C-293/97
29 Apr 1999
ECJ

Environment, Agriculture
(Judgment) Directive 91/676/EEC - Protection of waters against pollution caused by nitrates from agricultural sources - Identification of waters affected by pollution - Designation of vulnerable zones - Criteria - Validity in the light of the polluter pays principle, the principle that environmental damage should as a priority be rectified at source, the principle of proportionality and the right to property
[ Bailii ]

 
 Leeds City Council v Spencer; CA 6-May-1999 - Times, 24 May 1999; [1999] EWCA Civ 1351
 
Landcatch Limited v The Braer Corporation and Trevor Williams and Anthony Jones and Michael S Hudner and Assurance foreningen Skuld and the International Oil Pollution Compensation Fund Times, 14 June 1999; [1999] ScotCS 117; [1999] 2 Lloyd's LR 316
19 May 1999
IHCS
Lord Justice Clerk and Lord Cowie and Lord McCluskey
Environment, Scotland, Transport
The pursuers raised freshwater salmon (smolt) to the age of two before selling them on. An oil spill prevented them trading. They appealed a refusal of damages on the baiss that this was pure relational economic loss. Held: The appeal failed. Losses which arose following an environmental accident but which were related to particularly advantageous market conditions but for a prospective contract only were properly secondary economic losses and not recoverable under the Act. No distinction was drawn between the smolt that were sold for less than expected and those which were culled.
Merchant Shipping (Oil Pollution) Act 1971 5(3)
1 Cites

1 Citers

[ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ]
 
Assurenceforeningen Skuld v International Oil Pollution Compensation Fund and An Times, 14 June 1999
14 Jun 1999
OHCS

Environment
Where a compensation fund had been created with a last date for compensation claims to be made fixed, the Act was silent about how late claims were to be dealt with. There is no rule to say that applications for an extension of time must be made in advance, and the court felt it must be possible to apply.
Merchant Shipping (Oil Pollution) Act 1971 5(3)

 
Regina v Oldham Metropolitan Borough Council and Pugmanor Properties Ltd ex parte Foster [1999] EWHC Admin 774
30 Jul 1999
Admn

Environment, Planning

Environment Act 1995 95
[ Bailii ]
 
Savage and Another v Fairclough and others [1999] EWCA Civ 2056; [1999] EWCA Civ 2056
30 Jul 1999
CA
Lord Justice Auld Lord Justice Mummery Mr Justice Gage
Nuisance, Environment
The defendants had applied inorganic fertiliser to their land, eventually causing pollution of the claimant's water supply. The pollution exceeded EC levels. However the claimants had not established that the damage was foreseeable, nor that the practice of the defendant farmers was other than standard practice. Held: The claimant's appeal failed. They had not established forseeability as required in Cambridge Water.
EC Directive 80/778/EEC
1 Cites

[ Bailii ]
 
London Borough of Hillingdon v Secretary of State for Environment; Hillingdon Hospital NHS Trust; Clinical Energy Limited; Environmental Incineration Company Limited and Bfh Incineration Limited [1999] EWHC Admin 772
30 Jul 1999
Admn

Environment

[ Bailii ]
 
Official Receiver v Environment Agency Times, 05 August 1999
5 Aug 1999
CA

Environment, Insolvency
A waste management licence could constitute both property and onerous property for the purposes of the Insolvency Act. It could also be an interest incidental to the land to which it related. Because of this the liquidator of a waste management company could disclaim the licence without committing an offence under the Act.
Environmental Protection Act 1990 33 34 - Insolvency Act 1986 178(3), 436

 
In Re Rhondda Waste Disposal Company Ltd (In Administration) Times, 13 August 1999
13 Aug 1999
ChD

Environment
Where a company had gone into administration, it was not correct for a criminal prosecution under the Act to proceed without first getting the consent of the court or of the company's administrator. Such proceedings constituted 'other proceedings' under the Insolvency Act. The divisional court was not bound by decisions of the Court of Session where the decision was not on all fours with the instant case.
Environmental Protection Act 1990 - Insolvency Act 1986 10 11

 
Commission v Germany C-102/97 [1999] EUECJ C-102/97
9 Sep 1999
ECJ

Environment
ECJ Failure of a Member State to fulfil obligations - Directive 87/101/EEC - Disposal of waste oils - Transposition of the directive
Directive 87/101/EEC
[ Bailii ]
 
WWF and Others v Autonome Provinz Bozen and Others C-435/97 ECLI:EU:C:1999:418; [1999] ECR I-5613; [1999] EUECJ C-435/97
16 Sep 1999
ECJ

Environment
ECJ Environment - Directive 85/337/EEC - Assessment of the effects of certain public and private projects
1 Citers

[ Bailii ]
 
Commission v Ireland C-392/96; [1999] EUECJ C-392/96; [2000] Env LR D15; [2000] QB 636; [2000] 2 WLR 958; [1999] ECR I-5901; [1999] 3 CMLR 727; [1999] 4 PLR 107
21 Sep 1999
ECJ
J.-P. Puissochet, P
European, Environment
ECJ (Judgment) Environment - Directive 85/337/EEC - Assessment of the effects of certain public or private projects - Setting of thresholds
Directive 85/337/EEC
[ Bailii ]

 
 World Wildlife Fund and Others v Autonome Provinz Bozen and Others; ECJ 12-Oct-1999 - Times, 12 October 1999; [2001] 1 CMLR 149; C-435/97; [1999] EUECJ C-435/97
 
X v A and Others Gazette, 13 October 1999
13 Oct 1999
ChD

Trusts, Wills and Probate, Environment
A trustee under a will where there was a life interest had the ability to assert a lien over the estate in respect of potential liability which might be incurred because of the necessity of complying with any order for the clean-up of land forming part of the estate, even though the part of the Act which might operate was not yet in force.
Environmental Protection Act 1990 Part II

 
The Royal Society for the Protection of Birds and the Wildfowl and Wetlands Trust Ltd for Judicial Review of A Decision of the Secretary of State To Grant Licences To Shhot Barnacle Geese Times, 14 December 1999; [1999] ScotCS 239
14 Oct 1999
OHCS
Lord Johnston
Environment, European, Judicial Review, Scotland
When reviewing a decision applying European law, that procedure was the same as for testing a decision made under English law. There is no provision for the examination of factual basis of the decision. When assessing whether a licence was to be granted for the shooting of a protected species, the test for such a licence was the protection of crops. The view of whether the survival of the species was threatened was to be looked at in the light of the entire population,. Not just that at the license site.
EC Birds Directive 79/409/EEC
[ Bailii ] - [ ScotC ]

 
 A M L Van Rouge v Dagelijks Bestuur Van Het Waterschap De Dommel (Gebr Van Aarle Bv, Third Party); ECJ 15-Oct-1999 - Times, 15 October 1999; C-231/97; [1999] EUECJ C-231/97
 
Commission of the European Communities v Ireland Times, 19 October 1999; C-392/96
19 Oct 1999
ECJ

Environment, European
The Directive gave member states some discretion as to setting criteria to be fulfilled before a project could be said to have a substantial effect and so require an environmental assessment before being allowed to proceed. Nevertheless, it was not open to members to use a simple size measurement as such a criteria, since this made no allowance for the possible substantial effects of even small projects.
Council Directive 85/337/EEC on the assessment of the effects of certain public and private projects on the environment. - EC Treaty Art 226

 
Regina v Hammersmith and Fulham London Borough Council Ex Parte Trustees of the Council for the Protection of Rural England Gazette, 13 January 2000; CAT 26 October 1999
26 Oct 1999
QBD
Richards J
Environment, Planning, European
The authority gave permission for a new shopping centre up to 600,000 sq ft as an urban project. The Trustees sought that the permission be set aside since the council had not undertaken an environmental impact assessment, and under the EC Treaty they had the right to make such a request. It was held that an individual could not seek to enforce a directive once it had been properly enshrined in a member state's law. "…I accept that in exercising discretion with regard to costs … I should seek to give effect to the overriding objective and should have particular regard to the need, so far as practicable, to ensure that the parties are on an equal footing and that the case is dealt with in a way which is proportionate to the financial position of each party. Those aspects of the overriding objective seem to me to be embedded in any event in the principles laid down in ex p CPAG."
Town and Country Planning (Assessment of Environmental Effects) Regulations 1988 (1988 No 1199)
1 Citers


 
British Waterways Board v Severn Trent Water Ltd Times, 26 October 1999; Gazette, 03 November 1999
26 Oct 1999
ChD

Environment
A water company may have the implied power to discharge surface run-off water from sewers into canals. The powers and duties of water companies and sewerage undertakers were different both under statute and in general. The power to lay a run-off pipe might be held to imply a power to discharge what was run off through it.
Water Industry Act 1991 159
1 Citers



 
 Coventry and Solihull Waste Disposal Company Ltd v Russell; HL 25-Nov-1999 - Times, 30 November 1999; Gazette, 08 December 1999; [1999] UKHL 49; [1999] 1 WLR 2093; [2000] 1 All ER 97
 
Copyright 2014 David Swarbrick, 10 Halifax Road, Brighouse, West Yorkshire HD6 2AG.